Reviews

Gotta B by Claire Carmichael

cover image

Random House Australia, 2009. ISBN 9781741662986.
(Age 12+) Recommended. Set in the near future, Carmichael explores a society where every young person is online constantly, so much so that Dr Carter Renfrew believes that this generation is the next step in evolution, Homo electronicus. When Rick Lawrence is suddenly disconnected, his iZod dead, he discovers that he can no longer communicate with his friends, the Five, who have been together since Kindergarten; he can't play games or even get his homework. He feels like he doesn't exist and begins to get depressed. Communications companies, always keen to keep ahead of trends, are pushing for research into the teenage brain but how far is Renfrew and his colleague Dr Howard Unwin prepared to go in their quest for knowledge and power? And what are they prepared to do to Rick to get their data?
Carmichael has created a credible world where teenagers can cope only if they have their iZod and are constantly online. The main characters are well developed and engrossing. I became involved with Rick's wobbly mental state and cheered Tal when he decided that enough was enough and he and the Five would go to his rescue. The cyberbully Marianne was brilliantly described as was George the topnotch computer student.
There is plenty of action and suspense as Tal and his friends launch a cyber attack on a corporate bully and the evil researchers. It was fascinating to follow them as they mounted a campaign to stop the computer disconnections and research.
Themes of cyberbullying, unethical scientific experimentation and media manipulation weave through the story and would create lots of discussion points if used as a class novel.
I found this to be a riveting book which I couldn't put down. I finished it in the early hours in one sitting. What more can you ask of a book than that it totally engrosses the reader?
Pat Pledger

The disreputable history of Frankie Landau-Banks by E. Lockhart

cover image

Hyperion, 2009. ISBN 978-0786838196
(Age 14+) Recommended. Frankie Landau-Banks suddenly finds herself in the limelight at her exclusive boarding school. She manages to attract the attention of a popular boy Matthew and as his girlfriend finds that she has been elevated from obscurity and now belongs to the 'in' group. However she discovers that girls are not treated the same way as boys are in the group and in particular they are excluded from the secret society, the Loyal Order of the Basset Hounds. When she finds The Disreputable History, the long lost manual of the club, she decides that she will grab some of the power that has previously belonged just to the boys. Using a fake e-mail address, she directs the activities of the club, getting the members to do audacious pranks until her plotting is discovered.
Frankie is a girl who is determined not to be ignored, and refuses to be relegated into doing 'female' activities. She thinks that coming up with wonderful practical jokes and getting the old boys' club to carry out her instructions will give her power and gain respect, but finds to her dismay that discrimination is deeply embedded in society. Whilst determined to prove herself an equal with the boys, she doesn't realise that she herself is fitting into a mould by waiting around for Matthew when he dumps her for Basset meetings, and still hoping that after everything goes haywire, he will be there for her.
A feature of the book that stood out for me was the humorous wordplays and the literary allusions to Wodehouse. Frankie had lots of fun making up words and meanings and this added a richness to the story telling and gave insights into Frankie's intelligence and personality.
Lockhart explores feminism, discrimination, peer pressure and the networks that give power in this complex, funny and witty exploration of one girl's attempt to be in the right group with the right cute boyfriend.
Pat Pledger

Uglies series by Scott Westerfeld

cover image

Uglies by Scott Westerfeld Simon Pulse, 2005. ISBN 0689 865384
Recommended. Tally is an Ugly. She is almost 16 and will be transformed on her birthday into a Pretty. She will leave the dorm where she has lived for the past four years and join the other Pretties in New Pretty Town. Her friends have already had the operation; she is the last of her year in her dorm, so she sneaks over the river to check out Pretty Town. During one of thee clandestine outings she meets another Ugly, Shay, who changes her life unexpectedly.
Shay teaches Tally to hoverboard, talks of a mysterious boy called David and of the Smokies, a group of people who have rejected the Pretty way of life and live somewhere in the wilderness. Shay's operation draws near and Tally finds she has no intention of being a Pretty and is going to join the Smokies. Tally desperately wants to be Pretty and has no intention of following Shay, but Shay has left her some cryptic clues on how to find the Smokey settlement.
Just as Tally's big day arrives so do some very strange pretties, Tally has never seen their type before, and they take her to a place she never knew existed. She is taken to Dr. Cable who seems to be the head of the Special Circumstances Unit, a group she had believed was pure fable. Dr. Cable knows all about Tally and Shay, but needs to know where the Smokey settlement is, so she blackmails Tally into following Shay and triggering a location device. Only if she does this will she be made a Pretty. Tally is left with no choice.
Tally's interaction with the Smokies, particularly David, leads her to change her mind. She finds out exactly what the operation does to your brain when you are made a Pretty and decides to destroy the location device. Her actions however precipitate the destruction of the settlement and the rounding up of all the inhabitants.
Westerfeld constructs a very different future where society is controlled and manipulated. The Pretties have every comfort. Their life is easy they want for nothing, they are selfish and happy.  But are they free?

Pretties by Scott Westerfeld, Simon Pulse, 2005.ISBN 978 689 86539 8
Tally goes back into the city to try out a drug that has been made to reverse the brain lesions that keep the Pretties contented. She and her new friend Zane come to lead a group within the Pretties called the Crims. They like to take their rather limited and safe lives and perform outrageous acts to make themselves more 'bubbly'.
Tally and Zane are eventually contacted by the Smokies and given the two pills they need to reverse the effects of the operation. However, Zane and Tally have become so close that they decide to share the cure, and take one each. Zane's reaction to the medication is very different from Tally's. He begins to get terribly debilitating headaches and bouts of physical weakness. Tally decides they've got to go back to the Smokies and David's mother in particular to see what has gone wrong.
They devise a daring escape plan, but in the course of events Tally ends up separated from the rest of the group and a long way from the rusty ruins. When trying to find her way back she discovers a group of primitive humans surviving in the wild. It's not until she enlists the help of their shaman that the reality of the situation becomes clear.
When she reaches the rest of the group, she finds Zane in poor condition, but realises that Zane has also had a tracker devise implanted in a tooth and the Special Circumstances Unit, with her old friend Shay in charge, take them back to the city. The second in the series, Pretties follows Uglies, in this gripping trio of books about a dystopian society.

Specials by Scott Westerfeld, Simon Pulse, 2006.  ISBN 9781416939948
Tally awakes to find that she has been changed. She has joined Shay as one of the special, Specials. She is a Cutter. She has heightened senses, strength, intelligence and a greater acceptance of her superiority, even over other Specials.
One night while on patrol to follow and apprehend a group of Smokies that have been supplying the new cure for Pretties, the Cutters discover that things have changed. The Smokies are no longer the peaceful submissive group they once were. They've been able to get hold of sneak suits and hover boards as well as infra-red and bows and arrows. The tables are turned on Tally and Shay the Smokies now have captured some of the Cutters and are using stolen high tech hoverboards to move quickly.
Tally tracks the group in the hope of finding their new settlement. There is a surprise in store. The settlement is nothing like the one she and Shay were briefly part of, it's another city! Even in a place where differences are tolerated Tally still stands out and in a place where weapons are not tolerated Tally herself is considered a lethal weapon and must be neutralised.
Shay comes to her rescue, but there are more weird things happening. An armada of hovercraft are waging war on the city. Such a thing hasn't happened in 600 years! Tally needs to get back to the city and stop the actions that are of her own making.
This is an exciting trilogy that explores a future society that has many links to our own. The environment, freedom, selfishness, power and its use as well as equality are all dealt with in an accessible well crafted way.
Mark Knight
Editor's comment: Extras is the last in the series and is equally as good.

Letters to Leonardo by Dee White

cover image

Walker Books, 2009. ISBN 9781921150883.
This is a disturbing novel on many fronts. Matt's Mother, whom he believes to be dead, sends a birthday card on his fifteenth birthday. Matt is shocked and angry with his father for lying to him and he sets out to find his mother, whom he has not seen since he was five. Mum is bi polar and when on Lithium seems normal, but she believes she can't paint when on drugs and life becomes strange and unmanageable for Matt. The trauma is relieved by the wry comments of his best friend Troy and Matt's letters to Leonardo da Vinci break the flow of the narrative.
The book shows only one extreme end of the spectrum of bi polar and a horrifying and tragic one at that! I would be keen to know what psychologists would think appropriate in the area of mental illness for this age group. It's a frightening one-sided view, especially as this may be the reader's introduction to the illness. It is neither a healthy approach or a constructive discussion of an illness society is trying to discuss openly and helpfully. An adult, but passionate and beautifully written memoir about manic depression is An Unquiet Mind by Kay Redfield Jamison. A wonderfully uplifting read on the topic.
Sue Nosworthy

Editor's comment: Sue has a daughter with bi-polar who is under medication and is doing well.
Another review can be found here http://www.aussiereviews.com/article2852.html

Dig 3ft NW:The Legendary Journey of Burke and Wills by Murgatroyd, Sarah

cover image

That Burke and Wills ever became a household phrase is beyond me after reading to this extraordinary story. Murgatroyd details in her book the appalling beginnings of this exploration, riddled with political machinations, jealousy of South Australia, patronage and jobs for the boys. Burke, by anyone's standards, one of the most incompetent of the applicants for the position of leader of this prestigious expedition, had no idea, no surveying ability, could not read a compass, and was well known in the district where he served as a police officer, for getting lost on his way home from the pub.
Leaving Melbourne took hours, when on the first day, they travelled 11 miles, camping at Essendon, close enough for Burke to return to his mistress in Melbourne for the night. By the time the caravan of horse, camels, 20 tons of equipment, and men, reached Medindie, they had taken nearly 60 days, had lost much equipment, paid out much of the money and no longer given credit at the small store, hired and fired a dozen or so men, and divided their party. The incompetence is overwhelming. Reading this story makes the reader gasp in amazement, as stupidity upon stupidity is piled high.
This is an entertaining and very informative book. That this expedition ever got off the ground is staggering, and the mistakes made from selecting the participants to deciding what they would carry, along with ludicrous decisions made reflecting the jealousy between SA and Victoria makes the readers shake their heads in bewilderment. A great read for people of all ages.
Fran Knight

The dead and the gone

cover image

Pfeffer, Susan. Marion Lloyd Books, 2008. ISBN 9781407106229.
(Age 13+) A companion novel to Life as we knew it, this novel can be read as a stand-alone. A meteor has struck the moon, changing the earth's climate drastically and bringing disastrous tsunamis and flooding.This is the compelling story of what it is like to survive in New York where the tube stations have been flooded, shops looted and the Yankee Stadium filled with the bodies of the dead. Alex Morales and his two young sisters, Briana and Julie, find themselves alone in the city. Their father had been in Puerto Rico for a funeral when the disaster struck and their mother called away to help in a hospital. Nothing has been heard of either of them since the first early reports of the tragedy. Alex, who has come from a strict Catholic family, is left to look after his two sisters without the support of any adults.
While the protagonists face many of the same disasters, intermittent electricity, food shortages, grey dust and a flu epidemic, the urban setting brings a different set of problems to be faced.  The Church gives some spiritual and physical support like lunch at the schools, but it is Alex who takes on the difficult role of head of the household and keeps his family together.
This is a survival story, but highlights the plight of the poor. Although Alex is very bright and a leader at school, it is the boys who have rich and influential families who are able to leave the devastated city. Alex and Julie queue up for food in dangerous lines, the girls can't walk around unprotected and it is difficult to see how they can survive. Alex faces the moral dilemma of stealing from the dead to keep the family alive. The reader sees the young siblings grow from self-centred adolescents to brave and caring young adults. Perhaps one of the most challenging aspects of the story is the author's exploration of faith in testing times.
This is a compelling read. While it didn't grab me as powerfully as Life as we knew it, probably because I was prepared for the effects of the disaster, the themes that are explored, including religion, morality, class structure and family, are certainly thought provoking.
Pat Pledger
,

Grandpa baby by Margaret Wild.

cover image

Ill. by Deborah Niland. Penguin/Viking, 2009. ISBN 9780670071746.
(Age 2-7) Recommended. Grandpa looks after Georgie while Mum and dad are working. They make sand castles, read stories and plant flowers. One morning Georgie decides that she is going to be big and that Grandpa can be the baby. Off to the park they go, with Georgie holding onto Grandpa Baby's hand and giving him instructions on how to play.
This is a classic 'switch' story where the child gets to imagine what it is like to be in an adult's shoes. Georgie makes a great adult, looking after Grandpa Baby when he hurts himself and refusing to allow him to swing too high. She works out strategies to get him home when he is tired and puts him to bed for a rest. She also has a wonderful imagination and decides on a fabulous dress-up game for the following day.
Delightfully illustrated by Deborah Niland, the little chimps come alive in gorgeous colour. Their facial expressions are really expressive of their moods. Observant readers will notice what happens to the dummy, and will be engrossed in the little domestic details that illustrate the story.
I loved this book. It left me with a smile on my face and would make a lovely read aloud with pictures for young children to gloat over.
Pat Pledger

Burn this book edited by Toni Morrison

cover image

Harpercollins, 2009.
ISBN 9780061774003.
(Age 15+) Burn this book is a collection of essays edited by Toni Morrison on the power of writers and writing. The collection has been sponsored by the PEN association, an organization that since 1921 has worked for the rights of all to communicate freely. The essays are by well known authors including John Updike, Toni Morrison herself, Nadine Gordimer, Orphan Pamuk, Paul Auster and others, and deal with the reasons for writing as well as the transformative power of the written word. The writers' attitudes are at times influenced by their culture; those from the 'free' world, John Updike, for example, tend to be more skeptical about the influence of writers than those living under repressive regimes. All generally agree that good writing is not overtly political; it cannot preach or proselytize, support or undermine a government. Rather, it is a testament to the strength and dignity of the individual, the power of the imagination and the importance of freedom of expression. A strength of this collection is the variety of responses to the topic; Updike's essay explores his own methodology, David Grossman from Israel writes of the power of his writing to heal personal grief, Francine Prose, an American academic and critic, writes an entertaining piece about connections and 'unknowing', and Ed Park uses the banning of I am the Cheese by Robert Cormier as the springboard for a creative riff on censorship. The collection would be suitable for senior students.
Jenny Hamilton

Oliver Nocturne: Blood Ties by Kevin Emerson

cover image

Sitting in the principal's office with his parents on the last day of school, Oliver is not pleased to hear his teacher give him a load of extra maths work to do over the summer holidays before he goes to high school in the fall. They are all off to Morosia, the underworld vampire city where some of his relatives live, and he cannot get there soon enough. Meanwhile he visits his friends, Dean and Emalie, and they are on a quest to find Selene, who may be able to help them find out about Emalie's mother, who has disappeared.
A trawl through all the spirits and wraiths surrounding vampire lore, Oliver Nocturne is a series about Oliver and his life as a vampire, and what is expected of him in the future. Bringing in all the stories at once is a bit overwhelming, and the number of characters sometimes confusing, and some of the stories within the novel are quite scary. I was often reminded of The Munsters (the 70's TV show) as the story shows the vampires at home, going about their daily routines, and there will be an audience for this series with the predominance of vampires stories being published of late, but I think there are better books around to spend the limited library budget on.
Fran Knight

Short Stuff by Mark Stevens

cover image

Louis Braille Audio, 2009.ISBN 978174212. 4CD's, lasting 4 hours
Working Title Press, 2008
Mark Stevens' short stories are brought hilariously to life by the clear, funny voice of Don Bridges. I loved the coach in the first story, with reminiscences of Michael Caine coming through. The reader gives each story a different ring through making it memorable and inviting the listeners to stay for the whole CD.
In the first story, Henson longs to be a professional soccer player, and his time with the local soccer team is just his training time on the way to fulfilling his dream. Often his coach has to interrupt his dreams about his prowess. But on the Saturday that his team is about to win the local cup, his team taking on the Carver Hill mob, he wakes to a cloud hanging over his house. A few metres above his head, the cloud has a message and he feels impelled to ring the phone number emblazoned thereon. The Indian accent on the end of the phone line tells him to meet him outside his front door, and when he opens it he finds Finnias. From then on the laughs come thick and fast, as Fininas calls another person to log the incident with Geraldine the cloud.
Don Bridges' wonderful voice takes on the young Henson, the amiable Finnias, Amos the coach, various friends and family, beautifully. He modulates his voice to enable all listeners to hear the difference between the different people and the passages linking the conversations. His voice contains an undertone of humour which suits the style of the text, and his clear voice allows the listener to hear every word. As a filler in a classroom, as a start to the day, a lunchtime activity, or to borrow and take home to listen, for parents taking the kids on a trip, whatever the need, audio books like this are invaluable.
Fran Knight

A child's garden by Michael Foreman

cover image

Walker Books, 2009. ISBN 9781406312072.
(All ages) Highly recommended. Michael Foreman has written another stunning book with a message of peace that tugs at the heart strings. A little boy lives in a barren, war torn area behind a tall barbed wire fence. One day he finds a tiny green shoot and waters and nurtures it until it grows to cover the fence. Birds and butterflies find it and the area becomes a place of beauty and a playground for children. Then one day the soldiers come along and destroy it. The boy is heartbroken, but hope arrives when a little girl on the other side of the fence finds some shoots and waters them.
Foreman's illustrations bring to life the bleakness of war. With black and white pencil drawings he shows the desolate landscape with its ruins, buildings piled high with rubble and ragged shelters. As the boy's little shoot grows, he adds colour to show the beauty of plants and the birds and butterflies that collect there and the happiness of the children who have a lovely garden to play in. When the shoots grow on both sides of the fence and the landscape is transformed, the illustrations are all in colour to show the sharing of peace.
Foreman's message is overt. He gives the reader hope that the seeds of peace can be planted deep and will one day flourish in a place where there is no fence and people can live peacefully together. This would be a wonderful book to use with all age groups to look at the effects of war and oppression and how resilient the human spirit can be.
Pat Pledger

Siggy and Amber by Doug MacLeod

cover image

Puffin, 2009. ISBN 9780143304388.
(Age 13+) Recommended. Siggy wants to meet a girl who he hopes will be 'smart and amazing.And funny and probably not blonde.' At a dance at the Samsara Youth Club, he meets Amber, who may be the girl of his dreams. However he vomits on her shoes and he decides that the only way he might get to know her after that fiasco is to take her ghost hunting. He has seen something strange at Tallis Point and wants to investigate.
The book is peopled with a wide array of unusual characters all of whom add to the fun of the story. There is Siggy's friend Fergus who leads a double life as Highland Dancing Man, a sister who makes sculptures out of bits of shrapnel, a shop owner who sells vampire costumes and finally Amber who lives with her two mums and who has goldfish. Add to that witty dialogue that is side-splitting and you have a book that is sure to appeal to everyone who picks it up.
If you are after a humorous book for your library then this would make a delightful addition. It would also be a great read aloud and would be sure to engage reluctant readers.
Pat Pledger

Child 44 by Tom Rob Smith

cover image

Pocket Books, 2009. ISBN 9781847391599.
(Age 15+) Recommended. One of the best mystery thrillers that I have read in a long time, Child 44 took me on a roller coaster ride to Stalinist Russia, where children are being killed and mutilated by a serial killer. The Soviet system refuses to acknowledge that there is such a crime in its perfect society, and the deaths are blamed on deviants, homosexuals or intellectually disabled people. One detective, Leo Demidov, called to cover up the death of one of his men's children, gradually begins to realise that there is more than one child brutally killed and decides to atone for all the innocent victims that he himself has arrested. This leads to demotion and exile from his home.
What makes this story so engrossing is the combination of a good murder mystery with an in depth look at what it was like to live in Stalinist Russia. The emotions of the main characters play a leading role and Leo's feelings about his work in the secret police and his marriage are explored in detail. Fear pervades the society and Smith tackles the impact that fear has. Child 44 was on the Man Booker Prize long list, deservedly so - this is a well written, well researched and riveting thriller not to be missed.
Pat Pledger

Don't breathe a word by Marianne Musgrove

cover image

Random House, 2009.
(Age 8-12) Recommended. Mackenzie and Tahlia have been bought up by their grandfather - Pirate (because of his sunken chest!) however one day they arrive home from school to find that grandpa had had a fall and couldn't remember entirely how he came to be where they found him. Realising the seriousness of what has occurred but also fearing for a change in their circumstances if they allow people to find out about grandpa they agree to keep grandpa's fall a secret between themselves. This would be fine if Tahlia didn't continually have to go off to dancing class and Mackenzie wasn't left alone to cope with grandpa's strange behaviour. Eventually grandpa puts himself in extreme danger and the girls have no choice but to allow grandpa the help he needs.
This is an excellent novel dealing with dementia and the effect it has on those involved. It sensitively portrays the deterioration of the sufferer and the increasing concerns of those around them.
This is the third novel written by South Australian author Marianne Musgrove, with The Worry Tree and Lucy the Good preceding this title.
Tracy Glover

All we know of love by Nora Raleigh Baskin

cover image

Walker Books, 2009. ISBN 9781406315516.
(Ages 14+) Recommended. By observing the quotes at the beginning of each chapter, the reader hears Natalie's story whilst enjoying the plethora of ideas that famous people have about the different types of love and the emotional responses individuals have to 'love'. Natalie's Mother has been gone for four years, four months and fifteen days and Natalie blames herself. Her Mother was in mid sentence and Natalie wanted chocolate cookies not the oatmeal cookies and wasn't really listening.
Natalie is on her way from Stamford to Florida by bus to ask her Mother about her unfinished sentence involving love. She encounters a variety of people who influence her and share their views on 'love'. Natalie learns to hear other people's views on life and love and through the stories they tell. She is learning to believe in herself and as she says on page 192: 'I have to forgive myself for something I had nothing to do with. And second, I have to pay attention to the here and now.'
Natalie is beginning to accept what she can't change and enjoy the people who love her. She's growing up.
Sue Nosworthy