Reviews

Pugly bakes a cake by Pamela Butchart

cover image

Ill. by Gemma Correll. Nosy Crow, 2016. ISBN 9780857635990
(Age: Yr 1 - Yr 4) I guess we all know that pugs are pretty cute (and pretty fashionable) right now. If I hadn't got a toy poodle myself I probably would have got a pug - although my eccentric teaching colleague who had a wardrobe of outfits for hers and attended all the 'pug parties' in Brisbane at one time did kind of put me off a little.
Moving right along, newly independent readers are going to love this book. It's a HOOT! Last night I read this aloud straight through to The Divine Miss M who is having a sleepover and she thought it was great! She was able to predict and infer as I read which was pretty impressive as well.
Pugly and his rival Clem (Clementine) the cat are rivals for the undivided attention of their owner Maddy who is eight years old. Being a pug (no offence to pug owners), Pugly is not the sharpest knife in the drawer and Clem can very easily put it over him. Especially as Pugly's only ally is Clive the fish - and Pugly doesn't speak or understand fish-bubble. Inspired Pugly decides he is going to the first dog to ever bake a cake and thus win paws down 'The Great British Bake Off', be on TV and meet the Queen (as you do when you're famous). This plan will seal his status as Maddy's favourite pet he is sure. However, with Clem 'advising' him chaos reigns in the kitchen and elsewhere, as Pugly heeds all Clem's ideas, goes mental at the Evil Squirrel outside on the fence and more.
This is a laugh a minute book and not only proved a terrific read aloud (took about half an hour or so) but perfect for those readers beginning their individual reading journeys. Lots of capitalised words and extra large fonts give them the opportunity to incorporate tone and expression into reading as well. Get onto this one - it will be a great favourite with Year 1 to around Year 4 for sure!
Sue Warren

Something wonderful by Raewyn Caisley

cover image

Ill. by Karen Blair. Viking, 2016. ISBN 9780670078455
Sam lives in the country - way out in the country where the air is fresh and clean and he and his dog have room to run and chase feathers, climb trees, spin around on the Hills Hoist and build things from all sorts of old stuff lying around. Pulling things apart and putting them back together is what he loves best - so much so that he sometimes forgets his chores like feeding the chooks, collecting the eggs and making sure the goat is in its paddock. This frustrates his dad who thinks he should be more focused, but his mum understands and knows that his distractedness means a brain is very busy at work. For all that he seems to be playing, Sam is learning, learning, learning.
One day while chasing a shadow across the paddocks it starts to rain and after momentarily stopping to think whether a raindrop is round, Sam makes a dash for shelter in the shed. And in the shed are all the bits and pieces that Sam needs to make something wonderful. Raewyn Caisley and Karen Blair have once again combined to create something wonderful, their first since the delightful Hello from Nowhere. The book is dedicated to the real-life Sam who now 'works at a famous university in Europe, where he is trying to work out what is in-between the smallest things' and demonstrates that his mum was right - all that pulling apart and putting together, the curiosity, the wondering of it all was just the lead up to what he is doing now.
So even though not all tinkerers will end up at 'a famous university' those makerspaces we offer in city libraries could just be the breeding ground for a new Sam as they play and plan and dream. Just as Sam learns about pulling and pushing and pulleys (in the most hilarious way ever) so too could one of our students albeit it in a more artificial situation.
Karen Blair's illustrations are superb - you can feel the wind in your face and breathe the fresh country air, sense dad's frustration and Sam's sense of wonder - they are as wonderful as that which Sam creates. The final textless page and endpapers are divine!
Threaded throughout the joy in this story (which shines through like a mother's love) is a powerful message about the importance of play and discovery. THIS is what childhood is about - not academic competition and grades and being ICT savvy. Academic things should just be the means to an end - the vehicle on which children can make their own discoveries as they explore and explain and not only make sense of their world but make it better.
A very serious contender for my favourite book for a while.
Barbara Braxton

One thousand hills by James Roy and Noel Zihabamwe

cover image

Omnibus Books, 2016. ISBN 9781742990750
(Age: 15- Adult) Themes: Genocide; Historical events - Rwanda; Innocence; Discrimination; Children in a time of conflict; Refugees; Family. Knowing the ultimate outcome of the Rwandan Genocide in 1994 creates an underlying tension throughout the reading of this book. This narrative is essentially a counselling session - but it is also a horrible and slowly unfolding catastrophe. The young man, Pascal, retells his experience to a school counsellor in explanation for an incident that he was involved in at school. Slowly and painfully he reveals the events of his life at the time of the genocide and his survival after the incredible unspeakable tragedy. Should it remain unspoken? Or does speaking it out loud release the tension or bring it to mind again? For the reader, it is important to know how tragic this experience was for the people involved, and the innocent voice of the young Pascal, as his 10 year old self, creates added anguish. The boy comes from a mixed tribe family (both Hutu and Tutsi) and small snippets of the civil unrest filter to him through scattered threads of conversation until the events of the massacre impact violently into his normally gentle and religious family. The author slowly takes us on the journey from the tender and normal family life of the Rwandan family, with its normal sibling rivalries and chores, to the final explosive scenes of betrayal and genocide. In a manner similar to The Boy in Striped Pyjamas by John Boyne, the innocent voice of the central character magnifies the horror of the atrocities inflicted.
This is an extremely moving, but atrocious story. And it is an account of the reality of experience for co-author Noel Zihabamwe. This is a compelling narrative, but I would be loath to put this into the hands of a reader too young to understand this part of history or one who is vulnerable to violence or is traumatised by news accounts of bloody conflict. The added horror of the involvement of some from the church in assisting in the tragedy will also be difficult for some readers. How humans can be so cruel to one another and lose sight of their common humanity is a huge unspoken question from the young Pascal. Even though this is written in a simple and 'youthful' style it is suited for mature readers aged 15+ and adult readers.
Carolyn Hull

The Trap by Melanie Raabe

cover image

Trans. by Imogen Taylor. Text, 2016. ISBN 9781925240870
(Age: Secondary+) Melanie Raabe is a young German writer of screenplays, scripts and blogs. This, her first novel, is a thriller for which the film rights have already been secured. The main character, Linda, is a successful author who has lived in seclusion since the murder of her sister Anna. Linda found her sister's body and details of the scene are unforgettable, the sight of her sister's bleeding body, the sound of the Beatle's song 'Love me do' repeating incessantly on the CD player and most significantly, the glimpse she has of the killer fleeing from the room. The police at the time were sceptical at best and disbelieving at worse about her evidence. Unable to face the world she writes and remembers and is alienated from even her parents, until she sees again the face of the murderer on television. He is a well-respected journalist and Linda recoils from approaching the police. She feels they would be unlikely to believe her, and an interrogation would alert him to suspicion. She decides to find proof herself.
She writes a book, a thriller, in which the victim and the murder parallel her sister's murder. She undergoes desensitisation training to help her face her fears. She consults an expert on interrogation techniques. She wires her house with cameras and recording systems. She invites the news outlet that employs her suspect, Lenzen, to send him to interview her. She chooses a day when her staff are not at work and has a caterer provide food. The interview begins; Lenzen is an attractive and clever man, who she senses is aware of her suspicions. She gains the upper hand, she thinks, after a number of mind games and tries to force a confession by pointing a gun at him. However, she thinks she can hear the Beatles song 'Love me do' repeating and becomes confused. Is she going mad? Lenzen protests his innocence and takes the gun. He persuades her that she was the killer herself, and that was what the police had always suspected. Linda remembers childhood antagonisms and interprets her parents' cool behaviour as being based on suspicion. She has always been a story teller; has she invented her sighting of the murderer to provide herself with a cover? Lenzen seems to be off the hook until Linda has a chance meeting which causes her to again reassess, and to take further risky action which leads to a resolution and a life-affirming renewal.
The novel is tightly and simply written with believable characters, though slightly drawn, and a suspenseful and unpredictable plot. Though a thriller the story concerns the psychological reactions to events rather than the violence of events and so has more depth than many crime novels. It is suitable for secondary readers.
Jenny Hamilton

Wicked's Way by Anna Fienberg

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2016. ISBN: 9781743319901
(Age: 9-12) Highly recommended. Themes: Pirates; Love; Choices; Magic; Adventure; Transformation; Good and Evil. A young boy, Will, raised in a loving island home with his mother, learns tightrope walking and believes that one day he will be a circus star. Unfortunately his mother disappears, and although briefly he discovers that life goes on with new opportunities and a new friend despite his loss, eventually disaster strikes and he is stolen by pirates. The gentle Will is broken by the harshness of the tyrannical pirate captain, and renamed Wicked. The life on board a pirate ship is not pleasant, and the relationships that are formed are difficult. Wicked slowly becomes a shadow of his former self, and his desire to rediscover his mother and his friend slowly become a distant hope. A mutiny and some poor choices eventually lead Wicked to a solitary island existence with a talking parrot who shares pithy sayings and adages, and then there is an unfortunate re-encounter with someone who could not be trusted. This ultimately leads Wicked to rediscover himself and to be reshaped back into the trusting and open-hearted person from his past.
This is a story of restoration (and redemption) and the transformation from gentle Will to Wicked and back again is an interesting journey told within the medium of a Pirate adventure with a small dose of magical influence. With the reappearance of Horrendo from Fienberg's Horrendo's Curse there is also a rediscovery of the power of the friendly and amiable Horrendo.
Highly Recommended. This tale would make a great read-aloud story within a school context for ages 9-12. There is much to discuss about Will's emotional journey and Horrendo's influence. The metaphor of the tightrope journey - just place one foot in front of the other, and stay focused on the prize; plus the wisdom of a parrot could lead to many discussions.
Carolyn Hull

Rockhopping by Trace Balla

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2016. ISBN 9781760112349
(Age: 8+) Recommended. Themes: Bushwalking; Natural environment; Exploration. This is the companion text to the book Rivertime and in this book Clancy and Uncle Egg explore the Grampians and look for the source of the River. They pack for a walking trek through the Grampians region, trekking up craggy rocks and through the delight of the natural environment. The long arduous walk carrying heavy packs and a dangerous cliff top near-accident does not dampen their enthusiasm for the way the natural environment reveals itself to those who have time to look. Balla's Cartoon style, graphic novel includes a wealth of small captioned details that give the reader an insight into the variety of life within the environment and some of the historical perspectives of the region, including its Aboriginal history and view of the world. Clancy demonstrates incredible resilience as he overcomes difficulty, but he also discerns the joy of discovery as the world unfolds before him.
Balla's beautiful and simple illustrations are enchanting. The narrative is also delightful, telling of the journey, but also revealing the wonderful relationship between Clancy and his uncle and the simple pleasures of being outdoors.
Carolyn Hull

Six of Crows by Leigh Bardugo

cover image

Six of Crows bk 1. Henry Holt, 2015. ISBN 9781627792127
(Age: 14+) Highly recommended. Fantasy. Heists. Goodreads Choice Award Nominee for Young Adult Fantasy and Science Fiction (2015), YALSA's Best Books for Young Adults (2016). Kaz Brekker has been offered the chance to pull off the heist of a life time and he gathers around him five dangerous specialists, most from the Dregs, thieves of Kerch's underworld. There is Inej the Wraith, who can silently scale walls, Nina the girl who has betrayed her friend Matthias and is desperate to get him out of gaol, Jesper the gambler who cannot resist wagers and the rich runaway Wylan who hates his father. Led by Kaz, a superb thief and strategist, they are aiming to invade the Ice Palace in a seemingly impossible quest.
For those who enjoyed the Grisha series, Six of crows is the first book in another series set this time in Ketterdam, which is in a fantasy land similar to the Netherlands. Bardugo's world building is immaculate - her vivid descriptions make it easy to smell and see the slums, the canals the docks and the cold lands that the six traverse.
Then there is her outstanding character building. Each of the six main characters, who tell their own stories in separate chapters, have distinct voices and often heart-rending tales about their backgrounds that gradually emerge as the story unfolds. They are all compelling people with separate skills and together they must begin to trust each other and form an effective team to get the job done. There are subtle hints of romance, but this is not what stands out, rather the complexity of the personalities and their pasts is what holds the reader's interest.
Fans of Leigh Bardugo will really enjoy this, but readers new to this author and indeed, the fantasy genre, will find a fascinating world, irresistible action and feisty characters to entertain them.
Pat Pledger

Secret Tree Fort by Brianne Farley

cover image

Walker Books, 2016. ISBN 9781406367232
(Age: 5+) Recommended for a library collection. Themes: Sisters; Imagination; Reconciliation. Two sisters need to go outside. One, a book-loving reader, settles under a tree with her book. The other wants her sister to play with her. The ignored sister creates an imaginary Secret Fort to entice her sister to join her and play. The developing imagined detail is peculiar and grows with features as her imagination explores the ways to connect with her sister. However an argument bubbles to the surface. Eventually there is a compromise to explore Fort-building together and this draws the two sisters into a closer connection. This reconciliation after conflict makes this a useful book to discuss differences and solving problems. The illustrations are simple in style, but there is sufficient detail to engage a younger reader.
Although the book incorporates colourful detail, the tonal quality is somewhat muted.
Carolyn Hull

The Storyteller's Muse by Traci Harding

cover image

Harper Collins, 2016. ISBN 9780732299415
(Age: Senior secondary) Ageing author Penelope Whitman needs to write a story which she has been incubating for a long time but is frustrated by her failing faculties. Peter, a nurse in the aged-care home where she lives is a frustrated author and she asks him to help her write the story she dictates. The thread then alternates between the story and the writing process until the author dies leaving the narrative unfinished. A third story is introduced, Peter's own creation, based on historical research thrown up by Penelope's unfinished novel. Interspersed are strange supernatural incidents identified as the 'muse' or spirit that can be dangerous as well as creative. The chapter headings list the components of the writing process and there is some insight into what it takes to develop as a successfully published author although the luck and support budding writer Peter receives is a bit beyond belief.
Traci Harding is known for her stories in the fantasy genre and this convoluted tale may be of interest to her readers to understand how she writes. There is a sex scene which may preclude the book from some school libraries but senior students with writing aspirations may like it as will Traci Harding fans. It could be read with Rainbow Rowell's Fangirl, also a story about a writer.
Sue Speck

At the edge of the orchard by Tracy Chevalier

cover image

HarperCollins, 2016. ISBN 9780008135294
(Age: 15+) Highly recommended. Pioneer life in the US. Farmers. Apple growing. Family life. It is 1838. Deep in the Black Swamp of Ohio, James and Sadie Goodenough try to scrabble out a living, cutting down trees and attempting to grow the 50 apple trees that they need to claim their holding. James loves the apples, especially the sweet apple brought from his home in Connecticut, but Sadie is addicted to the applejack they make. Robert one of their sons, loves the apples too and watches out for his overworked sister, Martha. When disaster strikes, Robert leaves the farm and roams across the country, working on ranches and trying his hand at gold mining in California. When he meets William Lobb, a naturalist who collects seeds, he begins to work for him, but when his past catches up with him, he has to decide whether he will continue on his solitary way or make a home.
This a stunning book, meticulously researched, and the background of apple growing and the appearance of the folk hero Johnny Appleseed is fascinating. Pioneer life is described in all its brutality, the loneliness, isolation, back breaking work, infant mortality and alcohol addiction running counter with the family dramas as James and Sadie battle it out about whether the apple trees should be 'eaters' or 'spitters' to make applejack. The hardships that the family face are overwhelming and it is easy to imagine Sadie giving into the enticement of applejack.
Chevalier uses the different voices of her characters to tell the story. The reader learns about James' affection for the apples, his jealousy of Johnny Appleseed and his trust in two of his children, Robert and Martha. Sadie's narrative is less educated and more strident, and it is easy to see the lonely, difficult woman in her words. When Robert strikes out alone, it is his yearly letters to his family that bring alive his character and his narratives are so striking giving the reader information about the settlement of the US, the gold rushes and the fever that overtook the miners, and the hardship that women faced. The descriptions of the redwood and giant sequoia groves, the efforts of William Lobb to collect saplings and seeds to send back to England and the growing effect of tourism are rivetting. Martha's letters are heart rending and really make a huge impact about the reality of frontier life for young girls and women.
Notes are at the back of the book about the research Chevalier carried out and add to the reader's knowledge of some of the real life characters, Johnny Appleseed, William Lobb and others.
This book was a joy to read - the prose was vivid, the history fascinating and the family dynamics engrossing.
Pat Pledger

Nannie loves by Kylie Dunstan

cover image

Working Title Press, 2016. ISBN 9781921504839
(Ages: 2-6) Family. Grandparents. Farm life. The story starts with an illustration of a child posting a letter addressed to her Nan, while the text reads 'Nannie lives on a farm'. From there, the illustrations show us the child's family visiting the farm and exploring it with Nannie, while the text on each page tells us something about Nannie and her farm. In this way, the text and the illustrations each add something different to the story and provide plenty of material for discussion with children. Each page ends with 'Nannie loves her dog/garden/family/me'. The text is simple, but children will love it because they get to join in with the repeated 'Nannie loves...' on each page.
The collage and pencil illustrations, in earthy, natural colours are simply wonderful. They are bright and joyful and perfectly show the wonder and excitement the children have for the farm. Nannie's enthusiasm and love for the farm also shines through as she shows them around and does her jobs.
This is a great story for sharing and enjoying. It will also be fantastic for demonstrating mixed media illustrations and as inspiration for classroom art. The chooks on the endpapers are particularly fabulous, as are all the illustrations within.
Nicole Nelson

Milo: A moving story by Tohby Riddle

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2016. ISBN 9781760111632
(Age: 6+) Recommended. Friendship. Forgiveness. Tohby Riddle has created a visually interesting tale of friendship with quirky twists. The central character, Milo, is a dog with a couple of friends (with odd names!) A simple falling-out of friendship and an unusual storm event puts Milo into a position of danger. He eventually is able to return to offer an apology.
The illustrations within Riddle's book are muted in tone, but full of detail so are worth inspecting more closely. Young children may not instantly warm to the style, but an adult could spend some time pointing out the eccentric detail. I think this book could create discussion. The New York setting and references plus illustrations of other famous locales may lead to an exploration beyond the plot for older readers (or the adults who read it to the younger generation).
Carolyn Hull

Maralinga's long shadow, Yvonne's story by Christobel Mattingley

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2016. ISBN 9781760290177
(Age: 11 - Adult) Highly recommended. Aboriginal peoples. Nuclear weapons. Biography. Non-fiction. Maralinga's long shadow continues the themes explored by Christobel Mattingley in collaboration with the Anangu people in Maralinga, the Anangu story (2009) and Survival in our own land (1988).
This latest book is Yvonne Edward's story, a story that reflects the experience of too many Aboriginal people, turned off their traditional land and their children taken away. Yvonne's recollections expose the further horror of the Maralinga nuclear bomb tests carried out by the British government from 1953 to 1957. As Yvonne says so powerfully it was her grandparents' home that was bombed. 'That was their home where the bomb went off', sending up a radioactive cloud and contaminating the land. Subsequent generations of Yvonne's family suffered the consequences. Her husband was one of the Aboriginal men sent in to clean up the site without the protective clothing worn by the white men. Her family and others travelled through the area unaware of the dangers to their health. Devastatingly, her husband and two sons died of cancer and her grandson was born with a stomach defect. Yvonne herself died before she could finally work on the story she wanted people to know about. But Mattingley had collected enough notes from their long conversations to be able to bring the book to fruition. It is an important story to tell.
Learning about this terrible history through the lived experience of Yvonne's family makes it so much more potent, and very sad. Mattingley uses simple though often poetic language to tell the story, often using the words of Yvonne herself. Coloured photographs of the people and country make it very real and personal. This story, and Yvonne's beautiful paintings reproduced in the book, creates a wonderful legacy of a strong and courageous woman, proud in her culture, and determined to be heard.
Helen Eddy

Pig the winner by Aaron Blabey

cover image

Scholastic, 2016. ISBN 9781760154288
(Age: 4+) Highly recommended. Cheating, Winning, Good sportsmanship. Pig the pug loves to win. But he will do anything to come first, as Trevor finds out. If he doesn't win by putting his foot out to trip Trevor in a race, then he throws a tantrum so fierce that Trevor gives in telling him he has won. The long suffering Trevor can only look on as Pig goes to great lengths to overcome his partner, but one fateful day, Pig suggests that they see who can eat their food the fastest. Trevor decides that this is not for him and declines the invitation to compete, but this does not faze Pig. He wolfs down all the food he can find, his treats, his biscuits, his bowl of dog food, but incredibly in his haste, he finds that he has eaten his bowl.
Good old Trevor knows just what to do, grabbing the dog form behind and giving him a squeeze to force the bowl out. In doing so the bowl ricochets off the ceiling and pushes Pig into the rubbish bin. A much embarrassed Pig then becomes a much nicer dog to be with and plays with Trevor much more fairly, well, most of the time.
This delightful picture book, told in rhyming stanzas will be a hit with younger children who will predict what words will come next when it is read to them, enjoy sharing stanzas with their friends when reading together or discuss the implications of cheating when talking about sports. With so much press devoted to the scandals involving today's sportsmen and women, this is a timely book to introduce the theme with younger children at a level they can understand and laugh about. Blabey's illustrations are always delightful, and this book furthers the adventures of Pig the pug, and Pig the fibber, all subtly teaching some home truths to the readers.
Fran Knight

Big Nate blasts off by Lincoln Peirce

cover image

Harper Collins, 2016. ISBN 9780008135331
(Age: 8-13) Recommended. Themes: Bullying; Cartooning; Friendship; Growing up; School drama; Humour. This is a book that Diary of a Wimpy Kid devotees will also love. Big Nate is an ordinary kid who deals with a dad who makes dreadful lunches, a fellow classmate that intends harm, a connection with a girl that is hinting at romance and the normal ups and downs of school life with his friends. He shares his life with style - cartooning style! He has a quirky view of the world that he translates into wonderfully entertaining caricatures and cartoon strips. The big event of the book is an Ultimate Frisbee tournament against a rival school that needs to overcome the romance dilemmas, the bullying and detentions in order to overturn a 37 year losing streak!
This is not the first book with Big Nate, so look for other titles in the series, and it can be recommended for a school library collection (even though teachers are the target of many of Nate's jokes!) The book will not stay long on the shelves in the Library. Recommended as a fun book for reluctant readers aged 8-13; but all younger readers will enjoy the humour and the cartoons.
Carolyn Hull