Reviews

Brimstone by Kelly Gardiner

cover image

The Fire Watcher Chronicles book 1. Scholastic, 2018. ISBN 9781742994277
(Age: 9+) Highly recommended. Themes: Time travel, London Blitz, Great Fire of London. It is 1940 and Christopher Larkham is in the middle of the London Blitz. Seeking shelter from the bombs, he uncovers a ring with a phoenix symbol on it and finds himself transported back to 1666, the time of the Great Fire of London. Here he faces Brother Blowbladder who believe that London should burn because of its sin.
Brimstone is an exciting book and Christopher is a most engaging character. In London in 1940 he is a courageous firewatcher, managing to help identify where the bombs will be dropped and helping to put out spot fires with his mother who is a fire warden. In 1666 he manages to persuade the family who believe that he is Kit, their dead son and brother, to take their belongings and flee the advancing fire. He also bravely faces Brother Blowbladder and his cohort in the mysterious Righteous Temple and with the assistance of Master Merriman and Molly he manages to help save many lives.
Gardiner has brought together many strands, time travel, history and action, all rolled into one exciting adventure that will prove fascinating for the reader. Time travel is deftly handled as Christopher goes back and forth from 20th century London to 17th century London. The descriptions of both the fires caused by the bombs and those in the Great Fire of London are vividly and bring to life both events - readers will learn much about the history of both periods, while revelling in a well told adventure story. Gardiner has included an author's note about World War Two and the blitz and the Great Fire of London and a list of books that readers interested in the history could pursue.
Fans of both fantasy and historical fiction will really enjoy Brimstone and are sure to pick up the next two books in the series, Phoenix and Vigil, both coming in 2019.
Pat Pledger

Van Diemen's Land by James Boyce

cover image

Black Inc., 2008, new edition 2018. ISBN 9781760640781
(Age: Senior Secondary - Adult) Highly recommended. This award winning book has recently been republished with a foreword by Richard Flanagan.
James Boyce has written an enlightening early 'environmental' history of Van Diemen's Land which shows how the convicts were changed by the land and people they encountered. Instead of an arid wilderness beset by the kinds of problems encountered in early Sydney, the new inhabitants found an abundance of wildlife in the form of the Forester kangaroo and emu. Within 2 years of settlement convicts were able to live independently in the bush using nothing more than a hunting dog.
'They soon turned to native animal skin for their clothing and pretty soon they adapted aboriginal designs and learnt how to build overnight shelters very quickly and later, stronger huts. So basically, all of the essentials of life they were able to access from the bush around them. If you think of the poor of Britain you can imagine how tough life was for them in the early 19th century. Fresh meat was a very occasional luxury and even wheat, bread was very expensive. Genuine material poverty - so for the convicts that came here to be able to access the essentials of life - food, clothing, shelter, independently was an enormous boon.'
In the 1820s relations between Europeans and Aboriginal people in central Tasmania, began to change as almost all indigenous people were either killed or removed, wild dog numbers exploded, fire-stick burning ceased, emu became extinct and kangaroo numbers dwindled. This was followed by the peak of convict influx in the late 1830s and early 1840s, including large numbers of Irish and women convicts. The colony survived but the convict freedom and independence was curbed as more and more free settlers arrived.
The Appendix of the book, 'Towards Genocide Government Policies on the Aborigines 1827-38', provides a detailed examination of Lieutenant-Governor George Arthur's horrific assault on the Aborigines in north-west Tasmania, ending with their complete removal to islands in Bass Strait following roundup and imprisonment on Sarah Island in Macquarie Harbour.
The history is supported with a wide variety of primary sources and an extensive index.
It was an engrossing book, easy to read and accompanied by a beautiful cover using John Glover's 1834 portrait of Hobart and Mount Wellington, as well as photographs of the changed landscape, important identities and maps. It is also available as an ebook.
Paul Pledger

The way home for Wolf by Rachel Bright

cover image

Ill. by Jim Field. Orchard, 2019. ISBN 9781408349205
(Age: 4+) Highly recommended. Themes: Friendship, Caregivers, Lost. Assured wolf cub Wilf thinks he can do anything. He is full of confidence, itching to be grown up and lead the pack. When the pack needs to move because another animal has taken over their den, they must roam many miles, searching for a new home, through the snow and ice of the North Pole. Midwinter with the borealis lighting the night sky, they trudge on through snowfalls and blizzards. Wilf strays behind and when he recovers he has lost the pack. He has gone astray and is unsure of what to do. Setting down for the night the ice cracks beneath him and falling he is taken up by a watery unicorn who gathers him onto her tusk and lifts him onto the shore. Here she passes him over to her friend, Mr Walrus and he takes the young cub to Musk-Ox.
Each time he is passed from one animal to another readers will be excited to predict the rhyming word as they turn the page. The story is in four line rhyming stanzas, encouraging children to predict the last word of the next line, and marvel at the way the story is expressed. It makes easy reading and many of the phrases will stop the readers as they ponder the image presented. I loved the "howling of wolves" and the "wafting of fish" amongst others, and found myself reading it over again to check out the rhymes and word images.
The illustrations reflect the story, taking the reader into the cold and bleak northern Arctic, feeling lost with Wilf as he attempts to navigate the white and grey expanse. Field's use of white and grey, the dark and the shadows, is wonderful, making every reader feel alone in the wilderness with the wolf cub.
Wilf passes through a number of hands before he is reunited with his pack, and they huddle and cuddle their lost cub, welcoming him back to the pack. He is a wiser little cub.
A wonderful read aloud, this cautionary tale will be loved by all readers as they recognise the comfort of friendship and family, welcoming him home despite his bravado which helped him get lost in the first place.
Fran Knight

Morris the mole by Nikki Greenberg

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2018. ISBN 9781760630829
(Age: 4+) Recommended. Themes: Moles, Animals, Tunnelling, Adventure. Morris the mole simply loves to tunnel. And readers following his exploits will laugh with him as he finds the most unexpected of things in the tunnels he digs. Told in rhyming couplets, children will have a whole heap of fun predicting the word that rhymes to complete the line, probably learning some of the ones they like, and certainly learning to recognise alliteration as they read.
Morris extols the virtues of being underground as he sashays with his shovel, finds rich treasures, collects worms for desert and eventually digging a hole to get out into the fresh air, but in doing so, wrecks the mouse's birthday party by coming out exactly where the cake has been set upon the ground. The next time he pops up he wrecks the rabbits' garden, and then finally he finds something he cannot dig through. But will our hero give up? Never, and he digs through the bottom concrete layer of something quite unexpected. And just like Mr Toad from The Wind in the Willows finds another avenue for his adventurous spirit.
Readers will have gales of fun with Morris, watching his antics, digging with him as he comes up in the most surprising of places, causing all sorts of mayhem. And perhaps finding out more about moles in the classroom.
A book with lots of fun, and lively illustrations to complement the tale.
Fran Knight

Boats: Fast and Slow by Iris Volant and Jarom Vogel

cover image

Flying Eye Books, 2018. ISBN 9781911171928
(Age: 7-10) Subjects: Boats, Ships, Sea craft. Boats: Fast and Slow introduces in a simplified format the history of boats from the earliest rafts of woven reeds and Native American log canoes and on to boat festivals and modern sailing boats. The facts are presented in an easy to read format, beginning with a uncomplicated definition that 'boats carry people across water' and they are powered by sails, engines or human effort.
Not all boats are the same is such an obvious statement, why include it? Very basic overviews are included, without a depth of information that even young boat enthusiasts are keen to read. War boats introduces the Corinthian trireme used for battle by the Ancient Greeks. Three rows of oarsmen powered the sailing ship which had a ramming device at the bow of the ship. The seafaring Vikings built strong and sturdy longships capable of taken them across the seas to raid the Northern European countries.
Jumping to the early 19th century, we read of the Chinese pirate queen, Ching Shih, who commanded 300 ships and 30,000 pirates. Famous naturalist Charles Darwin and his sailing ship the HMS Beagle is included, with his scientific expedition to the Galapagos Islands noted. Steam-powered vessels are presented, manufactured in iron and steel, with coal furnaces to propel them across the oceans. From ancient Dragon Boat Festivals to the America's Cup, boats have been used for 'sport and leisure since the earliest times.'
Jarom Vogel's digital images sweep across the pages, the stylised boats, ships and recreational craft add interest to this historical look at seafaring history. Boats: fast and Slow is a useful resource for a Middle Primary class as a springboard into exploring the history of transport.
Rhyllis Bignell

Time's convert by Deborah Harkness

cover image

All soul's trilogy. Headline, 2018. ISBN 9780399564512.
(Ages: 16+) Recommended. Themes: Vampire/Historical fiction. Marcus MacNeil is a centuries-old vampire who was made during the time of the American revolution. This novelis split between Marcus's memories of the past in 18th century America and his presence in the 21st century with his lover Phoebe as she begins to make the transformation from human to vampire. He relives his own trials and turmoils and ultimately discovers what family truly means to him and to those he holds dear.
The characters of Time's convert were authentic to what time frame they were set in and felt realistic and likeable as they acted in ways that were true to what the novel painted them to be e.g. the mentor or the villain. Since many of the characters in this story were vampires the reader was able to see their attitudes and beliefs from a much older time and how these ideas conflicted with modern times. It was satisfying to see how the characters' relationships with each other grow and their thinking shifts to fit with the modern age as the experiences they endure shape them to be wiser and more mature or the opposite. In turn, the reader's relationship grows deeper as we see them struggle and overcome challenges which give us a feeling of being connected to Marcus and Phoebe.
The tone of the novel reads as a diary as Marcus tells us personally the challenges and triumphs he faced as a newly made vampire and Diana's a new mother and then Phoebes a newly made vampire in the 21st century. This creates a feeling of closeness with Marcus as we watch him essentially grow up in front of our eyes. The reader ends up caring deeply about what happens to Marcus and the people he holds dear in the story. The switching point of views in the story was an interesting a much-needed addition as we can see the thoughts, feelings and trails of Diana, Phoebe and Marcus through their own eyes. This was an effective way of driving the message of the story about the meaning of family dynamics and maternal relationships whilst also making it clear to the reader as each character's experience is different and thus the reader can look at the overarching theme from many angles.
The dialogue of Time's convert sounded extremely authentic for the 18th century and modern day. This made it easy for the reader to imagine what life was like in the different time frames and feel more fully immersed in the story itself. Another contributing factor to the story's allure was that each character had a distinctive voice which showed rather than told the reader the age, personality or even what religion the character was. This helped in not only making the characters more memorable but also aided in creating connections with the reader.
Amy Folker (Year 11 student)

The anger of angels by Sherryl Jordan

cover image

Walker Books Australia, 2018. ISBN 9781760650605
(Age: 12+) Recommended. Themes: Fantasy. Romance. In a world where it is a crime to speak against injustice, a jester dares to perform a play that enrages a powerful tyrant prince. The jester's daughter, Giovanna, must journey into the heart of danger to turn back the terrible consequences unleashed by her father's words - and becomes entangled in a treacherous plot to overthrow the prince. She alone holds a secret which, if made public, will end the prince's reign and liberate his oppressed people. But when to openly denounce him brings certain death, will Giovanna have the courage to speak out?
Jordan crafted an inspiring tale about the power of free speech, self-expression and the need for courage to do what is right. Self-sacrifice was a prominent theme as characters grew to recognise the magnitude of issues in their world and the importance of others. This not only emphasised the key ideas, but also prompted ethical debate, causing the readers to question whether it is morally correct to take a stand on an issue and encourage change even if it causes others pain, or to compromise to minimise the damage caused.
Giovanna was a strongly written main character whose bonds with other characters revealed the way like minds can connect. The romance in the story was innocent yet intense, with both characters fiercely devoted to each other after a short period of time. The imagery was vibrant and dynamic, with the descriptions of magic and the characters themselves bringing the story to life. The choice to write Giovanna without any magical powers while her antagonists had magic only served to emphasise the importance of knowledge and free speech, an important message in this day and age. The pacing started slowly as Jordan introduced the audience to Giovanna's world, but then sped up and reached the climactic scene at breakneck speed.
This was an interesting read, bringing modern day issues to the forefront of the mind and providing ideas and themes to reflect on.
Stephanie Lam

The house with a clock in its walls by John Bellairs

cover image

Piccadilly, 2018. ISBN 9781848127715
(Age: 10+) Highly recommended. Themes: Fantasy. Film tie-in. USA. Orphans. When Lewis Barnavelt is orphaned and sent to live with Uncle Johnathan, a man he has never met, his aunts are dismayed. But Lewis is thrilled: his uncle is endlessly interesting, a man of many talents, a magician to boot, and later, Lewis finds out that he is a wizard. And there is a mystery in his amazing house - apart from the unusual Mrs Zimmerman from next door, who cooks for them, the walls seem to tick.
This wholly engrossing story was first published in 1973 by United States' author, John Bellairs, and has been released as a film, starring Jack Black and Cate Blanchett.
The ticking walls draw Uncle Johnathan from his sleep and his prowling the walls each night wakens Lewis. Eventually they both meet during their nightly prowlings and Johnathan is forced to tell Lewis some of the story. But Lewis is having trouble fitting in at school. He hates sport and wears glasses. One boy seemed to take an interest and when this wains, Lewis betrays some of Johnathan's secrets to entice him back to being his friend. At the graveyard one Halloween, Lewis practises some of the wizardry he has been shown and releases the old owner of the house from his grave. The Izards used to live in Johnathan's house and their clock is ticking along nicely, ticking off the end of the world.
Lewis must do something to repair what he has done, and Mrs Zimmerman is there to help. This lively and engrossing book is most unusual, not your usual fantasy fare, but one that intrigues with the idea of a clock ticking within the walls of the house, spelling out impending doom.
Lewis is an amiable character with all the flaws of youth, trying desperately to find a friend in a new school, willing to do anything to keep him, despite the bullying and name calling. I will be interested to see how far the film strays from the book.
Fran Knight

Incy wincey spider by Matt Shanks

cover image

Scholastic, 2018. ISBN 9781760276959
(Age: 0-5) Highly recommended. I have to admit that I thought this was going to be just another book with the "Incy wincey spider" rhyme. Thankfully I was wrong! I have read lots of versions of Incy wincey spider but this is one that I really love. Scholastic have created an adaption of the original that children and adults alike will enjoy reading. It starts out as we all know it but then it takes an Australian twist. Incy meets animals such as a kangaroo, galah, emu and a cute little girl. It ends with a tired spider sleeping in its web.
The illustrations by Matt Shanks are fabulous, colourful and add such a vibrancy to this story.
This book has quickly become a favourite with my 4 year old, who especially loves the page with the galah. The facial expressions of the birds in the bird bath are hilarious and you can almost hear their frolicking sounds!
Another interest point within the book is the inclusion of a funny little fly on each page. This little guy gets up to lots of mischief and Miss 4 always wanted to find the fly on every turn of the page.
This book is fun, engaging and a really great Aussie addition to the many versions of the famous rhyme Incy wincey spider. Sure to be a firm favourite with all kids 5 and under, 5 out of 5.
Lauren Fountain

Pig the grub by Aaron Blabey

cover image

Scholastic, 2018. ISBN 9781742769691
(Age: 4+) Highly recommended. Themes: Dogs. Bath time. Smells. With wonderful words that rhyme with "rotten" and "rank" and "muck" that will bring lots of laughter from young readers, Blabey shows Pig the pug's antics as he does everything he can to avoid being bathed. He is the smelliest dog around, known for his loathsome habits shown in some detail in the book and readily recognised by the audience. He scrapes his bottom along the ground, rolls in the mud, drags things from the bin, licks up flavours long past their use by date, loves playing with poo, sniffs other dogs' bottoms and even drinks from the loo.
All these gross habits will resonate with kids as they read, screaming out words which reflect their disgust at Pig's habits.
So when mum decides it is time for the bath, Pig does all he can to avoid the torture. He gallops through the house, avoiding capture at every turn until, armed with a wrench, he turns the water off in the bathroom.
Kids will applaud his inventiveness but the action causes the water to explode from the wall, making his having a bath inevitable.
Sitting in the bath, Pig has his revenge, because even here he can cause mayhem with a smell.
A wonderful new story about Pig the pug, Blabey invests his little dog with such mischievous looks that everyone will be entranced by him. The looks on his face are priceless, Blabey able to give a knowing look on that pug face with absolute conviction.
Blabey's illustrations, acrylic with pen and pencil, are a delight from the mud pawed endpapers, to Pig's pink shower cap, the overturned bin and the knowing looks of the pig's companion - each page bringing a fresh look to peruse and look at more closely. The use of different sized font, italics and white space make reading this out loud a treat, and younger readers will adore predicting the next word in the line, after they have finished laughing.
Fran Knight

Leaving the Lyrebird Forest by Gary Crew

cover image

Ill. by Julian Laffan. Lothian, 2018. ISBN 9780734418432
(Age: 9-12) Highly recommended. Themes: Lyrebirds, Friendship, Coming of age.
"Are you lonely here?" her mother asked. "Never," Alice said. "Not while I am friends with the lyrebird".
Leaving the Lyrebird Forest is a poignant and lyrical story about friendship, family and growing up in the bush. Alice Dorrit lives with her artist parents in a small house surrounded by bushland. Set in the 1930s, the family live a self-sustaining and simple life. Alice walks three miles to school and her family drive their Model T Ford to the nearby town one hour away to sell their artworks and pick up supplies. When Alice turns three, a young male lyrebird begins to visit, knocking and tapping on her bedroom window. She awakes every second morning to visits by Birdy; Dad builds a platform for him and Alice feeds him grubs and worms. Alice and Birdy build a special relationship; she teaches him to respond to her calls and mimic sounds.
Alice befriends Mr Brown a lonely widower who lives on an adjoining property, and she discovers that he loves the forest and wildlife as much as she does. The mystery of the timing of Birdy's visit is solved as well. As Alice grows up, she knows her future lies in a different direction, and she must leave her family friends and much-loved lyrebird for her future schooling.
Award winning author Gary Crew's beautifully descriptive novel captures the lush forest settings, heart-warming relationships and special bond of Alice and her wild bird. Julian Laffan's impressive woodcuts add depth, dimension and character. Leaving the Lyrebird Forest showcases a wonderful synergy between author and artist.
A wonderful story to share with readers in the Middle Grades with themes of friendship, acceptance, caring for the environment concerns and coming of age.
Rhyllis Bignell

A Winter's Promise by Christelle Dabos

cover image

The Text Publishing Company, 2018. ISBN 9781925603828
(Age: 12+) Recommended. Themes: Fantasy. A mix of misfit and misunderstood genius, Ophelia possesses two special gifts: the ability to read the pasts of objects and to travel through mirrors. Her peaceful existence on the ark of Anima is interrupted when she is promised in marriage to Thorn, a member of a powerful clan from a distant ark, the cold and icy Pole. Ophelia must follow her fiance to the floating city of Citaceleste, where nobody can be trusted. In the company of her inscrutable future husband, Ophelia realises she is a pawn in a plot that will have consequences not only for her but for her entire world.
Dabos weaves a story of politics and manipulation in which the stakes are heightened by the fantastical setting and the characters' magical abilities; however, the story's messages still ring true for our society. The clever use of mirrors as a metaphor highlighted the need to search for truth in a society filled with subterfuge, manipulation, incredibly complex relationships, and social dynamics. The rich imagery was delightfully whimsical and was detailed enough to make the scene feel intimately real.
The main character Ophelia stands out in her mannerisms and attitudes; an unlikely protagonist at times, but as a mirror walker with a thirst for truth, she suits the story and grows along with it. The growth and development of her and many other characters in response to the trying times endured is thought provoking, providing a glimpse into the inner workings of our own society and how we as humans respond to pressures.
The pacing of the novel was overall steady, but sometimes slowed and became sluggish due to the long building of a revelation, or raced by as the characters whirled from place to place and emotion to emotion.
It was a great read with a wonderfully twisty plot as Ophelia unravels the secrets hidden from her. While the revelations were never expected, they always reinforced the poisonous nature of deceit and the need for candour.
This novel was a compelling analysis of society and gives rise to many questions about human nature.
Stephanie Lam

And the ocean was our sky by Patrick Ness

cover image

Ill. by Rovina Cai. Walker, 2018. ISBN 9781406383560
(Age: 14+) If Patrick Ness was to write a fractured fairy tale then this is it. It is the story of Moby Dick but turned completely upside down and inside out. The protagonist is 'the devil himself' the elusive Toby Wick who travels the ocean on a man ship.
In this story, the whales are the hunters and man is the prey. The whales travel the beneath the ocean in upside down ships led by captains who are supported by their crews of apprentices and 'sailors'. The crew on this ship is led by Captain Alexandra and one of her apprentices asks the reader to call her 'Bathsheba' (not her real name but is a biblical reference) and we see this tale unfold through her eyes.
The hunt for Toby Wick is cruel, bloodthirsty, and appears to be driven by a myth or legends of the past where the only reason for being is to avenge the deaths of those before them. In Bathsheba's case, it is her mother's death that drives her hunt.
Bathsheba is not as ruthless as her captain Alexandra even though the memory of her mother's death haunts her and this is depicted through the relationship she has with a human male prisoner, Demetrius, held captive on their ship. Captain Alexandra believes Demetrius holds information to where they can find Toby Wick and instructs Bathsheba to do whatever necessary to extract the information out of him. Demetrius knows he is doomed to die by the hands of the whales whether he gives the information or not.
The ending comes to a crescendo where we see the results of the whale's quest, of Bathsheba's relationship with Demetrius and the final confrontation with Toby Wick.
In Patrick Ness style, it is a dark and graphic story and supported perfectly by the illustrations that enhance the story.
Gerri Mills

Maddie's first day by Penny Matthews

cover image

Ill. by Liz Anelli. Walker Books, 2018. ISBN 9781925381351
(Age: 4+) Highly recommended. Themes: Schools, First day, Friends, Family. Before Maddie's first day at school, the family has prepared her for this big event, buying her uniform, buying a new backpack and filling it with new pencils, an art smock and a water bottle. Into this backpack is also her blanky, added once her parents were not looking. On the day, Dad makes her lunch, and she says goodbye to Mum. Once at the school gates with Dad, her tummy starts to wobble as she sees the number of other children, and not one that she knows. She puts her backpack into her locker, but takes out her blanky as she does. Other children see her and are rude about her actions, and when she sits with the group they tell her that the blanky should be left at home. But one of the group, Charlie takes her to the lockers where he shows her his backpack and inside is his blanky. The two remain together for the rest of the day, playing, learning, reading and drawing, and when Mum collects Maddie, she can tell her that she had the best day ever. At home that night, blanky is put into a drawer where it belongs.
A charming story of learning to fit in, of facing fears, of finding friends will appeal to all children. The first day jitters is a shared concern and this book allows younger readers to think about and discuss their qualms about going to school for the first time. Being involved in anything for the first time is always accompanied by a certain amount of concern and the skills learnt through this book will help children see that there are many first times and friends and family will support and share those concerns.
The soft illustrations, created with mixed media, draw the children's eyes to things they recognise, comparing Maddie's experiences with their own. Readers will love the detail, Maddie's house, her backpack, the walk to school, the view of the school yard, the classroom. Each page shows a view both known and different and readers will enjoy the visit that each page offers. I love the classroom photo at the end showing the range of children within the group.
Maddie's first day offers a range of things to discuss in the classroom, fears, friendship, bullying, first days, and being in a new school.
Fran Knight

Splat the Fake Fact! by Adam Frost

cover image

Ill. by Gemma Correll. Bloomsbury, 2018. ISBN 9781408889503
(Age: 8+) Splat the Fake Fact is a puzzle activity book filled with information that has escaped from popular author Adam Frost's Amazing Fact series. He encourages you to splat them, doodle on them or even lasso them! After the disclaimer is signed, he asks that you take any measure needed to completely obliterate the wrong facts. Which Barmy Beasts has Frost created, is it the bone-eating zombie-worm, the Javanese Tree Sheep or the Raspberry Crazy Ant. Luckily the answers are easy to find. For those who love fart facts and gross jokes there are plenty. There is a vast array of weird, wacky and unusual information on topics like Mad Monarchs, Camel Claptrap, Killer Creatures and Leonardo's Lab.
Guess which Surreal Sports is an imposter! Is it Worm Charming, Toilet Racing maybe Wife Carrying? There are disgusting facts about snot, vomit, ridiculous rules and exploding underpants. Frost's fake facts are fun to share, sometimes the most obvious answer is incorrect!
Gemma Correll's cartons, doodles, diagrams and crazy characters add to the humour of Frost's fact collection.
This is a fun activity book with plenty of opportunities to embellish, lasso, draw, solve the codes, decipher hieroglyphics and identify the truth.
Rhyllis Bignell