Reviews

Meet Poppy by Gabrielle Wang

cover image

Ill. by Lucia Masciullo. Our Australian Girl series. Penguin, 2011. ISBN 978 0143305323.
(Ages 9+) Australian history. Recommended. Poppy, living in an orphanage, a mission for children with an Aboriginal background, happens upon a letter in the head sister's office. It says that her brother Gus is about to be removed to another place, one where his habit of wandering off can be curbed. Fearful, Poppy tells Gus and he takes off that night. When the same woman then tells Poppy that she is about to be adopted by a Christian family from Sydney, she too, follows her brother, cutting off her hair and donning a boy's clothes to cover her tracks. The time is 1864, and Poppy and Gus are of Aboriginal and Chinese backgrounds, and both want to find their parents.
A lively adventure, Poppy is the main character in a quartet of books about this girl of Aboriginal and Chinese parents, finding her way in the gold seeking world that is Victoria in 1864. This character is one of the girls in the series, Our Australian Girl, giving modern readers a look at how girls lived in Australia's past, an engaging addition to books which will support the new Australian Curriculum with its emphasis on history. Much information is added to the readers' knowledge of Australia's past through reading these series.
Each of the books is about 100 pages long, with large clear print and they are easy to read. The stories are gripping and characters lively and likeable. Each book has information at the end of the story underlining that given in the story, and has a teaser, the first few pages of the book following this one, to get the readers interested in the following book.
Fran Knight

Poppy at Summerhill by Gabrielle Wang

cover image

Ill. by Lucia Masciullo. Our Australian Girl (series). Penguin, 2011. ISBN 978 0 14 330533 0.
(Ages: 9+) Australian history. After Poppy runs away from the mission, she falls into life at Summerhill, a station where Aboriginal stockman Tom, has a fair idea of just who she is in her boy's disguise. He helps her as she catches her ankle in a dingo trap and taking her back to the station, nurses her back to health, all the while teaching her some of the bush crafts and lore of the local Aboriginal people. At the station she is befriended by a young girl of her own age, Noni, but her brother Joe is very suspicious and bullying in his behaviour towards her. Poppy is a lively, fascinating character, as are the others she meets in this story, and although credulity is a little stretched and the incidents do pile one on top of the other, it is eminently readable and will be highly appealing to the middle primary audience it is aimed at.
This is the second in the quartet about Poppy, a girl living in the gold rush era of Australia, with factual information at the end of the book along with a teaser leading the readers to the next in the series of four, part of the Our Australian Girl series.
Fran Knight

Poppy and the thief by Gabrielle Wang

cover image

Ill. by Lucia Masciullo. Our Australian Girl (series). Penguin, 2011. ISBN 978 0 14 330534 7.
(Ages: 9+) Australian history. Poppy hears about Jimmy Ah Kew from the owner at Summerhill Station, when he spies her letter with his seal. She leaves the place headed for Wahgunyah, the town where Jimmy lives, again alone on the road, where many adventures befall her. She shares a meal with a man she meets, and later finds he is the notorious bushranger, Harry Power, and she finds a friend in Jimmy Ah Kew, as well as a dog she calls Fisher.
The third in the quartet about Poppy, a gold rush era girl living through the mid 1860's, a time of great change for Australia. The perspective of an Aboriginal Chinese girl gives it a different point of view of many other stories set in this time, and the facts given at the end of the book will help students understand the times more readily. As with the others in the Our Australian Girl series, there is a teaser leading readers to the fourth book in this series within a series.
Fran Knight

Poppy comes home by Gabrielle Wang

cover image

Ill. by Lucia Masciullo. Our Australian Girl (series). Penguin, 2011 ISBN 978 0 14 330535 4.
(Ages 9+) Australian history. In an ending which ties up all the strands from the three before, Poppy comes home, sees our hero finally reaching Beechworth, where she is working with a travelling salesman and his crew, selling entertainment and then medicines to the beguiled public. While performing she spies Blossom in the crowd, but is distracted when the bushranger, Harry Power is brought to justice. Talking to a man in the crowd, she finds he is the bookshop owner who sensing her love of books, takes her on as his assistant. She then introduces Blossom to the owner and she is adopted by his family. Searching for her dog, Fisher, lately stolen and sold by the professor from the travelling show, she comes across some people who tell her that Gus is buried in the local cemetery. But all is not lost, it is not Gus but another boy, and the family is reunited.
An easy to read story, it gallops along with plenty of adventure, coincidences and happenings for middles primary readers to enjoy. Poppy is engaging, and readers will want to know that her family is complete, while reading of this girl in the Our Australian Girl series.
Again lots of information is given in the background of the story adding to the readers' knowledge of Australia in the gold rush era, and information is given at the end of the book, before two pages showing the next two girls in the series, Nellie, 1849 and Alice, 1918.
Fran Knight

Come down, cat! by Sonya Hartnett

cover image

Ill. by Lucia Masciullo. Penguin. Viking. 2011. ISBN978 0 670 07475 4.
(Ages: 3+) Recommended. Picture book. Just as the sun is setting, and early evening draws near, Nicholas becomes concerned for his cat. She is on the roof of their house, and refuses to come down for the night. No matter what Nicholas says or does, the cat just says, 'Marl', and moves further back onto the roof. The cat, of course, is mercurial and independent, a large white Siamese, with eyes that shine on her owner. The 'Marl' which Hartnett puts into the cat's mouth is just right, reminding generations of cat owners just how their cat sounds. But Nicholas cannot sleep knowing his cat is still on the roof and imagines all sorts of awful things happening to his cat. He finally sleeps but is woken in the night by the sound of rain. He leaps out of bed and climbs the tallest ladder to rescue his cat,  which this time is very willing to leap safely into Nicholas' arms.
A charming story of bravery, the illustrations reflect the two main characters beautifully. Nicholas is in his pyjamas, ready for bed, he climbs the huge ladder, trying to get to the roof of this enormous house to fetch down the cat.
The cat, so tiny for most of the book, cowers on the roof,but when the rain falls her face fills the page with anguish until Nicholas climbs up and she leaps happily into his arms. I love the illustrations, from the Art Deco house, to the owls and bats flying over in the night, to the wonderful sequence of illustrations showing differing perspectives, that of the act on the roof, looking down, or the boy looking up at the cat, or the owl's view of the cat on the roof. All the different perspectives encourage the reader to see things from another's points of view, not just to focus on the boy and what he feels.The discussions about just who is the bravest will keep many readers thinking for a long time after the book is read.
Fran Knight

Alaska by Sue Saliba

cover image

Penguin, 2011. ISBN 9780143206118.
(Age 15+) From blurb:
mia's heart made a sound that no one heard
except for mia
late one night when she woke from dreams into darkness.

ethan was asleep beside her, and em was a forest away.
outside it was night and dark and alaska.
the sky was upside down.

Mia has left behind an alcoholic mother to live with her sister Em in Alaska. Em had always been the older sister, the one who protected her and helped her to survive their single parent family. However when Mia arrives in Alaska, she finds that Em has new priorities, her domineering husband, Terrence and baby Christian. Beguiled by the beauty of the forest surrounding Em's house she spends much time there and it is there that she meets a young engineer, Ethan, who she feels she may love. But does she know what love is?
Saliba's prose is lyrical and sparse. The omission of capital letters for sentence beginnings and names was difficult for me at first, but no doubt teens will have no problems with that! Once I became used to that I found the writing wonderful. Indeed, the forest almost became a magical entity for me. With a few words, Saliba paints the glory of the forest landscape, the fascinating deer and the horror that it all might be defaced by the pipeline that a corporation wants to run through it.
Saliba  delves deeply in the lives and motivations of Mia and her sister Em. It is essentially a beautiful coming of age story as Mia comes to grips with the fact that her sister has grown away from her and that she too has responsibilities and challenges to face on her own. Ethan is a shadowy character and little is known about other secondary characters, leaving the readers to come to their own conclusions about them. This leads to a surprising conclusion.
Older readers will find much to think about in this book. The themes of coming of age, of responsibility, of compromise, and of protecting the environment will linger for a long time in the minds of thoughtful teens.
Pat Pledger

The corpse walker and other true stories of life in China by Liao Yiwu

cover image

Text, 2011. ISBN 9781921656514.
(Age: Senior school) Recommended. Liao Yiwu is a Chinese writer and performer who was imprisoned for his poem Massacre, written and performed in response to the suppression of the Tienanamen Square student protests. In this collection of twenty-seven interviews translated by Wen Huang, Liao presents a view of a complex and multi-layered society, in which threads from the past inform the present. Some of the interviewees, the Human Trafficker and the Corpse Walker, were chosen because of their connections with traditional life while others, the Rightist and the Former Red Guard, because their lives epitomize the experiences of many during the cataclysmic events of the last century. The Corpse Walker describes the traditional practice of 'walking', by carrying on one's back, a corpse back to its home and family. Corpse walking becomes a metaphor for the burden of history carried by many of the interviewees in this collection. Chairman Mao is a dominant figure in the stories of these ordinary people's lives.The deprivations suffered during the Great Leap Forward, the Cultural Revolution and the Tienanmen Square massacre are described in a number of interviews, The Rightist, The Former Landowner and The Yi district Chief's Wife for example. The hunger, the loss of family members, the destruction of personal dignity, and the waste of years spent in unproductive activity are clearly revealed, as is the stoical bewilderment caused by living in a society where the political values were unpredictable. What is also clear is the extent to which traditional life and values exist; the family is important, and above all, a robust sense of humour that helps ensure and sweeten survival. This collection is recommended for any reader interested in China, and in the great events of the twentieth century in Asia.
Jenny Hamilton

All I ever wanted by Vikki Wakefield

cover image

Text, 2011. ISBN 9781921758300.
(Age 15+) Highly recommended. Mim has a set of rules that she is determined to live by. The first is not to be like her mother. She lives in a down trodden suburb, her mother sits on the sofa all day and her two brother are in prison for drug dealing. She longs to get away from her life and see the world, but she is stuck even though she is determined to finish school and do something. When she retrieves a package for her mother and Jordan, the boy she has had a crush on forever, takes it away from her, she is faced with lots of questions and danger. How will she be able to solve her problems?
This is a compulsive read on many levels.& Wakefield has kept the suspense quite tense for the reader as Mim struggles to get back the package her mother sent her to obtain. There are the sinister people who are involved with drug dealing and this thriller like thread makes for an excellent story. But it is the interactions that Mim has with the many characters in the street that flesh out this story and make it stand above many other adolescent books. Tahnee, her best friend for many years, is changing. She has discovered boys and booze and Mim is not sure that the friendship can last. There is a strange girl next door and she hates the elderly neighbour nearby. Jordan, who she has worshipped from afar for years, may not be the hero that she always thought and will the monster dog Gargoyle attack her?
Mim makes many discoveries on the way about herself, her perceptions of others and whether she can manage to live by a set of rigid rules.
An ideal class set or literature circle book, one that would appeal to reluctant readers, especially girls, All I ever wanted is sure to become popular if promoted in the library. Vikki Wakefield has been interviewed by Readings  and teacher notes are available at the Text website.
Pat Pledger

The golden door by Emily Rodda

cover image

Omnibus, 2011. ISBN 978 1 86291 912 9.
(Ages 10+) Warmly recommended. Fantasy. With the skimmers attacking every night, getting through the heavily guarded and blocked doors and crevices of the homes in the Weld, actually killing one family, the Warden finally acts. A proclamation stirs the passion of Dirk and Sholto and their friends, intent on being able to get outside of the wall and find the source of the skimmers, so destroying them. In so doing they will win the hand of the Warden's daughter, and be named his heir.
In a very few chapters, Emily Rodda introduces her new world, a world once safe behind its wall, where a myriad of rules keep people comforted and secure, but when a few of the younger generation find things too safe, the restrictions too cloying, and with the opportunity provided by this recent threat, they go searching for action. First Dirk and Sholto go off in search of the reason behind the skimmer attacks, and fail to return, their mother receiving a badge to wear showing that her sons have died in the line of duty. But when the skimmers destroy their home and livelihood, Rye and his mother must seek shelter at the Keep. Here they are separated and Rye seizes the opportunity to also go beyond the Wall.
A fantasy series full of adventure and colour, Rye's journey into the Fell Zone outside the Wall takes him far further than he could have imagined. I love this new series and am looking forward to book 2, as I am sure all readers will.
Fran Knight

For all creatures by Glenda Millard and Rebecca Cool, illustrator

cover image

Walker Books. 2011. ISBN 978 921520 81 8
(All ages) Recommended. Picture book. The array of creatures on the front cover impels the reader to quickly open this book to read what is going on. The title, reminding us of the hymn, All creatures great and small, too evokes many different memories and hints as we turn the page. Each page gives us a stanza with four lines of phrases, each phrase containing a group of words which describes a set of animals. But the descriptions are not those usually found, they are words which evoke a response from the reader, memories and observations, rounded off by the refrain, We are thankful. Frogs, for example, are described as a chorus of croakers, and this evocative phrase made me immediately think of times listening to frogs along a riverbank or pond. The words used are amazing, and Millard does not baulk at using words which will send both reader and teacher to the dictionary.
Each page is illustrated with animals and plants, surrounding the words in a visually stunning way, enticing the reader to look both at the words so framed and the illustrations complementing the words.
The colourful pages offer a dense series of richly detailed pictures for readers to look at over and over again. Their warmth and naiive quality will have immediate appeal to all readers, and are a stunning companion to the text.
Readers who enjoyed Isabella's garden by the same two will love this prayer to thankfullness for all we have around us. A wonder filled contribution to the array of animal picture books, this is a stand out.
Fran Knight

Once upon a time: A pop-in-the-slot storybook by Nick Sharratt

cover image

Walker Books, 2011 (c 2002). ISBN 9781406331929.
(Age 2-5) In this imaginative and slightly irreverent take on the traditional fairy tale where the princess makes three wishes, Nick Sharratt has produced a fun picture book that young children will love. It is different to the usual pop up book, in that it is a pop in the slot book, which allows young children to choose their own picture to complete the story, often with hilarious results. Imagine the results when the beautiful princess has the choice of a duck, toilet or fairy to grant her the three wishes. And what if the wishes were a pencil case, marrying a frog or being a pop star?
The illustrations are in bright colours and the princess is cartoon like with a range of amusing expressions. The pop in the slot idea gives active children the opportunity to be fully involved in making the pictures and story come alive. The pictures that go into the slots are on sheets in a pocket in the front of the book and will need to be carefully pressed out and perhaps put into a plastic bag to keep them together once they are out of their sheets.
Providing lots of funny alternatives, as well as pictures for the traditional story, this will provide children with different things to giggle about each time they look at the book. It will appeal to both girls and boys as there are things like a magic toilet that will interest boys and a fairy to interest girls.
I think that this could be an amusing choice for a gift to young children, especially if you would like a different storyline each time it is read.
Pat Pledger

Little sister by Aimee Said

cover image

Walker Books, 2011. ISBN: 9781921529214.
(Age 14+) Highly recommended. There are just thirty-eight days until Al's smart, pretty, popular and perfect-in-every-way sister Larrie finishes Year 12. Thirty-eight days until everyone at Whitlam High will stop seeing Al as Larrie's little sister and start appreciating the real Al Miller. But when rumours about Larrie start spreading, Al discovers that having a sister everybody is talking about is worse than having one everyone loves.
A very real-to-life story explaining how a sibling can react to a big secret. When I was reading this book I truly felt in the story. Al thought she was the one going through the hard time when really her sister was going through a harder one. Al has always been outshone by her sister and expected to do just as well as her if not better. Al hates always being outshone by her sister and can't wait until her sister graduates so that she can be herself. But things are never that easy.
A great book for anyone going through a hard time or just wanting to sit down and read a book over and over again.
Taylor Oxenham (Student)

Divergent by Veronica Roth

cover image

HarperCollins, 2011. ISBN 9780007420414.
(Age 14+) Highly recommended. This is one dystopian story that I had to finish in a day and that hasn't happened to me for quite a while. Reminiscent of The hunger games by Suzanne Collins; Divergent is the engrossing story of Beatrice (Tris for short) who has to choose what faction she will live in when she turns 16. The factions are Abnegation (selflessness), Candor (honesty), Amity (kindness), Dauntless (bravery) and Erudite (knowledge seeking). Each faction has placed enormous value on their own particular trait and members live their lives completely involved in it, believing that it keeps their world peaceful. Once a faction is chosen then that person must abide by its way of life or become displaced with no support and no group to belong to. When Tris makes her choice she has no idea of what she has let herself in for or that there are evil plans afoot to take power.
Tris is a fascinating main character. She is short, not pretty and finds it very difficult to live the selfless life that is expected of her in her Abnegation society. She is curious, wants to know what is going on and yearns for something more than always looking after others. When she is tested to see what faction she belongs to her tests are inconclusive and she is told that she is a Divergent - a person who has more than one trait - but her tester tells her to keep it a secret as it is dangerous.
There is action galore as Tris is pushed to her limit both physically and mentally in her training in her new faction. Many exciting moments had me holding my breath as Tris struggles to learn how to control both her mind and body and her growing attraction to Four, her trainer. She makes friends, one of who will betray her badly and uncovers a plot that could change her whole world. There is violence, murder, a near rape and bloodshed to content with.
I have read a lot of novels with dystopian themes and this is up there with the most engrossing. It wasn't difficult to place the factions into today's society - scientists being Erudite, the risk takers as the Dauntless and people like doctors and teachers who are often selfless as belonging to Abnegation. It had me thinking the roles that they play and what sort of society we would live in if, as in Tris' world, those selfless from Abnegation were the only ones allowed in government. But of course in any world there are the power seekers, the greedy and the selfish.
Nominated for ALA's Best Fiction for Teens award, this novel has every ingredient to make it very popular with both girls and boys. Tris and Four and secondary characters grab the reader's interest immediately, the theme of survival of the fittest is gripping and the world making is original.
Pat Pledger

Yulu's coal : a story from Adnyamathanha country by the Adnyamathanha community with Liz Thompson

cover image

Sharing our stories (series). Pearson Australia, 2011. ISBN 978 1 4425 4690 5.
(Ages 8+) Recommended. Aboriginal folklore. Yulu's coal, a story of how the coal came to be at Leigh Creek in South Australia's far north, is a story told over and over again by members of the Adnyamathanha community in explaining their heritage to their children.
The story tells of a ceremony at Wilpena Pound in the Flinders Ranges, where all the community was waiting for Yulu the Kingfisher Man to begin the ceremony. When he failed to appear, Wala the Wild Turkey Man was asked instead. But Yulu did not think that Wala could do this and lit a fire letting people know he was on his way.But two serpents also saw the smoke signals and came down to where Copley is today, curling around themselves forming the mountains now seen there. Arriving at the ceremony ground, the serpents made a lot of dust, and then ate many of the people, becoming so ill they needed to rest, and so formed Wilpena Pound. Yulu and Wala then formed the ochre pits near Copley and the coal now found at Leigh Creek.
The story itself tells people how the Flinders Ranges came to be and tells much about sites found in the mountains, Copley, Chamber's Gorge, Leigh Creek, Wilpena Pound, as well as giving much of the cultural detail about the Adnyamathnha people. It is a marvellous story, and is told by Noel Wilton, and illustrated by children from Leigh Creek Area School. At the end of the book the story is told in Adnyamathanha language and details are given about the elders and the children in this community. I appreciated the double page spread at the beginning introducing the Adnyamthanha community, detailing just where the people live, and the brief but very useful index.
All of the books in this series are similar, taking a story from one of the Aboriginal groups in Australia, having an elder tell the story, with children illustrating it, then adding much information about the community, the elders and the children. Bright, inviting illustrations round off a visually exciting range of books, sure to add much to the teaching of Aboriginal Dreaming stories in the classroom. But much more can be edduced from reading this with a class. The elders' stories give an insight into our shared history and what has happened to many Aboriginal people in the past, making these books an ideal springboard for class discussions not only about Dreaming stories but also the Stolen generation, Reconciliation and the Apology. For more about this fine series, go to this website.
Fran Knight

Northwood by Brian Falkner

cover image

Walker, 2011. ISBN: 978 1 921529 80 1.
Recommended for ages 9 and up. Nothing about Cecilia Undergarment's life is ordinary. In addition to her most unusual name, she lives with her parents in a six storey house, which looks like a bunch of balloons, and is able to speak to and understand animals and vice versa. When she and their maid rescue (or kidnap) Rocky, the dog owned by Mr. Proctor from next door, she becomes involved in a major adventure. Her attic room detaches itself from the rest of the house and drifts off in the direction of the forests of Northwood. Once the balloon comes to rest in the top of a tree, she and Rocky disembark and investigate the forest. They meet the other inhabitants of the area and attempt to rescue those who live there and take them back to her home. Not everything goes quite according to plan, however, and she meets with some resistance.
This title, although containing many everyday events and needs, crosses into the realms of almost parallel universes or fantasy worlds. Cecilia is a champion for the 'underdog' (no pun intended!) as she tries to support the inhabitants of the forest, particularly those who have not known any other life. She displays independence, compassion, persistence and resourcefulness as she fights for that in which she believes. Although she knows life is sometimes less than perfect, she endeavours to make things better for all whom she meets. Young children will undoubtedly enjoy reading about a girl of their own age, able to outsmart the 'unsavoury' adults in the tale, and be swept up in this adventure. Short chapters, double spaced print and full page illustrations liberally scattered throughout make this an easily accessible tale for younger, more competent readers through to the older children who are looking for an easy read.
Jo Schenkel