Reviews

The Storm Makers by Jennifer E Smith

cover image

Headline, 2013. ISBN 978-1-4722-0144-7.
Recommended for 10 to 13 year olds. Ruby is the first of the twins to see the mysterious stranger at their farm. His secret arrival heralds the beginning of an amazing adventure for both her and twin brother Simon.
Their life on a farm, far away from their city past heralds a new beginning for their family. Dad wants to invent and Mum paint but the farm is struggling because of the persistent drought. This whole book is centered on weather and as the title suggests, with humans who have a special gift that can control it.
Simon discovers he is one the youngest Storm Makers but there are others who can help and guide him. He must decide who he can trust as his special powers could be deadly.
Ruby tries to guide Simon to make the right choices and together they embark on an unbelievable journey into an unknown world where people have both extraordinary powers as well as human frailties.
This story, set in Wisconsin, takes some time to develop but is well worth the investment. I feel independent, motivated readers will enjoy this novel. Recommended for 10 to 13 year olds.
Jane Moore

Best books for primary compiled and edited by Pat Pledger

cover image

Pledger Consulting, 2013. ISBN 9781876678371.
If you have ever thought to yourself I wonder what new quality books I'm missing or I wonder what's available that I can use with my class, then this may be the book for you. From the stable of Pledger Consulting comes another useful bibliography; Best books for Primary contains a list of books reviewed and recommended by Australian teachers and teacher librarians on Pledger's Readplus site. Award winning titles are included from the Children's Book Council, Guardian Children's Book Prize, Newbery Awards and the Roald Dahl Funny Prize. Titles comprise four categories- Picture books; Middle Primary; Older Primary and Non Fiction.
Best books for Primary is not a complete set of reviews, but an annotated alphabetical list, with a sentence or two giving a very brief overview of the story. By choosing an age level readers can check interesting titles. The brief annotation gives enough of an idea to encourage you to look into the title further. In some cases these reviews on the website are complete with lesson notes. The list of non-fiction titles is particularly useful. An index adds to the usefulness of this aid to busy teachers and teacher-librarians.
Diana Warwick

Mysterious traveller by Mal Peet and Elspeth Graham

cover image

Ill. by P J Lynch. Walker Books, 2013. ISBN 9781 4063 3707 5.
(Age: 8+) Highly recommended. African story. Responsibility. When an old desert guide, Issa, finds a baby protected from the sand storm by a camel, he takes her home, raising her as a gift from the desert, and later when he becomes blind, she repays him by being the guide for him, describing for him where they are, enabling him to continue guiding people across the vastness ahead.
But one day a stranger with two servants asks him to guide them across the Bitter Mountains. This is not the usual route, and one that is dangerous, but they need to go quickly. On realising he is blind, they disparage him and storm off, deciding to find their own way. But Issa knows they will get into trouble so he and the girl set off to find them. saving them from the fierce sandstorm. This sees the young man return to Issa's house alone, to apologise and offer money for being saved. But seeing the girl's pendant, pieces fall into place about Mariama's background.
This beautiful story, wonderfully illustrated by Lynch, will encourage readers to read it over again, as they ponder just how the girl got to be in the desert and why the camel was so brave. The acceptance by Issa of the baby he finds in the desert, his responsibility in caring for her and then her being able to repay his kindness is a theme that carries the story along and remains with the reader.
The background to this small family, of Issa saying his prayers, of their kindness to strangers, of not wanting payment for saving the lives of the three, all point to a strong value system, and underpins their basic humanity, regardless of which religion they belong to. This is a wonderful tale, one that could be read and retold for its own sake, one that could be the springboard for discussions about responsibility, or about Africa where the story is set, the descriptions and illustrations giving an unforgettable background to the events as they unfold.
Fran Knight

Guinea pig town by Lorraine Marwood

cover image

Walker Books, 2013. ISBN 9781 922077 42 4
(Age: 7+) Warmly recommended. Poetry. Animal. Poet Lorraine Marwood has had several books of poems published, including the Star jumps, A note on the door, A ute picnic and Ratwhiskers and me, the latter being a verse novel set in the Gold Rush. Each of her books consists of short poems which are most accessible to middle primary students, eager to read and absorb a usually funny poem with a comment about society. In this selection, subtitled, 'and other animal poems', an array (50 plus) of funny, clever and sometimes poignant snapshots of animals in our homes, in our gardens, in the street is arranged in various groups which hint at the poems following. Marwood writes about poetry, for The Literature Base, a teacher's magazine which presents articles about literature to use in the classroom. She shows teachers a wide variety of poetic styles, and gives hints to teachers about teaching their students these poetic styles, often using some of her poems as examples.
In this book, as with her others, a wide variety of styles is used; haiku, rhyming verse, blank verse, prose poetry, lists, genre poems ect, encouraging the teacher and students to try for themselves. None is complicated or out of reach, but simply told with an eye for detail, using word images to create the idea behind the poem.
Watch out for A Woman, about a piglet being treated almost like a baby, or Ordinary magic, giving a small image of a dog at the sheep yards, or Sale Yard Time, which has every line starting with the same words, or the haiku, Billabong about frogs. Each poem is distinctly different and evocative of an image we see every day, but put into words which sing and beg to be read aloud.
Fran Knight

Harmless by Julienne Van Loon

cover image

Fremantle Press, 2013. ISBN 978 1922089045.
(Age: 14+) Slavery. Prison system. Western Australia. Dave is in prison waiting for visitors: his daughter, Amanda is being brought by his dead partner's father, Rattuwat, a Thai man lately coming to Australia for his daughter's funeral. He and his wife have received letters from Sua since she left their home, talking of her Australian husband and her children, but speaking little English, he has no idea of what has really happened. On their way to the prison, the car breaks down and the two, the old man and the child, abandon their car to walk the rest of the way. The child doesn't understand who this old man is, and impatient, leaves him behind. During the long hot day, we are taken into their worlds, understanding more of their backgrounds and what has happened to those who care for them.
It is a desperate story, one of an abused young girl in Thailand, repaying a family debt by working in a brothel, and a controlling Australian man who takes the girl back to his home, keeping her imprisoned. Her eventual escape and run to Dave with his daughter and much older son, brings some happiness for them both, a more settled life, until Dave is imprisoned, and he finds out how Sua rid herself of her tormenter.
The long day draws in other characters and their stories, filling in the background to Dave's incarceration and Sua's abuse, giving details of Dave's life with Amanda's mother, and allowing us to see the uncertainty with which all their lives are constrained. This is a compelling story, dragging the readers along with the smallness of these people's lives, and their inability to break away from the path before them. Each draws our tears, their lives buffetted by corruption and evil and we know that most will not rest easily.
Deemed a novella by the publishers, this could have some place in senior reading, where a story of modern Australia's life beneath the surface is exposed.
Fran Knight

Lost tooth rescue by Kate Ledger

cover image

Ill. by Kyla May. Twin Magic Series. Scholastic Level 2 Reader
(RA 5-6 years) Themes: School Life, Friendship, Teeth, Magic. Lottie and Mia are twins who have special powers; they can use their minds to move items. The twins have moved into a new house and are off to a new school. Luckily they can rely on each other. They share a bedroom with each side decorated with different design styles and colours. Lottie's side is pink and messy; Mia's is green and tidy. At school they meet Anna with a wobbly tooth. She wobbles it all morning, even during art class. Of course at recess the tooth is gone and the twins need to trace Anna's steps. They follow the glitter trail made by the Tooth Fairy back to the art room. With a little magic they save the day!
Kyla May's cartoon illustrations are bold, graphic and layered. These add the sparkle to the twin's story.  
This is a Scholastic Level 2 Reader. It specifically targets the audience of young girls who are becoming independent readers. This is the first book in a series suitable for girls aged 5-6 years.
Rhyllis Bignell

The Childhood of Jesus by J.M. Coetzee

cover image

Text, 2013. ISBN 9781922079701.
(Age: Senior secondary - adult) Highly recommended. Unlike anything I have ever read, The Childhood of Jesus by J.M. Coetzee is a surreal alternate-world refugee fable. Simon arrives in a new country from the camp, Belstar (could this name be an amalgam of the notorious concentration camp Belsen and the Star of David?). He has taken responsibility for a young boy who has been re-named David and who has been separated from his mother. People assume that Simon is his grandfather or father and he does take on this role whilst trying to reunite David with his mother. He inexplicably believes that he will know her when he sees her.
In the interim they find modest accommodation and Simon takes on the heavy manual work of a stevedore. His companions are reasonably helpful but not intimate. This is a bland, bloodless country, lacking in irony, news and substance. Coetzee's genius is the construction of a monochromatic, monotonous place which is also interesting and intriguing.
His characters are also astonishing. Simon sees a woman playing tennis in a closed residencia and makes the extraordinary assumption that she is David's mother. He gives the boy to her and builds some foreboding about her treatment of him.
David is a gifted child, winning at chess after only a few games, but he becomes precocious and can't be educated formally. Simon desires that David 'follow in the ways of goodness' but other parallels with Jesus are tenuous, such as mention of being 'the truth', reference to a carpenter and his arrival as a child in an alien place.
Perhaps Coetzee has re-imagined some tangents of a possible life of Jesus as a refugee to offer a vignette or profile of refugees today, who are allowed to enter a new place but welcomed only coolly with mediocre jobs and a hollow benevolence.
The Childhood of Jesus is a provocative, although possibly polarising, study for high level English students or those with an interest in refugees or religion.
Joy Lawn

Bureau of Mysteries and the Mechanomancers by H.J. Harper

cover image

Random House, 2013. ISBN 9781742756486.
(Ages: 10+) Highly recommended. Futuristic fantasy. Imp Spector and George Feather are on holiday after saving Obscuria City when a new batch of villains turn up - the Mechanomancers, ancient evil beings that combine science and magic. Joining forces with hero and novelist Lord Periwinkle Tinkerton and his mysterious secretary Lexica Quill, they strive to find and defeat the Mechanomancers.
Harper's fantasy demonstrates a large amount of humor and word play and has a lot of cryptic codes and puzzles to occupy your mind. A thrilling read, this book had me laughing at every page. I think this book can be read at any time - when you're sad, happy, struggling, hanging upside down! It doesn't matter if you are 10 or 70 - it is a book you will like.
Jos Alcorn (student)

Homecoming by Michael Morpurgo

cover image

Ill. by Peter Bailey. Walker Books, 2013. ISBN 978 1 4063 4107 2.
(Age: 6+) Warmly recommended. Short story, Historical, Childhood.Through deft prose, Michael tells the story of Mrs Pettigrew, a woman who lived at the edge of the marshland near their home at the village where he lived as a child.  Coming back after an absence of fifty years brings back the memories of this little woman from Thailand, living in a railway carriage with her donkey and dogs. Michael became her friend when he fell from his bike, bullied by a group of other children, and she patched him up, resulting in a strong friendship developing between Michael's mother and the woman. This friendship became much stronger when the village heard of a power station to be built on the marshes, necessitating the compulsory acquisition of the carriage. Michael's mother and Mrs Pettigrew did all they could to stop the development but to no avail.
Now returning, the man sees the derelict power station, long past its usefulness, a blot on the landscape where a dear friend lived. With spare, telling prose Morpurgo tells us of the rise and fall of machines and buildings which are built for short term purposes, left to lie derelict once their purpose has been expended. It is the tale often heard of the little people trying to protect their environment against the powerful machinery of corporations and government bodies, only to have their idyllic existences ruined for little gain. A tale heard the world over, but reduced in this instant to a woman in a small village on the edge of the marches and the young boy she befriended.
Morpurgo recreates the village of all our childhoods, people knowing each other, the closeness and warmth, destroyed by progress.  And all of this is beautifully captured by the soft ink and water colour illustrations by Bailey, recreating the atmosphere of village life.
Fran Knight

Love is in the air by Harry Vanda and George Young

cover image

Ill. by Shaun deVries. Scholastic, 2013. ISBN 978
(Age: 5+) Warmly recommended. Picture book. Animals. With John Paul Young's singing of Love is in the air (using the CD included with the book) who could not resist getting up and moving around, singing along with this song, which first appeared in the 1970's then was made an even more surprising hit with Baz Luhrman's film of 1992, Strictly ballroom. In this picture book, illustrated by deVries, who also did Phil Cumming's book about the two South Australian pandas, Wang Wang and Funi, as well as other books for Scholastic, the animals range from those living in the deep dark forests to those of the North Pole, where all animals have a huge loving smile on their faces.
Readers will love recognising the animals and their habitats as they read the book, listening to the CD as they do so. The bright colours, movement of the animals and information it incidentally gives will intrigue and keep them turning the pages. Readers will follow the antics of the little polar bear in his balloon with glee, spotting him on each page as he talks to many animals on his way back home, ensuring that love will be with them. The glow of the pages when talking of the rising of the sun and then at the time of the end of the day are wonderful, and lingered with me long after I closed the book. For junior primary classes just wanting some fun with John Paul Young's song, or using the book as a leap into work on animals or travelling around the world, or rhyming songs or ballads, then this is most useful.
Fran Knight

This place is cold by Vicki Cobb

cover image

Ill. by Barbara Lavallee. Bloomsbury, 2013. ISBN 9780 8027 3401 3.
(Age: 5-8) Warmly recommended. Picture book. Alaska. Non fiction. This fascinating little book, full of interesting and informative stories about aspects of life in Alaska for plants, animals and humans, piqued my interest from start to finish. Certainly that interest was held by the range of facts given, the scope of the text and the beautiful illustrations. Double page spreads in the first seven pages explain why the place in the Arctic Circle is so cold, and detail the severity of the cold for readers to better understand the temperatures of the place. There follows eight pages outlining how plants and animals survive in these harsh conditions, and then what people live there and how they too survive.
But I longed for a map, contents page, glossary and an index! With a non fiction text, these are essential tools for research, so I was surprised to read that this is a republishing of a 'ground breaking geography series' which first appeared in 1969. Despite these shortcomings, the text is fabulous, full of interest and detail, with illustrations that are full of life and colour, and I would probably see this as a non fiction text in a reader box, although it could be an information book within a group about the Arctic Circle, about which little is written.
The last few pages are most interesting, detailing the effects of humans on this environment. With the arrival of North American Indians, then Eskimos, followed by sealers, trappers, and then gold seekers, the place was opened up to outsiders, and has changed considerably as a result. Another in the series, called This place is wet, will follow.
Fran Knight

Verity Sparks Lost and found by Susan Green

cover image

Walker Books Australia, 2013. ISBN: 9781921977886.
(RA: 10-14 years) Highly recommended. Themes: Psychic Ability, Girl Detectives, Melbourne - 1870's, Boarding Schools, Mysteries. Susan Green has certainly 'gingered up the action' in her second Verity Sparks novel. Verity's psychic gift of teleagtivism, finding lost things has gone; instead she is troubled by shadowy dreams, portents of dangerous events.
Papa Savinov feels that Verity needs to develop into a proper lady and enrols her at an exclusive boarding school Hilltop House. Verity is a reluctant boarder, making both friends and enemies. She uses her detecting skills to solve mysterious thefts at school and investigates the dishonesty of college proprietors the Colonel and Mrs. Enderby-Smarke. Verity uses her journal to record her observations about school life, the dramas, bullying and home situations of the boarders. Even Lucifer Miss Deane's fifty year old cockatoo adds spice to the story.
There are a rich array of characters who both help and hinder Verity's quest to find missing heiress Lavinia Ecclethorpe. The settings of 1870's Melbourne and Mt. Macedon are realistically brought to life.
Verity and her governess Miss Deane move to Mount Macedon to investigate the murder of Lavinia's fiance Alan Ross. There are even more twists and turns as Verity's dreams start to come true.
This is another exciting novel by Susan Green; Verity Sparks is a dynamic character with a real sense of adventure. I would highly recommend this book for upper primary and lower secondary students.
The accurate historical portrayal of Melbourne, Bourke Street, the Yarra River and Mount Macedon and the modes of transport used in the 1870's, support the Australian History Curriculum.
Susan Green's blog- provides further insight into her creation of the novels. -
Rhyllis Bignell

The Night Circus by Erin Morgenstern

cover image

Vintage, 2012. ISBN 9780099554790.
(Age: 14+) Highly recommended. The circus arrives without warning. No announcements precede it. It is simply there, when yesterday it was not. Within the black-and-white striped canvas tents is an utterly unique experience full of breathtaking amazements. It is called Le Cirque des Reves, and it is only open at night. But behind the scenes, a fierce competition is underway - a duel between two young magicians, Celia and Marco, who have been trained since childhood expressly for this purpose by their mercurial instructors. Despite themselves, however, Celia and Marco tumble headfirst into love - a deep, magical love that makes the lights flicker and the room grow warm. True love or not, the game must play out . . .
The Night Circus is one of those rare books that manages to be unique, original, charming and fascinating all at the same time. It's written in beautiful, lyrical language that describes the circus with a kind of awestruck wonder, that perfectly suits a book like this. The characters are interesting and varied, from the cruel Prospero the Enchanter, to the kind and studious Marco. All of these characters, even minor ones, are developed well throughout the novel, each with their own little stories and nuances.
The circus itself is incredible, mysterious and enchanting, a circus one wishes was in reality, rather than embedded in pages of fiction. The author describes the circus in such a way that it almost seems to come alive, along with all the intricately detailed characters. This makes the book very memorable.
The Night Circus is unique, memorable, enchanting and incredible all at once, with an exciting plot and an endless stream of intriguing characters.
I highly recommend this book.
Rebecca Adams

Funny bums by Dr Mark Norman

cover image

Black Dog Books, 2013. ISBN 978
(Age: 6+) Recommended. Picture book. Animals. Humour.
From the wonderful elephant on the front cover, back to the audience, to the fabulous ducks on the back cover, emulating the old poem,
All along the back water,
Through the rushes tall,
Ducks are a-dabbling,
Up tails all!
(Wind in the willows, Kenneth Grahame)
the photos and words in this book will keep children amused and involved as they see the bums of many animals portrayed and discussed. Dr Mark Norman has written several wonderful books for black dog, including three books in the Wild Planet series (Antarctica, Great Barrier Reef, and The shark book), and Into the deep, Rare Earth: Saving Tasmanian Tigers.
In this one, he uses his prodigious scientific background to tell the reader neatly and efficiently, about the nether regions of a range of animals which includes the lemur, seahorse, several spiders and creeping insects, skunks, porcupines and lizards. Some have spines, some use smell emanating from their behinds, some have sticky substances, while some have exploding behinds (kids will love that one) Each group of animals has a few succinct words given and a number of wonderful photographs to illustrate the text.
There is, as always with black dog books, a useful index, an informative glossary and two pages with a fact file about the animals mentioned. All in all a most useful and fascinating book. But watch out for the African Bombardier Beetle.
Fran Knight

Have you seen my egg? by Penny Olsen

cover image

Ill. by Rhonda N. Garwar, National Library of Australia, 2013.
(Ages: 5+) Picture book. Australian animals. A non fiction book presented as a story of an emu looking for his missing egg, this book will interest and inform younger readers about the Australian environment and the sorts of eggs which exist. The emu begins with the magpies, describing his missing egg as large, green and hard shelled, but the magpies tell him that their eggs are small and spotty, and a life the flap in the corner shows one of the eggs hatching. On he goes to the echidna, the lizard, a frog, snail, shark and crocodile with a few others between, all the time describing his egg in the same way and having the other respond with a description of their eggs.
Readers will enjoy spotting the eggs and the hatching animals, recognising the animals as they appear on the pages, lifting the flap to see what is underneath and counting the number of eggs produced by each animal.
The environment as well as the animals are presented in a bold mix of colours, each page giving a strong sense of where that animal lives. At the end of the book are four pages with photos and information which add to the overall interest for the reader and educator.
Fran Knight