Reviews

The afterlife of Holly Chase by Cynthia Hand

cover image

Harper Collins Publishers, 2017. ISBN 9781460754283
(Ages: 12+) Highly recommended. A heart-warming and emotional tale of the importance of generosity, family, love and compassion. When Holly Chase is visited on Christmas Eve by three spirits warning her of the imminent consequences of her selfish actions, she elects to ignore their advice, doing nothing to mend her ways. Six days later, she dies. Awakening in an office, Holly learns that she will be working for a top-secret company called 'Project Scrooge' to help other 'Scrooges' like her change their behaviour before it's too late. She is appointed to the position of the Ghost of Christmas Past and accepts this as her fate; forced to redeem herself through encouraging others to do what she could not - change for the better. Five years after her death, however, she is faced with a Scrooge that she feels a connection to: Ethan Winters III, a seventeen-year-old who is similarly spoilt, materialistic and grieving the loss of a parent. For the first time since her death, Holly finds that she has something to be hopeful for.
Through her authentic and genuine characters, beautiful writing style and valuable moral, New York Times bestselling author Cynthia Hand provides a sweet, unforgettable and thought-provoking novel that will touch the heart of its reader, and fill them with hope, happiness and gratitude. A book that is impossible to put down, and even harder to stop thinking about, "The Afterlife of Holly Chase" is not a novel to miss and is a wonderful read all year round.
Daniella Chiarolli (university student)

Finch by Penny Matthews

cover image

Walker Books, 2018, ISBN 9781760650759
(Ages: 9+) Highly recommended. Themes: Country towns, Family, Vineyards. When Audrey and her family move to a small wine growing community after dad lost his job in the city, everyone is put out. Audrey and her sister miss their friends and school back in the city, Mum cannot believe that her husband wants to try his hand at farming and Dad is all at sea worrying about his new workload.
Audrey has always been on the outer at school, her love of birds makes her a bit of a nerd in the eyes of the other girls, so when she meets a boy living in a cave near the edge of their property she cannot believe how easily she talks to him, and they share her interest in birds. He swears her to secrecy, having left his uncle's farm where he worked because he was abused, but when a flash flood occurs and Audrey thinks the cave may be under water, she must divulge her secret.
This story will carry along the reader, hooked in by the story of the boy in the cave, wanting to follow his relationship with Audrey and find out just who he is. Along the way information is given about birds, particularly the Emu wren, an endangered scrub bird, rarely seen.
Audrey is a captivating character. Readers will follow her exploits with interest, willing her to fit into her new community, but aware of the problems the family is facing. The people within that community are lovingly composed and developed - we feel we know Mavis and her brother: the teacher and other students at the school, the people at the gift shop. Readers will be drawn to the references to food and its place within the town, the CWA, SES volunteers and the shop owners. Readers will feel like they can walk down the main street with the girls, recognising places described within the book and feel comforted as is Audrey by its familiarity.
Fran Knight

Backyard by Amanda Braxton-Smith

cover image

Ill. by Lizzy Newcomb. Black Dog Books, 2018. ISBN 9781925381177
(Age: 3+) Highly recommended. Themes: Backyards, Insects, Animals, STEM, Discovery. What a feast can be found in one's own backyard, simply using the skill of observation. This wonderful book impels younger readers to do just that, as a sleepy child and her star gazing dog sit on the back verandah and simply watch. Amongst the fig, lilly pilly and large eucalypts trees animals come out at night to eat. The tawny frogmouth is watching for whatever flies past, the spider is weaving her web waiting for an insect, midges fly around only to be eaten by the honeyeaters, a bat swoops up a dragonfly, a possum takes the last of the dog food from its bowl.
The child and her dog observe each and every animal they can see, and eager eyes reading the book will follow the text noticing each animal mentioned and observing more in the undergrowth. Newcomb's acrylic illustrations show us the breadth of the backyard, surrounded by large trees, shrubs and pot plants. Children will love looking at the array of things, recognising things found in their own yard, eager to seek out what they can see when they get home.
This delightful book will encourage children to look more closely at what surrounds them, to be more aware of the living things in their own backyard, to see what shares their home.
The visual and word imagery will intrigue and delight readers as they roll the lines around, practising reading them out loud and peruse the pictures with care to find out what lurks beneath the leaves.
Artist Lizzy Newcomb also illustrated "My name is Lizzie Flynn", the story of a quilt made by convict women on their way to Australia, while Amanda Braxton-Smith has written several novels for Black Dog Books including "Plenty" one of my favourites for 2014.
Fran Knight

The Funny Life of Pets by James Campbell

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2018. ISBN 9781408889947
(Age: 8+) Recommended. A dog's nose is more than 1 000 times more sensitive than our nose. That's why if you do a bottom burp in a dog's face it will go cross-eyed and fall over. Imagine a sausage dog's dilemma when it's eating sausages - the resemblance of this tasty snack to their Granny is uncanny! Uncover top tips for feeding goldfish and avoiding a mini tsunami in your house causing dinosaurs to evolve from your carpets! Discover some of the rarest dog breeds in the world, like the Jack Russell Sprout . . . but remember, they're not just for Christmas.
This is truly one of the funniest books I have ever read. Campbell have very cleverly mixed fact with fiction and will be a real hit with the young readers (8 and up) - especially the advice that is given to convince parents to allow them to get just the pet they want. It has a mix of quirky illustrations, sign posts indicating what directions you can choose and text. It is a little like a choose your own adventure book, whereby you can choose what you want to do. It is not a book that has to be read from cover to cover. I sneakily gave it to one of my Year 6 reluctant readers and he could not put it down - he was very keen to borrow it. I can also see myself using it to fill in the odd five minutes - picking it up and reading a couple of pages. A very lighthearted book that is a must have.
Kathryn Schumacher

Goal Power by Meredith Costain

cover image

Ella Diaries series. Scholastic, 2018. ISBN 9781743818060
(Age: 8+) Highly recommended. "Goal Power" is another instalment in the "Ella Diaries" series. It is a standalone read, and new readers to the series can start with this diary themed novel. Ella tells us about her daily life in a diary, complete with labelled diagrams. She looks at her life in a fun and positive way and changes words to help her describe everything. From 'fantabulous funerous fun' to 'desperating despair', Ella's (and the author's) play on words creates a fun and engaging text.
In "Goal Power", Ella and her friends start a girl's only lunchtime soccer club. Ella is so excited and can't wait to be a striker. Unfortunately, Ella struggles to learn the skills to be a striker so she has a go at being a defender. This doesn't work out either. Will Ella find her place in the soccer team?
"Goal Power" is all about friendship, positive female characters and finding what you are good at. The author portrays Ella as positive, adventurous and a bit dramatic which makes the story funny. Ella's diary entries and diagrams are great to read and easy to comprehend.
This novel is engaging for younger readings and is reminiscent of the "Diary of a Wimpy Kid" (but not so embarrassing). "Goal Power" is highly recommended for readers aged 8+.
Kylie Kempster

Changing Gear by Scott Gardner

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2018. ISBN 9781760631468
(Age: 14+) Recommended. Themes: relationships, family, self-discovery, nature. Year 12 is over and Merrick Hilton has two weeks to study for his final exams. He tells his amicably separated parents he is staying at the other's place and takes off on his restored postie bike. Since the death six months before, of his grandfather, his rock and mentor, Merrick has been disengaged with life, slipping through the space between the two families, and the road trip is a spur of the moment decision. "If you feel like shit, don't just sit around; make something, clean something, smash something - Grandad" p 33. Leaving behind his broken phone and forgetting his wallet, Merrick gathers up his swag, a handful of muesli bars and some cash he had stashed away and rides. Life on the road is challenging in many ways but the constant movement and passing landscape meets his needs, challenging his entrenched habits and when he reaches Little Desert National Park the slower pace required by sandy roads allows him to observe nature more closely. When the chain breaks on his bike Merrick reaches a low point. "I needed boobs, but there were none. I needed food. Proper food, not just muesli bars and bruised fruit. If I'd given this trip more than a moment's thought before I barrelled out the gate, I'd be in a much better place right now." p 69. On the remote desert track Merrick is forced to push his bike a considerable distance until he meets an old man walking the track who reminds him of his grandfather. Victor makes a temporary repair to the bike chain but it soon fails again and they walk together towards the nearest town. Somehow slowing down to a walking pace has grounded Merrick and the two find companionship while facing the challenges of the road.
Merrick's road trip is more than a simple coming of age story; it canvasses a wide range of issues including grief, relationships, real versus internet/media experience, values and a philosophy of life. The vast empty beauty of the land and the walking pace allows for a clarity of thought rarely possible in our modern world. Merrick is not afraid to listen and to learn to respect the land as he pursues his life-affirming inner and outer journey.
This is a robust and engaging story recommended especially for boys fourteen and over.
Sue Speck

Crossing Ebenezer Creek by Tanya Bolden

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2018. ISBN 9781681196992
(Age: 13+) Recommended. In the latter months of 1864, during the U.S. Civil War, General Sherman of the Union led a huge army through Georgia, freeing slaves, plundering goods and destroying property of the vanquished. Many ex-slaves chose to accompany the advancing army on the march. Many would have seen the Northern soldiers as saviours, some depended upon their rations and some undoubtedly wanted to participate in and witness the defeat of the Confederate South.
The Union army was glad to have the labour from thousands of willing workers for transporting equipment, foraging food and building pontoon bridges to replace those destroyed by the retreating Confederates. Accompanying the principally male ex-slaves engaged in military support were the women, children and elderly from their families or dependants from their previous life of servitude.
This story centres upon Mariah, a young woman whose main focus after being freed is the protection of her intellectually disabled young brother by establishing a home on one acre of land, upon which she can grow food. From her recollections, the reader comes to appreciate some of the abject misery and brutal cruelty endured by slaves in the American South. It is difficult to imagine conditions in an era when those who considered themselves part of civilised society might sell children away from traumatised mothers, would inflict barbaric, degrading punishments for the slightest of perceived misdeeds and could ultimately end a slave's life.
Liberated from tyranny, these ex-slaves rejoiced in freedom but faced the fact that they were ill prepared for life ahead, having no land or property and usually no education. When Mariah meets Caleb (a skilled black man working for the Union Army) she recognises his kind, gentle and decent nature and a romance develops which would have been realistic under the circumstances.
The climax of this story involves an historically accurate event which should be shamefully acknowledged and remembered, yet appears to have been buried and forgotten in the mists of time.
Young readers may be confused by the opening sequences of this story, especially if they have no knowledge of slavery in the American South. It may be difficult for those unfamiliar with plantation life and conditions to understand the various characters who are introduced in the early passages, yet if they persist, they will be better for learning about this profoundly important chapter of history.
Recommended for readers 13 years+
Rob Welsh

Bonkers about beetles by Owen Davey

cover image

Flying Eye Books, 2018. ISBN 9781911171485
(Ages: 6-adult) Highly recommended. Themes: Beetles. Non-fiction. What a wonderful encyclopaedic book about beetles, I read it from cover to cover, loving every piece of information given, observing the pictures with glee, scanning the layout and clear design features with admiration.
After a contents page, each double page fastens on one topic, well illustrated with clearly defined drawings, using colours that reflect the places the beetles dwell. Each page is covered with highly arresting information, distinctive and finely detailed illustrations which will enrapture the readers.
The first two double pages inform the reader about the basics of being a beetle: what they are and where they live. Readers will find that there are over 400,000 different beetles species, and that they can be terrestrial or aquatic, and herbivore, omnivore, predator or decomposer. While over the page is a magnificent drawing of a beetle with body parts numbered so that the reader can easily see what part is what, and read how each part is useful to a beetle. From there each double page concentrates on one aspect of the beetle: wings, food, disguise, defence, and camouflage while other pages concentrate on one beetle, like the ladybird and the horned dung beetle.
The last two double spreads show the beetles in mythology and conservation being made on the beetles' behalf. It will surprise readers to find out that although there are over 400,000 species of beetle, some are under threat, and Davey explains just what these beetles do and how we can help in their conservation.
All in all a sparkling look at beetles, and a book I will go back to, as will many readers who love gathering bits of information or who are potty about beetles, or just love the design of the book. Flying Eye Books has published three other books by Owen Davey that use the same entertaining style of both information and presentation: Mad about monkeys, Smart about sharks and Crazy about cats. All four of these books will gather a wide excited audience from primary people.
Fran Knight

Angry Cookie by Laura Dockrill

cover image

Ill. by Maria Karipidou. Walker Books, 2018. ISBN 9781406383089
(Age: 4+) Recommended. Themes: Anger. Friendship. Confronted by an angry Cookie from the start, the reader will be in no doubt about the theme of this book. We are told in no uncertain terms, not to open the book, not to turn the page, and not to try to do anything about his anger. With that, Cookie escapes up the stairs to his bedroom. But then he peeps around the door, apologetically, a little chagrinned about his outburst. Over the next few pages we find out why Cookie is angry. His best friend, the cactus, plays his recorder badly, a pigeon tries to snack on him, he has had a bad hair cut, his toothpaste runs out and he must use his parent's toothpaste which is not to his liking, in fact, his whole day goes awry. But he peeps again at the audience and realising that we are all still there listening to him, deduces that things can't be that bad. He is surprised that the reader keeps coming back despite his bad temper and anger, and concludes that the reader is there because he is a friend and that's what friends do. Young readers will readily empathise with Cookie, recognising the bad events that can happen to them all.
The humour behind the illustrations will have broad appeal to the reader, the simple Cookie expressing his emotions with small changes in the mouth, eyebrows, and eyes. I loved looking at the pictures first to see just how Cookie is going to react on each page before reading the story. Young readers will enjoy Cookie's exploration of what makes him angry, and like him, realise that a friend can make all the difference to how you feel. This is a perfect conduit to class discussions about feelings, anger and friendship.
Fran Knight

Melowy: The night of courage by Danielle Star

cover image

Scholastic, 2018. ISBN 9781338151787
(Age 7+) Recommended. The night of courage is book 3 in the Melowy series and will be enjoyed by any pony lover aged 5+. In this book, readers meet the Melowies, magical ponies who are at school together. They come from a variety of Melowy worlds and display skills and powers accordingly. The Melowies have been challenged to spend a night in the woods. Their teacher expresses the need to learn to not fear making mistakes as the fear stops you from trying something new. The trip starts well despite another Melowy being added to the group of friends, a Melowy who isn't normally nice to the group of friends. The girls build a successful shelter together but in the search for something to eat, Elektra goes missing. Will they find Elektra? Will Eris ruin the chances of the friends being reunited?
The night of courage is a simple narrative built around the themes of friendship and not being afraid. The storyline moves quickly and it is easy to read and understand. It is a short novel, making it ideal for younger readers moving into being independent readers. It would also make a great read for before bed whether independently or being read by an adult. Sections of the story could be linked to the Child protection and Health curriculums when discussing teamwork, problem solving and friendship.
The night of courage is a fun read and is recommended for independent readers aged 7+.
Kylie Kempster

I had such friends by Meg Gatland-Veness

cover image

Pantera Press 2018. ISBN 9781925700015
(Age: Teens) Themes: Death. Grief. Suicide. Bullying. Depression. Prejudice. Love. Loneliness and coming of age issues. Homophobia. Sexuality. Sexual identity. Abuse. Neglect. Alcoholism. Domestic violence. Child sexual abuse. Self-confessed loser Hamish Day lives with his parents on a small cabbage farm in an Australian seaside town. His whole school is in shock after their top student, Charlie Parker, is killed when his car swerved to avoid a dog; his girlfriend, the also popular Annie Bower, survived the accident. Hamish, also in year 12, wasn't friends with Charlie; his only friend is Martin, a computer geek from an affluent family. Both boys are studious and conscientious but relentlessly bullied at school so it is a great surprise when Peter Bridges, one of the popular footballer boys, offers Hamish a lift in his beaten up car. A friendship develops between this odd couple, the tall, strong confident Peter and the skinny, weak, anxious Hamish who so wants to impress his new friend that he wags school and nearly drowns after jumping off a rock into the sea. "I was worried about looking like a wimp in a situation where I could have died." (p 37) Hamish is no less surprised when Annie Bower, the most beautiful girl in his year, asks him on a date. Bewildered, but hopeful, he opens himself up to love and friendship. Hamish has some rapport with Annie's survivor guilt as his little sister died in a tragic accident at home and he lives in a home filled with grief. But both Peter and Annie's problems go deeper and Hamish's introspection is challenged as his new friends confide in him and he seeks to comfort them. In doing so Hamish discovers more about himself and the people around him than he thought possible. Appearances can be deceiving and people he thought were most to be envied for their perfect lives turn out to be holding on emotionally, mentally, physically, and financially out of sheer desperation. The dark underside of country life is explored and the feelings of hopelessness and isolation felt by teenagers who don't fit in are confronting. The homophobic rage and the actions of the teenagers against Peter and Hamish are horrific to read. It is possible the author tries to tackle too many big issues in the last half of the book ending up not doing them justice but there will be many boys who will relate to Hamish's insecurities and need to discover his identity. The story requires some emotional maturity but all teens should read this, if only to be made aware of the damage caused by bullying.
Sue Speck

The story of Eva Carmichael by Gary Crew

cover image

Ill. by Paul O'Sullivan. Harbour Publishing, 2018. ISBN 9781922134103
(Age: 7+) Highly recommended. Themes: Shipwrecks. Loch Aird. Migration. Victoria. Subtitled, "The wreck of the Loch Aird", this informative, sumptuously illustrated picture book will have readers delving into the delights of the internet to verify the truth behind the tale. The wreck of the ship along Victoria's infamous Shipwreck Coast is certainly true, and many visitors stop and wonder at Loch Aird Gorge during their trip along the Great Ocean Road. Crew imagines the young survivor (one of only two) of the shipwreck, Eva Carmichael, later recalling her life and in particular, the shipwreck.
Through his narrative, Crew fleshes out the reasons why her family emigrated, details life on board the ship, and the horror of that night, her rescue and life after the shipwreck. As with the book which burst on the young adult scene in 1990, Strange objects, this is a mix of fact and fiction, so seamlessly entangled that Crew has created a credible and entertaining story about one girl's life, built up around a true event, shocking in itself, but sure to carry every reader with it.
Strange objects saw many people debating whether his hero was a true character or fictional, whether the shipwreck had actually occurred, and I remember fielding many questions about the book in schools. So it will be with this book, many will debate the reality of Eva's narrative, wanting to find a diary in the state archives, others marvelling at Crew's ability to reveal the mind of this young woman with such empathy.
Part of the magic of this book is brought by the illustrator who uses his pencils to detail the ship and its rigging, the high seas and the shipwreck. Each view of the seas brings a different breathtaking perspective to the eye of the reader, and they like me will eagerly search each page, breathing in the details, admiring the way O'Sullivan draws the seas and its animals, the cliffs and the debris left by the shipwreck. I love the image of the girl on the front cover, contrasting with her image as an older woman in Ireland at the end, and the famous Peacock on display in Warrnambool's museum.
This is a wholly satisfying historical picture book which will ensure readers will inquire further, adding to their knowledge of an incident in Australia's past.
Fran Knight

The survival game by Nicky Singer

cover image

Hodder Children's Books, 2018, ISBN 9781444944525
(Ages: 12+) Mhairi is a child displaced and desperate to return home. The world is changing around her and she is caught in an exodus as the people of Africa flee north, praying for a chance at survival now Global Warming is taking its toll.
Parentless, traumatised, and alone, Mhairi knows that if she can just make it back to Scotland, to the Isle of Arran where she was born, everything will all be okay again. But the walk from Sudan is long and treacherous and she isn't sure that she will ever be free from the memories which haunt her. Regardless, Mhairi is determined to survive, even if that means abandoning a mute boy who tries to join her. But he's more persistent than she expects, and they soon become friends. Travelling alone had its benefits, particularly when it came to crossing borders but it's clear to Mhairi that the boy has no papers. He's an illegal. But he's just a boy. A mixture of compassion and guilt drives Mhairi to adopt the boy as her brother, causing even more problems than before. Will Mhairi's determination get them home? And will they be safe there when they arrive?
Singer provides a dystopian (and quite realistic) take on increasing global temperatures and explores the options humans might have in order to maintain their current lifestyles. Preservation and survival butt heads in this novel, yet it also weaves a tale of compassion and determination.
Kayla Gaskell

The heart of a whale by Anna Pignataro

cover image

Scholastic, 2018. ISBN 9781743817629
(Ages: 4+) Recommended. Themes: Whales. Loneliness. Melbourne author and illustrator, Pignataro has drawn and painted since a young child, culminating in a career of over 40 books, often nominated in prestigious Australian book awards. Her Agatha series, like this book, The heart of a whale, has a layer of poignancy which endears the books to readers.
Whale sings his song so that the whole ocean can hear. His song helps the newly born seahorses go to sleep, his song calms the wriggling octopus and cheers the sad urchin.
But even though his song reaches all the depths of the seas, there is no song to fill his empty heart. The sea creatures hear his sigh and it travels through forgotten seabeds and sleeping turtles to seek out another whale and his wish is granted.
In spare prose, Pigantaro weaves a wonderful tale of shrugging off loneliness as the whale is able to tell of his sorrow and find company.
Despite his ability to bring happiness to all those around him, he has an empty heart and craves company.
This is a beautiful tale to read aloud and discuss with children, promoting the issue of mental health amongst younger people. The story encourages younger readers to talk about their friends and friendships and the way friends support each other.
The watercolour illustrations support the view of the whale in the water. Each page is full of blues and greys, with touches of colour, replicating what can be seen underwater. Younger readers will love recognising the animals and plants they can find on each page and cheer with the whale when he finds a mate at the end. And on the last page are facts designed to further delight the young readers.
Fran Knight

How to Ninja: Activity book by Marcus Emerson

cover image

Diary of a 6th grade Ninja series. Allen and Unwin, 2018. ISBN 9781760523824
(Ages: 7+) Recommended. Themes: Ninja. Adventure. Humour. For those who have loved every edition of the funny series, Diary of a 6th grade Ninja, then this book is sure to add to their pleasure. An activity book, it has all sorts of games, puzzles, activities of all kinds to keep readers amused.
The first five pages offer thumbnail sketches of the main protagonists in the series: Chase, Brayden, Faith and Zoe, then their opposite numbers, Wyatt, Olivia and Carlyle. Two pages follow showing readers how to draw Chase, and he tells how to be a Ninja. After that are 'spot the difference' pages, and some more art activities. The pages are filled with an array of things to do about Chase and his Ninja friends and foes, and readers are invited to answer questions, draw Ninja fashion, complete word searches and mazes.
In between are pages of articles about each Ninja, full of humour and interest to those already hooked on the series, and complete enough to hook new readers.
For those who wish to see if they have answered all the questions correctly, answer pages follow the activities, and after these are two pages depicting the front cover of the ten books in the series, and a page about the author, Marcus Emerson.
Great fun for those already fans of the books, but also designed to increase their following, the humour is infectious and will draw readers in to read it from cover to cover and enjoy the activities.
Fran Knight