Reviews

How to train your dragon written and ill. by Cressida Cowell

cover image

Hodder Children's Books, 2019 (c2003). ISBN: 9781444950380.
(Age: 8-12) Recommended. To become a Viking hero it was a tradition of the Hooligan Tribe to undertake the dreaded Dragon Initiation Programme. Failure meant banishment from the tribe forever.
The unremarkable Hiccup, the son of Viking Chieftain Stoic the Vast, and a member of the Hairy Hooligans, must capture a sleeping baby dragon from the cave in Wild Dragon Cliff, preferably without awakening the mass, take it back to the village and train it to obey and catch fish for him. No easy task.
Hiccup and his little dragon, Toothless, are scorned and bullied by other members of the gang. He has great difficulty training his reluctant dragon, but patience pays off and Toothless eventually proves to be very heroic when most needed.
All the characters have unbecoming names such as Snotlout, Thuggery, Baggybum and Gobber, who is a six-and-a-half foot giant with a mad glint in his one working eye and a beard like exploding fireworks.
The teenage Hooligans and their counterparts, the Meatheads, initially clash in fierce rivalry. A dreadful crisis threatens the entire village and the 'Big Drums' summon the two teams of boys, who must work together to overcome two humungous dragons, causing spectacular havoc.
Brave Hiccup, the only person who can converse with dragons, devises a remarkably clever plan and endures a mindboggling experience with Green Death and, with Toothless helping, struggles to outwit the monsters, to avert a catastrophe.
Joan Kerr-Smith
Editor's note: Review from earlier edition.

The flying orchestra by Clare McFadden

cover image

UQP, 2019. ISBN 9780702249297
(Age: 4+) Recommended. Themes: Music. Orchestras. A windy day in Brisbane sees a flying orchestra hit town. The image on the title page shows a lad watching as the orchestra blows in, heralding a story full of magical touches. Some poignant, others full of laughter, the music played by the orchestra hits the right tone as it creates a background symphony to the everyday corners of all of our lives. Each page presents a different aspect of our lives, missing the train, welcoming someone home at the airport, when a baby is born or someone lies awake all night, thinking. Others are at the beach or in the park, cooking for six or watching the dawn, and each time music can be heard; an orchestra or solo violinist, a percussionist is playing somewhere on the page, a soundtrack to our lives.
McFadden's illustrations are vague and ethereal, sometimes almost out of focus but each capturing the spirit of the words and its music, as a slice of life is presented. I particularly loved the image of the man missing the train. What a story could be evinced, with his sad look, holding a bag with a bunch of flowers, the grey and fawn colours of the neglected railway station reflecting his mood. (With Bach's 'Chacomne' playing) And the image of the orchestra playing on the escalator in a shopping centre, people watching as they ride up, but one man stopping, leaning against the rail, intent on hearing the music. (Elgar's 'Nimrod Variations' here) Readers will love spying the orchestra on the pages and recognising the different instruments, hearing the music as each page is mused over. Teachers will be able to introduce instruments to the class, having them hear how each sounds and what sort of emotion it elicits.
I listened to some of the tunes on the playlist at the end of the book and was astounded at how closely they recalled the images presented in the book. What a wonderful class reading this would be with the music playing in the background. Winner of the CBCA 2011 Crichton Award, this is the first time is has appeared in paperback.
Fran Knight

Happy camper by Shamini Flint

cover image

Ill. by Sally Heinrich. The Susie K Diaries. Allen and Unwin, 2019. ISBN 9781760528287.
(Age: 8-12) Recommended. Themes: Camping. Problem solving. Susie K really, really does not like camping. What she does like is her skeleton, Bones, the school goldfish, her own company and reading. So, when the camping trip approaches, she is far from a 'happy camper'. But her parents think it will be so wonderful. When she finally is on the trip, there is only one other person who is even less suited to camping than herself - Clementine, the school glamour queen. Camping begins to become less awful for Susie K until she gets lost with Clementine. It takes all of Susie's problem solving and book-reading skills to get them out of the 'jungle'.
Shamini Flint has again created a wonderful character that will endear herself to young readers. Previously loved for her Diary of a . . . sports no-hoper series, this new series with a female character will be a hit with those who love the odd-ball character and the quirky cartoon style illustrations by Sally Heinrich. There is minimal text and the reading skills required are also suited to the reluctant reader.
Carolyn Hull

The lost girls by Jennifer Spence

cover image

Simon and Schuster 2019. ISBN 9781925791372.
(Age: Senior secondary - Adult) Themes: Loss. Time travel. Families. Choices. When Stella makes her way home to the Sydney waterside suburb she and husband Richard have lived in for forty years, it soon becomes apparent that all is not as it should be. She finds herself transported back in time twenty years to 1997 when the apartment she now lives in is still undeveloped and her daughter who had died at the age of 16 is still alive. Not knowing what else to do she presents herself at the house they used to live in and is taken in as the long lost Aunt Linda who disappeared fifty years ago, also at age 16. Stella convinces herself that the time shift happened so she could change the course of her daughter's life and avert the tragedy of her overdose but as she tries to exert her influence on the family she finds it is not possible to direct that influence without affecting others. Her own mother knows immediately that Stella is not Linda, her sister, and Stella gets involved with finding out what really happened to Linda while forging new bonds with her mother. As time in 1997 passes for Stella she begins to doubt her own shifting memories and starts to write them down in a notebook she finds in a drawer, referencing Doris Lessing's The golden notebook. Towards the end Stella's grip seems to be slipping and her behaviour more extreme. For older readers there is a gentle nostalgia to indulge in while reflecting on the course of life and the yearning for lost loved ones. Anyone who can remember the events of 1997 onwards will enjoy the evocation of that time and the tantalising idea of going back to change our own history.
Sue Speck

The Ice Monster by David Walliams

cover image

HarperCollins Children's Books, 2018. ISBN: 9780008297244.
(Age: 8-13) Highly recommended. Themes: Mammoths; Humorous Fiction; Orphans. David Walliams writes in a style that would make Roald Dahl proud! Characters are quirky, some of the adults are Dahl-esque and unpleasant and the plot is fanciful and yet wholly appealing. In this book, a poor orphan named Elsie rescues the Frozen Ice Monster (the extinct Woolly Mammoth) from his frozen Museum display - creating an extreme resuscitation involving a home-made balloon, lightning and copper wire! With the help of the extremely dipsy Museum cleaner, Dotty, she demonstrates incredible thinking skills and ingenuity to make the escape with her new friend, 'Woolly', safe from attack by predatory adults. The care that Elsie shows to her fellow orphans, to the big Woolly Mammoth and for her new friend Dotty and an entourage of aged soldiers is endearing and ultimately very rewarding. (Queen Victoria thinks so too!)
This book will be devoured and loved by Primary aged readers and can certainly be recommended to lovers of Walliams and Dahl. The humour and warped history will satisfy their desire for a 'funny story' that is entertaining. The onomatopoeia scattered through the story also adds an auditory and visual highlight for younger readers.
Highly recommended for readers aged 8 - 13
Carolyn Hull

Mr Bambuckle's Remarkables on the lookout by Tim Harris

cover image

Ill. by James Hart. Penguin, 2018. ISBN: 9780143793144.
(Age: 9-12) Recommended. Themes: Missing persons, Teachers, Camping. Tim Harris continues the humour, enjoyment and excitement in this fourth story of Mr Bambuckle and his wild class from room 12B. Mr Bambuckle's Remarkables on the lookout begins with a roll call that includes the students' names, likes, dislikes and introduces the Wu twins.
Imagine taking this class on camp! Mr Bambuckle's style of learning is more laid back, he values creativity and individuality whilst Assistant Principal Miss Frost is a stickler for discipline, rules and procedures. When Vex Vron who loves cars and dislikes everything else, disappears on the final day of camp, the two teachers approach the search in two totally different ways. The teachers decide to keep Vex's disappearance a secret, so the school and his parents don't know he's missing.
Creative fund-raising, taxi rides across town, following unicycle tracks, checking supermarket security footage, the pace picks up as the student detectives follow the clues. It's a creative dance, hiding their undercover activities from Mr Sternblast the principal. Magical batons, orchestra conducting, even a romantic story, this is a rollercoaster ride.
Standing out from the narrative are Harris's use of visual storytelling, phone messages, conversations with cranky canteen Carol, notes passed around the class and a list of 'dos' and 'don'ts'. Jokes, witticisms and snappy dialogue make this an amusing read. What stands out is Mr Bambuckle's unique style of teaching, his care of the students and his valuing of their strengths. This all adds up to an exciting junior novel just right for readers aged 9-12.
Rhyllis Bignell

The anger of angels by Sherryl Jordan

cover image

Walker Books Australia, 2018. ISBN: 9781760650605.
(Age: 12+) I have never read a book by Sherryl Jordan before and was given this by a family friend. I originally was skeptical about whether or not I would enjoy this book, as it is not what I would usually read. It is a historical fantasy/romance that involves magic and mystery and it tells the story of Giovanna who is the daughter of a court jester. During a day in court she meets a young man, Raffaelle who is a hunchback and has just arrived from the opposing tyrannical city of the city that she lives. Raffaelle knows how cruel the prince is and has seen what he can do to those who offend him. Together they watch Giovanna's father performing a play that would enrage the tyrant prince, and this play will in turn cause terrible consequences towards innocents when the prince finds out about it. After learning about a secret that could destroy the tyrant prince Giovanna must decide what to do with the information.
This was an interesting book, the plot was compelling and I was eager to complete this book and find out what was going to happen next. The character development is well done and I read on as the relationship between Giovanna and Raffaelle grew.
The Anger of Angels is a book with a message of hope and shows us anyone can have the strength to act towards what you believe in or love.
Hoop Porter age 17

Bizz buzz boss by Natalie McKinnon

cover image

Ill. by Margaret Tolland. Starfish Bay Children's Books, 2018. ISBN: 9781760360566.
(Age: 4+) Themes: Insects, Gardens, Bees, Cautionary tales. This is a fascinating look at the role of each of a number of insects and other creatures in the garden (ladybird (bug), spider, bee, worm and skink). This cautionary tale reminds readers not to be insular and self absorbed, to check what is happening around them and certainly not to brag about their abilities. The spider in the garden, curled up in her leaf, watches the bee as it darts and buzzes around the flowers, collecting pollen for the hive.
As she goes about her work, she repeats a similar refrain, 'My work is important you see. I collect pollen to take to my hive. No one works as hard as me.' Several of the other creatures in the garden come nearby but she brushes them aside using the same lines but with a second line that reflects the work she does. So when interrupted by the worm she tells him that she collects pollen: when it is the ladybird who interrupts she tells her that she sprinkles pollen on each flower: with the skink, she reminds him that the pollen helps the fruit grow. Each time the bee is showing the reader what the work of a bee is in every garden, and how important it is to our survival.
But the other creatures are a little tired of her; she is condescending in her retorts that she is the one working, seemingly the only one! and the creatures seek help from the little spider. She uses her skills in the most appropriate way to let the bee know how useful every member of the garden community is.
A cunning tale about inclusivity and interdependence, children will love the climax of the story as the bee learns more about her surroundings, and sees she is not alone in her usefulness to the garden.
Starfish Bay Children's Books began in Adelaide in 2014 and more information about this publisher can be found here.
Fran Knight

Wrestle! by Charlotte Mars, Maya Newell and Gus Skatterbol-James

cover image

Ill. by Tom Jellett. Allen and Unwin, 2019. ISBN 9781760296810
(Age: 4+) Highly recommended. Themes: Families. LGBT. Toys. Mardi Gras. Sydney. What does a parent do when their child takes up a hobby or interest they dislike? In this funny take on a well known family situation, the three authors and the illustrator are able to show a resolution for this perennial source of disharmony, one that involves all members of their family resolving the issue to everyone's satisfaction.
Gus can't wait for Mardi Gras when he and his sister, Rory, get to dress up. This year, Gus wants to dress up as a wrestler. His mums are a little taken aback; they worry that he thinks that this is what it is to be a man, a popular man, a smart man. They offer alternatives but Gus is determined, clutching his wrestling hero dolls. He play wrestles with Rory which ends in tears, his mums again concerned that he is developing some thoughts that they do not like. But that night, Gus dreams of wrestlers wrestling each other to the ground and hurting each other. This is not what he wants to do at all! So he comes up with a resolution, discussing it with his mums and sister, Rory, so that by Mardi Gras they have developed an altogether different style of wrestling and march together at the Mardi Gras with the crowds.
A delightful tale of a boy developing his image of what it is to be male, supported by his parents, to see that there is another side to the idea of wrestling, that it can be done with love and humour, with all the family involved.
Jellett's wonderful illustrations show a warm involved family, full of love and care, discussing and resolving issues, being together. Children will love looking at the details he includes in his pictures, picking out the nods to Sydney, all the people at the Mardi Gras, and the array of toys in the back garden.
Fran Knight

The ember blade by Chris Wooding

cover image

Gollancz, 2018. 824 pages. Paperback. ISBN 9781473214859.
(Age: 15+) Recommended for advanced young adult readers. Two young boys living in an occupied Kingdom, are fighting to recover a stolen treasure of their people. The ember blade follows Aren and Cade, two young boys who are swept from their home village and sent to work as slaves in the prison mine. In a moment, their entire world is brought crashing down around them. Still, it isn't until they escape into the world beyond the prison walls that their epic adventure truly begins.
The strongest theme of this story is that of the brotherly bond between the two friends, shown through their lively banter and the actions that they take to protect one another. There is a strong sense of disbelief portrayed by Aren. Aren has always seen himself as the hero of the story and struggles to come to terms with how he can be wronged, even when he believes that he has done everything right. Cade has always been resentful of the Krodan people, but it is Aren who is affected most.
Wooding's writing is suspenseful and detailed, constructing beautiful mountainous landscapes, filled with medieval terrors and the cruel and unjust rulers of the occupying Krodan people. The story is filled with edge-of-your-seat action, and excellent, humorous dialogue between the characters. The magic in the story was the use of druidic arts, founded on faith in the Aspects (the Gods of the Ossian people) and an understanding of nature. It was an interesting twist on magic, and one that I found to be well constructed. The ember blade reads like an Arthurian classic, which as huge fan of Arthurian legend, I certainly enjoyed. A brilliant start to the trilogy.
Jake Morgan, Unley Libraries

Stephen Hawking by Maria Isabel Sanchez Vagara

cover image

Ill. by Matt Hunt. Little people, big dreams series. Frances Lincoln, 2019. ISBN 9781786037329.
(Ages: 6-10) Recommended. Themes: Physicists. Biographies. 'However difficult life may, there is always something that you can do and succeed at.' Stephen Hawking's life was truly amazing and this Little people, big dreams biography opens up his life and scientific endeavours to a younger generation. Vagara presents the key facts, milestones, accomplishments and personal struggles in an enjoyable and relatable style. 'Children are sponges absorbing the world around them,' is her impetus for writing these biographies. Hawking's life is pleasingly portrayed by Matt Hunt's crisp, linear digital illustrations where dark skies shimmer with stars, dark and lighter tones shape the setting and simple stylised characters show stages of life.
Young Stephen was born during World Ward II in Oxford, England, to a family who loved science and encouraged education. His nickname at school was Einstein, he even built a computer from clock workings and an old telephone. His passion was studying the universe and he studied cosmology at Oxford University. When diagnosed with ALS, a neurodegenerative disease he determined to study the stars rather than be limited by his condition. Vagara presents this information with a simplicity suited to younger readers.
Hawking's brilliant mind turned to the study of black holes, where he discovered tiny lights escaping from them, named 'Hawking radiation' in his honour. Utilising a robotic voice, he dictated his scientific books and helped the world understand the universe. A comprehensive biography concludes this picture book, just right for students to begin researching. Vagara's Little people, big dreams series opens up children's eyes to inspirational, authentic and unique world changers.
Rhyllis Bignell

Suitcase of dreams by Tania Blanchard

cover image

Simon & Schuster, 2018. ISBN 9781925596168.
(Age: Adolescents - Adults) Themes: Immigration. Germans in Australia. Sydney. In 1956 a young couple arrive in Australia by ship, ready to begin a new life together, far away from their own country, Germany, that has been suffering the woes of the post-war period, the deprivation, loss of hope and lack of opportunity. This is Erich's second marriage and he is determined to make his new wife, Lotte, happy, by moving to a new country to begin their lives together in the 'new' world. The story reflects the European experience of the post-war period, the idea of fleeing one's country to begin a new life and to make a fresh start in a safe place.
This intriguing story tells us a narrative of a young family with an earnest desire to make a new life in a country far away from their own tired, devastated homeland. We are made aware of the deepest desires and hopes of the couple, and we gain a sense of being so caught up in their story that we are embraced by their little world. Uplifting and honest, this narrative places us firmly in the time and place of Australia in the 1950s as it recovers from the war years, coping with the needs of the returned soldiers, many of whom are psychologically damaged, and welcoming the refugees from the 'old world'. Arriving full of hope, but fearful of acceptance, having to learn a new language, and to settle without their own wider families, the new arrivals are determined to put aside the tragedy, the terrible memories and the prejudices of the old world, wishing to rebuild their lives.
There are many setbacks, and nothing is easy for this young couple, but their love and devotion to one another, and their children, enables them to cope. They experience some terrible things and go through hard times, but eventually it all seems to be coming together. Life begins to look good, and their positive outlook seems to support them and their family. When tragedy strikes, however, they are devastated, barely able to cope and terrified of everything collapsing around them. They survive, but things change and they find that they have to adjust, and they find the strength to do so.
In this story the characters are vividly depicted, the story is fresh and vibrant, the narrative drawing us into the lives of the characters, their hopes, dreams, achievements and their tragedies. Suitable for adults and adolescents, this fine book embraces the historical events of the Second World War and its aftermath, and celebrates Australia's welcoming of the new citizens with friendliness and support, defining what it is to be Australian then and now. It is most suitable for young adults and adults, particularly recreating the world of that time for older readers. It is the sequel to The girl from Munich.
Elizabeth Bondar

Der glumph went the little green frog ill. by Matt Shanks

cover image

Scholastic, 2019. ISBN 9781742993676.
(Age: 4+) Recommended. Themes: Frogs. Humour. Australian animals. A version of the song on which this picture book is based showing the noise made by a frog can be found on Youtube. Scholastic takes it one step further, including an array of Australian animals and the imagined noises they make when unobserved. The echidna makes the sound of scritch scratch, snuggy snug hug go the penguins, the roo, hop hop hop and the little pink bird (galah) goes squwark squwark. Each animal is shown doing what it does enabling readers to recognise the characteristics of that animal as they sing along.
The simple tune is well known and children will easily adapt the new lines to the song, although several may need tweaking, and readers will learn them quickly to sing along with the teacher. Actions will be added, making this a book full of fun and laughter in the classroom. Shanks' illustrations add to the merriment, despite the girl's face being out of alignment (I thought her eye was permanently closed until I realised it was her nose I was looking at.
Readers will love spotting the Australian flora and fauna well depicted by Shanks, and laugh out loud at the humorous touches included in his illustrations: the echidnas being used as bowling balls and the galah appearing on each page, and being wooed on the last page, while the sounds they make in the book invites discussion in the classroom about the noises really made by these animals.
Fran Knight

47 degrees by Justin D'Ath

cover image

Puffin, 2019. ISBN: 9780143789079.
(Age: 10+) Highly recommended. Themes: Bushfire, Victoria, Survival, Disaster. Justin D'Ath lost his house and possessions in the fatal bushfire now known as Black Saturday which tore through Victoria in January 2009.
He has recreated this appalling event with incredible clarity and tells the story through the eyes of Zeelie, a twelve year old working with her father to try and save their house and land. Stay and Defend is his catch cry and he has many things in place to help him do that but when the wind changes direction and the temperature climbs to 47, the fire comes without warning forcing them to leave.
All morning we see Dan attaching pipes, setting up the generator, cleaning gutters and clearing the area around the house. Zeelie helps but is concerned for her horse and dogs as well as her mother and brother, gone to Melbourne to the emergency hospital after he fell and hurt his arm. Leaving her mobile at home they cannot talk to her, and when the networks fall over all contact is gone. Power outages means Dan and Zeelie must rely on the few people they meet on the road for information.
The absolute chaos of the day is well told, bringing the readers into the fear, flames and smell of the day, the smoke making their view of the surrounds impossible, police blocking their way as the roads are now impassable, and not knowing where mum and her brother are. The fear is palpable.
Leaving their home and Zeelie's horse, they end up at Yea with loads of other people they do not know, refugees in their own community. They are surprised at the generosity of the people of Yea, and when the army turns up to erect a tent city, they find their family.
D'Ath enfolds us all in the gravity of the day; we yearn with Zeelie the need for news of her mother and brother, hoping they did not leave the city to try and get home, we ache for her horse left behind, scan the faces of those milling on the Yea oval, hoping for news of their homes. A map at the beginning of the book shows the reader just how close to Melbourne the fires raged, and an afterword gives us more information about what happened. Dan's fire plan, like D'Ath's, prepared for a fire event, but nothing prepared anyone for that day, with those temperatures and winds.
In this the tenth anniversary of Black Saturday this cautionary tale, will impel readers look at their own fire plans, making sure there is an escape route wherever they are.
Fran Knight

Two can keep a secret by Karen M. McManus

cover image

Penguin Books, 2019. ISBN: 9780141375656.
(Age: 15+) Recommended. Themes: Mystery, Diversity. McManus shows a masterly hand at the mystery genre with this easy to read, dark tale of secrets in a small town. Ellery and her twin brother Ezra return to Echo Ridge to live with their grandmother, after their mother was sent to rehab for driving into a jewellery shop. It is the town where their aunt went missing years ago and where a Homecoming Queen was murdered. No one knows what happened to these girls and it has affected everyone in the town, especially Malcolm whose older brother was the prime suspect. When his brother returns to town and another girl disappears Ellery and Malcolm know that they have to unravel the secrets in the town.
This is a gripping murder mystery which kept me guessing until the end about who committed the murders and what the motivation could possibly be. Narrated in two voices, that of Ellery and Malcolm, the author gradually informs the reader about the past mysteries, while increasing the tension about the present disappearance and who might be behind it.
Fans of McManus' first book One of us is lying and fans of the mystery genre like me will find much to love about this book. The suspense builds up very effectively, there are some very scary moments, the characters portrayed are believable and the tension lasts until the very end.
Pat Pledger