Reviews

The new friend by Kim Kane and Jon Davis

cover image

Ginger Green, Play Date Queen series. Hardie Grant Egmont, 2016. ISBN 9781760127701
(Age: 5-7) Highly recommended. Friends. Who hasn't faced the difficulty of having a new friend visit, and being unsure of what to do and talk about? In The new friend, Ginger has invited Skye over to play. She met Skye at ballet class and being the queen of play dates immediately wanted her to visit to play. But there is a problem - Skye doesn't want her dad to leave and it is rather difficult trying to play when he is around. What can Ginger do?
Another in this delightful series explores the notion of what it takes to become comfortable with a new friend. Ginger tries lots of different activities but it is not until she remembers the one thing that both she and Skye have in common that her new friend feels at ease and begins to have fun and is willing to let her dad go home.
Short chapters, large font and amusing illustrations make this a very appealing book for newly emerging readers to tackle by themselves. The joys and trials of making new friends is explored in a very enlightening way and readers are sure to realise that when they have friends over, they need to find something in common so that their friends will enjoy their play date.
Pat Pledger

Zoo ball by Aleesah Darlison

cover image

Ill. by Australian children. Wombat Books, 2016. ISBN 9781925139433
Ned loves his big, bright bouncing ball. So much so, that he takes it to the zoo and even though his parents warn him not to bounce it, he just can't help himself. Everywhere he goes he bounces it, right into the kangaroos starting a wonderful adventure for the animals as they get in on the game and send it from one to the other, from kangaroo to lion, to penguins to pelican, from tiger to toucan and tapir too. Even into Ellie Elephant's poo!! Ned, his mum, dad, Aunt Lucy and the zookeeper follow, trying to retrieve it but they are always one step behind and all the while the ball is continuing its journey giving animals and crowd alike fun and joy. Then Ned has an idea.
This is a joyful story that bounces along in rhyming text providing as much fun for the reader as it does for the zoo creatures. But the unique feature is its illustrations. Wombat Books invited children all over Australia to submit drawings to accompany the story to provide them with an introduction to the world of illustrating and the opportunity to be published professionally. Now, twenty aspiring illustrators have their work included and acknowledged in a story that will be very popular with young readers. Even the cover is by a young illustrator, Alyssa Teoh, who also has an illustration in the book.
However, as well as inspiring those who were successful to continue, this book will also inspire other young artists. Sadly, children are often only exposed to the 'perfect' artwork of adults and never believe their own is quite good enough. We have all heard the plaintive questions, 'Do you like mine, Miss?' and 'Is this good enough?' as they seek reassurance for their efforts so this is an excellent book to celebrate the beauty and worthiness of children's art. It should be on hand to show them what can be achieved even by children. That what they produce is valid, valued and valuable. One of the young artists said, 'I entered the Zoo Ball Challenge following Aleesah Darlison's visit to our primary school at the beginning of 2014,' she said. 'Aleesah was really passionate about her writing and I am really passionate about my drawing. I thought immediately that this was the challenge for me.'
Aleesah's passion for writing comes through every story she writes and to be able to inspire our students to read, write and draw as she does, is a special gift to be treasured. You can read more about how the project evolved in an interview with Aleesah on Kids' Book Review. I hope this book is really successful so that Wombat Books are inspired to host a similar challenge in future.
Barbara Braxton

Desert Lake by Pamela Freeman

cover image

Ill. by Liz Anelli. Nature Storybooks series. Walker Books, 2016. ISBN 9781921529436
(Age: 6+) Highly recommended. Kati Thanda-Lake Eyre, Desert, South Australia, Animals. Within the realm of this wonderful series, a story is told in which every word is true, set alongside a text which gives the non fiction detail. This template has worked with other books in this series, Big red kangaroo, Python and Emu. And here the same format is used again to show the reader the amazing life of a desert lake in South Australia, known as Kati Thanda or Lake Eyre.
The story sited at the top of each page tells of the coming rains which invigorate the eggs laid beneath the dry crust of the lake, while at the bottom of each page in a different font, we read the detail, that the rains only come every ten years or so, that the eggs are buried deep in the earth often years before. Over the page we learn that the rain falls many kilometres away that it takes a long time to trickle south to the lake, that the water makes the eggs quickly turn into tadpoles then frogs, ready to mate and die before the desert takes over again. Thousands of birds fly north, lizards come along to the water's edge, and each drinks and eats until the desert begins to take over again. Plants grow, seed and die and the water begins to dry up.
The story at the top of the page in larger font, uses a heavier font to accentuate some of the words, like Rain falls, or emerge, and so on, underlining the events which are happening at the lake. The smaller font at the bottom of the page reads more like a text, but one so interesting that it dovetails the words above, giving them a wider meaning.
The illustrations are luminous, giving an image of that outback place with its variety and colour for all readers to pore over. On every page closer inspection is called for if only to look for the range of flora and fauna included on that page. Small hints are given of man's footprint on the land, a farmhouse and train line, a windmill and train, but the overwhelming theme is of the natural world in all of its glory, reviving with the intermittent rains, bringing the once dry lake back to life, only to have it all gone with months, if not weeks. The sheer amazement at this occurrence in the north of South Australia is given full reign in this book, and it will appeal to anyone opening its pages.
Fran Knight

The crazy friend by Kim Kane and Jon Davis

cover image

Ginger Green, Play Date Queen series. Hardie Grant Egmont, 2016. ISBN 9781760127718
(Age: 5-7) Highly recommended. Lots of fun in this book for emerging readers! Ginger Green just loves having her friends over for a play date, but sometimes things can become difficult. Today she is playing with Maisy but Maisy is crazy! She is noisy and runs all over the house; she sheds her clothes and races around nude but worst of all she climbs onto the roof with mum's car keys. How will Ginger cope with Maisy's bad behaviour?
This is a story that all children will relate to as the chances are that a friend who seemed fine at school can be rather different when they come around for a play date. The dilemma for a child is how to persuade a friend to play by the rules that operate in their household and also to play safely and not put anyone or anything at risk. Ginger manages to get her friend off the roof and to find an activity that will keep them both active and happy. This could engender lots of discussion about playing safely and treating other people's home in a respectful manner.
This aside, the story is a great one with lots of humour, easy chapters, big font and the illustrations of little foxes by Jon Davis are a delight. It will be perfect as a book for newly independent readers.
Pat Pledger

A Midsummer Night's Dream by William Shakespeare, rewritten by Terry Deary

cover image

Shakespeare Tales series. Bloomsbury, 2016. ISBN 9781472917775
(Age: 7+) Highly recommended. Shakespeare, Elizabethan times. As with Macbeth, this story is told through the eyes of Molly, a servant with a troupe of players who tour England presenting Shakespeare's plays to whatever audience comes along. One of the actors, Richard Armin, is the fool employed in many of the plays. Molly tells us that Shakespeare even wrote comic scenes in some of the sadder plays to include Armin. But she and Armin do not like each other and he treats her badly.
The background tale of Molly and her place within the troupe is lively and informative and will give readers an idea of just how children their age survived in these perilous times. This book is set in a Nottingham Market and readers will see for themselves the lifestyles of the people in the town in Elizabethan times.
Against Molly's story is that of A Midsummer Night's Dream, with a precis of the play given between Molly's tale. Deary gives the reader a brief but satisfyingly ample outline of the tale with the fairy Oberon making his wife love the first person she sees when she wakes after being given a love potion. The comedy has her seeing a donkey while the other characters, Hermia, Demetrius, Helena and Lysander are also given the love potion and much confusion arises as two of these people are supposed to marry each other and two are planning to elope. Confusion ensues from all directions, but is it all a dream?
The series of books now includes four plays, Macbeth, A Midsummer Night's Dream, Romeo and Juliet and Twelfth Night, designed to bring Shakespeare to a new audience.
Fran Knight

Invisible mending by Mike Ladd

cover image

Wakefield Press, 2016. ISBN 9781743054079
(Age: 16+) Commencing with wry observations about Adelaide and touching recollections of the lives of everyday people, Mike Ladd tells his stories in both poetry and prose.
Warmth, compassion and affection are evident in short stories and poems which reveal a lot of cynicism and even anger, sometimes tempered by a humour which prompts the reader to giggle.
As someone who is reluctant to spend time deciphering hidden meaning in unstructured poetry, I found the verse unpretentious, with a clear message. Often the poems contain simple observation, but are written in a way that the average reader can understand and appreciate the theme.
I identified with the characters in the short stories very much. The personal account of his family's friendship with a young refugee is very touching for so many reasons, but mainly because the writer emphasises that whilst these people are all around us, few of us try to get to know them.
Men depicted having hospital treatment were drawn with great realism and poignancy. I can imagine the writer mentally writing the piece whilst sitting in the ward with his desperately suffering father, over an extended period.
The style and theme of the works take an abrupt change as the author writes about his life overseas in Malaysia and Chile. His experience and knowledge give an insight on a range of topics. I particularly liked the depiction of a smuggling operation with a calm acknowledgement of what prompted various individuals, without attempting to excuse the behaviour.
I was left feeling that this author has a great affection for the world, despite being disappointed and sometimes distraught by the behaviour of people. It was delightful to read his short story about an impromptu catch up with a son who had been travelling and surviving on nothing in South America for two years. I found it affirming that the father was interested in alternate perspectives and was open to learning from the younger man whilst trying to cope with compressed time in a slightly surreal environment, unfamiliar and undesirable to both of them.
Most readers will find something they enjoy in this eclectic book.
Rob Welsh

Fenn Halflin and the Fearzero by Francesca Armour-Chelu

cover image

Walker Books, 2016. ISBN 9781406363128
(Age: 10+) Highly recommended. In Fenn Halflin's world, the sea has been taking over for as long as he has been alive and before. The landborn, who are lead by Terra Firma, hunt and banish the seaborn from the land, keeping the safe, land areas for themselves. They kidnap children to be slaves and to build walls around the land. Fenn is 13 and has been hidden by his grandfather, hidden from Terra Firma who are always looking for boys. Unknown to Fenn, he is the lost child of two resistance leaders who were killed by Terra Firma. One night, the warship is seen and Fenn's grandfather organises for Fenn to leave. They are separated. Fenn is smuggled out on a ship but halfway through the journey, fear encourages the captain to abandon Fenn in a shanty town located in the middle of the sea and from which, escape is impossible. Will Fenn and his new friend escape this place of despair. A place where food is scarce and you have to fight to survive.
Fenn Halflin and the Fearzero is the first in a series about the end of the world. The heroes are all children, showing readers you can make changes and be brave no matter your age. The writing is suspenseful in places, making it highly engaging. The author uses descriptive writing to immerse the reader in the happenings in this watery and scary world. Highly recommended for boys aged 10+ but anyone who likes an adventure story will definitely be hanging out for the next instalment.
Kylie Kempster

Macbeth by William Shakespeare, rewritten by Terry Deary

cover image

Shakespeare Tales series. Bloomsbury, 2016. ISBN 9781472917805
(Age: 7+) Highly recommended. Shakespeare, Macbeth, Elizabethan times. In this lively series, a character is introduced who becomes a narrator presenting the play within the confines of that person's life and times. With Macbeth we meet potgirl, Mary as she cleans up the blood on the stage after another performance of Macbeth. She tells us about the pig's blood used for the killing scenes, and between her talk about her life and work, the author presents the play.
Mary is a sympathetic character, a young girl taken into the harsh service of a tavern owner, a person who treats her badly, yelling at her in front of customers, beating her when she does things wrong, and paying her very little. She must take the jug of ale around to the customers while they stand in the yard watching the play, and she learns the play well. She talks to some of the actors, showing the reader how these men exist going form town to town, and she meets William Shakespeare. After one particularly nasty scolding from her employer she hides in one of the stage baskets and gets away, joining the troupe.
All the while the play is going on, and we read a summary of the plot and characters in text designed for the younger reader. The story is well written for a younger audience and the series will add to the growing interest in Shakespeare's plays for this audience. At the end of each book is given several pages of lively information about the play.
Fran Knight

Circle by Jeannie Baker

cover image

Walker Books, 2016. ISBN 9781406338010
(Age: all) Highly recommended. Natural world. Birds. Inter relationship. Environment. The circle of life is reprised on every page in this beautiful new book from illustrator/author Jennie Baker. Her story of the godwits, the birds which amazingly wing their way from Alaska to Australia and back each year, will stun the readers. The story itself is a powerful reminder that we are all interrelated, that what humans do has an impact upon the rest of the planet, and from the perspective of this one small bird, that our interference with the coastline seriously degrades their habitat. Linked with her glorious collage illustrations the book reflects the environment in which we all live and makes a spine tingling imperative that we do much more to protect it.
The life cycle of the godwit is shown through one bird, one with white splashes on his wings, and we follow him throughout the book. He flies from Alaska to Australia, a journey of 11,000 kilometres and on the return journey he finds a mate, they build a nest together and raise their chicks. Each arm of their journey is fraught with danger as their environment is degraded, places they once stopped to rest are gone, buildings dot the coastlines, land clearance has put their feeding places at risk and foxes search for their chicks.
Every page greets the inquiring reader, intriguing them with hints of just how each picture is made, astonishing them with information about this amazing bird, revealing just how we have made the environment so difficult for these birds to survive. Each page impels the reader to stop and think about why our earth is now in such great peril. Our interconnection is repeated throughout the book, no reader can miss the powerful message being offered.
The circle motif is repeated throughout the book with the curvature of the earth shown in many of the illustrations. The reader cannot escape the image of the reserve where the boy watches the birds at the beginning of the book, compared with the reserve at the end: degraded, overused, with industry encroaching on its borders. Readers will easily spot the impact of man on this environment, the lights of the city seen from on high as the birds fly north, the increasing rubbish seen on the beach, the degradation of the waterfront, the number of buildings seen in the background, planes in the sky. Further inspection of each wonderful image will enhance the readers' interpretation and awe. And readers will ponder the image of the boy, at first disabled and in a wheelchair, dreaming of flying, at the end leaving his crutches behind and running onto the beach, and later still dreaming of flying with his crutches beneath his bed. The bird and the boy have been on impressive journeys, causing the reader to stop and speculate on each of them, and wondering how the boy, a bird watcher, can use his knowledge to make a change. This book throws the question back on the reader, and will create much discussion in classrooms and libraries.
Fran Knight
Editor's note: Teacher's notes are available at the publisher's website.

Three by Justin D'Ath

cover image

Ford Street Publishing, 2016. ISBN 9781925272277
(Age: 11-14) Sunday Balewo is sixteen, a keen soccer player and in love with Holly Parr. His father is also President for Life of an African nation, Zantugi.
But everything changes dramatically when Sunday's parents are killed in a coup and Sunday himself is being targeted, not by a guerrilla but by a baboon, a trained animal wearing a suicide vest.
Even though Sunday escapes the immediate attack, the baboon and its handlers are determined to track him down. He must find somewhere to hide and someone to help him. Anyone breaking the curfew at night is in danger of being shot, which makes Sunday's plight even more hazardous.
Just as in D'Ath's Extreme Adventure series, the plot is fast paced, unpredictable and full of suspense. Some of the facts we discover about the baboon, and some twists in the plot are less than credible but entertainment is the main focus here. Upper Primary and Lower Secondary students of both sexes will enjoy this story and empathise with Sunday.
Thelma Harvey

Jimmy Cook discovers third grade by Kate and Jol Temple

cover image

Ill. by Jon Foye. Allen & Unwin, 2016. ISBN 9781760291938
(Age: 10+) Highly recommended. Humour. Australian history. School. Jimmy Cook becomes a butt of jokes in class when he insists that he is related to Captain James Cook, despite the man having no known descendants. This does not deter Jimmy however and he is sure that he must go on an adventure just like his forebear, this time to Hawaii where Captain Cook was killed, as Jimmy firmly believes that the place needs a dose of law and order.
History Week at school gives him another forum for discussing the Captain, and he does this at length, going to such extremes as dressing his hair in the same way and wearing a tricorn hat. Luckily a certain brand of cereal has a competition running which sees Jimmy collecting all the coupons he can with the help of his friends, in order to win first prize, a trip to Hawaii. But one hitch is that his enemy in class, Alice, is also collecting the coupons so they are rivals. There follows a funny story of Jimmy and his ambition often thwarted by Alice, but the rivalry which exists in third grade is well drawn, and the accompanying wonderful illustrations which dot the pages are a treat. I particularly love the inventory of Captain Cook's things adding much interest to the behind the scenes history of such a voyage of exploration. Learning history at this sort of pace is most infectious and I hope we will see more of Jimmy Cook.
Fran Knight

The furball strikes back by Aaron Blabey

cover image

The bad guys, episode 3. Scholastic, 2016. ISBN 9781760157265
(Age: 7+) Highly recommended. Animals, Adventure, Heroism.  Subtitled, The furball strikes back, readers who laughed their way through Episode 2 with the break in at the Sunnyside Chicken Farm, will know that the owner, Doctor Rupert Marmalade, will be wreaking revenge upon our heroes. Led by Mr Wolf, the three other friends, Mr Snake, Mr Piranha and Legs have gone along with his plans of shrugging off their bad guy images by doing good deeds. So far this has not gone well, but releasing the chickens from the Stalag type chicken farm has at least gained them a host of friends, if only of the chicken variety.
But Doctor Marmalade is out for revenge and tricks them into coming to his lair where he captures them and ties them up, not knowing that Mr Piranha is still outside.
Blabey's graphic novel style, giving the story in short easily digested chapters full of laugh out loud cartoon images, will have readers grabbing this book from the shelf. The pages are full of movement as the characters pit their strengths against those of Doctor Marmalade, and the various styles used by comic writers shine out. Pages change from whole page illustrations to those where three or four lines of pictures are used while different fonts and font sizes are used, and some faces peer out at the reader with an intimate gaze. It adds up to a wholly fascinating story which furthers the adventures of the four heroes to the great enjoyment of the readers.
And of course, Episode 4 is coming as zombie kittens make their presence felt.
Fran Knight

WeirDo: Crazy Weird by Anh Do

cover image

Scholastic, 2016. ISBN 9781760159085
(Age: 7+) Highly recommended. Weir Do visits the dentist and discovers he needs braces. How embarrassing! Will he ever open his mouth again? Mum can't make him and his pets keep running away from him. How will he ever get through a day at the fun fair with his friends? Worse yet, the girls he likes keeps on wanting to talk to him. There is no way Weir Do wants her to see his teeth!
WeirDo - Crazy Weird is book 6 in the WeirDo collection and is highly entertaining. The author has the right mix of silly events, black and white images and a variety of fonts to help create an engaging story. It features short bursts of text, making it a great first novel for budding readers. Highly recommended for boys aged 7+ but girls will enjoy it as well. The book is also very supportive of more reluctant readers thanks to the short text, interesting illustrations and quick moving storyline.
Kylie Kempster

Flawed by Cecelia Ahern

cover image

Harper Collins 2016. ISBN 9780008126360
(Age: 14+) Is there anything worse than imperfection? In a world that champions perfection should your flaws be laid bare for the world to see? With a system that is inherently flawed - how can it be overthrown? From within? Or from without, could the Flawed rise up and begin a revolution? How? Who would lead them?
When the system fails and you become the most flawed person in existence what do you do? Sentenced to five brands (foot, hand, heart, head, and tongue) for the simple act of compassion towards another human being, Celestine North finds herself the reluctant emblem of a revolution she never had any intention of fighting. She put her trust in one man, her boyfriend's father, Judge Crevan. A fearsome man, but a man just the same. With Crevan and her family pressuring her to lie in the courts when she is on trial for being flawed, Celestine begins to question a system that would judge her flawed for simply helping an old, sick man who just happened to be flawed. Even though he was flawed, he, like Judge Crevan, was just a man. For her compassion and her honesty Celestine's life is forever changed - she can never go back to her life of utter perfection. Her dreams, her plans, and her future are all ruined-forever.
Sitting in the same class as Veronica Roth's Divergent series, Flawed is certainly recommended for girls aged fourteen and up who like dystopians. While the first few chapters are questionable, the book improves and mellows out into an easy read with a great and terrifying concept. Certainly something to make the reader appreciate our society.
Kayla Gaskell (University student)

The girl who raced Fairyland all the way home by Catherynne M. Valente

cover image

Atom, 2016. ISBN 9781472112835
Recommended for fantasy lovers. Fantasy. Adventure. Fairies. Magical world. This is unlike anything I have read before, although there is an essence of Alice and a looking-glass world, a hint of a crossover with a Wardrobe world, and a dose of psychedelic fairy-tale adventure within its idiosyncratic style. My desire is to write a review that reveals a little of the cloudburst that has occurred within me as I read. This is a book with a magical maelstrom of characters that are woven in a kaleidoscope of fantasy magic, adventure and mystery, mixed with a pandemic of inscrutability. The windstorm of characterisation of features and follies is at first very difficult to follow, and the ultimate fantasy 'Race' to sort out who deserves to be the current reigning Royal takes the reader to places that no one knows or can fathom. The confusion of plot and characters at first floored this reader - it was hard to create a mental image of all that was exploding onto the page in this unique fantasy creation. However the idiosyncrasies and inherent humour of the language used, and the quirks of expression were so unique that they had an irresistible charm that created a desire to keep reading. (I am not so sure that this would be enough for some younger readers, who would find the worlds and wordsmithery confusing.) Note the following early descriptive example to describe the world in which we find the central character, September.
'A vast and hungry country takes tea somewhat differently than you and I. Fairyland's teatime consisted of a dollop of rain in the Autumn Provinces, a particular delicate icing of clouds over the Painted Forest, a healthy squeeze of blazing sun in the Hourglass Desert, and a fresh, green wind blowing wild through the streets and alleyways and secret corners of Pandemonium.' (p2)
The winner in this incredibly unique telling is the language use; metaphor, simile, word-play, personification and a general licking of alliteration at every turn. The characters are also given exceptional features, costumes and skills by the author Valente, who obviously has a very verdant imagination. Each chapter has a Dickens-like preamble to guide the reader into the next panoply of wonder.
This can be recommended to those who love fantasy deeply, but who also are inspired by words and wordplay. It might be confusing for those who lack persistence or who devour books in small bites! This is the last of the Fairyland series... but the first I have read. It may be that those who already love this world would not be as likely to be confused.
Carolyn Hull