Reviews

The Pear Affair by Judith Eagle

cover image

Illus. by Kim Geyer. Faber & Faber. 2020. ISBN: 9780571346851. 288pp
(Age: 8+) Highly recommended. What a beautifully written mystery for young readers, who will delight in the sights and smells of Paris as Penelope Magnificent tries to find Perrine, nicknamed Pear, the au pair that her parents had sent away. Pear had promised to take her away from her awful parents but her letters had stopped six months ago and Nell is determined to find her. When her parents take her to Paris, she befriends a young bellboy, Xav, at her posh hotel and with a group of friends explores the Paris catacombs and tries to uncover what has happened to Pear.
Readers are very fortunate - they have the joy of following not just one mystery but two in this adventurous romp through Paris. Not only does Nell have trouble finding Pear, but all the bakeries in Paris are suffering from a strange spore called the Thing which makes their bread and cakes go mouldy. How is this happening and why are the Pain-tastique bakeries not suffering from the same trouble?
Eagle's characters are well developed and believable. Nell is such a determined girl and the characters of the children and adults she meets are beautifully created. And what horrors her parents are - readers will shudder at their uncaring ways and really want the beloved Pear to be found.
Readers who enjoy action and adventure will enjoy the thrills of the chase as Nell's group works out what is happening. There are lots of heart-stopping moments, especially when Nell is crawling around in the dark in the Paris catacombs and when she is captured and held prisoner. A believable happy ending will also satisfy readers and the black and white illustrations by Kim Geyer bring the Paris of bakeries, fashion and underground homes to life.
Those who enjoyed this may like to read Rooftoppers by Katherine Rundell. Themes include betrayal, friendship, greed and mapping.
Pat Pledger

The very hungry caterpillar's hide and seek by Eric Carle

cover image

Puffin, 2020. ISBN: 9780241425657. Board book.
(Age: 0+) Highly recommended. Lovers of The very hungry caterpillar are in for a real treat with this latest offering showing what lives in the forest and finally where the little caterpillar hides. As always the illustrations are exquisite; bright colours pop out from the pages and all the animals in the forest are beautifully depicted, each having their own personality, and are so happy and active.
Starting with bees the large sturdy lift-the-flap show a bright yellow hive:
Who is in the forest where it's bright and sunny?
Busy, buzzing bees making tasty honey!
Other scenes show little green frogs leaping, and a large brown duck looking for food, wild birds soaring in the sky, fluffy mice underground and a fox prowling in the woods.
All the flaps are very well made and will stay the distance for little fingers that will want to lift them again and again. The young child will have fun searching for the very hungry caterpillar on different pages, and the lovely verse is ideal for adults to read aloud and enjoy.
There is much in this book to delight over - animals to name, little creatures to find and time to discuss animal habitats and as the cover states, a finger trail for little fingers to follow.
This is a book that is sure to be a favourite and one to keep for the next generation.
Pat Pledger

Little disasters by Sarah Vaughan

cover image

Simon and Schuster, 2020. ISBN: 9781471194900
(Ages: Senior secondary/Adult) Recommended. Sarah Vaughan's latest book deals with issues which are familiar to anyone who has been or is a parent. It is only a matter of degree as to the effects parenting has on the family. A group of friends who met at antenatal classes seem on the surface to be successful, financially and socially, but all harbour secrets and their veneer of contentment hides self doubt to varying extents.
Jess and Liz's contact has lessened recently. Liz has a demanding job as a paediatrician in a London NHS hospital, her shifts and rosters mean she has little time for her friends and at times even for her own young family. While Jess is a stay-at-home mother who has recently given birth to her third child, she seems to all who know her to be the perfect mother. Her home is always ordered. When she entertains all is considered, thoughtful and beautifully presented. She is a wonderful mother, successfully dealing with her second child Frankie who is demanding and hyperactive.
However Jess is not coping - she is finding her baby Betsey difficult. She finds herself caught up in a regime of cleaning, sterilising, tidying and ensuring her home is a safe place. All at the expense of emotional support not only of Betsey but her other children. Her husband Ed has always left the child rearing to her and spends much of his time at work and lately has avoided coming home to where he increasingly feels an outsider.
Alarm bells ring when Betsey is admitted to hospital and Liz is on duty. Betsey has a fractured skull and protocols demand police and social services are called. Suspicions are roused and Liz finds herself in a precarious position. She cannot believe that her friend would ever harm her baby, but also feels Jess is not telling the whole truth about the circumstances of her baby's injury.
The incident triggers Liz's own childhood memories of her mother, a distant cold figure struggling with two children while running a cafe. The treatment of her brother's serious burn injury has always been cause for distress. These thoughts come into focus when her mother's health begins to fail and she confides a long held secret to her.
The truth about Betsey's injury eventually comes out. There are guilty feelings by those close to Jess, who were unable to see she was not coping. Even after Betsey's hospitalisation it takes some time before it is recognised that Jess is in need of mental health support.
Little disasters highlights the need for support for parenting. There are always doubts when trying to deal with children and how unprepared we are to cope with childrearing. Especially when expectations around children and their development are highlighted in the media. Many parents may be worried that they are perceived as failures or inadequate in comparison to their peers. This story highlights the difference between reality and perception and makes a plea for greater understanding for all parents. Themes: Crime fiction, Parenting, Friendship.
Mark Knight

What stars are made of by Sarah Allen

cover image

Puffin Books, 2020. ISBN: 9780241427965.
(Ages: 10+) Highly recommended. Twelve year old Libby Munroe has Turner Syndrome. She is missing a chromosome, her heart is three times too big for her body and she copes with other physical and neurological conditions that become evident throughout the story. Added to this Libby has incredible resilience and stamina, a brilliant brain and a love of all things Science related. Her parents are her greatest supporters as well as her older married sister Nonny who lives in another state but returns home when her husband is retrenched. Nonny is pregnant and this becomes a worrying time for Libby. She comes up with a plan to support her sister and keep the baby safe. Libby excels in her school work and when the opportunity arises to take part in a national Smithsonian Women in STEM contest Libby utilises this to firstly study her favourite female scientist Cecilia Payne and secondly to help Nonny's family. This is not an easy path chosen by Libby and along the way she builds a relationship with her American History teacher Ms Trepky, and more importantly finds friendship with the new girl Talia who is subjected to bullying and like Libby struggles to be accepted. This is Libby's first real experience of friendship and both girls support each other through difficult times.
There are some challenging events in the story and the clever use of short chapters to convey the seriousness of one such event gives the reader a distinct indication of the possible heartbreak to come. The author Sarah Allen has Turner Syndrome and the details that she shares naturally with the reader leads to a growing understanding of the complexities of the condition.
Libby is an endearing and honest character whose telling of the story will engage the reader to the very end. The story is cleverly told in the first person narrative and the reader will feel Libby's heartfelt attempts at friendships, her disappointments and struggles, and her deep love and concern for her family. Themes: Family, Turner Syndrome, Medical Conditions, Friendship, School Bullying, STEM.
Kathryn Beilby

World of the Five Gods: Penric & Desdemona series by Lois McMaster Bujold

cover image

Penric's Travels. Baen, 2020. ISBN: 9781982124571.
Penric's Progress. Baen Books, 2020. ISBN: 9781982124298.
The Physicians of Vilnoc. Spectrum Literary Agency, 2020. ASIN B088D695MK.
(Age 15+) Highly recommended. I am a fan of any work by Lois McMaster Bujold who writes with wit, warmth and always has a unique world. In this series of novellas the reader follows the adventures of young Lord Penric who when stopping to help at an accident of a Temple divine, is overtaken by the five demons that reside within her. These strange powers change the course of his life. He finds himself studying to become a Divine and a scholar and is called upon to solve mysteries and problems in his world with the aid of his demon Desdemona.
First published as e-books, the first three novellas have been published in hardback as Penric's Travels, and include the Hugo nominations Penric's Demon and Penric and the Shaman. The next three have been published in Penric's Progress, and the latest two, The orphans of Raspray and The Physicians of Vilnoc as e-books. The Physicians of Vilnoc has Penric called to solve the reason that an epidemic has struck the army fort of Vilnoc, and with the help of dedicated colleagues, he must root out the origins of the deadly plague. Readers who are familiar with the series can read this comfortably in difficult times, as Penric although facing severe trials, is usually triumphant.
All the novellas feature Penric and Desdemona and their witty interactions often bring a smile to the face as they face adversity and adventure. They are easy to read, well written novellas and for readers who like a hard copy the collections will be a boon. The novellas are set in the world of the Hugo winning fantasy series, Chalion, and readers may want to pursue The curse of Chalion and Paladin of souls.
Pat Pledger

The Book of Chance by Sue Whiting

cover image

Walker Books Australia, 2020. ISBN: 9781760651367. 277 pp.
(Age: 10 +) In recent years, Sue Whiting has emerged as a talented writer of Young Adult literature, as well as an awarding winning writer of picture books for the young.
Missing, published in 2018, was received very well and The Book of Chance follows with a strong teenage voice and believable characters. The book addresses social media and the way it affects decision making for the right or wrong reasons. Protagonist, Chance Callahan, arranges for a reality TV team to make over her house; in the process, the discovery of some past newspaper cuttings reveal secrets, which must be faced, but will cause her world to be turned upside down.
The Book of Chance is an easy read, but well handled with polished dialogue, a strong narrative voice and a mystery which holds the reader's attention. Teacher's notes are available.
Julie Wells

Good question by Sue Whiting

cover image

Illus. by Annie White. Walker Books, 2020. ISBN: 9781760650841.
(Age: 4+) Highly recommended. Wily Fox is striving to appease his hunger but keeps getting into the wrong fairy tale, causing some disquiet amongst the other characters.
Readers will eagerly follow his exploits as he tries to find food, causing ripples of laughter as they recognise the story he has invaded. We see him first in a forest hiding from a giant with a huge cudgel, searching for Fox to add to his pot of stew. Fox is adamant that he was doing nothing wrong trying to take the giant's goose, after all that is what foxes do. And we find over the page that the rascally Jack had thrown the goose at the fox while he was climbing the beanstalk. The next question to ask is why he was on that beanstalk. We find out that Fox was hiding from Wolf, the same one whose Pig Fox tried to steal when Wolf puffed Pig's house down. And Fox only tried to catch the Pig because he was hungry after being chased by the Bears from their home when he tried to eat their porridge.
And on it goes, each page asking the question about what Fox is doing in this particular story, and winding its way through many beloved fairy stories until at last, we see the initial story that began all the mayhem.
A great deal of fun will be had reading this story. Children will laugh out loud recognising favourite stories and characters and seeing the predicament Fox is in while wandering through each tale.
It is great fun, especially taking note of the subtitle, A tale told backwards, and is a wonderful story beautifully told, with illustrations that match the chaos of the story, encouraging a veiled sympathy for Fox as he does what foxes do. The use of different fonts and font sizes adds interest and delight as the reader turns the pages, noting the movement within the lines of text and the way they interact with the illustrations. And of course, there is a good question on every double page, impelling the reader to turn the page to find out why the Fox has become part of that story. This book will provoke the readers to seek out the fairy tales mentioned and reread them as well. Teacher's notes are available and a video showing the author. Themes: Fairy tales, Fox, Twisted fairy tales, Hunger.
Fran Knight

The sin eater by Megan Campisi

cover image

Macmillan, 2020. ISBN: 9781529019100.
(Age: Adolescent - Adult) This vibrant story plunges us into the world of the Middle Ages in Britain, Campisi vividly reflecting historical Elizabethan world in a tale that focuses on the particular role of the 'sin eater' in that era. The narrative is centred on a young adolescent woman, who, struggling to survive alone with no family, job or money, is arrested for stealing. Inexplicably, she is not hanged with the other young female perpetrators of minor misdeeds, but is told, bluntly, and clearly with no choice, that she will now be a 'sin-eater'. She is forced to undergo the torture of having the 'S' for sin-eater burnt on to her tongue and a brass collar clamped around her neck, then told that she is to fulfill this new role in silence, and thus to have nothing to do with anyone else, as she is now and will be, for the rest of her life feared as an untouchable.
Within a short time she is called to do her first sin-eating, escorted to a home, and given particular foods that are chosen as appropriate for the story of a newly-dead person's life. After each 'eating' she returns to the small room where she manages to live alone with almost no possessions. As Campisi draws us deeply into a world where poverty dominates, we become aware of her gradual acceptance of her 'work', and of the strangeness of this life. In the realisation that the task will enable her to eat, she accepts that she has a position where it is a law that no-one may speak to her, but neither should they ever hurt her, because she is tainted by her role, and this would endanger others.
Through her construction of a re-imagined and startlingly vivid world set in Elizabethan England, Campisi depicts the squalor and poverty of that time, especially that endured by the poor, seen in such stark contrast to that of the rich, especially of the royals. We note some specific aspects of that era through her clever adaptation of words, Campisi having constructed alternative names and places for what we know historically. In her vibrant, descriptive story-telling, she reveals much about the lives of those who are poor and struggling to survive, while also describing many 'probable' aspects of how those, whom we recognise as 'the royals', lived. Plunging us into this world of rigid and distinct social classes, Campisi inferentially enables us to make sense of time and place, to work out who is the ruling monarch, and thus to read this story as representation of real history. The sin eater is indeed an exciting read and a vibrant, wonderful creation. It would be suitable for adolescent and adult readers.
Elizabeth Bondar

Artemis Fowl by Eoin Colfer

cover image

Puffin, 2020. ISBN: 9780241387177. 277 pp.
(Age: 10+) Many readers will remember the popularity of the 12 year old genius, Artemis Fowl, introduced in the first book of eight fantasy novels, who wants to capture one of the Fairy People and hold her to ransom in order to restore his family's fortune. This is not an easy task - Artemis' skills (ingenuity, confidence and courage, plus a gift for decoding Fairy messages) will be enlisted on all levels. This makes for an exciting, face-paced and often humorous read and, obviously, for all new readers (which there will be), there are the joys ahead of reading the seven books which followed the original. This is a special edition of the first story issued in 2001, coinciding with the imminent release of the film, Artemis Fowl (Disney), produced and directed by Kenneth Branagh. It contains a new author's note, a letter from the Branagh and photos from the film. Artemis Fowl is set to appeal to a new generation of readers, the older ones of us included.
Julie Wells

James Gong : The Big Hit by Paul Collins

cover image

Hybrid Publishers, 2020. ISBN: 9781925736441. 161pp.
(Age: 10-13) Recommended. James Gong is the anti-hero of this humorous novel told in the first person. James is a 14 year old average Australian school boy who is very good at taekwondo. The reader soon realises that James has an overly high opinion of himself. In fact he is quite self-centred, picks his nose and is an annoying younger brother to his sister, Caitlin. His taekwondo skills become noticed by some film makers who enlist him as an actor in their film, Ham Solo : Revenge of the Fist. Along with his wiser friends, we become aware that the film is not the Hollywood standard that it is purported to be by the film makers. James' acquaintances are expert skateboarders; James worries about having to kiss one of the actors and he ends up organising all the publicity for the film. Throughout most of the novel James continues to make excuses for his own failings and the lack of professionalism by the film makers.
You fear he will never wise up and take on responsibility for his own actions. There are several major reveals in the last few chapters, which help us learn about James' endearing side and understand some odd behaviour earlier in the novel.
There's plenty of light weight, crazy action which will maintain the appeal for middle to upper primary boys. It is ideal for reluctant readers, although not necessarily readers with reading difficulties. The author has brought his considerable knowledge of taekwondo to the story and given this some authenticity. There are quite a few references to old movies and TV series which may go above readers' heads. However it is grounded in today's multicultural Australia and younger male interests. The cover has an attractive manga design and small illustrations also feature at the beginning of each chapter. Teacher's notes are available.
Jo Marshall

The Night Country by Melissa Albert

cover image

Penguin Random House UK, 2020. ISBN: 9780241370285.
(Age: Young Adult/Adult). Recommended. The Night Country, sequel to Melissa Albert's 2018 debut The Hazel Wood, is a dark and twisted tale of murder, friendship and the search for belonging. Part fairy tale, part urban fantasy, part horror, this book is recommended for older teens and adults. The Night Country continues the story of Alice Proserpine, the former fairy tale character or 'Story' after her escape from the realm known as the Hinterland. Alice enrols in high school, gets a job at a bookstore and tries to put the past behind her as she navigates life as a teen in New York City. Her attempt at normalcy soon derails however when former Hinterland residents begin to gruesomely die and Alice becomes the chief suspect. Forced back into a world that she tried to forget, Alice begins a desperate search to find a murderer, save her friends and prove her innocence.
The Night Country is also the story of Ellery Finch, Alice's former classmate and love interest. While Alice fled, Finch remained behind in the Hinterland; trapped in a world that is disintegrating around him. Desperate to return to both New York and Alice, Finch embarks on his own perilous journey of understanding as he tries to find his way home. The narrative alternates between Alice and Finch's viewpoints, weaving their story lines together and culminating in a clever climax and conclusion.
The Night Country is a unique but very enjoyable young adult novel. Albert's macabre take on the fairy tale genre may be unsettling for some younger readers but, ultimately, The Night Country is a bloody and brilliant conclusion to Alice and Finch's story. Themes: Fairy Tales, Death, Identity, Love, Friendship, New York City.
Rose Tabeni

First, we make the beast beautiful by Sarah Wilson

cover image

MacMillan, 2017. ISBN: 9781743535868.
(Age: Adult) A book for the times, perhaps, a reprint of Sarah Wilson's book about anxiety has now been published. Over-researched and wordy, the book is a mix of un-referenced research snippets, therapy ideas and confessional anecdotes. It rattles along at the pace of a hyper-anxious mind. Wilson makes her references available on her website but there is no numbering of notes and the curious reader just has page numbers and the lead-in words of a sentence to try to find relevant sources. Yet as a self-help book it seems to have resonated with many if one can go by the comments collected in the preface and online. There are so many ideas, it is almost inevitable that there will be something worth taking away, so anxiety sufferers will probably recognise some shared experiences and find suggestions for ways to live with their anxiety. On the last page there is a list of professional sources of help.
Themes: Anxiety, Obsessive compulsive disorder, Mental illness.
Helen Eddy

The list of things that will not change by Rebecca Stead

cover image

Text Publishing, 2020. ISBN: 9781922268679.
(Age: 10+) Highly recommended. Rebecca Stead is a favourite author of mine, and she always writes with warmth and compassion about difficult topics. In this book she looks at the effects that divorce can have on a child and the notion of what makes a family. Bea keeps a list of things that will not change after her parents have divorced. Most important, both will still love her and she is happy when Dad decides to marry his boyfriend Jesse. She is thrilled at the idea of having a sister, even though Jesse's daughter Sonia, lives far away. She writes a series of letters to her, but Sonia finds it more difficult to fit into Bea's new family.
Bea's visits to a counsellor and the insights she gains there about her past actions and how she can manage her fears will resonate with middle grade readers, while appreciating the love that both parents give Bea. Stead does not paper over the difficulties of children who belong to families that are not the norm, but the love that the adults give Bea shines through the story and the support that she receives from them and her friends is heart-warming. Children who belong to families with two dads, or two mums, will be strengthened by this insightful portrayal of family love and children who belong to traditional families will gain an understanding of family love and the importance of friends helping each other.
It is a story that demonstrates tolerance, resilience and empathy and would make a wonderful literature circle novel, as would others by Stead, including the award winning When you reach me, Liar and spy, Goodbye stranger and Bob.
Teacher's notes are available.
Pat Pledger

Scribbly Gum Secrets by Dannika Patterson

cover image

Illus. by Megan Forward. Ford Street Publishing, 2020. ISBN: 9781925804485. Unpaged
(Ages 6+) This rather unassuming picture book has taken me by surprise. The reader goes on the same very special journey that the family does. Mum decides that the children need to accompany her on a nearby bushwalk. Reluctant at first, they are soon distracted by simple yet delightful discoveries as they walk along a dry gravel track through semi tropical bush.
The illustrations, though lacking in sophistication, are evocative and deceptively meaningful. Just as the creatures are hiding, the illustrations only gradually reveal the detail and variety of the surroundings.
A number of double page spreads encompass extensive parts of the bush, alternating with close up views of newly discovered things.
Megan Forward has combined softly drawn watercolour hues with the occasional photographed detail of leaves, blossoms and feathers. This technique works well.
The text is simple but effective and provides for more thoughtful exploration by the reader. Teacher's notes are available.
Julie Wells

Editor's note: I loved this book. Highly recommended.

Me, Frida, and the secret of the Peacock Ring by Angela Cervantes

cover image

Scholastic Press, 2018. ISBN: 9781338159318. 220 pp.
(Age: 10+) I purchased this book with my young granddaughter in mind. She has a love of the art of Frida Kahlo. Paloma is travelling for the first time to Mexico City, the birthplace of her deceased father. Her mother, who has been awarded a four week literary fellowship here, wishes her daughter to experience some of the cultural rewards this country offers. She will be able to learn some Spanish and find out about Frida Kahlo, who was Paloma's father's favourite artist; therefore, keeping alive those precious memories of her father. While her mother attends the university, Paloma attends school in Mexico and has the chance to explore the city art galleries and La Casa Azul (the Blue House) where Frida lived in Coyoacan. She meets Lizzie and Gael who want her to help them find a valuable ring that once belonged to the artist herself.
Paloma sees herself as Lulu Pennywhistle, the mastermind of the spy books she loves reading. An intriguing set of unexpected discoveries take place, as the young ones try to solve the mystery of the lost ring. The book has all the ingredients of a well-paced adventure; at the same time it introduces the young reader to an important piece of art history and, as her story progresses, Paloma comes to understand the importance of friendship and how much both her parents mean to her. This is an engaging and memorable story.
Julie Wells