Reviews

Max by Marc Martin

cover image

Penguin, 2014. ISBN 9780670077434.
Max and Bob are great mates. They live by the sea and during the day, Max keeps Bob company in his fish and chip shop (Max loves both fish and chips so it's a perfect partnership) and in the evening they go fishing together.
How can that scenario make for a most enchanting story that kept 9 and 10 year-olds engaged for over an hour and wanting more?
Well, Max is a seagull, who's a little bit cheeky and a little bit mischievous, and this is the story of a friendship that endures even after Bob has to close his shop because of a lack of business. When Max comes to the shop one morning, Bob has gone, and even though he waits and waits and waits, his friend does not return. Without Bob there is no attraction for Max and so he decides to leave - but as he flies high over the city looking for another home he smells a familiar smell . . .
Marc Martin won the 2013 Crichton Award for Australia's best new illustrator and the illustrations for 'Max' add so much to its message and its charm. Using a variety of techniques, vignettes and full-page spreads, (the class laughed out loud at Max sitting on top of the No Seagulls sign) they are rich and exquisite, providing so many more layers to the story than just the text alone. For example, while there is no written explanation for the downturn in business, the picture of cranes soaring high above the funfair, the main drawcard of the area, tells its own story and opened up a discussion about the impact of tourism on local economies (particularly pertinent where I live). Later, the reason for the dismantling for the funfair is also evident and sparked a debate about 'you can't stop progress'. What seems like a simple tale for a preschooler to enjoy is so much more.
As well as an enthusiastic discussion that ranged from personal stories of feeding seagulls hot chips, recalling other seagull stories we've read such as The Lighthouse Keeper's Lunch and Samantha Seagull's Sandals to the importance of the snow-oriented industry on our region, to country versus city living, the students also embraced the task of imagining what Max would have seen as he flew over our town and then drawing a birds-eye view map of it. Suddenly that concept made sense to them! What started as a story to share because I loved it became a rich and rewarding experience for all of us that went far beyond the focus and timeframe I'd allocated. But when you're on a good thing . . .
Barbara Braxton

Prisoner of night and fog by Anne Blankman

cover image

Headline, 2014. ISBN 9781472207821.
In just a few hundred pages, Anne Blankman has truly unravelled a unique story which is both compelling and sympathetic. With fresh and original characters, she manages to revive a piece of history with an engrossing original storyline intertwined with true events. From the very beginning, Anne delivers a beautifully crafted masterpiece and seduces readers to fall in love with every character, good or bad. It's a coming of age story that's prominent for its historic settings and disarming plotline which stimulates the main character's growth.
The book takes place in Munich 1931, a few years prior to Hitler's utmost height of power. The National Socialist Party holds Munich in their tight hands and Hitler is hypnotizing his audiences with patriotism. After the chilling event of her father's death, seventeen year old Gretchen Muller dwells in the shadow of her Uncle Dolf. Fallen victim to Hitler's patriotic deceit, she disarms the lies of her father's death bit by bit and hunts for the truth. With ploys and ferocity brandished at the ready, Gretchen joins forces with quick-witted Jew reporter, Daniel Cohen much to the utter dislike of her family.
As each chapter begins, Anne Blankman grants the reader lyrical storylines entangled with disbelieving plot twists and world building backgrounds. She presents us with a tale like no other and charmingly bestows us with characters we love to hate or we just simply adore.
An additional few pages of the Author's Note provides keen readers with an insight to Anne Blankman's fictional and non-fictional characters with bonus content on Gretchen's Munich. Teaching this novel to a class will bestow them an alternative view on Munich in 1931 and those who allied themselves with Adolf Hitler. The book can be well compared with The Book Thief written by Markus Zusak as they both offer a young and unpredictable girl's view on this exclusive part of history.
Samantha May (Student)

Mary's Australia: How Mary McKillop changed Australia by Pamela Freeman

cover image

Black Dog Books, 2014. ISBN 9781922077905.
(Age: 9+) The lifespan of Mary McKillop coincided with a period of transformation in the Australian colonies. Pamela Freeman has asked how Australia changed during that time and to what extent the subject of her book contributed to that change.
The result is two narratives in one - the story of colonies that united to form one nation, and the story of a woman with a passion for teaching, who was determined to ensure that children from poor families had access to education. Readers can follow Mary's life story alongside the events of her era. The inclusive and wide-ranging depiction of colonial society provides details of daily life, as well as accounts of the social, political and economic upheavals that helped to shape Mary's experiences. The author's balanced and thoughtful approach to the writing of history ensures that readers will learn much from her brief overviews of the issues that emerged during Australia's development. Her focus on the lives of children and the limited opportunities available to underprivileged people, explains not only the social issues that motivated a young governess to found a teaching order, but also the significance of Mary McKillop's educational reforms.
Photographs, cartoons and illustrations on every page provide further insights into colonial life. They are generously sized and clearly captioned. The use of double columns and a small font are common in history books but younger readers may find this format challenging. Population statistics, an index and a limited glossary are useful.
Mary's Australia will meet the needs of readers who want to know only about Mary McKillop's life and achievements. However, Pamela Freeman has succeeded in presenting her biography as part of a larger canvas - the growth, discoveries, setbacks and social reforms of an extraordinary era in Australian history.
Elizabeth Bor

I am Cow, Hear me Moo! by Jill Esbaum and Gus Gordon

cover image

Viking, 2014. ISBN: 9780670077106.
For early readers 4 years and up. I can practically guarantee that every teacher has had, at some point, a Nadine in their class. Nadine is very talented, very brave and very special cow - well, in her own opinion which is, after all, the only one that really counts.With some rollicking rhyming Nadine impresses her friends with her daring tour through the scary woods. Friends being suitably awed, they depart - night falls and Nadine is left on her own in a spooky gloomy cave. Suddenly her bravado evaporates and she must conquer her sudden lapse of over-confidence.
As always, Gus Gordon's illustrations are absolutely delightful and make this picture book a must have. Young children will enjoy the story and rhythm and no doubt will recognise the Nadine in their midst.
Read Kids' Book Review's interview with Gus here.
This parable would be a very useful discussion starter for smaller people - what is bravery? Is it important how others perceive us? Is it important how we see ourselves? Having confidence is a wonderful thing and there would be some small people who would truly benefit from recognising that they have that confidence in themselves.
Sue Warren

Gigantosaurus by Jonny Duddle

cover image

Scholastic, 2014. ISBN 9781742761015.
(Age: 5+) Fantasy, Picture book, Humour. The intricate illustrations will enthrall those readers who love books about dinosaurs and fantastical inventions as the dinosaur parents warn their offspring about the Gigantosurus.
They must be wary of this gigantic creature with sharp teeth and sharp eyes, on the lookout for small creatures as a snack.
Bonehead tells his friends, Tiny, Bill and Fin to stay where they are while he climbs an anthill to see if the huge dinosaur is coming. Three times he calls out that it is coming, and his three friends run and hide, and each time he tells them he is just testing them. When the Gigantosuaurs does come he is caught unawares and is almost eaten.
This is a retelling of The Boy who cried wolf in a different guise and will entreat all those who read it. The information about the various dinosaurs is given in the back of the book, along with information about Gigantosaurus, which will intrigue dinosaur followers. The luscious illustrations burst with life and mayhem and humour, as many will stop to seek out the range of things in the undergrowth.
Fran Knight

Diary of a Track and Field Titan by Shamini Flint

cover image

Allen & Unwin, 2014. ISBN: 9781743317297.
(Ages: 7 to 11) Highly recommended. Marcus Atkinson returns in another instalment of the Diary of a . . . series. Marcus knows the only things he is good at are maths and computer games, but his dad is convinced that there is a sport out there for Marcus, they just haven't found the right one yet. After trying soccer, cricket, rugby and taekwondo, his dad wants him to try track and field. Thinking this through, Marcus decides he has had a lot of practice running away from bullies, and he is good at throwing things (like rubbish and tantrums!), so maybe track and field won't be so bad after all. The usual hilarity ensues, with familiar themes and in-jokes sure to please fans of the series.
Shamini Flint uses the diary technique and numerous cartoon illustrations to encourage reluctant readers to continue. The sports theme always resonates with children, and whether they love sports or are more like Marcus himself, they will find it easy to identify with the characters and situations in this book. Not only will kids love reading about Marcus' misadventures, they will also learn a lot about sport! As with all the titles in the series, Diary of a Track and Field Titan is a light and entertaining read.
Donella Reed

Every word by Ellie Marney

cover image

Every series, bk. 2. Allen & Unwin, 2014. ISBN 9781743316511.
(Age: 15+) Highly recommended. Mystery. James Mycroft has gone to London without saying a word to Rachel Watts, who worked with him to solve the mystery of the murder in Every breath, the first in the Every series. Rachel is not happy especially when she finds out that James will be investigating a car accident, very similar to the one in which his parents had died many years before. She knows that he will need her support, so using her reward money, she hops on a plane and flies to London, where the couple immediately find themselves surrounded by danger as they investigate the accident and the theft of a priceless copy of Shakespeare's first folio.
Readers will enjoy the vivid descriptions of the trip to London, the crime scenes and the grisly police procedures and will be holding their breath during the intrepid Rachel's adventure with a gang determined to find out where the folio has been stashed.
Told from the point of view of Rachel, the reader gets a really good feeling for the type of person that she is, starting from the opening scenes where she is starring as an intrepid roller skater, to the caring girlfriend who knows that Mycroft will need her support in London, facing the memories of the death of his parents. She is brave and intelligent and together the pair use their considerable brain power to work out the mystery. Their romance has some steamy moments as well, but never overwhelms the mystery and action.
Every word is certainly not a 'cosy' mystery but rather a chilling thriller. There is violence and gore and the book is not for the faint hearted. The plot in this book is brought to a satisfying conclusion, and once the pair are back in Australia, the seeds for the next book are planted so that the reader is eager to read the final outcome.
Pat Pledger

The way to the zoo by John Burningham

cover image

Walker Books, 2014 ISBN 9781406348408.
(Age: 4+) Highly recommended. Picture book, Imagination, Animals, Zoos, Sleeping. Born in 1936, Burningham has thrilled his young audiences with imaginative stories and illustrations for over fifty years. The way to the zoo brings a fresh approach to going to bed as the young girl Sylvie, spies a door in her bedroom wall that she has not seen before. Going through it leads to another door, and beyond that the zoo. Here all the animals are intrigued and she takes a little bear back to her bedroom with her. He sleeps the night in her bed and in the morning she takes him back to the zoo, remembering to close the door to her bedroom. The following night she brings another bear back to her bedroom, the following night, three penguins, and then a tiger and her cub. After than a flock of birds come in, but when a larger animal, an elephant wants to come in, it cannot fit. But baby rhino can and the next morning she sleeps in and rushes to get the rhino back to the zoo, forgetting to close the door before leaving for school. Catastrophe happens, and Mum's words when she comes home make a laugh out loud comment on the whole story.
This imaginative tale will be a delight to read to children before bedtime, or in a class where animals and bedtime is under discussion, or simply to enjoy a lovely story well told, with illustrations that cause mirth and recognition. The pictures of the animals in bed with Sylvie are charming, and I loved the image of the rhino sleeping on the floor with its legs crossed, and the flurry of mischievious animals in mum's lounge room.
Burningham's mix of subtle humour, imagination and the everyday make this book most endearing to all who read it.
Fran Knight

Meet Douglas Mawson by Mike Dumbleton

cover image

Ill. by Snip Green. Random House, 2014. ISBN 9780857981950.
(Age: 5+) Recommended. Picture book, Explorers, Mawson. A hardcover picture book in the series, Meet ... will fill a niche in primary schools where explorers and great Australians are an accepted part of the curriculum. Others in this series include books about Ned Kelly and Mary McKillop. Each is of necessity, brief, giving an account of the person's life and achievements in sparse prose, highlighting only a few events.
With Mawson, the focus is on the first Australian Expedition to Antarctica, in 1911. With Mawson as its leader, the expedition sorely tested those who went, and Dumbleton's pared down words combined with the breathtaking illustrations, give an amazing account of the privations these men underwent.
His determination to see the continent, mapping it, taking measurements and geological observations in an attempt to understand the place and how it evolved was paramount, but when Ninnis and his sled plunged down a ravine taking most of their food with him, Mawson and the other remaining team member, Mertz were five hundred kilometres from their base.
The story of how Mawson survived is one of the great feats of history and will amaze younger readers.
The wallpaper like images across the pages, underscore the freezing nature of the environment, giving the reader the feeling of cold and ice, building the feeling of dread as Mawson attempts to get back to the base.
So fascinating is this brief taste, that students will feel impelled to look further to find out more about this man, one of Australia's heroes.
Fran Knight

Fizzlebert Stump - The boy who cried Fish by A.F. Harrold

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2014. ISBN 9781408842461.
(Ages: 7 to 12) Recommended. Fizzlebert Stump lives in a circus where he has an act involving sticking his head in the mouth of a very old lion. His best friend Wystan the Bearded Boy does an act with a sealion called Fish. One day Fish goes missing, and the boys believe he has been stolen to perform in the aquarium near the beach. When they break into the aquarium though, they encounter another mystery - all the fish keep disappearing. Through their adventures we meet a range of interesting characters, from the piratical owner of the aquarium Admiral Spratt-Haddock, to an overly-friendly crocodile. The boys need to explore the aquarium and their own circus family to discover that all is not what it seems, and that sometimes people will to to extreme lengths to appear something they are not.
This is the third title in the Fizzlebert Stump series, and again A.F. Harrold has created a world of eccentricity, fantastical characters, mystery, and all the nonsensical ramblings which middle primary school children love. The way he plays with words and incorporates himself as the self-deprecating author will have children in fits of laughter and wanting to re-read this over and over. Even the entertaining little doodles and illustrations by Sarah Horne keep you turning the pages to see what the characters will get up to next. A very enjoyable and light-hearted book.
Donella Reed

Athlete vs. Mathlete - Double dribble by W.C. Mack

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2013. ISBN 9781599909387.
(Ages: 9-12) Seventh-grade twins Russ and Owen are very different from each other, in looks and personalities. While Owen is a natural at sports, Russ feels more at home with numbers. They don't even look alike. Finally they discover something in common, and Russ joins the basketball team. A new set of problems arise though in the form of identical twins Mitch and Marcus. These new boys are all-rounders, with a flair for sports and academia, leaving both Russ and Owen feeling jealous and insecure. After and unfortunate accident however, they realise that Mitch and Marcus only succeed when working as a team. Russ and Owen must decide whether to use this to their advantage to reclaim their place in the team.
As with the original Athlete vs. Mathlete book, this has alternating chapters in the voices of the two boys. Much of the content of Owen's chapters centres around the action on the basketball court, which may become a bit tedious for readers not interested in the sport. Kids who do enjoy sports however will be able to relate to Owen's passion, disappointment and insecurities as he faces the possibility of being 'benched.' The boys face a moral dilemma which is resolved a bit too quickly, but without becoming preachy and off-putting. Conflicts are also resolved a little too easily to ring true to many readers. In general, this title will be a welcome refuge for students wanting to focus on sport fiction.
Donella Reed

Figaro and Rumba and the Crocodile Cafe by Anna Fienberg

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2014. ISBN 9781743314883.
(Ages: 6 to 9) Recommended. The Crocodile Cafe is the first title in a new series by Anna Fienberg (of the Tashi books), based around two very likeable characters Figaro and Rumba. Figaro is a energetic, happy-go-lucky dog who lives with his best friend Rumba, a very conscientious and somewhat melancholy Cuban cat. Rumba misses his home in Cuba, and channels his energy into a rigorous cleaning routine. Figaro on the other hand would rather play and explore, and catch the Very Fast Train. Rumba agrees they can go on the train after they have mopped the floor and cleaned the windows. After a few interruptions they finally catch the train, and meet a Cuban conga0playing crocodile. They learn some important lessons about friendship and trust, and we get to meet some other interesting characters who will appear in future titles.
Stephen Michael King's illustrations enhance the story beautifully capturing the quirky, bohemian, and suaveness of the various characters. Every page has a small colour illustration, with a few full-page pictures along the way, making it a perfect book for readers moving from picture books to novels. A lovely introduction to what is sure to become a favourite new series among primary students.
Donella Reed

Crooked Leg Road by Jennifer Walsh

cover image

Allen & Unwin, 2014. ISBN: 9781743316931
(Age: 10-12) Highly recommended. Both boys and girls who enjoy mystery/adventure stories will love this new book from Jennifer Walsh. Somewhat like a contemporary, fast-paced Famous Five but much edgier - a group of friends from Balmain become embroiled in a dangerous game of political intrigue and financial misappropriations. David, Martin, Kitty and Andrea are both friends and schoolmates, each with their own interests and strengths, who combine well as a group hanging together in the regular sense. When David mysteriously disappears, feared kidnapped, his friends pool their combined observations and knowledge with some startling results.
Parallel to this plot are timely ideas such as multiculturalism, ethics in positions of power, judgemental behaviour, tolerance and acceptance and friendships. New girl, Samantha, who is despised in general, because of her 'posh' background and ineffectual attempts to impress, and mysterious new boy, Skender, technically a 'boat person' and whose family comes under suspicion by the sleuthing teens, add a depth to the plot that leads the reader to examine initial perceptions of 'outsiders'.
Thoroughly engaging and completely compulsive reading (I read it in one sitting) - this is a real page turner with very plausible plot, characterisations and complications/resolutions.
Highly recommended for readers 10 and up, put this one on the shopping list for any of those readers who are looking for an exciting read.
Watch the trailer.
Visit the author's website .
Jennifer Walsh writes children's books under this name and adult books under Jennifer Spence (she is married to Bruce Spence, the actor) and lives in Balmain, Sydney. Her previous book The tunnels of Tarcoola featured the abandoned coal mines under that suburb and her new book Crooked Leg Road is also set in this lively and historic area.
Sue Warren

The Caller by Juliet Marillier

cover image

Shadowfell series, bk 3. Pan Macmillan, 2014. ISBN 9781742612454.
(Age 13+) Highly recommended. Fantasy. Only when Neryn has been trained by all four of the Guardians will she be ready to play her part as a Caller and help the rebels to topple the evil King Keldec. She seeks out the mysterious White Lady but she is not what Neryn expected and is fast facing extinction. Neryn pushes on, knowing that Flint is in mortal danger of being exposed as a traitor to the King, who has found a Caller of his own, one who is grabbing hold of the minds of the Good Folk of the Kingdom.
Marillier is one of my favourite fantasy authors, whose books I always look forward to reading. It has been a pleasure to read this beautifully written fantasy series, and to follow the growth of Neryn as she progresses from a shy girl to a leader who is prepared to take risks for what she believes in. Not only do her skills develop as she learns from the Guardians, but her self-confidence and ethic certainly also grow.
Marillier's ability to write wonderful fantasy romances is on display in this series. The romance between Flint and Neryn is bittersweet, each knowing that the fate of the Kingdom is more important than being together, and even though they don't spend much time together, their feelings for each other are beautifully described. Flint is such a courageous young man, and as a reader I had to hold my breath as he faced possible betrayal by his team and the King's Caller.
There is plenty of action as Neryn travels across the country to find the White Lady and then finally faces the King and his Caller. Readers who enjoy the quest in fantasy will be satisfied by the conclusion of this series as Marillier wraps up the story in a satisfying way.
The Shadowfell series was written for young adults who are sure to enjoy the well written prose, wonderful setting, and memorable characters. They could then move onto Marillier's Sevenwaters series or The Bridei chronicles written for adults, equally as powerful and memorable.
Pat Pledger

Hard nuts of history series by Tracey Turner

cover image

Ill. Jamie Lenman. A&C Black, 2014.
Warriors: Who's who in hard nut history. ISBN 9781472905642.
Ancient Egypt: Who's who in hard nut history. ISBN 9781472905635.
(Age: 7+) Recommended. Humour, Easy reads, History. Two more in this series of books which showcase some of the memorable people in history who many young people may have heard mentioned, but known anything about, are offered here to delight, inform and entertain. In short, snappy and funny pages, an outline of their lives is given which will intrigue younger readers.
People covered in Warriors, for example, include the Duke of Wellington, Julius Caesar, Geronimo, the Trung sisters, Joan of Arc, Tomyris and Napoleon. Each is given a double page spread about their life and its impact and why they are remembered. Some are well know, others not so well known, there is a range of women and men and a world view is taken by the author.
At the back is a most useful index and glossary, while the quiz will ensure some students will have a great time asking questions of others. A time line completes the information given to this most interesting little book. I longed for a world map, so make sure you have one handy.
Similarly in Ancient Egypt, double pages are devoted to famous people, Cleopatra, Ptolemy, Tutmose, Nefertiti and so on, as well as sites, the River Nile, the Pyramids and the Valley of the Kings, while double pages are also devoted to the Gods and the embalming process. All is designed to be informative and fun, with an emphasis on gaining information quickly and easily. A good index and glossary are at the back with a quiz and timeline, ensuring students will have fun with these two new books in this series.
Fran Knight