Reviews

The Haters by Jesse Andrews

cover image

Allen and Unwin, Australia, 2016. ISBN 9781760291891
(Age: 15+) Recommended. Wes and Corey have been friends for a long time, founded by their love of hating music and searching for music so good they can't hate on it. When they are booked into a summer jazz camp they quickly realise that due to the lack of females this is going to be a lame camp. Then they meet free spirited Ash, the stand out female in the whole camp. During a three hour jam session they soon realise together they have some talent and embark on The Haters, Summer of Hate World Tour 2016. What follows is an exciting, fun filled adventure across America in the world's smelliest car, which feels like there are scorpions built into the seat.
Jesse Andrews has written a coming of age story which is funny, a little wicked and with a heap of teenage wit thrown in. Even though there is a lot of comedy it also gives us serious topics, one being the relationships the three main characters have with their parents which helps understand the main characters. I love the referencing to bands and Youtube clips that feature throughout, and the dialogue Wes has when imagining or explaining conversations. I loved Jesse Andrew's style of writing especially the way he made me laugh out loud many times throughout the book. This book will appeal to those more mature teenage readers with a deviant sense of humour. If you loved Me and Earl and the dying girl (also written by Jesse Andrews), or John Green's Paper towns you will love this story.
Jody Holmes

The snow wombat by Susannah Chambers

cover image

Ill. by Mark Jackson. Allen and Unwin, 2016. ISBN 9781760113810
This homage to the High Country in south east Australia shows off the environment, both natural and man-made, its flora and fauna and those who live there. I was struck as I read at the range of indigenous and introduced animals represented in the illustrations, as well as depictions of the way the environment is used.
The story of the wombat and its journey through the snow to its warm, snuggly den makes for exciting reading for younger people, as they are asked to predict the rhyming word which completes each stanza of four short lines. Younger readers will call out the words with gusto, learning that the wombat has a nose, ears and a tum just like them and where they are on its body. The wombat's journey is delightfully shown on maps on the endpapers, and the watercolour illustrations show the many animals that live in the area, along with some stunning renditions of the snow covered eucalypts. Each page is a treat, teaching the reader about this area of Australia not often seen in books, and they will learn to appreciate the lives of the animals and people that live there. We are shown the stations with miles of fencing to keep in the wool covered sheep, the rugged up skiers coming down the mountainside, the alpine signs on the roads warning motorists of kangaroos and wombat, and plenty of other animals looking for shelter from the harsh winds and sleet. This is a charming introduction to an area of Australia which children know little of, learning about wombats along the way with rhyming words to predict as well. And with the animal snuggled up safe and warm at the end, what more can a picture book offer.
Fran Knight

This girl that girl by Charlotte Lance

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2016. ISBN 9781760291709
(Age: 3+) Recommended. Difference. Neighbours. Families. Living next door to each other, two girls cannot be more different. This girl is neat and tidy, with neatly combed hair, tied up shoelaces and neat clothes, while that girl has every which way hair, floaty clothing with a cape and seems careless of which colours go with what. The soft watercolour illustrations will attract the reader's attention from the start as they turn the pages and take in the differences shown. Over the page we see the sort of things each girl likes, further underlining their differences. This girl likes to collect plants to add to a scrapbook, hoovering up the scraps at the end of her day, and is particular about setting the table, and often sits in a corner and reads. That girl, on the other hand loves running through the leaves, scattering them around, climbing onto a brick wall and walking along the top, and eating worms. They could not be more different. Over the next few pages we see their families and their houses, marking their differences again, but now their fathers seem the exact opposite of each girl. One dad is neat and tidy, the other dressed in unusual clothes with wispy floating hair. Each dad has attributes seemingly more aligned to the girl next door, not their own daughter.
But when it comes to building a treehouse, despite all the preparation on one side and the haphazard manner of building on the other, both finished tree houses look exactly the same. Readers will love comparing both girls and their fathers, comparing the attributes of each of the people shown, comparing the preparation each does to build the tree house with the final results. Readers cannot help but see that despite outside appearances, we are all the same.
Fran Knight

The royal baby's big red bus tour of London by Martha Mumford

cover image

Ill. by Ada Grey. Bloomsbury, 2016. ISBN 9781408868966
(Age: 4+) Highly recommended. London, Royal family, Great Britain, Babies. After the success of the first three books devoted to the offspring of the Duke and Duchess of Cambridge, Shh don't wake the royal baby, Happy birthday royal baby, and Hooray it's a new royal baby, it's great to see a fourth book devoted to the children's view of the city in which they live, London. Few books exist extolling the main features of some of our great cities, so this will make a perfect introduction to London and the iconic features of that place to a child or class. I loved looking at the views the book offers, reminding me of the things I saw when there. For children it will be a fabulous journey on the big red bus, the well known London transport system. The shiny red bus on the cover will ensure readers open the book and read on.
The Royal Family is sitting in the gardens at Buckingham Palace when a big red bus pulls up calling them to come on a tour of London. They all pile on board, taking along a bus load of accoutrements!
The bus pulls into a range of major London sights, Natural History Museum, ZSL London Zoo, Regent's Park, British Museum, National Portrait Gallery, Trafalgar Square, Nelson's Column before going onto the River Thames. Here they cruise past the Houses of Parliament, Tower of London, Big Ben, Tower Bridge and on down to Greenwich, where they spy the Observatory and Planetarium. On the return journey they stop at London Eye and then return to the palace for tea. Going to bed, the prince realises that he has lost his toy, a baby dinosaur, so mum retraces their steps to find it for him.
This is a fun book to read, encouraging discussion of the Royal Family and what it does during the day, as well as showing off the wonderful sights of London and what the city offers to its visitors. The funny illustrations will encourage discussion about travel and transport as well as city life.
Fran Knight

The family with two front doors by Anna Ciddor

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2016. ISBN 9781925266641
(Age: 8+) Anna Ciddor, a prolific and popular Australian author, has written a warm and amusing recollection of her grandmother's childhood in Lublin, Poland in 1920.
The Jewish family of nine children rent two apartments alongside each other, hence making use of the two front doors on the ground floor of the building. The household is constantly bustling and busy with family rituals and meals, alongside father's commitments, as a rabbi, to the local community. Long-held traditions of the Jewish people are the backdrop for the story of the betrothal of Adina Rabinovich, the oldest daughter, to Mordechai Weinberg, both in their late teens. No one has met young Mordechai, so the intrigue and excitement about him, grows as the wedding date comes closer. Food, clothes, jewellery, and family customs remain the main subject of this charming memoir along with the wonderful family bond that exists between parents and children. Their exuberance about life is infectious! However, underlying the joyfulness of this snapshot of life we realise that the Rabinovich family live in a poorer part of the city - the Jewish quarter. Mama's jewels are family heirlooms, forever fascinating for the young sisters, but we wonder how safe these treasures, and their shared treasured lives, will be in times to come. Lublin is about 150 kilometres south east of Warsaw. Deliberately, Ciddor does not mention the battle for Warsaw in the summer of 1920 and only refers to the perils of the Second World War and the Holocaust in her author's note.
Julie Wells

The next together by Lauren James

cover image

Walker Books, 2015. ISBN 9781406358056
(Age: 14+) Recommended. Kate Finchley and Matt Galloway have started to fall in love during the year 2039 whilst both attending University of Nottingham Campus, England. The peculiar thing isn't that they have both just met but the feeling that they have been through this all before. Rewind to 1854, where Katy (Kit) is living as a boy to be able to work as a kitchen boy in the house of a lord. Lord Sommerset wants her to assist journalist Matthew Galloway, reporting on the war front in the Crimea on the condition that she spy on the journalist and report secrets back home. Rewind again to 1754 and Katherine is tired of her Aunt introducing her to prospective marital matches, so whilst she excuses herself to spend time in the garden she is secretly hoping to spend time with the family's coachman Matthew Galloway. How can these two people be linked throughout time and share memories that aren't their own? As 2039 Kate and Matt search for clues on the murder of their Aunt and Uncle (Kate and Matt) they discover the secret on why their lives seem to be destined to be together again and again.
Whilst the concept of this book intrigued me at first I found it difficult to be able to follow the timeline of each of the Kate and Matthew characters through history. The characters are written with strong personalities and with added charm and plenty of humour. The chapters do jump from one period to the next and as the story evolved I found it easier to follow along. I appreciated that Lauren James has intertwined the genres together making it a great book for lovers of historical, science fiction and even romance novels to enjoy. I would recommend this book to young adults from the ages of 14 years and above. I look forward to finding out what happens with Kate and Matt in the sequel The last beginning.
Jody Holmes

Milo: a moving story by Tohby Riddle

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2016. ISBN 9781760111632
(Age: 6+) Recommended. Friends, City life, Relationships. A picture book for older readers, the title alerts readers to the double meaning of the story, particularly when the cover illustration shows Milo and his kennel perched precariously on top of a tall building.
Milo lives a quiet, ordered life. He has a number of friends with whom he has adventures and when they are at home during the night call out to each other across the rooftops of the city. But one night, he dreams he is on a boat, with high winds and choppy seas. He tosses and turns, restless and sleeping badly. When he wakes he is tired and impatient, so much so that when his friend, Snombo calls he rudely sends him away. He instantly regrets his rude words to his friend and that night a storm erupts, leaving Milo and his kennel stuck on a roof. Alone he ponders his plight and the events of the previous day. A migrating bird, Carlos flies in and helps him from his kennel onto the roof of the building and during the night they talk and swap stories.
In the morning a window cleaner comes to work and in return for helping him down from the top of the building, he helps the window cleaner finish his work.
He returns with his kennel to his usual spot, surprised that his friends are there looking for him, even Snombo. He recounts his adventures and during the celebrations he apologises to his friend, Snombo.
That night he dreams again of being in a boat, but this time the seas are calm and the boat still.
This charming picture book illustrates the importance of friends, of working to keep them, of the adventures that friends have together. Riddle's illustrations in a mix of colour wash, collage and photographic images are a treat. They will have younger readers searching for instances of city life as they hum the tunes of In the good old summer time, and Give my regards to Broadway. The New York setting will intrigue readers who will be able to pick out sights of that city. Riddle's whimsical approach to the group of friends, shown as dogs dressed in their apparel from the mid twentieth century is further enhanced by the sepia colours used, giving the whole a very old fashioned look.
Like all of Riddle's books, the more it is read, the more the reader sees.
And it is worth the effort.
Fran Knight
Editor's note: Teacher's notes are available.

Series set in Realm of the Elderlings by Robin Hobb

cover image

Harper Collins, various dates.
(Age: 15+) Highly recommended. Books set in the Realm of the Elderlings by Robin Hobb have grabbed my reading time over the last few weeks - and are fabulous for readers who enjoy epic fantasy. Although The Farseer Trilogy (Assassin's apprentice, Royal Assassin, Assassin's quest,) were first published many years ago Hobb's fantastic storytelling has ensured that their popularity has endured and the books have been reprinted. The Farseer Trilogy is followed by the Tawny Man series (Fool's errand, Golden fool and Fool's fate), Liveship Traders (Ship of magic, The mad ship, Ship of destiny), the Rainwild chronicles (The dragon keeper, Dragon haven, City of dragons and Blood of dragons) and The Fitz and the fool series (Fool's Assassin, Fool's Quest and Assassin's Fate due in 2017).
These series of books are a very valuable addition to a library or if budgets don't allow for their purchase, would be worthwhile to recommend to readers to borrow from a public library. Those who start following the adventures of Fitz and the Fool, both compelling characters who face strange and compelling times in a wonderful setting, are likely to want to read all in the series.
Pat Pledger

The war of the four isles by Andrew McGahan

cover image

Ship Kings series, Book 3. Allen and Unwin, 2014. ISBN 9781760291693
(Age: Junior secondary) Young readers have a treat in store when award winning author, Andrew McGahan, turns his hand to adolescent fiction. It is a pleasure to share his skill with words, which makes his young Admiral, Dow Amber, so convincing and appealing, and the many twists and turns of fortune so intriguing.
In this episode of the Ship Kings saga, the legend of his bravery grows as he and his colleagues face the anger of the sea and the monsters of the deep.
Together, they face the dangers of battle and most of all they face the danger of betrayal. With differing factions within the two opposing enemies, the Ship Kings and the Twin Islanders, who can be trusted? It is hard to unravel the truth.
After visiting the legendary home of the Twin Islanders, Amber devises a plan to rescue Nell and the other leaders who stood against the dominance of the Ship Kings. Amber is successful but what has he achieved? Have innocent people died because of his actions?
When Amber journeys to New Island to reunite with his family, he discovers he is hated for supposedly abandoning them and his people. After the horror he discovers there, he rejoins the battle between the two opposing powers with new purpose, his heart set on revenge.
Those who love a fast paced adventure will enjoy this novel and look forward to the fourth episode to come.
Thelma Harvey

Eve and Elly by Mike Dumbleton

cover image

Ill. by Laura Wood. Random House, 2016. ISBN 9780857988515
(Age: 3+) Recommended. Loss. Toys. Family. Eve simply loves her pet stuffed elephant, Elly. She takes him with her wherever she goes, clutching him tightly under her arm. When they go on holiday, Elly goes too, and sits on the beach with Eve as she builds a sandcastle. On their return, Eve feels ill and Mum cuddles her until she falls asleep, but the worst thing has happened, Elly has fallen from the car unnoticed.
At home Eve searches everywhere for her elephant, all through the house and car and in the garden. She is inconsolable and rejects every other toy offered by her caring parents. But Dad has an idea and shortly after a parcel arrives in the post. Eve is thrilled but a little taken aback at the size of Elly until Dad explains Elly's amazing journey to return home.
This is a wonderful story to read aloud, brimming with the love that surrounds the child and her love for her toy. The loss of the toy will be recognised by all readers and they will be on edge as the tale unfolds, bringing the child and her toy back together with a very cute twist. The story Dad tells is full of humour and adventure as the elephant finds his way back home.
The illustrations reflect the loving family and the place held by the toy elephant. I love the parcel cover, and the cheeky look on Elly's face throughout the book. This book will have instant appeal to younger children, and initiate discussions about the place their toys hold in the family and what they do when something is lost. Fran Knight

MARTians by Blythe Woolston

cover image

Walker Books, 2016. ISBN 9781406341393
(Age: 14+) Recommended. Consumerism. Dystopian fiction. Zoe Zindleman has been abandoned by her mother and the government has shut down her school. She is given the opportunity to start work at ALLMART, where 'your smile is the AllMART welcome mat'. Her house is going to be repossessed and when she meet MORTimmer, he warns her that it is not a smart idea to live in ALLMART's dormitories. Trusting him, she moves into the Warren, a deserted shopping centre where a laundromat becomes her home, shared with the little boy 5er and Timmer. Then her ordeal as an employee of ALLMART begins as she learns the ins and outs of selling in a big store.
This is a grim but totally engrossing story about consumerism gone wild told in the heart wrenching voice of Zoe, an intelligent girl. As her training progresses she realises that there is no future for her as she will always be in debt to AllMART, who charge her enormous prices for uniforms and food. As Zoe battles her way through learning about how to sell, the reader will find many familiar descriptions of different store departments and how they are set up. Equally bleak are the stories of abandoned children, whose parents have left them behind, and the stories of repossessed houses that are pulled apart for their metal, and a government that has abandoned everyone.
However there is one small glimpse of hope that Timmer gives: Look for the ones who need help and spread the good around.
This was an exceptionally thought provoking book. References were made to Ray Bradbury's The Martian Chronicles but don't detract for those who haven't read it, and will make them want to pick it up.
This would make an ideal literature circle book or class novel with the themes of consumerism gone wild, governments who cannot help people whose homes are repossessed, unemployment, and abandoned children making for great discussion points for their relevance for today's society.
Pat Pledger

Marmaduke the very popular dragon by Rachel Valentine

cover image

Ill. by Ed Eaves. Bloomsbury, 2016. ISBN 9781408862667
(Age: 4+) Recommended. Friendship, Dragons, Medieval times. A sequel to Marmaduke the very different dragon (2014), this one has friendship as its core theme, as Meg and Marmaduke again do everything together. The two are inseparable, that is until one of the princesses, locked away in her tower asks Marmaduke if they can play together. So popular is this new experience, all the princesses join them, and the other dragons join in and eventually the princes too. Meg is happy that Marmaduke has built up a large friendship group, and all play together well. Meg reminds Marmaduke of the forthcoming Whizz Cone Competition knowing that the two of them will easily win the trophy. She watches the preparations uneasily wondering where Marmaduke has got to, and eventually goes searching for him. He is not in any of the usual places so she goes over the hill and there she hears Marmaduke and Prince Bertie making arrangements to compete for the trophy. She is distraught and when the day comes, sits outside the arena listening to the accolades received by the victorious Marmaduke and Prince Bertie. But Marmaduke suddenly remembers Meg, and goes off to search for her. He hears sobbing and flies down to fold her in his wings, apologising for being such a bad friend. They both realise that there is more to being a friend than meets the eye.
Young children will love the dragon theme, and be intrigued with the sparkly wings, and more importantly come to see that being a friend also involves some responsibilities. Young children will eagerly discuss their own friendship groups and how they work out their differences.
Fran Knight

The words in my hand by Guinevere Glasfurd

cover image

Two Roads, 2016. ISBN 9781473617865
(Age: 16+) Highly recommended for mature readers. Themes: Philosophy; Education of women; Rene Descartes; Relationships. Weaving together the story of Rene Descartes with the young maid with whom he has a relationship, the reader gets an insight into the way the world has changed on so many fronts. Descartes was a French philosopher, scientist and writer whose thinking and words were germinal in beginning a transformation in the way the world was understood. This was a dangerous occupation as it upset the status quo. This very well crafted first novel by Glasfurd, enables us to see Descartes life through the eyes of the young maid, Helena Jans Von Strom, that he meets while lodging in the Dutch house where she works for an English Bookseller. She is portrayed as an intelligent woman trapped in her role because of her gender and the intransigence of her circumstances as a maid. From the perspective of the 21st Century reader, this level of discrimination seems so unfair and we mourn with her as she attempts to self-educate herself and to be respected and to be acknowledged as a woman of worth in the highly patriarchal and socially discriminative era of the 1600's world. She becomes Descartes' love interest and the mother of his child and yet her position needs to remain hidden to protect reputations and to enable her to fit into the society of the day. Helena's love of learning and her exploration of ideas live in parallel to the philosophical world of Descartes. We see how the power of paper and the words that it can carry enters the world of the young woman, and yet the words in her hands remain constrained by her status. Her sorrows and powerlessness are potent for the reader.
This book is not unlike The Girl with the Pearl Earring in portraying a piece of Dutch history in a fictional way albeit a century earlier. It will be enjoyed by Book Club readers who will enjoy the insight into the world of the philosopher who challenges the world in which he lives as well as comparing the role of women from the past. (It does also portray the illicit relationship in detail and there is a violent incident that is quite distressing, so readers need to have some maturity.)
Carolyn Hull

Gary by Leila Rudge

cover image

Walker Books, 2016. ISBN 9781925081695
(Age: 3+) Highly recommended. Birds. Adventure. Maps. Difference. Gary the pigeon cannot fly, so sits at home when the others are taken in the basket to a place far away to compete in a pigeon race and return home. Gary loves hearing their stories and adds their mementos to his scrapbook. This includes maps and tickets, postcards and timetables. He adroitly uses a roll of sticky tape with his beak to stick each of the items into his scrapbook, and listens intently at night as they recount their adventures, adding their stories to his collection.
But one night Gary leans a little too far, tumbling into the basket with his scrapbook. Next day the basket is taken away with the other pigeons for their race home. Finding himself a long way from home is a challenge for Gary because he cannot fly and so find his own way home. But he has his scrapbook, and opening it he is able to chart his way using other methods of travel.
The wonderful pictures tell the story of Gary and his cohort, dressed in their finery for the big race, with the plain Gary looking on. His scrapbook is wonderful, with little drawings of the mementoes that he keeps tucked away. Kids will love looking at these and working out where the pigeons may have collected them from, and then later how Gary uses them to get back home. His adventure will open up all sorts of avenues for classes to discuss maps and mapping, directories, finding your way around your area and so on. As part of the Geography focus this book will be well used, but it is also about someone taking the bull by the horns, about difference and solving a problem, so having their own neat adventure.
The illustrations are wonderful, the pages full of pigeons as they strut around in their cages, the delightful scrapbook used as the endpapers as well, the flowing tumble of Gary into the pigeon basket, Gary in the city using public transport. Each is very funny and shows Gary off to the reader, as he uses his difference to solve his problem. What a treat to reinforce the difference in us all, that everyone has their own characteristics, that one trait is not superior to another.
This will be one of those books in the library where children will cluster around to hear it read out loud, thinking about how Gary can possibly get home, or dreaming of their own big adventure.
Fran Knight

Horses: Fun facts and amazing stories by Dianne Bates

cover image

Ill. by Sophie Scahill. Awesome animals 3. Big Sky Publishing, 2016. ISBN 9781925275858
(Age: 8+) Horses. Horsemanship. Horses: Fun facts and amazing stories is a compendium and a celebration of all things horse! Dianne Bates has sourced an amazing array of horse facts, stories, daring rescues, working horses, horses in movies and television and their historical origins. Colourful photographs of the Horse Shepherd / Equine Sanctuary animals highlight the importance of rescuing these animals. Playful horse caricatures drawn by Sophie Scahill add humour to this factual book - there's a horse king perched on a throne and a horse relaxing with his glasses perched on the end of his nose reading a horse story.
These brave animals have led soldiers into battle, supported Spanish conquistadors settling in new lands and moved the Barnum and Bailey Circus across North America. In the early 1900s there were 750 horses used to haul the carriages and animal cages, to help raise the big top and to perform acts. Walers were the horses used by the Australian light horseman in World War 1 to mobilise the cavalry into battle.
Smallest, tallest, biggest, fastest, and oldest horses, there's an array of horse records to pique the interest of many animal fans. Old Billy, an English barge horse, lived until he was 62 years old.
The text is set out in easy to read boxes, some with colourful backgrounds, horse jokes and horse poems - nursery rhymes are also included. Horses: Fun facts and amazing stories is suitable for the capable reader who enjoys reading factual information.
Rhyllis Bignell