Reviews

Where's Wally? The Incredible Paper Chase by Martin Handford

cover image

Walker Books, 2009. ISBN: 9781406324464.
(All ages) Wally's back-if you can find him!
'The search for Wally continues through more astounding scenes in this new classic title in the Where's Wally? Series. As Wally travels through worlds of dinosaurs, soldiers and clowns he leaves a tiny piece of paper to look for in every scene. Can you find it?' Walker Books Press Release
Wally is a global phenomenon. I couldn't believe that over 47 million copies have been sold across 30 countries - although on reflection of the popularity of this series in my own school library I am really not that surprised. Wally is a cultural icon, even appearing on the cover of Rolling Stone magazine - I doubt there are too many book characters with that claim to fame.
Creator Martin Handford spends about 2 months completing each scene, using a list of jokes, puns and funny happenings as his starting point. As you carefully scan over the pages looking for that ever elusive Wally your eye is continuously drawn to the different interactions and humour within the page. Each time you open the book and try again to find Wally (I haven't on every page yet), you notice new characters come to life.
This version of Wally also comes with the added bonus of fold out board game and press out circus, making the journey with Wally even more interactive for those who are young and young at heart.
I am sure this latest in the Where's Wally series, containing all the old favourite characters along with some kooky new ones will appeal to all Wally hunters.
Zana Thiele

Monster War by Dean Lorey

cover image

(Nightmare Academy series). HarperCollins, 2010. ISBN: 9780061340505.
(Age 12+) In this book, the third of the series, Charlie Benjamin is called upon to stop the evil Fifth Queen of Nightmares from summoning all of the monsters from the Nether to destroy the earth. From her lair in Central Park New York, the Fifth is summoning and commanding golems to take control of the whole Earth (there is even a brief mention of Australia). To stop this from happening Charlie needs to obtain the Sword of Sacrifice. Charlie's quest is made more difficult because of his exile from the Academy as punishment for something that he didn't do. Charlie's loyal band of friends decides to join him however, defying the orders of their Academy commanders, to the Netherworld and back-again, several times, in order to help find the Sword and defeat the Fifth. The small group face several obstacles along the way including: a misunderstood witch and a traitor from the former ally turned traitor and part-lobster called Pinch. Charlie's loyalties to his friends are sacrificed in order to obtain the sword. This easy to read and at times humorous book has plenty of characters and monsters to remain interesting and would be recommended for readers who like to read more in this type of fantasy series.
Adam Fitzgerald

Rhodon by Elise K. Ackers

cover image

Book 1 of the Rhodon Saga. Sid Harta Publishers, 2010. ISBN 9781921642784.
(Age 12+) Recommended. Ruby has always been an outcast. Animals are terrified of her and strange things happen when she is around. Worst of all, she is the least loved daughter. Although all three girls in her family are adopted, Ruby has never fit in and she feels totally unloved. On her graduation day from Year 10, she meets a strange boy, Finn Gallagher, who tries to get her into a program that would make her dreams come true. Instead, he ruins it, and to make up for her loss, he takes her to his parallel world, Rhodon, where Ruby finds that she no longer is a freak; animals love her and she has wonderful powers. For the first time she feels as if she belongs. But will she risk the lives of the Gallagher family is she stays?
This is a gripping story on two levels: characterisation and unique setting. Ruby's plight in a world where she just doesn't fit demanded my attention from the beginning of the book, as it seemed so real and poignant. I found it hard to imagine a family as uncaring as hers and really wanted her to have a better life. I became totally engrossed in hoping that somewhere she would be happy with people who cared for her. It was a relief when she finds acceptance in the warm, loving atmosphere of Finn's home. It was good to see the Gallagher family, both parents and siblings, being so responsible and generous. Ruby is a great main character, courageous and caring about the welfare of others.
The other engrossing aspect of this story is Rhodon, the parallel world to Kyanos, or Earth as we know it. It was fun following Ruby as she weaved her way through life in Rhodon, struggling with Customs officials, money and people who could talk to animals. Olive, the bunny who attaches herself to Ruby, is a terrific character in her own right and one I loved. Emotions are more evident on Rhodon, where they manifest themselves in colour.
There is also plenty of action to keep the most demanding reader continuing to the end of the story. Ruby's powers are amazing, and the fact that she can manipulate 'tears' in the fabric of time is quite fascinating. Her struggles against the charismatic but manipulative Alistor Iron who wants to use her powers for evil, are only just beginning. The second in the series, Dios, which I am looking forward to, will no doubt bring lots more action and intrigue.
This is a story of alienation, coming of age and the love that can be found in a caring family, all wrapped up in an exciting adventure story.
Pat Pledger

Rich and Mad by William Nicolson

cover image

Egmont, 2010. ISBN 9781405247399.
(Age Range:16-18 Upper Secondary) I approached this book with interest, considering the success and popularity of William Nicolson's The Wind on Fire Trilogy presenting fantastical worlds of fast-paced action and imaginative characters all beautifully described. Obviously, the subject matter of Rich and Mad is quite different and, I suspect, strange territory for the author.
Maddy Fisher decides in the opening paragraph that it is time for her to fall in love; 'can't-eat can't-sleep crazy in love.' At this time in her life, though, she has no clue as to who she may fall for. Maddy takes the reader on a love-search journey to home, school, friends' houses and the shops where we share in rather silly, self indulgent conversations with family and friends about her wish to find a love partner. The most unlikely boy around is Rich, yet it is easy to predict that he will make it happen! Rich Ross is in Maddy's year at school but he is attracted to Maddy's friend Grace. There follows a stream of incidences where friends betray each other, and lies and jealousy bring unhappiness.
Nicolson writes a superficial story with little character interest. Any attempts at description are clumsy and ill-fitting. One cannot take seriously the phrase - 'The vapour trails of high-flying jets were slowly disintegrating, forming long streamers of transparent cloud against the blue' to begin a chapter entitled 'The Boy with the Sex Manual'.
There are aspects of this book which will be read and enjoyed but it is generally cliched and lacking depth. There are better books around which look at first sexual experience where characters play out an interesting storyline as well.
Julie Wells

Jekel loves Hyde by Beth Fantaskey

cover image

Penguin, 2010. ISBN 9780143204046.
(Age 14+) Jill Jekel is devastated. Her father has been murdered and the only person who seems to understand her grief is the mysterious Tristen Hyde, who turns up to comfort her at his funeral. Then she discovers that her college fund has spent by her father, her mother is severely depressed, and that all her plans for the future are in chaos. There is one light in the tunnel for her - her science teacher encourages her to make up a chemistry experiment and apply for a scholarship which will fund her future studies. The perfect solution seems to be to join up with Tristen and use the names of Jekel and Hyde to gain the attention of the judges by trading on the Robert Louis Stevenson's story, The strange case of Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde.
Told in alternating chapters by Jill and Tristen, I was fascinated to see how the author conveyed ideas from the classic story into a modern horror setting. Jill finally decides to break into her father's forbidden box in his study and steal the notes about experiments that are in there. When recreating the formula, they hope to save Tristen from the murderous rages that he fears since his grandfather has told him that he is descended from Mr Hyde. But for Jill, a taste of the potion brings out her dark, wild side.
In the meantime Tristen's father has taken over the care of Jill's mother, but when Tristen reads his father's journal, he fears that all is not right. As the two continue their search for the formula, their romance waxes and wanes, the mystery deepens and danger threatens.
With a brooding, gorgeous boy and a girl who is just realising her strengths, a Gothic mystery and some surprising plot turns, there is enough action to keep readers engrossed to the end. Some may even be inspired to turn to Stevenson's classic novel to see why the original story has lasted so long.
Pat Pledger

40 Super human body tricks by Ruben Meerman

cover image

ABC Books, 2009. ISBN 9780733325694.
Middle school. A whole lot of fun can be had reading through and trying out some of the experiments outlined by Surfing Scientist, Ruben Meerman. Featured in ABC TV's RollerCoaster, Meerman is well known to young kids in his aim at making science and the body interesting. From making a broken nose, to counting the amount of sugar in a typical can of soft drink, there are 40 amazing things to do in this book.
I loved the Straw heart beat monitor and tried it myself, as well as the Blind taste test and of course the mind puzzles and brain teasers at the end of the book. I can imagine classes trying out some of the double page instructions for themselves, or kids trying things out at home. It's a funny book, full of easy to read instructions, and easily digested explanations of why these things occur. A contents page that is easy to follow, with 2 pages of Amazing body facts and World records at the end of the book add to the fun of it all, and of course, the last experiment to try is making your own snot. What fun!
Fran Knight

Yellow is my favourite colour by Judy Horacek

cover image

Penguin, 2010. ISBN 9780143504283.
(Age 1-3) Highly recommended. Boardbook. Yellow is my favourite colour is a beautiful picture books in verse which describes all the colours that a little girl likes, although her favourite colour is yellow, because it 'brings sunshine' to her day.
Horacek, the illustrator of Where is the green sheep? by Mem Fox, again brings her beautiful cartoon like figures and vivid colours to this story. The little girl is drawn as such a happy person, her laughing face showing different views of her exuberance as she revels in the different colours. I especially loved the pictures of her bouncing on pink cushions and winning a car race in her yellow car.
It is perfect for small hands to manage and wonderful to read aloud. Not only a joyful addition to stories for the very young, it also provides a parent or caregiver the opportunity to teach the colours in a fun way and then to discuss what the toddler's favourite colour is. After reading this to a young child, it wouldn't be hard to find reminders in the home and on walks of all the colours found in the book.
This is such a happy, energetic book that I am sure it will become a favourite of any young children lucky enough to get their hands on it. Be prepared to read it over and over!
Pat Pledger

Shades series by various authors

cover image

Evans Brothers, 2010.
Dragonwood by Alex Stewart
ISBN 9780237541354
Well recommended. Pip, the Halfling assassin, has taken a bet to obtain the head of Graznik, the leader of the Dragonwood orcs. This is a thriller with a clever twist. It has a good plot followed with strong characters who lead the way. The names are interesting and add to the interest. Pip's relationship with Kalliandashira is interesting to say the least! The plot develops smoothly and the fascinating way the story ends is well concealed.

Off the rails by Anne Rooney
ISBN 9780237541347.
(Age 13+) This book really belongs to the adult section of crime but is written in a very simple way. Karl sees a carpet with a leg hanging out as his train passes a crossing. The reader learns that groups have vendettas against groups of people, in this case gypsies.  
Sue Nosworthy
Editor's note: The publisher recommends the series as suitable for 12-16 year olds and it is aimed at reluctant readers.

Slime Squad vs The Fearsome Fists by Steve Cole

cover image

Random House, 2010. ISBN 9781862308763.
Highly recommended. Another good versus evil by the creator of Astrosaurs, with lots of boy appeal (ie slime, sewers and smelly feet). The unlikely monster hero is Plog and the enemy are the Fearsome Fists. The battle takes place in Trashland where its inhabitants read newspoopers and watch smellyvision. Other members of Slime Squad are Furp, Zill and Danjo whose leader is the 'all seeing PIE', a computer directing them to rescue characters like Mrs Bumflop. Trashland is full of monsters living in 'suburbs' with very humorous names such as Mucky Mattress Marshes, Poo-nited States, Heavy Metal Hills and Plastic Bag Forest, just to name a few. (An extensive list can be viewed on the story map included at the beginning.) Illustrations by Woody Fox enhance written descriptions of Plog with cauldrons on his feet (to stop the smell), and the ugly Fearsome Fists engaged in battle with the Slime Squad. I highly recommend this story for children who love to see good triumph and a monster with nothing going for him become a hero.
Vicki Nunn

Shark Girl by Kelly Bingham

cover image

Candlewick Press 2010. ISBN 9780763646271.
(Ages 12+) This verse novel tells the story of blossoming artist, Jane Arrowood, snatched from the jaws of a shark by her brother, while out swimming with her family. She loses her arm and faces the potential loss of friends, her talent for drawing and painting and her sense of belonging. Told in the first person, Kelly Bingham captures a strong and absorbing voice.
After a long convalescence, cared for by a loving mother and challenging brother, Jane faces her return to school. The journey to some sort of normality is long and difficult and she realises that her life is changed forever. Frustrated, she wants life to be as it was, but, gradually she comes to an understanding of what life now means - she is the one who needs to face the reality and adjust, accepting the love and support of friends and family members, even if they don't always respond as she would hope. She discovers that Max, the school heart-throb may even be interested in her as a person; herself as she is now!
Jane finds comfort in Justin's friendship, a young boy she meets in hospital who has lost his leg. Her confidence is boosted by his pragmatic acceptance of life's disappointments.
He friends respond to her in different ways - as is only natural - but she comes to understand the pressures they place on themselves, too, in confronting her accident.
She learns to understand the responses of her family, though often exasperating.
Her talent for drawing is not lost as she grows in determination and courage. She comes to accept the fact that family photos now reveal a new Jane, but not any less of a person.
Though somewhat long, and at times repetitive, Shark Girl reveals a young girl's journey through life after a tragic accident.
The choice of verse narration works well as her inner thoughts are well explored. The narration is interrupted at times with news media articles, and letters from readers of these, but this clever device widens the interest level of Jane's story.
The language is realistic and often evocative, and, despite its length and reiteration of responses, this novel is very readable.
Julie Wells

Destroying Avalon by Kate McCaffrey

cover image

Read by Kellie Jones. Louis Braille Audio, ISBN 9780732033705.
I utilised the Destroying Avalon text (CD format) in my Pastoral Care Classes when we were focussing on Cyber bullying. I had already read the novel and was aware that it had been highly recommended for students by child psychologist, Dr Michael Carr-Greg.
I thought that this would be a good way to deliver the story for teachers because: It would eliminate the need to read the book and thus conserve the voice. It would remove the issue of having to read lots of swearing/language that I felt could be uncomfortable to read! It provided listeners with another voice to rather than hearing the same old teacher's voice!
For the reasons outlined above, I believe that the delivery method was good.
The class was a composite Year 9/10 group with 14 students. I asked students to review the text and the delivery method and I have included some of their responses. They were asked: Please indicate the extent to which you enjoyed the story (1 being lowest enjoyment, 10 being highest).
The average response was 7.
Please indicate the extent to which you enjoyed the delivery method (1 being lowest enjoyment, 10 being highest)
The average response was between 5 and 6 with some respondents citing 1 and others a 9. It was very well received by some whilst others did not like the delivery method at all. Their responses were quite extreme.
A compilation of quotes when asked the question, 'Would you recommend the text for future students, why or why not?' follows:
'Yes, because it makes kids think about what they are doing on the web. It would definitely be good for the future.' (Female student, 15)
'Yeah, it beats doing worksheets and other stuff about bullying.' (Female student, 14)
'Yes because it delivers a powerful, in-depth look at bullying'. (Male student, 15)
'Yes, I would recommend this book to future students because it shows how things like bullying can become very serious and may lead to death'. (Male student, 15)
'Yes because you can learn from other people's experiences and find out what to do in these circumstances. It was enjoyable.' (Female student, 14)
'Yes. It seemed like a very good thing to be aware of and it was easy to understand what could happen in a real-life matter.' (Female student, 15)
'The book, yes. The audio CD, no (Voice gives me a headache).' (Female student, 14)
'Yes and no. Yes because it delivers it in a way that will stick in our minds. No because some people can't just sit still to get it, they have to be moving.' (Female student, 15)
Melissa Wendland

Trouble at the Zoo by Chris Kunz

cover image

Bindi Wildlife Adventures. Random House Australia, 2010. ISBN 9781864719963
A new series featuring Bindi Irwin, famous daughter of crocodile hunter Steve Irwin. No 1, titled Trouble at the Zoo, is a quaint little story for beginner readers. In this first adventure we are introduced to the Irwin family, celebrating Bindi's 11th birthday, as well as Australia Zoo, where the family live and work. Although a short story the book covers all the excitement of a themed costume party open to the public at the Zoo, and how the plot by a zoo patron to steal one of its animals is quite easily foiled by the Irwin siblings. It includes of course the message of wildlife conservation and endangered animals that is expected when reading about Bindi Irwin. Delightful in its simplicity, it will appeal to children dedicated to saving wildlife themselves. What is special about this series is each book also includes information about the animals in the story written simply so children could use for school projects or just to better understand the creature.
Vicki Nunn

Where I belong by Gillian Cross

cover image

Oxford University Press, 2010.
(Ages 13+) Highly recommended. Gillian Cross weaves an original, complex and satisfying story of three very different young people. Khadija is a Somali girl sent to England to live among Somali strangers. She must pretend they are her family for the sake of an education, a job and money that will help her poverty stricken family. Abdi was born in the Netherlands, lives in England and has never visited his homeland but is Somali through and through. He is doubtful about welcoming Khadija into his family. Freya is a London teenager living under the shadow of her Father, an award winning war photographer and her mother, a celebrated fashion designer.
The three teenagers are thrown together when Freya's mother, Sandy sees Khadija in the street and decides that this tall and stunning girl must be her next model. However, Sandy insists that Khadija must have a new name and wear a full veil so that her identity is never revealed. She also decides that for maximum impact the fashion show should be shot in Somalia and beamed by satellite across the world. Things become seriously complicated when Khadija's brother is kidnapped in Somalia and a 10,000 pound ransom is demanded.
This is a story about our shrinking world, the power of the media and the uncomfortable fit of high fashion in a place usually associated with warlords, piracy and poverty. Cross forces her characters to face the trauma of family betrayal and the nature of homeland and identity. Khadija must conceal her identity from an ever intrusive media frenzy, while desperately trying to rescue her kidnapped brother. Abdi may never have visited Somalia but when he eventually arrives he makes a shocking discovery that will change his life forever. Cross expertly draws together the hints, clues and red herrings to deliver a superb plot twist that is completely unexpected.
With equal appeal for girls and boys this would make an excellent class reader for middle secondary students as there is so much to think about and discuss.
I have admired Gillian Cross since I first read On the Edge, and she is still on form some 25 years later. My only very minor criticism is that the story is told alternately by the three teenagers and occasionally I found the constant shift between characters a little clumsy. However this is also part of the story's strength as the reader becomes immersed in the thoughts and feelings of each of the teenagers.  I hope this one makes next year's Carnegie shortlist.
Claire Larson.

Captain Stella by Ruth Starke

cover image

Aussie Chomps. Puffin, 2010. ISBN 97801433051506
(Age: Middle School) Highly recommended. Ruth Starke has once again told a perfectly believable story about a young girl helping her grandmother and her friends turn around the fortunes of an opportunity shop, destined to be closed by the local council. Stella, the main character from the award winning, Stella by the Sea, has to stay with Granny Bee while her parents are at a real estate conference in Las Vegas. Helping Granny Bee and her friends at the op shop is worrying when she sees the utter mess and total disarray of all the goods on sale, but she is amazed at the variety of customers the shop attracts. The people who visit include some who simply come along each day to pass the time with friends, or who join in with morning tea or who, new to the country, find a place where their untried language skills can be practiced.
Faced with the shop's closure, Stella devises a plan to reinvent the place as a vintage and retro shop, so attracting new customers. She enlists the help of several of her friends, Chester, the retired cook, Jeffrey and Shane the florist and hair stylist, the Kings, the printers from down the road, and Ted, the old man who almost lives at the shop. Together, this disparate group works to transform the shop, making it into something more attractive, so that the assessor will change his mind. But a clever twist sees the inspector have a change of heart for an entirely different reason. And along the way, in keeping with all of Ruth Starke's books, the underlying multicultural nature of Australia is displayed beautifully. It is an absolute delight to revisit Stella in this wonderful story.
Fran Knight

The Prince of Mist by Carlos Ruiz Zafron

cover image

Text Publishing, 2010. ISBN 9781921656354.
(Age 11+) Recommended. When Max Carver's father decides to move his family to a small town on the coast, Max is fascinated by the secrets in the old house that they live in. It has a strange garden with statues that look like a circus troop. An eerie clown statue which stands at the centre of the six-pointed star in the garden, seems to come alive. A black cat with strange eyes attaches itself to the family and they find old films belonging to the previous owners, the Fleischmanns, whose son has died in mysterious circumstances. In the bay below the house is a ship that was wrecked many years before in a terrible storm. Max meets Roland and together with his sister Alicia, they go diving to investigate the shipwreck. Gradually the chilling story of the Prince of Mists emerges.
The Prince of Mist was first published in 1993 and was specifically written for young adults by Carlos Ruiz Zafron who has had enormous success with his adult novel Shadow of the wind. It is a haunting story of the evil Dr Cain who promises wish fulfilment, but at a terrible price. I was fascinated with the idea of having a wish granted and it was a compelling exercise to see what people were prepared to give up to gain what they wanted. The story is much more subtle than found in many of the gothic thrillers around, and although deceptively easy to read, leaves behind much to think about.
Told in the third person, all the characters are fleshed out well. Max is an inquisitive boy, who is determined to find out about the frightening Clown apparition. The Prince of Mists emerges as a very sinister and frightening character, who is scary enough to stay in the reader's memory. Roland and Alicia's delicate romance add to the interest and the adults in the family, seen through the eyes of Max, are believable.
I thoroughly enjoyed this suspenseful, well-written and creepy ghost story.
Pat Pledger