Reviews

Three Billy Goats Gruff by Nick Bland

cover image

Classic Fairytales. Scholastic Australia, 2019. ISBN: 9781743815885.
(Age:2-5) Recommended. Themes: Fairy tales, Problem solving, Humour, Adventure. The classic and much loved Three Billy Goats Gruff fairytale has been brought to life by Nick Bland's bold illustrations. It is a joy to read the well known story and follow the three clever billy goats Gruff as they decide to try the grass that is greener on the other side of the bridge. But of course they have to get past the ugly troll who lives under the bridge and wants to eat them for his dinner.
This has always been a favourite of mine and one that is much loved as a read aloud by toddlers and by young children. They will love to repeat the 'Trip, Trap, Trip, Trap, Trip, Trap! ' refrain as the billygoats go over the bridge and will really enjoy the fact that it is the smallest goat who goes first and tricks the troll with his cleverness.
The illustrations are in tones of greens, blues and yellows, and bring the countryside to life. The expressions on the faces of the goats and the trolls are priceless and will have readers smiling. The troll, too, is not so scary that little people will be afraid and the final scene when the big billygoat pushes the troll into the stream is a hoot.
This will be a keeper for young children and I can see them demanding to have it read again and again.
Pat Pledger

David Astle's 101 Weird Words (and 3 fakes) by David Astle

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2018. ISBN: 9781760633660.
(Age: 8-12) Recommended. David Astle's bio at the back of the book states that he 'loves words. Eats them. Dreams them.' This non-fiction book is a fun journey into the world of words.
There were words that I knew and many more than the prescribed 3 that I wondered if they were fake.
Words such as farnarkle, lackadaisical and skulduggery will challenge many students.
At least one page is dedicated to each word, with an added pronunciation guide and a detailed description. There is often a little riddle or joke thrown in at the end too.
Fun illustrations are scattered throughout the book to add to the appeal of the book.
Many children would love to pour through this book and enjoy the words but I think it would be a fun classroom activity to have a word a week and see if the students can work out the word's meaning and predict if it is one of the 3 hidden fakes.
David Astle kindly gives you the code to work out the 3 fakes at the end of the book.
I recommend this book to 8 to 12 year olds.
Jane Moore

Melody Trumpet by Gabrielle Tozer

cover image

Angus and Robertson, 2019. ISBN: 9781460754979.
(Age: 8-12) Melody Trumpet comes from a famous musical family. Her mother is a world-renowned singer and her father an exceptional conductor. Both parents were extremely disappointed to find out that their long-awaited child was a musical disaster. She can't sing or play any instrument even after years of exclusive tutoring.
Melody's parents hide her away in shame and forbid her to mix with any other children in case her talentless secret is revealed.
Mr and Mrs Trumpet are reminiscent of poor Matilda's parents in Roald Dahl's famous book of the same name. They are cruel, uncaring and completely self-obsessed.
Melody briefly escapes her parent's mansion to discover another world and new friends. It is Melody's notebook that changes her life and gives her a chance to discover her true talent.
Melody discovers how important friendship is and that money and fame are unimportant without love and kindness. The novel also celebrates discovering your special skill or talent and applauding differences.
Gabrielle Tozer's previous books have been written for young adults and this is her first book for younger students.
This is a delightful, amusing story that will appeal to readers from 8 to 12 years old.
Jane Moore

Boys will be boys - Power, patriarchy and the toxic bonds of mateship by Clementine Ford

cover image

Allen and Unwin 2018. ISBN: 9781760632335.
(Age: Adults - senior secondary) Described on the book jacket as 'Fearless feminist heroine' Clementine Ford has followed up her tirade about sexism Fight Like a Girl with an examination of toxic masculinity. She reasons that as she is now the mother of a boy she needs to ensure he grows up to be a supporter not a perpetrator. The phenomenon in western culture of gender stereotypes expressed from birth in blue for boys, pink for girls; active toys for boys and domestic ones for girls is a 'manifestation of capitalist ideals'. The reader is assured that if they conform 'you are not a bad person but you are doing a bad thing' p15. Ford's language is provocative and strident, she makes sweeping statements and her assertions tend to be repetitive but the book is full of examples, case studies and statistics which have the added relevance of being from an Australian, and often South Australian perspective. 'Boys are defined by how impressive they are while girls are defined by how impressive they look', 'my job is to disrupt that dynamic, not facilitate it' p24. The following chapters look at sharing of domestic chores and child rearing; the imbalance of roles in movies for women 'include a girl but make sure she won't be the main one' p80; the insistence that not all men are perpetrators diluting the debate about violence towards women; the double standards applied to multiple sexual relationships for boys and girls; the phenomenon of internet trolling and the torrent of abuse from the Men's Rights Movement. She looks at the way the legal system takes gender into account and in a chapter on the lack of women in leadership roles she has a delicious quote from Tony Abbott about it being folly to expect women to dominate or even approach equal representation p230. There are worrying chapters on rape jokes and sentencing in rape cases ending with twenty pages outlining cases of men who have been accused or convicted of various crimes against women. The epilogue is a sensitive and tentatively positive letter to her son and I would have liked to have more positive suggestions and examples throughout the book. I don't think, as the book jacket claims, this book will answer the question 'how do I raise my son to respect women and give them equal space in the world' but it will raise awareness of the multiple ways we might fail. Suitable for adults and senior students, details about rape and violence towards women make it unsuitable for younger readers.
Sue Speck

How high the moon by Karyn Parsons

cover image

Puffin Books, 2019. ISBN: 9780241346891.
(Age: Secondary students and mature Year 7) Recommended. The book's front cover immediately leaves the reader with no illusions about the serious event that is to occur in the story. A torn newspaper graphic announces that the novel was 'inspired by the tragic true tale of George Stinney, the youngest ever American to be executed at the age of fourteen . . . '
The newspaper is 'The South Carolina Times' and the date is 1944, which gives background information about the setting and time. This historical perspective may not be obvious to the young adult reader but Karyn Parsons's story reveals the racism of Southern America through the eyes of young black Americans.
Ella is the main character and it is her journey of self-discovery that directs most of the plot. Ella lives in a loving extended family with her grandparents and cousins. Her mother has moved to the North to pursue a better life and Ella has no knowledge of her father.
Surprisingly her mother sends for Ella to join her in Boston and at first this seems exciting, but her mama's day job and busy night life as an aspiring jazz singer means Ella is often alone. She yearns for school and her past family life and her main focus is trying to discover information about her dad.
This story is told from the perspective of several characters and is an insight into the strong racial feelings of the times. Ella is amazed by the differences between attitudes in the more liberal North and racist Southern USA, especially the fragile, tenuous existence of black people in her home state of South Carolina.
The title of the novel is an Ella Fitzgerald song and a link to the jazz music of the time.
This is a wonderful story that deals with powerful issues. I would recommend this story to secondary students and mature year 7's.
Here is a video of the author talking about her novel.
Jane Moore

A Curse of Ash and Embers by Jo Spurrier

cover image

Tales of the Blackbone Witches book 1, Harper Voyager, 2018. ISBN: 9781460756331.
(Age: 13+) Highly recommended. Aurealis Awards Best Young Adult novel shortlist 2018. Themes: Witches, Curses, Coming of age. When Elodie is sent off to be a servant she doesn't dream that she would be working for a witch. Desperate to leave a home where she is belittled by her stepfather and used as a drudge, she travels to a distant village where she finds Aleida, a young witch and immediately sees that she is needed not only as a servant but as someone who has Aleida's back. Aleida has been in a massive fight with her mistress Gyssha Blackbone, who has made huge monsters that ravage the countryside and who has cursed her. For Elodie, anything is better than going home.
This is a fantasy tale that will quickly grip the reader's attention. Elodie is an engaging heroine: sensible and pragmatic, she is also compassionate and helpful. As the story progresses, the reader knows that she will do everything she can to help Aleida foil the wicked Gyssha, even though she finds it very difficult. Aleida is a mysterious character and Spurrier cleverly unfolds her story and other surprises along the way.
There is plenty of action for those who like adventure and the descriptions of the ways that witchcraft is used gives an interesting background to the world that Elodie and Aleida inhabit.
I really enjoyed reading this story and look forward to the sequel. Although there was a touch of romance, it was Elodie's growth in confidence and self esteem on escaping her past and the growing friendship between Aleida and Elodie that made the story interesting.
A Curse of Ash and Embers is likely to appeal to fans of stories about witches and warlocks like Tempests and slaughter by Tamora Pierce and How to hang a witch by Adriana Mather.
Pat Pledger

The book chook by Amelia McInerney

cover image

Illus. by Connah Brecon. Omnibus, 2019. ISBN: 9781742994987.
(Age: 4+) Highly recommended. Themes: Humour, Poultry, Illustrative technique. A very funny look at a chook, Ray who does not realise that he is a book chook, a two dimensional drawing that has a place only on a page. He is appalled and checks himself out. He realises that his feathers are flat, he has no smell near his behind, while he talks in rhyme. He calls out to the audience to help him escape from the page, by calling his name, and as the pages are turned he is begging them to call out more loudly. Janine all the while waits patiently while his attempts to escape fail, and tells him to rethink his plans. After all does he realise what a chook does all day? Does he know that they cannot read and write? And finally she convinces him that he is better off where he is with Janine for a friend.
This delightful story will have eager readers asking it to be read out again and again, so that they can help Ray escape from the book by calling out his name. Audience participation will be loud and encouraging, and they will laugh out loud at his antics to get off that page.
The clever illustrations give each of the main characters wonderful facial expressions, revealing what each is feeling as Ray attempts at escape. I can imagine readers grabbing all the books about chooks from the shelves in their libraries, comparing just how chooks are illustrated and perhaps coming to the conclusion that Ray is better off with his friend. And they will laugh at the contrast between real chooks and those shown in picture books.
A lovely read, extolling the phrase, 'there's no place like home'.
Fran Knight

Say something by Peter H. Reynolds

cover image

Scholastic, 2019. ISBN: 9781760664992.
(Age: 4+) Recommended. Themes: Discussion, Communication, Sharing. Encouraging kids to speak out, to say what they feel and make themselves heard is the basis for this picture book aimed at lower primary kids and made for a class where issues are discussed openly. The opening endpaper sings out its themes: justice, peace, onward, stay strong etc impelling readers to add their own words and phrases showing their beliefs. Kids will be encouraged to find their own voice and as they turn the next pages will see examples of what they can do to make the world a better place. If you see someone who is lonely, speak to them, if you see an empty canvas, add your paint, if you see an empty garden plot, sow something and watch it grow, if you invent something, share it, if you are angry tell someone why.
Each double page begins with 'if you', putting the reader in the place of the person on the page, asking them to discover for themselves what they can do about the situation. In this way, the reader is given the task of doing something about a situation which they may have felt was outside their control. It is now in their hands, and the book continues encouraging, prodding, reminding just how much they can do to make things better.
The figures on each page are reflected against a brightly patterned background, readers seeing the child in sharp contrast to its surroundings. This heightened image again impels readers to think about what they want to say, and on the last page, Reynolds leaves the page full of empty conversation outlines for them to add their own words. He urges readers to use their voices to 'inspire, heal and transform' and in the classroom where a sympathetic teacher will use this book to advantage, this will be encouraged.
Fran Knight

Tilly Maguire and the royal wedding mess by Emma Grey

cover image

Angus and Robertson, 2018. ISBN: 9781460755051.
(Age: Young adult) Tilly Maguire and the royal wedding mess by Emma Grey is a contemporary romance novel catered towards a young adult audience. We follow Tilly Maguire, a bubbly and fresh out of high school eighteen-year-old as she embarks on a gap year in London working for a major PR company set to cover a royal event. When things go awry Tilly is swept up in a whirlwind of social media scandal and a heart throbbing romance with her childhood celebrity crush.
The characters in this novel were oftentimes one dimensional and cliched. No character seemed to stray from their assigned position in the story e.g. villain wanted to ruin the main character's life for no special reason and the love interest immediately falls in love for no reason beside the main character being 'not like other girls' he has dated. The diversity in this story felt somewhat forced and added as a bonus to appeal to the younger generation instead of actually being genuine or well informed about the LGBT+ community.
The plot was typical of the young adult genre. It heavily focused on the romance and nothing much else. Things moved too quickly for there to be any emotional build up or for the readers to form connections with the characters.
The imagery and language choices were also rather cliched  e.g. 'she looked like a model' etc . . . This seemed to counteract the whole point of having diversity in the story as there was seemingly nothing diverse about the way the characters or settings were described.
Overall, I would recommend this book to a younger audience. It is fast paced and easy to read. However, there is nothing unique about the plot or the characters but if you enjoy a book with a heavy romance element to it I think the cliche aspects of the story could be overlooked.
Amy Folker (Student)

Jae-Dee survives the home of many mothers by Jae-Dee Collier

cover image

Balboa Press, 2018. ISBN: 9781504315692.
(Age: 14+) Highly recommended. Jae-Dee's sad story of abandonment to an Adelaide orphanage as a three year old in the 1950s is fictionalised, told from the point of view of the child. So it's the child's voice we hear as she struggles to make sense of the world she finds herself in, longing for love but always receiving rejection and humiliation from Sster, as the children call the nun in charge. Sster Grace couldn't be more removed from the idea of grace; she is harsh and cruel, beats the children in her charge and subjects them to cruel taunting and humiliation. Jae-Dee is a bed-wetter, and as a three year old has to drag her sheets to the laundry, hand-wash them, and drag the clothes basket to the clothesline.
Jae-Dee has beautiful memories of her parents, a handsome couple gliding across the ballroom. She longs to be with them. But whilst they are good intentioned, they are a fragile couple, her mother ill and teetering on depression and her father too fond of the drink. Nevertheless, for Jae-Dee it is the love of her mother and father that she constantly craves - she desperately wants to be reunited with them and with her younger sisters. It is the abuse and lack of love in the orphanage that becomes the most damaging experience.
Collier clearly writes from her memories; she captures exactly how a three year old struggles with the stairs, planting both feet on each step, and then how she skips to keep up with the nun's quick stride along the corridor. We share in the child's love of warm sweet food like rice pudding, and her detestation of boiled vegetables. And we empathise with her humiliation and embarrassment as she wakes each morning in a wet bed. From time to time, Collier adds a comment as an adult, reminding us this all really happened - children who were so in need of love and care, were kept in the most cold and uncaring environment, in an institution that was supposed to stand for love and charity.
At the end of the book, Collier includes the transcript of the Prime Minister's 2009 apology to the Forgotten Australians and former child migrants; a recognition and regret for the experiences of children who suffered neglect and abuse in orphanages, and a reminder that the protection of children is a sacred duty. It is to be hoped that in writing her story, Collier finds release from some of the memories, and strength in knowing she is a survivor.
Helen Eddy

The quiet at the end of the world by Lauren James

cover image

Walker Books; 2019. ISBN: 9781406375510. 352p; p/b.
(Age: Middle secondary+) Recommended. In a future where the human race is infertile, the last two people to ever be born confront the fear of loneliness when a mystery disease rages through an already dwindling population.
It's difficult to discuss what makes this book good, because its best aspects hinge on a plot twist that shouldn't be spoilt. It tackles some interesting ethical issues that are becoming increasingly relevant today, and some thought provoking takes on the future of humanity. Don't worry though, it's not all heavy futurism - the novel also contains some quite personal themes of love and secrets. It's quite engaging, with a unique narrative device of reading through archived chat-logs online, interspersed at precisely paced intervals with more traditional narration. The representation in the cast is inspiring - bi and trans will last as long as humanity does.
You will just have to read it yourself, it is a wonderful read. The book is suitable for middle secondary-aged readers due to the themes discussed, however it can be a good conversation with classes as to the diversity and power of humanity.
Vincent Hermann

Sea Bear: a journey for survival by Lindsay Moore

cover image

Greenwillow Books, 2019. ISBN: 9780062791283. 48pp., hbk.
Imagine you are a polar bear.
Your coat is thick. Your teeth are sharp.
Your front paws are paddles, your back paws are rudders, and you can swim for miles.
Your home has always been the sea and the ice.
A sea bear, far north in the Arctic, hunts and naps and raises her young. She moves with the ice, swimming, running, stalking seals, resting. She follows the rhythm of the sea and the seasons. But what happens when those rhythms change? What happens when there is no ice?
Told from the perspective of a female bear, the reader is taken on a journey of the Arctic seasons starting in spring when the ice is thick and the baby seals numerous, through to summer when the water warms and the ice melts, making it too thin to stand on and the seals more wary and quicker. Smelling land on the offshore breeze, the bear starts to swim to shore for food but it is a long arduous and perilous journey filled with lots of other creatures of the cold seas. But above all, polar bears are patient and so she continues knowing that the world will turn, the time will pass and winter will come again. Courage, determination, resilience - even in the animal kingdom.
As well as the evocative text, it is the illustrations which make this book a stand-out. Using a palette of a myriad of blues, the reader is treated to all the moods and times of this wonderland - starry night skies, ocean depths and shallows, the aurora borealis, the breaking ice pack and isolate seashore. While it could be a story of any sea bear, using the first person builds a connection with the reader so we are invested in her survival as well as that of all her kind. Her companions of the deep become less threatening as they pass by each other as Moore's illustrations reflect her Master of Science in Medical and Scientific Illustration.
A page of information about sea ice and polar bears and another introducing the creatures she passes on her journey to shore add to the value of this book which shines a light on the plight of Arctic (and Antarctic) creatures as global warming continues and the amount of sea ice declines each year.
A valuable addition to your environment and sustainability collection.
Barbara Braxton

The boy: His stories and how they came to be by Oliver Jeffers

cover image

HarperCollins, 2018. ISBN: 9780008294342. 168pp., hbk.
In 2004, Oliver Jeffers set out to do a painting of someone trying to do something impossible - a boy catching a star with a butterfly net - and that idea evolved not only into the book How to catch a star but into a series of four stories including Lost and found, The way back home and Up and down.
Now collected into one collection, this book also offers a unique look behind the scenes at the development of each book. As well as a letter from Jeffers himself explaining how the series grew (and may still do so, although that is unlikely), it contains more than 100 distinctive sketches, notes and ideas that he has chosen from his archives that show the thoughts, events and incidents that shaped the stories.
Apart from its inherent beauty, this book has much to offer about how stories grow in the minds of their creators, giving it an appeal and a use far beyond the target audience of the original stories themselves.
Barbara Braxton

Mummy Cuddle by Kate Mayes

cover image

Illus. by Sara Acton. ABC Books, 2019. ISBN: 9780733339431.
(Age: 1-5) Highly recommended. Themes: Bedtime, Parent and child, Mothers, Feel good book. A lovely gentle but very humorous book Mummy cuddle tugs at the heartstrings and leaves the reader feeling happy after reading it. Bunny creeps out of bed and 'brum brum', pushes a little car down the stairs and asks Mummy to play. Mummy is very patient and carries him back upstairs on her back and quietly answers questions while trying to get Bunny to sleep.
The narrative is sparse with most double page spreads having only two words: 'Mummy play?' Mummy talk?' 'Mummy brush?' 'Mummy pat' until finally 'Mummy dream' and 'Mummy cuddle'. Children will have fun predicting just what Bunny will come up with next in the quest to stay awake and many will know just what will happen. Sara Acton's outstanding illustrations done in soft pastels, with Mummy and Bunny outlined in black, are enchanting. The characteristics of both are clear - Mummy is such a loving, unflappable parent while Bunny is persistent but loving as well, even covering Mummy with a blanket as she sleeps on the floor. The endpapers are worthy of close examination, the front ones showing Bunny having a bath and getting ready for bed, while the back ones show an exuberant dance.
This would be an ideal book to share with children on Mother's Day in particular, but the message of parental love is one for any time. I can see it becoming a cherished book that celebrates the bond between mother and child.
Pat Pledger

On the come up by Angie Thomas

cover image

Walker Books, 2019. ISBN: 9781406372168.
(Age: Young adult) Recommended. On the come up by Angie Thomas is a hard-hitting contemporary young adult novel novel that brings light to topics such as racial stereotyping and discrimination of people due to their social class.
Bri has always dreamed of being a famous rapper like her dad so when she gets the chance to compete in an amateur rap battle in her inner-city neighbourhood she jumps on it. She believes that becoming a rapper is the key to saving her family from poverty and to rise above the racism and hate she experiences from being African American in her community.
The characters in this novel were realistic and unique from each other. Their personalities and ambitions in the novel were memorable and special to that character. This made you feel like you were getting to know and forming real relationships with the characters in the novel.
The plot was unique and spoke about racial inequality in a way that clearly highlighted the injustices minorities face daily in real life. These heavy topics are delivered in a non-graphic and easy to interpret way so readers young or old will feel as if they have gained knowledge and a deeper understanding of racial prejudice.
The imagery and language choices were true to the setting of the novel which is a predominately African American neighbourhood. It felt as if I was transported to America and could hear the characters through their realistic dialogue. The language choices were clear and easy to understand which is most likely because this book is aimed at young adults.
Overall, I would recommend this book to a younger audience who would like to know more about the injustices racial minorities face in modern day society. It is a fast paced but still emotional impactful read. If you enjoy realistic characters and an action packed plot this is the book for you!
Amy Folker (student)