Reviews

Bird and Bear and the special day by Ann James

cover image

Five Mile Press, 2016. ISBN 9781760402808
(Age: 3+) Recommended. Friendship, Shadows, Birthdays. Ann James' beautiful drawings grace every page, reflecting every move of the two friends which young children will adore. I love Bear's boots and scarf and wooly hat, the leaves swirling around his feet, and the gull, Bird, sitting upon his head. James' few confident brush strokes give pages full of interest, humour, colour and meaning while both story and illustrations impel the reader to turn the pages.
It is Bird's birthday and she meets best friend, Bear with his rucksack to go out for the day. They head for the park and as they go, Bird asks questions to which Bear responds encouraging readers to predict the answers that Bear will give. The readers will be exposed to the words high and low, big and small, wet and dry, while looking at their big shadows. It is time for their picnic and Bear takes three small cakes out of his backpack. They eat two and Bear puts one away for later. Meanwhile they continue their game of finding something big and small, but also tall and wet, until their day is at an end. Bear calls Bird to meet him at the top of the hill where birthday greetings are given along with the third cake for Bird for her birthday. Bear has not forgotten after all.
This delightful tale of friendship also includes learning new words as well as looking at the things children can do on a picnic. The lovely soft illustrations reflect the care shown between the friends, their looking after each other, remembering a birthday and making it a special day for the other.
Fran Knight

Out of the ice by Ann Turner

cover image

Simon and Schuster, 2016. ISBN 9781925030891
(Age: 16+) Recommended. Thriller. Antarctica. Friendship. Women. Viruses. Laura Alvarado is an environmental scientist based in the Antarctic. When she is sent to a remote area to report whether Fredelighavn, an abandoned whaling station, could be used for tourism or stay as a pristine environment for the wildlife, she finds disturbing evidence that it is being misused and the wildlife behaving strangely. When the normally placid penguins and seals attack, Laura knows that someone has been interfering with their way of life. On a dive at the station with her friend Sara, she glimpses a young boy screaming for help through the ice and as more and more strange things begin to happen she finds herself in danger. What is going on at the Research Station? Why is she seeing eerie things and being shunned by the scientists at the base?
This is a tense and engrossing thriller and the setting of the ice of Antarctica sets it apart immediately. The reader is swept into the life of people living in its cold environment, and the initial chapters describing the animal life, the penguins, seals and whales give a fabulous background to the thrilling story as the suspense unfolds. Fredelighavn, an abandoned whaling station is depicted in great detail. The Norwegian buildings, portraits of the people who lived there, the Scandavian furniture and even an abandoned cinema, are all brought to life against the background of the terrible slaughter of the whales that were the mainstay of the settlement.
Although Laura could perhaps be 'toasty', a condition of seeing things after spending too much time in Antactica, she is a strong and determined woman, who rationally analyses what has happened and is convinced that she has seen a young boy screaming for help. With the assistance of her friend Sara and boss Georgia, a detective stationed nearby, they investigate Fredelighavn. Continuing the search, Laura goes to Nantucket, pursuing the elusive scientist Snow and uncovers more of the mysteries surrounding the abandoned whaling station.
There are many questions for the reader to pursue, including the theme of strong women in a predominantly male environment, the strength of friendship and the preservation of wildlife. Add these to exciting action, suspense, some very unexpected twists and turns and moments of heartbreak and the reader is in for a real treat. I will certainly be picking up any more books by Ann Turner.
Pat Pledger

Grayling's song by Karen Cushman

cover image

Clarion Books, 2016. ISBN 9780544301801
(Age: 10-13) Recommended. Fantasy. Magic. Adventure. Self-confidence. Middle Ages. Grayling is horrified when her mother, wise woman Hannah Strong, starts turning into a tree, 'her feet rooted into the earth. What had been toes were now spreading roots, and what had been soft skin was as rough and brown as a tree trunk'. Her mother sends her off on a quest to find 'the others' who she says will help Grayling retrieve her grimoire and break the spell. Grayling is a shy girl, but is determined to rescue her mother and gradually finds the others, a motley assortment of minor witches, who were not strong enough to gain the attention of the evil being who is turning all wise people into trees and stealing their grimoires. Assisted by a talking, shape shifting mouse named Pook, Grayling becomes the leader of the group and faces kidnapping, imprisonment, tiredness, and the strain of travelling with strange companions.
A compelling coming of age story finds Grayling, away from the influence of her strong willed mother, taking charge and finding the strength of character and determination to follow her quest to regain the grimoires and rescue those turned into trees. Cushman, who won a Newbery Medal for her wonderful novel, The midwife's apprentice, brings the alternative medieval period to life with vivid and lyrical prose. As she recounts in her fascinating notes at the conclusion of the story, the Middle Ages were a time when wise women, wise men or those commonly known as hedge witches, used herbal potions and made prophecies.
As well as some exciting adventures, when Grayling must use all her wits and courage to keep going, there are many moments of humour as the companions learn to travel together. Each of the characters, from Auld Nancy to Pansy, are fully developed, with their own funny idiosyncrasies, and strengths and weaknesses while Pook, the little mouse, is a delightful creature that readers are sure to love. A slight hint of romance with the young paper maker is also a welcome touch.
This delightful coming of age story, with its themes of courage and determination, of gaining self confidence and finding ways to be a leader, will appeal to middle school students and all who enjoy historical fantasy.
Pat Pledger

Mrs Dog by Janeen Brian

cover image

Ill. by Marjorie Crosby-Fairall. Five Mile Press, 2016. ISBN 9781760066451
(Age: 4+) Highly recommended. Animals. Dogs. Families. Courage. An ailing lamb in the paddock is found by Mrs Dog and her farmer, Tall-One as they survey the mob of sheep. Tall-One tells the dog to leave it but Mrs Dog takes the lamb back to her basket at the homestead. Here she looks after the ailing lamb and Tall-Two gives it some spare milk. With all this help, the baby animal, Baa-rah thrives until it is time for Mrs Dog to teach it how to be a farm dog. She is at the end of her working life so needs a well trained dog to take her place. But this one does not seem to take to the instructions of belly crawl and beg or pounce, and is even worse when being taught to bark. Readers will laugh out loud at Mrs Dog's attempts to teach the lamb, but on the very next page, danger lurks. Mrs Dog, on returning to the farm, is attacked by Beaky-Wing and falls over the dangerous cliff she has warned Baa-rah to avoid. Baa-rah realises that something has happened to Mrs Dog when she does not return and goes to great lengths to get help from the farmer, finally doing something that Mrs Dog has tried unsuccessfully to teach, to attract Tall-One's attention.
This is a charming story of love and courage, of the links between all animals, of caring for something in need. In helping the lamb survive, the old farm dog has that favour returned when she needs help later on.
Our interdependence is made clear through the story of the farm dog and the stray lamb and children will be enthralled to read of how the selfless act of the dog not only saved the lamb's life, but also her own.
Fran Knight

Uprooted by Naomi Novik

cover image

Macmillan, 2015. ISBN 9781447294139
(Age: 15+) Highly recommended. Fantasy. This was a stunning read, worthy of all the awards and nominations that it has been given (Hugo Award Nominee for Best Novel, 2016, Nebula Award for Best Novel, 2015, Goodreads Choice Award Nominee for Young Adult Fantasy & Science Fiction, 2015). Agnieszka loves her quiet valley home which is bordered by an evil Wood that can swallow people or turn them mad. The village and valley is shielded by the Dragon, a wizard, who in return for his protection takes a village girl every ten years to serve him. When the girls return to the village they are changed forever and no longer want to stay in the valley. The time of choosing is fast approaching and everyone expects that Agnieszka's beautiful friend Kasia will be selected, but no one can really predict who the Dragon will take and it is not Kasia that he finally chooses.
Novik has written a beautifully imaginative story loosely based on European folklore. Agnieszka is a wonderful heroine who gradually learns of her magical powers as a witch. Together with Sarkan, the Dragon wizard, she faces the corrupted Tree woman who is determined to take over their world. There are sorcerous battles, magic summonings and frightening heart-trees that can absorb people into their trunk and limbs that keep the reader breathless with suspense. A touch of romance between the unlikely pair - the cranky Dragon and untidy Agnieszka add to the interest in the story and the enduring friendship between Agnieszka and her friend Kasia that all make for a very engrossing fantasy novel.
I loved this story from the author of the Temeraire series. It is sure to please lovers of high fantasy and fans of Robin Hobb, Trudi Cavavan and Juliet Marillier.
Pat Pledger

Eliza Rose by Lucy Worsley

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2016. ISBN 9781408869437
(Age: Older teen readers) Themes: English History; Royalty; Life as a Courtier; King Henry VIII; Katherine Howard. This book is marketed as a children's novel. The cover is sweetly 'cute' and cartoon-like and the narrative begins naively, recounting the early life of the main character. However this is not an innocent telling of this historical period! As the life of the feisty red-headed Eliza progresses, we are taken into the somewhat risque and adult world of King Henry VIII's court. Lucy Worsley does not leave out detail about adultery and the coquettish role of the Ladies-in-Waiting and even detail about the King's bedroom behaviours are included. For a sub-teen, this detail is confronting and although the history is so well known that it is expected, it is not easy to recommend this for a naive, immature reader. (How early is too early to lay bare the rampant behaviour of the Henry VIII court, with adultery and sexual exploitation as part of the norm? I am sure that Worsley has toned this down for the book, but it is still perhaps too scandalous for the under-12 audience suggested by the cover.) Katherine Howard's ultimate fate and execution might be well known to an older reader, but this too is fairly clearly detailed.
Having given warning, I can still say that this is an interesting tale and a compelling novel for an older reader, written from the perspective of Katherine Howard's fictional cousin. We get a good look at life for those who were attempting to marry well by being placed in the Royal Court in a position that could lead to a profitable marriage. The Royal life and the surrounding entourage and life-style of grand dresses and feasts are all interesting when seen from the perspective of the female Courtiers, trained from a young age to 'play their part' in adorning the Royal world. King Henry VIII is revealed with all his flaws, and the central character is uncomfortably close to the grieving King after Katherine's death. Worsley has written in a youthful and simple style, but the mature content does not translate well for a child audience.
Carolyn Hull
Editor's note: Teacher's notes are available.

Lenny and Lucy by Philip C. Stead

cover image

Ill. by Erin E. Stead. Allen and Unwin, 2016. ISBN 9781760292119
(Age: All) I recall reading a short piece by Stephen Romei, the literary editor of The Australian, speaking about the best reads for 2016. On top of his anticipated list was the new picture book by Philip C. Stead. Stead's earlier book, A Sick Day for Amos McGee, and a winner of the Caldecott Medal, is a charming story of how the animals at the City Zoo visit the zoo-keeper when he has to take a sick day. Gentle drawings in muted shades illustrate both books, with charcoal being the medium for Lenny and Lucy, his new title. Peter and his Dad, along with Harold the dog, are moving to a new house, but they have to drive through dark woods and over a bridge before they get there. Harold and Peter are very unsettled at night as they look out to the landscape beyond the house. The next day Peter improvises a 'guard of the bridge', called Lenny, made from pillows and blankets. Inevitably, Peter realises that Lenny is lonely so Lucy is made from leaves and cloths, to keep him company. Daytime play centres around the two new friends, with Millie soon joining them from next door. With just the right amount of text, placed so well amongst the delightful illustrations, this picture book has great appeal for young and older readers. Overcoming fears and making new friends in unfamiliar places are observed beautifully.
Julie Wells

The Haters by Jesse Andrews

cover image

Allen and Unwin, Australia, 2016. ISBN 9781760291891
(Age: 15+) Recommended. Wes and Corey have been friends for a long time, founded by their love of hating music and searching for music so good they can't hate on it. When they are booked into a summer jazz camp they quickly realise that due to the lack of females this is going to be a lame camp. Then they meet free spirited Ash, the stand out female in the whole camp. During a three hour jam session they soon realise together they have some talent and embark on The Haters, Summer of Hate World Tour 2016. What follows is an exciting, fun filled adventure across America in the world's smelliest car, which feels like there are scorpions built into the seat.
Jesse Andrews has written a coming of age story which is funny, a little wicked and with a heap of teenage wit thrown in. Even though there is a lot of comedy it also gives us serious topics, one being the relationships the three main characters have with their parents which helps understand the main characters. I love the referencing to bands and Youtube clips that feature throughout, and the dialogue Wes has when imagining or explaining conversations. I loved Jesse Andrew's style of writing especially the way he made me laugh out loud many times throughout the book. This book will appeal to those more mature teenage readers with a deviant sense of humour. If you loved Me and Earl and the dying girl (also written by Jesse Andrews), or John Green's Paper towns you will love this story.
Jody Holmes

The snow wombat by Susannah Chambers

cover image

Ill. by Mark Jackson. Allen and Unwin, 2016. ISBN 9781760113810
This homage to the High Country in south east Australia shows off the environment, both natural and man-made, its flora and fauna and those who live there. I was struck as I read at the range of indigenous and introduced animals represented in the illustrations, as well as depictions of the way the environment is used.
The story of the wombat and its journey through the snow to its warm, snuggly den makes for exciting reading for younger people, as they are asked to predict the rhyming word which completes each stanza of four short lines. Younger readers will call out the words with gusto, learning that the wombat has a nose, ears and a tum just like them and where they are on its body. The wombat's journey is delightfully shown on maps on the endpapers, and the watercolour illustrations show the many animals that live in the area, along with some stunning renditions of the snow covered eucalypts. Each page is a treat, teaching the reader about this area of Australia not often seen in books, and they will learn to appreciate the lives of the animals and people that live there. We are shown the stations with miles of fencing to keep in the wool covered sheep, the rugged up skiers coming down the mountainside, the alpine signs on the roads warning motorists of kangaroos and wombat, and plenty of other animals looking for shelter from the harsh winds and sleet. This is a charming introduction to an area of Australia which children know little of, learning about wombats along the way with rhyming words to predict as well. And with the animal snuggled up safe and warm at the end, what more can a picture book offer.
Fran Knight

This girl that girl by Charlotte Lance

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2016. ISBN 9781760291709
(Age: 3+) Recommended. Difference. Neighbours. Families. Living next door to each other, two girls cannot be more different. This girl is neat and tidy, with neatly combed hair, tied up shoelaces and neat clothes, while that girl has every which way hair, floaty clothing with a cape and seems careless of which colours go with what. The soft watercolour illustrations will attract the reader's attention from the start as they turn the pages and take in the differences shown. Over the page we see the sort of things each girl likes, further underlining their differences. This girl likes to collect plants to add to a scrapbook, hoovering up the scraps at the end of her day, and is particular about setting the table, and often sits in a corner and reads. That girl, on the other hand loves running through the leaves, scattering them around, climbing onto a brick wall and walking along the top, and eating worms. They could not be more different. Over the next few pages we see their families and their houses, marking their differences again, but now their fathers seem the exact opposite of each girl. One dad is neat and tidy, the other dressed in unusual clothes with wispy floating hair. Each dad has attributes seemingly more aligned to the girl next door, not their own daughter.
But when it comes to building a treehouse, despite all the preparation on one side and the haphazard manner of building on the other, both finished tree houses look exactly the same. Readers will love comparing both girls and their fathers, comparing the attributes of each of the people shown, comparing the preparation each does to build the tree house with the final results. Readers cannot help but see that despite outside appearances, we are all the same.
Fran Knight

The royal baby's big red bus tour of London by Martha Mumford

cover image

Ill. by Ada Grey. Bloomsbury, 2016. ISBN 9781408868966
(Age: 4+) Highly recommended. London, Royal family, Great Britain, Babies. After the success of the first three books devoted to the offspring of the Duke and Duchess of Cambridge, Shh don't wake the royal baby, Happy birthday royal baby, and Hooray it's a new royal baby, it's great to see a fourth book devoted to the children's view of the city in which they live, London. Few books exist extolling the main features of some of our great cities, so this will make a perfect introduction to London and the iconic features of that place to a child or class. I loved looking at the views the book offers, reminding me of the things I saw when there. For children it will be a fabulous journey on the big red bus, the well known London transport system. The shiny red bus on the cover will ensure readers open the book and read on.
The Royal Family is sitting in the gardens at Buckingham Palace when a big red bus pulls up calling them to come on a tour of London. They all pile on board, taking along a bus load of accoutrements!
The bus pulls into a range of major London sights, Natural History Museum, ZSL London Zoo, Regent's Park, British Museum, National Portrait Gallery, Trafalgar Square, Nelson's Column before going onto the River Thames. Here they cruise past the Houses of Parliament, Tower of London, Big Ben, Tower Bridge and on down to Greenwich, where they spy the Observatory and Planetarium. On the return journey they stop at London Eye and then return to the palace for tea. Going to bed, the prince realises that he has lost his toy, a baby dinosaur, so mum retraces their steps to find it for him.
This is a fun book to read, encouraging discussion of the Royal Family and what it does during the day, as well as showing off the wonderful sights of London and what the city offers to its visitors. The funny illustrations will encourage discussion about travel and transport as well as city life.
Fran Knight

The family with two front doors by Anna Ciddor

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2016. ISBN 9781925266641
(Age: 8+) Anna Ciddor, a prolific and popular Australian author, has written a warm and amusing recollection of her grandmother's childhood in Lublin, Poland in 1920.
The Jewish family of nine children rent two apartments alongside each other, hence making use of the two front doors on the ground floor of the building. The household is constantly bustling and busy with family rituals and meals, alongside father's commitments, as a rabbi, to the local community. Long-held traditions of the Jewish people are the backdrop for the story of the betrothal of Adina Rabinovich, the oldest daughter, to Mordechai Weinberg, both in their late teens. No one has met young Mordechai, so the intrigue and excitement about him, grows as the wedding date comes closer. Food, clothes, jewellery, and family customs remain the main subject of this charming memoir along with the wonderful family bond that exists between parents and children. Their exuberance about life is infectious! However, underlying the joyfulness of this snapshot of life we realise that the Rabinovich family live in a poorer part of the city - the Jewish quarter. Mama's jewels are family heirlooms, forever fascinating for the young sisters, but we wonder how safe these treasures, and their shared treasured lives, will be in times to come. Lublin is about 150 kilometres south east of Warsaw. Deliberately, Ciddor does not mention the battle for Warsaw in the summer of 1920 and only refers to the perils of the Second World War and the Holocaust in her author's note.
Julie Wells

The next together by Lauren James

cover image

Walker Books, 2015. ISBN 9781406358056
(Age: 14+) Recommended. Kate Finchley and Matt Galloway have started to fall in love during the year 2039 whilst both attending University of Nottingham Campus, England. The peculiar thing isn't that they have both just met but the feeling that they have been through this all before. Rewind to 1854, where Katy (Kit) is living as a boy to be able to work as a kitchen boy in the house of a lord. Lord Sommerset wants her to assist journalist Matthew Galloway, reporting on the war front in the Crimea on the condition that she spy on the journalist and report secrets back home. Rewind again to 1754 and Katherine is tired of her Aunt introducing her to prospective marital matches, so whilst she excuses herself to spend time in the garden she is secretly hoping to spend time with the family's coachman Matthew Galloway. How can these two people be linked throughout time and share memories that aren't their own? As 2039 Kate and Matt search for clues on the murder of their Aunt and Uncle (Kate and Matt) they discover the secret on why their lives seem to be destined to be together again and again.
Whilst the concept of this book intrigued me at first I found it difficult to be able to follow the timeline of each of the Kate and Matthew characters through history. The characters are written with strong personalities and with added charm and plenty of humour. The chapters do jump from one period to the next and as the story evolved I found it easier to follow along. I appreciated that Lauren James has intertwined the genres together making it a great book for lovers of historical, science fiction and even romance novels to enjoy. I would recommend this book to young adults from the ages of 14 years and above. I look forward to finding out what happens with Kate and Matt in the sequel The last beginning.
Jody Holmes

Milo: a moving story by Tohby Riddle

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2016. ISBN 9781760111632
(Age: 6+) Recommended. Friends, City life, Relationships. A picture book for older readers, the title alerts readers to the double meaning of the story, particularly when the cover illustration shows Milo and his kennel perched precariously on top of a tall building.
Milo lives a quiet, ordered life. He has a number of friends with whom he has adventures and when they are at home during the night call out to each other across the rooftops of the city. But one night, he dreams he is on a boat, with high winds and choppy seas. He tosses and turns, restless and sleeping badly. When he wakes he is tired and impatient, so much so that when his friend, Snombo calls he rudely sends him away. He instantly regrets his rude words to his friend and that night a storm erupts, leaving Milo and his kennel stuck on a roof. Alone he ponders his plight and the events of the previous day. A migrating bird, Carlos flies in and helps him from his kennel onto the roof of the building and during the night they talk and swap stories.
In the morning a window cleaner comes to work and in return for helping him down from the top of the building, he helps the window cleaner finish his work.
He returns with his kennel to his usual spot, surprised that his friends are there looking for him, even Snombo. He recounts his adventures and during the celebrations he apologises to his friend, Snombo.
That night he dreams again of being in a boat, but this time the seas are calm and the boat still.
This charming picture book illustrates the importance of friends, of working to keep them, of the adventures that friends have together. Riddle's illustrations in a mix of colour wash, collage and photographic images are a treat. They will have younger readers searching for instances of city life as they hum the tunes of In the good old summer time, and Give my regards to Broadway. The New York setting will intrigue readers who will be able to pick out sights of that city. Riddle's whimsical approach to the group of friends, shown as dogs dressed in their apparel from the mid twentieth century is further enhanced by the sepia colours used, giving the whole a very old fashioned look.
Like all of Riddle's books, the more it is read, the more the reader sees.
And it is worth the effort.
Fran Knight
Editor's note: Teacher's notes are available.

Series set in Realm of the Elderlings by Robin Hobb

cover image

Harper Collins, various dates.
(Age: 15+) Highly recommended. Books set in the Realm of the Elderlings by Robin Hobb have grabbed my reading time over the last few weeks - and are fabulous for readers who enjoy epic fantasy. Although The Farseer Trilogy (Assassin's apprentice, Royal Assassin, Assassin's quest,) were first published many years ago Hobb's fantastic storytelling has ensured that their popularity has endured and the books have been reprinted. The Farseer Trilogy is followed by the Tawny Man series (Fool's errand, Golden fool and Fool's fate), Liveship Traders (Ship of magic, The mad ship, Ship of destiny), the Rainwild chronicles (The dragon keeper, Dragon haven, City of dragons and Blood of dragons) and The Fitz and the fool series (Fool's Assassin, Fool's Quest and Assassin's Fate due in 2017).
These series of books are a very valuable addition to a library or if budgets don't allow for their purchase, would be worthwhile to recommend to readers to borrow from a public library. Those who start following the adventures of Fitz and the Fool, both compelling characters who face strange and compelling times in a wonderful setting, are likely to want to read all in the series.
Pat Pledger