Reviews

Australians All: A History of Growing Up from the Ice Age to the Apology by Nadia Wheatley

cover image

Ill. by Ken Searle. Allen and Unwin, 2013. ISBN: 9781741146370.
Highly recommended. Nadia Wheatley has compiled an important and beautifully presented resource which will be valued as much for the narratives presented as the historical context that they represent. The eighty or so stories collected in this book cover in chronological order what it was like to be a child and live in the Australia of the time.
From an exploration of the arrival of Aboriginal people 40 thousand years ago through the experience of some children living in England during the 18th century to the arrival of the convicts and the subsequent growth of the Australian population including the experience of refugees, the stories are a snapshot of the lives of children and their families.
Each chapter is contextualised with a brief account of the issues of the time and a timeline of significant events. The individual accounts cover experiences of hardship and good times, work and play, schooling in all situations, disadvantage, discrimination and death for both aboriginal and non aboriginal Australians.
A comprehensive reference at the end lets us know what happened to the children and families to give further insight to their lives. A Glossary explains some of the terms used and an extensive Index enables one to follow a theme, e.g. education, over many eras, whilst the Bibliography and annotations enable specific stories or pictures to be followed up.
I can see many uses for these stories both within the History Curriculum as an exploration of the past, as well as an opportunity to become familiar with some of the figures that have shaped our country and culture whether they go on to become famous like Henry Lawson or Eddie Mabo or the ill-fated McCallum children who died of diphtheria near Port Lincoln.
Sue Keane

The dark unwinding by Sharon Cameron

cover image

The dark unwinding bk 1. Scholastic, 2013. ISBN 9780545327879.
(Age 13+) Recommended. Gothic. Mystery. Historical. Katharine Tulman is sent to the estate of her eccentric uncle by her Aunt who believes that he should be put into an asylum as he is squandering her son's inheritance. But when Katharine arrives she finds an eccentric genius inventor who is supporting over 900 employees that have been rescued from the workhouses of London. Katharine knows that she can secure a future for herself if she declares that her uncle is mad, but she is torn when she sees the good work that her uncle is doing by giving employment to so many destitute men and their families. Things are further complicated by the presence of a handsome apprentice and a beguiling student who is fascinated by her uncle's inventions. When she starts to do strange things at night, she begins to fear for her own sanity and gradually the tension grows around her as she tries to unravel the mystery surrounding her.
I love gothic mysteries and this one did not disappoint. Readers who are new to this genre will revel in the twists and turns of the plot; the suggestions of insanity, the threat of asylums for the insane, the loss of inheritances and the dark romance surrounding the young men in the story. Readers who are familiar with the genre will revel in a good story that contains some plot lines that resonate but also some unique ideas and sub plots. It was particularly interesting to read the author's note at the end about where she got some of her ideas for her background and its historical accuracy.
Not only is the plot captivating, the characters stand out as well. Uncle Tully the eccentric inventor, who could be autistic, makes wonderful and strange animations and devices that challenge the imagination. Both Katharine's and his ability with numbers is fascinating and creates a bond between the two. The reader is kept wondering about which of the two young men will engage Katharine's interest but the romance doesn't dominate the story at all, it is the mystery surrounding Katharine's strange behaviour and her dilemma about what she will do about her uncle that is so engrossing.
I loved the mid-19th century setting, the dilapidated mansion with its secret passages, the lord of the manor structure and the anger of the men who were afraid that Katharine would jeopardise their livelihood. This was an entertaining and atmospheric thriller that is sure to gain an audience from readers who like historical mysteries.
Pat Pledger

No matter who we're with by Robert Vescio

cover image

Ill. by Cheri Scholten. IP Kidz; Australia: 2013. ISBN: 9781922120212.
One for the Wellbeing shelf, or the Counsellor's library. At time when more and more children are experiencing their parents separating and learning to cope with shared custody arrangements, this book offers comfort whilst acknowledging some of the difficulties of living between two houses.
Written after the author's own separation the story reflects on the fun things the children do with each loving parent: The trips to the pool and beach, watching movies and dress-up, games, gardening and cooking. The warm colours used in the illustrations reflect the joy experienced by the children whilst the occasional more sombre expression reminds us of the missing parent.
The message is reaffirmed that regardless of the situation that missing one parent whilst with the other is OK, and that you can still love both parents regardless of where they live.
This book would be a useful tool to support children struggling with split homes and a definite addition to the School Counsellor's library.
Sue Keane

How to scare the pants off your pets by Henry Winkler and Lin Oliver

cover image

Ghost Buddy series. Scholastic, 2013. ISBN 9781407132303.
Recommended 8-12 years. Henry Winkler and Lin Oliver continue their long history of collaborating to write children's books with this the third of the Ghost Buddy Series featuring Billy Broccoli and his ghostly housemate Hoover Porterhouse the Third aka The Hoove.
Billy has a problem. Well more to the point The Hoove has a problem which equates to a less than pleasant life for Billy. Once again The Higher-ups, the higher beings that monitor ghost behaviour, have been very disappointed in The Hoove's grades in 'Responsibility to Others'. So much so, that now he has been confined to the house, until he shows a marked improvement in his grade.
Living with a bored ghost who thinks he's perfect and who no one else sees is not easy, made more so as The Hoove rages against his confinement. A chance meeting with Amber and her pet rat gives Billy an idea. What better way to show responsibility than to take care of a pet.
A series of hilarious episodes follow as pet after low maintenance pet is introduced to The Hoove with chaos reigning and no sign of the Higher-ups relenting. The arrival of a stray cat which seems remarkably calm in the presence of a ghost who finally manages to be ungrounded.
As I read I could imagine the scenes played out on the small screen reflecting the background of both writers as television producers.
Sue Keane

Dork Diaries: Holiday Heartbreak by Rachel Renee Russell

cover image

Simon and Schuster, 2023
For girls ages 9+. With the 'girls' choice' dance fast approaching, Nikki Maxwell is excited at the possibility of inviting her major crush, Brandon. When he gets in first to invite her on an 'almost' date, she is wildly excited. As is usual for Nikki, things go wrong and suddenly Brandon starts to change and begins to appear disinterested. Her initial enthusiasm to attend the dance disappears as she can't risk being turned down . . . can she? Younger sister Brianna again adds to the mayhem of the story, creating weird and wonderful hairdos for her Nikki and managing to send a photo of her to all of Nikki's contacts.
Russell again includes themes of friendship, bullying and cyber bullying, elements of junior romance, siblings and family. Written in a diary format with each page looking like the lined pages of an exercise book and sketches drawn on virtually every page, this series would most likely appeal to younger girls or reluctant female readers. Personally, I feel there are some discrepancies between the abilities and interests of the main character and her assumed age of fourteen yet students seem to be able to overlook this issue. Naturally, the dork comes out on top and this book leaves the reader with the feeling that fairy tale endings can happen to anyone.
Jo Schenkel

If you're cheeky and you know it by P. Crumble

cover image

Ill. by Chris Kennett. Scholastic Australia, 2013. ISBN: 9781742836478.
One for the 3-5 year olds. If you're familiar with the rhyme, clap your hands!
A whole new generation of pre-school children are being exposed to the old rhymes and songs through this series of colourful picture books by P. Crumble. This version follows on from his previously published If you're happy and you know it! Australian Edition but features a collection of common African animals with a frog and penguin thrown in for good measure.
While the rhyme is familiar it is Chris Kennett's illustrations which bring the book alive with their comic, colourful appearance, huge eyes and expressive faces. Each animal has an action with the others joining in. My favourite page would have to be the meerkat and other animals staring.
With the complete rhyme written on the first page, each other action is a double page spread introducing the animal and action with simple and clear and colourful text. Having introduced all the actions the final pages have the complete rhyme for each animal. A great help to parents or carers who have forgotten the pattern of the song.
I can see many youngsters enjoying an active sing along with this book and some adults reminiscing at the first reading before encouraging independent reading using the pictures as cues.
Sue Keane

Briar Rose by Jana Oliver

cover image

Macmillan, 2013. ISBN 9781447241096.
(Age: 15+) Imagine the Sleeping Beauty tale revisited upon a small Southern town in America. Sounds intriguing? If only it delivered as much as promised.
Growing up in the small township of Bliss, Briar Rose's life at first seems aptly blissful, until we learn that a family feud has come between Briar and her former best friend, Joshua Quinn. To make matters worse, Briar discovers that due to an old curse, she will not survive her 16th birthday, which just happens to be when the novel starts.
However, instead of dying, Briar falls into a deep slumber inhabited by a fairy tale nightmare. Instead of a charming tale of handsome princes and fabulous castles, Briar awakens to a world filled with violence and dread. In this nightmare world, while the beautiful princess sleeps, the young princes who try to awaken her are brutally killed and a cruel regent rules in place of the Royal family.
In the first half of the novel, the fairy tale within a fairy tale scenario is cleverly deployed and the main characters are credibly complex. However, gradually our engagement with the story starts to wane. This is partly due to the writer's narrative style which is overtaxed with Americanisms. These become particularly distracting as the action intensifies; the constant use of phrases like 'Right back at you, girlfriend' simply sounds cheesy and dissipates the supposed tension at critical moments. Whilst humour can be used to balance darkness, these attempts at lightness feel corny rather than clever.
The characters also become more one-dimensional as the novel progresses: Briar's first saviour, Ruric, loses his mysterious qualities and behaves like a stock storybook prince, whilst the bad boy at the start of the novel (Pat Daniels) is all too easily reformed! Meanwhile the budding romance between Briar and Joshua is described in increasingly mawkish and unrealistic terms.
Ultimately, what begins as an enticing premise is diminished by the manner of the telling.
Deborah Marshall

Rose under fire by Elizabeth Wein

cover image

Electric Monkey, 2013. ISBN 9781405265119.
(Age: 14+) Highly recommended. War. Strong female character. In this companion novel to the award winning Code Name Verity, the story revolves around Rose Justice who is a young American pilot, working for the British Air Transport Auxiliary. She has been flying with her father since she was very young and loves being a pilot who delivers planes and transports pilots for the RAF during the summer of 1944. She loves to write poetry and is enjoying a romance with a young pilot. Then once day her world changes when she is flying home from Europe. Crashing the airplane she is captured by the Germans and discovers what it is like to survive in Ravensbruck, a notorious women's concentration camp.
Wein cleverly takes the reader from the relatively safe but exciting world that Rose inhabits in Britain to the horror of a concentration camp, showing the courage that it takes to live in both worlds. Then in story telling that is very memorable, the author takes the reader one step further and shows the devastation that an experience like Ravensbruck can have on the spirit, even after Rose has been rescued.
This is a story of courage and resilience, of survival under terrible conditions and of both the depravity that people can sink to and the strength of the human spirit. Rose uses the poetry of Edna St. Vincent Millay and her own poetry to help others and herself survive Ravensbruck and poetry, journals and letters keep the narrative engrossing.
This would be a fabulous book to use when studying World War 2. The use of concentration camps, the heartlessness of the Nazis, what it was like to survive the aftermath of the war and the Nuremberg trials are all covered and given a female point of view which is unusual. It is a well written, heart breaking novel that will remain with me for a long time.
Pat Pledger

The Nelly gang by Stephen Axelsen

cover image

Walker Books Australia, 2013. ISBN 9781921977918.
(Age: 8+) Highly recommended. Graphic novel. Bushrangers. Australian history. Gold rush. Watching Stephen Axelsen create parts of this fascinating book a couple of years ago in Adelaide where he was the recipient of the May Gibbs Fellowship, opened my eyes to the complexity of the creative process using digital imaging to bring together his pen and ink drawings and the impeccably researched story. I had always loved his earlier graphic novel, The mostly true story of Matthew and Trim (Cassandra Golds, author) and I was very pleased to see this one finally published.
The result, this involved and involving graphic novel set in the gold rushes in northern Victoria in the 1860's brings to the fore the range of people attracted to the gold fields, the people from a variety of other countries, the bushrangers, lazy police, the hard working miners, having to pay for the privilege of searching for their meagre finds, and the range of women and children who accompanied them.
Nelly Nolan is at her lessons when she hears the rarely heard sound of 'Eureka'. Escaping the tedious school, she rushes to her father's mine and finds that he has struck it rich. All seems assured, they will catch the coach to Wodonga, there to go to Sydney where Nelly's mother lives. But on the way the coach is held up by bushrangers, and there follows quite an adventure as Nelly flees into the bush with her goat and friend, Jin. They meet their other friend, Miro, whose knowledge of the bush helps them find Nelly's father, after a few dead ends and red herrings, and all comes to a neatly resolved conclusion.
This highly entertaining graphic novel will easily draw in readers, fascinated by the story of the young girl and her two friends, equally absorbed by the background detail, and captivated by the illustrative technique. From a teaching perspective, this could form the basis of a unit of work around the gold rushes, Australia in the nineteenth century and bushrangers. The detail is extraordinary and will entice all readers to look closely at every page. More information about Stephen can be found at his website.
Fran Knight

The fabulous Finola Fox by Carmel Bird

cover image

Ill. by Kerry Argent. Penguin/Viking, 2013. ISBN 9780670029488.
(Age: 4+) Warmly recommended. Picture book. Shoes. Family. Finola Fox is a shoe fetishist. Whenever she sees shoes, she must have them, so spirits them away in her capacious handbag, taking them home where she stores them in rows in her cellar.  She hopes one day to be able to open a museum to display them all, but until then, she busies herself arranging them all. She notices that one shoe is alone. It was a glamorous jewelled and feathered shoe that she found in an alleyway last summer.
She sets out to find its pair. She goes to the wonderful hotel, the art gallery, the Botanic Gardens and the Opera House, all to no avail. Outside the Opera House, she notices a pair of green sandals getting into  a limousine. About to follow the car, she is stopped by another fox who introduces himself as Frederick, who asks her what she is searching for. He surprises her by telling her that he thinks he knows just where to look. Together they find the missing shoe and return to her house which Frederick thinks is an ideal place for the museum.
This is a charming tale of coming together, like a pair of shoes. The two foxes find each other in the streets of Sydney, and together find the shoe Finola is searching for. The pair of shoes parallels the two foxes in finding a friend, a mate, a companion.
Argent's illustrations are just wonderful. She has an amazing collection of people and animals on each page, reflecting the text in the foxes' search for the missing shoe. The bold, colourful pages will entice the reader to look more closely, following the fox as she searches under counters, along the rows of seats in the Opera House, through the shrubbery in the gardens.
Fran Knight

Stardines swim high across the sky by Jack Prelutsky

cover image

Ill. by Carin Berger. HarperCollins, 2013. ISBN 9780062014641.
(Age: 5+) Recommended. Poetry. Humour. With verses about animals that are made up using the roots of several words, these poems are simply fun. Star and sardine, for example is an amalgam that produces a fish like thing in the night sky, swimming in giant school, lighting up the night sky. The sobcat is a very very sad feline, while the slobbster is a very messy lobster, so messy in fact that it is a slob.
Each of the animals has a poem about it, explaining its virtues and possibly its disadvantages as well. The poems are short, easy to read, but do not pander to a younger audience, using an array of wonderful words like lachrymose, preposterously and copious. I found myself thinking how to use it in the classroom, not merely as a wonderful read a loud, but as a model for poetry lessons, encouraging children to make up words from known animals, and then using the technique to make up a poem. Most of the poems use the basic four line stanza of alternatively rhyming lines, while some use nursery rhymes as the basis of the rhythm, and so are easy to emulate.
The illustrations will engage the children's interest immediately. Berger builds dioramas, using a huge range of things to build up the images which are then photographed for the book. Children will love picking out the found objects, the pieces of note paper, he music paper, wool, cloth, ribbon, cut up paper and so on. Each page is absorbing to look at as the poem is read. It is a lovely book to hold and read, full of possibilities, humour and fun, begging to be shared.
Fran Knight

Lulu Bell and the Cubby Fort by Belinda Murrell

cover image

Ill. by Serena Geddes. Random House Australia Children's, 2013. ISBN: 9781742758794.
Themes: Family Life, Farm Life, Holidays.
Lulu Bell and the Moon Dragon by Belinda Murrell
Ill. by Serena Geddes. Random House Australia Children's, 2013. ISBN: 9781742758817.
Themes: Vietnamese Moon Festival, Whale watching, School Life, Bullying, Conflict Resolution, Friendship.
(Age: 7-9) Highly recommended. Lulu Bell is a fun-loving, friendly eight-year-old girl with honey-blonde plaits. Her family lives next door to her dad Dr. Bell's vet hospital. Her Mum is an artist, her six year old sister Rosie wears angel wings and sparkly shoes and her three year old brother Gus loves to wear his superhero Bug Boy suit. Of course they have a large menagerie of animals, two dogs called Asha and Jessie, two ginger cats called Pickles and Pepper, some ducklings, and a rabbit. Lulu Bell and her family were introduced in Lulu Bell and the Birthday Unicorn where the family has trouble at Rosie's sixth birthday with a runaway pony. In Lulu Bell and the Fairy Penguin, the family is going for a swim when a runaway dog chases a little penguin down the beach and Lulu involved in the rescue.
The adventures continue in Lulu Bell and the Cubby Fort with her family spending an exciting Easter holiday at her Uncle's farm with lots of their cousins. They enjoy the freedom of the farm, building and setting up a cubby fort in the bush, swimming in the creek, riding horses and rescuing a calf stuck in the mud. Campfires and sleeping in tents add to the holiday excitement.
Lulu Bell and the Moon Dragon is another well written story celebrating the Vietnamese Lunar Festival with the Lulu's friends and family, making costumes, lanterns and moon cakes. Belinda Murrell portrays school life vividly from a class excursion to watching the whales migrating, to dealing with bullying and sharing cultural diversity.
This series is a great class read-aloud and I would highly recommend them for readers from 7-9 years. The quirky family are very relatable and funny. Serena Geddes black and white sketches support the narrative and add an exciting emotional quality to the novels.
Rhyllis Bignell

Alfie's search for destiny by David Hardy

cover image

Magabala Books, 2013. ISBN 1 92114241 5
(Age: 4+) Picture book. Aboriginal themes. Survival. Family. In searching for his destiny, Alfie wanders away from home, looking under rocks, and into the sky, looking behind trees. He runs from the croc rearing up beneath the river, and escapes from the snake hanging down from the tree, until he finds a group of animals. He asks them what his destiny is, but they are unable to answer. Eventually the boy returns home and hearing the voices of his mum and dad, realises that his life is with them, his destiny is at home.
In rhyming text, the tale of Alfie searching all the while for his destiny, and finally realising his place is at home, represents us all in our search for the question about the meaning of life and why we are here. The story reflects the need of all children to be given space but within the context of a warm loving, family.
The background illustrations show the range of territory that Alfie wanders over, exposing the Northern Australian environment to another audience, and Hardy's time spent in the studios of Walt Disney clearly has influenced his work. A touch of Manga will also appeal to the younger readers, eager to pick up a book which exemplifies the stability and base that a loving family offers all children.
Fran Knight

Star cursed by Jessica Spotswood

cover image

Penguin, 2013. ISBN 9780141342139. 367p.
Star Cursed is the sequel to Born Wicked, making it the second volume of the Cahill Witch Chronicles. Jessica Spotswood's alternate history of New England, USA, chronicles the secret society of witches. We follow Cate's recruitment to the big city convent school, but the religious order is a front for the 'Sisterhood' of witches in the same manner that 'Hogwarts' is really a school for English witches and wizards.
Cate could be the witch prophesied to lead the Sisterhood next when Sister Cora passes away. Or is it one of her sisters - Maura or Tess? When all sisters are forced to join the Sisterhood, Maura plots to overthrow Cate as the favourite candidate.
The puritan society of New England is a dangerous place for these witches who are capable of illusions, erasing minds and healing. These skills cannot be used haphazardly without arousing suspicion because the brotherhood is arresting and torturing any innocent woman suspected of witchcraft or visions.
Finn is still Cate's romantic interest and he has joined the Brotherhood. Will he understand why she ran away to the convent instead of accepting his marriage proposal?
Maura's alliances and attacks threaten to incite the Brotherhood to persecute witches like never before, whereas Cate and Tess prefer less risky resistance and rescue operations. The next instalment should see the conflict resolved and a true leader emerge.
Deb Robins

Spy for the Queen of Scots by Theresa Breslin

cover image

Corgi, 2013. ISBN: 9780552560757.
Highly recommended. Award winning author Theresa Breslin provides insight into the tragic life of history's obscure Scottish regent Mary Stuart who faced sexism and religious discrimination from all those of her age whilst she struggled to unite a warring nation.
Born into royalty and crowned as a baby, Mary Stuart Queen of Scots is surrounded by agents of deceit throughout her life, never knowing quite who to trust, however there is one person who has always remained loyal, Jenny. Childhood friends who were nursed together in France away from their Scottish homeland, Jenny is the confidant and friend that Mary needs throughout the persecution she faces on her return to her Scottish homeland after the murder of her first husband, King Francis. While Mary relies upon her friend the Lady Ginette, Jenny in turn relies upon her protector Sir Duncan Alexander, a man who she has always loved, although surrounded by the deceit and ill-intent towards her queen Jenny distrusts the man who always seems to be in the right place at the right time. In her role as spy for the Queen of Scots, her suspicions drive a wedge between the two.
I would highly recommend this novel to all lovers of historic fiction, the simple presentation of the complex dramas of 1500's monarch life is easy to understand and provides for a very exciting read. Sophisticated and engaging, this novel is a sure representation of great historic fiction. It brings the drama of court life, the stress of political problems and the treachery of nobles and lords of old. This novel has everything any good novel should, a dramatic plot filled with subterfuge, believable characters and of course a brilliant writer.
Kayla Gaskell (Student)