Reviews

The Pirate Prisoner by Terry Deary

cover image

A and C Black, 2011. ISBN 9781408128343.
This novel is one in a series of pirate adventures. Terry Deary has a reputation for capturing historical facts in episodes of fiction, bringing delight to young audiences worldwide. In this story Red Legs Greaves owns a sugar plantation on the island of Nevis. He used to be a pirate but his days of roaming the high seas have caught up with him. He faces the gallows for robbing a wealthy ship owner many years before. Only a miracle can save him.
This book is an exciting read that will intrigue most children. It is a short, fast paced adventure guaranteed to whet the appetite for the remainder of the series.
Tina Cain

Three summers by Judith Clarke

cover image

Allen and Unwin, ISBN 978 1 74237 827 5
(Ages: 12+) Highly recommended. The first summer sees best friends, Ruth and Fee waiting for their year eleven results. Fee already knows what she wants in life, marriage and children and has set herself upon that path. Ruth, encouraged all her life by her grandmother, Margaret May, the child of an orphanage and a sour marriage, aims for university, and is in two minds when she wins a scholarship and place at Sydney University. The local priest, a long time friend of Margaret May, who has watched over the motherless Ruth, rages against the decision to move to Sydney from the pulpit. After all men do not marry educated women and cities are places of sin and abomination.
The small country town, west of Dubbo breaths rumour and innuendo, gossip and half truths as the fabric of their living is revealed by Clarke in this story of the girls' lives. Ruth is attracted to Tam a young man from the big house outside town, and rumoured to have fathered several children to girls in Ruth's school. After an encounter with him, thoughts of what might have been shadow Ruth for the rest of her life.
Fee's letters later follow Ruth to London where she lectures and writes, letters full of her marriage and five sons, and a longing to know if Ruth is happy. The second summer sees Fee begin to question her life, and when her youngest son, Josh is accepted at university but also intends to marry, Fee is shocked into saying things she later regrets.
During the third summer, Ruth has returned to Sydney and living in the mountains, fosters a damaged girl, one she is warned, never shows affection. During one long day of extreme heat and with the promise of fire in the air, the two women, the retired lecturer and the young girl with Tam's grey eyes, find a path of connection.
This is a stunning novel. The two women, friends for life, are on opposing paths on life's journey, one staying home contentedly married and bringing up children, the other seeking worlds anew. Both question their decision, but each knows it is the right choice. The steadfast friendship remains a constant theme in their lives, and the one true thing each has aimed for is there for each of them.
Neither can imagine living the life of the other, but as the summers pass they both accept what each has chosen, just as each realise that their path is particular to themselves.
Again Clarke deposits us in the world she has created, we laugh and cry, recognise people and situations, and are dismayed all over again with the narrowness of some while congratulating those who have some recognition of what makes them human. This is a moving story, skillfully told, which will readily capture the imagination of its readers.
Fran Knight

Kick it to me by Neridah McMullin

cover image

Ill. by Peter Hudson. One Day Hill (distributed by Scholastic) 2012. ISBN 978 0 980794 6 1.
Warmly recommended. Picture book. Football. The story of the beginnings of Aussie Rules Football is not a story widely known, but it is brought to life in this engaging story by Neridah McMullin. Tom Wills, a young boy living on a Western Victoria pastoral station, was sad at the end of summer when cricket was finished for the year. His Aboriginal friends invited him to join them, and so he learnt the basics of Marn-grook. Years later, in a position where a new game was being touted to encourage fitness in Australia, rugby was suggested, but Tom Wills, famously said ; "we shall have a game of our own" and so Aussie Rules Football was born.
A two water bag introduction by Eddie McGuire gives the premise for the book, but readers will jump straight into the story and get what they can from it by themselves. They will engage with the story readily, it has all the ingredients necessary for a good tale, football, boys out by themselves trying new things and comradeship. That it is true, adds another dimension to the tale, and readers will look at the game and its Aboriginal footballers with renewed interest and respect.
The lively illustrations will engage and direct the reader to things mentioned in the text. I loved the close up pictures of the boys' faces staring straight out of the frame; they give a directness to the story and challenge the reader to think about what they are reading. The biographical information about Tom Wills rounds off a book which slots in well with our new curriculum.
Fran Knight

My green day by Melanie Walsh

cover image

Walker Books, 2012. ISBN 978 1 4063 3001 4.
Warmly recommended for younger readers. Picture book. Environment. With the subtitle, 10 things I can do today, the books has a smiling face peering out of the round hole in the cover inviting readers inside. When she wakes she tells us that she eats free range egg for breakfast, and this is shown in the illustrations, while in smaller print at the bottom of the page, the term, free range, is explained. One the next page we are told that she places the egg shell in the compost bin, and this is shown, again with an explanation of why this is done. Through ten double pages, many with an inset, we see the things the narrator can do at home to be green, thinking about her impact upon the environment. Each page is loaded with things children can talk about. Each page would act as a springboard for a class discussion or small group discussion.
I really like the way the publisher uses cut outs and part pages to create interest in turning each page, and the bold swathes of single colour too added to the interest for the reader. I can imagine this book being used in the classroom, with a teacher using it to introduce a topic about being green, or the environment, or what to do at home to help the planet, and about recycling. There are endless possibilities, but make sure you have a muffin recipe ready to use.
Fran Knight

Ten Scared Fish by Ros Moriarty

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2012. ISBN: 9781742379128.
(Age 2-5) With turtles by the waterhole, snakes in the river grass and fish in the saltwater, all seems to be well until the arrival of a shark changes the dynamics.
This simple counting book continues to add animals until the appearance of the wide open mouth of the threatening shark. Young children would enjoy counting along with the addition of each animal. Basic shapes used to create the illustrations could easily be copied by young children as the artwork holds much appeal.
Jo Schenkel

Night School by C. J. Daugherty

cover image

Atom Books, 2012.ISBN 9781907411212.
(Age: teens) Highly recommended. Something sinister appears to be happening at Cimmeria Academy, and secrets need to be uncovered before someone is hurt. In her novel Night School, C. J. Daugherty builds great tension into this wildly intriguing plot. The brooding graphic and blurb on the cover, together amplify the undercurrents lurking in this novel. By invoking elements of vandalism, young love, murder and fires, there is plenty of action going around.
Night School opens with sixteen-year-old Allie caught red-handed in a brazen act of vandalism, her artistic graffiti boldly adorning the school principal's office door. After a night in the lock-up and an unceremonious handover by the police, Allie discovers there will be no meter of leniency from her parents. All too soon she finds herself bundled away to boarding school.
Once installed in the vast three-story gothic mansion, Allie begins to ask herself whether it is a school, or a prison? Automatic locking gates, curfews and 'night school' all fill her with apprehension. In spite of her reservations however, Allie begins to make friends, and quickly discovers a connection with the quietly withdrawn Carter West, but also confusingly, handsome Sylvain's admiration is difficult to resist. Tres difficile. Life at the academy settles into an orbit of classes, secrets and explorations and then, disaster strikes. What happens on the night of the summer ball, and why has it not been reported? When everyone is lying, who do you trust? Allie isn't sure, but is determined to find out.
Writing in the third person, C. J. Daugherty quickly establishes believable characters. Some of her strengths lie in description and dialogue, and, she has manifested interaction well between the characters in her broad cast. Although some tensions are left unresolved in this novel, these mysteries will surely be revealed once the sequels hit the bookstores. Publication of the first sequel to Night School is anticipated in 2013. I look forward to it. Night School is highly recommended for secondary school libraries.
Colleen Tuovinen

Au revoir, crazy European chick by Joe Schreiber

cover image

Electric Monkey, 2011. ISBN 9781405259439.
(Age: 13+) ALA 2012 Quick Picks for Reluctant Young Readers. Perry Stormaire is persuaded by his parents to take the Lithuanian exchange student, Gobi Zaksauskas to the senior prom. The bribe of having his father's Jag to drive sweetens the ordeal for Perry, who really doesn't want to take the unattractive young girl out. Instead he wants to play in his band which has finally got a gig at a nightclub. It turns out that Gobi is a highly trained, attractive assassin who is out for revenge and Perry is in for the ride of his life.
Each short, snappy chapter starts with an essay topic from a leading university. This gives a fresh and funny approach to the writing, which is done in the first person by Perry.  Through his writing the reader finds out about his bossy lawyer Dad, his band, and his hopes for his future. Best of all, the reader is taken on a high octane ride through New York as the hapless Perry is forced to drive his father's Jag as a getaway car after Gobi carries out her assassinations.
The action is so fast and the suspense so thrilling, that I was compelled to suspend belief and read this in one sitting. Smart writing and funny asides from Perry added to the enjoyment. Schreiber gave enough information about his characters to make them believable, and the hint of romance was a nice touch.
It is sure to be a hit with both boys and girls and is certainly one to tempt reluctant readers.
Pat Pledger

The ghost of Ping-Ling by Peter Cooper

cover image

Omnibus, 2011. ISBN 978 1 86291 918 1.
(Age: 11-14) Dillen is an orphan looked after at the temple in Ping-Ling by the priest Kaji who despises him. His life is changed forever when he is visited by an Easterner in the service of the Empire who tells him to find the sorcerer Hallegat and serve him well.  After the temple burns down and Dillen is blamed for it by Kaji he has no real alternative but to flee.  He is soon captured by the Puk-do, a blend of pig and human, luckily he escapes and teams up with Tajni and later Koto, Tajni's friend. They then embark together on the quest to find Hallegat, along the way meeting many others both human and non-human. The Empire has some resemblances to Japan and the author has skillfully woven together many diverse elements to create an exciting story.  It is not clear whether Dillen is meant to succeed or merely provide a diversion. However by equal combinations of luck and skill, Dillen and his friends eventually succeed and he returns to Ping-Ling to expose Kaji for what he is. 
This fantasy should appeal to those who like an oriental flavor to their story, but also elements of magic and magical creatures.  The story moves along at a cracking pace and should appeal to both boys and girls in middle school. There are two other books in the series as Dillen and his friends continue the quest for the Blue Jade.
David Rayner

Chicken big by Keith Graves

cover image

Scholastic, 2012. ISBN 978 1 74169 977 7
(Ages: 5+ ) Picture book. On a very small farm a huge egg is laid by a very small hen, and out of the egg hatches a humungous chicken. He is so big that he does not fit into the chook house, so big that he that the other animals think he is all sorts of things. So begins a search for what this large yellow animal really is, as the chooks sift through a number of large things, to arrive at a name for him. Is he an elephant, or an umbrella, and so on, each time deciding why he is not what they think he might be. Classes and individual readers will have a great time trawling through the reasons why the animals think he is one thing, and be able to call out why he is not. A great deal of fun will be had. The illustrations too add another layer of mirth as roosters and hens walk in line scared of this large yellow animal. The expressions on their faces add another level of fun for the readers.
When the large chicken saves the day by scaring the fox away, all is resolved as the large chicken is accepted for what he is and invited to reside in the hen house with the rest of the chooks.
A wonderfully funny story of difference and acceptance.
Fran Knight

Crow Country by Kate Constable

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2011. ISBN: 978 1 74237 395 9
Highly recommended. When I began the novel Crow Country I had no idea what to expect. However I soon learned that Crow Country is one of those rare great Australian mythological novels tying in not only with the original land owners but with the war and the Australian football culture as well. This book is one I would highly recommend to young people with an appreciation for culture.
When Sadie Hazzard and Her mother move from their Melbourne home to the town of Boort in rural Victoria she didn't expect to like it. Boort was a strange place full of even stranger people who all seemed to know her mother. Feeling lonely one day Sadie decides to find the much-talked-about second lake of Boort. But what she finds there is enough to turn anyone's head.
The Mortlocks and the Hazzards have lived in Boort ever since anyone can remember. They grew up together, worked together and even went to war together. Clancy Hazzard knows this and he full appreciated the position Mr. Mortlock puts him in coming into his home with blood on his hands.
The story must be told, what was lost must be found and what is sacred must be protected by those who know. Sadie teams up with her friend Walter, an aboriginal boy, to try and solve this mysterious puzzle all the while being watched by one particularly auspicious crow.
Crow Country is a very engaging book made even more so with the links to aboriginal mythologies and WWII. Kate Constable has previously been labelled as 'the time-slip queen' and I can see how she earns her title. This compelling book recreates voices of the past in a superb manner and it seems a shame that the book had to reach an end. I am looking forward to reading more of Kate Constable's novels.
Kayla Gaskell (Student, 16)

Wisdom's Kiss by Catherine Gilbert Murdock

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2012. ISBN 9781742379265.
(Age: 10+) Recommended. This amusing story is told through a combination of narrative form, letters, diaries, and encyclopaedia entries, and even a play. The main characters here are Princess Wisdom, otherwise known as Dizzy. Then there's Tips, a soldier who's trying to keep his true identity a secret. And last, there's Fortitude, an orphaned maid who longs for Tips and has an unusual gift of sight. They must work together in order to preserve their empire from ruin, and they might even accomplish their dreams on the way.
Wisdom's Kiss is oddly satisfying; it has an excellent cast of characters, each with well-developed, interesting personalities. It has a fun, not too serious storyline and it is consistently amusing, with some truly hilarious moments. More than all that, it's smart. There's an underlying theme of dry, funny wit throughout, and it's very cleverly written.
If it were just written in an ordinary narrative style, it'd be good, but by combining the narrative with letters, diaries, encyclopaedia entries (some amusingly informative), and for some reason a play, this makes a good story great.
Wisdom's Kiss is a funny, sometimes hilarious story with memorable characters, perfect for a light read. It doesn't take itself too seriously, so neither should you. I recommend this book.
Rebecca Adams (Student, Year 10)

BZRK by Michael Grant

cover image

Egmont, 2012. ISBN 9781405259941.
Nano technology in the form of biological and robotic 'bugs' is applied for both therapeutic and sinister purposes in this long-science / future fiction story. Nano bots developed for medical use by the fabulously wealthy McLure Corporation have been hijacked by operatives employed by the conjoined Armstrong twins who have delusional plans for world domination. These individuals are so ruthless that they are prepared to commit mass murder to achieve their goals and one of the many creepy aspects of this story is that the logistical and practical application of their plans has the background and sense of being little more than electronic games.
Nano bots are controlled by Twitchers and the best of these, like the Bugman who works for the Armstrong twins, can manage multiple units simultaneously in a similar fashion to an individual playing several video games at once. Competitive spirit prompts the best twitchers on both sides of the Good versus Evil divide to yearn to defeat their opponents in battle. This sense of gamesmanship must be put into perspective in that the battles are waged within the bodies of unsuspecting human beings and the gladiators are microscopic robots whose primary tasks are cellular repair or alternatively internal sabotage, depending upon the cause of the Twitcher.
This runaway, suspense filled drama will interest middle teens for its action and predictable characters, yet it contained both unexpectedly thought provoking and gratuitously unpleasant elements.
The reader is made to feel decidedly uncomfortable by the fact that subjects and targets have no choice about whether they are penetrated by nanobots. Twitchers simply introduce the particles via innocuous touch, causing them to enter bodies through eyes, ears or noses via remote control. Disturbingly, the Twitchers have access to what the subject can see, hear and, to some degree, think, with the target being completely oblivious to their presence. One particularly repellant example is how the Bugman artificially conjures affection and devotion from his impossibly beautiful girlfriend by using nano technology to rewire certain brain receptors. The fact that this girl would otherwise have no interest in him and is prompted to be intimately accommodating to an underage teen makes this little more than technologically advanced sexual assault.
Battles waged on the micro level within humans are played out as a consequence on a monstrous scale in the real or macro world. The various characters are complex and cleverly presented with operatives having colossal controlling power over sublimely developed technology whilst possessing debilitating human flaws. A theme which readily prompts consideration is that the threatening twins have repellant intentions, yet they sincerely believe that they are doing good for mankind. Alternatively, the forces who oppose them don't hesitate to use criminal or immoral means in their crusade against evil. The result is a dizzying web of interaction between players and everyone, including the reader, has little confidence in who can be trusted.
Rob Welsh

Hallowed by Cynthia Hand

cover image

Harper Collins, 2012. ISBN 9780732292614
(Age: 13+) Hallowed is the second in a series, following on from Unearthly and with a third to follow, possibly. The main character, Clara is part-angel, part-human; she and her brother, Jeffery, are learning what this means while they living as 'normal' students and dealing with more mundane and expected teenage problems. They each have a purpose, and varying superpowers. They can both fly, a useful trait, and Clara is very empathetic and can read some minds. They are also recovering from the trauma of the forest fire that concludes Unearthly. Has Clara failed to fulfill her purpose? Is she still in love with Tucker? Can Clara learn to control her 'glory', an ability to glow with power? Can Tucker cope with her angel-related relatives? To their surprise, they meet others in their area who are part-angel, part-human and have similar abilities, but learn that some, the 'Black-wings', use their power negatively. Sameeza, a Blackwing, continues to haunt Clara's life. They learn also that part-angels part-humans have long but limited lives, and Clara realizes that her own mother will die soon. In her final year at high school Clara must plan for her future while dealing with the death of her much loved mother. The device of the angelblood involves the writer in some clunky plotting. Heaven and Hell must be assumed to exist, and parts of the Old Testament are interpreted quite literally. The degree of angelblood has some tricky genetic implications, as 'angelblood' should be maintained through marriage. However, the writing, in teenspeak, is lively and engaging, and the characters are generally believable, despite the young men being quite stereotypical. The novel is a mixture of fantasy, romance and teen issues, and will be enjoyed by girls aged 13+.
Jenny Hamilton

The Grimstones by Asphyxia

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2012.
Hatched ISBN 978-1-74237-688-2
Mortimer revealed ISBN 978-1-74237-689-9
Described as a gothic fairytale, the Grimstones a quirky, small novel, immediately made me curious. These small books are illustrated with both puppets and people and the author's name Asphyxia is certainly unique. It was only when I searched the internet that I discovered that The Grimstones is based on a puppet show with the author as one of the two puppeteers and an actor in the show.
Hatched, the first book, introduces us to the Grimstone family through Martha Grimstone, a young girl, lonely since the death of her father and the resulting incurable grieving of her mother, Velvetta. Martha would like to follow her grandfather's footsteps into the world of magic but even though she has been forbidden, she dabbles in a spell creating an egg which hatches into an unusual and remarkable brother.
Mortimer revealed continues Martha's quest to discover how her father died. No one in the family is willing to give an explanation, so she decides with the help of Crumpet, her 'hatched brother', to find her own answers.
These stories are unique and fascinating to read. The puppets are gothic yet appealing and the small sets used in the puppet play are cleverly constructed and a doll house lover's dream. There are some interesting oddities in the book such as the embalmed father Mortimer lying in his open coffin, visited by both Velvetta and Martha and Martha's creation of the three legged child, Crumpet.
I enjoyed reading both these original stories and I predict they will be popular with 8 to 12 year olds, in particular, girls. For some background information on the puppet show on which the books are based visit here.
Jane Moore

The Flappers: Vixen by Jillian Larkin

cover image

Inkhouse, 2011. ISBN 9780552565042.
Every girl wants the flapper lifestyle. Gloria has it all, and is living it up with her best friend, Lorraine. Gloria is engaged to Sebastian Grey. Gloria's cousin, Clare has arrived to make sure the high-society wedding goes to plan. Gloria loves to party, surely she still has enough time to party before she has to walk down the aisle. Lorraine is tired of living in Gloria's shadow and when her envy spills over, nobody is safe.
I love the early 1900's and the twenties were a crazy time. Vixen is intriguing and full of suspense. The minor characters all were of some importance and had a role to play, leaving you wanting for more after each page. The book is written from three points of perspective, which may cause a little confusion but is more interesting in the telling. The author uses the language of the 1920's, and it is captivating. It is different to not picture the teens with laptops and cell phones and was a great book to change that image. It's good read and those whom love the early 1900's will love this book.
Cecilia Richards.