Reviews

Echo after Echo by Amy Rose Capetta

cover image

Candlewick Press, 2017. ISBN 9780763691646
(Age: Young Adult readers) Recommended. I must admit this is not my usual type of book, but a few pages in and I was hooked. I literally felt like I was part of the theatre observing the story so closely that I was an eye witness. I love the fact the novel is set out like a three-act play where the reader is drawn into this compelling story. A dream come true for Zara but with a nightmarish edge that makes the reader feel very deeply. I could vividly picture the shabby theatre in New York where the story is based. Zara gains her dream role as Echo in the Greek tragedy Echo and Ariston at the Aurelia theatre. The eccentric but visionary director Leopold Henneman ensures that Zara commits herself to the play and nothing else.
It is a tale that has something for everyone: love, mystery, a possible curse and murder. If I could have sat just reading this from beginning to end and forgetting everything else, I would have been a very happy reader. The leading ladies Zara and Eli are relatable but what made this pairing very refreshing was they fall in love with each other without the usual cliched struggle for acceptance. I felt a little like Agatha's Christie's Miss Marple trying to solve the murders that are plaguing the theatre, as the story unfolds.
I love the way that Amy Rose Capetta has woven the story, it is like coming to a fork in the road and not knowing where it will take you but having no choice but venture forward.
I found this an utterly delightful book and at last a Young Adult romance with SUBSTANCE. It may be the novel to turn around my opinion of Romance as a genre.
Elaine Grottick

Princess Hayley's comet by Rebecca Fung

cover image

Ill. by Kathy Creamer. Christmas Press, 2018. ISBN 9780994528070
(Age: 7+) Recommended. Themes: Princesses, Haley's Comet, Presents, Birthdays. Indulged Princess Hayley always gets what she wants for her birthdays. Her father cannot say no. But this birthday, her tenth, she decides that she wants a comet. She has been given an astronomy book by her best friend, Ned and the princess has fallen in love with the page depicting the comet. She asks her father to fulfil her wish, and he speaks to his Advisory Council which cannot see a solution to the problem. The princess and her friends Ned and Caa decide to catch a comet for themselves and set about constructing the most amazing contraptions to practise firstly, then lassoo the comet as it passes by. It makes for very funny reading as the trio talks to the gardener about a host of ladders joined together to reach the sky, then the cook to make a pile of meatballs with which to practise catching the comet, and finally the fishermen about having a net big enough and strong enough to catch the real comet.
Readers will thoroughly enjoy reading of the process the princess uses to achieve her aim, laughing as she enlists the help of a variety of people around the kingdom to achieve her end, and finally at the climax where she realises that catching a comet may not be what she really wants. A funny story for those new to reading chapter books, the strong characters and their single-mindedness will appeal to young readers as the princess sets about achieving her aim. Line drawings by Kathy Creamer add to the fun of the tale.
Fran Knight

Birthday Drama! by Rachel Renee Russell

cover image

Dork Diaries book 13. Simon and Schuster, 2018. ISBN 9781471173158
(Ages 9-12) Themes: Family life, Birthdays, Friendship. Birthday Drama is the thirteenth book in the very popular Dork Diaries series by Rachel Renee Russell. 'The Private Diaries of Nikki J. Maxwell' take us into the high and lows of her teenage life, friendships, frenemies, parents, bullying and her teenage crush. Presented in a notebook format and illustrated with line drawings, doodles and comic strips, fourteen-year-old Nikki's world is filled with drama, tension and emotion. Russell and her daughter Erin's Nikki are excitedly planning her ultimate birthday party with her two BFFs Chloe and Zoey; this will be the social event of the year. After lots of fun discussions they decide a POOL PARTAY - a tropical island theme at the local pool. Nikki's must-haves include a DJ, lots of delicious food and exciting decorations, with a hundred guests invited. Will this impress Nikki's crush, handsome teen Brandon?
One major problem with the expensive party plans is Nikki's lack of funds, her secret sock contains only $8.73, not quite the $500 Chloe needs for the budget. Mum's plans are also problematic, her $100 offer includes their neighbour Mrs. Wallabanger's accordion music and two ladies performing from her senior's belly-dancing class. Her little sister's offer to make the birthday cake is fraught with disaster as well. She decides to cancel her party; however, Chloe's already posted the invitations. The girls decide to retrieve the letters before they are sent out. Their hunt for the posted invitations leads to the Mail Room where the Mail Man is nearly wiped-out by three 'birthday-party-obsessed psychotic girls.'
Nikki's summer plans are also causing problems, should she tour with Brandon and the Bad Boyz band or join the trip to Paris? Luckily, her sister Miss Bri Bri's unusual flavoured dog cookies help save the birthday party in a special way.
Russell's series is extremely popular, tween readers love the excitement, drama and fun that makes up Nikki's life. Birthday Drama is aptly named and will be enjoyed by Dork Diaries fans.
Rhyllis Bignell

The dodo made me do it by Jo Simmons

cover image

Ill. by Sheena Dempsey. Bloomsbury, 2018. ISBN 9781408877777
Recommended. This is a hilarious tale of wish fulfilment gone wrong that every child will relate to and is perfect for fans of My Brother is a Superhero by David Solomons.
A funny book with plenty of set-pieces that fans will giggle their heads off at sees scenes with the characters dealing with Dodo poo and attempting to teach a flightless bird to fly. There is also a lot more going on, not least the yin-yang relationship between the cool-headed Scientific Susie and the feet-first think-later Danny.
The remote Scottish Village of Kinoussie is also awash with eccentric characters.
I would like to see more stories set here (and to find out a bit more about porridge-mad Granny Flora's backstory.
Donna Isgar

Trouble on the Farm by Chris Higgins

cover image

Ill. by Emily MacKenzie. Bloomsbury, 2018. ISBN 9781408868874
(Age: 5-7) Themes: Farms, Friends. Trouble on the Farm is a delightful easy-to-read story for the newly independent reader. Chris Higgins captures all the sights, sounds and smells of the countryside and she voices the excitement felt by young Bella and Sid as the visit the farm.
On a sunny Saturday two children who've never been to a farm before, can't contain their excitement. Since Bella and her younger brother Sid and their parents moved from the city a month ago, they've enjoyed all the new country experiences. Tom, a boy from Bella's class has invited the children to spend a day on the dairy farm.
After several changes of clothes, Bella is ready. Mum loads them up with a bunch of flowers and some iced lollies for Tom and his sister Kizzy. Magda their next-door neighbour invites herself along for their farm day, Magda is a force to be reckoned with and doesn't always listen to instructions.
Five-year-old Sid is surprised by the funny looking chickens and even more surprised when Kizzy explains they are turkeys raised for Christmas dinners. Megan, Tom and Kizzy's mother carefully explains what the children can do on the farm and where they can go. She's very specific about not driving the new tractor or riding horses bare-back. Bella's visit soon turns into a major disaster, with Magda leaving gates open, the cows escaping and an unexpected tractor ride.
Chris Higgin's adds lots of fun and drama when the runaway cows are herded into the Farmer's Arms carpark just before a big wedding. With cow poo everywhere, the bride refuses to walk down the red carpet. Bella saves the day which results in a grand entrance on the farm's shiny new red tractor and Megan's farm-style pasties are a winner at the wedding reception.
Emily MacKenzie's energetic drawings show the highlights and the dramas involved in Bella and Sid's farm day. Trouble on the Farm is an engaging story about friendship, being responsible and understanding the consequences of your actions. Young readers will enjoy reading this fun farm story.
Rhyllis Bignell

Angry Cookie by Laura Dockrill

cover image

Ill. by Maria Karipodou. Walker Books, 2018. ISBN 9781406383089
(Age: 4-8) Recommended. Themes: Anger, Friendship, Feelings, Self-worth. The cover on this book is an intense fluoro orange! It will shout at young readers from the shelf, and ironically, the central character does just that towards the reader. Angry Cookie is aptly named . . . he is fuming and really does not want the reader to keep poking their nose into his business and turning the page. However, of course we do! Eventually getting rid of the reader seems like a waste of time, so he tries to explain why he is angry in order that we understand the reason for his poor temper. A recorder playing incessantly, an embarrassing haircut, an attack on his 'cookie' body, a missing ice-cream treat all compound his ill humour, but eventually he realises that they are all symptomatic of feeling ignored and unheard. The persistent reader is of course still 'paying attention' and 'listening' so is able to restore Angry Cookie's sense of self-worth and give him a change of humour and a new way of dealing with life.
This book joins many others of similar ilk (Don't let the pigeon Drive the Bus by Mo Willems; Don't Open this Book by Andy Lee) with the book's characters engaging with the reader and almost teasing them to make a response. Young children will enjoy this almost inherent interactivity. The colourful and quirky illustrations by Maria Karipidou will also appeal, not because they are detailed, but because they are cartoon-like and most characters are food items. (Cookie's hairdresser is a banana!) Cookie's defused anger also gives an opportunity to discuss with children about their own responses to feeling angry.
Recommended for ages 4 - 8
Carolyn Hull

Wundersmith: The Calling of Morrigan Crow by Jessica Townsend

cover image

Nevermoor book 2. Hachette, 2018. ISBN 9780734418227
(Age: 10+) Highly recommended. Themes: Magical realism, Fantasy, Coming of Age, Missing Persons. Jessica Townsend's second book is a richly rewarding read, fast-paced, brimful of powerful magic, foreboding dark forces and amazing wonderfulness. Twelve-year-old Mog's life is about to change, she's beginning her academic journey at the elite Wundrous Society. Her confidence and loyalty are tested as she develops her Wundersmith powers and tries to make friends with her Unit 919 brothers and sisters. Luckily her best friend Hawthorne Swift's part of the unit, his unswerving belief in her helps during some of the most difficult times she faces.
Morrigan's left to fend for herself, as she struggles with her school life. She only has one class, the History of Heinous Wundrous Acts which frighteningly relay all the 'missteps, blunders and fiascos' enacted by former Wundersmiths. With her patron Jupiter North busy investigating the mysterious disappearance of Wunsoc members, she doesn't have any adult to confide in and help her in the difficult times. There is a dark side to the city of Nevermoor, villain Ezra Squall and his eerie Hunt of Shadow and Smoke return, holding Ghostly Markets selling the most frightening goods. A devious blackmailer is determined to break up Unit 919 and lure Morrigan away from safety, delivering her into Squall's clutches so he can use her for his nefarious plans.
Townsend's fast-paced narrative is powerful; the world of Nevermoor is wonderfully detailed and descriptive. Travelling by brolly rail, delicious feasts and the quirky, funny Deucalion Hotel characters will be delightfully familiar to the fans of Nevermoor. As we venture down Tricksy Lanes and discover evil forces at play, the author opens our eyes to the malevolent powers at play. Wundersmith: The Calling of Morrigan Crow continues to reveal the strength of the protagonist's character, her depths, insecurities and her determination to right the wrongs she encounters.
Jessica Townsend's much awaited second novel is powerful and relatable, resonating with themes of friendship, loyalty, inclusiveness, activism, happiness and humour and the power of good and evil.
Rhyllis Bignell

An absolutely remarkable thing by Hank Green

cover image

Trapeze, 2018. ISBN 9781473224193
(Age: Young adults+) A recent graphic design graduate working in New York comes across a larger than life sculpture on the sidewalk on her way home from a late stint at the office. The robot sculpture so impresses her that she rings a friend and together they name it Carl and make a YouTube video. By the morning their video has gone viral and 23 year old April May and her friend Andy Skampt are famous, not just because they made the video but because they were the first to name and publicise the sculptures which have popped up all over the world simultaneously and are now universally known as 'the Carls'. All of their training in visual engineering comes into play and Andy's lawyer dad ensures they get paid for the use of their material and all their media appearances. April begins the process of  'intentionally converting myself into a brand' p. 83 and as their fame grows so do the compromises she makes trying to stay in the front of the internet storm. One of the casualties of their fame is April's relationship with her partner Maya and it dawns on her that life will never be the same again. As it becomes more and more apparent that the sculptures are not of this world April finds that, while her audience still strongly link her with the Carls, they start to polarise into either loving her or hating her. 'People all over the world whom I had never met and would never meet hated me. Hated. And what they thought about me was completely out of my control' p. 168. As the plot unfolds April bravely tries to counter the negativity and fear using the power of collaboration and open communication with the online community, harnessing human talent and ingenuity beyond individual possibilities and beyond borders.
Hank Green, with his famous author brother John Green, and his own internet fame as a blogger and YouTube science educator understands celebrity and contemporary culture better than most and the technical side of the story was refreshingly thorough. April is an engaging narrator, wryly acknowledging the compromises and mistakes she makes but sometimes the author's commentary on the strengths and weaknesses of contemporary culture gets in the way of the story.
Set in today's globally connected world this is a relevant book for a wide range of readers, from young adults who might be warned of exploitation, to older readers who might discover the true extent of the online world and how it impacts our lives.
Sue Speck

Night walk by Alison Binks

cover image

Berbay Publishing, 2018. ISBN 9780994384171
Themes: Nature; Friendship; Connection. Set on a camping holiday in a pristine setting, Caspar leaves his tent in the middle of the night to discover the wonders of what is there. Stars in abundance, night creatures and trails, smells and solitude . . . and the wonder of the natural world are there to be discovered and enjoyed. As he reflects, he also considers what his friend will be doing on her holiday, far away.
The illustrations in this book are delightful, and although the text tries to capture the delight of camping and the exploration of nature for the child who has the confidence to leave his tent alone in the middle of the night, there is always the feeling that words cannot really convey all that is wondrous about the night in the natural world. (There is a little bit of caution in me for the unsupervised walk through the bush in the dark with a torch and a whistle, but this is evocative fiction!) The author has delightfully book-ended Caspar's story with the experience of the natural world across the globe for his friend Levi.
A book that could be added to a library collection for young readers with no difficulty.
Carolyn Hull

Mr. Bambuckle's Remarkables go wild by Tim Harris

cover image

Ill. by James Hart. Penguin, 2018. ISBN 9780143789024
(Age: 7-12) Recommended. Themes: Humour, School life, Teachers, Outdoor education. As with the other two books in the series, Mr Bambuckle's remarkables and Mr Bambuckle's Remarkables fight back, there are short stories within, narrated by students, as well as dialogue (again with Canteen Carol and Mr. Bambuckle), hand-written notes and illustrations.
Although the School Principal, Mr. Sternblast, has not succeeded in getting rid of the fabulous teacher, Mr. Bambuckle, he has managed to bring back and engage a new Deputy Principal, Miss Frost! Mr. Bambuckle decides to take the kids out to camp with the cantankerous Canteen Carol - interestingly, he tells her to provide for the kids and TWO grown-ups. This is because he happens to know that Miss Frost will gatecrash the camp!
More wild adventures follow but the strange thing is Mr. Bambuckle seems to like Miss Frost and is doing all he can to melt her icy character. Also, one of the kids has a grudge and it requires Mr. Bambuckle's skills to thwart the student's attempts to cause trouble, but he wants to win this kid around too. Will he succeed?
Donna Isgar

There's a baddie running through this book by Shelly Unwin and Vivienne To

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2018. ISBN 9781760630614
(Age: Preschool+) Recommended. Themes: Humour, Books, Robbers and outlaws, Theft. There's a baddie running through this book is a fun, action packed and engrossing story which encourages children to follow the path of destruction left by the baddie (a racoon). From page one he sneaks his way through the pages stealing different things from other animals he meets. Each time he steals something, it is a piece of paper torn from the illustration, asking children look more closely at the drawings and seeing where the torn piece fits. This encourages interaction on a different level as they must use spatial skills to see how the pieces align.
The thief leaves a trail of sweets and nuts behind him as he makes his way, and this allows the police and those from whom he has stolen to follow and catch him. When he is caught all the goods are returned to their rightful owners and he is locked up, but in tearing a piece of the illustration showing the jail, the question must be asked, how long will he stay behind bars?
The illustrations are great fun encouraging children to pick out the baddie in his mask, with his sack over his shoulder, while laughing at the disruption that he leaves behind and sympathising with those who have lost goods. The book will easily lead classes to discuss the idea of law and order, encouraging them to see what mayhem the thief causes, and how upset those he has stolen from can be. They will see that his crimes lead to jail time, but the twist in the tale gives a hint that he may escape.
I loved the cleverly torn pieces of the drawings, encouraging children to use their eyes and think about how each piece fits, and where the pieces come from. I love the endpapers with the array of characters from the story, encouraging readers to recognise and name each animal.
The rhyming pairs of lines encourage readers to predict the last word of each line, while the use of 'up' and 'down', 'above' and 'below', 'fast ' and 'slow', 'left' and 'right', all reiterate words used every day. The seemingly simple rhyme is infectious: There's a baddie running through this book, Turn the pages; have a look. There he goes, did you see? Sound your siren, chase with me (Publisher) and a joy to read aloud.
Fran Knight

The funny life of pets by James Campbell

cover image

Ill. by Rob Jones. Bloomsbury, 2018. ISBN 9781408889947
(Age: 8+) Recommended. Themes: Pets; Humour. Written with the potential for choosing your own path through the muddle of information and complete fabrication related to pets and owning pets, this is essentially a book of nonsense. Campbell obviously has a great sense of humour that would appeal to the generation that loves fart jokes and stories about poo and is mildly interested in animals. Note: serious interest in animals should automatically preclude you from reading this book, and certainly it should never be used as a source of reliable information for a school project! But this information is clearly spelled out in the introduction. The quirky illustrations (similar in style to Diary of a Wimpy Kid) would instantly reveal that this book is designed to amuse and not educate. Young people will probably enjoy the silly humour, but this is not a work of great literature, and the constant references to the disgusting things that animals do may offend animal lovers and some adults. There are certainly many times when the 'facts' are fake and the animals are the work of an active imagination.
Recommended with caution, as diversionary reading material for the reluctant reader who likes animals and who says they want a funny book. But if you want them to avoid reading material that mentions poo, bottom-burps and bums this may not be a book to put in their hands. But don't be surprised if their best friend shares it with them!
Carolyn Hull

Mirror Mirror by Cara Delevingne (with Rowan Coleman)

cover image

Trapeze, 2017. ISBN 9781409172758
(Ages 16+) Highly recommended. Red, Naomi, Leo and Rose are four misfits who become the closest of friends upon the formation of their band, Mirror Mirror. Band rehearsal is an escape for all four, giving them momentary freedom from the hardships they face in their regular lives. Red has an alcoholic mother and often absent father, Leo's criminal brother encourages him to follow in his footsteps, Rose uses alcohol and boys to numb her painful past and Naomi runs away from home to finally be free. Just as the band are coming to terms with their group identity and feel as close as a family, Naomi goes missing and subsequently turns up half dead in the Thames. The police believe that she did this to herself but Red begins to find clues suggesting that things are not as they seem. The trio decide that they must take matters into their own hands to truly find out what happened to Naomi.
A tale of determination, mystery and friendship in the face of adversity, this novel reminds its reader that they are stronger than they know and can make a difference in this world. In her debut novel, Delevingne presents realistic characters, deep emotional twists and an all-round inspiring story. Through Red, the reader is brought on a journey of self-discovery while learning some powerful messages along the way.
A beautiful yet sorrowful story that truly captures the turbulence that is our teenage years.
Daniella Chiarolli

The boys from St Francis by Ashley Mallett

cover image

Wakefield Press, 2018. ISBN 9781743055809
(Age: 14+) Recommended. Non-fiction. In 1945, six Alice Springs mothers parted with their sons, sending them off into the trusted hands of kindly Father Smith and his wife Isobel, to gain a better education in Adelaide. They were part of Father Smith's assimilation experiment: his belief that young Aboriginal children offered a high level of education would have a better chance in life. He wanted them to be proud of their Aboriginal heritage but also to succeed in the white world.
However need for greater financial support led Smith to be persuaded by the Australian Board of Missions to extend his original concept to allow for up to 50 'part-Aboriginal' boys to be included in his scheme - boys of the Stolen Generations, taken from their mothers. And while the boys remember Father Smith with affection, his dreams were gradually eroded by lack of funds and when he finally abandoned them, Smith was replaced by series of sadistic and cruel superintendents. That many of the boys were able to survive those times and go on to achieve in a variety of fields, is due more to their strength of character and determination not to be beaten, than to any care they received. They had to learn to fight to protect themselves; many found a path to respect and acceptance on the sports field. Wally Macarthur was a champion athlete, John Moriarty became the first man of Aboriginal descent to play soccer for Australia, Charlie Perkins played international soccer, many played rugby league or Australian Rules football.
They all faced racism - from being asked to leave the Balfours cake shop, to being denied opportunity to represent Australia in the Olympics, to being expected to sign a certificate of 'exemption' of Aboriginality to access the ordinary rights of other Australians. Charlie Perkins famously led the freedom bus ride visiting NSW country towns to focus attention on the blatant racism and segregation that was life for Aboriginal Australians. Yet despite all that they endured in those times, so many of the boys of St Francis went on to become exceptionally high achievers. You can read about Charlie Perkins, soccer star and activist; Bill Espie, policeman, awarded the Queen's Medal for bravery; Malcolm Cooper, first Aboriginal player to play for Port Adelaide in a grand final; John Moriarty, designer; Gordon Briscoe, history professor; Harold Thomas, creator of the Aboriginal flag; Vince Copley, Australian Rules footballer and AM in the Queen's Birthday 2014 Honours List; the list goes on. Their stories are ones of sadness and joy, loneliness and friendship, hard work, perseverance and warm-hearted humour.
Ashley Mallett's book highlights the amazing impact that the boys from St Francis had on Australian society. He would like to see their stories more widely known. A good start would be to have this book in every school library.
Helen Eddy

The tales of Mr Walker by Jess Black

cover image

Penguin Books Australia, 2018. ISBN 9780143793076
(Age: 7+) Recommended. Subtitled A hotel dog with a nose for adventure. On a brilliant Autumn's day, Mr Walker arrives at the grandest hotel in town. While things get off to a wobbly start, this charming Labrador is determined to put his best paw forward. And it's just as well because the most unexpected adventures await...
The tales of Mr Walker contains four delightful stories inspired by the real-life Mr Walker, a Guide Dog Ambassador who now calls Park Hyatt Melbourne home.
This is an absolutely beautiful book for ages 7 and up. Once trained to be a guide dog, Mr Walker finds himself as an ambassador at the Park Hyatt in Melbourne. He is an endearing dog, with likeable traits who soon finds himself popular with the guests. The book contains four heart warming stories that are beautifully illustrated. Mr Walker learns the many quirky traits of people and frequently adapts his behaviour to suit their needs.
I love the fact that the royalties from this book support the Guide Dogs of Victoria. I am sure there will be more adventures of Mr Walker.
Kathryn Schumacher