Reviews

The war of the four isles by Andrew McGahan

cover image

Ship Kings series, Book 3. Allen and Unwin, 2014. ISBN 9781760291693
(Age: Junior secondary) Young readers have a treat in store when award winning author, Andrew McGahan, turns his hand to adolescent fiction. It is a pleasure to share his skill with words, which makes his young Admiral, Dow Amber, so convincing and appealing, and the many twists and turns of fortune so intriguing.
In this episode of the Ship Kings saga, the legend of his bravery grows as he and his colleagues face the anger of the sea and the monsters of the deep.
Together, they face the dangers of battle and most of all they face the danger of betrayal. With differing factions within the two opposing enemies, the Ship Kings and the Twin Islanders, who can be trusted? It is hard to unravel the truth.
After visiting the legendary home of the Twin Islanders, Amber devises a plan to rescue Nell and the other leaders who stood against the dominance of the Ship Kings. Amber is successful but what has he achieved? Have innocent people died because of his actions?
When Amber journeys to New Island to reunite with his family, he discovers he is hated for supposedly abandoning them and his people. After the horror he discovers there, he rejoins the battle between the two opposing powers with new purpose, his heart set on revenge.
Those who love a fast paced adventure will enjoy this novel and look forward to the fourth episode to come.
Thelma Harvey

Eve and Elly by Mike Dumbleton

cover image

Ill. by Laura Wood. Random House, 2016. ISBN 9780857988515
(Age: 3+) Recommended. Loss. Toys. Family. Eve simply loves her pet stuffed elephant, Elly. She takes him with her wherever she goes, clutching him tightly under her arm. When they go on holiday, Elly goes too, and sits on the beach with Eve as she builds a sandcastle. On their return, Eve feels ill and Mum cuddles her until she falls asleep, but the worst thing has happened, Elly has fallen from the car unnoticed.
At home Eve searches everywhere for her elephant, all through the house and car and in the garden. She is inconsolable and rejects every other toy offered by her caring parents. But Dad has an idea and shortly after a parcel arrives in the post. Eve is thrilled but a little taken aback at the size of Elly until Dad explains Elly's amazing journey to return home.
This is a wonderful story to read aloud, brimming with the love that surrounds the child and her love for her toy. The loss of the toy will be recognised by all readers and they will be on edge as the tale unfolds, bringing the child and her toy back together with a very cute twist. The story Dad tells is full of humour and adventure as the elephant finds his way back home.
The illustrations reflect the loving family and the place held by the toy elephant. I love the parcel cover, and the cheeky look on Elly's face throughout the book. This book will have instant appeal to younger children, and initiate discussions about the place their toys hold in the family and what they do when something is lost. Fran Knight

MARTians by Blythe Woolston

cover image

Walker Books, 2016. ISBN 9781406341393
(Age: 14+) Recommended. Consumerism. Dystopian fiction. Zoe Zindleman has been abandoned by her mother and the government has shut down her school. She is given the opportunity to start work at ALLMART, where 'your smile is the AllMART welcome mat'. Her house is going to be repossessed and when she meet MORTimmer, he warns her that it is not a smart idea to live in ALLMART's dormitories. Trusting him, she moves into the Warren, a deserted shopping centre where a laundromat becomes her home, shared with the little boy 5er and Timmer. Then her ordeal as an employee of ALLMART begins as she learns the ins and outs of selling in a big store.
This is a grim but totally engrossing story about consumerism gone wild told in the heart wrenching voice of Zoe, an intelligent girl. As her training progresses she realises that there is no future for her as she will always be in debt to AllMART, who charge her enormous prices for uniforms and food. As Zoe battles her way through learning about how to sell, the reader will find many familiar descriptions of different store departments and how they are set up. Equally bleak are the stories of abandoned children, whose parents have left them behind, and the stories of repossessed houses that are pulled apart for their metal, and a government that has abandoned everyone.
However there is one small glimpse of hope that Timmer gives: Look for the ones who need help and spread the good around.
This was an exceptionally thought provoking book. References were made to Ray Bradbury's The Martian Chronicles but don't detract for those who haven't read it, and will make them want to pick it up.
This would make an ideal literature circle book or class novel with the themes of consumerism gone wild, governments who cannot help people whose homes are repossessed, unemployment, and abandoned children making for great discussion points for their relevance for today's society.
Pat Pledger

Marmaduke the very popular dragon by Rachel Valentine

cover image

Ill. by Ed Eaves. Bloomsbury, 2016. ISBN 9781408862667
(Age: 4+) Recommended. Friendship, Dragons, Medieval times. A sequel to Marmaduke the very different dragon (2014), this one has friendship as its core theme, as Meg and Marmaduke again do everything together. The two are inseparable, that is until one of the princesses, locked away in her tower asks Marmaduke if they can play together. So popular is this new experience, all the princesses join them, and the other dragons join in and eventually the princes too. Meg is happy that Marmaduke has built up a large friendship group, and all play together well. Meg reminds Marmaduke of the forthcoming Whizz Cone Competition knowing that the two of them will easily win the trophy. She watches the preparations uneasily wondering where Marmaduke has got to, and eventually goes searching for him. He is not in any of the usual places so she goes over the hill and there she hears Marmaduke and Prince Bertie making arrangements to compete for the trophy. She is distraught and when the day comes, sits outside the arena listening to the accolades received by the victorious Marmaduke and Prince Bertie. But Marmaduke suddenly remembers Meg, and goes off to search for her. He hears sobbing and flies down to fold her in his wings, apologising for being such a bad friend. They both realise that there is more to being a friend than meets the eye.
Young children will love the dragon theme, and be intrigued with the sparkly wings, and more importantly come to see that being a friend also involves some responsibilities. Young children will eagerly discuss their own friendship groups and how they work out their differences.
Fran Knight

The words in my hand by Guinevere Glasfurd

cover image

Two Roads, 2016. ISBN 9781473617865
(Age: 16+) Highly recommended for mature readers. Themes: Philosophy; Education of women; Rene Descartes; Relationships. Weaving together the story of Rene Descartes with the young maid with whom he has a relationship, the reader gets an insight into the way the world has changed on so many fronts. Descartes was a French philosopher, scientist and writer whose thinking and words were germinal in beginning a transformation in the way the world was understood. This was a dangerous occupation as it upset the status quo. This very well crafted first novel by Glasfurd, enables us to see Descartes life through the eyes of the young maid, Helena Jans Von Strom, that he meets while lodging in the Dutch house where she works for an English Bookseller. She is portrayed as an intelligent woman trapped in her role because of her gender and the intransigence of her circumstances as a maid. From the perspective of the 21st Century reader, this level of discrimination seems so unfair and we mourn with her as she attempts to self-educate herself and to be respected and to be acknowledged as a woman of worth in the highly patriarchal and socially discriminative era of the 1600's world. She becomes Descartes' love interest and the mother of his child and yet her position needs to remain hidden to protect reputations and to enable her to fit into the society of the day. Helena's love of learning and her exploration of ideas live in parallel to the philosophical world of Descartes. We see how the power of paper and the words that it can carry enters the world of the young woman, and yet the words in her hands remain constrained by her status. Her sorrows and powerlessness are potent for the reader.
This book is not unlike The Girl with the Pearl Earring in portraying a piece of Dutch history in a fictional way albeit a century earlier. It will be enjoyed by Book Club readers who will enjoy the insight into the world of the philosopher who challenges the world in which he lives as well as comparing the role of women from the past. (It does also portray the illicit relationship in detail and there is a violent incident that is quite distressing, so readers need to have some maturity.)
Carolyn Hull

Gary by Leila Rudge

cover image

Walker Books, 2016. ISBN 9781925081695
(Age: 3+) Highly recommended. Birds. Adventure. Maps. Difference. Gary the pigeon cannot fly, so sits at home when the others are taken in the basket to a place far away to compete in a pigeon race and return home. Gary loves hearing their stories and adds their mementos to his scrapbook. This includes maps and tickets, postcards and timetables. He adroitly uses a roll of sticky tape with his beak to stick each of the items into his scrapbook, and listens intently at night as they recount their adventures, adding their stories to his collection.
But one night Gary leans a little too far, tumbling into the basket with his scrapbook. Next day the basket is taken away with the other pigeons for their race home. Finding himself a long way from home is a challenge for Gary because he cannot fly and so find his own way home. But he has his scrapbook, and opening it he is able to chart his way using other methods of travel.
The wonderful pictures tell the story of Gary and his cohort, dressed in their finery for the big race, with the plain Gary looking on. His scrapbook is wonderful, with little drawings of the mementoes that he keeps tucked away. Kids will love looking at these and working out where the pigeons may have collected them from, and then later how Gary uses them to get back home. His adventure will open up all sorts of avenues for classes to discuss maps and mapping, directories, finding your way around your area and so on. As part of the Geography focus this book will be well used, but it is also about someone taking the bull by the horns, about difference and solving a problem, so having their own neat adventure.
The illustrations are wonderful, the pages full of pigeons as they strut around in their cages, the delightful scrapbook used as the endpapers as well, the flowing tumble of Gary into the pigeon basket, Gary in the city using public transport. Each is very funny and shows Gary off to the reader, as he uses his difference to solve his problem. What a treat to reinforce the difference in us all, that everyone has their own characteristics, that one trait is not superior to another.
This will be one of those books in the library where children will cluster around to hear it read out loud, thinking about how Gary can possibly get home, or dreaming of their own big adventure.
Fran Knight

Horses: Fun facts and amazing stories by Dianne Bates

cover image

Ill. by Sophie Scahill. Awesome animals 3. Big Sky Publishing, 2016. ISBN 9781925275858
(Age: 8+) Horses. Horsemanship. Horses: Fun facts and amazing stories is a compendium and a celebration of all things horse! Dianne Bates has sourced an amazing array of horse facts, stories, daring rescues, working horses, horses in movies and television and their historical origins. Colourful photographs of the Horse Shepherd / Equine Sanctuary animals highlight the importance of rescuing these animals. Playful horse caricatures drawn by Sophie Scahill add humour to this factual book - there's a horse king perched on a throne and a horse relaxing with his glasses perched on the end of his nose reading a horse story.
These brave animals have led soldiers into battle, supported Spanish conquistadors settling in new lands and moved the Barnum and Bailey Circus across North America. In the early 1900s there were 750 horses used to haul the carriages and animal cages, to help raise the big top and to perform acts. Walers were the horses used by the Australian light horseman in World War 1 to mobilise the cavalry into battle.
Smallest, tallest, biggest, fastest, and oldest horses, there's an array of horse records to pique the interest of many animal fans. Old Billy, an English barge horse, lived until he was 62 years old.
The text is set out in easy to read boxes, some with colourful backgrounds, horse jokes and horse poems - nursery rhymes are also included. Horses: Fun facts and amazing stories is suitable for the capable reader who enjoys reading factual information.
Rhyllis Bignell

The turners by Mick Elliott

cover image

Lothian; 2015. ISBN 9780734416629
(Age: Junior secondary) Mick Elliott, award winning Nickelodeon producer, takes us on a rollicking ride into a fantastic world of weirdness.
Leo Lennox, a typical thirteen year old, sits in the school library, admiring his attractive classmate, Lily. Suddenly, life changes for ever as he turns into a komodo dragon, a very hungry one, and his classmates scatter. Leo discovers the family secret: at night, his father and his sister turn in to various animals with very little warning. Leo is different in that he turns during the day as well.
His father, still mourning the loss of his wife, Leo's mother, seeks help dealing with Leo's predicament. When he fails to return, Leo and his sister must try to find him. Leo inadvertently impacts upon his sister in his efforts to control his changes and these are very funny. As they face one dangerous episode after another, they learn to trust and respect each other.
Life as a turner all seems reasonably entertaining until Leo and his sister, Abbie, encounter their long lost relative, a revengeful, cruel scientist who hates turners and who has created a gruesome and repugnant world. The weirdness factor rises as does the pace of the story as the family faces a truly horrific death.
This is the first book in a planned trilogy. I hope Elliott will focus more on the humour and tone down the gore. I think the ghastly death of the villains in the story will be distressing to sensitive students.
Thelma Harvey

Taking turns by Lisa Kerr

cover image

Cheeky Monkey manners. The Five Mile Press, 2016. ISBN 9781760402662
(Ages: 2-5) Recommended. This is another in the Cheeky Monkey manners series (Please, Thank you, Sorry, Excuse me, Listening) and one of many in the Cheeky Monkey series. The small board book format is suited to preschool and early childhood and is a fun way to springboard discussions about manners - what they are, and when to use them. In this title, Cheeky Monkey hasn't learned how to take turns yet. When he has his friends over to play and they ask to have a turn of his bubble toy, it is lucky his mother is there to step in. She gives him a special timer for knowing when to swap over. Later on, she helps again, giving Cheeky Monkey a painted pebble to help the friends take turns talking and listening. The colourful illustrations are large without great detail; Cheeky Monkey is the main element on each page with a secondary focus on the other animals and their facial expressions. There are, however, many additional small animals (frogs, birds, mice, butterflies, etc.) which will enable younger children to retain focus, give them things to search for and foster discussions about the illustrations.
This book is great because it doesn't just talk about the importance of taking turns; it shows how much fun the animals all have have when they take turns, gives simple strategies that children can use for taking turns and encourages children to think about what it is like for the other animals when they don't get a turn. Social skills books such as these can often be overly didactic, but this one is understanding of children and of how hard it is to take turns. It lets the child know that it is okay to have trouble taking turns sometimes, but gives strategies for improving. The text manages successfully to tell an engaging story, get a message across and remain concise. With only five double-page spreads this book will keep young readers interested until the very end. Overall, it is a fun, simple way to introduce the idea of taking turns and learn some strategies for doing so.
Nicole Smith-Forrest

When we collided by Emery Lord

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2016. ISBN 9781408870082
(Age: Senior Secondary) Highly recommended.  Extroverted Vivi, her cheerfulness hiding her fragility and the embarrassing memories she wants to forget, arrives with her mother to spend the summer in Verona Cove, a tiny coastal town, its details 'so perfect that it feels like a film set'. It is an idyllic setting and the inhabitants are kindly, caring, considerate and gentle.
Here octogenarians enjoy a drink of coffee in Betty's Diner, their ' . . . white puffs of hair hovering like clouds over the back of the aqua vinyl booths . . . ' and the owner greets everyone with endearments.
Vivi has a summer job at the pottery shop and this is where she meets Jonah and his five year old sister, Leah.
Jonah, the third oldest of six children, must share the role of father and mother to his younger siblings following the death of his father and his mother's inability to cope with her grief. He must share the responsibility of keeping the family restaurant operating to bring in income for the family. He loved and admired his father and grieves for him and he is sure this girl 'who looks like lemon meringue pie tastes, sunny, tangy, sweet', will refuse Leah's impulsive invitation to dinner. But Vivi accepts and falls in love with not only Jonah, but his siblings as well.
Vivi declares, 'I'm not much for silence: it simply doesn't suit me', Her vitality, creativity and sense of fun, even though her emotions are sometimes too high, sometimes too low, is like a tonic for this family, helping them breathe more easily 'in the stiflingly sad house'.
Vivi has found a family who needs her and this is balm to her troubled spirit. Vivi feels that Jonah complements her 'like mint ice cream and chocolate chips' and they draw close together with Vivi forcing Jonah to rethink his plans for the future and to try new ideas in the restaurant.
But Vivi's behaviour becomes more erratic. Without her mother's knowledge, she has been throwing away one of the tablets she is supposed to take every day to prevent another episode similar to the painful memories she is trying to suppress.
Vivi discovers her father's identity and after facing him and his hostility, she spins out of control and Jonah witnesses the road accident which nearly claims her life. During her recovery, Vivi faces up to the fact that she has bipolar disorder, and she and her mother reassess their future and decide to return to their former home.
These are warm, vital characters, with genuine concern for each other. It is so easy to become involved in their story and so refreshing to read of characters who know there will be difficult weeks in their lives but who move on with courage and optimism. They reach for 'happiness even in uncertainty'.
Emery Lord closes the novel with advice about dealing with bipolar disorder. Her belief that 'maybe the path isn't perfect but you get there' reflects the feeling of optimism that floods this book.
I highly recommend this book to teenage readers of either sex, just as I would recommend Jandy Nelson's novel, I'll give you the sun, for its honesty and compassion.
Thelma Harvey

Reflection by Rebecka Sharpe Shelberg

cover image

Ill. by Robin Cowcher. Walker Books, 2016. ISBN 9781922179050
(Age: 7+) Recommended. War, Australia's involvement with war, Memorials, Anzac Day, Remembrance. This picture book presents a different way of looking at war in the classroom. It offers an introduction to the many wars in which Australia has been represented form the Boer War in 1899 through to the Second Gulf War. It reminds students that we have been in many conflicts around the world, and are still involved in an advisory capacity.
Each double page shows a family on Anzac Day. One page shows them remembering what has happened, honouring those who did not return from war, while the other side includes a picture of the war in which Australians were involved.
The family marching to the war memorial is reflected in the marching boots of the soldiers in the Boer War, and horses' hooves can be seen interspersed with those of the men. The cold of the early morning rise for the family is paralleled with the cold and wet conditions of the soldiers hunkered down in the trenches during World War One, while the service at the war memorial is reflected with the soldiers burying their dead during a lull in hostilities during World War Two. And on it goes, one page shiws the modern family at the memorial the other page reflecting one of the wars Australia has been part of through the years; Boer War, two World Wars, Korean War, Vietnam War, Timor, Afghanistan, Iraq and Bosnia. It is salutary to realise that war continues, that these wars have not ended war, that people still resort to war to solve problems between territories. In reflecting upon war, children will come to see that war affects us all, that it is not only Australians who are affected by war.
This book adds to the range of books available to remind students about war and its cost, of the many wars Australia has been involved in and the way we remember. And the beautiful water colour wash illustrations reflect this theme to perfection. Cowcher has used pen and ink outlines to render the family and those at war. Children will be intrigued to find clues in the illustrations to work out where the soldiers are fighting, and be aware of the number of red poppies accumulating as they read. Haunting red splotches fill the endpapers making a poignant reminder of this symbol of death in war.
And the last pages gives them an outline of those wars.
Fran Knight

Mad Magpie by Gregg Dreise

cover image

Magabala Books, 2016. ISBN 9781925360066
(Age: 4-9) Highly recommended. Stay calm like the surface of the water, yet strong like its current. Greg Dreise's third morality tale Mad Magpie is dedicated to those children who have been picked on or bullied.
In the Dreamtime, Guluu the very angry magpie would swoop down and attack the bush animals. The magpie tries to justify his own actions telling the Elders, he is reacting to the butcher birds teasing him. To protect himself, he begins to act in a tough and angry manner. Old Dinewah the wise emu offers Guluu some sage advice to stay strong inside and ignore their bad behaviour.
Guluu attempts to ignore the naughty behaviour of the butcher birds, even when he flies to the other river bank, but the bullies pursue him. He stands up for himself and calms his anger with his beautiful songs. In turn, this wisdom and life lesson help bush and all the animals to live harmoniously again.
Gregg Driesse's paintings engage the audience with their traditional and modern style. He incorporates the use of natural colours - ochres, reds, browns and blacks with bird tracks and vibrant colours in the circles of dot painting. The birds are painted with a strength of emotions, there's angry Guluu, the taunting butcher birds and wise cockatoos placed against the calm surface and powerful river currents to anchor the action.
Silly Birds, Kookoo Kookaburra and Mad Magpie are motivating Dreamtime Stories. Gregg Driesse's picture books are important resources for schools and kindergartens, useful for lessons in English, Art, Health, Wellbeing, Music and Drama. They provide wisdom, insight and offer keys to help deal with children's behaviours and difficult situations faced by them.
Rhyllis Bignell

Raymie Nightingale by Kate DiCamillo

cover image

Candlewick Press, 2016. ISBN 9781406363135
(Age: 9+) Highly recommended. Friendship, Grief, Single parents, Aged care, Competition. When her father leaves, Raymie is distraught. She joins a baton twirling class in the hope of winning Little Miss Central Florida Tire 1975, so having her picture in the paper to lure him back home. She knows that doing a good deed will sit well with the judges and tries to find one. But her soul does not seem to be getting much bigger. At the class she meets two other hopefuls, Louisiana and Beverly, each of whom have quite different reasons for being there. Beverly is a take it as you see it type of girl, no holds barred, straight talking and often abrasive, while her cynical comments about baton twirling, cat homes, families and the outrageous Ida Nee will have the reader laughing out loud. Louisiana is an orphan but quietly determined and lives with a very odd grandmother, always on the lookout for the authorities who may take her to a children's home. All three girls are quite different but come to work together to achieve their goals.
But the class does not turn out as it should, partly because of the antics of the very odd teacher, Ida Nee, and Raymie decides to read to someone at the aged centre instead of going to class, so embroiling Louisiana and Beverly in her attempts to retrieve the library book which she loses under one aged person's bed. Beverly wants to sabotage the baton competition, while all Louisiana wants is to get her cat, Archie back. Losing any possibility of winning the money for baton twirling, the girls decide to take matters into their own hands and go to the cat shelter to get Archie, making use of Beverly's skills.
A very funny, darkly humorous episode at the end sees Louisiana in hospital with an array of parents and caregivers arriving to tend to their girls. Raymie's soul becomes larger as she develops friendships and helps solve some of their problems, while accepting that her father is not returning.
Beautifully written, this tale is most appealing in detailing the lives of three young girls who do not quite fit in and are certainly not what they seem. The story evokes understanding and pathos, sympathy and humour as The Three Rancheros set out to right some wrongs.
Fran Knight

Chasing dreams by Karen Wood

cover image

Trickstars bk 5. Allen and Unwin, 2015. ISBN 9781743319109
(Age: Early chapter book readers) Themes: Dreams; Horse-riding; Performance. The Trickstars trick-riding triplets face a new possibility in their lives after their Aunt Zelda posts a video of their amazing skills on the internet. Aunt Zelda, a practising fortune-teller, creates a dream opportunity for the girls through this publicity which is not immediately appreciated by the girl's Grandfather. An unfortunate accident occurs that almost prevents them showing their skills, but the girls still get to perform to a talent scout for their favourite television show.
The skills of the girls as trick-riders are central to the story, but their inherited 'magical' traits from their gypsy background also influence life. The mystic factor is usually low-key in this series, but it is inherent in the story-line. The triplets overcome their struggles and demonstrate positive behaviours with the occasional influence of the visions or magical gifts from their family heritage.
Suited for girls who love horses, and enjoy a bit of daring in an early chapter book.
Carolyn Hull

The boy who could do what he liked by David Baddiel

cover image

Ill. by Jim Field. HarperCollins, 2016. ISBN 9780008167813
(Age: 7+) Highly recommended for young readers aged 7+.
(Alfie is a little older, but the story is easily accessible for a younger reader.) Family. Rules and routines. Children's behaviour.
Alfie lives a fairly boring life; at least his classmates tell him so. At home he lives a fairly regulated life, with documented routines for every aspect of life. But Alfie is not dreadfully unhappy, or worried by this. But his normal structured existence is ruffled a little the night his parents cannot get their normal babysitter, and the new sitter injects a little magical spark of mayhem when she says, 'Do what you like!' There is a little hint of the Fairy Godmother in her ability to make significant change without doing much at all... and she is incredibly and breath-takingly ancient!
This is a charming story, without the syrupy inclusion of the 'moral of the story' type ending. In fact the simplicity of the tale and the charming way that Baddiel introduces the routines of Alfie's life will appeal to all young readers. The amusing 'fart in the bed' scenario will also entertain young readers.
Carolyn Hull