Reviews

Operation Merry Christmas by Meredith Costain

cover image

Ill. by Danielle McDonald. Ella Diaries. Scholastic, 2016. ISBN 9781760159580
(Age: 6+) Recommended. Themes: Christmas; Humour; Friendship. This Christmas tale from the Ella Diaries series is quirky, cute and contains creative moments!! Including creative spelling! Ella gets bad news that means that Christmas this year will not be the same - and Ella's Mum will be the sadderest. So Ella, with her friend Zoe, make plans that will bring joy but there is always mischief and mayhem when they make plans. But will there be snow? In addition the girls have to contend with end of year parties, Kris Kringle and missing out on an invite to Peach Parker's Christmas Party! Ella has wonderful intentions, but sometimes she does not always think through the consequences, even if she has the most ingenious ideas. But all works out well in the end!
Written in diary format, in Ella's voice (and with her creative spelling and thinking) and with McDonald's naive cartoon style illustrations on display, this will be loved by young female devotees of the Ella Diaries series.
Carolyn Hull

Christmas in the barn by Margaret Wise Brown

cover image

Ill. by Anna Dewdney. HarperCollins, 2016. ISBN 9780062379863
First published in 1952, but reprinted with new full-colour illustrations, Christmas in the Barn is a retelling of the Nativity from the perspective of the barn animals. As dusk comes and night settles, and the animals take up their usual places and positions two people come into the barn and before long, without fuss or fear, Mary gives birth. The star shines, the shepherds and the Wise Men arrive and the baby is laid in a manger, no crib for a bed.
Told in rhyme this is a charming retelling of the traditional story that underpins the celebration of Christmas that is quite secular in its interpretation, making it perfect for sharing and explaining what is behind the images and imagery that is common at this time.
While some schools and communities have bowed to political correctness and taken the story of the Nativity out of the curriculum, I believe that given the widespread celebration of Christmas in Australia, all children should know its origins so they can understand the importance placed on it, just as they should know the stories and understandings behind the commemorations and celebrations of other religions. Because this version makes no reference to God - indeed neither the people nor the baby are even named because the emphasis is on the warmth, safety and harmony of everyone and everything in the barn - it is perfect for introducing very young children or those unfamiliar with Christmas to the basis of the beliefs of those who celebrate.
Barbara Braxton

Emily's Bush Christmas by Jackie French

cover image

Ill. by Bruce Whatley. HarperCollins, 2015. ISBN 9780732286934
It's Christmas Day in Shaggy Gully and all the animals are doing the things they do best - the kangaroos are bouncing, the echidnas are prickly, the emus are peckish, koalas are relaxing and the bats and wombats are just hanging about. The Shaggy Gully chorus are sharing their Christmas carols - the cockatoos and kookaburras are giving it their all while Emily tries to keep in tune with her tuba. Suddenly the ambiance is shattered by a ghastly groan coming up from the creek.
"ooooogggggghhhhhh! I'm mad and I'm mean!
I'm the BUNYIP ooooogggggghhhhhh!."
In response, Emily Emu's tuba echoes the same ghastly sound! The bunyip's moan makes her tuba groan. But Emily decides that everyone, including bunyips, should be happy at Christmas and so she sets about trying to change the bunyip's mood. But no matter what she and her friends do, the bunyip stays mad and mean! Until he discovers Emily's tuba . . .
You just know that a Christmas story from Jackie French and Bruce Whatley is going to be Australian and it's going to be good. And so it is with this tale which is uniquely Australian and which will bring a smile to the face of little ones (and bunyips.) They will love to see what their favourite creatures get up to in the bush on this special day - even Ringo the Dingo is there - as Jackie always weaves a wonderful story that is worth reading over and over, especially if you play them this sound clip  so they can hear the sound of the tuba and why it is so perfect for a bunyip! This team always produces the best - and this is no exception.
Barbara Braxton

Penguin's Christmas wish by Salina Yoon

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2016. ISBN 9781408882566
Pumpkin really wanted a Christmas tree this Christmas but there are no trees on the ice where penguins live. But Penguin had an idea and after loading up the sled and going on a long journey with little brother Pumpkin, his friend Bootsy and Grandpa, they found themselves in the middle of a forest where Pinecone had grown into a magnificent tree. The penguins decorated Pinecone with all the trimmings they had brought on the sled and it was so beautiful that Penguin wanted to share it with everyone.
That night a storm blew up and a blizzard shrouded the tree and the landscape. In the morning there was nothing to be seen. Penguin is very sad but Grandpa tells him Christmas is about love not presents and decorations. So Penguin goes off into the snow and shares what he has learned. And when the snow begins to melt, he finds that wishes do come true.
The sixth in this series about Penguin, this is a charming story for young readers about family and friendship and sharing and finding magic in unexpected places. The simple shapes, bold colours, and thick, black outlines that are distinctive of Yoon's illustrations will appeal to young readers in their simplicity, and while the penguins all look the same she has given each a distinctive feature so littlies can distinguish them and know who's who. And Penguin's ingenious Christmas presents will help them understand that gifts don't have to come in rich wrapping and cost a lot of money. Perhaps they will use their imaginations and give those they love some really personal, unique gifts too.
Barbara Braxton

Five little elves by Dan Yaccarino

cover image

HarperFestival, 2016. ISBN 9780062253385
Five little elves sitting on a sled,
The first one said, "Where's the man in red?"

With the concept of Elf on a Shelf gaining such ground in the homes of those with little people - the perfect spy for Santa - this timely release of this traditional rhyme in board book format is a perfect addition to the Christmas stocking of the very young. With its rhyme and rhythm and bold, bright illustrations it is definitely one for sharing over and over, helping even the tiniest ones start to learn the nuances of our language and the joy of story. At the same time, being a board book, it is sturdy enough to be placed in those tiny hands and survive the explorations that they and teeth will make.
Board books are an ideal way to introduce children to the love of reading as having heard the story in a safe, loving relationship, their format allows them to be handled and sucked and chewed as the little one begins to exercise their own power over the story. Even though they might not yet be able to read the words for themselves, may even be too young to join familiar rhymes and stories, being able to handle and manipulate the book itself is a huge step in that early reading journey.
Barbara Braxton

Jack and Mia by Robert Vescio

cover image

Ill. by Claire Richards. Wombat Books, 2016. ISBN 9781925139730
Before Mia moved in next door, Jack was lonely. But Mia brought rainbows, jungles, concerts and lots and lots of giggles. Even their mums thought they were 'two sides of the one coin' and 'fit together like a puzzle.' Mia's amazing imagination took them on adventures that Jack had never dreamed of and when they both got sick at the same time, they were each given a book about making and doing, make-believe and play that allowed them to continue the fun from their beds.
When they were better they kept using their books, snipping, gluing, taping and tying a magnificent cardboard castle. They each wore crowns and royal robes and ruled over their kingdom with wisdom and kindness. They were as close as the materials that held that castle together. Until one day Mia moves far away with her family and Jack is back into the isolation and desolation that he felt before Mia entered his life. Nothing was the same any more.
Across the sea, Mia had also given up. She was missing Jack just as much. But then Jack found Mia's book in his toybox and...
There is nothing like the deep friendships forged in childhood where there are no distractions beyond deciding what today's fun will be about. Jack and Mia is a charming story that focuses on such a friendship and how it can continue even after separation has intervened. It will resonate with children who have moved away from familiar surroundings and friends and show them that there are plenty of ways of keeping in touch to relive old memories and make new ones. The technology of today gives them so much more than that of previous generations and the world can come to you with just a few clicks.
The illustrations enrich the storyline as Jack and Mia do not share the same skin colour but neither notice - it's all about who each child is, how they connect and the fun that can be had when kids get together, just as it is in any playground. In fact, I'd proffer that the readers will not even notice the difference. Racism and all that it entails is very definitely a concept learned from adults.
Heartwarming and positive.
Barbara Braxton

Cobweb Christmas: the tradition of tinsel by Shirley Climo

cover image

Ill. by Jane Manning. Harper Collins, 2001. ISBN 9780060290337
Tante is so little she has to stand on a stool to climb into bed and so old she can't count all the Christmases she has seen. She lived at the edge of a pine forest in Germany in a tiny cottage with her canary, her cat and her dog. Beside the cottage was a barn with a donkey, a goat, a rooster and a hen - so she had all she needed.
Usually Tante wasn't too fussed about having a spic and span house but at Christmas time when the days were short and the nights long, she cleaned her house from top to bottom and corner to corner sweeping even the tiniest cobwebs and their inhabitants from the rafters. She would chop down the best Christmas tree she could find and decorated it with sugar cookies and gingerbread and put special presents under it for her animals. She invited the village children in to see her tree and share its goodies - there was something for everyone including her animals, except the spiders who had all been swept out the door.
But still Tante wasn't really happy - all her life she had heard about the marvellous things that happened on Christmas Eve like animals talking or bees humming carols. So she sat down to wait for the Christmas magic but soon fell asleep so she never knew whether it happened or not. She certainly did not hear tiny little voices begging to be let in out of the cold - but Kriss Kringle did so he opened the door a crack and in went all the spiders who had been swept outside.
And the next morning Tante woke to find that Christmas magic had really happened...
Based on an old European folktale, Shirley Climo and Jane Manning have brought this story to the 21st century in a superb retelling with charming illustrations. Tinsel - originally shiny strands of brass or copper - has been part of traditional Christmas decorations since the end of the 19th century as people tried to bring light and sparkle into their homes at a dark time of the year in the northern hemisphere. Anyone who has seen a cobweb dipped in dew in the early morning and gleaming as the sun catches it can easily make the connection between the spiders' work and the sparkly loops of foil we use today.
This is a story worth tracking down to add to your Christmas collection - well-written and adding just a bit more to the story of this special time, it will be one to read every Christmas Countdown.
Barbara Braxton

Christmas songbook by Sam Taplin

cover image

Ill. by Richard Johnson. Usborne, 2016. ISBN 9781474921244
In certain countries and to certain generations, the images of carol singers going door to door at this time of the year sharing their music is not far from the mind. More recently, the school-based Carols by Candlelight was always a sign that the festive season was here as neighbourhoods joined together to herald this fun time in song, sentiment and a sausage sizzle. Classes practised those traditional songs in preparation for the annual Christmas concert and there were few who did not know all the verses of 'Away in a manger' and 'Silent night'.
So to find a new illustrated volume of these well-known tunes arranged for voice, piano and guitar is a delight as yet a new Christmas season is here and another generation needs to know the music that binds this time. Some are very familiar, others not so, but each is presented on a clear double page spread with all the verses and music as well as an illustration that makes this more than just a book of sheet music. Even the extra original verses of 'Jingle bells' - nothing to do with Batman or even a rusty Holden ute - are there right alongside 'I saw three ships', the first song my sea-loving grandfather ever taught me!
Vision Australia's Carols by Candlelight at the Sidney Myer Music Bowl remains one of the most watched television broadcasts on Christmas Eve - how wonderful if our children could fully participate because the tunes are familiar and the words are known!
A perfect addition to both your private and professional collection.
Barbara Braxton

All I want for Christmas is you by Mariah Carey

cover image

Ill. by Colleen Madden. Doubleday, 2015. ISBN 9780399551390
It is more than 20 years since Mariah Carey wrote and released the song in 1994 but it wasn't until December 2015 that the song peaked at 11 on the Billboard Hot 100, making it its highest peak since its original release. Now it is one of the most iconic tunes of the season.
So it seems fitting that it become a picture book with bright bold pictures, all the lyrics and a special twist at the end that makes it particularly suitable for young readers although the clues are there in the pictures from the beginning. The little girl's wish is clear for the astute to find because she manages to drop her hint into every part of the Christmas preparations. Making cookies and decorations, hanging stockings, even out playing in the snow she clings to her dream. Then, amidst all the presents for all the family, there is one special gift... one that so many little ones wish for!!!
This video is an interpretation that will make this a favourite in your family too - and you will have an earworm for the rest of the day!
Barbara Braxton

The cat who ate Christmas by Lil Chase and Thomas Docherty

cover image

Little Brown Books, 2016. ISBN 9781510200821
(Age: 5+) Recommended. Christmas, Chapter book, Family, humour. Written for younger readers new to chapter books, the story of Jingles, the cat and his escapades at Christmas time is highly entertaining, with every page having a wonderfully Christmassy illustration to pore over.
On Christmas Eve, Rose attempts to tie a piece of tinsel to Jingle's tail. This results in the tipping over of the Christmas Tree and from then on, things happen in the most unexpected ways.
The family wakes the next morning to find that the cat has pulled apart all the gifts left by Santa, and taken down all the decorations. But when Mum takes the turkey out of the oven and leaves it on top of the stove, while they collect Grandma, they arrive home to find the turkey almost eaten.
It's no wonder the cat cannot be found, but the next day at the supermarket Jingles is found again, all is forgiven and Christmas is what it should be, full of fun and family being together.
This lovely story subtly detailing the customs of Christmas, is wonderfully illustrated, bringing a close family feel to every page. Each page has between a few lines and a paragraph of two and with the illustrations makes this a fabulous read for newly competent readers who can tackle chapter books. The last few pages contain some truly awful Christmas jokes which will cause huge laughter amongst the target audience, a recipe and an angel to make.
Fran Knight

Beck by Mal Peet with Meg Rosoff

cover image

Walker Books, 2016. ISBN 9781406331127
(Age: Adults - senior secondary). Highly recommended. Warning: Violent sex scene. Reading this novel is like being plunged deep into a maelstrom. The writers take us back in time to the devastatingly poor world of the early 1900s. Here a woman and a man come together briefly, she using her body simply to make enough money to feed her child and herself, he a lonely sailor in a foreign port. This is unflinchingly told - as we learn that she is not a prostitute, but her body was the only means left to enable her survival.
This is a bald tale, as the writers establish from the start. After his mothers death and his horrifyingly harsh early years, Beck is put on a boat that will take him to Canada, for what reason he is utterly unaware. The Catholic brothers, who take in the orphans, are apparently generous and kind, feeding and clothing the boys in readiness for their going out into the world to find work. At this point it seems to be a world of some degree of decency. However, the one scene, so vividly described it feels like one is watching it on stage, and indeed plays back in the mind like one - reverberated in the days following my reading. The child Beck, with little knowledge of anything in the world, is treated so horrifyingly that it stayed vivid, coloured by deep emotions, disgust and anger.
The scene is left as a dread noose that colours Becks life. Yet, bravely told, this tale, of the potential for immense human cruelty and indeed of disdain for others, is a new genre of a literary story that leaps away from the heart-warming story genre into the reality genre. The writers lift the story up from this point, and draw vividly, the dark world of early European settlement in the wilds of Canada, where the struggle to survive is hard enough, while to do more, to thrive, seems an impossibility, especially for a young black boy who is utterly alone in the world.
This novel is a tale of a harsh world, offering almost no hope for the protagonist, but somehow the writers manage to keep us entranced, desperate as we might be to find a glow of goodness that is not fake, and indeed keep us reading with hope through to the end. Our hero's life begins, towards the end, to be turn, and indeed the end is a balm for the bruised spirit.
I could not recommend it for young readers. It is far too brutal, too shocking in its revelations of our human capacity for evil, for young readers. It took me days to stop replaying some of the scenes, and I ached for days afterwards in thinking about the characters and the world of this text, its absolutely grueling severity and the harsh struggle to survive. As I write I notice that Canada and the northern US states are plunged into another polar vortex, with temperatures of up to minus 20C. I have been in that part of the world in minus 45C - in the modern world this is bearable, but back in the days of this novel, it would have been almost impossible to survive. It is a book one lives through and it is worthwhile, perhaps transformative, in the end.
Liz Bondar

Signal loss by Garry Disher

cover image

Inspector Challis bk 7. Text Publishing, 2016. ISBN 9781925355260
(Age: 15+) Recommended. The seventh book in the Inspector Challis series, set on the Mornington Peninsula in Victoria, sees Hal investigating not only the spread of the drug ice, but the reason that two hit men from Sydney are found in a burnt-out Mercedes after a bushfire. Meanwhile Ellen Destry, head of the sex crimes unit, is investigating a serial rapist who breaks into the homes of young women.
It is not necessary to have read all the previous books in the series to enjoy Signal Loss - although of course, a reader would have a fuller picture of the background and personalities of the main character if the books had been read. Disher is a master of the written word and he fleshes out his detectives very well even for a newcomer to the series.
The reader will find plenty of complexity and interest as each of the detectives investigates the difficult situations that confront them. Detective Constable Pam Murphy has to confront her beliefs as she gets to know one of the suspects in the drug case. The dangers of the ice trade and how it is conducted are frightening and the reader becomes aware of the problems surrounding sex crimes.
Excellent descriptions of the people, the landscape and emotions provide a great background to the tightly written plot, and the reader is left wanting to read more novels about Hal and Ellen and the police force on the Mornington Peninsula.
A must read for people who like crime novels.
Pat Pledger

Sachiko: A Nagasaki bomb survivor's story by Caren Stelson

cover image

Carolrhoda Books, 2016. ISBN 9781467789035
(Aged 12+) Highly recommended. Themes: War; Conflict; Resilience; Peace; Nagasaki. If war was only about winning and losing, we would not know this story. Sachiko's story is the story of loss, of finding a voice in the face of incredible difficulty, of survival despite the overwhelming weight of the impossible cloud of despair and it is a story of resilience. Sachiko is one of the few who survived the Nuclear holocaust that resulted when the nuclear bomb was dropped on Nagasaki. Why she survived is a mystery considering how close she was to its epicentre, but the opportunity we have is to hear her words and wisdom, and to grow in our understanding of the personal cost at the individual level when war is waged against nations. Sachiko's tale is a painful yet uplifting story of her personal growth in the face of adversity, of the consolation and wisdom she gained from her family and the words of Gandhi, Dr Martin Luther-King and even of Helen Keller. These influences infiltrated her own response to the tragedies that did not just touch her, but swamped her life in ways that defy our ability to understand. It is our responsibility as we hear her story to consider our own response to world issues and to ponder how we can protect other children from the devastation that conflict brings. Sachiko took a long time to find her voice after the events of 1945 . . . it is a story that is worth hearing. It is also a testament to those that did not survive.
Caren Stelson has written this book as a narrative non-fiction, with Sachiko's story told with historical excerpts and analysis scattered alongside the personal accounts. These non-fiction accounts are well-referenced, and written with simple clarity to make this history accessible for a younger reader, as well as interested adults. Stelson has used transcripts from Sachiko's memories and added her own research to confirm details of the events of this time. Sachiko (through Caren Stelson) is an honourable contributor to the history of World War II and its conclusion, and her accounts are worthy of our respect. Current younger readers and students could read this book alongside the well-known story of Sadako and the Thousand Paper Cranes by Eleanor Coerr. This book contains excellent photographs including some from Sachiko's own personal history.
Carolyn Hull

The great barbie disaster by Tania Ingram

cover image

Ill. by Christina Miesen. Mates series. Omnibus, 2016. ISBN 9781742991245
(Age: 6+) Highly recommended. Humour. I love the Mates series of books, giving newly independent readers short easy read chapters, copiously illustrated, with some words in a different font to mull over.
In this funny tale, Dad is one of a long line of do it yourselfers, and when it comes to the backyard barbie, he wants to try out his skills. But he is not like his brothers who are legendary in the things they build. In this tale, Dad tries three different ways to build a barbie,but each attempt ends in disaster.
Readers will laugh out loud at his various attempts and the results of his dubious carpentry.
His first attempt uses an old metal box which he attaches to a old table. The barbie ends up in flames. His second attempt uses some old tyres and most children would be able to predict what happens when tyres accidentally catch alight. His third attempt sees him using an old wheelbarrow, and so convinced is he that this will work that the family is invited around the next day. But of course an amazing series of events sees this barbie end in chaos, and without drawing breath, Dad is planning the next. A very funny look at families and how they interact forms the background of this tale.
Fran Knight

Island of Glass by Nora Roberts

cover image

The Guardians trilogy, bk. 3. Piatkus, 2016. ISBN 9780349407906
(Age: Adult) Romance. Fantasy. The third in The Guardians series see Roberts return to Ireland as her setting where Doyle, the immortal, must come to grips with his past when he finds that the house they are living in has been built on the exact spot where he grew up centuries before. As they begin to search Irish history and landscape for the final star and the Island of Glass, both Doyle and Riley must come to grips with the attraction that they feel towards each other and be courageous enough to admit their love. Island of glass is not a stand-alone novel, readers should read the others in the series, Stars of fortune and Bay of sighs, before reading this.
Roberts' love of Ireland is evident in her telling of this tale. The soft landscape, misty mornings, green fields and ancient monuments provide a background to Doyle and Riley's story. The other four protagonists - Annika the effervescent mermaid, Sawyer the time traveller, Bran the Irish sorcerer and Sasha the seer, all play an important role, but it is Doyle and Riley who dominate the story in Island of Glass. There are dramatic moments, action packed incidents and a beautiful fantasy island for the seekers of the stars and readers will be swept along for the quest.
Fans of Roberts will be very familiar with the way she pairs off six people, giving them a seemingly impossible task to perform, while finding love on the way, but her novels always provide a great deal of escapism and ease of reading that brings fans back for more.
Pat Pledger