Reviews

In the Clearing by J. P. Pomare

cover image

Hachette, 2020. ISBN: 9781869713393.
Recommended for adults. J. P. Pomare delivers a taut psychological thriller loosely based on the Victorian Family Cult which controlled its followers through brainwashing and subjected the children to abuse.
Told in two voices, teenager Amy who lives in the Clearing, totally dominated by the Elders and adult Freya who lives with her son Billy in a safe house, scared of the outside world. The author builds a tightly controlled plot, leaving little breadcrumbs - times, dates, family structure, even chapter headings, be very aware as Freya's and Amy's stories take you on an emotional journey.
Security is key in Freya's world, she's escaped from an horrific upbringing and taken refuge in an isolated farmhouse, protected by her guard dog Rocky. Shutters, a security system, panic buttons and a fire bunker, all assist Freya in her bid to be safe and protected. When bunches of flowers are left on her doorstep and strangers are seen at her swimming hole, Freya's anxiety levels build, her paranoia grows, and she feels a sense of deja vu. Her first son Aspen was kidnapped, and she is over-vigilant in protecting Billy.
Amy's diary entries chronicle the deprivation, the rigid control, the brainwashing and terror she experiences in The Clearing. The chosen children are starved, forced to hide in The Hole when strangers visit, have their sleep controlled and suffer cruel punishments. Amy believes that outsiders are blue devils and she must remain true to Adrienne their leader. When new girl Asha who was kidnapped on her way home from school, tells of her life on the outside, Amy begins to question her life and the world outside.
In the Clearing is filled with twists and turns, at times very graphic and confronting, skilfully written, even frightening at times. Pomare's tension-building plot, his separate yet interconnected storylines and explosive conclusion, make this a powerful psychological suspense novel. Themes: Psychological thriller, Cults - Australia, Missing Persons, Secrecy.
Rhyllis Bignell

Scorch Dragons by Amie Kaufman

cover image

Elementals book 2. HarperCollins Children's Books, 2019. ISBN: 9781460755280. 448pp. pbk.
(Age: Middle Years 9+) Recommended. Dragons, wolves, adventure and magic. What else does a middle grade reader want in a book? Just imagine being able to transform into a dragon or a wolf, something any middle grader would love to do.
Scorched Dragons is, Amie Kaufman's second book from Elementals series. I can see why she is a New York Bestseller author.
Right from the start I knew it will be a book I could not put down. I loved the detailed map of the land of Vallen I was about to visit.
I have not read book one, Ice Wolves and I gathered that Scorched Dragons leads on from after the war that reunited Anders and Rayna who are twins that are totally opposites. Together with Lisabet they go on a hunt for a weather changing artefact called the Snowstone. They must find the Snowstone or the dragons will be in trouble.
I loved reading about the history of the conflict between dragons and the wolves and why each other hated the other. It was great to see wolves and dragons working together to save everyone and learning that the things they were taught over the years about each other were untrue. Anders and Rayna also discover who their parents are.
Scorched Dragons is a great fantasy book all about adventure, magic, transformation magic, friendships and friendships between enemies.
The characters were good and you could picture them transforming into dragons and wolves. They did stay in their human form most of the time which made it easier for me to relate to what was happening and finding the story more real.
I must say, Kess is my favourite character. Their lost cat that reappears during the story. Hehe can you tell I'm a cat person.
Maria Komninos

The other Bennet sister by Janice Hadlow

cover image

Pan Macmillan, 2020. ISBN: 9781509842032. 320pp.
(Age: 15+) Highly recommended. Mary is the other Bennet sister, the one we hear least about in Jane Austen's Pride and prejudice. Jane and Lizzie, the two eldest are beautiful and intelligent, the two younger ones, Kitty and Lydia, are vain and flighty, and Mary is the one in the middle, the plain and serious one with her head in books. Mary is the object of her mother's disdain, seen as the most unattractive and least marriageable of her daughters, and even her father spares little thought for her, Lizzie being his favourite.
Author Hadlow takes the character of Mary and retells Austen's story from Mary's perspective. Part One is Pride and prejudice retold, we remember key scenes and events but told by a different narrator. This section of the novel would make an excellent focus for the English curriculum study of appropriation and adaptation as a literary device.
But then Hadlow goes further. She imagines what happens to Mary after the ending of Pride and prejudice when the four other sisters are all happily settled and secure in their marriages. Mary is in an extremely untenable position with no home of her own, no income, no marriage prospects, and parents that are embarrassed by her. She moves from place to place staying in turn with sisters, friends and relatives. She continues to read, the subjects more and more intellectually demanding, and she observes the marriages of others, gradually coming to an appreciation of the qualities that make a good relationship. As she matures, she is fortunate to have the encouragement of some who have an appreciation of her good qualities and intellect, and there are even male companions who seem to take an interest in her.
In Hadlow's story, Mary is the kind of heroine we find in Jane Eyre, self-effacing and lonely, a plain but good natured, intelligent woman who longs for the love and companionship of someone who recognises her good qualities. She has to overcome the humiliating experiences of her youth and eventually blossom into a confident person who can take her place in society. Like Austen, Hadlow has told a fascinating story that explores identity, love, marriage, class and the role of women in the 19th century.
Helen Eddy

Willy Wonka's everlasting book of fun by Roald Dahl

cover image

Penguin Random House, 2020. ISBN: 9780241428139.
(Ages: 7-12). Highly recommended. An activity book filled with games, activities, recipes and information all centred around the characters and story of Charlie and the chocolate factory by Roald Dahl. Willy Wonka introduces the book with a chapter about the chocolate factory and presents games and quizzes that tell you about the chocolate factory, different sweets to read about and make plus quiz questions to test your knowledge of the story.
The book then takes a chapter for each character - Charlie Bucket, Augustus Gloop, Violet Beauregarde, Veruca Salt and Mike Teavee. Ending the book is a chapter about the Oomp-Loompas and then lastly included at the end is a chapter of the original book which was never included in the published version. Scattered throughout the book are those fantastic, whimsical illustrations by Quentin Blake.
The activities in the chapters revolve around the things the characters encountered in the story and each chapter is about 15 pages long and is a mixture of recipes, word finds, quiz questions, drawing activities, experiments and games. The advertising for this book says there are over 365 activities in total, enough to keep a child busy for months, especially on rainy days. Classroom teachers using Charlie and the chocolate factory as a read aloud story could include the quiz questions and other activities in this book alongside the reading to really involve children in the Roald Dahl experience. Themes: Amusements, Puzzles, Roald Dahl characters.
Gabrielle Anderson

Bone china by Laura Purcell

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2019. ISBN: 9781526602527. 384pp.
(Age: Adolescent - Adult) This story begins with Hester Why's enigmatic statement that 'love is fragile' and it is indeed clearly her past experiences, her fear and unsettled present that, we gather, are 'dragging her' to Cornwall in the midst of a chilling winter, to find work as an escape from her previous life. Doctor Pinecroft's large house, in which she is to live and work, is depicted as 'grey, wide and squat' standing with its 'rough-cast face' on the 'crest of the cliff'. This gripping tale tells of the harshness of life at that time, as we are drawn into the chill, and indeed the dread that Hester experiences daily, knowing that not only might she catch the disease, but also is aware that her employers would fire her if they were to discover her past and her secrets.
Doctor Pinecroft is described as a visionary, determined to find a way to treat the tuberculosis that has heavily affected his family, and indeed that has taken the lives of so many others, but is also in search of a cure. In his bold experiment, a group of prisoners from a local gaol in Cornwall are released into his care. He sets up a campsite, where he daily spends some time with them living in old caves by the sea. His wild plan is that the crippling cold and sea air will enable the men to beat the disease - a desperate hope.
Working for the doctor's family, Hester is one of the few women involved in supporting the men. As the story is told through her experiences, we learn about the lives of the servants of that era, and their ever-present fear of illness and poverty. Opium, alcohol and other drugs appear to be available, and we read of the problems that these and other drugs cause. Yet we are positioned to grasp the dread of the illness experienced by so many people during that time, and to understand the consequent despair that runs through the whole narrative. It is a wild story in its own way, lively, evocative and sadly indicative of the terrible living conditions for many people in that historical time and place.
This intriguing narrative, that gives us a vivid picture of the way people lived and of the understandable fears that troubled everyone at that time, is a comprehensive, well-written work that would be most suitable for both adult and adolescent reading.
Elizabeth Bondar

Where's Peppa's magical unicorn?

cover image

Penguin Random House, 2020. ISBN: 9780241412046. 10pp.
(Age: 1-4) Daddy Pig is helping Peppa look for her magical unicorn. It isn't in her toy cupboard, that's just Horsey Twinkle Toes. "Where else shall we look?" asks Daddy Pig. "A fairy-tale castle!" says Peppa. And so the search continues, across an array of settings including the beach and the bottom of the rainbow. But each time Peppa is disappointed; the tail poking out of a dragon bush is not a unicorn tail after all - it's a kite! And the glow at the end of the rainbow? It's a pot of gold, not Magical Unicorn. A disappointed Peppa heads home, but as soon they are safely inside the doorbell rings; it is Grandpa Pig . . . with Peppa's magical unicorn. She's been hiding out at Grandpa and Grandma Pig's house and Peppa is so glad to see her.
Young ones will love lifting the flaps as they join in Peppa's search for her special friend. The glittery front cover will catch their attention and the familiar and comforting world of Peppa Pig will hold their attention. This sturdily made board book will delight little Peppa fans and allows for self-exploration as well as shared reading. Themes: Board book, Lift-the-flap book, Peppa Pig.
Nicole Nelson

The Good Hawk by Joseph Elliott

cover image

Walker Books, 2020. ISBN: 9781406385854. 368pp.
(Age: Upper primary - secondary) Highly recommended. The Good Hawk by Joseph Elliott has a solid central character in Agatha. It is a fantasy story where two friends are forced to leave their ravaged home and travel to distant, frightening places that are shrouded in dark history and mystery. The use of the Scottish-Gaelic and Old Norse language throughout adds to the ethereal, otherworldly atmosphere of this tale.
Agatha is a loyal and steadfast character who perseveres against all odds to defend and uphold her clan and her friends. We hear her pure and unaffected voice in the first person. She stutters but she expresses herself with the clarity of the innocent. She sees through people to their true core and she has a special and unique skill - communication with animals. Early on the reader hears that she is teased - told that she should have been thrown off a cliff as a babe. We read that she looks different. We understand that she has a disability, that she is not able to do some things and that people think they can't rely on her. But she has a steely pride - she is a Hawk. Jamie is her friend with his own fears and undiscovered strengths.
Their journey to rescue their clan takes supreme courage in the face of fearsome obstacles, the out-and-out brutality of evil foes and frightening mystical, wild, primeval forces.
There is consideration of the alternative perspectives of all manner of cultural and societal beliefs and practices as our two heroes encounter extraordinarily outlandish good and evil characters during their journey. Love remains demonstratively pure and powerful throughout.
This book is not for the faint hearted but it is redemptive. Elliott's depiction of a heroine with Down's syndrome is wonderful. I agree with Katya Balen, author of The Space We're In in her praise for Elliott's portrayal of Agatha. She is indeed . . . "the sort of hero children's literature has been lacking for too long."
The Good Hawk is a swashbuckling adventure set in a fantasy world somewhere up in the North Sea in the vicinity of the Isle of Skye, Scotland and Norway; The Space We're In is more domestic. Both books are powerful portrayals of lived disability. They will surprise and grip the reader. The gap that has existed for books about heroes with disabilities is at last being addressed and it is a very good thing.
I highly recommend both books to Upper Primary and Senior School students. Teacher's notes are available.
Wendy Jeffrey

Spinoza's overcoat: Travels with writers and poets by Subhash Jaireth

cover image

Transit Lounge, 2020. ISBN: 9781925760460.
(Age: Adult) Non-fiction. This collection of essays by Jaireth explores the poetry and lives of some of his personally selected writers and poets, some probably not well known to many readers. However his book also includes poems that are the subject of his study, so the reader is able to read the original words and also follow his explorations of meaning and place. Jaireth is intrigued to actually visit some of the scenes described, or the places where the words were written, seeking to understand more fully the experience of the poets he is curious about. Thus he travels to hidden places in Prague, Paris, Leiden, Amsterdam, Moscow and other cities, to trace the paths of Kafka's sister, Paul Celan, Bulgakov, Spinoza, Pasternak, and Hiromi Ito, among others. And in sharing his explorations, and his search to understand more of the written words that fascinate him, he also shares some snippets of his own life, his personal travails and search for self-expression.
I was most interested in his discoveries of the ancient city of Baghdad, the City of Peace, a circular city built within a circle of fire, setting for many of the stories of The Thousand and One Nights, the original city now replaced and overbuilt by a sprawling new city, following wars, terrorism and looting. Jaireth hopes that the tales of Baghdad may be rediscovered in sculptures by Ghani Hikmar and new monuments dedicated to the rebirth of Iraqi culture.
For Jaireth, the writer's choice of particular scenes, particular words, the rhythmic meter, the form and shape of poems, and especially the choices made in translation, are a constant source of interest and he shares with us some of the history and the art of the poet, the writer and the translator, an insight that can only enrich our appreciation of the written works he wants us to understand better.
Helen Eddy

Dippy and the Dinosaurs by Jackie French and Bruce Whatley

cover image

Angus and Robertson, 2020. ISBN: 9781460754092. 32pp., hbk.
Dippy the Diprotodon has dug a new hole and the best thing about a hole is that if you have sharp claws you can make it bigger and bigger. In fact you can make it so big it can take you into another world! A swimming hole, to be precise, one filled with creatures that Dippy doesn't recognise but who he is convinced will want to be friends. But will they?
Right alongside Mothball, Dippy is my favourite literary character because his innocence and expectation that he will be loved epitomises and reflects that of our youngest generation as they learn to navigate the world beyond home and family. It never occurs to Dippy that the creatures that he discovers (and who discover him) will do him harm or be unkind. Both French and Whatley capture this perfectly in text and words demonstrating that while new situations might be different, even strange, that doesn't necessarily mean they are confrontational and antagonistic.
As our littlest ones head off to preschool and big school, they can go with a positive attitude and confidence that yes, it's a new world but it doesn't have to be scary. To explore this in the context of a book about dinosaurs which resonated with that age group is just genius.
For those of you who want to explore the world of Dippy, diprotodons and other megafauna there are teachers' notes (written by me) available.
Barbara Braxton

Under the Milky Way: traditions and celebrations beneath the stars by Frane Lessac

cover image

Candlewick Press, 2020. ISBN: 9781536200959. 31pp.
(Age: 5-10) Recommended. Lovers of festivals and Astronomy enthusiasts are in for a wonderful time as Lessac takes the reader around North America looking at different places and their traditions, all under the Milky Way. Beginning with the ever popular Halloween festival, readers will be enthralled by the detailed illustrations of what the festival looks like in Salem, Massachusetts, with pumpkins peering from all the houses, ghosts and spiders adorning the trees and children all dressed up in costumes. Then there is the information about the origins of the Halloween festival, and Salem. This formula of very colourful and detailed illustrations with captions about the tradition and the place visited is followed as readers find about ice skating in Maple Grove, Minnesota, dragon dancers in San Francisco, night time markets in Toronto, Canada, dog racing in Nome, Alaska, the Nations dancing in Seattle, Washington and so on. At the top of the page is information about the night time celebration in large print which will facilitate reading the book aloud, and the smaller captions of information could be used for discussion about the cities and the festivals.
Two pages of information about the Milky Way and star formations is given at the back of the book and finally readers are instructed to find Lessac's dog Banjo, which is featured on every page. This will immediately make the reader turn back to inspect the busy, brightly coloured pages with all their tiny figures to seek out the small brown dog.
A companion to Lessac's Under the Southern Cross, this book is ideal for libraries and classrooms where children will learn not only about festivals in North America but some of its geography and history as well. Themes; Astronomy, Festivals, Night and Day, Galaxies.
Pat Pledger

Love from the Crayons by Drew Daywalt

cover image

Illus. by Oliver Jeffers. HarperCollins, 2019. ISBN: 9780008384920. 32pp., hbk.
Love is yellow and orange.
Because love is sunny and warm.

Join the Crayons as they bring us another charming tale, this time about how love is many colours depending on how we are feeling and what we are doing at the time.
Explore how love can be shown in so many ways apart from saying those three words, and then take it further by investigating how we often assign colours to our emotions and how colours can affect and reflect our moods.
Something charming for Valentine's Day and Library Lovers' Day.
Barbara Braxton

Imaginary friend by Stephen Chbosky

cover image

Orion Books, 2019. ISBN: 9781409184812. 704 pp.
(Age: Adult) Fans of horror stories and who have the constitution to read this massive volume of 704 pages will find a different story to Chbosky's famous The Perks of Being a Wallflower. After Kate leaves an abusive relationship she hides in the small community of Mill Grove, where she hopes she and her 7 year old son Christopher will be safe. Christopher makes friends with a boy named Special Ed. He and a group of boys spend a lot of time in the Mission Street Woods where they build a tree house, given instructions by a strange man that only Christopher can hear. Christopher appears to access a strange world through this treehouse and disappears for six days, reappearing with his learning disability gone. Then the town goes into meltdown.
There is a sense of menace hanging over the narrative that is quite frightening as Christopher gets headaches and a hissing lady whispers into people's ears. Fear is the overarching theme of the book and this pervasive fear may keep some readers reading to the conclusion, with its overtones of Christianity. Verdict: Horror fans will enjoy this, but other readers may find the repetition, strange spelling and length of the story a problem.
Pat Pledger

Wheels by Sally Sutton

cover image

Illus. by Brian Lovelock. Walker Books, 2020. ISBN: 9781760651589. 32pp.
(Age: 2-5) Highly recommended. Lots of fun to be had for any child who is interested in things that move, this book will have young children guessing just what wheels belong to the picture illustrated as they read along to the rhyming verse.
Rumbly wheels, grumbly wheels,
Hauling-up-the-hill wheels.
Wheels go fast, wheels go slow.
Shout what's coming, if you know!

Readers and listeners will love to chime in with the little boy and child in the story as they guess the type of vehicle that the wheels belong to. The refrain "Wheels go fast, wheels go slow. Shout what's coming, if you know!" is repeated with each new vehicle and this adds to the enjoyment of the narrative while making it a most enjoyable read aloud for parents and teachers in the classroom. Sutton's narrative and Lovelock's bright engaging illustrations give lots of hints about the nature of the mode of transport and its uses. For example, in the drawings of the rubbish truck, bins are lined up on the streets in the very early morning, and garbage men in bright safety coats are collecting them to take to the bright yellow rubbish truck.
Children will also learn the proper name of the vehicles that are described: a rig, motorbike, taxi, firetruck, rubbish truck, school bus and scooter. On the second last double page spread the family is seen riding bikes with the little girl scooting along and all the vehicles parading on the elevated road above. And finally "Parts of a wheel" is a labelled illustration that shows all the different parts that combine to make a wheel.
The combination of Sutton and Lovelock have also produced Dig, dump, roll, and Ambulance, ambulance! and this is sure to be another book to please both boys and girls. Themes: Transport, Vehicles, Wheels, Bicycles.
Pat Pledger

Tunnel of bones by Victoria Schwab

cover image

Cassidy Blake book 2. Scholastic, 2019. ISBN: 9781407196930. 272pp.
(Age: 11-14) Recommended. Cass and Jacob (her ghost best friend) have another exciting adventure in the wonderful city of Paris, where Cass's parents are filming their TV show The Inspecters. Cass's skills as a ghost hunter are still growing and in this fast paced story, she accidentally wakes up a very scary poltergeist in the catacombs that lie beneath the city. It is up to her to stop the ghost destroying things as it twirls around in a strange game of Hide and Seek.
The book opens with a map of Paris, showing all the world famous tourist destinations, which Cass and her parents visit, but it is the catacombs that will fascinate the reader as Cass becomes embroiled in the mystery of the little boy who begins to create havoc in the city. The realisation that there are tunnels of bones beneath the streets will intrigue while the story behind the young poltergeist will also tug at the heartstrings as Cass and Jacob gradually unravel what happened many years ago.
A Goodreads Choice Award Nominee for Middle Grade and Children's books (2019) this was a fun read and the setting of Paris was fabulous. This could be read as a stand-alone but fans of the ghost genre would really enjoy the first in the series City of ghosts (2018), and at 272 pages it is not too long and very easy to read. It is a book that will appeal to reluctant readers as well. Themes: Ghosts, Paris (France), Psychic ability, Friendship.
Pat Pledger

The Creature Choir by David Walliams

cover image

Illus. by Tony Ross. HarperCollins, 2019. ISBN: 9780008262198. 32pp., hbk.
Warble the walrus loved to sing and her dream was to one day take part in The Great Big Animal Talent Show. Sadly though, her warbling was somewhat less than melodic - in fact it was shocking - and eventually the other walruses banned her from ever singing again. While this made Warble very sad, she tried hard to stay silent but she just couldn't and burst into song. The consequences were disastrous - she caused an avalanche and everyone was buried in deep snow. So while Warble slept that night they all crept away leaving her alone. But she continued to warble and that attracted a lot of other creatures who also liked to sing but whose voices were also a little rough around the edges. Warble never said no to any of them and soon they had a choir, one that sang all around the world and was finally ready to enter The Great Big Animal Talent Show!
Being one of those with a voice like Warble who liked to sing but whose singing seemed to offend everyone (even strangers on a bus trip in the middle of nowhere at midnight!) this story really resonated with me. Being about being true to yourself and doing what you love just for the sheer joy of it, not because you believe you are the best (or even want to be) epitomises the feeling behind the mantra "Dance like nobody's watching!" This would be the most wonderful story to have the children imagine and make the noises the various creatures would, and create their own choir that sings and dances just for joy. There could be all sorts of ways to explore tone and rhythm and how they can combine to make something that is pleasing to the ear while just having fun!
Barbara Braxton