Reviews

Sailmaker by Rosanne Hawke

cover image

UQP, 2013. ISBN 9780702249723.
(Age: 11-14) Highly recommended. Themes: Step-parents and stepchildren, ADHD, Belonging, Ghosts, Family, Friendship, Mystery Fiction.
Rosanne Hawke's Sailmaker is the second fast-paced adventure story in this trilogy that started with The Keeper and concludes with the publication of the Killer Ute in 2013.
With this first person narrative, the reader sees the world through Joel's eyes as continues to struggle with his medication and ADHD, his family relationships and friendships. He is a believable teenage character who is struggling with his own self confidence and self-control.
The mystery Joel and his friend Mei set out to solve involves a lighthouse ghost, an abandoned tinny and an escaped prisoner. Rosanne Hawke uses the setting of the coastal town, the elemental sea and the nearby island with its bird sanctuary and iron lighthouse to effectively underpin Joel's adventures. There are many appropriate metaphors used to develop the reader's understanding of Joel, he calls his problems with his biological father a shark of his own to deal with.
Joel's relationship with his foster father Dev Eagle is still undergoing some difficult patches causing some anxiety as well. Vern Solomon, the sailmaker and bird sanctuary caretaker who lives on the island provides sage advice and sanctuary during the storm. Rosanne Hawke's adds Dev's sister, problems with his biological mother Zoe and his druggie ex-con father Scott into the mix. School life with its dramas, bullying and illness management is realistically portrayed.
Sailmaker was a CBCA Notable book in 2003 and this reprinting introduces Joel to a new generation of readers. I would highly recommend this series for readers from 11 to 14. They are excellent for a class read-aloud and for reluctant teenage boy readers.
Rhyllis Bignell

Stung by Bethany Wiggins

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2013. ISBN 9781408840665.
(Age: Older teens) Stung is an all-star, action packed novel written by author Bethany Wiggins that creates an aura of adrenaline and excitement for the reader who gets hooked by this elaborate masterpiece. The twists in the plot gives a sense of mystery and suspicion and keeps the reader guessing while they enjoy life-like dialogue between characters and realistic situations that the characters find themselves in. A book best suited for older teenagers rather than younger teens due to some themes included, these themes may confuse younger readers.
Fiona wakes up in the middle of disaster; the people she loves are missing, her house is a ruin and she has physically aged by a few years. This is what happens when life as you know it is plunged into chaos . . . Over bees. Waking up, she finds a strange tattoo on her hand and something moving in her house as well as a lack of memories. Making an escape, she walks out into a brand new world. Houses are deserted and the people she knew have either changed or disappeared. Finding confidence in an old friend, Fiona tries to understand what has happened to her, her family and friends and the place she grew up.
This is a twist of a novel and I can't wait for the sequel to be published; I thank the author for a brilliant read that kept me excited and addicted to the very last page.
Sarah Filkin

The Frog Who Lost His Underpants by Juliette MacIver

cover image

Ill. by Cat Chapman. Walker, 2013. ISBN: 9781921977893.
Recommended for 4-6 year olds. Subjects: Frogs - Fiction, Underwear, Stories in rhyme, Jungles, Problem Solving.
Juliette MacIver's rhyming picture is an adaptation of a favourite children's action rhyme Round and round the garden, like a teddy bear. The teddy bear is walking through the jungle kicking up the lakka leaves when he meets an orange-spotted jungle frog. The small frog ask Teddy for help he needs to find his stolen underpants to regain his dignity. Their search takes them deep in the jungle and they encounter little chimpanzee and Mr. Elephant who join in the hunt for the missing item of clothing. The resolution to the problem with the clever use of jungle materials will be enjoyed by the young reader.
Cat Chapman's busy paintings fill the double page spreads, with the rich green jungle background and the funny antics of the jungle animals in the foreground. The frogs fighting over the underpants is a fun close-up showing a range of emotions from happy to determined.
Juliette's rhyming text is fun to read aloud and students soon pick up the pattern and join in. There are some tricky words like dignity and distraught that are great words for discussion.
A Teacher's Guide is available .
Rhyllis Bignell

Reboot by Amy Tintera

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2013. ISBN 9781743315507.
(Ages: 13+) Lacking the revolutionary struggles of the constrained society in Divergent, and the badassery and depth of character development of June in Legend, I found Reboot by Amy Tintera to be lackluster in comparison. It's already been optioned for a movie by Fox and is receiving rave reviews everywhere, but unfortunately, I couldn't see the appeal.
The concept of Rebooted humans who wake up minutes after their death stronger, faster, and with healing abilities, is appealing and unique. Those who wake up sooner after their death are more attuned to their human emotions than those who woke up later. Wren, who woke up 178 minutes after her death, is the perfect soldier. She takes a new student under her wing, Callum (or number 22) who is closer to human than most. He's weak, emotional, and is going to be a problem . . . at least when it comes to HARC, who trains the Reboots to extract or assassinate humans.
Wren, as a main character, was inconsistent. Because she rebooted so long after her death, she's cold, emotionless, basically lacking human emotion. When she meets Callum, she is attracted to him physically, but sees him as weak as he is governed by his emotions. Instead of falling in love with Callum's human traits, she pretty much mimics him towards the end - giggling, laughing and kissing - not the emotionless soldier we believed she was.
While Wren is the perfect soldier, Callum is weak, can't bring himself to harm or kill humans, won't follow orders, and is always crying in the book. The chemistry seems forced between the two and we're lead to believe this non-complimentary couple is good for each other.
The world building was also poor. We don't know how or why people are rebooting and the book doesn't go into detail about the nature of the environment they are living in. Instead of fleshing it out, the plot became wholly focused on the romance.
Reboot is action packed with a great concept, but overall, I think there are much better dystopians out there.
Jeann Wong

Welcome to my country by Laklak Burarrwanga and family

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2013. ISBN 9781743313961.
(Age: 14+) Recommended. This is a beautiful book. Laklak and her sisters invite you in to learn about Yolngu country and culture in northeast Arnhem Land - country that many people may know only as the land of Yothu Yindi, the famous Aboriginal band with their songs Treaty and Djapana Sunset Dreaming. Laklak explains that in Yolngu culture, yothu yindi means mother-child, a relationship that is core to their beliefs and part of the land as well, like the web of Dhuwa and Yirritja moieties that weave and hold everyone and everything together. With each chapter we learn a little more - about water, the six seasons, collecting and sharing food, the counting system, astronomy and space, justice and peace, relationships and warnings.
Each chapter starts with a conversation from Laklak to the reader, describing the season, and inviting you to join in whatever activity is happening at the time. Each chapter also has a story that illustrates and adds meaning to the lesson learnt. We learn the history as well - of the early relationship with the Macassan traders from Indonesia, the struggle for recognition of land rights, and the creation of the Bark Petition now hanging in Parliament House, Canberra.
The book is written simply in a conversational style, the font is large and there are many attractive coloured photographs, but this is not a simple book. Although the early chapters might be shared with a younger audience, the lessons become increasingly complex, and a later chapter deals with the serious issue of forbidden sexual relationships.
There are layers upon layers of knowledge, like peeling the layers of a paperbark tree. As Laklak says, 'For Yolngu, knowledge is told in context, at the right time and to the appropriate audience. If you are reading this, it is the right time for you to learn'.
For me, I feel I could read it over again, and begin to understand a bit more with each reading. This invitation to country provides an insight into a wonderfully rich and complex culture that stands proud and strong, offering to share knowledge and go forward in a two-ways learning exchange.
Helen Eddy

World War 1 tales by Terry Deary

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2013
The last flight ISBN 9781408191682
The war game ISBN 9781408191743
(Age: 8+) Recommended. Historical fiction. World War One. Early chapter book.
In the series, World War 1 tales, Terry Deary offers stories that are not well known to his readers.
In The last flight, letters from Alfred to his sister back home outline his extraordinary luck at not being sent to the trenches during World War One. He was able to volunteer his photography skills when the men were being photographed and so from there moved into the Air Force where he and a pilot were sent to photograph enemy lines before the push against the German Army in 1917.
The letters reveal a great deal of information about life for a young man in the army at this time, and much of this would be new to the age group reading this easy to absorb series of books. At just 60 pages, with large print, some informative illustrations, wide margins and information added at the back about some of the things mentioned in the text, this series of books will be readily picked up by the target audience. In the back is an outline of the others in Deary's series, Viking tales, Pirate tales and Victorian tales. As yet there are only two in the current series about war.
The second, The war game, outlines the story of Christmas Eve in 1914, when Germans and British soldiers came together to spend the evening together, playing a football match. Told through the eyes of two men, Charlie and Alfred, the readers will absorb the boredom of life in the trenches at the time, the orders given by those above in rank, and the humanity of the ordinary soldiers and their wanting to be safe at home. Bloomsbury's website lists several more in this series.
Fran Knight

The novel cure: An A-Z of literary remedies by Ella Berthoud and Susan Elberkin

cover image

Text, 2013. ISBN 9781922079350.
This book is written in praise of literature as a cure for physical and psychological ailments. It is organised under 'ailments', which are arranged alphabetically and include topics both serious and comical. The authors claim that Abandonment, their first condition, can be remediated if not cured by reading Kent Haruf's Plainsong, which shows how characters with losses have their needs filled by surprising contributions from their community. The last condition, Zestlessness, it is suggested can be cured by reading Doctorow's Ragtime, an energetic capturing of life in New York in the early twentieth century. Some of the discussions inbetween deal with equally serious subjects, Insomnia, Happiness, Hatred, while others are tongue-in-cheek, for example Itchy teeth (apparently a condition described in Saul Bellow's Henderson the rain king and which needs to be consulted for the cure) and Idiot, feeling like an (read Dostoyevsky's The idiot!). The headings are beautifully organised, with cross-references that work, and concludes with an index of authors and titles. There are also lists of recommended reading , under the heading of 'The ten best...' These include recommendations for audio books, novellas, 'big fat tomes', for 'drowning out snoring', for 'reading on the loo', and for each decade from the teenage years to the over one hundreds. The recommendations are widely based, and include classics, little known works of the twentieth century and very up-to-date publications. Dickens is here, Austen too, and Cervantes, and so are Suzanne Collins, John Green, Mark Dunn and Sam Lipsyte. The writing is lively and entertaining, and following up the cross-referencing is enjoyable. The discussions of the texts and sometimes the ailments are usually insightful, though classics teachers would disagree with the characterisation of Odysseus as having 'itchy feet'. This is an energetic and entertaining approach to reading for adults, but is appropriate for senior students and should be very useful for teacher-librarians and teachers of literature. It is also great fun too for a casual browse.
Jenny Hamilton

What is a crocodile's favourite thing? by Ben Hawkes

cover image

Jonathan Cape, 2013. ISBN 9781780080222.
One of the world's greatest unanswered questions - until now. What IS a crocodile's favourite thing? Is it a racing car that looks like a sausage or maybe riding a tricycle made of jelly on the moon? No - it's ...!
Children will have a lot of fun with this book, not only making up crazy-daisy scenarios that might be the answer but also interpreting them in art! But beware of the twist in the tale.
This is another one of those quirky picture books that just look like a lot of fun on the surface, but which, in the hands of a creative teacher, can lead to a lot of literacy and language learning.
Barbara Braxton

Snugglepot and Cuddlepie's sleepover by May Gibbs and Mark McLeod

cover image

Scholastic, 2013. ISBN 9781742830216.
(Age: 4+) Recommended. Picture book. May Gibbs. A beautiful present, this hardcover picture book with May Gibbs' illustrations adorning every page will entice younger readers to further explore this classic Australian author and illustrator. One of three commissioned by Scholastic with copyright holders, the Northcott Society and Cerebral Palsy Alliance, part of the proceeds gained from the books will assist in their work.
The story centres around the two friends inviting others over for a sleepover. Snugglepot and Cuddlepie invite Obelia, Ragged Blossom and Mrs Koala's children to join them.
But someone has forgotten to invite Mrs Kookaburra, partly because her six very noisy offspring would not be good to have at a sleepover. Cuddlepie is put into a position where he must invite them, and of course, the predicted outcome happens. Ragged Blossom goes to find Snugglepot and Cuddlepie to tell the baby kookaburras a story in the hope that this will help them sleep, but cannot find the two friends anywhere. A delightful story with May Gibbs' beautiful illustrations will take her work to a new generation.
Fran Knight

Marcy Series 2 by Susan Halliday

cover image

Ford Street, 2013.
Quiz champs ISBN 9781921665721 (pbk.)
Thirteen dolphins ISBN 9781921665738 (pbk.)
Lost dogs ISBN 9781921665745 (pbk.)
Award winners ISBN 9781921665752 (pbk.)
Netball challenge ISBN 9781921665714 (pbk.)
Box Set ISBN 9781921665882.
In order to appeal more to girls, Susan Halliday has written a parallel series to the Toocool series by Phil Kettle, with Marcy as the main character.
Containing the same structure as the Toocool series, each again concludes with some factual information, a glossary and some jokes and is based on the same characters. Written in narrative format, these titles are easy to read and Marcy sets some great examples to her readers. She cares about others and is always willing to help. Her positive, helpful nature and self image means that there is no challenge to which she won't rise. From rescuing dolphins to finding homes for lost dogs, each title is easy to read and contains a touch of humour often based on the ever present rivalry between girls and boys at the ages of these characters.
Halliday includes some phrases which are somewhat old fashioned and allows Marcy to find the meanings of the words, along with the reader. With the new Australian curriculum, these titles could be used as read alouds or in literature circles with younger children and changing language could be discussed as an offshoot of these books, as could the positive messages included therein.
Jo Schenkel

Meet Captain Cook by Rae Murdie

cover image

Ill. by Chris Nixon. Random House, 2013. ISBN 9780857980175.
In this, the third in this series of picture books introducing our younger readers to those who have contributed so much to Australia, we meet Captain James Cook. While it might be said that there couldn't possibly be room for yet another book about Cook on the shelves, this one has the younger reader, the one for whom the name Cook is still unknown, in mind. Succinctly dealing with his younger life, the story picks up with the beginning of the journey which was to lay the foundation for Australia's future and tells the story that we all know.
Fitting neatly into the history strand of the Australian National Curriculum for Years 3-4 this is a text written at a level for this audience, its picture book format adding to its appeal. It is accompanied by a timeline which continues on to later travels as well as easy-to-interpret maps on the endpapers. Written in a way that draws the reader into a story rather than just a series of facts and figures, this is a perfect introduction to the topic that teaches as it tells.
Others in this excellent series focus on Ned Kelly and Mary MacKillop, with a new title about Antarctic explorer Douglas Mawson due for publication early 2014.
Barbara Braxton

The screaming staircase by Jonathan Stroud

cover image

Doubleday, 2013. ISBN 9780857532022.
(Age: 11+) Highly recommended. Supernatural, Humour, Adventure. The first in a new series, Lockwood and Co., this is a world in the here and now where things have got out of hand and ghosts have appeared. Their arrival has meant wholesale changes to society; curfews, fear of the dark, and the rise of ghost hunters with their guidelines and marketing strategies. Into this mix comes a new firm of rather disorganised ghost hunters, Lockwood and Co., young and eager but spied on with suspicion by the older more well known firms, lest they fail and so undermine the other companies, or succeed and take their customers.
The company's newest member, Lucy, recently dismissed from her post as psychic investigator at another firm is keen to do well, partly so she can live but also to dispel the stories about her that threaten her livelihood. She joins Anthony Lockwood and his employee, George, who takes an instant dislike to Lucy, trying everything he can to undermine and humiliate her. So the stage is set for tension to rub between the three as they endeavour to solve people's ghostly problems. Their first big case however, results in the burning down of a house, and the subsequent suing for compensation sees them take on an investigation which could result in their deaths. With the creepiest house to stay in for the night, a ghastly employer and a plethora of horrors awaiting them, the trio sets in for the night which could see their fortunes made or their lives cut short.
An auspicious start to a hair-raising adventure into the supernatural world, this series will have a legion of avid followers. There are plenty of strings to follow: just who is Anthony and why does he have this enormous house to himself? where has George come from? and just what is behind Lucy's abilities?
Fran Knight

East of the sun, west of the moon by Jackie Morris

cover image

Frances Lincoln Children's Books, 2013. ISBN 9781847802941.
(Age: 11+) Warmly recommended. Fairy tale retelling, Fantasy, Princes, Freedom. With the fairy tale of Beauty and the beast hovering in the background, this beautifully told story is more than a retelling, as the author adds layers of setting and characterisation, plot and motive to the original tale.
A large white bear asks the girl to go with him. There is no question that she will go, she has always known it, but her mother is distraught. She loves being with the bear, is amazed at the palace where he lives, and what he does for her, to the point of giving her a treasured photo of her family, lost when they fled their country.
But each night she is aware that someone creeps into her bed, lying beside her leaving in the morning. She longs to see who it is but the matches will not strike. When she misses her family, the bear takes her home for a month and a day, but warns her not to be alone with her mother.
On returning, mother has given her new matches and so one night she strikes one, enabling her to see the person who lies in her bed. His shocking story is revealed, and by striking the match she has destined him to marry the ogre's daughter, never to return.
She then sets out to search for him, to right the wrong she has made and in her search finds true love.
The retelling of the story is languid and poetic, descriptions are matched by the mythical water colour illustrations as they drape across the pages, adding to the pleasure girls will have on reading this tale.
The small size is appealing and handy to hold, adding to the pleasure of the read.
Fran Knight

The shiny guys by Doug Macleod

cover image

Penguin, 2012. ISBN 9780143565307.
The shiny guys is a bold, abrasive and surprisingly funny novel, akin to Ken Kesey's One flew over the cuckoo's nest in terms of subject matter, and worthy of similar praise.
The story concerns a 15-year old boy who has been admitted to an asylum during the 1980s, a time when the treatment of mental health patients was still radical but beginning to be questioned.
From the first page, each word seems hand picked, like a meticulously compiled string of sentences. Despite the strength of the writing, each word has an irresistible urgency and secrecy, as though betraying too much of it to another would be breaking some intimate vow.
Doug Macleod presents teenagers with a genuinely smart, genuinely funny and genuinely hard-hitting piece of collage writing. He combines normal contemporary prose with letters, transcribed conversations and other styles. This format is wildly eclectic and effective, allowing for the disjointed characters and dialogue to be presented in a way that serves rather than stifles their quirks.
The mixed-up writing almost recalls Beat Generation poetry, whimsical and dark, equally edgy and translucent.
The shiny guys is a strong, nostalgic and never accusatory literary nod towards the treacherous mental health system of times gone by, but more importantly the fragile health in question of young people. It poignantly recollects and highlights the institutional damage inflicted on those who are already damaged.
An intelligent read recommended for teenagers looking for something with bite, but enough heart to balance the dark.
Henry Vaughan (Student)

Scarlet in the snow by Sophie Masson

cover image

Random House, 2013. ISBN 9781742758152.
(Age 12+) Highly recommended. There seems to be a real fashion for updating fairy tales in recent times. Of course, over the years there have been many retellings of traditional tales, but this latest foray seems to be concentrated in presenting new versions in more adult formats vis-a-vis cinematic offerings such as Snow White and the huntsman or Mirror mirror or books such as Moonlight and ashes (also by Sophie Masson).
Sophie Masson presents a new styling of the old 'beauty and the beast' traditional tale (La belle et la bete), first published in 1740, and gives it a new and engaging twist that will be sure to captivate the girls looking for something with rather more substance than the general pulp fiction in the romance genre. Carefully employing many of the original elements of the story - a once rich family reduced to poverty, the enchanted forest, a mysterious mansion occupied by an apparently invisible owner, tables laden with magical food, and most importantly a beautiful rose plucked innocently without any malice - Masson weaves a complex but beautiful rendering of the story breathing real life into the characters and their circumstances.
Tragedy, revenge, intrigue and love triumphant are crafted into an unravelling of the story in which Masson has combined selected motifs of the many hundreds of versions of the original tale. Taking her setting from Russia and drawing most heavily on the version retold in that country, the author has created highly believable and very human characters in Natasha, Ivan and even Old Bony. There is a definite tone of steampunk in the later settings/incidents in the book which this reader found highly engaging.
With teaching notes available from the publisher this would make a terrific book for lower secondary students engaged in shared reading or a book group. Highly recommended for able readers 12 and up - especially girls.
Sue Warren