Reviews

The butterfly heart by Paula Leyden

cover image

Walker Books, 2011. ISBN 9781406327922.
This modern story set in the butterfly shaped country of Zambia in Southern Africa considers the existence of traditional beliefs in contemporary society. Bul-Boo and Madillo are twin sisters in their early teens who discover that their close school friend Winifred has a distressing problem. Winifred's father has recently died and according to traditional custom, her domineering and aggressive uncle has taken her widowed mother as a wife, and worse, has promised Winifred as a bride to his equally repugnant friend.
Not knowing how to help, the twins enlist the help of Ifwafwa, the local snake catcher who has mysterious powers but is kindly with decent values. Not knowing if he will be able to deal with this problem, the help of a 'Witch' (in the sense of witch-doctor) is also sought. Through these two characters, the reader appreciates that traditional laws are being misinterpreted and misused by the Uncle and that ancient cultural values exist to prevent such action.
The affirming notion evident throughout this tale is that innocent children must be protected and that risks should be taken and fears overcome to achieve this.
This novel is interesting and easy to read, but I was left feeling a little disappointed by what I perceived to be confusion in direction and an incomplete resolution. There are many veiled references to premature death and the creation of hardship for families and orphaned children, yet H.I.V. is only explicitly mentioned once and the sheer enormity of the situation may escape some readers. One cannot expect 'happily ever after' conclusions in novels of this type, however I was disappointed that important elements specifically introduced by the author were not finalised. Others however may consider that metaphysical and metaphorical elements provided the facility for the reader to construct their own outcome.
This novel will educate readers about social and economic realities in Southern Africa and will give some appreciation of how fortunate and secure most of us are in the developed world. It is fitting that it has been endorsed by Amnesty International.
Robin Welsh

Find Chaffy by Jamie Smart

cover image

Scholastic, 2011. ISBN 9781407120904.
(All ages) A fun alternative to Where's Wally, this book will keep children (and adults) entertained for hours as they attempt to find Chaffy, who is white and has a cute little face and one droopy ear. Ten of these little Chaffies have wandered off and become lost and it is up to the reader to find them.
Jamie Smart has written and drawn an incredibly detailed adventure for the little Chaffies. He has placed the lost Chaffies in a double page spread with hundreds of black and white pandas for a start, and it is not an easy task to find a white Chaffy in a sea of pandas, I can tell you! I was pleased that there was a hint on the front cover, showing where a couple of them could be located. This helped a bit in understanding just how tiny they were on the page. At the kitty circus, nine Chaffies are lost, but one looks different and so on!
Every alternative double spread has humorous stories about the Chaffies' adventure and is very funny to read. The detail of all the little faces that Jamie Smart has drawn is amazing.
This would make an ideal present for any child who likes to examine detail and needs to be entertained for hours searching for things. In a library the trick will be to stop the ever-eager reader putting a mark on the Chaffy when they find it!
Pat Pledger

If you're happy and you know it! by P. Crumble and Chris Kennett

cover image

Scholastic, 2011. ISBN 9781741698916.
(Age: 2-5) An Aussie edition of the very familiar song If you're happy and you know it, this book will have children climbing a tree with a possum, digging a hole with a wombat, bouncing around with a wallaby, scratching fleas with a dingo and laughing out loud with a kookaburra. And that's just a few of the Australian animals and their actions!
A good addition for parents and pre-schools, this gives a unique twist to the classic rhyme and provides a lot of fun for youngsters. In fact, if you are sick of singing the traditional rhyme this will be a good alternative! Children are sure to enjoy doing the actions associated with the animals. The book starts with the first verse of the song, and then gives a double page spread for each Australian animal, with the first line of the song on the left hand side and pictures of each additional animal on the right. After the reader gets to 'When you're a koala and you know it, fall asleep', the text shows each of the verses for the animals in a separate box for each one. This means that the book could be used as a story or the teacher/parent could just go the back of the book and find all the rhymes to sing and act out.
The illustrations are cute and will appeal to young children. They are colourful and cartoon like, with human accessories like a bow in the pink possum's hair and glasses on the bandicoot. If the aim of the book were to teach about Australian animals, it would pay to have real photos as well, to compare just what they look like.
The popularity of this song has stood the test of time and this will be a whimsical option when singing it or reading out loud to children.
Pat Pledger

Flood by Jackie French and Bruce Whatley

cover image

Scholastic, 2011. ISBN978 1 742630728.
(Ages: All) Recommended. Picture book. Environment. The watery wash and pencil drawings of Bruce Whatley are an enticing counterpoint to Jackie French's spare writing, in which the power of the floods to destroy much of riverside Brisbane is evoked in this magnificent picture book. From the beginnings, where gentle rain falls, to its becoming incessant and surging down rivers, breaking their banks forcing people onto their rooftops, the power of the water is obvious in both word and illustration. Whatley's pictures go from green to brown as the water swirls up soil and debris, while French's words remind us that people are always there, volunteering to fill sandbags, helping people from their roofs, ferrying them across swollen rivers.
Part way through the story, the wood and metal boardwalk is loosed from its moorings and begins to float into the Brisbane River, threatening whatever is in its path. A small but determined tug boat chugs out and nudges it into the middle of the river where it washes out to sea, safe from causing harm. The tug, a metaphor for all the brave volunteers who took it upon themselves in those days to feed, house and clothe the many made homeless by the floods, or those filling sandbags and rowing the boats, cheered the hearts of all who watched.
In a forward by Anna Bligh, Premier of Queensland, the reader is told that every school in Australia will receive a free copy of this book, while profits made from the sale of this book, will be donated to the Premier's Disaster Relief Appeal. At the end of the book, both Jackie French and Bruce Whatley give more information about the book and its development.
This is a most pertinent picture book, not only telling a rousing story with beautiful illustrations but one which could be used over and over in the classroom where environment, sustainability, disasters and particularly, floods, are under discussion.
Fran Knight

Herbert the Brave Sea Dog by Robyn Belton

cover image

Walker Books, 2011. ISBN 978921529313.
Herbert was loved by everyone, but most of all by Tim. One day, Tim's father and two friends began an everyday trip in their boat through the French Pass in New Zealand's Marlborough Sounds. Because those waters are treacherous, Tim was left to make the trip by car with his mother, but Herbert the dog jumped on the boat ready for adventure. And what an adventure it was . . . At first the sea was calm and sparkling but as is common in that area, things soon changed for the worse, and in the middle of the storm, Herbert was lost overboard, slipping in unnoticed.
This is the true story of a little boy's faith, a courageous dog and a happy ending. The end-papers pay tribute to what Herbert endured during his 30 hours at sea, and a story that will be in Nelson's folklore forever. The book won the Russell Clark Award which recognises excellence in children's book illustration and received very positive reviews from publications such as the New York Times and the Toronto Star. All are very well-deserved. I found it compelling reading.
Barbara Braxton

I love you, Mummy by Catherine Vase

cover image

Gullane Children's Books, 2011. ISBN 9781862338098.
Board book. Mummy is all of Little Elephant's favourite things . . . a woolly jumper, soft and snug; a cat's gentle purr; a juicy strawberry. While the concept of the book is quite simple and it is a complete tuck-me-in, kiss-me-goodnight story, it also has a place in kick starting a child's venture into figurative language and writing. Imagine how a mother would treasure a book written and illustrated by her child telling her she is the golden sunshine for Mother's Day, or a dad getting the same for Father's Day. And imagine the learning that would go into creating such a tome. This book has the potential to be more than a feel-good warm fuzzy.
And my mum??? You are the springboard off which I jumped, the safety net that caught me and the soft, warm quilt in which I wrapped myself.
Barbara Braxton

Pearson Picture Books series by various authors

cover image

Pearson, 2011.
(Age 5-7) Pearson Picture Books is a series of readers aimed at young children. The stories were all interesting and illustrated with pictures that would appeal to young children. They would be ideal to send home with children who are just beginning to read as the number of words is fairly limited and there is lots of repetition to help children learn new words. The hardback books are study and would hold up to a lot of handling. The stories are ones that would appeal to both boys and girls.

Two baby elephants by Jeanne Willis and Tony Ross. ISBN 9781442548114.
Recommended. Two children have lots of fun with tow baby elephants while Mum is away. They eat the food, leave the dirty dishes and leave havoc behind wherever they go. This is a lot of fun to read and the illustrations are fabulous. The text rhymes and it is easy to predict. The conclusion makes a humorous finish to a book that will appeal to children.

Try again, Emma by Jane Langford and Ann Kroneimer. ISBN  978 1 44254 799 5.
A cute story about a little girl, who makes a poster for a competition, has a message about continuing to try to do one's best even if there are pitfalls on the way.

The day the sky fell down by Michaela Morgan and Jane Cope. ISBN 9781442548015.
A variation on an old folktale, about a chicken that thought the sky was falling in, this verse story is amusing and should appeal to young children.
Pat Pledger

In the Sea there are Crocodiles by Fabio Geda

cover image

Random House, 2011. ISBN 9781846554766.
Highly Recommended. This is a compelling and intimate story about Enaiatollah Akbari and his journey from Afghanistan to Italy. Fearful for her son's life, Enaiatollah's mother takes him to Pakistan. Without explanation and without warning she leaves him there to make a life of his own. He is only 10 years old. What is truly incredible about Enaiatollah's story is that it is not unique; there are other boys, just like him, refugees from Afghanistan trying to survive, trying to stay safe, trying to find a place they can call home.
Before she left him, Enaiatollah's mother made him promise that he would not steal, he would not take drugs and he would not use weapons. Three promises she left him with, as a manifesto, a guide to follow whilst making his journey into manhood. Without the protection of family, as well as living in strange and violent lands Enaiatollah strives to uphold those ideals.
Fabio Geda retells Enaiatollah's story with warmth and compassion, interacting with him in a gentle and intimate manner which brings depth to the story. Although written as a fictional piece the story is recreated from Enaiatollah's memory.  With its simplistic style, the reader is drawn into the world of the child: his thought processes and his perceptions. The story spans five years, Enaiatollah is only fifteen when he arrives in Italy and realizes that this is the place he wants to call home.
Sue Mann

The loser list by H.N. Kowitt

cover image

Scholastic, 2011. ISBN 978 0 545 24004 8.
(Age 10 years+) The Loser List is an insight into the lives of 12 year old kids and the ups and downs of fitting in at school. It is told from Danny's point of view, the kid who generally walks to the beat of his own drum, until his name gets put on the 'Loser List' in the girl's toilet (of all places). Danny tries to remove his name but is caught. Through a trip to detention, he meets Axl, the school bully, and before long others are seeing him differently. Unfortunately, while some good things happen, Danny is unknowingly involved in a theft!
The Loser List is a comical story of when to do the right thing, being accepted by your peers and accepting yourself.  Will Danny officially join Axl's gang to be popular? Will Logan ever forgive him? Will he get his best friend back? Readers 10 years+ will enjoy the fast-paced novel with easy to read text and cartoon illustrations. It will appeal to readers who have enjoyed the Diary of a Wimpy Kid series.
Kylie Kempster

Pink by Janet A. Holmes and Jonathan Bentley

cover image

Little Hare, 2011. ISBN 9781921541797.
Lily loves all things pink - strawberry ice cream, her pink bike, her pink tutu, her pink ball and her pink high-heeled boots, hat and feather boa. But poor Lily has no one to share her ice cream, to play catch with, to dance or ride with or even to dress up with. Poor, lonely Lily. She tries to make friends with the snail, the mouse and the chicken and the goat chews her beautiful hat. Will she ever find a friend? And then, along comes the perfect friend of all   . . . a beautiful, intelligent, pink . . .
Miss 5 adores pink and she adored this story. It's fun, it's imaginative and the perfect feel-good, close-your-eyes story for bedtime. I just hope she doesn't ask for a pink . . . to go with all her other pink things. Could be tricky.
Barbara Braxton

Mole hunt by Paul Collins

cover image

Ford St, 2011. ISBN 9781921665264.
This book is hard to categorise. Part science fiction, part thriller, part action adventure, barely does it justice. Maximus Black is thoroughly unpleasant, totally self centred and prepared to do whatever is necessary to achieve his ends. This includes wholesale murder and manipulation. Maximus is a star cadet for RIM, a law enforcement come spy agency with tentacles across the galaxy. The only problem is that he is also a mole in RIM and is there to achieve his own ends. One day a message is received at the agency that there is a mole in the agency. As he is the mole Maximus Black takes swift and decisive action against Anneke Longshadow the author of the message. Thus begins an exciting cat and mouse game of move and counter move as Anneke seeks to uncover the mole and Maximus tries everything he can to remain undetected. The violence escalates as each thwarts the other.  There is plenty of technical detail to keep the science fiction fans happy and it still manages to stay on the right side of believable as the story unfolds. Neither of the main characters is particularly likeable, their creed being the end justifies the means.
It is an exciting fast paced story and I am sure that it will have many readers looking forward to the sequel to find out more about Maximus and his evil schemes.
David Rayner

The happy book by Malachy Doyle

cover image

Ill. by Caroline Uff. Bloomsbury Books, 2011. ISBN 9780747595489.
(All ages) Highly recommended. Malachy Doyle hits the spot with this wonderful picture book. In the blog, An Awfully Big Blog Adventure  he writes that the inspiration for the book was an old Swedish proverb:

'Fear less, hope more,
Whine less, breathe more,
Talk less, say more,
Hate less, love more
And all good things will be yours.'

Doyle takes the reader, young and old through a series of scenarios showing both negative and positive feelings and behaviours. Malachy comes up with ways of helping to prevent the nasty situations and emotions that all children face: teasing, having toys grabbed from them, grumbling, shouting and squabbling. Each scenario gives the reader a real solution to start feeling happy in difficult times. I particularly loved the 'Tease less' on the left hand page and 'Tickle more' on the right hand page and the 'Worry less', 'Wonder more' instruction followed by the 'Be happy'command.
The language has a rhythm to it that lends to having it read aloud, and I can imagine young children joining in with a chorus of the antidotes to the negative feelings. Caroline Uff has produced warm, colourful images of an older sister and younger brother in familiar surroundings. Her drawings complement the words and add to the inviting nature of the book.
This is certainly a book that could be used for classroom discussion to help produce a happy, co-operative atmosphere and will be a boon as a family read. Now I have to decide whether to keep it for a personal bible to being happy or send it to London to my grandchildren!
Pat Pledger

Harry's war by John Heffernan

cover image

Omnibus, 2011. ISBN 978 1 86291 9273.
(Ages 10+)War. Harry idolises his grandfather and spends a great deal of time with him listening to his seemingly endless stories of war and his involvement in Malaysia during WW2. His beloved grandfather fills him with stories of the glory of war, and keeps reminding Harry of his being a chip off the old block, and about how ready he is to follow in the family footsteps. When his teacher asks Harry to see if is grandfather will talk at the school, Harry is very keen for this to happen. His father died when he was three, and until now, the family has spoken little of the man whom Harry barely remembers but still speaks to when going to bed at night. Photos of him in uniform fill the small photograph album that Harry keeps near his bed. But things come to a head when Harry's friend asks what his father died of. The story of cancer does not add up when the man in the last photograph is looking so healthy and strong. The question brings the truth, but there is more to the truth than meets the eye, so when Harry goes to ask his grandfather, the local television crew is there, and Harry innocently tells them of his grandfather's heroic actions.
A fascinating story of how war affects families, Heffernan has again created a tale that rings with truth. The relationship between Harry and his grandfather is based on a lie and it is this lie that both must contend with before their relationship can be repaired. But Harry proves that he too can be a hero, not one who must talk about what happened but one who knows within himself what a real hero is and should be.
Fran Knight

Planet of the apes by Pierre Boulle

cover image

Vintage, 2011 (originally published 1963). ISBN 9780099529040.
(Age 15+) Ulysse Merou is a journalist who accompanies the brilliant scientist Professor Antille on an inter-galactic journey to a planet called Soror. Conveniently but necessarily this new world has an atmosphere and environment which is almost identical to Earth's. The travellers attain a speed near that of light, enabling both the passage of unimaginable distances and the crossing of hundreds of years in comparative time.
Merou and his party naturally seek contact when they discover the planet's humanoid population. The reader learns that the humans are completely backward, with no obvious intellectual capacity, verbal communication or understanding of objects such as tools or even clothing. Whilst this tentative encounter is taking place, a highly organised operation to drive the people from the forest is undertaken by gorillas who enjoy shooting them for sport but who are also charged with collecting specimens for scientific research. The reader comprehends that Soror is controlled by gorillas, orangutans and chimpanzees who are intellectually and technologically developed.
The continuing narrative focuses on Merou as he struggles to survive captivity as a scientific subject and the story gains significant momentum and depth as he demonstrates his superior cerebral capacity to the chimpanzee researchers.
This story is compelling and enjoyable but its most valuable feature is a marvellous philosophical examination of the treatment and abuse of other species for science. It was curious to feel indignant and even appalled at the treatment of humans by monkeys who are cast as unfeeling and even cruel, but then be reminded that this is merely a mirror of our own attitudes towards 'lesser species'.
The academic consideration of the evolution of apes against the regression of man and a thought provoking analysis of learning versus imitation is a strong theme within the tale. So engaging are the philosophical aspects of the story that the reader is forgiving of some very clumsy science fiction constructs and a flimsy literary framework which allows the tale to be introduced and concluded.
Published in 1963, this novel possibly compares poorly against modern science fiction which has benefited from five decades of staggering technological development. Together with true science, today's authors may also draw upon a wealth of science fiction imagination which has gone before.
This is still a wonderful book however and readers 15 and older will cope with the complexities posed by the theme and peculiarities from translation.
Rob Welsh

Losers? by Pauline Deeves

cover image

Ill. by Adam Carruthers. Mates series. Omnibus Books for Scholastic Australia, 2011. ISBN 9781862918511.
'Will the Wiggly Worms ever beat the Rotten Rats? Maybe not. But they always pick up their orange skins after half-time!' The captain of the Wiggly Worms is set to report at the school assembly on his team's performance. After trying to justify their fifteen to one loss and replaying all the disastrous things that contributed to the score he begins to reflect on all the good things about the team and their supporters.
I liked this story of the struggling soccer team and their realization as they progress through the book that even though the scoreboard is often against them, they have a wonderfully loyal and dedicated team and supporters. Even though they kick goals in the wrong direction most of the time, they each have a special skill and receive an award.
Nicely illustrated to add to the story and help break up text for those earlier readers, this story is a heartwarming look at competitive sport and how sometimes being second can be a good thing.
Zana Thiele