Reviews

Naku Dharuk: The bark petitions by Clare Wright

cover image

Naku Dharuk is the third book in Clare Wright’s Democracy Trilogy which began with the rebels of Eureka and their struggle for rights and liberties, then moved to the women’s suffrage movement, and now presents the story of the Yolngu people of northeast Arnhem Land and their campaign for recognition of their sovereign rights. Thus we have the Eureka flag, the Women’s Suffrage Banner, and then the Bark Petitions, three founding documents in Australia’s path to democracy. Wright sums it up: 'Flag. Banner. Bark.' Three key moments in our nation’s history.

Clare Wright had the fortuitous opportunity to live with Yolngu on their land, mix with families, learn the language, and then gradually piece together an important story gleaned both from a Yolngu perspective and through the meticulous researching of diaries and papers. It is the story of a sovereign nation well used to trading with other nations: the trade with the Makassans for trepang, with the Methodist missionaries, and even with mining prospectors, there had always been a history of fair and respectful exchange. It never occurred to the Yolngu that some other power had assumed the rights to their country. Only when an unknown person pegged out lines through their peanut farm alongside the Methodist mission, that they started to query ‘Who wants this?’, little knowing that a distant federal government had excised a large portion of their country and granted mining licences to a French company for mining bauxite, without any consultation or any consideration of the people who lived there.

The Bark Petitions created by Yolngu artists with an accompanying message typed by the wife of the mission superintendent, sent to key people in the Australian government, was not a complaint about mining as such, it was about the reasonable expectation of consultation over the allocation of rights, and compensation for what they were prepared to give up. It was a call for recognition of an existing nation with its own laws and governance, and set the path for discarding the 'terra nullius' myth and ultimately recognising an indigenous people and their existing land rights.

Wright describes the hand of diplomacy extended by the people of Yirrkala, masters of cross-cultural collaboration, as a precursor to the Uluru Statement from the Heart, a respectful invitation to walk together, something that even today Australians struggle with.

Subtitled ‘How the people of Yirrkala changed the course of Australian democracy’, Clare Wright’s book is long, over 600 pages, but is very readable. Ted Egan asserts that it should become ‘standard reading material for all secondary students’. Most would know about the Eureka Stockade and the women’s rights campaign, but far fewer know about Naku Dharuk, the Bark Petitions, two copies held in Parliament House, one held by the National Museum of Australia, and the fourth, a treasure, miraculously rediscovered in the process of writing the book, and returned to the Yolngu people.

For fascinating interviews and reviews, see the Text Publishing website. Then add the book to your school library.

Themes Australian democracy, Yolngu people, Aboriginal rights, Sovereignty, Methodist mission.

Helen Eddy

The Order of Masks by Alina Bellchambers

cover image

The Order of Masks is the debut novel from Adelaide Hills author, Alina Bellchambers. A dark fantasy romance, Bellchambers has crafted a captivating world of political intrigue, magic and betrayal.

Mira has been on the run for her entire life, fleeing a past that her mother refuses to talk about. All Mira has ever known is constant upheaval and a feeling of never truly belonging anywhere. Exhausted by the endless turmoil and secrets, Mira is determined to find a way to secure her future once and for all, no matter the risk. To do this she must enter the deadly trials of the Ravalian Court, where she will either rise to become a powerful wielder of magic or die at the hands of the emperor, who has more than one reason to want her dead.

The Order of Masks also follows Scarlett, an ambitious princess struggling against her power-hungry brothers, forceful mother and aloof father. Despite their wildly different backgrounds, Mira and Scarlett are brought together by both ambition and desperation and have more in common than either could have imagined. If only they could trust one another long enough to discover this.

The hidden motives and morally grey natures of both Mira and Scarlett make for an engaging read, as Bellchambers skillfully builds a conflict that questions the thin line between ally and adversary. The Order of Masks balances action, romance, and suspense, making this novel a must-read for fans of fantasy with a dark edge.

Themes Fantasy, Thriller, Romance, Revenge, Family, Politics, Magic, War.

Rose Tabeni

When among crows by Veronica Roth

cover image

Dymitr comes from a long line of hunters whose souls are split in order to fight monsters. The distress of this role is hard and propels himself directly into struggle. Ala has inherited a curse that is slowly destroying her. Dymitr sets out on a quest to unburden himself, but needs the magical power of others to assist in the process. The conflict between magical forces and beings is fraught with multiple layers of pain, and Dymitr and Ala (as well as the intriguing Niko) must put themselves in danger before they can know  some resolution to their pain. 

This novella is not easy fantasy, it weaves Polish folklore and Slavic mythology (and some Polish language) in a complex dance of evil, pain and conflict, but with a tinge of compassion. The unusual nature of magical or mythical creatures and their dark powers adds some complexity to the story and this book does not have the clarity of Roth’s writing in the Divergent series. There are no true mortals or humans within this mythological world, and yet we recognise the struggle for those who feel uncomfortable in their place in their world and the way good can still rise from the mire of conflict.

This will require a reader with a heart for complex fantasy, aged 15+. There is some violence, but it is the unknowns of the mythology that create a cloudiness for understanding and thus only the persistent fantasy devotee that will appreciate this dark story.

Themes Fantasy, Polish folklore, Curses, Pain, Submission.

Carolyn Hull

Don't worry, Felix by Yohann Devezy and Katharine Alice. Illus. by Zoe Bennett

cover image

It is Felix’s first day at a new school. When he gets into the car with his family, he finds a red balloon, and as the family gets closer to the school, the balloon gets bigger. The balloon incorporates all the worries Felix has about starting his new school. Then when it is his turn to read, the balloon is so big it covers his mouth.

The balloon is a metaphor for Felix’s worries and concerns about change. And we see the little boy floundering as he wants to play with the others at break, but his balloon gets in the way. In bed that night the balloon is still there but when Dad comes in to say goodnight, he sees that something is upsetting the boy. He asks him about his worries, then tells him his trick for dealing with them. He gets Felix to try the trick of breathing in and out while pinching his fingers. Felix finds that it works, and he sleeps. Riding to school the next day the balloon reappears, so Dad and Felix practise the special trick, and the balloon becomes smaller and smaller as the day goes on.

At break Felix finds another child sitting by himself just as he had done. He goes up to the child, asking how he feels, and when he tells him, Felix shares his Dad’s special trick.  Together the two practise Dad’s special trick, ensuring they feel calm and compatible.

This is a neat story about confidence, about overcoming anxiety and fears, with a proven breathing exercise that many people practise every day.

It is wonderfully coiled into the story,  making it an easy way to acquaint children with the fact that many people feel the same way and practise this simple breathing exercise.

Illustrator Zoe Bennett draws beautifully presented children in a variety of poses, promoting their inventiveness, playfulness and courage. She uses water colour, gouache and digital methods to create her cheeky mob of children whose emotions are clearly obvious by the looks on their faces. Zoe is an animal lover and has included different animals in the background of her work. I loved the images set in the school, reminding children of their role in being part of the school cohort, not just there to learn, but also to advise, share and befriend others. Felix’s sharing of his new found skill with another child is a lovely end to this story and reinforces the fact that we all play a part in the school environment. Teacher's notes are available.

Themes Confidence, Anxiety, Breathing, Mediation, Sharing, School.

Fran Knight

Lani and the Universe by Victoria Carless

cover image

Lani Scrub is 11 years old, and in Year 6 at St Agatha’s. She is passionate about quantum physics and astronomy – and particularly obsessed with celebrity scientist, Kit Galway, and the upcoming Junior Interschool Science Championship Cup (which she has been looking forward to since Year 3). She is a quirky girl who deals with anxiety and only has one friend.

At home, Lani’s anaesthetist dad is so busy working long shifts that he’s become a virtual stranger, and her mum’s enthusiasm for nature (including getting backyard chickens and researching home permaculture gardening) couldn’t be more opposite to non-outdoorsy Lani.  

But suddenly Lani and her mum swap their normal lives for a tree change – living with the ‘Folk’ of a nature-based community called Passing Waters. Lani very reluctantly agrees to participate for a two-week experiment, and initially does lots of judging and eye-rolling at the ceremonies, clothing, ‘skooling’ and food involved in the community. She is determined to just get through the fortnight and slot straight back into her previous life as if this was all a bad dream.

The Folk live in a simple, meaningful and environmentally responsible way. Every member of the community is expected to pull their weight, whether by caring for animals, preparing food, making candles and soaps to sell, or contributing to buildings and ceremonies. The lovely theme of environment is entwined with respect and acknowledgement for the traditional Indigenous custodians of the Passing Waters land.

What Lani doesn’t expect is that she will be challenged and changed by this short experiment. That she’ll make friends, learn more about science and space (thanks to a resident astronomer), and come to care for the land, animals and Folk around her. This all sounds quite heavy but a thread of humour runs through the book, adding a light-heartedness that young readers will appreciate.

This is Victoria Carless’ second middle grade novel, following the popular release of Gus and the Starlight in 2022. Both novels share themes of science and family, and finding a meaningful place to belong. The book ends with just over two pages titled ‘sources and further reading about the science concepts in this story’ which is a fabulous resource for keen young STEM fans.

Themes Environment, Family, Anxiety, Science, Space, Friendship.

Kylie Grant

Riley's failproof guide to... breaking a school record! by Dani Vee and Jules Faber

cover image

Riley Noodle is in Year 6 and she is always in a muddle or finding herself in trouble. She also thinks she's no good at anything, unlike her twin brother, Charlie, who is the best at everything and very highly regarded by all the teachers. She's about to leave primary school and every person except her has broken one school record. Time is ticking and she really wants to achieve her ultimate goal. Black and white line drawings support and break up the text. Those who love this type of easy reading format such as in Diary of a Wimpy Kid or Tom Gates will be likely readers. 

There is quirky chaos around every corner for Riley Noodle. In the first four chapters alone, Riley swallows half of her friend Henry's earthworm and also manages to accidentally eat their class pet. Other unique characteristics abound: Riley's Dad wants to save the Earth so has given up eating meat, Riley's friend Henry is a hot dog eating champion and Riley is obsessed with meat to the point where she hides cheeseburgers in her school locker. It's done in humour, but some of the dialogue borders on insensitive or inappropriate. Riley's teacher says to her 'I gave up on you years ago' and sanctions Riley's clothes being cut off her in the middle of the schoolyard, despite her protestations. The year six children also say some pretty horrible things to each other and at one point the schoolyard bully takes a phone recording of Riley in an embarassing situation. There is no follow-up on this incident and it is portrayed as being quite a normal occurrence. Riley's dad also rips his pants up on a stage and everybody laughs at him. It wraps up with Riley becoming a bit of an unexpected hero and developing some self-confidence around who she is and what makes her special, but it all seems a bit forced. There is a lot crammed in and then no time or space to tie up all the loose ends. 

Themes Humour, Embarassment.

Nicole Nelson

Astro Chimp by David Walliams. Illus. by Adam Stower

cover image

Unbelievably, this is bestselling author David Walliams's first graphic novel. Featuring full-colour, whole page illustrations, this takes the quirky humour of Walliams and makes it accessible to a wider audience than many of his text-heavy titles. Different format aside, his distinctive voice hits you from the get go: 'The rocket lifted off from the ground, and shot into the sky like a rocket. Oh, it's already a rocket. All right, then, it shot off into the sky faster than something else that was still really, really, really fast!'. You can tell while reading this that restraining his narration to a bare minimum was probably difficult for Walliams and I have to say it left me wanting this to be a longer, more fleshed out saga. However, what's there is still fantastic, humorous and infectiously fun to read. 

Chump the chimpanzee is off on a rocket to orbit the Earth. All he has to do is sit in his seat and NOT push the red button...What could go wrong? Everything, it seems. The rest of the story takes place 50 years later, when, after being frozen solid in space like an icicle, Chump is accidentally awoken by Dmitri, the one and only dog space pirate. And then ensues a crazy journey through space as they meet many other animals shot off into space by humans, each with a crazy origin story: giant fruit flies, a space police force made up of nine cloned cats and the two tortoises of the space emergency rescue team. Witty dialogue between the animals is the highlight as is the inanity of Chump and the pure madness of the whole thing. A smattering of toilet humour keeps everything ticking alone nicely. There is also an intriguing and brief history of animals in space at the end of the book as all the characters are based on real animals that were indeed blasted into space by humans. This one will be thoroughly enjoyed by all David Walliams fans, graphic novel aficionados, lovers of space travel stories and anyone who just likes a quick laugh at a silly tale.

Themes Humour, Graphic Novel, Space Travel.

Nicole Nelson

House by Dan Giovannoni & Charlotte Lane

cover image

This visually stunning picture book is one to read by children and adults of all ages. The deeply thoughtful and compelling story about the loneliness felt firstly by the house and then the young child, shares unspoken moments that many readers may feel when all seems lost and hopeless.

The large, mystical house believes there is more to life than being isolated and alone. It magically releases itself from its foundations and travels through the dark and stormy sky to find what is missing. Happening upon a young girl whose own feelings of loneliness reach out to house; a strong shared connection is ready to be created. House anchors itself to the earth and the child finds comfort and safety in its beautiful quirky rooms.

The lyrical prose is full of descriptive imagery and the spacing and movement of words across the pages add to the imaginative quality of the story. The astonishing illustrations in dark tones for the journey and vibrant colour when the young girl is safely cocooned in and exploring this wondrous place, perfectly complement the text and add their own deep layers to this delightful narrative.

For parents, carers, teachers and librarians this is an exquisite story to share and discuss with children who may be struggling with deep feelings of loneliness. It is a story full of hope that friendship and connection can be found in unexpected ways. Teaching notes and a teaching activity are available from the publisher.

Themes Loneliness, Connection, Friendship, Searching, Safety, Imagination, Creativity.

Kathryn Beilby

Extreme animal facts by Jennifer Cossins

cover image

Well-known author/illustrator Jennifer Cossins has added to her impressive collection of books with another fascinating look at animals. This time though, the animals mentioned are some of the record holders in their category with some very unusual habits. There is the biggest category which include the blue whale, elephant, ostrich as well as the goliath beetle which is the world’s heaviest insect. The slowest moving category mentions the sloth, the Gila monster and the slowest of all, the sea anemone which rarely moves but if it does it is one cm per hour!

There are so many more interesting record holders included. Some of these are the most epic migrations, the most venomous, the strongest bite, the most babies, the fastest wingbeats and the very interesting, most unusual mating ritual with the bowerbird mentioned.

This is an engaging book to pour over with so many varied creatures and their quirky behaviours discussed. The muted colour palette changes for each page with the text well-spaced amongst the labelled beautifully drawn illustrations of the chosen creatures. There is a contents page at the beginning along with an introduction and a glossary at the end.

Another wonderful addition to a home, school or public library. Teacher's notes are available.

Themes Extraordinary Animals, Facts, Habitats.

Kathryn Beilby

Brave Kahu & the Porangi magpie by Shelley Burne-Field

cover image

For her first children's fiction book, Shelley Burne-Field from Te Matau-a-Maui (Hawke's Bay) in New Zealand, wanted to write an adventure story in the vein of the classic Watership Down, that included love, hope, danger, birth and death. She says, "Kids can handle that sort of information. It is part of their lives and so we should talk about it. The best authors who write the best books don't dumb down their readers or take them for idiots." Her idea for this story came from watching a hawk get attacked by a small group of magpies and this is essentially the crux of the story - a flock of magpies have killed Poto's mother and are now threatening the harmony of the valley where her hawke family live. Adding to the drama is the prophecy of an impending earthquake and resulting flood that is going to hit the valley in just three days. 

The bird's eye view of the world, combined with Burne-Field's poetic language and rich description make this an absolute joy to read. Tangible and relatable sibling relationships and feelings make the characters come to life to the point that you almost forget you are taking on the viewpoint of a bird rather than a human (if it wasn't for the obvious bird behaviours!). If you don't come away from this book watching birds and trying to work out their internal monologue and their backstory it would be surprising, as the author paints such rich and complex lives for these characters. There are no perfect prototypes here - everyone is flawed and troubled to some degree. There is also a lot of drama, both within the family group as well as violent fighting between the birds and other animals. 

The use of Te Reo Maori language is fantastic but it is quite heavily used and it's often not possible to pick up the meaning of the word from the context clues alone. Reliance on flipping back to the Glossary is a reality of reading this, so it becomes quite a complex read, hence the slightly older age recommendation. Even the word 'autism' is given in Maori, used in reference to Poto's brother Ari. 

Overall, this is a beautifully written story full of heavy drama. While not one for the lover of light-hearted tales, this will be enthralling for those who can handle a more serious read and who can cope with the constant language switch up. It also makes a good read aloud, but due to the constant need for translation probably more suited to a one or one than a class novel. Teacher's notes and activity notes are available from the publisher.

Themes Birds, Adventure, Family.

Nicole Nelson

Stand proud by Nicho Hynes, Marlee Silva. Illus. by Blak Douglas

cover image

This powerful story about Rugby League star Nicho Hynes shares an important message about identity and feeling comfortable in oneself. Nicho grew up knowing he had an Aboriginal mother who was one of the Stolen Generation but Nicho struggled with his own understanding of what this meant. He was continually belittled by other non-Aboriginal people as he did not have the same colouring. Yet when he sees Bruce representing his culture on Harmony Day, he is drawn to find out more and take part in traditional dancing. He feels a connection.

Over time Nicho learns more about his family and his past and finds acceptance with his people and cultural identity. Nicho learns he is a Wiradjuri man with a strong community who embrace him with arms wide open. He is a ‘loud, proud blackfella’ and continues to fulfil this saying that his mother instilled in him.

The striking illustrations in bold, vibrant colour add to the engagement of the story and enrich the narrative. For young children who are struggling with cultural and own self-acceptance this is an important book to share and discuss.

Themes First Nations people, Identity, Family, Rugby League, Culture, Stolen Generation, Connection.

Kathryn Beilby

Taronga presents: Night owls by Kristin Darell. Illus. by Laura Wood

cover image

The fourth and final book in the Taronga Presents series written by author Kristin Darell is called Night Owls and showcases the zoo in the evening. It’s the Christmas school holidays and Sophia and Ollie are back volunteering at Taronga Zoo in Sydney, Australia. For their first job of the day as volunteers they are tasked with solving a Treasure Trek activity in one hour, where cryptic animal clues lead them to name each of the four mystery animals. This trek takes them all over the zoo and finally to the habitat of JR, a long-beaked echidna more than 50 years old. The children are worried JR is missing but they find out he is in another enclosure and may come out during the evening to go back to his usual home. Sophia and Ollie ask to stay and help out at night with moving JR and happily they are given permission by their parents to do so.

Once Taronga Zoo closes for the day, it becomes a different place. Sophia and Ollie are amazed at the noise of the animals, the sunset and the thrill of joining in and helping with the “Roar and Snore” tour.  They wander around with torches that glow red in order to not distress the animals. Ollie finds the night walk a touch scary but with the help of Sophia he copes well.

The thoughtful illustrations spread throughout give more context to the story for those readers who appreciate visual clues. The Treasure Trek quiz is a clever way of sharing animal facts with readers as is Ollie’s Fun Fact File in the final pages. This book would be wonderful hook for teachers to read to students when Information Report writing is focused on during the school year. There are so many different animals discussed and facts given that students could research further and build upon their knowledge.

Themes Taronga Zoo, Animals, Volunteers, Friendship, Night Walks.

Kathryn Beilby

Taronga presents: Baby boom by Kristin Darell. Illus. by Laura Wood

cover image

The third book in the Taronga Presents series written by author Kristin Darell has the title Baby Boom. Best friends Ollie and Sophia are now fully trained Taronga Zoo volunteers and undertake lots of jobs throughout the day where they are interacting with the zoo animals. At all times they are under supervision from adult zookeepers who trust Sophie and Ollie to do the right thing and listen to their instructions.

In this story there is a real baby boom at the zoo and the children are fortunate to observe some of the newest additions. These include three baby Sumatran tiger cubs, meerkat pups, a surprise kangaroo joey, bearded dragon offspring, chimpanzee baby and a pygmy hippo calf. They also are able to help feed and look after a baby wombat that has no mother. For Sophia there is a bit of an uncomfortable moment when she has to share Ollie with his younger sister Katy, but eventually she is able to work through her feelings and all is sorted out.

Throughout this book are delightful illustrations that provide valuable visual images to further engage readers. There are facts cleverly interwoven through the narrative and quite a few puns add a touch of humour. Ollie’s Fun Fact File in the final pages of the book are an added bonus.

This series would be a wonderful classroom read aloud for junior to middle primary children.

Themes Taronga Zoo, Animals, Volunteers, Friends, Family, Babies, Facts.

Kathryn Beilby

The Imagineer by Christopher Cheng and Lucia Masciullo

cover image

Penny loves to build things: she draws up plans, gather bits and pieces and builds. In her tiny apartment, she has built a spaceship with interstellar communications, and a submarine to explore the deep oceans. She plans and builds then takes things apart to try again. One day she visits her grandpa who lives a long way away in a vey big house. Penny is delighted and tries out the things she finds in his rooms. She tries the harmonium while he peddles, she turns the handle of the butter churn. Grandpa tells her that everything has a purpose, and when she discovers his shed, stacked full of purposeful things, she is flabbergasted. She takes a close look at all the things before her, convinced that she will be able to build something very useful for her grandpa, and she does.

This beautiful book delights in encouraging the imaginations of the readers, with pages full of fascinating bits and pieces which can be found in old sheds. Children will be full of awe at the things they have heard about, and take a cue from the book to try to adapt things for themselves.

Masciullo’s wonderful pencil and watercolour illustrations will capture the reader’s attention as their eyes peruse the wondrous array of old things, now no longer in use, but which could still be repurposed. They will be amazed at the old things in the shed roof, or in Grandpa’s house, and delight at the planning that makes place to make something useful out of the old stuff.

The fold out drawing of the gizmo that Penny makes will keep children amused as they work out just what Penny and Grandpa used to make the machine. I loved the fold out image of the machine built to help Grandpa, and the way Penny’s ideas are pegged to a clothesline across the pages.

At the end of the book are a number of pages devoted to the things that an imagineer can use, and two pages giving details about some of the old things spotted in the rooms. And the endppapers too hold interest for those who would like to see more of Penny’s plans. This wonderful book not only encourages reusing things, but also highlights the relationship between a child and her grandfather, and her willingness to try something new, to repurpose things found in the house.

Themes Imagination, STEM, Building, Creativity, Planning, Grandfathers.

Fran Knight

The 113th assistant librarian by Stuart Wilson

cover image

For Oliver Wormwood the calling to a profession in his magical world is layered with uncertainty and the pressures of family expectations. His anxiety does not easily disappear once he takes on the role as 113th Library Assistant, and then almost immediately replaces the Librarian in difficult circumstances. This Library is not a boring, quiet place of dust and dullness, but it contains the wonders and dangers of knowledge. And some of this knowledge is extremely dangerous. Oliver finds a new friend, some helpful cats and eventually works out ways to protect the library from threats internal and external. 

This is a wonderful, whimsical, magical, radical and risky adventure that will appeal to all who love libraries and the treasures hidden within. There are magical elements, coming-to-maturity moments, overcoming fear and threat, and the wonders of a world that is a mystery. I loved this joyful step inside a different world and will be looking forward to another library adventure from Stuart Wilson with Oliver Wormwood as Librarian,  restricting, cataloguing and controlling the books and those who seek to exploit knowledge.  This is the kind of book that fantasy and book lovers will appreciate. For avid readers aged 9-14 this will be a loved journey of discovery.  It has a few elements of the Harry Potter sorting hats, but the location in the world of words and books is a different kind of magic.

Themes Fantasy, Magic, Libraries, Librarians, Families.

Carolyn Hull