Reviews

Athlete vs mathlete by W.C. Mack

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2013. ISBN 978 1 599 908 58 8.
Owen and Russell are fraternal twins who have very different interests.  Owen loves basketball and Russell loves maths and Master of the Minds.  They are each happy with their role until the new basketball coach gets Russell to try out for basketball because of his height.  After reluctantly going along with it against his better judgment, to his own and everyone else's surprise he gets on the team.  This leads to trouble with Owen and Russell's non basketballing friends who think he is letting them down in their efforts to win Master of the Minds.  What follows is an exploration of the relationship between brothers as Owen resorts to dirty tactics to retain his position.
The story also explores how we each have our own concept of our value and self-worth.  This is done subtly and is resolved in a way that restores the relationship between the brothers as they each appreciate their strengths and realize that together they are stronger.
There is enough about basketball to keep the sporting reader happy whilst the other areas add some depth to the story.  I think that primary/middle school readers would find it an enjoyable read.
David Rayner

A cyclone is coming by Darlene Oxenham

cover image

Waarda series. Fremantle Press, 2013. ISBN 9781922089342.
Recommended for Year 3. This book tells of Annie, who lives with her parents in a caravan in the north of Western Australia. Other members of their extended Aboriginal family also live in the caravan park, and a number of other children do as well. All the children are great friends who do everything together in the holidays. They swim, fish and collect shells amongst other things. One day when they were considering going to the beach, Annie's Grandfather looked at the sky and said it was not a good idea because a cyclone was coming.  Annie helps prepare for the cyclone including tying the caravan to a large scraper that her father has placed next to their van. The rest of the story covers the waiting, and then the arrival of Cyclone Tessie, and gives an excellent picture of just what happens in the event of a cyclone. When Annie goes back to school, she is able to tell her class all about her adventure and the bottle with a message which she and her friends found. When the class asked what the message said they were told it was a story for another time.
Rhoda Jenkin

Meet Mary MacKillop by Sally Murphy and Sonia Martinez

cover image

Random House, 2013. ISBN 9781742757216.Ebook ISBN 9781742757230 hbk., col. ill., RRP $A19.95.
(Age: 6+) Mary MacKillop believed deeply in educating children, particularly those in remote areas of Australia, and in 1866, full of excitement and enthusiasm she left her home and all that she knew to set up her first school in Penola, South Australia. This is the story of the establishment of that school and Mary's insistence that it would be for every child regardless of their parent's status or ability to pay. With a deep belief in God, she and her sisters put their trust in His ability to provide and enable them to survive and flourish. During the first year Mary decided to become a nun, Sister Mary of the Cross, and founded the order of the Sisters of St Joseph, 'doing God's work and helping the poor wherever we can.'
Since her beatification in 1995 and subsequent canonisation in 2010, the life and work of Mary MacKillop has become much more widely known, and, as Australia's first saint, the interest spreads beyond the Catholic Church. In this beautifully illustrated picture book, we learn how and where it all began.
This is the second in the Meet . . . series, a collection of picture books that tell the stories of some of Australia's most significant people. Ned Kelly was the focus of the first, Captain James Cook the next one. Designed to complement the outcomes of the History strand of the Australian National Curriculum, it's a great way to get the youngest readers interested in who has shaped this country.
Barbara Braxton

Nell's festival of crisp winter glories by Glenda Millard

cover image

Ill. by Stephen Michael King. ABC Books, 2013. ISBN 9780733329845.
(Age: 8+) Highly recommended. Family. Age. Festivals. The family Silk, in the small community of Cameron's Creek, is again presented in all of its warmth. The wonderful Nell, grandmother to all, Ben her adopted son and wife Annie with their children, including Perry Angel, their tales told in previous award winning books, come together for one last episode.
Perry has noticed that Nell is sometimes lonely, and he has also been aware that his personal assistant at school is in the same boat. He plots to bring them together, knowing they both used to like dancing, and gathers some of the other family members together to achieve this. In Mr Kauri's shop they plan their dance, but when Nell falls and breaks her hip, plans must be altered to suit the situation.
This is a wonderful book, full of the love and happiness that a strong family brings to its members, Millard recreating a warm centered rural life with its animals, jams, sharing of food when the need arises, knitting, and simply watching out for each other. In her beautiful prose, full of the richness of the lives she describes, their characters come easily through, wrapping themselves around the reader, drawing them into the circle Millard creates.
I have only read two of the Silk family stories and will search out the others, saddened that this is the last as I am sure the many fans will be as well.
Fran Knight

The bookman's tale by Charlie Lovett

cover image

Text, 2013. ISBN 9781922079336.
(Senior secondary readers) The bookman's tale by Charlie Lovett is a thriller about bibliophiles, bibliopegy and greed. Books are bound, hidden and discovered, along with the occasional body, in this story that ranges from Shakespearean England to the 1990's. While Shakespeare's canon is hallowed ground, the recognition of Shakespeare as author is under threat from the anti-Stratfordians, those who believe that Shakespeare could not have written the works attributed to him. The main character, Peter Byerley, is an antiquarian bookseller and book binder. He has the good fortune to meet the beautiful Amanda, who not only falls in love with Peter but is also very wealthy, thus allowing him to pursue his chosen occupation. After the death of Amanda, Peter moves to England and becomes involved with a book collector who may have a Folio edition of Shakespeare's play Hamlet. Instead Peter finds a pamphlet written by Robert Greene, a contemporary of Shakespeare, and seemingly annotated with Shakespeare's marginalia. This would prove beyond doubt that Shakespeare was the author of the plays, but is the document a forgery? The owner of the pamphlet needs money and Peter feels that he cannot be trusted. The author weaves a tangled and complicated web of inter-family rivalry that stretches back to the nineteenth century. In his investigation the mild-mannered Peter becomes implicated in a murder, is trapped in a medieval chapel, finds an underground tunnel, overcomes claustrophobia and outwits a gun-toting murderer. Peter is convinced that the document he has is a forgery, but he also believes that he knows where the original is. In a retrospective deus ex machina, Peter himself is the rightful owner of it.
There is a wealth of information here about books and book restoration, about Shakespeare and his contemporaries and about Shakespearean scholarship. This is the novel's strength. The plot seems unbelievably Machiavellian and is quite complicated. Peter is an unlikely hero but a convincing book lover. The novel is suitable for older readers.
Jenny Hamilton

Max and George by Cori Brooke and Sue deGennaro

cover image

Penguin/Viking, 2013. ISBN 9780670076352. Hbk, RRP $A24.99
Max was never lonely. As long as there was a window, he had a friend because George lived in windows. No matter where the window was, Max could see George and he spent a long time looking at him. Because they were very similar - same height, same clothes, and whenever Max moved, so did George. They even shared the same feelings. But then the time comes for Max to start school. And he's nervous. Even though George was there in the school window, Max's teacher made him sit where he couldn't see him. Will Max find the confidence to leave George and make a real friend?
This is a delightful book, perfect for the child about to start school and finding it hard to let go of what is known and take the leap into the unknown. With its charming illustrations, it will appeal to all children - those who are like Max and empathise with him, and those like Sam who are a bit more confident and can reassure him. Tip for parents - teach your child a joke before they leave...
Barbara Braxton

Florentine and Pig and the lost pirate treasure by Eva Katzler

cover image

Ill. by Jess Mikhail. Bloomsbury, 2013. ISBN 9781408824405.
(Age: 5+) Picture book. Pirates. Humour. Things to do. Imagination. Florentine and Pig are back with another adventure to please the hearts of their fans. Stuck in the house on a cold and wet, wintry day, they search around for something to do. Out of the dress-up box comes a range of things to wear, and each is dressed as a pirate. Pig with his pirate hat and telescope looks just the part, and Florentine ambles behind him with her favourite sparkling cardigan which is missing one button. They find a pirate map, and use the furniture in the lounge room to create a ship on which to sail to find the treasure mentioned in the map. Fun abounds as they go on their adventure, and the story includes a list of the things they need to take, as well as the recipes for the food mentioned, the hat Pig wears, and the flag flown on their ship.
An entertaining look at using one's imagination, children will thrill at the mischief the pair gets up to. Readers will love to try things for themselves, and then cook the recipes given at the end of the story. For teachers, this is another book to include in the pirate books already available, and be a neat adjunct to work done in using imagination and play. I can imagine many students in early childhood setting wanting to emulate Florentine and Pig on their big adventure, so have the dress-up box ready, along with the ingredients for making the biscuits, cakes and pasta, as well as a pirate hat and flag.
Fran Knight

The watcher in the garden by Joan Phipson

cover image

Text Classics, 2013. ISBN 9781922147011
Recommended. The watcher in the garden (1982) by Joan Phipson has been republished by Text Classics for a new generation of readers to appreciate this timeless tale of adolescent angst played out against the backdrop of its uniquely Australian background.
The cover design and the wonderful introduction by Margo Lanagan set the mood for this remarkable tale. The Australian landscape, its beauty and mystery, is represented by the garden which belongs to the blind Mr Lovett and into which stumble the malevolent Terry and the angry and confused Kitty.
Mr Lovett befriends and becomes to depend on Kitty and her descriptions of the garden. His friendship and respect encourages Kitty to examine her own anger and behaviour. The garden brings her peace and tranquillity after she is welcomed by him.
At the same time Terry bears a grudge against Mr Lovett, and watches him as he plots his revenge for perceived slights against his family. Terry and Kitty tread warily around each other but their lives become entwined by the garden and its almost supernatural presence. Both become aware that the garden has a force which bears its influence on them.
In a powerful scene Kitty and Terry physically confront each other and both are injured. When they come to they realise that they have a psychic connection and can feel what the other is thinking. When Kitty is lost and has to stay in the bush overnight, Terry knows where to find her. Are they in a symbiotic relationship?
This connection leads to the penultimate scene when amidst an earth tremor Kitty struggles up the sides of the gorge in order to save Mr Lovett; Terry is there too and the garden plays its part in the drama as it unfolds.
I recommend this novel.
Michael Jongen

The maleficent seven by Derek Landy

cover image

Skulduggery Pleasant series. HarperCollins Children's, 2013. ISBN 9780007512386. 284 p. paperback
(Ages: 12-14) Themes: Good and evil. Skeletons. Magic. Fantasy. Sorcery.
Irish author Derek Landy's novella departs from the usual protagonists Skulduggery and Valkyrie, focussing on Tanith Low's dark corrupt character who now is permanently possessed by a Remnant spirit. Tanith recruits a team of villainous characters to search for and steal the four God-Killer level weapons to help Darquesse in the destruction of the world. The first weapon the team needs to find is the dagger at the German Sanctuary. Her crew are pitted against a secret group of Sanctuary sorcerers lead by Dexter Vex. Billy Ray Sanguine, one of her team, is particularly blood-thirsty, using his cut-throat razor to protect Tanith.
Tanith's back story is interspersed with the action chapters. She is left by her parents to work with the master Quoneel and other masters, learning the art of sorcery, killing, forgery and wall-walking. At this stage she still has a conscience.
The battles are graphically described; the killings matter of fact and the characters assisting Tanith are truly evil. This is another very dark story that will be welcomed by fans of the Skullduggery Pleasant series. Background understanding of this fantasy world is needed to read this book.
Rhyllis Bignell

Tom Gates is absolutely fantastic (at some things) by Liz Pichon

cover image

Scholastic Children's, 2013. ISBN 9781407134512. 249 p.
(Age: 8-11 ) Highly recommended. Diary stories. Family life. School stories. Boys. Brothers and sisters. Winner: Roald Dahl Funny Prize 2011, Blue Peter Book Award for Best Story. Tom Gates' diary is filled with doodles, illustrations, hidden monsters and a running commentary about school and home life. Tom has an intense dislike of his teacher Mr. Fullerman, as well as one of his classmates Marcus Meldrew and his rather mean older sister Delia. He spends most of his time at school drawing in his notebook, sketching and wickedly commenting on his class dramas. This time Tom's class is off on a camping trip and he hands in his signed form at the last minute. Even a trip to the supermarket with his Mum is a comedy, when the giant packet of toilet paper splits and he has to chase two rolls across the floor of the checkouts, landing in front of his secret crush, Amy.
At the Activity Centre, there are lots of laughs as Tom deals with his mother's hidden notes, Marcus Meldrew's annoying behaviour and his bunkmate's sleep talking. Nothing in Tom's life is dull or boring and he always finds trouble wherever he goes.
The text in this story includes handwriting, bubble writing, emphasized words, block writing and words made out of patterns; this makes it look handwritten. Liz Pichon's creative bold pen drawings and doodles complement the text style. This is another in the exciting series of Tom Gates books and I would highly recommend it for a reading audience from 8-11.
Rhyllis Bignell

Primrose by Alex T. Smith

cover image

Scholastic, 2013. ISBN 9781407109664.
(Age: 4+) Warmly recommended. Princesses. Fun. Family. When Princess Primrose gets out into the garden to pull vegetables, her parents are aghast, when she goes into the kitchen to cook, the chef shoos her out, when she climbs a tree in the orchard, her father tells her to get down and behave like a real princess, and when she plays with her dog, Percy, in her bedroom, Mum shrieks and makes her wear proper princess clothes. All in all, Primrose would rather be in old clothes, getting dirty and having fun, so her parents decide to call Grandmama for help.
Grandmama is stiff and starched, a very proper old woman but she has a surprise in store for the king and queen. She orders the king to climb the tree in the orchard and there he spies the old tea house and remembers his childhood days spent there. She orders the king and queen to change their clothes and help pull the vegetables, to play board games, to mess around in the kitchen, and generally to have fun, a concept they seem to have forgotten.
This delightful turn of events will engage younger readers who will laugh at the antics of the family in trying to get back to their childhoods and have a good laugh instead of obeying the rules and protocols in place in the palace.
Fran Knight

Pony problem by Yvette Poshoglian

cover image

Ella and Olivia series. Scholastic, 2013. ISBN: 9781742837987
When seven year old Ella and her younger sister Olivia accompany Ella's friend Zoe to her pony competition, things quickly get out of hand when Ella finds herself on a pony and is accidentally included in the equestrian events. Who will come to the rescue when things start to go wrong? Will this be Ella's dream come true or her worst nightmare?
This is a slim story for emergent female readers who love horses. Enormous font, liberally scattered illustrations and lacy patterned edges to the pages would possibly add to the appeal of the title for the very young child. Despite difficult words such as equestrian and dismounts, they are minimal in number so the series would not provide an overwhelming challenge in terms of vocabulary. Themes of horse-riding, friendship, envy, bravery and winning and losing are positive and age appropriate for the target audience.
Jo Schenkel

Rumble in the jungle by Geronimo Stilton

cover image

Ill. by Giuseppe Ferrario. Geronimo Stilton series bk 53. Scholastic, 2013. ISBN 9780545481939. 108p.
(Age: 7-9) Highly recommended. Mice. Jungles. Treasure. Adventure stories. Rainforests. Brazil. Amazon Region.
Rumble in the Jungle takes Geronimo Stilton from the comforts of his home off on another exciting fabumouse adventure in Brazil. His adventurous friend Bruce Hyena drops in one evening and hijacks Geronimo's boring Mousebook page and his life. Geronimo narrates this adventure teamed at first with his mouse friends Wild Willie and Maya. Unfortunately Geronimo becomes separated and has to fend for himself in a variety of difficult situations, coping with language problems, the loss of his wallet, samba dancing in a Rio Carnival, tumbling down the Iguazu Falls and searching for stolen treasure.
Information boxes are included for reader interest: maps, country facts, rainforest facts, a recipe and jungle animals. Colourful cartoon illustrations add vibrancy and comic relief as Geronimo stumbles his way through his adventures. Colourful phrases, different fonts and text sizes add emphasis and excitement for the booklover.
This series is extremely popular and I highly recommend this new addition to the series for readers from 7-9 years.
Geronimo's World is available online.
Rhyllis Bignell

Evan's Gallipoli by Kerry Greenwood

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2013. ISBN 9781743311356
(Age: 11+) Warmly recommended. War. Gallipoli. With a set up similar to those encountered in the Scholastic My Australian story series, and Penguin's Our Australian girl, this diary format story of a lad's time spent at Gallipoli is sure to win readers. Fourteen year old Evan accompanies his father as he goes to Gallipoli, to offer not only physical things to alleviate their suffering, lice powder and the like, but also religious help for those in need. But they are totally unprepared for what they find. Separated from their soldiers, they are recaptured by the Turks, there follows a road journey in which they escape to Greece, before returning to Australia. Along the way, Evan meets up with Abdul, a Muslim boy being used as a pawn to try to persuade his powerful father to fight, and the trio see some of the sights of war not usually found in history books.
Being a captive of the Turks allows Evan to describe the Gallipoli from a different perspective, one not always seen in our books (Candles at dawn by Serpil Ural was published in 2004 by Limelight Press). Well researched, Greenwood's book is informative as well as entertaining, and will appeal to middle school readers looking for a different perspective on a subject lately often written about, as the 100th anniversary of World War One (1914) and Gallipoli (1915) come along.
Fran Knight

Hold on tight by Sara Acton

cover image

Scholastic, 2012. ISBN 9781742833491
(Age: 4+) Warmly recommended. Picture book. Family. Imagination. Being safe. Seasons. On this cold winter's day I have read several books which have made me feel chilled to the bone. A bear and a tree is set in the snowy icy landscape where Bear is about to get into his den for hibernation, while this one concerns a young child on a wintry day holding her mother's hand as they walk through the landscape. Both books are full of the cold, wintry season, with snowflakes, rain, ice and wind tearing across each page.
When the girl's mother reminds her to hold on tight, the child wonders what would happen if she did not hold on tight, and so a range of wonderful excursions are imagined. Each double page spread shows a different adventure, told in two rhyming sentences with glorious illustrations reflecting and adding to the words. Ink and watercolour are used to great effect as the sparsely filled ink drawings reflect movement and a sense of the ephemeral nature of the season. On one double page for example, the child sits on a branch having afternoon tea with a bird, while over the page she floats on high, hanging onto a sycamore seed as it floats to the earth. Coming back to earth with Mum holding her hand, the child determines that she will not blow away today.
A charming introduction to the idea of using one's imagination, or discussions about safe behaviour, or being with Mum and why she wants to hold your hand, this lovely story will be used for a variety of reasons by teachers and parents, not least of which is that it is a beautiful rhyming story, well told, with evocative illustrations. Fran Knight