Reviews

The Cabinet of Curiosities by Paul Dowswell

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2010. ISBN 978 1 4088 0046 1.
The Cabinet of Curiosities is perfect for readers who like history. Set in 1598, around the time of the Spanish Inquisition, we meet teenager Lukas. He is on his way to Prague to become an apprentice to his uncle, Anselmus, the apothecary to the Emperor.
The Cabinet of Curiosities is a dark story, starting out with attempted murder and robbery, with Lukas having to steal and trick his way to Prague. He makes friends with Etienne, a quick-talking, confident con-artist.
Life in the castle is very different for Lukas and he is put to work, learning the ways of an apothecary. His uncle shows Lukas the Cabinet of Curiosities, a room full of wonders and treasures from around the world.
The dark themes continue as Spanish diplomats vie for the attention of the Emperor (in hopes of him following their ways). Lukas has made friends but they make plans to con and steal. The question is - from who?
Is The Cabinet of Curiosities on their agenda?
What will Lukas's uncle say when he finds out?
Kylie Kempster

Slog's dad by David Almond

cover image

Ill. by Dave McKean. Walker Books, 2010. ISBN 978-1406322903.
(Age: 10+) Recommended. From the blurb: 'Do you believe there's life after death? Slog does. He reckons that the scruffy bloke sitting outside the pork shop is his dad come back to visit him for one last time. But Slog's mate Davie isn't convinced.' The bloke seems to know things about Slog's dad that are impossible for Davie to understand.
The collaboration of Almond and McKean had a winning book in The Savage, and Slog's dad is equally as compelling. The exploration of the possibility of life after death is a thought provoking one that is handled very well. Almond's sparse prose, interspersed with McKean's fabulous pictures, graphically tells the story of how Slog's dad, a bin man, gradually becomes more and more ill, until he loses his legs and dies. Slog's belief that his father has come back is so compelling that I rushed to the end to see what the outcome of Slog's encounter with the tramp would be. After reading the story, I then went back and read more slowly, examining the pictures and thinking about all the ideas that are presented in this tender tale of love. I was fascinated by the supernatural hints that McKean drew in his illustrations of the man sitting on the park bench and the sepia toned newspaper articles that alluded to other things happening.
This is a very touching tale that will appeal both to those who believe in life after death and the possibility of someone returning for one last farewell, and to those who are sceptical. Almond's story combined with the illustrations, allow for both beliefs to exist side by side.
Slog's dad is a wonderful story that should give rise to much discussion in a classroom.
Pat Pledger

Haunted by Barbara Haworth-Attard

cover image

Random House Australia, 2010. ISBN 9781742750491.
(Age 12+) Recommended. Winner of the 2010 Arthur Ellis Crime Award, Haworth-Attard has created a scary, engrossing story that kept me reading to the end. Dee is frightened when bones are discovered on the mountain. To make it worse, a ring belonging to her friend Mary Ann Simpson was found with the bones, and other girls have disappeared from the area as well. Dee, like her grandmother, has the 'sight', and she catches glimpses of people who have died, but whose spirits are unwilling to move onto the afterlife. This ability, as well as the fact that her mother disappeared when she was a baby, makes her an outsider in the small town where she lives.
The suspense that Haworth-Attard builds up is totally gripping, as she describes the small town gossip and stifling attitudes that Dee and her grandmother have to tolerate. I virtually read this book in one sitting as I followed the progress of the police investigation as they attempted to find what turned out to be a serial killer. The plot twists are excellent, with few clues given to the identity of the murderer until the very end and the addition of the ghosts that Dee sees make it an enthralling read.
The book is rich with well-developed characters. Dee is a pragmatic child, intelligent and forthright and I loved the way that she was determined to have an education and do something with it. Descriptions of the health care that her grandmother gave the poorer people show what a strong and helpful character she was. Clarence, the soldier who has returned from the war in France, appears often to talk to Dee and the reader learns much about the First World War and what it was like afterwards for the families whose men had been killed.
I enjoy mystery stories and feel that Haunted is an excellent example of the genre.
Pat Pledger

Up and down by Oliver Jeffers

cover image

HarperCollins Children's Books, 2010. ISBN 978-0007263844.
Recommended. Picture book. The penguin and the boy are the best of friends. They always do things together. Because he does have wings, the penguin decides that he wants to fly and that is something that he tries although his wings didn't work very well. Ignoring the boy's advice, he continues on his quest to fly alone, leaving his friend behind.
This is a beautiful warm story about the power of friendship. Although the penguin is determined to fly by himself, the boy doesn't give up on him and is there to help him make a happy landing after his adventures.
Beautiful colours and amusing images of the boy and the penguin make this a visually appealing book to look at. Jeffers uses sombre colours and wistful expressions on the faces of the two companions to show how they were missing each other, and more vibrant happy shades to denote cheerfulness. My favourite picture comes at the end of the book and has a gorgeous pink background, with the penguin scooting along and the boy walking on stilts, making 'a break for home.'
Although Up and down is the fourth book about the boy and the penguin, it reads as a stand-alone and would be a valuable addition to a collection.
Pat Pledger

Zac wipes out by H.I. Larry

cover image

Zac power. Spy camp Mission 6. Hardie Grant Egmont, 2010. ISBN 9781921690518.
(Age: Newly independent readers) Zac is sitting in the dentist chair when he is suddenly whished off to Spy Camp to learn some more spying skills. Here he pairs off with Cam, code name Agent Wave because he loves surfing. They are taken by helicopter to a volcano, and here Zac has to put all his training and skills to work to rescue Cam from the lava flow.
Another in this great series for young readers, especially boys, Zac wipes out will especially appeal to children who enjoy surfing. They will really appreciate how Zac uses a stretcher as a surfboard and rides the lava wave.
Fifty-six pages of large print, interspersed with black and white illustrations make it a good book for the emerging reader.
Pat Pledger
,

The legacy by Gemma Malley

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2010. ISBN 978-1408800898.
The third in the series following The Declaration and The Resistance, sees a return to a dystopian future where very few children are born, as Longevity, a drug developed by the Pincent Pharma laboratories, keeps all the adults alive, promising eternal life. However blackened corpses are turning up everywhere as a virus sweeps the world and it appears that Longevity is no longer working. Richard Pincent is determined to find the original formula developed by Albert Fern but in the meantime blames the Underground movement for releasing the virus.
The Declaration is one of my favourite dystopian novels, its theme of what would happen in a world where new life no longer brings new ideas, fresh and original. The legacy brings to a satisfying conclusion the story of Peter and Anna, Jude and Sheila. Malley cleverly describes a world where the prevailing drug stops working, just as drugs today can lose their potency and fail to perform. The frightening machinations of politicians and drug company director are very realistic, as are the actions of the adults who could see their existence coming to an end.
Richard Pincent is a frightening villain, and Jude comes into his own in this volume. It was good to see how he used his computer skills to research and the slight romance with Sheila was engaging.
Malley's plot is engrossing and the ending has some unexpected twists and turns, which were a surprise, but nevertheless, very satisfying. This series is sure to please readers who like to think about issues like overpopulation, power of big drug companies and the selfishness of human nature, all themes in these books.
Pat Pledger

The Christmas book by Dick Bruna

cover image

Hardie Grant Egmont, 2007 (c1964). ISBN 9781921288814.
(Age 4-8) Recommended. Dick Bruna, the creator of the Miffy books, tells the Nativity story in this charming book. Although first published in 1964, it is a timeless book that will appeal to today's children, who may want to know the story behind Christmas.
Bruna has retold the story of the shepherds and the three wise men following a bright light that is an angel, to a stable in Bethlehem in a manner that is simple and easy to understand. The language is direct and sincere and describes the Nativity in a very straightforward way.
The delightful illustrations complement the words. I can image children using ideas from the way that Bruna has constructed his figures to making their own Nativity scene.
A useful addition to a collection of Christmas books, The Christmas book would also be book to read aloud to tell the story of the birth of Jesus.
Pat Pledger

Totally Bindi by Jess Black

cover image

Random House Australia, 2010. ISBN 978 1864718584.
(Ages 7+) Picture book/non fiction. A stocking filler for young girls and boys, this compilation of all things Bindi and the Australian Zoo, will please many. Pages of photos of Bindi with various animals, her family and father Steve Irwin will keep the reader involved and interested in all the things Bindi does from day to day. Each double page is sumptuous in its photography and has bites of information aimed at getting information quickly and easily. From swimming, skiing, snorkeling, riding a horse, showing people and friends the zoo, to motorcycling, the child does a range of activities which will entrance the reader. Seeing her grabbing a tortoise, listening to a koala's heartbeat, cuddling a snake, feeding a crocodile, Bindi is shown in all possible stances at Australia Zoo.
Interspersed with the many animal photos is a range of photos of Bindi and her family, making this feel like a family album, and those entranced with Steve Irwin and his life, will see many photos of him in action. Along the way are cross word puzzles, recipes, questions to answer and quizzes, word games and activities, all designed to keep the reader interested and reading. With pages of information about animals the books will please all comers.
Fran Knight

Mice by Gordon Reece

cover image

Allen and Unwin; 2010.
(Suitable for Year 10-12) The first part of this novel is quite disturbing due to girls subversively bullying and harassing Shelley. When the truth becomes evident Shelley and her mother decided that it is best if they move from their comfortable lifestyle to a quiet life in the country. This was meant to be the plan however not all goes according to this plan.
This novel is about gaining strength and realizing that you cannot be a victim forever. But in order to have this strength, compromise and morals are called into question. The characters are well defined and the story is well written with the reader constantly questioning what is fair and just.
Wendy Rutten

The Dead of Winter by Chris Priestley

cover image

Bloomsbury 2010.
(Ages 10-14) Recommended. I loved Chris Priestley's Tales of Terror from the Black Ship and this marvellously gothic ghost story more than lived up to my expectations.
Following the death of his mother, Michael is sent to stay with his benefactor who inhabits a crumbling mausoleum in the featureless marshlands of East Anglia. Sir Stephen is weak of mind, tormented by mysterious ghostly noises and apparitions. Michael himself is also haunted by these ghosts and his Christmas visit to the house is truly terrifying.
The death of Lady Clarendon, Sir Stephen's tragic wife, is shrouded in mystery and her ghost now haunts the house and grounds. To add to the air of threat, Sir Stephen himself is plagued by memories of a childhood ordeal when he was imprisoned in a priest hole by his father. He has never recovered from this trauma and when the same thing happens to Michael he relives his terror.
Priestley's steady build up of atmosphere and tension is outstanding as Michael gradually uncovers the mystery surrounding Lady Clarendon's death and we learn that although ghosts are present, responsibility for her death lies firmly at the feet of the living. The terror intensifies to a cracking denouement that will leave readers with nerves jangling and their hair standing on end!
Priestly has almost certainly borrowed ideas and characters from the best examples of gothic novels and I could detect elements of Jane Eyre, Great Expectations and Rebecca here. Although not exactly Christmassy The Dead of Winter is set over the festive season, so you could recommend it as a scary Christmas read.
Claire Larson

Summer of sabotage by Bob Temple

cover image

Raintree, ISBN 978 1406215960.
Recommended for upper primary and those older, who find reading a challenge. A good 'who done it' mystery. The plot is well developed and keeps the reader in suspense until the end. Daniel and Aaron love the water park and spend as much of the summer there as they can. Unaccountable accidents begin to occur and Daniel is sure they are deliberate so he decides to investigate much to his friend Aaron's initial amusement. But when they are forbidden to go to the Park for a week they both spend their time thinking of possible suspects. Is it Gabe, the Water Park's Manager, Mrs Parker or even Janie, the heroine of the Water Park. The language is not complex, has simple sentences and the chapters short and easily read. A useful Glossary, Discussion Questions, Author Information, Writing Prompts and most useful is a double page of water safety suggestions. Typeface and font are very appropriate.
Sue Nosworthy

Charles Dickens's A Christmas Carol retold by Martin Howard

cover image

Ill. by Carlo Molinari and Chris Gould. Hardie Grant Egmont, 2009.
ISBN 978-192156420-8
This attractively produced picture book version of Dickens' story does not live up to its early promise.
Martin Howard retells Charles Dickens' classic story of mean Ebenezer Scrooge's encounter with the ghosts of Christmas past, present and future and his eventual redemption. The book is lavishly illustrated with sliders, flaps, add-ins and a pop up centre depicting the ghost of Christmas present. The text appears in blocks around the brightly coloured illustrations of Victorian London interspersed with panels of extra information, recipes and games. What makes this an uncomfortable format is the density of the text, a lot to read aloud as a story book and confusingly disjointed when constructing a continuous narrative from the parts. A lot of the illustrations depict sinister subjects and sections of the text are quite scary. Unless familiar with the happy ending, readers dipping into the separate parts of the book could be left with a worryingly negative view of what should be a happy time of year.
The pop-ups and extras are not particularly exciting and would make this a fragile book to have in a school library.
Not recommended for readers under 9 years.
Sue Speck

The Odyssey: a Graphic Novel by Gareth Hinds

cover image

Candlewick Press, 2010. ISBN 978-0-7636-4268-6.
This beautifully crafted graphic novel is one of the best I have read. It is the story of Odysseus, thwarted by the god Poseidon in his attempts to return home to his wife and son after the Trojan wars. Monsters and obstacles are put in his way, only to be overcome with the help of the goddess Athena, and the hero has some romantic encounters on the way.  This interpretation of Homer's epic poem is well researched as are the atmospheric pencil and watercolour renderings of life on the Greek islands in the Bronze Age add another dimension to the text.
Well balanced between the carefully chosen dialogue and the visual narrative, each frame effectively communicates the story without the need for extra explanation. The characters are well drawn and easy to identify, the use of soft coloured outlines to distinguish gods from mortals, works well. The reader is able to instantly and vividly recognise the characters' emotions as they struggle through each trial and dynamic viewpoints add to the fast pace.
Following on from Hinds' graphic adaptations of Beowulf and Shakespeare's King Lear and Merchant of Venice, this literate adaptation will have appeal for adults and senior students revisiting the classic text while the skill of the artist makes it accessible to ESL and middle school students looking for a story of adventure and hardships overcome.
Sue Speck

Legend of the Golden Snail by Graeme Base

cover image

Puffin, 2010. ISBN 9780670073498.
(Ages: 4-8) Highly recommended. Wilbur is enchanted by a story about a Golden Snail, which takes the shape of a golden galleon when it sails through the Magical Realm. One day it is captured by a Grand Enchanter, who forces it to obey his commands. After sailing it for a 100 years, the Enchanter banishes it to the ends of the earth until a new master comes to claim it. Wilbur decides to find the Golden Snail and he and his faithful cat set off on sailboat, finding some creatures that need rescuing on the way.
Like all good fairy tales, there is a moral to the story. Wilbur sees creatures in distress and instead of leaving them in their misery, he helps them on their way. He waters a butterfly bush that is wilting, releases a crab from a net, and stops earwig pirates from stealing light bulbs from lantern fish. In turn, when Wilbur gets into trouble, these creatures come to his aid.
The language is beautiful, full of alliterations and stunning images. It is a lovely book to read aloud, stimulating the imagination and leaving behind haunting thoughts of good and evil.
The artwork is striking, with beautiful bold pictures, and gorgeous greens, blues and golds. I particularly loved the picture of the 'newly blossomed butterflies' bringing back the wind when Wilbur's boat drifts into the Dreadful Doldrums.
With extras in the book, like a small additional book attached in the front page, and a picture of a snail and crossbones on every page for the curious to find, as well as instructions to go to Base's website, this book will delight children and adults everywhere. It is a keeper!
Pat Pledger

Slice by Steven Herrick

cover image

Woolshed Press 2010. ISBN 9781864719642.
Recommended for ages 14+. As we have come to expect from the writing of Steven Herrick, Slice, is a witty and enjoyable narrative, with many 'juicy moments' to savour!The story is simply told - more like glimpses of a teenage life, as the title suggests - by Darcy Walker, 16 year old school student carrying a bit of baggage from home; namely parental expectations which haven't really eventuated. Darcy is very likeable though and his relationships with family and friends bring out a good deal of conversational humour which makes for entertaining reading.
Slice has the appeal of previous stories, such as The Spangled Drongo and Tom Jones Saves the World. Attention is focused on his attraction and developing intimacy with Audrey: their conversations are great fun to overhear. Indeed, there are many scenes throughout Slice which read so well out loud.
Light-hearted and honest, with no pretensions, this novel is clever, funny and very readable.
Julie Wells