Reviews

Sad, the dog by Sandy Fussell

cover image

Ill. by Tull Suwannakit. Walker Books, 2015. ISBN 9781921529641
(Age: 5+) Highly recommended. Pets, Dogs, Family, Home. A dog given to an older couple as a gift is looked after by them but never given a name. They feed him, wash him, scold him for barking or digging the garden, or tearing up the newspapers but do not name him. So he names himself. He calls himself Sad, because that is how he feels in this home where he is unwanted and unloved. One day the couple pack their belongings and move away leaving Sad behind. A new family arrives and the young boy sees the dog and is instantly excited. The family feeds him, they give him fresh water to drink and take him for a walk. He is given a soft warm bed on the back verandah and when he wakes, Jack is there with a treat. He does all the things he did with his previous family but now he is not scolded or left outside; he is loved, wanted and called by his new name, Lucky.
This is a treat of a story, one full of warmth and charm as the dog is at first not cared for and then finds someone who loves him. Along the way readers will see the difference between owning a dog and loving and caring for a dog, how a dog reacts to the care given it, of how an animal fits into the family. Children will love reading of Sad and marvel at his change of fortune, and be instantly mesmerised by the watercolour illustrations showing the changes in the dog's fortunes as he goes from being alone and dejected to being alive and happy. The endpapers reflect his status beautifully. This is a treat simply as a great story well told and illustrated, but a boon for teachers and parents wanting to discuss the care of a pet.
Fran Knight

Shadowcat by Julia Louise

cover image

Ill. by Anne Ryan. Five Mile Press, 2015. ISBN 9781760067090
(Age: 4+) Recommended. Bravery, Dreams, Siblings. Edith often sits in the garden alone, avoiding her baby brother. She feels she is turning into a garden gnome, sitting there quietly, without moving, allowing the grass to grow around her. But one day a cat comes by and asks her why she is doing what she is doing. He inquires why she doesn't dream, and Edith, surprised asks him how he knows. He tells her that cats can see when people dream as stardust forms around them. He takes her hand and together they walk into the overgrown garden and he teaches her to dance. Each night she dances and stardust forms around her as she dreams. She dances in the garden taking her brother's hand in hers. But one night the cat does not come back, and she begins to feel a bit gnomish, until she finally sees him through her window and he tells her to dream alone, to be brave as the stars are always with her.
This is a charming story of daring to dream, of being brave, as Edith becomes introverted when a baby appears in the household, losing her place within the family. The stylised acrylic illustrations show the young girl sitting quietly in the garden, amongst the gnomes. The shadows of the trees make the garden look ominous, but the night sky becomes warm and encompassing as she dances with the cat.
A wonderful addition to the range of stories about the arrival of a new baby in the household and learning to be resilient.
Fran Knight

The flyaway girls by Julia Lawrinson

cover image

Penguin, 2015. ISBN 9780143308652
(Age: 10+) Highly recommended. Gymnastics, Jealousy, Friendship. Chelsea is threatened when a new girl, Telia joins her gymnastic club. Chelsea has worked hard for a long time, doing extra training at home after her five hours at the club each week, in preparation for the Nationals. But this new girl has a natural talent that Chelsea can only dream about, and each time she tries a new skill, needs only a small amount of instruction from Louisa to get it right the next time. Ellie does not believe that she has not been trained and continues her snide remarks and comments towards the new girl. Chelsea's other friends, Rosie and Gemma, practising for the school band, form a neat contrast to the problems at the club, especially when Chelsea can see her aim of being chosen for the Nationals slipping away. But she likes Telia, and cannot abide the bickering of Ellie, so she has a dilemma to work out, who to support.
This is a wonderfully written story of middle primary girls training their hearts out for a chance at a place in the top rung of their sport. The threat of not making it is always hangs over their heads, and their regime at the club reinforces the work they must do to succeed.
The finely observed detail of working so hard at club level pervades the story and the reader settles in easily into the strengths and weaknesses shown by the girls.
Problems at home also add to the mix of this very readable story which will make all readers watch with new eyes the gymnastics at the Olympic and Commonwealth Games.
Fran Knight

The Phantom Bully by Jeffrey Brown

cover image

Star Wars: Jedi Academy bk 3. Scholastic, 2015. ISBN 9780545621267
(Age: 9-12) Recommended. Author, illustrator Jeffrey Brown's popular Star Wars Jedi Academy returns. Roan Sanchez is about to enter his final year at the Jedi Academy. Middle School proves to be challenging for the young trainee, as he is honing his Jedi skills, performing in a class talent show, dating and coping with the class bully Cronah. Creatively set out as diary entries with class schedules, notes, holomail, holobook chats, cartoons, graphic diagrams, Roan's diary is an exciting account of his student life.
After Spring Break Roan settles down to training with his mentor Mr. G, as he wants to be a pilot like his father and enjoys using the flight simulator. There's the Jedi Obstacle Challenge Trial to complete where Roan learns the importance of friendship and resilience. At the Icecream Social, Roan serves the dessert with mite sauce and beetle jelly added for extra taste. Of course Cronah's involved in this mischief. After a light saber battle between Roan and his enemy, the reader gains an understanding of the reasons behind the bully's behaviour.
This diary format with personal information, insights and illustrations is an extremely popular format with preteen readers. Jeff Brown's setting of the Jedi Academy and his understanding of middle school life makes this another exciting adventure for Star Wars fans.
Rhyllis Bignell

Wombat wins by Jackie French and Bruce Whatley

cover image

Angus & Robertson, 2015. ISBN 9780732299576
(Age: 4+) Recommended. Wombats, Winning, Carrots. The winning combination of French and Whatley has produced another book in the series about wombats. In this one, Mothball goes along to the school sports day. She has yawned, scratched, eaten some grass and noticed, after rummaging through the fridge that the small humans are racing past the window.
The reader can see from their distinctive clothing that they are off to a sporting arena of some sort, but Mothball has only one thought in mind, to beat them getting to the carrots. So begins a marvellous series of pages where Mothball is seemingly competing against the small humans, winning the race by burrowing through the hill, winning the sack race, jumping across the heads of the swimmers to reach the end of the pool and inadvertently taking a gold medal. But she spies a shopping bag out of which is sticking some greenery, so hunts it down and luxuriates in the greens until she falls asleep.
Ah, just another day in the life of a wombat, Mothball. Readers will love reading the story and looking at the wonderful illustrations, reveling in the antics of this creature, wondering just how one comes to be in a household, and marveling at the patience needed to house such a thing. And also contemplate the idea of sports days, winning and aspects of competition.
Fran Knight,

When I was me by Hilary Freeman

cover image

Hot Key Books, 2015. ISBN: 9781471404924
(Age: 15+) Story: Yesterday, Ella's life was completely normal. Today, she woke up as a different person. Or, to be more exact, she feels like the same person, but she looks different, her friends are different, and every facet of her life is different to what she remembers. At first she thinks she must be crazy, especially since she's the only person who thinks that anything is wrong, but when she meets a stranger named Daniel, she starts drawing closer and closer to the truth . . .
Review: First things first: When I was me is actually a good book. It has an intriguing, very original plotline, some interesting characters, and tremendous amounts of potential. However, this potential is never fully achieved - despite being very promising at first, this book ends up just sitting squarely within the genre of  'teen romance'. While not a bad thing necessarily, the intrigue of the original idea - that of a girl waking up in a life that is not hers, and all the consequences of that - almost feels wasted here. One feels that Freeman could have easily made this into a complex thriller with a dash of science-fiction sensibilities, but instead the book remains simple - at times far too much - and becomes just another run-of-the-mill teen novel rife with romance and friendship dramas. This is not to say the novel is totally flawed, however - there are some excellent themes here at play, and Freeman deals deftly with complicated topics such as finding your identity, and how we perceive reality. The characters are interesting, yet ultimately underdeveloped, and it rollicks along at an exciting pace. But while this novel is definitely enjoyable, it never quite reaches the heights it could have, and ultimately, that's the most frustrating thing.
Rebecca Adams (university student)

Battle of the Heroes by Kate Forsyth

cover image

The Impossible Quest bk 5. Scholastic, 2015. ISBN 9781743624104
(Age: 9-12) Highly recommended. Themes: Fantasy, Magical Creatures, Good and Evil, Sorcery, Quests, Adventures. Kate Forsyth's impressive conclusion to her magical fantasy series Battle of the Heroes pits the four young heroes and their magical creatures against the most frightening of creatures in Wolfhaven Castle. Quinn, Sebastian, Elanor and Tom have escaped the evil witch sisters' clutches by ingenious trickery and begin preparations for a dangerous sea voyage to return to their former home, free the imprisoned lord and his people and fulfill the ancient prophecy. They have gathered the magical elements, a griffin's feather, unicorn's horn, sea-serpent's scale and dragon's tooth and are ready to wake the four sleeping warriors hidden beneath the castle. Sabre the sea-serpent aids the travellers pulling their wooden coracles across the dark treacherous lake.
Each step of their journey is fraught with danger - fighting the spear-wielding bog-men, escaping from the Mistress Mauldred's attacking ravens, relying on their magical creatures for rescue - Tom's griffin helps with Jack's escape. The young adventurers draw on their skills and knowledge to race into the underground tunnels constantly being chased by their enemies. Together they discover the hidden bone key in the Great Room and the secret passage that leads to the sleeping warriors' chamber.
The final battle scenes are heightened drama, fighting a skeleton army riding skeleton horses, fierce giant rats, swash-buckling sword fights and overcoming the witches evil acts that nearly foil the prophecy's fulfillment.
Kate Forsyth's rich imagery, feisty characters, lyrical language, fast-paced action and engaging magic and fantasy elements, make the The Impossible Quest series appealing to both younger readers and adult fans of this genre.
Rhyllis Bignell

Me and Earl and the dying girl by Jesse Andrews

cover image

Allen & Unwin, 2015. ISBN 9781760290184
(Age: 14+) Recommended. For those thinking this contemporary debut is similar to John Green's The Fault in Our Stars, think again. This entertaining and highly realistic novel is not your average 'sick lit'. Greg Gaines is a bit of a social chameleon. His goal is to remain civil with everyone at school but not to belong to any particular clique. After all, Greg just wants everyone to like him. He only has one real friend, the pint-sized and foul-mouthed Earl, who shares his love of film making. At least Greg only has one friend until his mother makes him hang out with Rachel, an old childhood acquaintance who has been diagnosed with leukaemia. Despite Greg's protests, his mother believes that he can use his infamous humour to cheer Rachel up in her time of need. Greg ends up sharing more with Rachel than just his jokes, and he is well and truly pushed out of his comfort zone. The one thing that he tried to avoid, being disliked by anyone, becomes all too hard after all.
Jesse Andrews explores many themes in his debut including grief, peer pressure, poor family backgrounds, and of course, cancer. He tells the story of a leukaemia stricken girl in a very honest way and uses humour to soften the harshness of this topic. Some mature middle school students could handle this book, but it would better suit senior school students due to the language used, and the reoccurring use of drugs and smoking in the novel. Although, both are well within the context of the story and are necessary in exploring the theme of poor family backgrounds. Boys will especially enjoy this truly hilarious and very real novel.
Emma Gay

Blue whale blues by Peter Carnavas

cover image

New Frontier Publishing, 2015. ISBN 9781925059410
(Age: 4+) Warmly recommended. Whales, Depression, Friendship, Environment. When Penguin hears Whale singing the blues, he decides to investigate. He asks what the problem is and Whale points out that his bike is not right. Penguin laughs saying it is just upside down and puts it up the right way and Whale is happy. Later Penguin hears him singing the blues again and asks him what the problem is. Whale is concerned that his bike is getting wet so Penguin gives him a towel to dry it. This story line continues as the Whale sings the blues and Penguin comes along like a good friend to help. Each four page sees something which troubles Whale, and a friend coming to his aid. When Turtle turns up on a trike, Whale laughs when Penguin explains that he cannot use a trike as he has no legs and arms. This evokes a great belly laugh from Whale and the friends are happy that Whale is happy.
A gentle repetition of one line about the Whale feeling happy will be a line readers will call out when each situation occurs. The song to accompany the story is available as a download, and the illustrations will cause a ripple of laughs from the readers as they spy the absurdity of Whale's concerns under the sea. Along the way readers will get a sense of some of the rubbish which eventually finds its way into the oceans, and wonder how it affects the animals that live there.
Fran Knight

The Tournament at Gorlan by John Flanagan

cover image

Ranger's Apprentice, The Early Years bk 1. Random House Australia, 2015. ISBN 9781742759302
(Age: 10+) Recommended. I admit that I am a big fan of the Ranger's Apprentice series and so I was looking forward to reading this prequel.
This book takes us back to earlier days when Halt was an aspiring Ranger. He travels with friend and fellow Ranger, Crowley, on a mission to rebel against Baron Morgarath's evil plotting.
King Oswald is virtually a prisoner and Prince Duncan apparently has begun to behave in a cruel and un-princely manner, losing the support of his people.
Halt and Crowley need to find the many Rangers who have been dismissed and replaced with Baron Morgarath's puppets.
This book highlights the friendship between Halt and Crowley. They enjoy each other's company and their friendly banter and jibes are comical and entertaining. Each ex-Ranger that joins their group brings their own story and skills but they are only a small group and Mogarath has the support of many.
The action, suspense and dialogue keep the reader entertained and always curious about the next chapter. This is a classic good against evil story that delivers a great tale.
I recommend this book for students from 10 years +.
Jane Moore

As big as you by Sara Acton

cover image

Scholastic, 2015. ISBN 9781743629697
(Age: 4+) Highly recommended. Difference, Elephants, Size and shape. The soft watercolour illustrations of Sara Acton fill the pages of this engaging book showing its readers the difference between the words big and small, as the father (Claude) and baby elephant (Finlay) compare their exertions. Claude flaps his ears to cover his head from the sun, while Finlay can only wriggle his: Claude can trumpet loudly but Finlay can only produce a squeak: Claude's feet on the ground sound like thunder, while Finlay's little feet only bounce. Claude can run very fast and Finlay has trouble catching up, so much so that he lags behind and cannot see his father. He climbs a tree to see if he can see Claude, and then falls, finding he can use his ears to float to the ground and into his father's arms.
All the while the wonderful illustrations will attract the readers to watch as Finlay explores his environment, learning what he can and cannot do at his age. Guided by dad, he learns things about himself, and learns particularly that he will grow up to be like dad in time. A wonderful book to read with young children, reinforcing the relationship between father and son, showing readers that they too will be like dad one day, and teaching them the difference between the words big and little.
Fran Knight

Emmy and Oliver by Robin Benway

cover image

Simon & Schuster, 2015. ISBN 9781471144134
(Age: 15+) Readers will laugh out loud and sympathise with a heart wrenching story as they enjoy Robin Benway's, Emmy and Oliver. After the kidnapping of her best childhood friend - Oliver - in 2nd grade, Emmy has wanted to be in charge of her own life and break free from her overprotective parents. Now, in her final year of school and on the cusp of adulthood, Oliver is back. He's not the little boy Emmy remembers from next door - he is a tall, handsome stranger. Though he isn't the carefree little boy he once was. Oliver is dealing with a tumultuous past - he must come to terms with being kidnapped and lied to all these years by his own father and learn to fit in to his new life with a mother he barely remembers and her new family - the one she started after he was snatched away.
Emmy and Oliver have always shared a connection that neither can ignore - one that picks right up where it left off. Benway writes with humour and captures poignantly what it's like to be a teenager facing grown up decisions. Readers will love her easy-to-read style of writing and connect with her surprisingly real characters, though should be aware of the occasional profanity she uses in order to express the raw emotions of an aching heart. Benway drops the pace slightly midway through the novel, but finishes strong. This novel is recommended for public and school libraries for mature teen audiences. (15+).
Rhiannon Mesner

True Light by Susannah McFarlane

cover image

EJ12 bk 20 series. LemonFizz Media, Scholastic, 2015. ISBN 9781925206036
(Age: 8-10) Highly recommended. Themes: Family Life, Spies, Codes and Ciphers, Resilience. Family is a very important part of Emma Jack's life, both her mother and her Farmor - father's mother have undertaken SHINE missions and adventures. Although Emma is upset about the loss of her grandmother, she must show courage and resilience as she takes on a new mission with SJ45 her mum. Somewhere in the Arctic Circle SHADOW agents have set up a laboratory to make copies of every world currency. Emma's skills in solving codes are called upon to help find the hidden location.
In EJ12 Girl Hero 20: True Light, solving the present day mission and one that occurred nine months earlier in Sweden are mysteriously linked. In a flashback Emma recalls her special visit with her father's family, celebrating wonderful Christmas traditions. She loves the food - smorgasbord meals, making the meatballs with her cousin and singing to the ham. Emma's father and aunt are concerned for their mother who is looking frail. The day after Christmas Emma and her mother are called out on a mission - Farmor BH85 has a secret spy room in her wardrobe as well.
EJ12 is on another amazing adventure, dog sledding across the icy landscape, helping poisoned reindeer, finding the hidden mine and collecting a mysterious little red horse that has a hidden message. Her present day mission in the Arctic summer is just as exciting, as she works with her mother again to stop SHADOW's evil plans.
Susanna McFarlane's novel gives the reader a great insight into Emma's family life and the SHINE connections. Her descriptions of fabulous scenery, delicious food and Swedish Christmas traditions make this an extra special story in this popular series.
Rhyllis Bignell

The naughtiest reindeer at the zoo by Nicki Greenberg

cover image

Allen & Unwin, 2015. ISBN 9781760112141
(Age: 5+) Recommended, Christmas, Reindeers, Pets, Zoos, Families. In rhyming stanzas Nicki Greenberg tells the tale of Ruby the pet reindeer. Last Christmas she caused mayhem at Grandma's for Christmas, so when the family heads off again this year, they leave Ruby at the zoo. But here she causes even more mayhem and needs to call in for extra help. Ruby is very lonely at the zoo, the other animals are grim and will not speak to her, and she misses the companionship of the other reindeers in Santa's sleigh. The animals point out to her that she has nothing to be sad about. After all they never get a visit from Santa. All the children are at their homes, the keepers stay away and no one visits them, let alone bring a present. Silly Ruby decides to give them all a present and finding the keeper's key, lets the animals out.
Now she does need Santa to call by and help her put them all back in their cages. A clever idea does just that and has all the animals rand the children visit each other on Christmas Day. A cute story, underlining the role of Christmas in children's lives and the fact that zoos are closed only one day of the year. Families are portrayed as doing things together at Christmas and the customs that underpin Christmas are shown. A brightly illustrated story that will give children a treat.
Fran Knight

Devoted in death by J.D. Robb

cover image

In death bk 41. Piaktus, 2015. ISBN 9780349403731
(Age: Adult) Crime. thriller. Serial killers. Ella-Loo and Darryl are a couple on their way to New York, when they they find that they become addicted to murder after killing a motorist for his car. They manage to get away with multiple murders until they kill a much loved musician in New York and Lieutenant Eve Dallas puts together the clues that link this murder to many others across the country. Now they have taken another young woman and their grisly acts are ramping up.
Devoted in death is different in that the reader knows who has committed the murders and why they have been committed. Robb gives an in-depth description of the two criminals, how their minds work and what they do and all the suspense in the story is to be found as the reader desperately hopes that Eve and Roake can put together the pieces and rescue the pair's latest victims.
Not many authors are able to keep the reader's interest in a series that contains 41 books, but Robb manages to provide enough thrills, chills and suspense to keep the reader engrossed and look forward to another one.
Pat Pledger