Reviews

The lilac ladies by Jenny Hughes and Jonathan Bentley

cover image

Little Hare Books, 2013. ISBN 978 1 921894 23 7.
(Age: 4+) Warmly recommended. Picture book. Age. Death. Friendship. The routines of older people are beautifully illustrated in this wonderful reminder that people will not always be here. Four older women, Ida, Nelly, Maisie and Rose are the very best of friends and do the same things together each day of the week. Sometimes the women are not as capable as Nelly, but she is always there to help. Monday sees them bowling, Tuesday swimming, Wednesday at the coffee shop, Thursday they dance the tango and on Friday, the best day of the week, they have high tea with Nelly who makes the most superb cupcakes. But one week Nelly is not as active as usual, and the others are a little concerned. Going to her place they find Nelly in bed, and the four old friends talk of things they have done together in the past, until it is time for Nelly to go. The following week the friends no longer wish to do the things they did in the past when Nelly was around to give them a hand, but a week later they decide that they must continue. They might be a little different and they might not be as successful at the activities as when Nelly was there to help them, but they are achievable. Things are certainly different but they are still together and in many ways Nelly is there as well.
The lovely illustrations underline the points about friendship and change, about death and loss being made in the text. The four easily discernible women with their various hair styles, handbags, glasses and jewelry, peer out of the pages beckoning the readers in to look more closely. The readers happily become part of the routines, and share Nelly's expertise at helping her friends when help is needed. The readers will admire the women for being with Nelly as she dies, and congratulate the women continuing the daily activities, learning to adjust to Nelly's absence. The theme of loss and change is one to be lauded, as it is not often tackled in children's books. Here children will see that life does indeed go on after someones death and things may be different in some ways but change is inevitable.
Fran Knight

The Gorgle by Emma Fischel

cover image

A & C Black, 2012. ISBN 9781408174135/
Recommended for competent readers from 8-10 years of age. Themes: Family, mystery, overcoming fear and grief. Finn is a city kid transplanted to the country when his Mum wins Gulliver House, a dark creepy place with archways and turrets. His sisters and Mum run off to explore the many rooms filled with old furniture, draped with dust cloths and cobwebs hanging from the ceiling. The house has a dark persona that feeds Finn's anxieties and leads to the fear charged meeting with the giant moth-like creature as it hatches from a chrysalis. The tension is counter-balanced with Finn pulling pranks and teasing his sisters Lily and Mo who he calls The Piggy Princesses. They are enjoying exploring the many rooms of Gulliver House searching for the hidden room. Finn's ally and young next door neighbour Oliver the only one who has seen the moth monster helps Finn search the dark woods for him.
This is quite a scary read; the moth is a huge hissing shape that plagues Finn's life. It is an invasive shape shifter that is very frightening. Emma Fischel builds the drama through the use of short sharp descriptive sentences that are enhanced by Peter Cottrill's very dark cartoon style illustrations.
Rhyllis Bignell

The diggers are coming! by Susan Steggall

cover image

Ill. by Susan Steggall. Frances Lincoln Children's Books, 2013. Hardcover. ISBN 9781 84780 2880.
(Age: 2-5) Recommended. This is a glorious celebration of the roar of big construction machines and the work they do. There is much on every page to capture the attention of any young child, with colourful illustrations, captured in torn-paper collage. From the wreckers which whack, wallop and wham, to the people who come with boxes, bundles and bags, this truly is a 'ground up' story, capturing the process of turning old abandoned buildings into a thriving new community.
It's a story which is certain to appeal to any 'machine' fan, as well as being a source of explanation for a child who is watching the transformation of a space in their community, or a child moving to a newly constructed home. One of the aspects of the story which appeals is that the machines are in their 'natural' state - these are not amorphisised with eyes and smiling mouths on a nonsensical mission to deliver presents or be helpful - these are machines designed to smash things, flatten them and haul them away.
The author is a teacher, librarian and mother, and this shows in both big and small ways, with quality in both language and illustration. This would make a valuable addition to any school or home library.
Freya Lucas

Truly Tan by Jen Storer

cover image

ABC Books, 2012. ISBN: 9780733331213
Recommended for children ages 8 and up. Tan and the 'lollipops', her older sisters Emerald, Amber and Rose, are about to re-locate to the country with their parents. Following a rather eventful journey, involving an assortment of pets and dodgy removalists, the family finally spies the dead fox draped over the fence to mark their turn and arrives at their new home, only to find all of their possessions have been dumped on the front lawn. Thus begins life in the country, camping out on the verandah! Quickly the girls meet some children who live nearby and become involved in solving some mysteries, especially one pertaining to a 'ghost's' house. Fancying herself as something of a detective, Tan takes to solving the mystery, eager to follow up on any clues she is able to find.
This is an easy read for confident readers, filled with diary entries, a smattering of definitions which appear to have been taped onto the pages, Penny Pollard style, and appealing illustrations both in the form of photographs and line drawings. Tan is a likeable character, who provides some humorous observations and the family pets add to the laughs. A book about family, friendship, every-day fun and adventure, overcoming one's fears as well as providing a historic twist, this should be easily accessible to girls who enjoy a bit of mystery. Written by the author of Tensy Farlow, a title I had previously read and reviewed this book wasn't quite what I was expecting, yet I found it to be most enjoyable, nonetheless. It's far simpler, everyday story line is eminently suited to its younger audience.
Jo Schenkel

Princess and Fairy: Enchanting Carnival by Anna Pignataro

cover image

Scholastic, 2012, ISBN: 9781742833200.
With the Carnival on its way, Princess and Fairy need to find all of the things on their list. Heading off in a hot air balloon, they visit Curious Treat Street, Cragbottom Heath, Moss Water Merry and Wild Wooly Acres and begin to collect their treasures which they must then deliver to the Carnival King. After the goodies are distributed, Fairy and Princess become the carnival queens at the greatest show in all of Fairyland.
As with the other books in the Princess and Fairy Look and Find series by Anna Pignataro, the divine pastel shades used in these water colour illustrations and huge quantities of glitter are bound to hold much appeal to the young female readers. From the initial pages which contain much white space to those later in the book with beautiful borders and intricate details on every spare inch of the space, this will capture the attention of little girls who love fairies and magic. The message that one can find joy in helping others is also strong and positive throughout, making this a delightful tale.
Jo Schenkel

A Literature Companion for Teachers by Lorraine McDonald

cover image

A Literature Companion for Teachers by Lorraine McDonald
Primary English Teachers Association Australia, ISBN 9781875622863. 192pp., pbk RRP $A42.95 (non-members); $A32.70 (members)
In the foreword to this book, Associate Professor Alyson Simpson says, 'A companion is someone who travels with you; a guide who has gone before and therefore knows how to prepare you for the journey and what to highlight on the way. This companion text shows you the way to travel in the literary landscape, providing signposts for you to look around with increased awareness but also stepping back so you can make your own discoveries.' That statement perfectly sums up this professional text which explores the English strand of the Australian Curriculum, particularly the Literature substrand.
Starting with a section on the value of narrative for children and young adults and the types of literary texts that our students should encounter, the author (an academic at ACU, Sydney) shows us how to navigate the literature requirements of the Australian Curriculum through information, ideas, insight, examples, questions and tasks that provide a very sound map for the journey. 'It presents literary writing as both an 'art' and a 'craft' and explores aspects of the 'craft' of writers' 'artistry'.' (p6)
For example, it explores the importance of the context - historical, cultural and social - of a text so that as teachers we have that fundamental knowledge to share with students, and this is supported with examples of texts, suggested questions to interrogate it, including sample responses and evidence, as well as tasks that students could undertake to develop their own understandings. Subsequent chapters address responding to literature, examining literature, creating literary texts, figurative language, poetry, reading and viewing picture books, and literature in a digital age and each has the ACELT outcome and year level clearly referenced.
While its key focus is the literature strand, the language strand is interwoven to enable us how to show students how literary language constructs meaning and how literary texts provide models on which they can build. Similarly, the tasks which focus on critical analysis, structured conversations, close reading and guided writing mean that the literacy strand is also prominent.
This book is going to be the basis on which the leaders of The FIRST Book Club will base the tasks for students to complete, and while these will be based on the outcomes for Year 5/6, it would be an excellent platform for the program of any teacher librarian or classroom-based teacher from K-10. It is one of the few titles I've encountered where the contents live up to the blurb on the back, and which won't just sit on the bookshelf unopened. It is more than a companion - it is a valued and valuable friend, and my copy is well-thumbed already.
Barbara Braxton

The People Smuggler by Robin de Crespigny

cover image

Penguin, 2012. ISBN 9780670076550.
Recommended for senior readers. At the time of writing, Ali Al Jenabi is living in Sydney on a Removal Pending Bridging Visa, which allows him to live here until Iraq is deemed safe enough for his return. The People smuggler is the story of his life up to this point. He grew up in Iraq under Saddam Hussein; his father was arrested and tortured in front of him as an Islamist; he and three of his brothers were also tortured and spent years in gaol. In 2012 one brother was still imprisoned despite regime change in Iraq. Ali became responsible for his family and earned money in a variety of ways, including as a tailor. For a short time he was supported by a dissident group in the Kurdish area of Iraq. He eventually escaped into Iran and Turkey, and then Indonesia after hearing about asylum in Australia. He found the situation for refugees to be unorganised, and United Nations support to be non-existent. To earn money to help his family escape he organised boats to carry groups of people to Ashmore Reef. In return they paid him what they could and he used that money to buy boats, pay for accommodation and bribe swathes of officials, including immigration and police. He was a people smuggler. Betrayed many times he was eventually arrested and tried in Darwin. He served a gaol term and then was put in detention as an asylum seeker. In his sentencing comments the judge at his trial compared him with Oskar Schindler, the German manufacturer who saved some Jews from the Holocaust, in that he acted for his family and did not seek to make large sums of money. Some may disagree with this. However, this is a story of almost unbearable suffering, betrayal and determination. The use of the first person voice and the present tense can be annoying, but ultimately the reader is left feeling grateful that we live here but baffled and angry about our attitudes to asylum seekers.
Jenny Hamilton

Daisy and the puppy by Lisa Shanahan and Sara Acton

cover image

Scholastic, 2013. ISBN 9781742830513.
(Age: 5+) Recommended. Picture book. Pets. Who hasn't had the idea of getting a pup brewing within the family? That need is behind this lovely picture book, beautifully told by Shanahan with matching illustrations by Acton, which will readily tug at the heart strings.
Daisy and her family go to the pet shop every Saturday and look at the pets. A whole range is offered, but Daisy wants a pup. So decided is she that she begins to act like a dog, she sleeps in a wicker basket, adds a tail to her backside, howls at passing ambulances and fire engines, and washes all the dogs in the neighbourhood.
Eventually she wins and the family brings home a pup from the pet shop. But the youngest sibling is not so sure about the puppy in the household, and several scenes are played out where the addition of the puppy may be reversed. A funny and neat resolution to the problem occurs which will brings smiles to all faces.
The charming illustrations, in gouache and watercolour, sweep easily across the pages, flowing with the movement of a young family, adding a substantial background to the already endearing story. A few seemingly simple lines create the faces of the family, and the pup's movements are beautifully captured with blobs of grey watercolour, corralled by line drawings. The small things of a family's life are scattered across each page and the intimacy of sleeping, bathing, shopping together, all given an outing that children will love to see.
Fran Knight

Arkie Sparkle series by Petra James

cover image

Pan Macmillan Australia, 2012.
Arkie Sparkle 3 White Fright. ISBN 9781742611259.
Arkie Sparkle 4 Treasure Hunter. ISBN 9781742611266.
A recommended series for primary school. Arkie Sparkle continues her search to find another treasure in a different continent. She has to succeed in her task in order to save her parents who have mysteriously disappeared. Yet Arkie Sparkle is not alone in her quest for she has the help of her brilliant cousin TJ and Cleo a basset hound.
In White Fright Arkie must travel into the Arctic Circle to visit the Doomsday Vault, a real life storage facility for seeds from around the world. It is during her near miss capture inside the vault that she meets a surprise character and ends up too close to a very hungry polar bear.
In Ruby Red, Arkie and TJ had to gate crash a party for the notorious pirate, Blackbeard in order to steal 'The Black Prince's Ruby'. Things do not go as planned as pirates don't take too kindly to discovering spies in their midst.
Each book continues the excitement with Arkie and TJ tracking down the latest treasure and getting out of tight scrapes. The covers and format are all similar and easy to recognise. At the end of each novel, relevant true facts are listed as well as a teaser to keep the suspense going for the next book. With about 100 pages, these are an easy read for 8 to 11 year olds. A recommended series for primary school.
Jane Moore

Nora's chicks by Patricia MacLachlan

cover image

Ill. by Kathryn Brown. Candlewick Press, 2013. ISBN 978 0 7636 4753 7
(Age: 5+) Highly recommended. Picture book. Friendship. Belonging. Migration. When Nora and her family move from Russia to take up farming in the American prairies, life is very different from the life they left behind. Father has his work, mother has her colourful house, even her baby brother Milo finds a stray dog to adopt, but Nora is alone. She misses the hills and trees of Russia, her family and her friends, until one day father brings home a dozen chicks and 2 geese. Nora adopts them immediately, disallowing her father's idea that they be raised to eat. The birds follow her everywhere, even to church, and it is after church one day that she finds one chick is missing.
A neat resolution saves the day and Nora finds a friend in the girl on the next farm through her chicks.
The sweeping prairies are beautifully drawn by the illustrator, and bring the vastness of the new land home to the reader. Small things dot each page reminding us of the isolation of these people, and of the new life they have chosen to live. That the new arrivals have come from a vastly different setting is made clear through mum's pictures on the wall, and the few treasures they were able to bring with them. Their clothes show them to be different as do their head scarves and even the way they tie their hair. Details such as these cry out to be noted and discussed.
This is the story of all who set out to make a fresh start, a new beginning, finding comfort in the new, making friends and overcoming loneliness. It is the story of so many of us, and all readers will find something in the story to identify with and feel part of.
Patrician MacLachlan is the author of the beautiful, Sarah plain and tall, a Newbery Medal Winner in 1986, which was made into a film.
Fran Knight

The Mountain by Drusilla Modjeska

cover image

Vintage Books, 2012. ISBN 9781741666502.
(Age: Senior secondary - adult) Highly recommended. Papua New Guinea is often overlooked by Australians in spite of its geographical proximity and close historical and political ties. Australia was the colonial administrator whose influence the inhabitants tried to throw off at Independence. However, the links between the mountain men and Australian soldiers in WW2 have become further immortalised by the increasing tourism to the Kokoda Track.
The (fictitious - but representative) mountain of Drusilla Modjesta's title is set not far from Kokoda on the largest island of New Guinea. Europeans Rika and Leonard lived in Port Moresby during the late sixties and early seventies. As an anthropologist, Leonard spent time on the mountain and his film became a seminal account of traditional life and its change caused by newcomers. Rika falls in love with indigenous Aaron, an upcoming leader who is the hope of Independence. There is foreboding about the length of his life. Jericho, the child of Leonard and a mountain woman, is given as a 'gift child' to Rika and Aaron, who can't have children. The second part of the narrative focuses on Jericho, who is the product of a life brought up in London and the art world but who is searching for his whole identity. He recognises the quality of the bark-cloth of the high mountain villages.
The descriptions of art and place are linked with the surrealists. Walking into one scene is described as being inside a Max Ernst painting. Modjeska knows her art - she wrote the acclaimed Stravinsky's Lunch about two Australian artists living at opposite ends of the world.
The Mountain is a rich, sensory epic. It will enlighten those who know little about Papua New Guinea - a place of contrasts, 'the treachery of paradise'. The English curriculum encourages the use of texts which engage with Asia. While definition of the countries of Asia is contested, the Pacific Islands/Oceania is included by ACARA and so parts of The Mountain would be useful in schools, although it is ideally aimed at adults or mature secondary students.
Joy Lawn

Marcy Series #2 by Susan Halliday

cover image

Quiz Champs: ISBN: 9781921665721 (pbk.)
Thirteen Dolphins: ISBN: 9781921665738 (pbk.)
Lost Dogs: ISBN: 9781921665745 (pbk.)
Award Winners: ISBN: 9781921665752 (pbk.)
Netball Challenge: ISBN: 9781921665714
Box Set: ISBN: 9781921665882
Ford Street, 2013. 55 pages, paperback  AUD $9.95 each . Boxed set with Toocool: $89.95.
(Age: Beginning readers) Adventure. Just watch the smaller humans scramble for the shelves when they see these arrive! All those eager little readers who are beginning their 'chapter' book journeys just eat up these fun and exciting stories and bask in their success in doing so. A perfect addition to any school or home library, and available singly or as a boxed set (both series). As the characters in both series, Too Cool and Marcy, are the same, both boys and girls can relate to them and share the laughter which inevitably results from following their exploits.
After the success of the first series of the Marcy books, Susan Halliday has provided us with a whole new set of Marcy stories to entertain and delight young readers, particularly girls. While Marcy has her fair share of foibles, she is a girl who is ready to have a go at anything, invariably with great gusto.  Marcy's positive attitude and her self confidence (sometimes a tad TOO much confidence!) make her an endearing character and the reader is immensely pleased to read about the success and unexpected rewards of her ventures.  This series has a commendable thread of responsibility and citizenship running through, which would lend itself well to a class discussion on these values. I can also well imagine some enthusiastic girls initiating a staff/student netball challenge at their own schools! As with Toocool, the books follow the useful format of glossary and information and similarly these are handled in a way which is entertaining and engaging.
Ford St has provided a wonderful set of teaching notes (linked to the Australian curriculum) on its website.
These series would also make an extremely useful addition to any 'home reading' program with far more engagement and potential 'follow on' than the ubiquitous basal reader. Enthusiastically recommended for readers 7 years and on, for library, classroom or home.
Sue Warren

Feed by M.T. Anderson

cover image

Candlewick Press, 2012. First published 2002. ISBN: 9780763662622.
(Ages: 14+) Highly recommended. A good dystopian novel is frightening because it feels like a plausible extrapolation of a real-world situation. Feed goes one step further. Its social commentary is so incisive that it often seems to show us ourselves not as we could be, but as we already are. At times, its dire predictions seem not only plausible, but inevitable, and it is difficult to escape from the feeling that many of them are already coming true.
Set in a future where the internet is delivered directly to people's brains via microchip, Feed follows Titus, a teenager who is partying on the moon when his 'feed' is unexpectedly shut down by an activist. Normality for Titus and his friends is a constant stream of chat messages, videos, games and advertisements that merge seamlessly with their thoughts. The feed has eliminated the need for written communication. Thirty pages in, you can feel the narrative voice fighting against the decay of language itself, as Titus struggles to find words to express what he is experiencing.
This dystopian scenario is so skillfully explored and so thoroughly realised that it seems as bottomless as reality itself. There are upcars, air factories, disposable tables, stacking suburbs, lo-grav bars and meat tissue plantations, to say nothing of the invented popular culture and the impressive vocabulary of slang. When kids go to parties, dance music plays in their heads instead of out loud, and illegal 'malfunction' websites do the work of party drugs. The premise never stagnates - new facets are constantly being introduced - and in the final fifty pages, the dystopia escalates towards a spectacular conclusion.
The cover calls it satire rather than science fiction, which makes a lot of sense - as well as being immoderately funny, Feed is a compelling condemnation of the ways in which consumer culture and the internet are rewiring our brains, right now. This, perhaps, is the novel's most terrifying implication: that we might wake up one day to find that the world has ended without our noticing, because we had become experts at ignoring anything that our shortened attention spans were not equipped to handle. And it all becomes twice as frightening when you realise that this book was first published in 2002, before the creation of Facebook (2004), YouTube (2005) and Twitter (2006), whose feed-based models Anderson skewers with visionary precision. If this one doesn't give teenage readers something to think about, nothing will.
Samuel Williams

Life in Outer Space by Melissa Keil

cover image

Hardie Grant Egmont, 2013. ISBN: 9781742973951.
(Age: 14+) Highly recommended. Hardie Grant Egmont seems passionate about publishing debut novels, and the first book developed for what's being called The Ampersand Project  is Melissa Keil's novel, Life in Outer Space.
I had heard nothing about it, no build up or word-of-mouth. I found it in Big W of all places (although it has since turned up in my ASO pack), and I just loved it. I think my preferred YA contemporary novels are those with male protagonists, and Sam is the perfect example of such a narrator. He is a clever nerd, with only four friends and a routine life exactly as he wants. It's safe. As long as the arrogant Justin Zigoni and his group (who Sam refers to as 'the Vessels of Wank') leave him alone.
When bold and unique Camilla arrives at school, his organised world is turned on its head. Camilla refuses to fit into any group, any stereotype, any clique, and - horror of horrors! - she invades his familiar spaces and talks to him, without irony, and without embarrassment. Admittedly, the friendship begins online behind World of Warcraft avatars, but eventually their IRL ('in real life') encounters occur almost daily, and Sam's confusion and cluelessness is adorable and funny.
Sam only talks to Camilla because he believes there is no way she could possibly be interested in a romantic relationship. His self worth, governed by the moronic high school hierarchy, gives Sam the opportunity to befriend Camilla, although she isn't one to be refused. She is determined to be part of their group, and her matter-of-fact way of joining conversations, and ignoring the possibility of becoming socially outcast, is pure sass and blustery confidence. I have rarely seen such a genuine character in YA. She's pretty awesome really. Sam's friends are not shoved to the side. We see that Mike is struggling with issues, although it takes till the end of the novel before Sam is able to figure out how to make him talk. His gayness is dealt with honestly and affectionately. Allison seems to be smitten with Sam, yet her storyline is resolved positively, and Adrian, well, he stayed Adrian. Sam is loyal and cares for his friends, another of his great traits. Hmm, I might be gushing, a bit.
Keil uses film, specifically the Horror genre, to highlight her main concerns, to pull the male readers in, and to weave a consistent theme through her narrative, which is all about self perception and figuring out who you are. Great to see a positive and fun Australian YA contemporary. In the vein of Gabrielle Williams and Fiona Wood.
Trisha Buckley

Game over by S. Carey

cover image

Eerie Series. Penguin, 2013. ISBN 9780143306689. Paperback, 72 pages. RRP:$9.99.
(Age: 8+) Highly recommended for readers with a taste for the macabre. Cast your mind back to some of those great series like Deadly and Wicked (Jennings/Gleitzman) and After Dark (Gary Crew et al) and think about how popular they were with readers, particularly boys, of about Year 4/5 level. Quick to read, ghoulish enough to be creepy but not graphic and written in a quality style - interesting vocabulary that just stretches the newly independent reader.
The Eeries series promises to deliver just such a successful formula. Game Over takes the reader on quite a retro trip back to the 80s and readers may be slightly baffled at first by the described desirables - an Atari 2600 for example. However, they will be familiar (or dare I say, should be!) with others like MAD magazine, Doritos, Oreos and other American delights which were just beginning to creep into our collective consciousness back in the decade of big hair and bigger shoulder pads.
John's new classmate, Samuel, is an unappealing American kid with a very appealing mother and houseful of goodies - all too tempting for an average suburban 80s Aussie kid. Lurking beneath this seeming haven of tempting treats is a sinister fate for those who succumb (think Lotus Eaters and you're on the right track). Is Samuel really as indolent and unemotional as he seems? Is his rather glamorous mother as kind and beautiful as she appears? Hang around, eat enough goodies and play enough arcade games and you will find out. In fact, you may find yourself in a very unpleasant situation!
Sue Warren