Reviews

Dad by my side by Soosh

cover image

Lothian Children's Books, 2018. ISBN 9780734418739
(Age: 3+) Highly recommended. Themes: Fathers. Daughters. Relationships. Family. Love. The most beautiful watercolour illustrations demonstrate from page one the loving relationship between a father and his daughter. Dad is depicted as a very large person indeed, with his slightly too small shirt and pants, thongs and very curly beard and hair. He dotes on his daughter; they do everything together, sharing their days as they play games, read, talk, cook and try new things. But not only this, he stops his work to listen to her, he comforts her when she is sad and gives her lots of cuddles. When he goes away they are both sad, but he rings often to sing her to sleep. He makes marks on the door frame to show how much she has grown, learns from her just as much as she learns from him.
The highly humorous illustrations will tickle the readers as they spy the large man attempting to do everything his daughter wants him to do. Seeing him crawling under the table, or keeping watch as she sleeps, ready to take on the monsters that may lie under her bed will delight and endear the story to the readers, exposing some of the fears they may have. Each image underlines the bond between the two and reiterates what a happy household is like where things are shared, where the child is supported, where Dad is part of the meld.
A lovely story to read out loud, to give to children to learn to read for themselves, for children to see how much of the story relies upon the illustrations, and how much the illustrations tell the reader.
The text and images speak for themselves and make the word from the author at the end seem rather superfluous.
The endpapers recreate some of the images used in the book.
Fran Knight

The Fandom by Anna Day

cover image

Chicken House, 2018. ISBN 9781910655672
(Age: Older teens - YA) Note on book: Not suitable for younger readers. Anyone in any fandom's greatest dream is to be transported into the canon world of their favourite story and live out the events as the main character. Maybe except for fans of The Hunger Games, Game of Thrones and now The Gallows Dance. The story follows four teens who were transported from Comic-Con to the canon world of The Gallows Dance, where regular humans are looked down upon and discriminated against. Of course, then it all goes wrong; they accidentally kill the main character and Violet, our main character, takes her place in the story. The Fandom is full of tropes and cliches, but is comforting in the sense that you can anticipate what happens next. The comfortably cliched style is reminiscent of novels like The Medoran Chronicles by Lynette Noni and is pleasant to read and follow along to; however, if you like suspense and surprise, you might feel the book falls short. The only problem I had with the tropes and cliches (without giving too much away) was the death-revival trope, as it doesn't allow for emotional payoff.
Although friendship is meant to be a large theme within the story, there doesn't seem to be much true friendship displayed throughout the book, something which disappointed me. The action moves quickly once the world is established, and though you know what's going to happen as the story follows canon, the writing describes it beautifully and of course, nothing ever really goes to plan. The twists and turns keep you on your toes as you read. The teens and the audience get a glimpse at how large and deep a story's universe is and how much effort goes into creating such a detailed, captivating world.
Day gives a satirical look at discrimination and oppression, emphasising everyone's humanity and the futility of social constructs. The main character Violet is a massive fangirl and a brave but reluctant hero, whose sarcasm and wit bring a spark to the book. The story was compelling and complex, with witty twists and turns.
I would recommend this book to people who want something comfortable and easy to read, but captivating nonetheless.
Stephanie Lam

These are animals by Daniel Egneus

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2018. ISBN 9781408889909
(Age: 3+) Highly recommended. Animals. Humour. Read aloud. Movement. Sound. What a lovely way to introduce animals to young readers. A vibrant, colourful display of animals around the world is presented with verve and movement, noises and sounds for little kids to enjoy, join in, make the noises and move around copying the the traits of the animals shown.
Neatly divided into areas: woodland animals, polar, grassland, night time, rainforest and ocean, each section shows a range of animals that survive in this particular habitat. Grassland animals depicts, for example, giraffes, elephants, zebras and lions, encouraging children to make the noises of the elephant and lion, copying the expressions on their faces. Some readers may even question why these animals live in this particular part of the world, eliciting all sorts of information from the adults. Night time animals too, depicts bats, owls and wolves and children will laugh with delight trying out the noises that the owl and wolf make, while blinking like the owl or hanging upside down like a bat. Each page is brim full of ideas for younger children to take to heart: moving, making noises, stretching, jumping, howling, squawking and swinging through the trees.
This is a delightfully colour filled book of sound and movement to introduce younger readers to the range of animals that exist around us.
Fran Knight

A royal murder by Sandra Winter-Dewhirst

cover image

A Rebecca Keith mystery book 2. Wakefield Press, 2018. ISBN 9781743055243
(Age: Adult) Recommended. Themes: Mystery. Murder. Adelaide. During the Women's Australian Open golf tournament in Adelaide, Rebecca Keith discovers a silk duffle bag containing the body of one of the golfers. She then embarks on an investigation of the murder, cavorting through some of Adelaide's best restaurants and eateries, not to forget the delights of Kangaroo Island and the Barossa Valley.
Like the first in the series, The Pop Eye murder, this is an easy to read, lighthearted murder mystery, with the food and wine topping the bill for interest. South Australians will once again delight in recognising favourite restaurants and the fabulous Adelaide parklands as Rebecca follows clues to the murders, and other readers will enjoy the atmosphere and setting. It is heart-warming to see the close friendship of Rebecca and her two friends, Penny and Lisa. There are quite a few laughs to be had as they travel around South Australia.
The background to the murders is also unusual with Chinese triads, top women professional golfers and property developers on the suspect list. This keeps the reader involved following the clues while enjoying a gourmet food and wine trail. Details about the process of getting news articles published and a slow moving romance with the police officer Gary, also round out what is an entertaining read.
Pat Pledger

The case of the missing hippo by Laura James

cover image

Ill. by Emily Fox. Fabio: The world's greatest flamingo detective series, book 1. Bloomsbury, 2018. ISBN 9781408889312
(Age: 6-9) Highly recommended. Themes: Detective story. Animal tale. This is a 'classic' detective story involving the great Flamingo Detective, Fabio. He is an intelligent flamingo, with a very tall giraffe co-worker (who is not quite as clever, but he is very tall!) and Fabio is exceptionally good at solving the problem of the missing hippo. Putting together the clues and bringing the case to a satisfactory conclusion (in a Hercule Poirot revelatory and flamboyant style), is detailed very simply for a young reader, but without underestimating their desire for a good story. This is an interesting mystery - it is after all fairly difficult to hide a hippo! Young readers will love the story, and animal characters add a touch of humour.
Illustrations are scattered through the pages, done in a simple, but amusing, cartoon style, and intensely vivid pink and green pages are also randomly included. This colour explosion adds a burst of interest for even the most reluctant reader.
Highly recommended for independent readers aged 6-9, and could still appeal to an older reluctant reader as they will recognise the subtle (or not so subtle) humour.
Carolyn Hull

A pet called Nibbles by Zanni Louise

cover image

Ill. by Gillian Flint. Tiggy and the magic paintbrush. Five Mile, 2018. ISBN 9781760680411
(Age: 5-6) Themes: Magic. Pet Day. School. Tiggy does not have a pet for pet day, but she does have a secret magic paintbrush in her sock. She creates a magic pet - a small dragon, called Nibbles. This solves her problem, but not everything goes smoothly for Nibbles - after all he is only pocket-sized. Illustrations by Gillian Flint are a mix of colour and black and white and are in an appealing cartoon-style.
This is an easy to read book suited for those who would like to transition to independent readers, rather than picture books. It is not an early chapter book - there is only one chapter, but is well-suited to those aged 5-6.
Carolyn Hull

I do not like books anymore by Daisy Hirst

cover image

Walker Books, 2018. ISBN 9781406369137
(Age: 4+) Recommended. Themes: Books and reading. Learning to read. Cooperation. Natalie and Alphonse love to read together. Dad reads them picture books, Mum reads them scary stories, Grandma tells them stories about the terrible shrew. And they love all of them, and often make them up, retelling stories that they know.
Natalie is impatient to learn to read and to read a story all by herself, even able to read it to Alphonse. But given a book to read, she finds it unintelligible, and in desperation, throws it away. The writing is a lot of squiggles, looking a lot like birds' feet, with nothing in it that she recognises. Miss Bimble tells her that it will take practice, and Mum and Dad tell her to be patient. She sticks at it all week until she can read her cat book, but when Alphonse offers her another book to read to him, she finds it a lot like before, lots of squiggles. She gives up saying that her toy elephant needs to be cared for. Alphonse asks her to tell him a story and in so doing, encourages her to illustrate it and getting Dad to write the words, she finds that she can retell it after all.
A charming story of trying different methods to help children learn to read, the story will resonate with children who are in that stage where writing is a bit of a jumble. But perseverance and help from others leads to the children learning to read.
Fran Knight

Bronte's big sister problem by Mary Van Reyk

cover image

Surf Riders Club. Lothian Children's Books, 2018. ISBN 9780734417923
(Age: 9+) Recommended. Bronte is in Year 8 and really idolises her sister Carrie, who is 17. Before their older brother, Oscar, left for University, the three siblings had such a close friendship and now it feels like there is a rift between them. Lately, Carrie has been secretive and boy-obsessed and is trying to set Bronte up with Daniel; but won't listen to her sister saying that she is not interested. She also wants Bronte to do whatever she does and sulks if Bronte won't do what she wants. Bronte is feeling so lost without her sister, but her friends are encouraging and interested in the same things as she is so she has to make choices.
Bronte is in the Surf Rider Club, a group of 5 girls, (Ava, Janani, Alex, Molly and herself) who love catching waves and hanging out at the beach. When a surf competition comes to their local beach, the Surf Riders Club are keen to enter. The problem is, Carrie makes Bronte promise she will go to see a DJ with her that day. Bronte feels like she doesn't get a choice. All of the stress of it is interfering with Bronte's practising for the upcoming comps.
In the second book of this series, Bronte works through her feelings and eventually learns to talk about them to her sister. Her brother Oscar is a big help in this, though his character came across as a little too text book eg "I'm sorry, this must feel very overwhelming for you... " In saying that, this story will teach young girls to be a little more assertive, and that is a definite win.
I'd recommend this for girls of Year 4 and up who are interested in surfing, are having relationship issues within families and those with a good conceptual understanding.
Clare Thompson

Hubert Wilkins: Forgotten hero by Elizabeth Corfe

cover image

Era Publications, 2011. ISBN 9781741205114
(Age: Upper primary) Hubert Wilkins is probably not well known to Australian students although he was born in South Australia in 1888 and was quite famous in the 1920s. This biography written for upper primary age students highlights Wilkins' pioneering work studying weather in polar regions and the significance of his use of technology, exploration and leadership.
Early chapters of the book describe the young man's farm experience and the hardship caused by drought. Understanding the weather became a motivating force in his life. He became a film maker, learnt to fly and experienced the Arctic climate first hand. Each new adventure gave Hubert the skills and understanding to undertake new missions such as the study of Australia's Aboriginal people, the Inuit of Canada and Russia. The First World War battle field tested his courage and willingness to undertake difficult challenges.
Through short paragraphs and appropriate vocabulary the author presents the life of a forgotten hero whose discoveries were ahead of his time. Each page is illustrated with interesting photographs, maps and illustrations. Important background information (e.g. drought, the first movies, life in the trenches) is highlighted in brief side panels. The book's conclusion includes a timeline and glossary.
Paul Pledger

My grandfather's war by Glynn Harper

cover image

Ill. by Jenny Cooper. EK Books, 2018. ISBN 9781775592990
My grandfather's war tells us of a more recent conflict, the Vietnam War, a war where those who served are now the grandparents of its target audience, our primary school students.
At a time when the world had almost emerged into a new era following World War II, the USA and the USSR were the new superpowers and the common catch-cry promoted by prime ministers and politicians was "All the way with LBJ", Australian and New Zealand joined forces with the USA in this new conflict to stop the "Yellow Peril" of China moving south and overtaking nations just as Japan had tried to do between 1941 and 1945. Among the 65 000 troops of both nations committed between 1963 and 1975 was Robert, Sarah's grandfather who now lives with her family and who is "sometimes very sad."
Possibly a natio, drafted because a marble with his birthdate on it dropped into a bucket, old enough to die for his country but too young to vote for those who sent him, Robert, like so many others of his age whose fathers and grandfathers had served, thought that this was his turn and his duty and that the war "would be exciting". But this was a war unlike those fought by the conservative, traditional decision-makers - this was one fought in jungles and villages where the enemy could be anywhere and anyone; one where chemicals were used almost as much as bullets; one where the soldiers were not welcomed as liberators but as invaders; and one which the soldiers themselves knew they could not win. It was also the first war that was taken directly into the lounge rooms of those at home as television became more widespread, affordable and accessible.
And the reality of the images shown clashed with the ideality of those watching them, a "make-love-not-war" generation who, naive to the ways of politics and its big-picture perspective of power and prestige, were more concerned for the individual civilians whose lives were being destroyed and demanded that the troops be withdrawn. Huge marches were held throughout the USA, New Zealand and Australia and politicians, recognising that the protesters were old enough to vote and held their futures in their hands, began the withdrawal.
But this was not the triumphant homecoming like those of the servicemen before them. Robert came home to a hostile nation who held him and his fellow soldiers personally responsible for the atrocities they had seen on their screens. There were no welcome home marches, no public thanks, no acknowledgement of heroes and heroism, and Robert, like so many of those he fought with, slipped back into society almost as though he was in disgrace. While the official statistics record 578 killed and 3187 wounded across the two countries, the stats for those who continued to suffer from their physical and mental wounds and those who died because of them, often at their own hands, are much more difficult to discover. Like most returned servicemen, Robert did not talk about his experiences, not wanting to inflict the horror on his family and friends and believing that unless you were there you wouldn't understand; and without the acknowledgement and support of the nation he was supposedly saving and seeing his mates continue to battle the impact of both the conflict and the chemicals, he sank into that deep depression that Sarah sees as his sadness but which is now known as post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD).
Disturbed by his sadness but told never to talk to her grandfather about the war, Sarah is curious and turns to the library for help. But with her questions unanswered there, she finally plucks up the courage to ask him and then she learns Grandad's story - a story that could be told to our students by any number of grandfathers, and one that will raise so many memories as the 50th anniversary of the Battle of Khe Sanh approaches, and perhaps prompt other Sarahs to talk to their grandfathers.
Few picture books about the Vietnam War have been written for young readers, and yet it is a period of our history that is perhaps having the greatest impact on our nation and its families in current times. Apart from the personal impact on families as grandfathers, particularly, continue to struggle with their demons, it opened the gates to Asian immigration in an unprecedented way, changing and shaping our nation permanently.
Together, Harper and Cooper have created a sensitive, personal and accessible story that needs to be shared, its origins explored and understanding generated.
Lest We Forget.
Barbara Braxton

Sorry Day by Coral Vass and Dub Lefler

cover image

NLA Publishing, 2018. ISBN 9780642279033
(Age: 6+) Highly recommended. Themes: Aboriginal themes, Sorry Day, Aboriginal history, Reconciliation, Apology, Kevin Rudd. Two stories coincide in this beautifully illustrated picture book telling of National Sorry Day celebrated on May 26. The momentous day of February 13, 2008 is the setting of this tale as Maggie and her mother stand amongst the crowd eagerly waiting for Prime Minister Kevin Rudd to say sorry to Aboriginal families for what was done to them in the twentieth century taking away their children as a matter of government policy.
In the crowd Maggie loses sight of her mother, and in this way the book parallels the plight of those children forcibly removed. But all is well for Maggie and she is restored to her mother, just in time to hear the Prime Minister utter the words that so many have longed to hear for generations.
This is a deceptively simple story, sparsely told, one that shadows the Stolen Generation in its words and illustrations. Without over telling the tale, students are acquainted with the bare bones: that children were taken - enough to ignite many discussions and stories in the classroom as part of the Australian Curriculum.
The illustrations accompanying the text parallel the words with subtle sincerity. The sepia wash double pages show what happened in the past, reflecting the lifestyle of the groups living in fear of the men in authority coming for their children. In between these pages subdued colours show Maggie and her mother waiting in the crowd, excited by the momentous happenings on that day.
Each double page reflects the difference between Maggie and her mother celebrating with their families and the children of the past being taken. One page has legs hiding Maggie as she loses sight of mum, while the next shows the legs of the authorities rounding up the children. Readers will enjoy recognising these parallels and marvel at the skill of the illustrator, Dub Leffler, a descendant of the people of south west Queensland, the Bigambul and the Mandambarji, underscoring the events of each day
With a foreword by Lee Joachim, Chair of Rumablara Aboriginal Cooperative, a double page spread giving an outline of Sorry Day and its history, and photos on the last pages, the book offers an insight into the celebration of Sorry Day and why it was established, making it a must read for any library and classroom to initiate discussion, inform, delight and educate.
The front cover is stunning, with the colours of the Aboriginal flag subtly forming the background, the young girl focussed on looking ahead and the grasses in one corner offering a link to the past, and I love the fold out page towards the end where all the themes come together, everyone looking forward together. Teacher notes are available on the NLA website.
Fran Knight

Turtle Trackers by Samantha Wheeler

cover image

UQP, 2018. ISBN 9780702259951
(Age: 9-12) Recommended. Ten year old Isaac lives with his widowed mother in a caravan park in seaside Queensland. They are the park caretakers and the huge workload impacts on their lives, ensuring Isaac has very little free time during his holidays. His passion is for the migrating turtle species who arrive on the nearby beaches every year to lay their eggs. These eggs are at risk from marauding dogs, visiting tourists and feral wildlife. Isaac wants to be an official turtle tracker, someone who watches over the turtles and their nests, but his commitments in the caravan park make it impossible for him to fulfil his dream.
To add to the pressure, visiting travel blogger Eddie Eastwood is visiting the caravan park with his unleashed, mischievous dog Bella and it looks as though a poor review will be forthcoming . . . bad news for his Mum and her future employment with the owners of the park, the local council.
Isaac has a strong environmental passion which is evident in the story and the author uses his voice to educate about the importance of protecting turtles and the impact of pollution on the turtle population. Only one in a thousand hatchlings will survive to generate new eggs so it is important to be aware of the necessity of protecting the turtle's future.
Although this book has a strong message to tell, the story entertains and keeps the reader interested in Isaac and his hopes and dreams.
For the reader that wants to learn more about turtles, the author provides further information and links at the end of the novel.
Turtle Trackers reminds me of another of Samantha Wheeler's books Mister Cassowary, which gives an insight into the prehistoric like cassowary, while telling an interesting story about a boy and his family's past.
The bright primary colours on the jacket are appealing and clearly identify the book's focus.
I recommend this novel to 9 to 12 year olds.
Jane Moore

Being Fishkill by Ruth Lehrer

cover image

Candlewick Books, 2018. ISBN 9780763684426
(Age: Mature14+) Being Fishkill focusses on 12-year-old Carmel Fishkill who is named after a highway exit sign her mother, Keely, glimpsed while giving birth in the back seat of a car. Her life is complex and she decides that starting seventh grade in a new school is an opportunity to reshape her image, now that her abusive grandfather is dead, and her drug-addicted mother has vanished. Starting with a name reversal, Carmel becomes the tough girl, Fishkill, but her plan is thrown off course when the more precocious but equally tough Duck-Duck Farina befriends her.
The novel is dark, with moments of lightness, as Fishkill quietly 'fights' to establish an identity that is not based on her dysfunctional family. This narrative is about a search for connections and also enters the realm of the first stages of exploring sexual identity.
For me, as a reader, Fishkill and Duck-Duck seemed much older than their 12 years, and that caused a block in the plausibility of their characters.
There are flashbacks to a disrupted and disturbing life with her mother and grandfather. This is countered with Duck-Duck's mother, Molly. who welcomes her into the home.
There are many twists and turns in this novel which would keep the reader engaged. Emotions and experiences are intense and at times confronting.
I would recommend this for more mature readers of 14 years and up.
Maree Samuel

Bannerless by Carrie Vaughn

cover image

John Joseph Adams/Houghton Mifflin Harcourt, 2017. ISBN 9780544947306
(Age: 15+) Recommended. Philip K. Dick Award (2017). Themes: Dystopian fiction, Science fiction, Murder, Birth control. Years after an environmental disaster has devastated the world, killing millions, the Coast Road in the US has developed a thriving culture, where birth control is mandatory and people must earn a banner if they want to have a child. In Haven, Enid has not only earned a banner but is an Investigator, helping to solve problems and mediate when necessary. When there is a suspected murder in another town she is sent to investigate and uncovers more than she was anticipating.
Bannerless is a sometimes bleak and very different take on a dystopian future, with less emphasis on solving a crime but exploring a society that allowed it to happen. Through a series of flashbacks the reader follows the progress of Enid as she grows from a restless young woman roaming the roads with Dak to a responsible member of her community trusted to obey the laws that allow it to flourish and to enforce them if necessary. People live together in small groups, grow their own food and look after each other, putting the needs of the community before individual needs. Cities no longer exist and much of the technological knowledge that ruled the world before its downfall has disappeared. The Coast Road people managed to salvage what knowledge they thought was most important, birth control being one of the major needs.
Vaughan, better known for her Kitty series, featuring a werewolf, shows off her writing ability in Bannerless, bringing alive a different and unique take on a dystopian future. Its themes of birth control, self sufficiency, sharing and group living, as well as the ethics surrounding the murder of a loner, make it a fascinating and memorable read.
Pat Pledger

Fantastically great women who made History by Kate Pankhurst

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2018, ISBN 9781408878897
(Age: 8-12) Recommended. Subjects: Women - History, Women - Biography. Fantastically Great Women Who Made History looks at the lives, discoveries and achievements of many important women from Hatshepsut in Ancient Egypt to Russian astronaut Valentin Tereshkova. Kate Pankhurst's has an engaging and unique presentation design, interweaving fun and interesting factual information with stylish cartoon characters, bold coloured text boxes and visually engaging fonts and sizes.
'To make history you need to be brave, bold and believe in yourself - just like the women in this book.' The book begins with Harriet Tubman who helped many runaway slaves escape through the Underground Railroad between 1850 and 1860 in Maryland. Flora Drummond fought for women's equality and for the right to vote in Edwardian England, as did the author's relative Emmeline Pankhurst. Chinese Qiu Jin wrote poems, articles and gave speeches about the unfair treatment of Chinese women, in the late 1800's. She was passionate about the cruel practice of feet binding and encouraged her students to secretly rebel against the old-fashioned government rulers. English inventor Ada Lovelace designed a flying machine in 1828 when she was just twelve, and later worked with Charles Babbage on his Difference Engine.
Pankhurst travels through history, focussing on inspirational women, some famous and others who have made important contributions to women's rights, people's lives and living conditions across the arts, literature, music and world issues. Pankhurst concludes with a challenge 'How will you make history?' Fantastically Great Women who made History is an excellent resource suited to Humanities and Social Sciences from Year 2-Year 9 reflecting on women's influences in the shaping of Australia and the world.
Rhyllis Bignell