Reviews

Alfie in the Garden by Debi Gliori

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2014. ISBN 9781408839515
(Age: Preschool) Alfie Rabbit is helping Mama-Bun in the garden. But his world turns from real to imagined as he peers through the leaves. Now he's in the jungle! He's a lion on the prowl, an elephant spraying water from his trunk, and a little bird flying home to his nest . . . to have a nap with Mummy! Alfie's imagination is bigger than his backyard!
This is a beautiful book for preschoolers that takes the child into the backyard jungle of their home. Just what is hiding in amongst all those bushes and flowers that are at eye-level for the young child? Debi Gliori's beautiful, distinctive illustrations open up a new world that could be really useful in getting our littlest readers to start exploring the world of creatures even smaller than they are. The soft colour palette, the curved lines of the insects - even those with heart-shaped noses - and their gentle expressions take away any threats so the reader sees this as a friendly world, although there is always the need to share a word of caution especially in Australian gardens.
A great read-together for the very young reader.
Barbara Braxton

The Iron trial by Cassandra CLare and Holly Black

cover image

Doubleday Childrens, 2104. ISBN 9780857532503
Many readers will already know these two authors - Cassandra from her very successful Mortal Instruments series, and Holly from her equally successful Spiderwick Chronicles partnership. Now these two have collaborated on the first in a new series which Harry Potter fans will no doubt eat up. In fact, HP devotees will love to spot the similarities throughout the book I am sure.
Easy to read and a real page-turner, The Iron Trial takes us into the Magisterium, a facility for educating potential mages. Callum Hunt (Call) is the son of mages with no inkling of his own magical ability, although at times strange things have happened around him. As a baby, Call's mother died in an ambush by the Enemy, and Call survived, though with a badly damaged leg. When Call's grieving father Alastair discovers his dead wife, surrounded by their dead comrades and discovered his baby son alive, he was struck by his wife's mysterious last message scratched into the nearby rock - 'Kill the child'.
When the kids of Call's district reach a certain age, they are summoned to a testing day to assess their suitability for entry to the Magisterium. Call, having been warned all his life by this father to avoid magic, desperately wants to fail the tests - already marking him as the odd one out as all the other applicants just as earnestly want to be selected as Mages' apprentices.
Call's botching of the tests is spectacular and gives some indication of his latent powers, but he is not successful in avoiding selection. Master Rufus, most revered Mage, selects Tamara and Aaron the two highest scoring applicants - and Call, the lowest scoring as his new apprentices. Despite initial hostility between the three apprentices, they forge a real bond with an understanding of each other and their strengths and weaknesses.
Amid the usual personality clashes of a new school and the inevitable 'stuck up' kid, the usual nervous ones and as it turns out, the innocuous seeming boy who turns out to be anything but! Call navigates his way through his Iron Year and realises that his father's warnings seem far away as he comes to appreciate what magic can achieve and how being accepted makes him feel.
There are undercurrents of secrecy as Master Rufus and Call's father differ on the way to handle Call's magical ability, with Call knowing less than most of the other kids about the history behind the Mages and their wars with the Enemy.
You can be sure of one thing. Call will turn out to be the 'Chosen One' and will no doubt be aided in whatever challenges lie ahead by his fellow apprentices.
One of our Year 6 students last week picked up the promo postcard from the Circ Desk and said excitedly, 'Oh Miss, this is a GREAT book! I got it for my birthday and I read it straightaway! I can't wait for the second one to come out!'. Not a bad recommendation, I'd say. Again I say, for those who need a HP type fix, this is the book to do it. I find it is darker and edgier with a little more real humour than those but there are definitely many many similarities.
Sue Warren

A Chick 'n' Pug Christmas by Jennifer Sattler

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2014. ISBN 9781599906027
Recommended for 2-5 year olds. Christmas is coming and Pug is dressed up in his itchy Santa suit, he even looks a little like him with his large tummy. His friend Chick is very excited and bursting with questions about Christmas, who is this special person, what does he do and how does he deliver all the presents in one night? All Pug wants to do is nap in the snowy backyard. Chick is taken with the idea that Santa is really a superhero, he really wants to be his helper - an elf. They decide to help some friends, sharing Christmas cheer with Mr. Snuggles, The Dude and an ordinary citizen.
Jennifer Sattler's new picture book celebrates the wonder and spirit of Christmas, her familiar characters Chick and Pug are a quirky duo. Her illustrations are bold and vibrant, the young reader is drawn in to the excitement as the illustrations bring the story to life - poor Mr. Snuggles wrapped up in Christmas bells.
Rhyllis Bignell

The Last of the Spirits by Chris Priestley

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2014. ISBN 9781408854136
(Age: 11-15) Recommended. I am not familiar with Chris Priestley's work - no doubt, because the supernatural/paranormal genre is not one for which I usually opt. But reading a little of his bio, it seems this 'master of the macabre' loves nothing better than to take a traditional Gothic horror story and put a complete new twist on it.
And this he has done with A Christmas Carol. I really like Dickens but I'm not an Egghead knowing all there is to know about every book and while I like A Christmas Carol it has never been my favourite, and I had completely forgotten about the two 'wild' children hidden underneath the robes of the Ghost of Christmas Present. Ignorance and Want, these two feral children become the focus of this side stepping of the original story, taking the reader into the dark and disturbing world of Dickens' London.
Written in a style that will totally captivate those young readers who relish a bit of spookiness, this story is new, fresh and engaging while completely retaining the pervading message of the original novel.
I'm giving this a big thumbs up and will definitely be promoting it to Middle School next year - creepy but not horrific, matter of fact but not graphic (about the dire circumstances of London's poor) and totally resolved in a satisfactory manner.
I'd be grabbing this one for your library shelves - readers around 11 to 15 would love it I believe
Sue Warren

Once upon a Christmas compiled and edited by Beattie Alvarez

cover image

Christmas Press, 2014. ISBN 9780992283858
(Age: 9+) This is a collection of Christmas stories, poems and illustrations, dedicated to Santa Claus. With contributions from many of Australia's well known and best loved authors like Duncan Ball, Ursula Dubosarsky, Vashti Farrer, Kate Forsyth, Pamela Freeman, Susanne Gervay, Juliet Marillier and Sophie Masson, and illustrations by a variety of artists, this is a wide ranging collection of memoirs about Christmas, some folktales and poetry. Those looking for stories that celebrate the birth of Christ will find only a few references to this event, although I found the poignant poem by Anne Bee, The Donkey a beautiful reminder of the Nativity as was the poem The Mouse by Nette Hilton
I browsed through this collection picking out stories by my favourite authors. In the Inglenook by Juliet Marillier tells the tale of two abandoned Christmas decoration toys who are rescued by a mother who remembered them from her childhood. Robert's tree by Pamela Freeman describes how Robert's Christmas tree grew so big that it had to be put in the ground. For older readers, reading the poignant, Christmas at the Homeless Shelter by Adele Geras, could mean a discussion about the true meaning of Christmas and how they could perhaps help those in need at this time. Babushka and the Star a traditional Russian Christmas legend retold by Sophie Masson is a beautiful tale of Babushka, who 'will never stop looking for the little child born under the miraculous star.'
Some of the stories describe how the authors celebrate Christmas, Grandma's Christmas by Susanne Gervay brings a picture of her much loved parents and how their contributions to Christmas are being passed down through the generations. Isabelle Merlin in Childhood Christmas - plus a cake describes how she loved her Christmas celebrations in France, and even gives an easy French Christmas log cake recipe that would be easy for young readers to make with the help of an adult. These memoirs could give rise to a writing activity in class, with each child writing about how Christmas or another important holiday is celebrated in their family. The diverse writings could prove to be discussion point in the class about many beliefs and customs in Australia and around the world.
Each page is decorated with Christmas bells and holly and there are some lovely full page coloured illustrations, disconcertingly placed in the middle of the book, rather than with the story they illustrate.
All in all this would be a very useful collection to have in a library and the varied texts could lead to lively discussions and directed writing about Christmas.
Pat Pledger

The Walled City by Ryan Graudin

cover image

Indigo, 2014. ISBN 9781780621999
Not suitable for younger readers. In the brutal, lawless Walled City, violent criminals are in control whilst broken, lost souls such as street children try to survive anyway they can, living in filthy squalor and being wary of everyone.
Most of the story centres upon a brothel owned by a vicious gang who press young girls into sexual slavery. Accordingly, the subject is grim with women being forcibly detained, savagely beaten, sexually assaulted and prostituted for the profit of the gang's leader.
The violence and competition for survival on the streets is such that to stay alive, children must run from ever present threats and be handy with a knife to defend themselves. Two characters have reason to gain entry to the brothel, Jin Ling seeks to rescue an enslaved sister, whilst Dai is under immense pressure to accomplish a task before a given date. Cooperating requires that the pair break the primary rule of survival, being 'Trust nobody'. This is no small matter given the hair raising exploits the pair become involved in, with each having the other's life in their hands on occasion. The mystery of Dai's race against time and his reason for being in the city took too long to reveal and became annoying and boring rather than captivating.
One of the many confronting aspects of this story is that it is based on the Kowloon Walled City, however it is set in contemporary time. A story such as this set in a futuristic, dystopian society or even a Medieval fantasy world enables escapism, however the setting of this tale firmly emphasises that many women do experience this barbarous mistreatment in our modern world. Given that lives of violence and sexual exploitation are a reality for too many women and children, it is valid for adults to be prompted to feel deeply about the misery and degradation experienced by the less fortunate. Whether this is fit and appropriate for adolescent readers is a complex question which many will have diverse, strong opinions about.
My own feeling is that the evil practices portrayed in this novel are not depicted gratuitously yet readers will be disturbed. Further, it would be concerning if readers were not disturbed by this issue but I don't consider that the novel has enough depth to make it compelling literature. For this reason I urge parents to read it carefully before giving it to their children and suggest that librarians and teachers exercise caution in regard to whether this is appropriate for their collection and if so, which age levels may borrow it.
Rob Welsh

The Tree House by Toni Brisland

cover image

Ill. by Michele Gaudion. Little Steps, 2014. ISBN 9781925117011
(Age: K - 3) Teresa and Emma are sisters and best friends and Emma's greatest wish is that her profoundly disabled sister could run on rainbows and do the things that she can, like climbing trees. So she asks Daddy and Grandpa to build a treehouse instead. But while they do that there is an accident which puts Teresa in hospital and changes the plans dramatically.
This is a sensitive family story that gives children with disabilities like Teresa's, or their sisters, an opportunity to see themselves as characters in a story. While Teresa's disability plays a significant role in the events, it is about family love first and disability second. Accompanied by gentle artwork, it is a feel-good story that might help others think about the things they do and take for granted. Imagine even eating strawberries becoming a challenge or being unable to speak, let alone unable to do either. Yet this is the life of many young children and we need to acknowledge it.
This book was written after the author had a conversation with a social worker who told her that there were very few books available to start discussions with the siblings of disabled children who are finding it hard to cope with the situation. It is based on Toni's sister, Teresa, who had cerebral palsy, and the influence Teresa had on her. While I've read other books in which the main character has a disability, this is the first one I recall written from the perspective of a sibling.
Worth having in your collection.
Barbara Braxton

Rory and the Monstersitter by Rosie Reeve

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2014. ISBN 9781408845516
(Age: Preschool - Yr 2) Rory the Monster loves to cook and he's always creating new and interesting recipes using whatever ingredients he has to hand - bats, bugs, anything is likely to end up in the mix. One evening, his parents decide to go on a dinner date, hiring an enormous hairy monster to look after Rory, Fangus, Lily and Baby Grub. The monster sits himself down in front of the television ignoring what the children are up to in the kitchen and then outside. Their tummies are rumbling so while their parents are enjoying a delicious dinner at the Cockroach Cafe, they concoct their own dinner starting with leaves and twigs, a splash of water, a twist of pepper and a sprinkling of salt. But it is missing a vital ingredient . . .
This is a laugh-out-loud story that has a superb twist in its telling (not just the twist of pepper.) When I first read it to some six-year-olds they were quite quizzical at the ending, but when it finally sunk in what had happened and what was planned they begged for it to be read again and again. Between the text and the superb illustrations there was much to pick up on and enjoy. It also led to a discussion about how authors use unexpected events and endings to turn stories on their heads and how, sometimes, even with all we know we are surprised.
It would be very easy to use this text address the Australian Curriculum Year 1 outcome ACELY1660 ('Use comprehension strategies to build literal and inferred meaning about key events, ideas and information in texts that they listen to, view and read by drawing on growing knowledge of context, text structures and language features') because its humour and twist set it apart from many of the other stories for this age group.
Barbara Braxton

My Little Star by Mark Sperring

cover image

Ill. by Nicola O'Byrne. Bloomsbury, 2014. ISBN 9781408849613
(Age: Preschool - K)
'When the day is done and sleeps draws near
When the moon's aglow and stars appear
I'll whisper something crystal clear
Words just meant for you hear'
.
Mem Fox once said that the bedtime story routine is like 'drawing the curtains on the day' and this lovely lullaby-esque is the perfect story to finish off and share a kiss goodnight. With soft, gentle illustrations, animal mothers look up and share their love with their babies. Lions, giraffes, koalas, even penguins show that the bond between mother and child is deep, enduring and unbreakable. It could start a chat about the individual and personal routines the children follow - is an on-the-knees prayer still part of it? - as well as being a perfect starter for focusing on Mothers Day and what our mums do for us.
Little ones will love this and will want to make it part of their go-to-sleep ritual every night.
Barbara Braxton

The Wombats at the Zoo by Roland Harvey

cover image

Allen & Unwin, 2014. ISBN: 9781743319048
(Age: 6-9) Highly recommended. Picture books. 2013 marked the 30th anniversary of Roland Harvey's first published book and sixty years since he created his first book! Many lucky folk were able to attend his exhibition 'Roland Harvey: a Retrospective'. Roland has long been one of Australia's favourite illustrators and his long list of published works includes so many popular titles that one would be hard-pressed to ignore their impact on the children and adults with whom they have been shared.
The Wombats at the Zoo is the second in a series created by Roland about a class of quirky children and their teacher. The class is off to the zoo with each child charged with obtaining information about a specific topic and also writing a poem about an animal seen during the outing. Beginning with the wonderful endpapers on which each child is pictured with details about their favourite animal, scariest animal and other little titbits, the reader is immediately drawn into the action and becomes part of the class for the duration.
With very recognisable RH flair, the illustrations are seemingly simple but actually filled with minute details which beg close examination. One can already see the heads bent over, picking out the details such a miniscule pram underwater, baby fish a micro-copy of its parent floating along for a daily 'walk' or the orang-utans and meerkats holding up a sign 'Don't buy palm oil'. I particularly love the Aussie animal enclosure with the myriad native birds from spoonbills to brolgas (dancing of course!), herons to (very delightful) pelicans.
As usual there is lots of wordplay '. . . the longest snake, the Monty python, grows nearly nine metres long. . . . ' which could easily lead into an activity with your class collecting or inventing collective nouns, creating descriptions of a slightly whacky nature and more. And of course, both written and visual humour, so typical of Roland's work, is abundant.
Each 'Wombat' has a double page spread featuring their special report and poem with the final double spread a 'seek' page to find all the children as it's time to go home, with the endpage showing each child with their 'show-and-tell' to follow up the excursion.
All in all, like all Roland's books it is great fun both for independent reading and read-aloud, as well as a very useful springboard to language activities with vigour and humour.
Sue Warren

The arrival by Shaun Tan

cover image

Hachette, 2014. ISBN 9780734415868
(Age: All) Highly recommended. Immigration, Refugees, Loneliness. A stranger arrives in a strange land, leaving behind his wife and daughter until he can send for them. He is one of many, moving like robots through the immigration centre, finding work which casts him in the same anonymous role. Tan shows clearly through this wordless book, the disorientation of the new arrival, his efforts to fit in, to assimilate, his search for work and lodgings. Each page shows a strange language, impelling the readers to empathise with the migrant, lost in an unknown and unfriendly city.
Tan's sepia drawings, looking like old photographs, encapsulate the isolation of the new arrival. Repeated images of dislocation, disorientation, loneliness and sorrow are found throughout the book, the end papers having all of humanity shown in passport like pictures staring at the reader.
The story is divided into six chapters, the first following the man leaving, packing his suitcase while his wife and daughter accompany him to the ship which will take him away. He is then found amongst many others making that journey, sending letters like birds home to their families. Next he is seen talking to others who have their own stories of dislocation, sharing their experiences. The fourth shows the work he is able to get, and his mind drifts into the reasons he left, while the last chapter shows a positive future for the family as those left behind prepare to follow. In between we see snippets of those he befriends, people who share his experiences and help him along his journey, with the darker tones of some illustrations reflect the trauma of some of their stories. The image early in the book of the man seeing his family in his suitcase is haunting (one amongst many). Tan reprises some iconic images of migration, and the use he makes of the unusual animal and the engineering works all add another level of thought and discussion. There are images to share, images to ponder, and above all to read and reread, gaining more from each viewing. A New Arrivals class at Richmond Primary School pondered over this book for weeks, taking it home, sharing it with their parents and other members of their class. They spoke of it with recognition: some children were from refugee camps, some from detention centres, while some had arrived by plane. But they all had one thing in common, being a new arrival in an alien land, and that Shaun Tan has shown with incredible dexterity. This group of young people all found themselves and their families in the faces in the endpapers, their reasons for leaving their own country in some of the stories shown. In a classroom, this book could be used as an introduction to the theme of immigration, of difference, of starting again, of refugees, of the nature of picture books, or looking at an illustrator's skill.
This book won accolades around the world when first published: CBCA Picture book of the year in 2007, NSW Premier's Award, 2007, WA Premier's Prize, 2007, ABBA award 2007, Best Album Award, France, 2007.
To see it republished in a smaller, softcover edition reminds us again of Tan's prodigious talents, and the need for books such as these to be placed in front of readers of all ages.
When asked if this was about the refugee debate in today's Australia, he responded,
'If The Arrival contributes to a public discussion at all, it would be in reminding us that these issues are more than just passing fodder for politicians and media.'
This book soars as it reflects all of our beginnings.
Fran Knight

Snow by Walter de la Mare

cover image

Ill. by Carolina Rabei. Faber, 2014. ISBN 9780571312191
(Ages: 4-6) Highly recommended. This stunning presentation of de la Mare's poem is a triumph. Rabei's illustrations using a limited palette of colours to accentuate the crisp white of the snow are just beautiful and take the classic poem from being simply about the wonder of a snowy winter to a celebration of a northern hemisphere Christmas.
The text is sparingly scattered throughout the book which has a combination of styles from full double page spreads to snap-shot style story boards, and the reader can follow a family's preparations for a cosy Christmas.
There is a quiet beauty to this poem and in this format is all the more accessible to a new generation.
No breath of wind,
No gleam of sun -
Still the white snow
Whirls softly down -

Small and I really enjoyed sharing this, loving the sound of the language but also 'telling' the story through the illustrations.
I don't know that I'll ever be able to conjure up enough snow to make a snowman but at least we can vicariously do so as well as toboggan, run through the woods with the puppy and trace the feathery frost on the windows.
Highly recommended for young readers from around 4 up. I just really adore the almost minimalist design of this book - truly beautiful!
Find out more about Walter de la Mare here.
Sue Warren

Isla and the happily ever after by Stephanie Perkins

cover image

Anna and the French Kiss, bk 3. Usborne, 2014. ISBN 9781409581130
(Age: 15+) Recommended. Romance. Travel. Friendship. Paris. Manhattan. Stephanie Perkins is the queen of the teen romance and has written another wonderful story, this time following the ups and downs of a romance between shy and clever Isla and artist Josh, at the same time making some connections with Anna and Etienne and Lola and Cricket from her previous books Anna and the French Kiss and Lola and the Boy Next Door .
Once again the setting of the story is fabulous. Readers are taken on a tour of Manhattan as Isla meets up with Josh, who she has had a crush on for years. She sees him in a cafe during the summer vacation and hopes that it could be the start of a new romance for her, but he disappears and she doesn't see him again until they both go back to school in Paris. Here they connect and scenes of Paris are joyfully described. Then for an even more exotic setting, Perkins takes her characters off to Barcelona for an illicit weekend, and paints a glowing picture of the amazing art of Gaudi. Teens will be enthralled with the descriptions of Paris, Manhattan and Spain that are sure to make them want to travel, and people who have been lucky enough to travel will enjoy revisiting the places in the book.
The romance of course is the central theme and Isla has a bumpy road with Josh, as they navigate the perils of a relationship with its associated misunderstandings, heartbreak and joy. The final chapters bring together the characters from her previous books in a totally satisfying conclusion and readers have much to think about when considering if happily ever after can exist.
Pat Pledger

Amelie and Nanette: Sparkly Shoes and Picnic Parties by Sophie Tilley

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2013. ISBN 9781408836637
Amelie and Nanette are very excited. Nanette has a brand new pair of shoes, red and shiny with the prettiest bows. She was just about to give up looking for new shoes when she spotted them on the highest shelf. And Amelie had something new too - a party dress with roses and ribbons. So they decide to have a New Shoes and New Dress Picnic Party. So they packed up a yummy picnic and a blanket, umbrella, sunhats, sunglasses and towels (in case they went paddling) got dressed in their new clothes with extra petticoats, bangles and necklaces. Then they carried everything over the fence into the meadow to their favourite tree by the stream. It was their own secret hideaway.
Their new clothes make them feel like dancing and singing and spinning until they fell down giddy and giggling. It is time for the picnic - but what's a picnic without flowers? So Amelie goes off to pick some while Nanette goes to the stream to get water and disaster strikes.
This is one of those traditional, feel-good stories about carefree kids who are best friends, sharing everything. Both the text and the illustrations have an olde-worlde feel about them that takes the reader back to a slower, simpler, safer world where two young girls can pack a picnic, go over the fence and have fun without a care in the world. And you just know that there will be a happy ending. This is an ideal series for introducing young children to the concept of a continuing collection of stories with the same characters, an important element of developing early literacy skills. Not only does it allow them to 'dive right into the story' because they already know who these characters are and what they're like but that in itself makes them think back and bring that information to the present situation. "What do I already know about Amelie and Nanette that will help me enjoy this story?" is part of that ability to transfer known knowledge to new situations. It helps them predict what might happen based on what they already know and well-developed characters like Amelie and Nanette become favourite friends, reinforcing the understanding that books and reading are friendly, fun, perhaps even a solace.
Barbara Braxton

Alfie's Big Wish by David Hardy

cover image

Magabala Books, 2014. ISBN: 9781922142535
(Ages: Lower primary, Middle primary) Highly recommended for small humans around 3 and up. In his second book about Alfie, David Hardy tells the story of Alfie's loneliness after his friends move on with their family and his longing for someone to play with. The simple rhyming text will appeal to young readers and the illustrations are just delightful - and very expressive. Children will readily identify with Alfie's emotions throughout.
David is a descendant of the Barkindji people of the Brewarrina (NSW) district and was for many years working with the Walt Disney Animations Studios. His skill with drawing and creating characters is evident in this charming book - especially with facial expressions. I particularly love the end papers with their 'pencil' sketches of Alfie in various activities and moods.
After his mates move away, Alfie is left feeling very forlorn as all the other kids are much bigger. He tries to amuse himself (alongside some animal friends) but it just isn't the same. He makes a big wish for someone to come along who is just the right age and size to be a playmate. And Surprise! His wish comes true when a new little girl, Myrna, appears. As new special friends the two play all day long and there are smiles all around.
A lovely take on friendship and an apt example that kids are kids and are friends despite gender differences, or anything else!
Sue Warren