Reviews

The Butterfly Heart by Paula Leyden

cover image

Walker Books, 2011. ISBN 9781406327922.
(Age: 12+) This charming story takes place in Zambia where twins Bul-Boo and Madillo live with their parents and a colourful assortment of friends and neighbours. When they discover that their school friend, Winifred, is destined for a terrible fate, the girls feel compelled to help. Bul-Boo seeks the help of Ifwafwa, the wise snake man but can he deliver a solution before it is too late? Fred, who lives next door, thinks his great grandmother can help. She is rumoured to be like a witch with magical powers but she inspires awe and terror in equal measure in the children.
The author spent her childhood in Zambia and her knowledge of local traditions, stories and customs make this story a delightful insight into the 'butterfly heart of Africa'. Superstition and logic interweave as the characters seek a solution to their problem. The story is essentially told in first person from the viewpoints of Bul-Boo, Ifwafwa and Winifred which sustains the momentum of the story. The chapters are short making it easy to read. Probably best suited to younger teens, it is a very enjoyable read.
Tina Cain

Equinox by Lara Morgan

cover image

Walker, 2011.
The Rosie Black chronicles are thrilling novels that lead on from each other perfectly, the books are set five hundred years into the future where mankind is split into three groups of civilization, the 'Centrals' are usually very popular and wealthy, an upper class civilization. The 'Ferals' are a race that scavenges to survive, living in poverty, dwelling on the fringe of humanity, and lastly, the 'Bankers' these people are in between 'Feral' and 'Central' status, living healthily but still aren't as good of as the 'Centrals'.
The main character of both novels is Rosie Black; in the novel Equinox (novel #2) she is struggling to shut down the evil corporation, 'Helios' the ones responsible for the death of her mother and many more through the creation of 'Mal X' a horrible disease that only gives you a very painful and draining short time to live after you have been infected. In this novel, Rosie and Pip (a very nice Feral) are trying to destroy the evil Helios with the help of Riley, a very smart man who is experienced in Helios technical workings along with Aunt Essie and Dalton (a central). Rosie's father has been captured by the Helios and Rosie and her friends are bent on rescuing him, but it is like a choice decision, save her father or destroy the Helios, or both. It is a very hard decision for Rosie.
This book was very enjoyable, with the action starting almost immediately, but, like the first novel, there is no clear plot but the little sequence of events are thrilling and make up for this. For age recommendation I would say 10 onwards because of the language and some of the terms are heard to understand for less mature readers.
Sarah Filkin (Student)

The Wicked Wood gathered by Isobelle Carmody and Nan McNab

cover image

Tales from the Tower: Volume 2. Allen and Unwin 2011. ISBN 9781742374413.
(Ages: 15+) Highly recommended. The Wicked Wood accompanies The Wilful Eye; both volumes described as collections of 'tales of enchantment from six writers of modern fantasy'. Most striking, at first glance, are the covers designed by Zoe Sadokierski. With the books placed alongside each other, the hands of two rather amazing winged female creatures meet, giving the collection unity and continuity. A valuable introduction by Nan McNab begins the journey for the reader and each of the contributors is given space at the conclusion of their particular story to explain its origin. Fairy tales carry great insights into everyday life and the same stories are told the world over. Analysing these tales can be a fascinating exercise and having new interpretations of well-known stories presented in this way makes for interesting and memorable reading. The length of each story differs, as does the familiarity of its plot. Each of the stories stands alone well, with a link to a traditional fairy tale being somewhat more obvious with some than with others. All are exciting tales of fiction, full of mystery and imagination. As with the previous volume, most stories in this collection will be of interest to the teenage reader with some obviously referring to more adult themes. Of interest, too, are the various writing styles of each of the chosen authors, and how they choose to retell their tale. This collection is highly recommended.
Julie Wells

Long Lankin by Lindsey Barraclough

cover image

Bodley Head, 2011. ISBN 9780370331966.
(Age 13+) Recommended. Horror. Based on an old folk ballad about Long Lankin, a bogeyman who creeps into houses and steals little children, this is a truly chilling story that sent shivers down my spine from the moment that I started it. When Cora and little Mimi's mother suffers a breakdown, they are sent to stay with their Aunt Ida, who lives in a large dilapidated manor house near the village of Bryers Guerdon. Aunt Ida is not pleased to see them and Cora immediately senses that all is not right when she forbids them to go near the local church and keeps all the windows and doors locked in the house. When Cora meets Roger and his large family, together they try to solve the mystery of the words Cave Bestiam (Beware the beast), which are above the front door of Aunt Ida's house and in the church.
Set in post-world war 2 Britain which is vividly depicted, the readers becomes immersed in the story which is told in the voices of Cora, Roger and Aunt Ida. Each of these characters are fully fleshed and come alive on the page. Cora is a brave, stoic girl who endures her aunt's beatings and continues to try and solve the mystery that surrounds the Guerdon family and the threat that surrounds Mimi. Roger comes from a large happy family and uses his intelligence to follow clues, and although Aunt Ida is forbidding, the reader gradually learns her story and comes to sympathizes with her plight.
Barraclough builds up suspense to an almost unbearable point. Terrifying and unexplained events happen. Dark strangers lurk and the ghosts of lost children appear. Mimi is terrified of a portrait in the house and Cora sees the ghost of a nurse. When the children disobey Aunt Ida and visit the churchyard, things become even more frightening.
I couldn't put this book down. It is one of the most chilling books that I have read, but it is also written beautifully, the prose bringing alive the characters of the children and adults, the threats of the marshlands, the old manor house and the horror of Long Lankin. People who have enjoyed Helen Grant's books or those by Marcus Sedgwick will enjoy this.
Pat Pledger

The Traitor and the Tunnel : a Mary Quinn mystery by Y. S. Lee

cover image

Walker, 2011. ISBN 9781406315974.
(Ages: 15+) Recommended. Mary is a young woman with a covert life. From a poverty stricken youth in harsh Victorian London that finds her tried and convicted of thievery, to an unexpected reprieve at the hands of a couple of bright, forward thinking women, she is now a trained private detective in a secret, all women's agency. In this, the third novel of the Mary Quinn Mystery series, we find Mary working undercover as a maid in Buckingham Palace, trying to find the culprit in a series of petty thefts. Whilst on the job, the Prince of Wales, becomes embroiled in a murder in an opium den much to the horror of his mother, Queen Victoria. To make matters worse, the prime suspect may be Mary's own long lost father. In her quest to find the truth, Mary witnesses a series of strange events, discovers a secret passage under the Palace and tries to find the traitor in the midst of all these intrigues. She also rekindles her acquaintance with the handsome but infuriating James Easton, all the while trying to ward off the unwelcome advances of the Prince of Wales and the attentions of the sleazy gutter journalist Octavius Jones.
The scenes shift from the opulent drawing rooms to the spartan servant quarters of Buckingham Palace, the prim niceties of Victorian society, to the slums and grim prisons of a dark, desperate London and the sewers that run beneath the city. This historical novel, that is obviously lovingly researched by its author, doesn't become bogged down in details, and is beguiling rather than overwrought. I especially enjoyed the banter and simmering passion between Mary and James, the man who keeps turning up in her life.
Mary is a fine character, that despite her terrible start in life, has managed to retain a sense of humour and worth and maintains self-respect and chutzpah throughout.
This is an enjoyable romp of a tale, though not without sadness and tragedy, which provides a glimpse into the life of Victorian England, as well as being a page turning mystery.
Alicia Papp

Crossed by Ally Condie

cover image

Penguin Books, 2011. ISBN 9780141333069.
(Age: 15+) Cassia lives in a world where everything is decided by a central ruling authority. The Society, as this authority is referred to, decrees which books one should read, the jobs that one should occupy and even selects the partner one should be matched with. Cassia risks everything when she defies the rules and falls in love with Ky. He has escaped to the wild frontiers beyond Society and Cassia is determined to find him. The world that Cassia discovers brings new challenges and Cassia is forced to reconsider her destiny.
Crossed is the second book in the Matched Trilogy. Readers who haven't read the first book will not be familiar with the unique setting and concepts that characterise this story. This makes the first few chapters a little challenging however it is well worth persevering with the sophisticated story. The reward is a fast paced, thrilling read and the anticipation of the final book, yet to come.
Tina Cain

I love you book by Libby Hathorn and Heath McKenzie

cover image

IP Books, 2011 ISBN 978 1 9214798 9 2
(Ages 4+) Picture book. A book promoting the same sentiments as Look, a BOOK! (Libby Gleeson and Freya Blackwood) but in an entirely different way, I love you book, has short stanzas on each page extolling the virtues of reading a book. So we see Dad reading to the children, or the children being flown away on a cloud of imagination, or talking about the words contained in a book and the dizzying heights a book can take you. The picture book talks about books good enough to eat, the smell and feel of books, the love of stories read in the past and those still to come and those read over and over again.
Each page is overwhelmingly colourful and energetic, as the children roll about in bed, or take to the stage, or go under the sea, or jump across piles of books. Enthusiasm for and a love of books is revealed on each page, and all readers will find things to look at and recognise amidst the scattering of people, animals and places.
Appropriately 2012 is the National year of Reading in Australia, designed to promote reading and books throughout the country and this along with several other books, will be read and reread as teachers promote reading with their classes.
Fran Knight

Inheritance by Christopher Paolini

cover image

Inheritance Cycle Bk 4. Random House, 2011. ISBN 9780385616508.
(Age: 13+) Highly recommended. For all of those people who fell in love with Eragon all those years ago (around 2003), this is what you all have been waiting for. Inheritance is the long-awaited final book in the worldwide best-selling series.
As Eragon prepares for battle with the evil and incredibly powerful Galbatorix, he is not the only one getting ready for war. With the help of the elves and the dwarves, the Varden begin infiltrating cities and recruiting soldiers to aid them in the impending war. But time is swiftly running out, and Eragon still has a lot to learn. If he is not even able to defeat his evil half-brother Murtagh, and his dragon Thorn, then how can he hope to overcome Galbatorix and save his home Alagaesia?
For many years, the Inheritance Cycle - Eragon, Eldest, Brisingr, and Inheritance - has been the topic of fierce debate between book nerds, with each side having valid points. Some claim that these books are great works of fiction, and admire Paolini for creating such a rich and fascinating world. Others claim that his plots are little more than poorly written re-hashes of Star Wars crossed with Lord Of The Rings; both sides are correct to some extent.
This book is definitely the best of the series. It contains a great deal more originality than the others, and it is also slightly better written. The quality of the writing is certainly not brilliant, as it rises to its best during exciting, action parts, and dwindles down to a crawl during the slow parts, such as the rather lengthy and boring chapters involved with Roran's (Eragon's brother) storming of the castle at Aroughs. At its best the writing is thrilling and some scenes are simply breath taking in their perfection and excitement, such as a particularly thrilling fight scene between Eragon's dragon Saphira, and Murtagh's dragon Thorn. But looking back at the series, one cannot help but notice the similarities between these books and Lord Of The Rings, and a great deal of the series seems like Star Wars set in Middle-Earth, with magic instead of the Force, and swords instead of light-sabres.
People will either love or hate this book, depending on their opinion of the rest of the series. Although at times it dwindles to a crawl and dwells on the unnecessary, it is still a fantastic end to a great fantasy saga, and will certainly satisfy all fans.
I highly recommend this book.
Rebecca Adams (Student)

Milo and the Restart Button by Alan Silverberg

cover image

Simon and Schuster, 2010. ISBN 9780857071903.
(Ages: 10+) Highly recommended. Milo has moved five times already in his life and so being in a new town and at a new school he calls hitting the restart button. Fitting in is not easy for Milo as he is a bit of a klutz and he finds it hard to read people and situations accurately. This leads to some very funny situations throughout the book that young readers will enjoy. Milo is also dealing with the loss of his mother from a brain tumour and Silberberg's writing about this is intensely sad but hopeful as Milo leads the whole family through their intense grief.
The comic style illustrations add to the appeal and I have already added it to my list of books to recommend when students have finished the Wimpy Kid series. This would be an excellent read aloud for Year 5-6 classes as well.
Chris Lloyd

Eight keys by Suzanne LaFleur

cover image

Puffin, 2011. ISBN 978-014-134203-0.
(Age 10+) Recommended. Realistic. Bildungsroman. I thoroughly enjoyed Lafleur's book, Love, Aubrey and consequently I was very happy to get the opportunity to read Eight keys. This is the story of Elise, almost 12 years old, and just entering middle school. She and Franklin have always been best friends, playing medieval Knights, roaming in the woods and using their imaginations. On her first day in the new school, an encounter with a popular girl, Amanda, who scoffs at the scabs she has on her arms from playing Knights, and calls her a baby, suddenly leaves Elise feeling an outsider, wondering if her friendship with Franklin is babyish. Her schoolwork suffers, and she becomes very unhappy. Although her parents are dead, she has a loving aunt and uncle and adult friends as a support system but she doesn't feel that she can tell them just how bad the bullying at school has become. The only thing that keeps her going is the discovery that the key she has spied in her uncle's barn, is labelled with her name and opens one of the eight mysterious locked rooms at the top of the building.
Lafleur's narrative flows gently and easily, pulling the reader in as she explores what it is like for Elise to move from a small school, where everyone knew her and where she felt safe, to a large school where the teachers didn't seem to care and where she becomes the victim of bullying.The bullying is both verbal and physical and Elise is unable to cope with it. She retreats from her best friend Franklin and doesn't stand up for him and tell the truth when it really counts. This exploration of bullying and the nature of friends will resonate with younger readers as will the exploration of peer pressure.
At home, Elise is jealous of the new people in her aunt and uncle's lives, especially the baby, and questions whether they really want her. It is not until she uncovers the secrets of the eight keys that open the mysterious rooms that she can come to terms with herself and begins to appreciate the love and friendship that surrounds her. A father going to the trouble of preparing rooms and keys to show a daughter how much she is loved and the type of girl she could grow up to be is a very beautiful and poignant idea. There are some heart wrenching moments that had me in tears and some funny moments as well.
I really loved this wonderful exploration of friendship, family and growing up. Combined with a touching look at the awful consequences of bullying, these relevant issues make this a very satisfying book for the younger reader.
Pat Pledger

The flying emu by Sally Morgan

cover image

Walker Books, 2011. ISBN 9781921720642
Sally Morgan explains that this collection of short stories which focus on animals or features from the physical world are not traditional tales but originate from her mother's imagination. These stories were created to entertain Sally's family and various members contributed to the progression and outcome of some as they were shared verbally.
The stories contain homely wisdom concerning aspects of life such as meaningful friendships, loyalty, gossip, bullying, trickery, deceit and greed. The animal characters in the stories assume human traits and roles as they perform the mini dramas which often have a twist, usually with humour. Cautionary tales appear frequently, yet they are benign and amusing. These stories will appeal to children because they are appropriately brief and not overly complex. Interestingly, the subject matter and the language structure is appropriate to a fairly broad age range. I can imagine that children from five to about twelve would enjoy the stories and could identify and discuss themes and symbols at various levels. Sally's illustrative artwork accompanies each story in colour.
Rob Welsh

No Ordinary Love Song by Alison Prince

cover image

Walker Books, 2011. ISBN: 9781406306637.
Cal is concerned about the state of the planet, unwilling to work terribly hard or communicate at school and is missing his sister, the only member of his family in whom he is willing to confide. When Kerry, the part aboriginal girl whom he has seen on the ferry, arrives at his school, his life begins to change. They fall in love and together they dream and talk about their future. Suddenly things change when Kerry announces that she is pregnant. Whilst Cal's life is in turmoil, amidst his dysfunctional family, the lives of his parents are also in flux with both of them going off to have affairs. Ultimately, the characters reveal sides to themselves which redeem them and bring about changes for the family.
Despite its heavy focus on teenage angst, this title differs from many other young adult fiction in that it is written from two different perspectives, those of both Callum and his mother. One could compare and contrast their experiences and emotions, as both are unhappy and lacking fulfillment, yet overcome some of their issues throughout the course of the novel. With themes such as the trials of teenage romance and relationships, music and the support of various adults, there is a certain amount of humour interspersed. Although an enjoyable read, this title still seemed to be somewhat lacking in depth.
Jo Schenkel

Monkey and Robot in the garden by Felix Hayes

cover image

Ill. by Hannah Broadway. Bloomsbury, 2011. ISBN 9781408806579.
When Monkey and Robot receive a mystery package of seeds in the post, Monkey plants the big, black stripey kind and Robot gets the little black dotty variety. Of course Monkey's plants grow the fastest and tallest, eventually producing the most impressive display of beautiful sunflowers. Robot's horticultural efforts are boring in comparison, with slow growing, unimpressive sprouts and no spectacular colours. This causes him to feel disappointed and less accomplished than his happy gardening partner.
In time, the pair discovers exactly what Robot's unknown plants are and they celebrate and enjoy them together. With assistance from the story teller, children will appreciate the lesson that we may often have to wait for rewards and indeed look below the surface to see some gifts. The notion that variety in life is important, that diverse achievements have independent value and promoting consumption of healthy food are also concepts which might be discussed.
The story does offer simplified gardening instructions for the readers to participate in similar activities to the characters. I know that seed planting definitely engages children who become very excited in the short term. The book also provides figurines and objects which can be pressed out to enable the readers to re-enact the story or create their own version. This was definitely a hit with a youngster I selected who was underwhelmed by the narrative but took great interest in the paper shapes.
Rob Welsh

Saving Private Sarbi by Sandra Lee

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2011. ISBN 9781 74237 557 1.
(Ages 11+) Recommended. Animals in war. When this story made headlines around the world, it drew attention to the animals that are deployed during war, adding another dimension of courage and loyalty to those fighting overseas. Sarbi, a Labrador/Newfoundland cross, was trained as a EDD (Explosive Detection Dog) and after a warm up stint at Melbourne's Commonwealth Games in 2006, was flown to Afghanistan with her handler, known as D. There she sniffed out IED's (Improvised Explosive Devices) saving the lives of many people in the booby trapped rods in the Uruzgan Province.
But it was after a battle with the Taliban that Sarbi went missing, presumed killed. September 2008 saw the convoy ambushed by the Taliban, and after many Australian soldiers were wounded, and equipment lost, they made it back to their base, not having the capability of staying to search for Sarbi. With D in hospital and then sent back in Australia, reports filtered through of a black dog being seen, but there were also rumours of the dog being killed, so no story was able to be verified. When at last someone came forward as a go between from a Taliban leader asking for money for the return of the dog, people were hopeful that this was Sarbi.
This is a fascinating account of the war in Afghanistan, seen through the eyes of the animals deployed to ensure the place is safer for all concerned. The author goes to great lengths at the start of the book to explain animal behaviour and the training of the animals in the army's care. For animal enthusiasts this will be an absorbing read, and for those interested in how the animals are trained, robustly enlightening.
Other stories are given augmenting the deeds of these animals, and we hear not only of the animal deaths but also of our soldiers. The book gives a sound background to the war in Afghanistan, and the presence of our troops and their work. For students and adults alike wanting to find out more about the war in Afghanistan, this is an easily read introduction to a complex issue, and also a heart warming story of one dog's life.
Fran Knight

Darkest Mercy by Melissa Marr

cover image

(Wicked Lovely Bk. 5). HarperCollins, 2011. ISBN 9780007346158.
(Age: 13+) Highly recommended. This is the final installment in the best-selling Wicked Lovely series. Within the faery courts, the evil fairy Bananach is thirsty for war, killing and provoking the other faery courts to start what she is hungry for: a colossal fight to the death. Within the Summer faery court, the queen Aislinn is preparing to fight, while worrying for her Summer king, Keenan, and her lover, Seth. Within the Winter faery court, the icy queen Donia is worried for her people, and also preparing to fight. But as Bananach grows ever more violent, will they ever survive this ordeal?
As this is the fifth book in a lengthy series (that I have not read), it was a little hard to understand at first. But this book does manage to stand on its own, and it does manage to be very good. The author has woven an intricate and fascinating world that is refreshingly original, and filled with intriguing characters. This book had several quite violent scenes, and the concept of the summer queen and court is that it is a place for passion and loving. These various scenes may not be suitable for younger readers.
This is book is easy to read, but not so easy that it becomes condescending. The best part of this book is easily the characters. Hardly is there such a wealth of differing personalities, actions and dialogue in a teenage fantasy novel.
What Melissa Marr has done for faeries is reinvent them into something new and exciting, much like Stephanie Meyer did for Twilight (although this book is much better in terms of plot, literature and characters).
I highly recommend this book/series.
Rebecca Adams (Student)