Reviews

Zafir by Prue Mason

cover image

Through my eyes series. Allen & Unwin, 2015. ISBN 9781743312544
(Age: 11+) Highly recommended. Syria, Dictatorship. When Zafir and his family move back to Syria, Zafir has little idea of what life will be like. He has been brought up in Dubai where he has mixed with a range of other kids his age from all countries of the world. He has been allowed to do things he wishes to do: talk openly about politics, use Facebook and a mobile phone without restriction, see the people he wants to see and so on, but when his father accepts a job in the hospital at Homs, his life changes dramatically. Here there are secrets, secrets he has little idea about, secrets when shared must be kept under wraps. His uncle seems to have more liberal views but again no one must know. His mother uses email, but only through a secret address and she has ideas about freedoms which too must never be discussed. His one friend at school, Rami also has secrets, and Zafir thinks it may have something to do with why the other boys call him names. When he finds out he must make a choice between his friend and the gang that pursues him. But one day he and his mother go to Damascus to see his uncle, without telling their father and here they see a brave few demonstrate against the government and see their uncle beaten and taken away by the police. The secrets have come out into the open and Zafir and his family are caught in the backlash when after a demonstration in Homs, his father helps a young man who has been shot by the police.
Another in the fine series, Through my eyes, sees Zafir at the centre of the story, a twelve year old Syrian boy exposed to a different lifestyle, seeing his own country's dark heart.
Through his eyes we see the terror under which many people live, the role of the state police and the cruel way some are treated. We see the more liberal minded striving for freedoms we take for granted in the West, and what happens to them when they call for change.
A timeline of Syria's history fills in some of the background to the novel, and can be found at the end of the book, along with a dictionary of the Arabic words found in the text and information about the other books in the series. A map at the start of the book helps readers place where the story is set. This is a most readable and engaging book about a country we hear little of. It could well be used as a class set, as with any of this fine series, or a study where the class selects one of the Through My Eyes series to read in a group.
Fran Knight

All fall down by Ally Carter

cover image

An Embassy Row novel. Scholastic, 2015. ISBN: 9781743628942
(Age: 13+) Highly recommended.
'The scar that is very real.
The scar that is perfectly clear.
The scar that has haunted my dreams every night since the moment my mother died - from the moment the Scarred Man killed her.'
Grace Blakely is a 16 year old girl. A 16 year old girl, who three years ago, witnessed the murder of her mother. Or so she says. No one believes her and they become even more skeptical when she claims to see him in the state of Adria. Everyone tells her that her mother's death was an accident, but Grace knows the truth. And she will do everything she can to catch the man behind it - the Scarred Man.
I would recommend this book to teenage girls, 13 and over. Boys who enjoy some action stories about friendship would also like this book.
Ally Carter is an inspiring author who knows how to portray the characters' emotions and feelings. Another Embassy Row Novel is due to come out soon and I am sure it will be just as interesting as the first one.
Jazmin Humphries (Student, Year 7)

Writing Clementine by Kate Gordon

cover image

Allen & Unwin, 2014. ISBN 9781743316634
(Age: Yr 7+) Recommended. Clementine Darcy's year 9 philosophy class isn't turning out to be what she expected. The teacher asks the students to simply write, whilst Clementine is hoping for answers to the big questions of life and wants to know 'Why am I here?' As she writes, she reflects upon her own life which isn't quite going in the direction she has hoped for either. Her friends want to change her to be more like them, her brother Fergus continues to lock himself in his room, failing to communicate with his family, her sister has her own issues, and Clem realises that life is far from perfect. As her story unravels through her journaling, Clementine continues to be true to herself and constantly endeavours to make life better for the people for whom she cares. Her meeting with a seemingly odd new boy in class causes her to question certain aspects of her own life and the way in which she behaves in certain situations. Will she be able to turn things around to mend her family and its problems?
Reading this book was a truly refreshing experience. Clementine is a delightfully strong and quirky female protagonist, confident enough not to change her style or interests to satisfy her friends, willing to accept the quirky Fred and his friends, breaking away from the strict guidelines her friends try to impose on her and teaching others in the process. Touching on serious issues of bullying, anorexia and mental illness, but all handled with a dose of sensitivity and humour, this will be added to my list of recommended reads for students in Year 7 and above.
Jo Schenkel

The book with no pictures by B. J. Novak

cover image

Puffin, 2014. ISBN 9780141361789
(Age: 4+) Well, you all know it goes. You hear so much hype about a book (or a movie, or a theatrical show blah blah blah) that you almost convince yourself that either you won't like it or it will be completely lame.
And, to be honest, that's pretty much how it was with this book. I'd had posts on Facebook and seen comments in email lists but it was all so full on that I kind of let it wash over me.
Then I got this in the post last week to review. Read it - hmmmm, laughing to myself - that was unexpected. Tonight, I read it to Small who giggled so much I was a little concerned she would give herself indigestion.
This is a very clever though seemingly simple book. Hands up, all of you who love to read aloud - with expression, with verve, with silly voices, with laughter - with engagement. You will not... cannot go wrong with this one.
I believe this read-aloud is not confined to younger children. I think I could read this to Upper Primary and have them still get the giggles.
I have a favourite fridge magnet (friends stand and 'read' my fridge because of the magnets)... it say's 'Take time every day to be silly'. This book will prove the easiest way to be silly ever and the kids with whom you share it will relish every single bit of kookiness.
If you have not yet encountered it - do yourself a favour - and most definitely put it on your shelves, in the library or at home, for children and those who relish humour, from around 4 upwards.
See for yourself here.
Sue Warren

The Internet is like a puddle by Shona Innes

cover image

Ill. by Irisz Agocs. Big Hug series. Five Mile Press, 2015. ISBN 9781760064167
(Age: 4+) Recommended. Internet, Safety. Discussing the dangers that lurk behind using the internet is one of those discussions that is hard to initiate and even more difficult to explain. Here with The internet is like a puddle, the opportunity is given to teachers and parents to introduce such a topic with young children. A clinical and forensic psychologist, Shona Innes has had many years of experience with young children and has developed in her book a way of involving both child and adult in presenting this theme.
The first few pages talk of the positive things the internet offers, giving the parent and child or teacher and a class the opportunity to look at the range offered by the internet, including the uses made of it in class or at home. Some of the devices which allow us to get into the internet are alluded to, and the games and information which can be accessed are stressed. She makes it clear that the internet is fun and can absorb a lot of time, but then goes on to explain that the internet is like a puddle, and uses that simile to underline the dangers that lurk there. Initially she talks about the time spent on the internet, and extols the virtues of being outside, of talking with friends, of exercise. She then talks of getting further into the internet to places that are not safe, that could show things unsuitable or entice the user to chat to strangers.
The solution to not falling into the puddle is being with someone who is safe, like an adult. The safety issue is stressed towards the end of the book, and without making it an overwhelmingly didactic, is made clear that this is the best way to have fun with the internet.
The illustrations add to the interest of the book with animals used as the main characters, and the soft swirly watercolour making it easy on the eye. Children will laugh out loud at the animals as they have some problems with the mud and deep water of the puddles but will also understand the image presented of a child being overcome by the unknown depth of the internet.
The ideas presented by Innes are clear and unequivocal. She leads the reader through the positives then introduces the negative aspects of this technology with reassurance.
This is a fascinating introductory book for class and home, allowing communication between adult and child on an issue of increasing importance.
Fran Knight

The playground is like the jungle by Shona Innes

cover image

Ill. by Irisz Agocs. Big Hug series. Five Mile Press, 2015. ISBN 9781760064150
(Age: 4+) Recommended. Playground, Safety. Clinical and forensic psychologist Shona Innes has taken on the topic of safety in the playground at school or in the community, to help parents and teachers initiate discussions between themselves and students or offspring about the behaviour they will come across when socialising in these places. With funny and apt watercolour illustrations, Agocs parallels the information given, using animals as the focus of the story. Younger children will be enchanted seeing the animals and the behaviour they display and will be able to act this out for themselves, or discuss the sorts of animals they see in their playground.
Innes begins by showing what a fun place the playground can be with all sorts of people coming to it and displaying all sorts of behaviour. She parallels the wide variety of people with the animals in the jungle. So a baboon may bang his chest wanting to be noticed, a snake may pretend to be a friend one minute, then slither away, a tiger may be aggressive, and little insects annoying. Some will want to be alone, while others might want to be with friends, some may put on a happy face while others avoid those who make them uncomfortable.
Then we get to the crux of the story that if another animal makes them feel uncomfortable, then they can seek the company of others, or ask an adult to be with them, or yell loudly, or simply avoid the person who makes them fell ill at ease.
Much discussion will come of sharing this book with younger readers, all of whom will have come across the sorts of behaviours shown in this book.
At the end of the book Innes outlines her reasons for writing this book, as with the others in the series, The internet is like a puddle, Life is like the wind and Friendship is like a seesaw, all of which deal with specific issues that can engulf younger children.
Fran Knight
Editor's note: Teacher's notes are available on the author's website.

Talking about tricky stuff with kids by Shona Innes

cover image

For more than 25 years now, I have had been in the privileged position of listening to the very private worries and concerns of many children. It is indeed a pretty special and sacred position to be in and I am always grateful for the opportunity. From that special spot with young people, I have been privy to their inner most thoughts, how they perceive themselves and others, and the things that they truly value.
When you take some time to understand how each child views the World, there's a moment where you can start to see the patterns of their feelings and their emotional 'logic'. Once you have found that moment or place, you can help a child to unwind the tangled experiences and interpretations so that they can deal with, accept or begin to change their emotional situation. To unwind it, means you have to have a shared explanation. You need something that the child can 'get' and understand.
When your client is a child, there is also a need to advocate for them within the various systems that they belong. To do this you need to be able to help their support team, (their families, their carers, their teachers, their welfare workers, their treating psychologists, their doctors, and their special people) to share that same special understanding. After each session with a young person, I usually write them a letter. By writing and sharing the concepts discussed during the sessions, I hope to reinforce what the child and I have learned together and do so in a way that they can share with their support team.
Young children cannot always understand a metaphor the first time around so it requires repeated simple links via words and pictures. I look for metaphors that all ages can understand so that the child can communicate about complex situations in simple ways with the people who know them best. In talking about life (and death), I wanted to base it on something that you know is there, but can't really touch . . . the wind. For dealing with the internet, I wanted something that could be fun if played with carefully, but could also have some slippery spots that need supervision and help . . . a puddle. For the others in the playground, I wanted a whole heap of metaphors to describe all the different types of personalities that mingle there . . . jungle creatures. The ups and downs of friendship were always going to be a seesaw. The next two in the Big Hug series are much more intimate and have been written for children when their might be trouble in their families or in the family of someone they know.
The human brain is very complex. There are lots of pathways that a thought or experience can take in a young brain. If a thought or experience has been laid down in childhood, then it needs a child friendly way of mapping it so it can be traversed. Finding a shared pathway can take the 'ickiness' or 'nagging' out of some tricky concepts and allow a child and their special people a way to work and talk together.

Ride, Ricardo, ride! by Phil Cummings

cover image

Ill. Shane Devries. Omnibus, 2015. ISBN 9781742990736
(Age: 5+) Highly recommended. War. Village life. Hope. Ricardo lives in a small mountain village in Italy, within a close community. His father teaches him to ride his bike and he can often be seen riding through the village, past the old men talking in the streets, past the workers in the fields and the happy, chasing children. But one day shadows appear. The village, once open and friendly, now has closed windows and doors as the noise increases and the sound of boots becomes louder. Father and Ricardo take apart the bike and hide its parts. The shadows remain, and one day his father disappears. The shadows eventually leave and the village returns to its old self, with singing and dancing, although some of its people are missing. Ricardo retrieves the pieces of his bike and puts it back together, because he knows his father would have wanted it that way. He has grown, the war is over and the memory of his father's words ring in his ears as he rides his bike once again through the village.
This wonderful book extolls the persistence of the human spirit, the perseverance of humanity in overcoming the worst of times to look forward to a brighter future. The shadows are never articulated, but they are there, their consequences tangible with the death of Ricardo's father, the community's fear, with the illustrations showing the smashed photograph and the bombed buildings.
I love the way Cummings replicates situations, as the end parallels the beginning with someone calling out, Ride, Ricardo, ride, underlining again the continuation of life.
And Devries' illustrations are absorbing, with his all-seeing eye approach, looking down upon so many scenes, making the reader a spectator, someone spying on this wonderful little community. His invading force casts long shadows across the pages, the village and the inhabitants, as well as Ricardo and his bike. Devries uses milky brown colours to great effect, with little colour showing through on the pages where the shadows appear, but small touches of colour underscore the end of war where blue sky appears once again.
Little touches by Devries made me catch my breath. Watch out for the wonderful image of the kitchen, the shadows of the planes overhead, and the image of mother comforting Ricardo amongst others.
At a time when more and more picture books about war cross my desk, this stands out in its depiction of the effect of war upon children while through it all, life persists.
Fran Knight

My Gallipoli by Ruth Starke and Robert Hannaford

cover image

Working Title Press, 2015. ISBN 9781921504761
(Age: 9+) Recommended. World War One. Gallipoli. Anzac Day. Memories. Picture book for older readers. From the old style binding to the haunting portraits on the front cover, this impressive book will stand out amongst the books on World War One leading up to the centenary of Anzac Day. This one is different for many reasons. Using charcoal outlines filled with water-colour and gouache to present his images, the stunning illustrations by highly regarded South Australian artist, Robert Hannaford, will make readers stop and look, peering into the faces of the people brought by happenstance to this lonely beach in the Dardenelles in 1915. The Turks above are fighting for their homeland, the men below told to take the hills at all costs. The stalemate that became a legend is revealed here with Hannaford's illustrations drawn from surprising angles, and showing aspects of war not usually seen: the wounded ferried across to the ships, the dead buried then reburied, the exhaustion in the trenches, the Turks firing down upon the enemy. And each page is filled with sympathy, these men could be someone you know, as Hannaford uses his portraiture skills to great effect, making each face recognisably different in the sweep of protagonists on that shore. Their courage and tenacity is there for the readers to wonder at. Hannaford's different approach is replicated with Starke's text.
Each page presents Gallipoli from a different perspective. Starke gives an outstanding range of points of view that include all protagonists, all calling Gallipoli, 'my' Gallipoli or Gelibolu, underlining the fact that this place, held in such high esteem by Australians is also respected by the many other nations which sent their men there.
From the shepherd on his beach, to the soldiers landing in the middle of the night and those who did not make it to shore, to the nurse, Ellen, on the hospital ship, to the Turks looking down, to the Gurkha rifleman Tul, the sniper Harry, the Turkish commander Mustafa Kemal, Badhur with the Indian Mule Company, Jack in hospital waiting to go home to Australia, the Wellington Brigade storming the hill, Cyril with the Grave Registration Unit and George Lambert, Australian War Artist, and finally to the many who now go back to pay their respects, this is their Gallipoli. And is forever 'my' Gallipoli.
For a class looking at the men who fought at Gallipoli, along with the women who nursed them on the nearby islands, this is a must to have ready for your students. Not only does it hone in on specific stories, it makes the reader aware of the range of people for whom Gallipoli is a significant part of their story. Starke has used people's words to write a chronological account of the eight months spent there, and augments these stories with information at the back of the book. Students could use the book to fill out those stories, to write their own accounts, to marvel at the significance of this place in our history, to further research those that Starke has presented, to look more closely at other nations for whom this place is significant, and look closely at the way Hannaford has given these stories a distinctive face.
I can imagine students gathering information about specific people, gathering other picture books for older readers and comparing them with this one, deciding how each author and illustrator combination has set about their task and discussing the impact each makes. It certainly packs a punch.
Fran Knight

The Anzac puppy by Peter Millett and Trish Bowles

cover image

Scholastic, 2015. ISBN 9781775430971
(Age: 6+) Recommended. War. Anzac. Animals. When Lucy's dog has a pup, she calls it Freda, but the family cannot afford to keep her, so Lucy sits with her outside their home until someone comes along to claim her. That person is Sam, a young man going off to war, and he takes Freda with him as a lucky mascot.
This moving story of Anzac, based on the true story of the mascot Freda of the NZ Rifle Brigade, will tug at people's heart strings as they read of the bond between man and dog, of the relationship they had over the grueling years of the war, of the men who died along the way.
In this fiction tale, the dog and his master return to New Zealand there to meet up again with Lucy and the three share a bond which ends in becoming a family.
The real dog returned to England and ended her days in Staffordshire where a small headstone marks her grave. As part of the 100th commemoration of World War one, her original headstone was placed in the Army Museum in New Zealand, with her collar inscribed with Freda.
With so many books about Anzac published at the moment, this makes a different story to present to a class or reader. It shows the theatre of war with pen and watercolour images designed to inform and engross the reader, and presents in spare prose the outline of the story. A double page at the end reprises the real tale of Fred and readers will enjoy seeing how the story has been augmented for a children's book.
In the classroom a group of picture books could be used to pinpoint where all are set, widening the children's idea of where the war was fought.
Fran Knight

Eat the sky, drink the ocean, edited by Kirsty Murray, Payal Dhar and Anita Roy

cover image

Allen & Unwin, 2015. ISBN 9781743319789
(Age: 12+) Recommended. Short Stories, Fantasy. When in 2012, two appalling crimes against women were perpetrated, one in India where a woman was raped and murdered in a bus and the other in Melbourne where a woman was raped and killed walking home, the idea for this anthology extolling the ambitions and dreams of women was born. A partnership between writers in India and Australia was promoted, resulting in pairs of authors working together to produce speculative fiction, with women grasping the world with both hands, ensuring that they take big chunks out of that pie in the sky.
As a result this anthology published by Allen & Unwin with funding from the Australia Council, presents ten short stories, six graphic stories and one play script.
Each story is unique, fascinating and playful.
In a classroom, they could be used as a study of short stories, a study of speculative fiction, a model for students' work, and a jumping off board for reading other works by the authors appearing.
Trying to choose just a few to talk about is almost impossible, as I enjoyed them all. A graphic story by Nicki Greenberg, Back-stage pass has a journalist interviewing Ophelia before her curtain call. The questioner asks the girl why she was written that way, why she killed herself and why she didn't have more to say for herself. Questions countless students ponder when studying Hamlet. Nicki's recognisable graphic style stands out. I can imagine readers going off on a tangent with this one, postulating Ophelia's story for themselves. But this applies to so many of the tales in this book.
In Little red suit, Justine Larbalestier puts Little Red Riding Hood into a dystopian future where people live in a bubble, protected from the outside world. But Poppy is desperate to visit her grandmother's house and comes across a wolf.
Anita Roy's Cooking time postulates a very future Master Chef where Mandy has another agenda in becoming a contestant.
Cast out by Sahmta Rani is very confronting beginning with a girl being whipped and removed form her village but finding a place where women come together.
Weft by Alyssa Brugman has a girl sell a kidney to receive enough credits to buy someone's hair, but in getting the hair entwined with hers, begins to think about the person who sold her hair.
Each story offers something different, and at the end of the book are pieces from each author explaining their collaboration with another, which adds another level of interest to the stories.
Fran Knight

Before After by Anne-Margot Ramstein and Matthias Aregui

cover image

Walker Books, 2014. ISBN 9781406357936
(Age: 6+) Highly recommended. This book is quite a beautiful package of images, colours and ideas. The hardback copy resembles a box with parchment-like pages meeting edge to edge with the cover.
It is a wordless picture book showing examples of before and after images; situations and consequences of change. Simple images, in matt-finished, muted shades add to the book's appeal and originality. There is the real and the fantastical, along with the whimsical, with each single image or double-page spread being open to many interesting interpretations. Of particular note is the image of the cave painting of a bull with a real bull outside the cave. This is followed by a picture of an easel painting featuring a bull, with one in the fields in real view. Coffee beans on a tree move to a cup of coffee. There is a delightful sequence of an octopus to ink, then bird to feather, then feather to typewriter, then pigeon to letter.
Throughout this delightful book, there is potential for conversations and storytelling; certainly an interesting educational medium. Originally a French publication, this will be shared and enjoyed by readers of any age.
Julie Wells

The Famous Five Annual 2015 by Enid Blyton

cover image

Hodder Children's Books, 2014. ISBN 9781444918816
(Age: 8+) Hachette/Hodder Publishers has produced this book in the style of the original Enid Blyton annuals enjoyed by young readers in the 1950 and 60s. There is a combination of original illustrations, including those of Eileen Soper, and adaptations of the Famous Five stories plus new material, which updates the whole publishing concept.
Selected series by the author are to be reissued by Hodder with new covers, so this Annual will be an enjoyable addition to the collections of Enid Blyton enthusiasts.
This durable hardcover edition with good quality papers, largely gloss finished, and with a fabulous concoction of information about the Famous Five, cartoon strip features, puzzles, historical material, stories and quizzes, introduces the young reader to what an 'annual' is all about! There is the potential for some great reading pastime.
Julie Wells

The Gathering of the Lost by Helen Lowe

cover image

Wall of Night series. Orbit Books, 2012. ISBN 9780356500577
(Age: Young adult/Adult) Highly recommended. Gathering of the Lost is the second of Helen Lowe's four-book Wall of Night fantasy series. Lowe loses none of her ability to weave her poetic imagery into each page, as she links these first two narratives. While retaining many familiar characters and introducing a host of new figures, she manipulates the increasingly broad cast with ease. Gathering of the Lost builds superbly on its predecessor The Heir of Night.
Lowe skilfully takes her readers into Gray Lands and Wild Lands; and speaks of the lands beyond the river and along the road to Ishnapur and Jhaine... It has been five years since Malian, The Heir of Night and her friend Kalan, were lost to the winter of Jaransor. Yet even now, there remain those - perhaps friend, perhaps foe - who still cannot believe Malian is dead...
Long ago The Earl of Night's minstrel, Haimyr the Golden, had desired that Malian flee the Wall of Night. But now there is urgency to find her. Believing the heralds Jehane Mor and Tarathan of Ar have hidden Malian, Haimyr issues a summons for the Heralds to return Malian to the Keep of Winds. The ever-astute Jehane Mor senses a veiled threat however, and ponders why the minstrel should now wish for Malian's return.
Soon there are more questions than answers. Much is happening - an attack on the Guild, bloodshed during the Festival of Masks, and an attack by the beast-men (were-hunters) for a start. Importantly, the reader is introduced to Carick, a River scholar, who was unprepared for bloodshed and warfare when he left the peaceable realms of Ar in the Riverlands and became cartographer to the Duke of Emer. Then as Jehane Mor invokes the dark sky during a wholesale attack by the were-hunters, Carick stands with arms outstretched, listening to the voice of the night-wind pleading him to hold with her, against the might and power of the were-beasts.
While there are references to killing, Lowe's lyrical narrative tempers the tone. As Lowe's cinematic composition unfolds, her readers are treated to characters who are not always who they appear to be, and Malian's whereabouts remain unclear. With inky creatures here and mind-speak there, people morphing into beast-men, and attempts to pursuade The Lost, it is easy to become absorbed in this magical web of intrigue.
Like its predecessor, Gathering of the Lost is an exceptionally well-crafted book, that builds seamlessly on its predecessor. Highly recommended for young adult and adult readers of fantasy.
Colleen Tuovinen

The Flywheel by Erin Gough

cover image

Hardie Grant Egmont, 2015. ISBN 9781742978178
(Age: 15+) Highly recommended.
'When life throws up in your lap, find yourself a distraction.'
This novel by an up and coming Australian author Erin Gough is a well written and delightful story. The characters are cleverly crafted to be truly believable. The action is well paced and the complexities of the plot keep those pages turning.
This book is about relationships and the joy, heartbreak, misery and contentment they generate. Delilah, a self-assured homosexual, experiences young love, but suffers bullying at school. She is fiercely loyal to her friends but must make a difficult decision about the lengths to which she can take that loyalty.
'I can't believe I am sitting here. The chair is comfy, yes, but it is the very chair I've been avoiding. It is the Comfy Chair of Doom. Opposite me on her ergonomic swivel seat sits Mrs Croenberg.'
This is also the story of a relationship with school and a teacher who just does not give up on Delilah. She is a teacher who helps Delilah understand herself and provides an invitation back to schooling.
'And in this moment I am happy. I don't what's around the corner but it doesn't matter, because what I feel right now is enough.'
Very importantly, this is a story with a happy ending. The complications are resolved and there is an optimistic air to life's challenges. This book is highly recommended.
Linda Guthrie