Reviews

Ice, wind, rock: Douglas Mawson in the Antarctic by Peter Gouldthorpe

cover image

Lothian, 2013. ISBN 978 0 7344 1155 6
(Age: 8+) Warmly recommended. Picture book. Non fiction. Antarctic. Heroism. Subtitled, Douglas Mawson in the Antarctic, and with an illustration of the man looking out from the front cover, readers picking up this book will immediately recognise that this is the tale of one of Australia's foremost scientists, explorers and heroes. A brief few words at the start of the book place him at the University of Adelaide where he is the lecturer of Geology and his interest in rocks lures him to a place where glacial activity is obvious. So begins his wonder at the Antarctic wildness, and the first expedition to the Antarctic in 1908 as a member of Shackleton's expedition.
This is a fascinating account of a man who is seen on the $100 note, but for many is simply a name they know. The book gives a brief outline of his interest in and expeditions to the Antarctic, and whets the appetite to find out more.
An insert in the book giving publication details, curiously gives a fascinating and informative time-line, so for those people purchasing this book, do not throw away this seemingly unimportant piece of paper, as the book itself contains no time-line and few dates are given to fix the details in a timeframe.
The illustrations certainly bring the icey world of the southern continent to life, ensuring any reader will be in no doubt about its inhospitable nature, the courage and strength of those who venture there, and the dangers which befell them. For someone new to the story, for introducing young readers to the heroism displayed by this man, this book is a wonderfully lively introduction, and I'm sure would be a stepping stone to find out more.
Fran Knight

The Probability of Miracles by Wendy Wunder

cover image

Penguin Books 2012. ISBN: 9780141340722. Paperback, 368pgs.
(Age 14+) Recommended. Campbell (Cam) has terminal cancer and has just been told by her doctor that after five years of chemo, there is nothing more they can do. Cam is ready to give up, to accept that she is dying but Cam's stubborn mum; Alicia and younger sister Perry are not ready to hear there is nothing left for them to try. They've heard of a town called Promise in Maine, a place where amazing, unexplained events are supposed to happen. If you can find the town - and most people can't - miracles can happen. What Cam needs is a miracle, but seventeen-year-old Cam doesn't believe in miracles. However, she embarks on this road trip and pursues her 'flamingo list'; a list of things to accomplish before she dies which was made with best friend and fellow cancer sufferer Lily. Cam is such a likeable character, that you really hope there is a miracle. This easy to read debut novel is a real page turner as you race towards the end in the hope of a real miracle. It is a beautiful story told through Cam's point of view, which is hilarious in places, especially Cam's Nana. I would recommend it to 14+ and fans of Jenny Downham's Before I die.
Michelle Thomson

Nanny Piggins: The Race to Power by R.A. Spratt

cover image

Random House, 2013, ISBN 978 1 74275 499 4.
(Age 11+) Highly recommended. A pig for a nanny? How can that be? The Race to Power is book 8 in the Nanny Piggins series. The opening page explains it is a standalone story and you don't need to have read any other stories to enjoy it. True.
Nanny Piggins is an outspoken, cake loving pig who cares for three amazing children. Mr. Green, their father, is horrible and Nanny Piggins makes no secret of the fact. If he isn't lying in his job as a tax lawyer, he is trying to ship his children off to work in hard labour jobs, practically trying to sell them off.
In this instalment of the series, Nanny Piggins discovers Mr. Green is running for mayor. Nanny Piggins is up in arms! What is Mr. Green's real reason? How will Nanny stop him? Highly recommended for independent readers aged 11+, it is a funny story from the opening pages where Nanny encourages cake for breakfast to the closing pages when they all realise just who has become mayor.
Kylie Kempster

Mortified: Lost in the Sands of Time by Martin Chatterton

cover image

Mort series bk 3, Random House Australia Children's, 2013. ISBN: 9781742758886. RRP $14.95 288 pages. Paperback
Recommended Reading Age: 9-11. Themes: Time Travel, Historical Fiction, Historical periods, Humour. Martin Chatterton's Mortified: Lost in the Sands of Time takes Mortimer Montmorency DeVere and his sister Agnetha on another exciting time travel adventure. Their family are 'frevers', for every year that a human ages, they take a thousand years. Mort and his sister are being hounded by the Unk Shire Assistant Chief Education Inspector Trish Molyneux and her assistant Nigel. Mort has spent hundreds of years at schools across the centuries, he can't face anymore time in school so he plans his break out from Festering Hall.
With his sister Agnetha, Genghis Kahn and H. G. Wells the English author, they escape aboard their Retro 2.0 time machine. The machine has accidentally had the Wikipedia page for world disasters programmed into the machine. They travel back in time and land in 1889 country England, where Arthur Conan Doyle (Sherlock Holmes author) and a young Howard Carter (discover of King Tut's tomb) join the action. The adventure is a fast-pace one, Mort and Agnetha are caught in a multitude of situations. Queen Victoria and her corgis are added to the time travel team along with Doyle and Carter as they tumble back through history in the damaged machine.
After touch downs on the Titanic, in London when the Great Fire is blazing, they finally land in Ancient Egypt, where King Tut rules, more dramas, problems zombie mummies, twists and turns unfold.
An engaging, humorous, fast-paced, time travel novel. As a class read aloud, students could research the historical figures and develop a timeline of events.
Rhyllis Bignell

Son of Slappy by R. L. Stine

cover image

Goosebumps Most Wanted series, bk 2, Scholastic, 2013.ISBN: 9780545417990. 134 p. Paperback.
(Age: 8-11) Subjects: Ventriloquism, Puppets and puppets shows, Horror stories. Written from twelve year old Jackson Stander's point of view, the reader soon develops an understanding of how perfect he is, he always does his homework, never gets into any trouble and doesn't lie. Rachel his sister, sarcastically calls him Robot, he's such a goodie-goodie. Life changes dramatically when the children are sent to Grandpa Whitman's for spring break. Grandpa is a collector of scary items, including a room of ventriloquist dummies, Edgar the frightening butler warns them to stay away from one named Slappy. Of course this Goosebumps book follows Stine's usual horror formula, the wicked doll Slappy is slipped in Jason's suitcase by the evil Edgar. On returning home things rapidly fall apart when Rachel invokes an evil charm and Jason turns into the Son of Slappy, creating havoc at home, school and the Youth Center.
R. L. Stine's Goosebumps series have been favourites since the first book was published in 1992. Slappy the Dummy is one of the series' most popular villains. This book is suitable for fans from 8-11 years of age.
Rhyllis Bignell

The river charm by Belinda Murrell

cover image

Random House Australia Children's, 2013. ISBN: 9781742757124. RRP $15.95. 320p
Highly recommended for readers 10-15 years particularly. Earlier books from Belinda Murrell, such as The locket of dreams and The ruby talisman, were hugely popular with the 10-13 year old girls in my school libraries. So popular in fact that I never seemed to get to read any of them. Her new novel, The river charm, is well titled as this reader found it indeed charming and engaging. As a lover of historical fiction and particularly Australian colonial history, this novel ticked all the right boxes.
Based on the family story of the author, who clearly demonstrates the inheritance of skilful writing and creativity, The river charm relates the story of the Atkinson family and their home Oldbury near Berrima, New South Wales. Charlotte Barton (Charlotte Waring Atkinson), the great-great-great-great grandmother of Belinda Murrell, was the celebrated writer of the first book for children published in Australia A mother's offering to her children: By a lady, long resident in New South Wales.
Through the fictionalised story of modern day Millie Mitchell, a descendant of the Atkinson family, the Atkinson family history is recounted by Aunt Jessamine, on a visit to the old home, Oldbury. Weaving fact with fiction, Murrell recreates the colonial atmosphere, attitudes and setting beautifully, not shying away from unpleasant aspects such as the lack of rights for women and Aboriginal people. The remarkable events which combined to best engender the triumph of Mrs Barton and her children against all odds have been painstakingly pieced together by a number of researchers and brought together by Murrell to provide the reader with a beautifully described story of courage and personal strength. The focus on strong female protagonists make this a natural choice to offer to young girls looking for inspirational characters.
Aside from the very clear appeal to readers of historical fiction, this is a novel which has much to offer as a support for Australian History curriculum topics as there is an abundance of accurate factual material contained in the story. This reader suggests this is a 'must have' title for any primary or lower secondary school library.
Sue Warren

Lulu Bell and the Birthday Unicorn by Belinda Murrell

cover image

Ill. by Serena Geddes. Random House Australia, 2013. ISBN: 9781742758756.
(Ages: 6-9) Recommended. Lulu Bell is another series of stories designed to appeal to the 6-9 year old reader, this time with a veterinary theme drawn from the author's own childhood and a strong focus on family life.
Lulu Bell and her friend Molly are busy helping the family prepare for Rosie's underwater themed birthday party when the call comes for the vet, Lulu Belle's dad, to rescue a runaway pony seen running loose on a busy road. Once the pony is safely recovered the only place to keep him is in the backyard whilst the police find the owners.
How Lulu Bell and Molly solve the problem of a horse in the back yard with a taste for cake, and make Rosie's birthday party with a crowd of junior mermaids a success is all part of the fun.
Belinda Murrell is better known for her novels Ivory Rose, Ruby Talisman and most recently Forgotten Pearl but her foray into the junior market with such a positive family based storyline will be welcomed by parents and readers alike. The black and white illustrations enhance the story and add a whimsical look at family life as the story unfolds.
Sue Keane

Bernard's plane trip by Adele Jaunn

cover image

Working Title Press, 2013. ISBN 9781921504563
(Age: 3+) Recommended. Picture book. Air travel. An endearing and informative look at a trip in an plane, this book is ideal for young would-be passengers and classrooms alike. The bear, Bernard, invites the reader to enjoy the trip with him and from the start introduces the readers to the details of going on a flight. From packing the bag to the security at the airport, all is included, giving the younger reader a clear idea of the protocol involved.
All the routines are mentioned, a boarding pass, the talk by the flight attendants, having a meal, sleeping, having things to do and then finally the welcome at the other end by friends and family.
Each is given a warm soft picture, in which Bernard is a prominent figure. Even more sensitive things are shown - going to the toilet, and sleeping on the long flight.
For children about to go on their first light, for classes looking at transport and for anyone with a sense of fun, following not only Bernard but also the little bee which can be found on most pages, this book is a delightful introduction to the joys of travel by plane.
Fran Knight

Hills End by Ivan Southall

cover image

Text Publishing, 2013. First published in 1962. ISBN 9781922147004
Written in the perspective of alternating characters this tale begins on the morning of the annual Stanley picnic, the air is thick with excitement in an isolated mill village in Northern Australia. While preparing to leave, seven children opt to stay behind and lead their solitary teacher up to the bluff where Adrian, the mayor's son, claims to have seen some Aboriginal cave drawings. However when the children and their teacher Miss Godwin are exploring the cave they are caught in a fierce storm which lay havoc to their village and kills the only other adult left behind. The storm destroys all of the bridges which were the only access points to the town. Having become separated from their teacher the children wallow in their fears until they collectively decide to return to the village. Timber and corrugated iron roofing litter the streets and the frightened children must learn to adapt in order to survive. Sharing what little knowledge they have between them they work together to battle their fear and their pride until the adults can return.
Ivan Southall's classic novel Hills End is one novel which I, previously, had not had the pleasure to be acquainted with. After reading the novel I understood that this novel set the groundwork for John Marsden's later novel Tomorrow when the war began.
The novel introduced the characters of the children and Miss Goodwin in an unobtrusive manner and continued to craft them throughout; this makes the characters seem more realistic and much more engaging for the audience. I would highly recommend this novel for both children and adults as the vivid imagery which Southall creates is something which is not as prominent in today's literature. I believe that it is important for young people to read books like this as they encourage a love for the written word, something which is often neglected these days.
Kayla Gaskell (Aged seventeen)

The view from the 32nd floor by Emma Cameron

cover image

Walker Books Australia, 2013. ISBN 9781922077295.
(Ages 8-12) Recommended. The View from the 32nd floor is an uplifting and gentle story where care and concern for others and themes of loneliness and friendship in an inner city setting and across the generational gap abound.
William lives on the 32nd floor of his apartment block with his musician parents and enjoys watching the residents of the apartments directly across the street with his plastic binoculars as he sits on his balcony. When Rebecca and her mother take up residence in the apartment directly opposite, William is quick to befriend her and together they begin a campaign to change the lives of the residents William sees from his balcony.
There is old Mr Crispin who worries William as he seems to have lost interest in life and is definitely not eating properly, and Fabian the palm grower who now lives alone and irons his holey jeans and who lives behind the sheer grey curtains which never open.
With the help of cake, visits by the children and some banana-shaped Post-it notes to remind him to put in his hearing aids, Mr Crispin begins to reconnect with the world but it is when the children are forced to enlist Fabian's help to break into his apartment to save his life that the real connections begin.
Tai chi in the park, lots of delicious food and a party to celebrate the unveiling of a mysterious statue on the roof encourage all the residents, even the reluctant Mrs Stavros who comes out from behind the curtains to meet and talk to their neighbours.
I enjoyed William's penchant for changing his name daily and that the meaning of the name reflected his actions and behaviour. The lyrics of the song selected each day by his father became the theme for the day as well, though I would think most of the references would not be in the target audience's playlist.
If one young person is inspired to interact with an elderly neighbour as result of reading this book the world can only be a better place.
Sue Keane

The universe versus Alex Woods by Gavin Extence

cover image

Hodder & Stoughton, 2013. ISBN 9781444764611.
(Ages: 15+) Highly recommended. This book tells the story of Alex Woods from the time he is ten until he is nearly eighteen and it is a truly extraordinary story.
At age ten Alex is hit by a meteorite and seriously injured. After spending a considerable time in hospital and therapy he is able to resume a somewhat normal life, hampered by the fact that he has epilepsy, a quite noticeable scar and a mother who is a clairvoyant. Being different, he is bullied at school and this leads to his meeting and subsequent friendship with the reclusive Mr Peterson, a widowed American Vietnam veteran. This proves to be a mutually rewarding friendship that evolves into Alex virtually becoming his carer as Mr Peterson's health deteriorates.
This is a wonderful story, Alex is very intelligent and pedantic but an exceptionally interesting character, as is Mr Peterson. The writing is assured and carries the story along to its satisfying conclusion. To reveal the ending would be doing a disservice.
I would highly recommend this book to upper secondary students as it deals with confronting issues sensitively but with humour and above all humanity.
David Rayner

Vanishing acts: A Maggie Brooklyn mystery by Leslie Margolis

cover image

Vanishing acts: A Maggie Brooklyn mystery by Leslie Margolis
Bloomsbury, 2013. ISBN 9781599909813.
(Ages: 8-12) Recommended. This mystery story has no superspies or gadgets, just ordinary kids in a familiar setting doing what we want kids to do, observing, thinking, investigating, questioning and researching, whilst attending school and battling parents about after school commitments and homework.
Maggie Brooklyn is a 12 year-old who has a twin brother Finn and walks dogs after school for busy neighbours. She successfully solved a dognapping case (the first Maggie Brooklyn mystery, Girl's best friend) so when dogs are being egged at the local park Maggie is enlisted by a fellow school student to investigate. At the same time teenage heartthrob Seth Ryan (think Justin Bieber lookalike) is filming his latest movie in town. Maggie's friends convince her and Finn to join them as extras on set. Maggie's career as an extra is short lived, however she does meet the star Seth Ryan.
When Seth disappears, Maggie is determined to find him especially as she learns more about him.
In the meantime there are personal issues to resolve like why is her best friend Lucy acting so strangely; what is Finn, her twin brother, not telling her; and why is Milo, who she thought might be boyfriend material, ignoring her?
The author has developed a witty and independent character in Maggie who narrates the story. The interactions with other characters are believable, especially the devotion of the Seth Ryan fans and the developing friendships between Milo and Maggie and Finn and Lucy.
As a fan of the detective story genre it is pleasing to see that younger readers will have the opportunity to develop a taste for the genre with intelligent and witty investigators long before they are old enough to appreciate the likes of Stephanie Plum, Janet Evanovich's feisty female lead character.
Sue Keane

Australian flags and emblems by Karen Tayleur

cover image

Black Dog Books, 2013. ISBN 9781742031095. Pbk RRP $17.95
(Age: Primary school) Highly recommended. It seems quite a while since there has been a new book on this topic and Karen Tayleur has done a fine job of producing both a very useful and attractive resource. With some introductory information on the background of emblems, including traditional heraldic definitions and examples, Tayleur leads the reader to a well presented explanation of the flags associated with our country. Several pages are devoted to official national flags - Australian national flag, Aboriginal flag and Torres Strait Islander, with a history of each along with some history regarding the Union Jack.
There is a pleasing uniformity to the format with a double spread devoted to each state flag - the description and history faced with a picture of flag, coat of arms (annotated) and fact box with other state emblems. Each page is thoughtfully presented with white space breaking up sections of text and illustrations.
Tayleur concludes the book with a double page spread of other Australian flags such as the Eureka flag and Australian Territory flags e.g. Norfolk Island, some flag protocol information as well as a glossary and index.
All in all, a highly recommended book for primary school library collections - superbly suited to Australian Curriculum (e.g. History/Year 3/Historical Knowledge and Understanding/Community Remembrance). This book could be used across year levels with ease.
Sue Warren

Red Samurai by Tiffiny Hall

cover image

Roxy Ran series. Harper Collins, 2013. ISBN 9780732294540.
(Ages: 8-12) Recommended. Action. Adventure. In the Red Samurai, Roxy Ran is the protagonist and narrator. She is a thirteen year old ninja who stands up to the school bully while crushing on her sister's ex-boyfriend. Her life mainly revolves around a ninja fighting the samurai. When Roxy becomes the White Warrior she's excited, nervous and scared. This isn't helped when her older sister Elecktra starts acting strange and using unnatural powers in public. Suddenly Elecktra is whisked off to the Cemetery of Warriors - another world - without any warning or training. Things just get harder and harder for Roxy as the days go on. The big showdown that was expected comes along, ending the book with an enthralling fight. All in all, the Red Samurai was an interesting book that I thought was perhaps aimed at 8-12 year olds. This book really forced my imagination to work as the sequence of events opened out in front of me. It was really action-packed with almost every chapter including a riveting fight scene. It was unusual in that it included battle and combat, but also included a romantic and feminine feel to the story. This is the second book in the trilogy by Tiffiny Hall which meant that some things mentioned confused me, so I would recommend reading the trilogy in order.
The Red Samurai was a thought-provoking book about teen problems such as bullies and secret crushes. This book conveys them in a way that's fun and suspenseful for pre-teens.
Jude Mills (student)

Kitty's war by Janet Butler

cover image

Queensland University Press, 2013. ISBN: 9780702249679.
Recommended. Biography. Memoirs. This book tells the story of Kit McNaughton, a nurse in World War I. It describes the conditions that nurses lived under in the pre-war years, the restrictions that female nurses endured and their position in society. Kit was a 'country girl' and the freedom and excitement of being on a troop ship, dining with the officers and enjoying the privilege that only rich people could usually afford, was heady indeed. Then came the arrival in Egypt, the experience of a change in culture and the life of the Egyptian people. Nurses were volunteers and didn't accept the British discipline very well. At this stage of the story there is more mention of visiting the Pyramids and Sphinx than the care and nursing of the wounded. Perhaps she didn't want to dwell on this as she was still in a state of excitement of being overseas.
Later she does describe the poor facilities, the hardships the wounded endured and the delay in getting them medical attention as they arrived in huge numbers.
On Lemnos Island, the hospital consisted of tents. The weather was freezing and the island was wind swept, causing the tents to collapse. This was bad for the nurses, but much worse for the wounded. The nurses didn't complain about the bad conditions - limited food, clothes and accommodation - as they believed they had to handle them, as did the troops. In addition to the abysmal conditions, the men were also wounded. This side of the war was not mentioned in the diaries of the nurses. As the nurses did not hold the rank of an officer, a difficult situation emerged where the nurses were unable to give instructions to male orderlies working with them - despite the fact they had three years nursing experience and the orderlies had only three months.
I have read much about the action on the front lines and the trenches but this story has been a real eye-opener.
Kit goes by troop ship to Marseilles and on shore there was little to do until the nurses went to a hospital to look after wounded German prisoners. She is eventually sent north to an English hospital where things were difficult - as the British nurses were attached to the Military - unlike our Australian volunteers. She is later stationed at an Australian Casualty clearing station, where the conditions are appalling. At this point, she is writing less of what she is doing in her diary. A lot of friends she has made along the way are being wounded or killed. The war is taking its toll on her health and the diary rarely mentions her nursing duties.
We eventually read of her trip back to Australia, her arrival in Melbourne and the subsequent parade. Her health is failing and she is on leave until she recovers. She then works in the Caulfield Military Hospital for a time, before going home to Werribee and marrying a farmer.
I was especially interested at this point, as my maternal Grandmother nursed the soldiers at this same hospital after the war.
I highly recommend this book to students of Australian war history, of the history of Nursing, and to anyone who is interested in Australians at war.
Bob Quinton