Reviews

The City of Guardian Stones by Jacob Sager Weinstein

cover image

Walker, 2018. ISBN: 9781406368864.
(Age: 9-12) Themes: London, Fantasy, Magical realism, Adventure. The City of Guardian Stones is a hilarious, entertaining fantasy caper that takes us deep down into sewers, art gallery and railway tunnels, chasing the dastardly Minnie Tickle stone thief. Hyacinth and her family and friends return for another fantastical quest to save their city from evil forces. Someone is stealing the magical heritage of London; ancient stones are disappearing from underground.
Hyacinth's family are mysteriously connected to the magical rivers that run under the city of London and the stones that hold the ancient secrets of the city. They undertake an epic journey across London, travelling with Oaroborous a giant pig wearing a swimsuit who communicates succinctly with responses written on little cards. They are also assisted by the Coade stone statues which are strategically placed throughout the city, especially the stone lion Hungerford who transports them and assists them in some dangerous situations.
The young girl, her Mom and Little Ben Franklin find themselves locked in jail, stuck in the Lost and Found Office and fighting in magical foggy conditions. Here, Hyacinth's sword and dancing skills utilising her 'Excalibrolly' prove useful fighting Minnie Tickle. Can Hyacinth and her friends stop Minnie from resurrecting the old London Bridge and stop the evil that wants to control the city?
Weinstein's epic story has a surprising array of quirky characters, strange settings and magical moments that takes the reader on a thrilling ride. His world building, architectural descriptions and unique underground places add to the excitement. Each of the main characters learn more about their capabilities, strengths and working together as a team. For added interest, photos and information of the real London sites are included.
Rhyllis Bignell

How to rob a bank by Tom Mitchell

cover image

HarperCollins Children's Books, 2019. ISBN: 9780008276508.
(Age: 11 and up) Recommended. Themes: Adolescents, humor, guilt, bank robberies, fires. When I first read the title of this book little alarm bells rang in my head thinking this may not be such a great topic to allow into a teenager's hands. However, the story is more about a young man's need to impress his first love than stealing from a bank. Fifteen-year-old Dylan Thomas is competing with annoying Harry for Beth's affections and giving her a Nepalese candle for her birthday seemed a great idea at the time. But as with many of Dylan's great ideas, his execution never seems to come up to what he's envisaged. The candle smelled awful and trying to get rid of it in a hurry when Beth's mum was on her way to catch him in Beth's bedroom meant throwing it into the bin. Great idea, unless the candle is still alight and causes a house fire.
Things turn from bad to worse when he realizes he has caused such a catastrophe that Beth must move in with her Aunt and go to a different school as the family can't afford the rent for the flat they are forced to live in as a result of the fire. The idea that he could somehow gift Beth the money her family needs gives him the motivation to rob a bank. Watching movies with his dad, who is not opposed to bending the rules when it suits him, has shown him that there are many smart ways out there to get money without having to go into a bank. In desperation to save Beth from her family's' financial woes he decides to try a few out.
Again, his implementation lets him down on several occasions providing the reader with a story that is very entertaining. Dylan is a thinker and is determined to get this right and no unfinished history homework, horrible Saturday job or nasty bank manager is going to stand in his way.
Gabrielle Anderson

The Talent Show by Delphine Davis

cover image

Mermaid Holidays bk. 1. Illus. by Adele K. Thomas. Puffin Books, 2019. ISBN: 9780143796510.
(Age: 6-8) Recommended. Themes: Friendship; Mermaids. This is an easy-to-read Friendship tale involving friends who catch up every school holiday break . . . and mermaids! Each of the four mer-friends has a companion side-kick - a marine creature that often speaks the words of wisdom that they need to hear. In this tale, the mer-girls get together to plan their mer-formance (performance) in the upcoming talent show. Sophia's bossiness gets in the way of a polished performance, creating waves amongst the friends. Will the friendship recover from the debacle? Only the voice of reason from Sophia's side-kick, Smedley, can restore what has been wrecked.
This is a book for readers of easy chapter fiction for girls, not dissimilar to many others written for this age group, but with mermaids as characters. Illustrations are simple comic style which reveals story and character details with hints of humour. There is no great complexity to the plot and young girls will recognise the playground and friendship dilemmas and solutions. There are other books to follow in the series, so this is one to recommend to the young reader discovering chapter books and reading independence. Especially if they love mermaids!
Carolyn Hull

The bug collector by Alex G. Griffiths

cover image

New Frontier Press, 2019. ISBN 9781925594539.
(Age: 4+) Highly recommended. Insects, Grandfathers, Collecting, Hobbies, Environment, Museums. When his Grandfather takes George to the museum on his favourite day of the week, Sunday, Grandfather takes the lead, pulling him past the dinosaurs, whales and mammoths to a place he likes best of all, the smallest creatures in the museum, the insects. George becomes hooked on these marvellous creatures and can talk of nothing else. He creates a backpack with all the necessary equipment and goes out to collect insects. At first it is very difficult, as the insects seem to know when he is about to net them, but he soon develops skills that see him net and trap a whole array of the insect world. He is very proud of his achievement, looking at all the insects in their finery in glass jars and bottles in his play house, but when he climbs down the ladder to go back home, he feels very alone. It is very quiet, there are no insects buzzing around the garden any more, no small creatures to look at and admire; they are all gone.
Next day in the garden he notices that nothing looks quite right: plants have wilted, trees are losing their gloss and there are no insects to be seen. Grandfather realises that George has taken all the insects from the garden and he explains just how important insects are to the health of the environment they live in. George goes immediately to his play house and opens all the doors and windows, bottles and jars to let the insects out and back into their world.
A life lesson is learnt by all in an easily explained picture book which will evoke tons of discussion in the classroom, and all insects that venture in will be watched with glee. The humorous illustrations fit the bill, with Grandfather in his tiny hat, and Darwinesque beard, George with his backpack and ever present cat, and an array of insects on every page.
I love the ease with which Griffiths outlines some basic information about the role of insects in our world, sure to be much thought about in classrooms.
Fran Knight

Gone by midnight by Candice Fox

cover image

Crimson Lake bk. 3. Bantam, 2019. ISBN: 9780143789154.
(Age: 16+) Recommended. Themes: Crime, Detectives. Ted Conkaffey is back with his partner, Amanda Pharrell, in a suspenseful, locked room mystery. Following on from the success of the first two books in this series, Crimson Lake and Redemption Point, Fox once again writes an engrossing story that keeps the reader guessing right until its thrilling conclusion. Four young boys had been left alone in a locked room, while their parents dine downstairs. When one of the parents checks on the children, they discover one of them is missing and no trace of his whereabouts can be found on the CCTV of the building. Conkaffey and Amanda are brought in by the parent of the missing child and begin to investigate what has really happened that night.
Lovers of mysteries and police procedurals will really enjoy this story, trying to follow the clues and work out just what has happened to the young boy. Amanda's abrasive personality and quirky dialogue brings some welcome relief to the story, and Fox's exploration of the joys and responsibilities of parenthood adds depth to the mystery. Ted is supposed to be caring for his daughter Lillian, at the time of the investigation, and has to call on his friend to help childmind while he leaves to follow leads, and Sara, the mother of the missing boy, is fighting her ex-husband for custody. The background of the crocodile infested Crimson Lake in Northern Queensland, Amanda's bikie friends and her stalker all add colour and vitality to a clever and well written book.
Ned Kelly award winning author, Fox, gives enough background for this to be read as a stand-alone crime story, but new readers would find that the first two in the series are well worth pursuing.
Pat Pledger

Adventure Duck vs Power Pug by Steve Cole

cover image

Illus. Aleksei Bitskoff. Orchard Books, 2019. ISBN: 9781408356838.
(Age: 6+) Recommended. Themes: Superpowers, Humour, Good vs evil. Imagine a meteor lands and the impact creates a surge of energy that transforms animals nearby into over-charged versions of themselves with powers that defy reason . . . and that is the premise to this book. When an ordinary duck, living an ordinary life in a local duck pond, (A Duck, self-named as Adventure Duck) becomes the recipient of this excessive burst of 'super' and supreme influence, he also gets to team up with a mind-reading egg (with Eggstra-sensory Perception) and a striking Neon Zebra to bring their evil nemesis, Power Pug and his sidekick, Apocalypse Cow, to their knees.
This book does defy reason, but the extremely quirky characters with their bizarre powers are entertaining. The story is filled with mildly amusing puns and expressions that will appeal to young readers. With a second book to follow, ready to incorporate Adventure Duck's talents, young readers who enjoy humorous stories will be recommending this book to their friends.
This is not great literature, and the illustrations are suitably eccentric, but kids will be laughing as they read and will enjoy the super-charged hapless superhero.
Recommended for readers aged 6+.
Carolyn Hull

Boy oh boy by Cliff Leek

cover image

Illus. by Bene Rohlmann. Quarto Publishing, 2019. ISBN: 9781786033291.
Themes: Masculinity, Activism, Racism, LGBTIQ. Subtitled 'From boys to men', inspired by 30 coming-of-age stories of sportsmen, artists, politicians, educators and scientists, Boy oh boy is a collection of biographical entries to highlight the way that different young men from around the world have expressed their strength, individuality and their influence in the world. The variety of expressions of what it is to be a man is deliberate in showing that there are many ways to do this. From Nelson Mandela, Mohammed Ali, Gandhi to Prince and LeBron James, there are many examples of activists, politicians, musicians, artists and sports stars that have changed the world in some way. Many of the men will be unknown to young readers, but do make interesting reading. There are also individuals whose fame has also given them opportunity to serve and impact the world and a number of LGBTIQ individuals whose stories of overcoming discrimination are told in this collection.
Illustrated with a Pop Art style bright design for each bio page, there is a youthful and non-realistic representation for each man depicted. This is ironic for a non-fiction biography and perhaps will attract some, and dissuade others from reading this book and may make it difficult to be used as a reference book.
Carolyn Hull

Follow after me by Allison Marlow Paterson

cover image

Big Sky Publishing, 2019. ISBN: 9781925675580.
(Age: 14+) Highly recommended. Themes: World War I; Romance; War; Family history. This is cross-generational story involving both a World War I story and a contemporary coming of age drama and romantic tale. It is compelling, romantic and sad, and yet also has heart-warming qualities. In 1916 we hear of the young girl Evie, whose boyfriend, Tom, goes to war with four of his five brothers. Sadly, only two of the young family members will return home. The heartbreak for one family is intense, and for Evie the uncertainty is also heart-rending. In a time when letters provide an opportunity to share one's heart, Evie and Tom share their lives and love despite the separation of war.
Generations later, these letters and their insights into the past, with the other family communications from the brothers, are rediscovered by Lizzie's family in an abandoned and slightly ghostly family home. Lizzie is encouraged to read the letters, but is going through some personal turmoil and contemporary challenges. Her friendship choices, social media, school and romantic life have taken a twist that threatens to create her own dramatic conflict with potentially disastrous consequences. A social encounter involving alcohol and a potential sexual assault reveals the danger to which poor choices can lead. A gentle fellow student and a protective older brother prove to be her heroes and more trustworthy than her new friends. As these two story threads are woven together, the author reveals the intensity and dangers that impact relationships can have similar elements across the generations, but the stresses of the times are quite different. Both storylines are gripping and the insights into the Anzac soldier's life are compelling.
Allison Marlow Paterson has based her World War I story line on her own family history detailed in her non-fiction work, Anzac Sons. Because of the truths of the circumstances from her own ancestry, this story resonates with tragedy. The facts of the war are well-detailed from her own research, and using her own family records and information from the Australian War Memorial. The setting of both generational tales in rural Australia is also revealing. The modern storyline incorporates many modern dramas - sexting, the dangers of choosing the 'wrong' friends, social media dilemmas, and the misunderstandings across generations. Lizzie's school visit to the Australian War Memorial in Canberra is a turning point in the book and for anyone who has visited, will remind them of the solemn experience.
This is a very readable book, and will stay with the reader for some time. Romantic and sad; confronting and gentle . . . and worthy of recommendation. Highly recommended for those who love social history, aged 14+.
Carolyn Hull

A quiet girl by Peter Carnavas

cover image

University of Queensland Press, 2019. ISBN: 9780702260025.
(Age: 4-8) Highly recommended. Themes: Sounds, Listening, Personal characteristics. Peter Carnavas's distinctive illustrations have a calming, soft and peaceful quality perfectly suited to the themes of this book. His previous publications, including The Children Who Loved Books and The Elephant, tend to encourage treading lightly on the world and stopping to appreciate the world around us, and A Quiet Girl is no exception. Mary is a free-spirit and the house seems to be full of things that she has made out of rubbish: bird feeders, wind chimes, pots and vases. She is also very quiet: she walks quietly, talks quietly and thinks quietly. 'Because Mary was quiet, she heard things nobody else heard. A dragonfly buzzing through the air. The soft sigh of the sleeping dog next door'. The problem is, Mary is so quiet nobody hears her. 'Use a nice, LOUD voice', says her dad over the racket of the blender. 'Speak up, honey', says her mum over the roar of the hairdryer. But she just can't do it, so instead she becomes quieter and quieter until it almost feels like she isn't there and the illustrations show her gradually lose colour and disappear. The story ends with Mary and her noisy family sitting down together and listening 'for all of the small wonderful things that lay hidden in the world'. It is beautiful to see them all entering Mary's world for a little while and it highlights the importance of recognising and appreciating differences and personal characteristics; she is different to the rest of her family, but that is okay. Mary's gentle interaction with the world encourages the reader to take note and revel in the wonder in the world: 'the smell of freshly cut grass . . . the tickle of the breeze ruffling her hair'.
This book is a little reminiscent of Margaret Wild's recent The Sloth Who Came to Stay in its message to slow down and enjoy the little things around us, but it is also about taking note of those children who are quieter and sometimes get lost or misunderstood in the ruckus of everyday life: a beautiful and thought-provoking message for all teachers, parents and noisy friends.  Teacher notes are available.
Nicole Nelson

Fart Monster and me: The birthday party by Tim Miller and Matt Stanton

cover image

HarperCollins, 2019. ISBN: 9780733340208.
(Age: 5-9) Themes: Birthday parties, Humour. This is the third book in the Fart Monster series (The Crash Landing, The New School). It uses simple language, perfect for newly independent readers. The content will also be appealing and relatable, even for slightly older children, making it a great series to try with struggling or reluctant readers. The series is wonderfully Australian, full of toilet humour and reflective of the everyday life of a typical Aussie kid. For those not familiar with the previous titles in the series there is a helpful prologue introducing Ben and his green fart monster who crash-landed in his yard. Luckily (and unluckily) Ben is the only one who can see the fart monster, so someone else is forever being blamed for his stench.
In The Birthday Party, Ben's whole class have been invited to Chris's birthday party and the fart monster is there too. There are plenty of party games and lots of farts being blamed on the dog. If you take out the constant farting this would just be a story of a kid going to a birthday party but add the farts in and it gives it a little more oomph. It's silly and repetitive but the jokes are just right for the target audience and it is a perfect length, layout and text for beginner readers. There are black line illustrations throughout showing the hideous fart monster, which will help to keep readers engaged.
Nicole Nelson

Me and my sister by Rose Robbins

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2019. ISBN: 9781760524456.
(Ages: 3-8) Themes: Autism, Differences, Siblings. Me and My Sister indirectly and gently looks at what it's like to live with a sibling with autism. It doesn't label the sister as having autism but her brother points out things that make them different (she doesn't use many words, likes different foods, can be rude to people, goes to a different school, doesn't get told for things that he would get in trouble for, doesn't always like hugs). The book also highlights things that they like doing together or that they can help each other with (listening to music, comforting each other, reading together, laughing together). The brother acknowledges that he doesn't always understand his sister or how other people respond to her, which is a common issue with siblings of children with autism and other disabilities. It shows the highs and lows common in any relationship, but the love between the two is clear.
The illustrations are warm and cheerful and it is a nice change to see a female depicted with autism in a picture book as it is commonly boys that feature. The author (based in England) has a brother with autism and she teaches autistic young children; this knowledge and understanding of everyday life with a person with autism is obvious and the tone of the book is empathetic and loving. This could be used as a general book about accepting difference in others but it will be much more appealing and meaningful to those who have a family member with autism.
Nicole Nelson

Baby business by Jasmine Seymour

cover image

Magabala Books, 2019. ISBN: 9781925768671.
(Age: 4+) Highly recommended. Themes: Aboriginal themes, Country, Babies, Smoking ceremonies. When a child is born, the women of the Darug community take the baby into the bush, gathering paperbark leaves, the leaves from green bushes and termite mound mud to prepare a smoking ceremony. This ceremony welcomes the new child into the community, making sure it will know things about the environment into which it is born and ensuring that it will follow the path of the community's laws. Warm smoke from the fire tickles the baby's feet making sure it is connected to Country; smoke winds its way to the heart ensuring the child knows it is cared for by Country; the smoke reaches the hands reminding the child that it takes only what it needs; smoke reaches the mouth and tongue keeping the language and songs of the ancestors alive and smoke reaches the ears making sure it will listen for the song of the bees, the baby's totem.
Each facet of the baby's life is mentioned in the smoking ceremony, passing on the laws that will make sure it survives just as its ancestors have for millennia.
This beautiful book shows a ritual as old as time - that of welcoming a new child into the community. All readers will be able to relate to this act be it in a church, temple, home, Country, as laws are passed on, customs reinforced, responsibilities outlined.
The book's digital illustrations, are simply stunning. The figures move through a wonderful landscape, with browns, greys and white predominant in the background, and keen eyes will notice specific plants and animals on the pages. The women's group collect their materials as they go, sitting in a semi-circle around the fire as the smoke curls up around the baby. They are all part of its growth, each taking part in its education into the community, the family a strong part of the child's development.
Darug words are used throughout the text, and many readers will work out what each word means as they read, and there is a glossary at the back of the book for those who need it.
Jasmine Seymour is a Darug woman from the Hawkesbury area of NSW and aims to make people aware that the Darug community is still there through her work. I hope this is the first of many stories from her.
Fran Knight

Willow Moss and the lost day by Dominique Valente

cover image

Illus. by Sarah Warburton. Starfell bk. 1. HarperCollins, 2019. ISBN: 9780008308391.
(Ages 8-12) Recommended. Themes: Magic, Witches, Time, Fantasy. Dominique Valente's debut fantasy novel conjures up a magical world, filled with witches and trolls, controlled by an evil time spell. In the village of Starfell everyone has a magical talent, some are more exciting than others. Unfortunately, Willow Moss has a simple one, she can find lost things, wooden teeth, lost glasses, and the townsfolk line up and pay a spurgle for her help. Then powerful witch, Moreg Vaine, requests that Willow accompany her on a quest to find the missing day - Tuesday. The pace picks up as Willow leaves her home town with her carpet bag and Oswin, a very opinionated kobold (a green furry cat-like creature) and ventures out into dark forests and magical towns. Journeying by broomstick, they are guided by the Storypass, and stopped by the menacing Brothers of Wol, Moreg who want to rule the world. Danger lurks at every turn, who can they trust, where will their journey take them?
The young witch grows in confidence as she travels far from home. Feathering the dragon joins the travellers transporting them up to Cloud Mountain, meeting a forgotten teller (not fortune teller) Nolin Sometimes, who reveals more of the mystery to them.
The impact of losing a weekday seems insignificant, until Willow thinks about all the births, deaths, special appointments and events that are lost, as history's course is changed. One young witch and her quite sarcastic sidekick Oswin the kobold finds hidden strengths, learn resilience and find courage on their dangerous mission.
Dominique Valente's imaginative world building, cast of unusual crazy characters, fun conversations, humorous and dangerous encounters and fast-paced actions make Willow Moss and the lost day an exciting and enjoyable novel. Middle Primary students will enjoy diving into this magical world, overflowing with witches, wizards, trolls and monsters. What's next for Willow Morse and her caustic kobold?
Rhyllis Bignell

Don't let go by Harlan Coben

cover image

Cornerstone, 2017. ISBN: 9781780894249.
(Age: 15+) Recommended. Themes: Mystery, Revenge, Secrets. Best-selling author Coben writes a compelling thriller about the death of two teenagers, Leo and his girlfriend Diana, who were found dead on train tracks. Nap Dumas, Leo's twin brother, now a detective in New Jersey, has never been convinced of the official verdict especially as his girlfriend Maura disappeared at the same time. When her fingerprints turn up in the case of a suspected murder, he is even more determined to find the truth.
Coben is a master at keeping the suspense going in a tightly woven plot that kept me reading until the twist at the end of the book. Nap Dumas was a complex and interesting character, and the exploration of his first love of Maura, adds to the plot. His investigation of secrets, those of his high school friends, his colleagues and the government and the notion of revenge make for a highly readable story, and the short chapters and crisp dialogue make it a quick read as well.
I had not read books by Coben for many years but will seek out more books written by him. I really enjoyed this suspenseful, tricky stand-alone story. A great read for lovers of mysteries and thrillers.
Pat Pledger

Shauna's great expectations by Kathleen Loughnan

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2019. ISBN: 9781760631574.
(Age: 16+) Shauna is on an Indigenous scholarship to Oakholme, a prestigious boarding school. She's in her final year and she's excelling at French and Maths, and dreams of going to Paris with her equally smart friend Jenny, before going on to study journalism at Uni. She has a great group of dorm friends, dubbed the 'ethnics' by rich country girl Keli, who gives them all a hard time. Keli has mastered the art of covert racist taunts and seems to have all the teachers' approval.
I thought the novel gave a particularly insightful expose of the frequent ineffectual response to bullying in schools despite the good intentions of teachers and the espousal of an anti-bullying policy. Shauna and her friends just have to swallow their anger, occasionally managing a smart retort.
Things start to become more complicated for Shauna at school. She's asked to mentor the latest scholarship recipient, Olivia, who is full of attitude and clearly doesn't want anything to do with her. And she discovers that her summer romance with country boy Nathan has brought its own complications...
When Shauna finds that some of her dreams are going to have to go by the wayside as she takes on the responsibility of an unplanned teenage pregnancy, the tone of the novel is strongly pro-life rather than abortion, and the drama is how to get the school to accept a pregnant student. Shauna's ambitions change, she is proud to be a good mum, friend and student, but how she is going to achieve her further study is left unclear. It seems to be enough that she has chosen her own path and has the support of family and friends.
The strength of the novel lies in its affirmation of friendship, and working through relationships to better understanding, even with the most difficult people. The friends' conversations and conflicts will resonate with many YA readers. However I am not sure why the author took on the persona of an Aboriginal girl - is this an authentic voice, or a device to distinguish this book from other school stories? You can read about Loughnan's views in the teaching notes available online.
Helen Eddy