Reviews

The River and the Book by Alison Croggon

cover image

Walker Books, 2015. ISBN 9781925081725
(Age: 10+) Alison Croggon is the author of the highly regarded Black Spring, and The Books of Pellinor. She is also a poet and opera librettist. This story is a fable for our times, beautifully written and resounding with messages that relate to the way of the world in past and present times. Here is a village set on a fertile riverbank, midway between mountains and a floodplain. The village has a traditional 'Keeper' of a Book which gives the village its identity and which can predict change. One day, a foreign visitor comes to the village, endears herself to the villagers, in particular, Simbala the latest Keeper, and manages to steal the precious Book from them. It is Simbala who takes the blame and who sets out to return this treasured item to the village. It is a quest which takes many years; she knows too that times have greatly changed and wonders if the book she eventually finds will come 'back to life' for her people. The story is an analogy for colonialism and reveals what can happen when there is often a total disregard for a people's culture, and for the natural environment, all for the sake of development. The River and the Book has been endorsed by Amnesty International as contributing to a better understanding of human rights and values.
The story is spellbinding and the character of Simbala is a delight to heed and observe as she journeys on her determined path. In a beautifully poetic style, the language is intoxicating and recalls the storytellers of past ages. Katie Harnett's superb black and white brushstrokes illustrate the beginnings of each chapter and her coloured cover art is most attractive.
Julie Wells

Eleanor by Jason Gurley

cover image

Harper Collins, 2015. ISBN: 9780008132910
(Age: 14+) Highly recommended. Sitting somewhere between the realms of science fiction and fantasy, Gurley's novel is certainly captivating. The prosaic style of the work draws attention to both its literary value and its story value, giving it a sense of overall tranquillity despite the terrifying circumstances that main character, Eleanor, finds herself in.
Eleanor's childhood ends the day she loses her twin in a car accident. Her parents begin fighting and eventually they separate leaving her mother, Agnes thrown back into the depression of her childhood. Eleanor stays with her hateful mother in order to take care of her, never drawing unnecessary attention or causing trouble. . . until she disappears. Walking through the cafeteria doors she falls into a dream world where she and her friend Jack are still children, playing in a field in Iowa. When the dream ends however, she finds herself back at school, after hours and locked in. It is the first time this has happened and it certainly won't be the last. She slowly realises that she has become the plaything of her twin beyond the grave who now goes by the name of Mae. Eleanor's disappearances become more frequent and she loses more and more time until finally her disappearance is noticed. She becomes a missing person (for lack of a body) landing Jack, her best friend, in a police investigation and leaving her mother who has just been diagnosed with cancer in her father's grudging care. Can the actions of Eleanor and her dead twin save their parents from their unhappiness? Only time can tell - but what time?
A novel thoroughly enjoyed, I would highly recommend for lovers of soft science fiction and fantasy fourteen and older. Gurley deals with themes of grief, regret and loneliness, allowing for a touchstone into reality despite its sci-fi qualities.
Kayla Gaskell (Age twenty)

Squishy McFluff, the Invisible Cat: Secret Santa by Pip Jones

cover image

Squishy McFluff, the Invisible Cat: Secret Santa by Pip Jones
Ill. by Ellie Okstad. Faber and Faber, 2015. ISBN 9780571302567
Squishy McFluff is so sweet, you'll be smitten.
Such a clever and funny invisible kitten!
Imagine the fun of having a cat that only you can see, especially when it is really good at inventing great things to do like playing hide-and-seek at which he is world champion. This is Ava's luck. She has a big imagination and is happiest when she's playing with her cat, even though it can lead to trouble - which is exactly what happens in this latest addition to this series.
It's nearly Christmas and Ava and Squishy are very excited. But there are still preparations to be made, like buying the last minute things which means going into town where all is decorations and celebrations. The trouble begins when Ava spots the wonky star at the top of the Christmas tree. The next day it is time to wrap the presents and when Mum says to wrap EVERYTHING, she is taken at her word. For someone who was trying to be good through all of December, this might not have a pretty ending for Ava, but she has one special thing she wants so she writes Santa a letter.
Young children will love this series from this English author as it holds many laughs and just a little bit of naughty. Written in rhyme it bounces along and Ella Okstad's limited-palette illustrations are charming, capturing the essence of the text perfectly.
For those who can't get enough of him, there's a website with extra information and more fun and games at http://squishymcfluff.com/ This is something a little bit different to offer those just getting started on their independent reading journey who need a bit of support through short chapters, larger font and uncomplicated vocabulary - I think they will be eagerly awaiting the next adventure. Perfect for putting aside for this year's Christmas Countdown.
Barbara Braxton

The fairiest fairy by Anna Booth

cover image

Ill. by Rosalind Beardshaw. Nosy Crow, 2015. ISBN 9780857633156
(Age: Pre-school - Yr 2) Betty was a fairy who just never got things right,
She was always in a muddle though she tried with all her might.
No matter what Betty tried to do at fairy school, she just couldn't get herself sorted. Even her wand was tied on with elastic so she wouldn't lose it! And her first attempts at spells did not have the desired results. She can't scatter dewdrops or wake up the flowers or paint rainbows and she is terribly upset. But Betty has something else - she has compassion and empathy and as she wends her way through the book many of nature's gentle creatures are thankful for what she offers.
So when it is time for the Fairy Ball, Betty is disconsolate for she knows she will not be chosen as the fairiest fairy until.
This is a charming story - that focuses on friendship, persistence, resilience and individuality in a setting that will definitely appeal to most very young girls. Betty could become a role model as she refuses to give up, putting the needs of others first when she could be practising. Booth has chosen to write the story in rhyme so it has that rhythm that little ones like and Beardshaw's gentle, bright illustrations are a delightful accompaniment.
Given the continued popularity of stories about fairies that never seems to wane as each new class of preschoolers and Kindy kids comes to the library, this will be a popular addition to the New-For-You display at the beginning of term.
Barbara Braxton

Socks, sandbags & leeches: letters to my Anzac dad by Pauline Deeves

cover image

National Library of Australia, 2016. ISBN 9780642278845
(Age: 10+) Recommended. World War One, Anzac, Home front, Propaganda. Through Ivy's letters to her father at Gallipoli during the eight months that the Anzac troops were stationed there, and after in France, we see what life is like at the Home Front, as she and her mother have to move in with Aunt Hilda, the small flat barely accommodating them. The twenty letters sent between 1914 and 1918, describe the attitudes at home, the volunteer work done, the lack of money, the making do, the work of the cheer up society, the growing prejudice against those with German ancestry, and the propaganda disseminated to the populace.
Each letter is illustrated with pictures from the times, sourced from the archives at the National Library of Australia, and indicative of society and its attitudes during World War One. For students to find out how children coped with their fathers away at war, and their family so confined by restrictions of war time, then this book will be a fascinating resource for the classroom and library. For older readers, it is an interesting factual book, as each letter reveals something about Australia at war, and for many the book will be like a memoir, a story to be read from start to finish, gaining a great deal of information about life in Australia one hundred years ago.
One letter amongst many which took my interest is about Fundraising. In the letter, Ivy tells of their visit to the local doctor's house, opened to raise finds for the Red Cross. She describes things about the house which would interest her father. Around the letter are many examples of fund raising activities with posters of the Red Cross Nurse, and a Gala Day. One poster shows an extravagant woman spending money on frivolous things, exhorting women to be thrifty, while another details the work done by the Education Department's War Relief Fund in Victoria. Each poster gives more information about the work done in raising money and awareness.
A detailed index appears after a glossary and fascinating list of illustrations, giving details of where all the illustrations came from, all designed to add weight to an already impressive resource book.
This is a book to use in the classrooms or just to dip into for an insight into how children coped with being on the home front during war time.
And a fascinating fact I came across: St Kilda Football Club changed their colours because they wee also Germany's colours, is one example of the range of information given sure to have broad appeal.
Fran Knight

BRO by Helen Chebatte

cover image

Hardie Grant Egmont, 2016. ISBN 9781760125509
(Age: 12+) Recommended. Bro by Helen Chebatte is a fictional work which explores the racial divide in modern Australia. The story is set in a modern school where racial matters are everything and the slightest insult cannot be tolerated. The author of this review would recommend this novel for those aged 12+.
Romeo Makhlouf is a boy caught in the racial divide in his school, with an Australian mother and an Arabic father. He is a member of the Lebs, one of the four racially divided groups in the school. He knows the rules: do not tolerate insult to your group, and do not be afraid to fight for the honour of your peers.
But when an unfortunate first kiss and the starting of a fight club spark war between the different groups, Romeo does not know on which side to stand; with the Lebs, where he has belonged all of his life, or with the Ozzies, where he has found both love and hate?
BRO demonstrates how foolish it is to focus on race, and the consequences of doing so.
Jos A. (Student, Year 10)

Squishy Taylor and the Bonus Sisters by Ailsa Wild

cover image

Ill. by Ben Wood. Hardie Grant Egmont, 2016. ISBN 9781760126759
(Age: 6+ - Independent readers) Recommended. Themes: Family - Step-families; Relationships; Homelessness; Forgiveness. Squishy Taylor is in a newly blended family, learning to deal with her laid-back father's divided attention, an absent Mother, a Step mother and her twin daughters and the young baby brother they share with Squishy. It takes a shared secret and a few poor decisions to bring the Bonus sisters together, but first they go through a fraught settling in period. A young runaway boy and a grumpy next door neighbour (and a bit of misguided revenge) assist to bring the girls together and to learn to see the benefits of having bonus sisters and living in a blended family.
This will be a new series involving Squishy (yes, it is a nick-name!), who is sometimes inclined to bounce against the boundaries, and will fit nicely between Billie B Brown and the Go Girl series for young readers.
Carolyn Hull

Illuminae by Amie Kaufman and Jay Kristoff

cover image

The Illuminae Files bk 1. Allen & Unwin, 2015. ISBN 9781760113803
(Age: 14+) Recommended. Science fiction. In the distant future of 2575, at the edge of the universe is a tiny, freezing planet known as Kerenza IV, where a secret mining colony live in relative peace. Then one day, a giant warship appears out of the sky and fires on the colony without warning, killing countless civilians and prompting a full evacuation.
Kady and her ex-boyfriend Ezra barely escape alive onto the rescue fleet, and that's just the start of their problems. With the warship still chasing them down, a mysterious illness spreading among the survivors, the rescue ship's artificial intelligence beginning to wreak havoc, and a possible conspiracy among their ship's command crew, Kady and Ezra will have to work together to uncover the truth.
One of the best facets of Illuminae is its rich, engaging world. The story is told through the unusual form of compiled 'real' documents such as interviews, private journals, emails, and so on. In the wrong hands this style could have easily felt out-of-place or gimmicky, but here it adds another layer of realism that draws the reader in even further.
Another highlight is the characters; they are multifaceted and likeable, but still have realistic flaws, and both Ezra and Kady are very enjoyable to read about. However, since the book is told mostly in third-person perspective 'documents', it's not as easy to relate to Kady and Ezra as it would be if it were a straightforward novel told in first-person.
Similarly, although Illuminae is fascinating because of how it is told - through interviews and the like - this also makes the story lose some of its immediacy. Take for example the opening interview where Kady is discussing her escape from Kerenza IV; while interesting, it lacks the excitement that having it described in present tense would generate - precisely because the reader already knows that Kady is alive to tell the tale, and thus any sense of danger during the scene is lost. Much of the novel is like this, but it's a small price to pay for such an intriguing story.
Illuminae is a page-turning, fascinating adventure of a novel.
Rebecca Adams (university student)

The Princess in Black and the hungry bunny horde by Shannon Hale and Dean Hale

cover image

Ill. by LeUyen Pham. The Princess in Black, bk 3. Candlewick Press, 2016. ISBN 9780763665135
(Age: 6+) Highly recommended. Princess Magnolia is off to have brunch with her friend Princess Sneezewort, when her glitter-stone ring rings and she is summoned to fight monsters as the Princess in Black. But when she and her unicorn Frimplepants, who turns into Blackie her horse, arrive at the goat meadow they find cute little rabbits nibbling on the grass. Even though Duff the Goat boy warns her that they are monsters, the Princess in Black thinks that the rabbits are really little darlings. Blackie her horse is not so sure of their innocence, especially when they start eating the princess's sceptre, and has to use his power to understand what the rabbits are saying and help save the day.
This is the third in the series and is just as good as the previous ones, The princess in black, and The princess in black and the perfect princess party. The contrast of an endearing princess who looks adorable dressed in sparkly pink and her bold endeavours as a superhero dressed in black is one that is sure to appeal to young readers. The idea that she can be comfortable both in pink and black, taking on two demanding roles, is a sure-fire winner. The cute little bunnies are so well drawn that they appeal to the reader as well as to the Princess in Black, and it is a good thing that Blackie can speak the rabbits' cute language and warn the princess of danger.
I love the Princess in Black stories. I adore the humour, the whimsical illustrations and best of all, my six year old granddaughter loves them too! They are ideal for children who are just starting to become independent readers, with short chapters, names that can be remembered like Frimplepants and Princess Sneezewort, and charming characters and funny plots.
The combination of humorous prose, an engaging plot and wonderful illustrations is a winning one.
Pat Pledger

This Broken Wondrous World by Jon Skovron

cover image

Man Made Boy bk 2. Allen & Unwin, 2015. ISBN: 9781743315972
(Age: 15+) After getting attacked by a myriad of monsters, taking down a psychotic artificial intelligence unit, and basically saving New York, seventeen-year-old Boy - the son of Frankenstein's monster - is looking for some downtime. With the advice of his father, Boy goes to live in Switzerland with the human descendants of Dr Frankenstein, hoping to attend college and live a normal life - or at least as normal as you can get for the child of a literal monster.
What he doesn't expect is to be contacted by the infamous Dr Moreau - long ago banished to a secret island - and asked to fight alongside his fellow monsters to help overthrow the human race. With a violent war escalating and Moreau's forces growing stronger, Boy will have to decide which side he's on - before it's too late.
Whereas Man Made Boy drew obvious inspiration from the works of Mary Shelley with Boy's character, in This Broken Wondrous World there is a noticeable H. G. Wells influence. As well as the characters of the Invisible Man and Doctor Moreau, the story itself reads vaguely like a Wells novel, from the descriptions of fearsome monsters, to the sense that it is much more of a character study than an action novel, as one might expect. While this does make it an intriguing read since the story focuses on the son of Frankenstein's monster, it is also one of its major flaws.
The character of Boy, while an interesting protagonist, is never really well developed or flawed enough for him to be relatable on a deeper level, and since the story is told through his perspective, it makes for an occasionally slow read. This is most noticeable in the first part of the book where he is living in Switzerland and attending college, which drags slightly despite it being quite well written. It is only when Dr Moreau actually appears in the story - almost halfway through the book - that the story really picks up the pace and becomes a truly engaging read.
This Broken Wondrous World is an enjoyable, if ultimately flawed read.
Rebecca Adams (university student)

Thicker than water by Brigid Kemmerer

cover image

Allen & Unwin, 2015. ISBN 9781743318638
(Age: 14+) Recommended. Mystery. Paranormal. Thomas Bellweather's mother has been murdered and he is the prime suspect. His new stepfather, Stan, is a cop and his colleagues are very suspicious of him. The only person who is prepared to believe in his innocence is Charlotte Rooker, whose three brothers are cops. Her best friend had been murdered many years before and she wants answers to both of the murders.
Written in alternating chapters with the voice of Thomas and Charlotte, the reader gets to know both of the characters very well. Thomas is a damaged boy and gradually the author, who has a great capacity to describe male protagonists, lets us know what his life has been like. It is not difficult to become supportive of him as his voice seems so honest and his love for his mother very real. Charlotte is very protected by her three brothers, but she is strong enough to form her own opinions about Thomas and his involvement in the murder. The romance takes second place to the tension that the mystery generates, but it will satisfy those who enjoy a romantic touch in their reading. Stan, Thomas' new stepfather, is also a well-developed character and the reader can sympathise with his actions as he tries to come to terms with his changed family circumstances.
Kemmerer ramps up the suspense in this exciting thriller with a touch of the paranormal that is very surprising. There is a lot of excitement, some shocks and an ending that the reader won't expect. It is a gripping mystery and leaves the reader wanting to know more about the characters and hope for a continuation of Thomas and Charlotte's story.
Pat Pledger

Boy 23 by Jim Carrington

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2015. ISBN 9781408822777
(Age: YA) Highly recommended. Themes: Science Fiction; Survival; Adventure. This is a story with a mystery that does not get fully revealed until right at the end, involving a naive boy with no name, who lives in isolation. His existence is supported by The Voice with whom he has no physical contact. From the beginning of the book we are part of Boy23's release from captivity. Blindfolded and abandoned with only a few basic items, he needs to survive and to escape from those who are desperate to recapture him. The Voice becomes his only means of support until he meets Carina in the religious Children's home where he has found temporary refuge. His unusual physicality leads to suggestions of a miracle.
The book is told with alternating voices - with the Boy, The Voice and Carina each telling the story from their perspective, with the past revealed through dream sequences or reflections of what has gone before. This is an alternate world, with influences of World War II Nazi occupation and a post-apocalyptic disaster combining to create a place in time and history that is unique, but non-specific. The language of the community is German, but Boy23 has been taught English by The Voice. Carina is bi-lingual and her own painful past gives her a reason to support the remarkably gifted Boy in his escape from powerful opposition.
This is wonderfully exciting book, a mystery adventure that will captivate a Young adult audience. The German language spoken by characters within the book is not translated and we get a feel for the confusion of the Young boy as he seeks to understand what is happening around him. (Students of German will enjoy using their language skills to add an extra layer of meaning. It is not necessary to translate, as the story becomes self-explanatory, and we make meaning from context.) There is some violence as part of the action of the book and a sexual assault is alluded to, but no detail given. Young readers will be captivated by the excitement of the escape attempt.
Highly recommended for YA.
Carolyn Hull

Cinderella's sister and the big bad wolf by Lorraine Carey

cover image

Ill. by Migy Blanco. Nosy Crow, 2015. ISBN 9780857633132
Once upon a time (although quite recently in this version), Cinderella lived with her stepmother Mrs Ugly and her three stepsisters. But this isn't a traditional or even a flipped story about Cinderella. It's about the youngest Ugly sister, Gertie. Unlike her mother and sisters who lived up to their name, Gertie was kind and gentle and very hard-working. While Cinderella lazed around and did nothing, Gertie did all the chores of the original story.
Gertie's niceness was the cause of great shame and despair in the Ugly family and so she was hidden away not allowed to go anywhere with them. So when an invitation comes to attend the Grand Ball, there is no question of Gertie going - unless she can prove that she can be bad and mean. But to be bad and mean will take lessons so she is sent to the Wicked Queen who is on her way to deliver a poisoned apple to Snow White. Unable to help herself, just as Snow White is about to accept the apple, Gertie warns her that it is poisoned. The Wicked Queen is furious and immediately sends Gertie home to her very angry mother. Gertie's pleas for a second chance see her protecting Hansel and Gretel from the Wicked Witch and again, sent home in disgrace. It is not until she meets the Big Bad Wolf who is determined to eat Little Red Riding Hood that her chances of going to the ball improve.
This is an hilarious twist on a range of familiar fairytales with a most delicious ending. The bright, trendy illustrations bring it into the 21st century and into the world of today's young reader. They will delight in revisiting characters they've already met and seeing a whole new side of the Cinderella they know and love.
Apart from being fun to read for its own sake, this would be an ideal story to use as part of an investigation into perspective because not only is the story told from a different character's point of view, bringing it into modern times offers a range of new possibilities too. Thus it will have a broader appeal than just the very young who are fairytale fans.
Barbara Braxton

New Year surprise! by Christopher Cheng

cover image

Ill. by Di Wu. National Library of Australia, 2016. ISBN 9780642278838
(Age: 5+) Highly recommended. Chinese New Year, Responsibility, Family, Celebrations, Festivals, China, Inclusivity. This beautiful book shows the reader many customs and traditions surrounding the celebration of New Year in Northern China. In a small village the New Year is almost here. Little Brother is told he is too little to help with the adults or older children, but Grandfather tells him that he has a special job to do. He is eager to find out what this is.
Each few pages shows the village preparing for the festival, with Little Brother wanting to help, and wondering whether this is hie special job. Through him we see the variety of preparations needed to celebrate new Year in the village: Sister and Mother spend lots of time making dumplings, Father hangs the banners and red lanterns, Brother and his friends go and fly their kites, Father chooses the duck from the hawker, the relatives come for special tea, and so on until finally it is time to get the Dragon ready. Little Brother hopes he will be included but is told he is too small. Father then appears with the Pearl of Wisdom to carry before the dragon. But he has two, one is for Little Brother and the two carry their Pearls of Wisdom before the dragon to bring luck to the village for the following year. Everyone sleeps well that night.
This beautiful book not only tells the story of how New Year is celebrated within a tale of inclusivity, but the illustrations will astound and astonish as well. Di Wu once a farmer in Northern China used traditional rice paper on which to do his illustrations using brushes and traditional colours to ensure its authenticity. His achievement is breath taking. Each page draws the eyes to its colour and movement, as the small child watches what is going on, desperate to be involved. Each page shows a range of activities and readers will love looking at its variety and vivacity.
A wonderful addition to any school or home library, the book has explanations at the back which are most informative as well.
Fran Knight

Anna and the Swallow Man by Gavriel Savit

cover image

Bodley Head, 2015. ISBN: 9781782300533
(Age: 12+) Highly recommended. Anna and the Swallow Man tells of the heartbreaking search of a little girl for meaning after her father, a professor of linguistics, disappears in Poland nearing the end of 1939. The country is in turmoil and bears and wolves are everywhere, determined to maintain control of the nation while Germany's forces expand. The story centres on Anna, whose life is about to change forever. A little girl with nothing more to lose, and everything to gain.
Having been left in the care of a German shopkeeper, Anna expects her father to return at any moment. When he doesn't return, Herr Doktor Fuchsmann refuses to have her in his shop any longer. Ever the good girl, Anna respects his wishes, waiting outside of the shop. Instead of her father appearing, Anna is approached by a tall, slender man in fine clothes and a red neck tie. Curious about her, he begins asking her questions, switching from language to language, unaware that she can understand them all. United by their multi-lingual talents, Anna follows the man out of town; hence, her new life begins.
Life is hard. Days are spent walking, foraging and avoiding patrols. Like her father, the Swallow Man is incredibly knowledgeable. He teaches her about the birds in the wetlands and how to be deceptive. He shows her how to get what she wants, what she needs, from people without ever having to ask. He teaches her how to survive. He has become everything to her. A friend. A mentor. A father. But can he maintain such a relationship when even her real father could not? Like her Swallow Man, she must do all that she can to stay alive, never to give in.
Already, this novel has been said to sit together with The Book Thief and The Boy in the Stripped Pyjamas. I would highly recommend it to all readers above twelve. While being set among very real events, the story possesses qualities of magical realism and enough intrigue to keep a reader guessing.
Kayla Gaskell (age 19)