Reviews

From those wonderful folks who gave you Pearl Harbor. Frontline dispatches from the advertising war by Jerry Della Femina

cover image

ed. Charles Sopkin. Text Publishing, 2010.
(Age: Year 12+) This book, originally published in 1971 as a look at the advertising world in New York, has been re-released following the success of the television series Mad men, based in part on it. Non-fiction, the book reveals the changes in the industry in New York, from so conservative that, as the author was told, 'people of his kind' would not be employed on ethnic grounds, to an industry where the copywriters were frequently high on drugs, did not start work until late in the day and the sexual revolution of the sixties was clearly happening.
The themes covered include the precariousness of the work, even experienced advertisers spending months unemployed at times. The author also reveals the need for intelligence, as well as the industry's reputation for glamour and in fact frequently the lack of glamour. Censorship is an important issue; as an advertiser the author is usually against it. He also demonstrates the relationships between the various branches in an agency, and how this can malfunction.
The book provides insights into how businesses work and how personalities are important; it has some discussion of the ethics of advertising and censorship but does not examine the methodology or techniques. The author's voice is distinctively from New York, his anecdotes are lively and humorous, and the book moves along at a good pace. Though probably of limited use for most students for curriculum purposes, it is an enjoyable and informative read.
Jenny Hamilton

Jasper Jones by Craig Silvey

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2009. ISBN 978 1 74212 370 7
Louis Braille Audio, 2010. 11 CDs, 13 hours. Read by Humphrey Bower
Highly recommended. Hearing someone calling him through his louvred bedroom window, Charlie climbs out and discovers the boy that parents warn against, a boy who roams the streets, with an alcoholic father and Aboriginal mother, an outcast in this small community, except for when he plays football. But Charlie does follow him and is taken to the most appalling sight he has ever seen, a dead girl hanging from a tree in a spot everyone knows is Jasper's private place.
Together the boys work out some sort of plan, hoping to uncover the killer before the police come for Jasper, knowing full well that if this happens, Jasper will end his days in jail.
Isolated Charlie faithfully records the hypocrisies of life in mid twentieth century Australia, but does not intervene when Vietnamese Jeffery, his best friend, is taunted and abused, or Jasper is beaten up, or Eliza is vilified by the ogling boys in the cricket team. Examples of killers abound as Charlie reads of the trials of Eric Cooke with the hair lip killing women in Perth in the 1960's or the horrific murder of Sylvia Likens in the USA in 1965, and later the disappearance of the Beaumont children in South Australia in the 1960's.  These form a disturbing backdrop the story of the death of Laura Wishart that is gripping and intriguing, leading us on until we know the whole shocking truth of this small country town.
The reading by Humphrey Bower is intoxicating. His voice takes on the innocence and fear of a young boy caught up in an incident beyond his experience and years. The two boys are contrasted extremely well, Bower's voice having a degree of unsettledness which denotes Charlie's shock at what is happening around him. Bower is able to easily identify for us the different characters, and the modulation and intensity of his voice grabs the readers' attention as the story progresses. The deliberate pace underlines the laconic nature of the Australian character and the range of characters is delineated by a change of tone rather than the use of stereotypical accents.
This is a disturbing story that resonates with moral questions, ambiguity and the notion of right and wrong. There is no black or white answer, but the subtlety of the story and its consequences will intrigue and provoke discussion.
Fran Knight

The Uninvited by Tim Wynne-Jones

cover image

Walker Books, 2010.
(Ages 14 plus) A complex set of circumstances conspire to ensure an extended dysfunctional (but strangely loving) family end up meeting through the vagaries of a wonderfully eccentric dad.
Mimi, an out of luck, mini-cooper driving New Yorker, attempts to erase an undesirable ex-lover from her mind by heading up to her father's 'undisclosed' holiday retreat in Ontario.
Adventures abound as Mimi discovers Jackson Page, living 'illegally' in the cabin (suggested by her dad as an antedote for recovering from a failed relationship.)
As Mimi and Jackson develop a smouldering friendship and sympathetic understanding of each other's past and future needs, Cramer, a local resident with issues of his own, spies and interferes (with strangely quirky logic) into their lives, eerily taking a fancy to Mimi.
The intricately woven relationships unfold, enabling 25 years of history to link the main three protagonists and solve many unanswered questions.
The creepy nature of some characters and settings ensure this book is an entertaining but engaging read right until the end as does the desire to find out the character connections that permeate the plot!
Deirdre Murphy

Ninth Grade Slays by Heather Brewer

cover image

Penguin, 2010. ISBN 978 0 14 320515 9.
Highly recommended. The second book in The Chronicles of Vladimir Tod - Ninth Grade Slays, continues to follow the life of Vladimir, his friend Henry and the trials of high school, particularly when you are a little different! Vladimir has discovered girls, in particular Meredith and is trying to work up the courage to talk to her. His uncle Otis continues to write sharing knowledge with Vladimir about his telepathy and how best to develop it. School begins and trouble starts: photographers following him, grades slipping. A trip to Siberian to study under one of his father's friends helps Vladimir to hone his skills but on his return he must cope with a vampire attack and confront the slayer hired to kill him.
This well written series is filled with intrigue, danger, search for identity, friendship and life experiences and despite the market being inundated with 'vampire' stories this stands out as one worth reading.
Tracy Glover

A secret gift by Ted Gup

cover image

Sub-title: How one man's kindness - and a trove of letters - revealed the hidden history of the Great Depression
Random House Australia, 2010. ISBN 9781741669442.
(Age 14+) On 18th December 1933, an advertisement appeared in the local paper of a small town in Ohio. It offered gifts of money for Christmas to 'men or families' in exchange for information about the difficulties they were facing. The advertisement was signed 'B. Virdot', a name unknown in the community. The letters poured in. They documented the bitter harvest of the Depression - unemployment, hunger, illness and separation.
Seventy-five years later, reporter Ted Gup found the letters in a suitcase in his mother's attic. The mysterious philanthropist was his grandfather. The seasoned journalist realised that he had discovered a window into the lives of those who suffered the greatest financial collapse of the twentieth century. He was also prompted to find out more about his grandfather and why he had been moved to help his community.
Although this book reveals life in small town America in the 1930s, it tells a universal tale about migration, hard work and the desperation of people who are thrown into poverty through no fault of their own. The author reflects on relationships, family secrets and the emotional, physical and social toll of chronic unemployment. He also sees parallels between the Great Depression and the recent Global Financial Crisis. A collection of black and white photographs includes 'then and now' portraits of some of the town's inhabitants.
By researching the personal circumstances of each letter writer and interspersing his findings with discoveries about his own family, Ted Gup has written a gentle but thought-provoking book. Although many younger readers might find the material fascinating and inspiring, the author has written his account for an adult audience. His clear, concise writing is the work of a consummate journalist accustomed to communicating with readers of the Washington Post and the New York Times.
A secret gift is a story which will reward anyone interested in the courage of so-called 'ordinary' people in times of hardship.
Elizabeth Bor

The Dragons - Excalibur by Colin Thompson

cover image

Random House, 2010. ISBN 978 1 74166382 2.
This is the second book in The Dragon series and follows on from the first. After a mistaken identity the real King Arthur has taken over the rule of the Kingdom and optimism spreads throughout Camelot. However Brat and Blot have other plans. They are not happy about the way King Arthur is ruling and plot an overthrow. When word reaches the palace, of Brat and Blot's plans, Morgan le Fey, Sir Lancelot and a vampire attempt to save the kingdom.
This series is written as a send up of ancient times. The language is obscure at times and the undertone and setting have limited appeal. The book has an interesting format with footnotes and illustrations scattered throughout to make sense of the story.
Tracy Glover

Mimi and the Blue Slave by Catherine Bateson

cover image

Woolshed Press, 2010. ISBN: 978 1 86471 994 9
(Ages 9+) Recommended. Mimi is part of a fairly normal, happy family until her father's death suddenly tears them apart. The story opens two days before the funeral, when Mimi has been struck down with the flu. Her mother has the support of her sisters, Ann who is somewhat proper and judgmental and Marita who is rather more alternative. Mimi must instead rely on her imaginary pirate friend, Ableth, for guidance and help. Following the funeral Mimi and her mum leave on a holiday which is meant to help them both but fails to achieve its purpose. On their return home, grief affects her mother badly and Mimi buries her own grief to try and keep the household and the antique business running. New friendships are forged with Fergus, the boy from the organic fruit and vegetable shop and various people her parents have long known from the antique trade and gradually life begins to improve again.
This is a brilliant story of change, grief, friendship, loyalty throughout the process of dealing with the death of someone close. It is imbued with warmth and humour as the personalities of the two aunts balance the serious side of the book. Bateson manages to focus on the tough issues in such a way as to make them accessible to younger readers, providing a sense of hope to any who may have had the misfortune to have experienced such things in their own lives.
Jo Schenkel

6 by Karen Tayleur

cover image

Black dog books. ISBN 978 174203155 2.
An amazingly confronting story of six young people in their last year of school. The voices of the characters seem so realistic and so true, especially to parents who have been through year twelve!  Sarah is the clever girl but longs to be admired and sought after by Finn, a first footy team member and very good looking. We hear the stories of the other five but it is mostly Sarah's story. The little ditties at the beginning of each chapter are intriguing, encouraging the reader to find out more.
Year twelve is a roller coaster ride for many students and so each person's story contributes to the whole. It's the usual scenario of who loves whom and how does this work and if it doesn't, then how devastating life becomes! What is so compelling about this year twelve drama is that the resolution is unexpected, thankfully! A very cleverly written story involving death, alcohol and cars. Parents and teachers sometimes worry about stories for year twelves, but this has all the elements of a disaster with an intriguing ending for discussion, and with the characters able to move into the next phase of their lives and having a little more understanding of the others in their group.
Well recommended for Middle and Senior Students
Sue Nosworthy

The Song of the Winns by Frances Watts

cover image

The Gerander Trilogy, Book. HarperCollins, 2010. ISBN: 978 0 7333 2786 5.
Highly recommended. Since their parents were killed in an accident, three mice, siblings Alex, Alistair and Alice, have lived with their Aunt and Uncle. Their 'ordinary' existence ceases when Alistair is kidnapped. Whilst Alistair finds himself unceremoniously dumped on top of Tibby Rose in a far off place and develops a friendship with her, Alex and Alice decide to embark on their own adventure to find and retrieve their brother.
Tibby and Alistair share an uncommon trait; they are both ginger mice, a fact which has not been a problem while they have been safe within the midst of their families. It is, however, this fact that leads them into dangerous situations and causes them to run away to what they hope is safety. Both pairs of mice try to understand why they are being followed and explain the mystery and adventure in which they have found themselves, as they battle the dilemma of who can be trusted.
As the first book in this trilogy, The Song of the Winns provides new and interesting characters, setting and a plot with sufficient interest and excitement to make one wish to continue reading the next book immediately. It brought to mind Mrs Frisby and the Rats of NIMH, which I read many years ago, as both series revolve around intelligent rodents and have the potential to become classic texts. This series has the capacity to become didactic with regard to war and prejudice due to race and colour but hopefully will not overshadow the entertaining nature of the tale of friendship, courage and adventure.
Jo Schenkel

Slog's Dad by David Almond

cover image

Illustrated by Dave McKean. Walker Books, 2010. ISBN 978 1 4063 22903.
Highly recommended. This is one of those rare books that will give you goose bumps as you read, a book that makes you weep quietly to yourself - a book that you read knowing that you are in the hands of a skilled writer. Slog's dad has died. First he had a black spot on his toe, so his foot was amputated, and then his leg and sitting in front of his house he joked with passers by. But then another spot appeared on his remaining leg. But when that leg was removed as well, he became quiet. The years of smoking and working on the rubbish trucks came to an end. He no longer joked with passers by, but kept to his room, with his wife waiting upon him. But he promised Slog that he would come back in the spring. The illustrations reiterate the story of the man losing his legs, showing a boy playing with a paper cut out of a man, taking one leg and then the other from the paper.
So when Slog sees a man in the park, he is ecstatic. Hus friend, Dave is not so sure, and butts in offering alternative explanations for this man, asking him questions that only Slog's dad would know how to answer. But despite this, Slog is convinced that he has seen his dad once again, and so says goodbye.
A bare story with few words, but what words! Each one resonates with meaning and empathy for the boy who has lost his father. In between the words are pages of incredible illustrations, designed, as with the words, to grasp at your throat, pulling the reader into the story of the boy accepting his father's death.
Fran Knight

Henry V by William Shakespeare, retold by Robert Swindells

cover image

A and C Black, 2010. ISBN 978 1 40812398 6.
A retelling of Shakespeare's Henry V in 94 pages makes the play more accessible to a wider audience. All of the main characters are there, Henry V, Bedford, Gloucester, Archbishop of Canterbury as well as the French king and his entourage, and even the lower orders, Pistol, a dying Falstaff and Num. The play opens with Henry V deciding with his advisers that their only option is to go to war with France. Act 2 sees the army in France, and the dialogue between the lower orders, Num Pistol and Bardolph easily parallels the lives of some of Henry's men. Act three sees the two armies the night before the Battle of Agincourt and we see Henry V strolling incognito amongst his men, gauging what they are feeling and encouraging their participation. Act four details the awful battle and statistics are given towards the end of this act to underscore the impressive defeat of the French army. Act five sees the mopping up of the campaign, and Henry V returning to France to marry the French king's sister, Katherine.
Those reading the original will be well served by reading this shortened modern retelling. A list of characters at the start of the play will aid the readers, and each act is prefaced by one of the important speeches from the play. Comments by Swindells at the end reiterate the power of Shakespeare's language in this play, and he quotes two of the major speeches which will resonate with many.
This amazing adaptation is one of the series, Shakespeare Today, published by A and C Black.
Fran Knight

Pearlie and the Big Doll by Wendy Harmer

cover image

Random House, 2010. (Deluxe edition). ISBN: 978 1864718218.
When cleaning the park one evening, Pearlie the Park Fairy discovers a lost doll which has been left behind by a visitor. Because the Dolly seems so sad to have lost her Little Girl, Pearlie enlists the help of all the park animals to give a wonderful concert to try and make Dolly happy. As the show occurs with the boot scooting Duck Family, Silky and Sulky the trapeze artist spiders, four acrobatic frogs, Brush and Sugar the singing possums, the rats, Scrag and Mr Flea, Dolly stops crying and begins to enjoy the performance.
Aimed at beginner readers, this series is perfectly targeted at young girls. The hot pink endpapers, glimmering cover and stylised art work, in addition to the paper doll which can be dressed in several different outfits, should make this a very appealing read and activity book for such an audience. During the concert, the rats, who have 'brushed their fur and cleaned their teeth', present some 'I say, I say' jokes and provide the type of humour bound to appeal to the young reader, showing that Harmer knows her audience well. Given that Pearlie has now been taken on by Nickelodeon as an animated cartoon series, the books will undoubtedly continue to gain even further popularity.
Jo Schenkel, Pilgrim School

A very special visitor by Rebecca Geelings

cover image

Ill. by Karen Sapp. Egmont, 2010. ISBN 9781405256193.
(Age 2-4) In this book about the magic of Christmas, there is a journey through many things that make Christmas special. Snow has covered everything, a church bell chimes and happy people sing carols. But best of all there is a very special visitor to delight everyone.
This board book contains flaps to lift which young children will enjoy. The flaps are cleverly hidden among the illustrations by Karen Sapp, and may provide a fascinating challenge for toddlers when they first listen to the book The last two pages have flaps containing Christmas tree decorations, which are lifted out of the book to place on the Christmas tree. I think that could be a very enjoyable Christmas activity for parent and child.
Pat Pledger

Miguel de Cervantes Don Quixote retold by Martin Jenkins

cover image

Ill. by Chris Riddell. Walker Books 2010. ISBN 9781406324303.
(Age 11+) When we remark that someone is 'tilting at windmills' and behaving in a 'quixotic' fashion, we are harking back to one of the most influential stories ever told - Don Quixote. The central character, a retired Spanish gentleman living in La Mancha, becomes so obsessed with old-fashioned tales of chivalry that he decides to live out his dream of becoming a knight who performs brave deeds. Wearing a home-made suit of armour and riding on his bony horse, Rocinante, he sets out on his quest. His fantasy is so complete that he mistakes bad food for good, an inn for a castle and windmills for giants. Quixote's 'Squire', the trusty and realistic Sancho Panza, is a perfect foil for his deluded master.
Cervantes lived in an era when the certainties of mediaeval life were being replaced by a spirit of enquiry. The hero's journey into fantasy then return to reality is regarded as the forerunner of the modern novel which traces a character's emotional development.
Chris Riddell's animated, cartoon-like pictures reveal the idiosyncrasies of a passing parade of characters. Pen and ink drawings, wrapped around text boxes, are interspersed with occasional full-page colour illustrations which make the old hero and his companion look both noble and ridiculous.
Curiously, while the illustrator has written an introduction to the work, the author has not. This is an opportunity missed. Young readers might welcome an overview of early 17th century Spanish culture and a glossary to explain terms like 'Basque' and 'Moor'. Occasional lapses in syntax prevent the story from flowing smoothly but the retelling is largely successful.
Martin Jenkins won the Kate Greenaway Medal for his retelling of Gulliver's travels. His adaptation of Don Quixote is a worthy attempt, attractively presented, to bring another classic within the reach of a younger audience.
Elizabeth Bor

I am Number Four by Pittacus Lore

cover image

Penguin Books, 2010. ISBN 9780143205135.
(Ages 13 +) I am Number Four is an entertaining book about an alien teenager from the planet Lorien, unoriginally given the ordinary name of John Smith. He has been living on earth since fleeing his home planet when he was four years old with nine other children. Three of the other children have already been hunted down and murdered by the Mogadorians, aliens from the planet that invaded and conquered Lorian. John and his guardian (or Cepan) Henri have continued to flee the detection and suspicion of people on earth and the Mogadorians by continuously moving from town to town, changing identities each time. However, when John and Henry arrive in the small town of Paradise, Ohio, John meets a girl and becomes more determined to stay, even if this means a head on encounter with Mogadorians who he knows want to kill him next. John's arrival in the new town also coincides with the arrival of his Legacies, these are special powers inherited from his Lorien parents. In this respect, I am Number Four is a 'coming of age' story where the central teenage character develops into adulthood taking control of his destiny with his new powers and freedoms and as a result the themes of this book parallel the lives of many teenage readers. There are also comparisons that could be made to the classic Romeo and Juliet love tragedy, although they are not strong. Whilst there is some minor depictions of violence and occasional course words this is fairly low level. A renewed interest in this book is likely to be generated with this quick release of the film version in early 2011 (refer to the film's official website at http://findnumberfour.com/). I suspect that this was the book's original intent given the speed in which the film version has been released.
Adam Fitzgerald