Reviews

The Cleo stories: A friend and a pet by Libby Gleeson

cover image

Ill. by Freya Blackwood. Allen & Unwin, 2015. ISBN 9781743315286
(Age: 6+) Highly recommended. Chapter book, Family, Friendship, Pets. Two more stories in this highly appealing tale of Cleo and her family, by the award winning duo of Gleeson and Blackwood will win hearts at first glance with its two entertaining short stories and wonderful illustrations.
In Cleo makes a friend, Cleo is at a loss on this rainy day: all her friends are away and there is one she no longer cares for, so she has nothing to do. Mum and Dad both suggest things, especially one about tidying her room, but she is still desolate. She begins to play with mum's makeup but is admonished, reminded that she is not allowed in that room. Going outside she sees her reflection in the newly formed puddles and this gives her an idea of what she can do.
The second story, Cleo wants a pet, sees Cleo begging her parents to have a pet in the house. She gives all the reasons children give their parents for having a pet in the family, and they respond with all the reasons parents give for it not to happen. It is wonderfully rounded story, with Cleo resolving the matter to everyone's satisfaction.
The wonderful soft edged illustrations show Cleo's house within the few streets of her suburb. Each drawing shows a different aspect of family life, from dad watering the vegetable garden, to breakfast at the kitchen table, going to bed, family discussions and so on: all redolent of the bonds between people living in the same house. Blackwood's illustrations are inviting: readers will peer into the details presented, comparing them with what they know. I love the endpapers, giving a bird's eye view of the streets, challenging the readers to work out where Cleo lives.
Fran Knight

Peter and the wolf, adapted and illustrated by Ayesha L Rubio

cover image

Five Mile Press, 2015. ISBN 9781760067816
Recommended. Folk tale, Animals, Respect. This old folk tale, written by Sergei Prokofiev, is adapted for a modern audience and stunningly illustrated to appeal to a new generation of readers.
Peter strays outside the garden gate and watches a bird and a duck argue near the pond. A cat skulks by trying to capture the bird but misses. Grandpa admonishes Peter for straying outside the safety of the garden as a wolf is about. Just when Grandpa hauls Peter back, the wolf eats the duck. Peter tells the bird to fly above the wolf's head so that he can capture the wolf. He lassoes its tail when hunters appear wanting to shoot the wolf. Peter placates them and talks to the wolf, offering to let him go free if he releases the duck from his stomach.
The old tale becomes one of reconciliation, of negotiation, of respecting each other.
Readers will love the bold artwork, and thrill at the images of the stalking wolf and the focussed hunters, as well as the image of a determined Peter. His determination becomes almost wolf like as it is given a voice, one which will save the wolf form being killed.
And finding an older version of Peter and the wolf, will give children a chance to compare the two stories and discuss why the author has made the changes.
Wikipedia offers an interesting outline of the original story and a fabulous musical version can be found at Youtube which could be shared on the electronic white board.
Fran Knight

Freddy Tangles Series by Jack Brand

cover image

Ill. by Tom Jellett. Allen & Unwin, 2015.
Legend or Loser. ISBN 9781760110345
Champ or Chicken. ISBN 9781760110345
(Age: 8-10) Recommended. This new series by Jack Brand explores young Freddy Tangles life, his family, school dramas and friendships. Presented in the style of Big Nate and Tom Gates, with cartoon illustrations, diagrams and two ants who provide a running commentary, these funny junior novels are easy to read.
Legend or Loser introduces young Frederick Augustus Reginald Tangles - Freddy Tangles who lives with his mum, dad, old dog Mince and younger annoying sister Jessica. He has to share a bedroom with her and even though he doesn't mind playing dollies, she often embarrasses him in front of his friends. He meets his Russian friend Blocker who lives down the street when he accidentally dakked Blocker's Mum. Freddy's life is full of crazy situations and comments; he accidentally touches Tabby's tongue when they share a dropped icecream cone, but he prefers to touch his dog's tongue. When his full name is read out at roll call, Freddy quickly becomes known as FARTboy and this quickly spreads across the school. Verbal and physical bullying occurs and Freddy is forced to take action, siding with another bully and his gang.
Freddy shows resilience as he creatively deals with the bullies will a little advice from Blocker's mother and his friends and family who are there to support him.
In Champ or Chicken, Freddy has to face his three worst fears, spiders, heights and becoming naked in public. After the running commentary on nose-picking, dealing with girls by pretending they are boys and the problems caused by the new kid at school, Freddy tries to be re-invited to Tabby's huge birthday party in the park. Unfortunately, just as he's changing into his cowboy costume - ready to ride the mechanical bull, he's confronted by menacing spiders. A naked and embarrassed Freddy quickly climbs a tree followed by the arachnids, and after reaching his limit, he falls onto the bull. How much trouble can one guy get up to?
Freddy Tangles is a funny character who has a unique way of dealing with all the dramas in his life. A great new series, complimented by Tom Jellett's humorous cartoons.
Rhyllis Bignell

The dog, Ray by Linda Coggin

cover image

Hot Key Books, 2015. ISBN 9781471403194
(Age: 11+) Unapologetically sappy, this inoffensive reincarnation story hits the spot for 11 years plus readers. Immediately after being killed in the same motor accident which leaves her father severely disabled, Daisy finds herself in the afterlife and learns that a limited number of souls exist, necessitating rebirth as another being. Following an imperfect re-entry, Daisy retains memories and human understanding (including the ability to read) when she is born as a dog which leads to an overpowering urge to return to her human parents for reunification.
Unfortunately for her, upon leaving the litter, she finds herself owned by a lazy, selfish boy - Cyril, who neglects and fails more than maltreating her, and Daisy has little compunction about bolting when she has the chance. The dog embarks on several adventures, meeting both kindly and intolerant humans on her quest to find her family. Daisy's greatest impediment is the incapacity to speak and her excited greetings, speeches and warnings to humans are naturally heard as frightening or irritating barks. The ability for dogs and some humans to have a mutually agreeable relationship and the understanding of voiced communication from both parties is depicted in a lovely way when she meets Jack, a homeless man who gives her to Pip, a lad who is sleeping rough.
Like Daisy, Pip is searching for lost family following a bereavement and the pair roam the countryside, protecting one another from dangers which threaten those without a home.
This story delivers a lot in terms of showing the value of human kindness lavished on both people and animals during life's journey. I also liked the message that different family arrangements can be loving, nurturing and supportive, a notion that may be some comfort to children following bereavement or family breakdown. What touched me the most in this story had less to do with spiritual revisiting than thinking about the delightful attempts by affectionate animals to commune with those whom they love.
Believing in reincarnation was no problem for the purpose of reading this story, however accepting that children in a contemporary narrative for Australia could be called 'Daisy', 'Cyril' and 'Pip' was difficult.
Rob Welsh

The pause by John Larkin

cover image

Random House, 2015. ISBN 9780857981707
(Age: 14+) Highly recommended. Depression, Suicide, Relationships, Psychiatric hospitals, Therapy, Future. When Declan sees the train appear, he runs towards it but suddenly pauses, thinking about the impact his death will have on those around him. His girlfriend, Lisa has been sent to Hong Kong, the furthest her dragon mother can send her away from Declan, and without a mobile phone, has not communicated with him for days. He is absolutely bereft and long forgotten trauma builds adding to his depression and anxiety. That pause saves his life, and the novel, told in non chronological scenes, tells us why and how he got to this point.
But Larkin is at pains to tell us in his opening letter that this is not a suicide novel, rather one of hope and the reasons for living. He has been at this point and wants readers to know the signs, to know there is help, to know that life is worth hanging on to.
Told in first person, Declan reveals his growing relationship with Lisa, the abject disdain of her mother, the waiting for a call from her in Hong Kong, the build up of tension and anxiety as he comes to the conclusion that their affair is over, and so the decision to die.
His pause on the railway station sees him surrounded by caring people, holding his hand, calming him down, talking gently to him. The ambulance takes him to emergency with the ambo holding his hand the whole time, and from there he is sent to a psychiatric unit. Here he learns techniques to avoid stress, to be aware of the signs of depression, to take medication that will help and he learns to laugh.
In the background his parents are bickering, hints are given about the dreaded Aunt Mary, and what seems an average family home, becomes more splintered. The second part of the story in part belongs to Lisa. Declan and his mother opt to got to Hong Kong for their family trip and there he meets Lisa and she is able to tell him what has happened to her. Overwhelming as her tale is she always felt that Declan was there, propping her up, encouraging her to take a stand against her mother, showing her that other families exist quite differently. And Declan finally opens up to her about the trauma of his past and the triggers which brought it all to the surface.
This is a wonderful story. Declan is frank about his reasons for thinking about suicide and just as frank about the pause. The story breathes truth, the psychiatric unit resounds with people's lives interrupted by trauma, and readers will be left knowing how to approach their friends who are having a rough time and recognise symptoms within themselves. Larkin has certainly achieved his aim of writing about hope.
And I must point out the wonderful cover and book design, the chapter headings and placement of the chapters, which all contribute to an absorbing read.
This book unsurprisingly won the Queensland Literary Award in 2105 for Young Adult Novel.
Fran Knight

Theophilus Grey and the demon thief by Catherine Jinks

cover image

Allen & Unwin, 2015. ISBN 9781760113605
(Age: 10+) Highly recommended. Humour, Historical novel, London, 1750, Street children. Theophilus (Philo to his friends) works for the lawyer's clerk, Garnet Hooke, a man who stays all day in bed, sending out his gang of linkboys to not only take people home in the dark of the night, but also gather information which he then sells. Philo hears from one of the less desirable acquaintances that there is something not quite right, a feeling of someone behind him, of a fearful smell. Philo talks to his master about it, but his fears about a demon are dismissed, although Philis is dismayed when later he finds that Garnet has been giving herbal remedies to others who are worried.
A London of two and a half centuries ago is brought incredibly alive in Jinks' writing as we see the children who work the streets, lighting the way for people going home, pickpockets, potboys and footpads, all squeezing out what little money they can get to survive. We see the women coming into London escaping their husbands, going to the parish church for help, girls selling small bunches of herbs on the street, the workhouses that some of Philo's crew have lived in, all uncomfortably real, redolent of the eighteenth century, of the London of a century before Jinks' previous series, City of Orphans.
This is the first in a series of two novels following Philo as he tries to unearth the demon that people think is striking people down. Helped by his new friend, the physician, Mr Paxton, he treads a wary path through the machinations of his ill employer and those who want him out of the way. His investigations take him to Rat's Castle, the dwelling of the worst of men in the byways of London's West End, and here he finds the flower seller, Samantha in a particular predicament.
The background of this wonderful story is so well detailed that any reader will be able to smell the filth and grime in which people live, and wonder at the changes that have befallen our lives in two hundred years and be grateful for it.
Philo is a most likable character, illiterate but street wise, canny in keeping himself and his crew safe, waiting for an opportunity to make a small amount of money and wary of those around him who would do him and his friends harm.
Fran Knight

Sad, the dog by Sandy Fussell

cover image

Ill. by Tull Suwannakit. Walker Books, 2015. ISBN 9781921529641
(Age: 5+) Highly recommended. Pets, Dogs, Family, Home. A dog given to an older couple as a gift is looked after by them but never given a name. They feed him, wash him, scold him for barking or digging the garden, or tearing up the newspapers but do not name him. So he names himself. He calls himself Sad, because that is how he feels in this home where he is unwanted and unloved. One day the couple pack their belongings and move away leaving Sad behind. A new family arrives and the young boy sees the dog and is instantly excited. The family feeds him, they give him fresh water to drink and take him for a walk. He is given a soft warm bed on the back verandah and when he wakes, Jack is there with a treat. He does all the things he did with his previous family but now he is not scolded or left outside; he is loved, wanted and called by his new name, Lucky.
This is a treat of a story, one full of warmth and charm as the dog is at first not cared for and then finds someone who loves him. Along the way readers will see the difference between owning a dog and loving and caring for a dog, how a dog reacts to the care given it, of how an animal fits into the family. Children will love reading of Sad and marvel at his change of fortune, and be instantly mesmerised by the watercolour illustrations showing the changes in the dog's fortunes as he goes from being alone and dejected to being alive and happy. The endpapers reflect his status beautifully. This is a treat simply as a great story well told and illustrated, but a boon for teachers and parents wanting to discuss the care of a pet.
Fran Knight

Shadowcat by Julia Louise

cover image

Ill. by Anne Ryan. Five Mile Press, 2015. ISBN 9781760067090
(Age: 4+) Recommended. Bravery, Dreams, Siblings. Edith often sits in the garden alone, avoiding her baby brother. She feels she is turning into a garden gnome, sitting there quietly, without moving, allowing the grass to grow around her. But one day a cat comes by and asks her why she is doing what she is doing. He inquires why she doesn't dream, and Edith, surprised asks him how he knows. He tells her that cats can see when people dream as stardust forms around them. He takes her hand and together they walk into the overgrown garden and he teaches her to dance. Each night she dances and stardust forms around her as she dreams. She dances in the garden taking her brother's hand in hers. But one night the cat does not come back, and she begins to feel a bit gnomish, until she finally sees him through her window and he tells her to dream alone, to be brave as the stars are always with her.
This is a charming story of daring to dream, of being brave, as Edith becomes introverted when a baby appears in the household, losing her place within the family. The stylised acrylic illustrations show the young girl sitting quietly in the garden, amongst the gnomes. The shadows of the trees make the garden look ominous, but the night sky becomes warm and encompassing as she dances with the cat.
A wonderful addition to the range of stories about the arrival of a new baby in the household and learning to be resilient.
Fran Knight

The flyaway girls by Julia Lawrinson

cover image

Penguin, 2015. ISBN 9780143308652
(Age: 10+) Highly recommended. Gymnastics, Jealousy, Friendship. Chelsea is threatened when a new girl, Telia joins her gymnastic club. Chelsea has worked hard for a long time, doing extra training at home after her five hours at the club each week, in preparation for the Nationals. But this new girl has a natural talent that Chelsea can only dream about, and each time she tries a new skill, needs only a small amount of instruction from Louisa to get it right the next time. Ellie does not believe that she has not been trained and continues her snide remarks and comments towards the new girl. Chelsea's other friends, Rosie and Gemma, practising for the school band, form a neat contrast to the problems at the club, especially when Chelsea can see her aim of being chosen for the Nationals slipping away. But she likes Telia, and cannot abide the bickering of Ellie, so she has a dilemma to work out, who to support.
This is a wonderfully written story of middle primary girls training their hearts out for a chance at a place in the top rung of their sport. The threat of not making it is always hangs over their heads, and their regime at the club reinforces the work they must do to succeed.
The finely observed detail of working so hard at club level pervades the story and the reader settles in easily into the strengths and weaknesses shown by the girls.
Problems at home also add to the mix of this very readable story which will make all readers watch with new eyes the gymnastics at the Olympic and Commonwealth Games.
Fran Knight

The Phantom Bully by Jeffrey Brown

cover image

Star Wars: Jedi Academy bk 3. Scholastic, 2015. ISBN 9780545621267
(Age: 9-12) Recommended. Author, illustrator Jeffrey Brown's popular Star Wars Jedi Academy returns. Roan Sanchez is about to enter his final year at the Jedi Academy. Middle School proves to be challenging for the young trainee, as he is honing his Jedi skills, performing in a class talent show, dating and coping with the class bully Cronah. Creatively set out as diary entries with class schedules, notes, holomail, holobook chats, cartoons, graphic diagrams, Roan's diary is an exciting account of his student life.
After Spring Break Roan settles down to training with his mentor Mr. G, as he wants to be a pilot like his father and enjoys using the flight simulator. There's the Jedi Obstacle Challenge Trial to complete where Roan learns the importance of friendship and resilience. At the Icecream Social, Roan serves the dessert with mite sauce and beetle jelly added for extra taste. Of course Cronah's involved in this mischief. After a light saber battle between Roan and his enemy, the reader gains an understanding of the reasons behind the bully's behaviour.
This diary format with personal information, insights and illustrations is an extremely popular format with preteen readers. Jeff Brown's setting of the Jedi Academy and his understanding of middle school life makes this another exciting adventure for Star Wars fans.
Rhyllis Bignell

Wombat wins by Jackie French and Bruce Whatley

cover image

Angus & Robertson, 2015. ISBN 9780732299576
(Age: 4+) Recommended. Wombats, Winning, Carrots. The winning combination of French and Whatley has produced another book in the series about wombats. In this one, Mothball goes along to the school sports day. She has yawned, scratched, eaten some grass and noticed, after rummaging through the fridge that the small humans are racing past the window.
The reader can see from their distinctive clothing that they are off to a sporting arena of some sort, but Mothball has only one thought in mind, to beat them getting to the carrots. So begins a marvellous series of pages where Mothball is seemingly competing against the small humans, winning the race by burrowing through the hill, winning the sack race, jumping across the heads of the swimmers to reach the end of the pool and inadvertently taking a gold medal. But she spies a shopping bag out of which is sticking some greenery, so hunts it down and luxuriates in the greens until she falls asleep.
Ah, just another day in the life of a wombat, Mothball. Readers will love reading the story and looking at the wonderful illustrations, reveling in the antics of this creature, wondering just how one comes to be in a household, and marveling at the patience needed to house such a thing. And also contemplate the idea of sports days, winning and aspects of competition.
Fran Knight,

When I was me by Hilary Freeman

cover image

Hot Key Books, 2015. ISBN: 9781471404924
(Age: 15+) Story: Yesterday, Ella's life was completely normal. Today, she woke up as a different person. Or, to be more exact, she feels like the same person, but she looks different, her friends are different, and every facet of her life is different to what she remembers. At first she thinks she must be crazy, especially since she's the only person who thinks that anything is wrong, but when she meets a stranger named Daniel, she starts drawing closer and closer to the truth . . .
Review: First things first: When I was me is actually a good book. It has an intriguing, very original plotline, some interesting characters, and tremendous amounts of potential. However, this potential is never fully achieved - despite being very promising at first, this book ends up just sitting squarely within the genre of  'teen romance'. While not a bad thing necessarily, the intrigue of the original idea - that of a girl waking up in a life that is not hers, and all the consequences of that - almost feels wasted here. One feels that Freeman could have easily made this into a complex thriller with a dash of science-fiction sensibilities, but instead the book remains simple - at times far too much - and becomes just another run-of-the-mill teen novel rife with romance and friendship dramas. This is not to say the novel is totally flawed, however - there are some excellent themes here at play, and Freeman deals deftly with complicated topics such as finding your identity, and how we perceive reality. The characters are interesting, yet ultimately underdeveloped, and it rollicks along at an exciting pace. But while this novel is definitely enjoyable, it never quite reaches the heights it could have, and ultimately, that's the most frustrating thing.
Rebecca Adams (university student)

Battle of the Heroes by Kate Forsyth

cover image

The Impossible Quest bk 5. Scholastic, 2015. ISBN 9781743624104
(Age: 9-12) Highly recommended. Themes: Fantasy, Magical Creatures, Good and Evil, Sorcery, Quests, Adventures. Kate Forsyth's impressive conclusion to her magical fantasy series Battle of the Heroes pits the four young heroes and their magical creatures against the most frightening of creatures in Wolfhaven Castle. Quinn, Sebastian, Elanor and Tom have escaped the evil witch sisters' clutches by ingenious trickery and begin preparations for a dangerous sea voyage to return to their former home, free the imprisoned lord and his people and fulfill the ancient prophecy. They have gathered the magical elements, a griffin's feather, unicorn's horn, sea-serpent's scale and dragon's tooth and are ready to wake the four sleeping warriors hidden beneath the castle. Sabre the sea-serpent aids the travellers pulling their wooden coracles across the dark treacherous lake.
Each step of their journey is fraught with danger - fighting the spear-wielding bog-men, escaping from the Mistress Mauldred's attacking ravens, relying on their magical creatures for rescue - Tom's griffin helps with Jack's escape. The young adventurers draw on their skills and knowledge to race into the underground tunnels constantly being chased by their enemies. Together they discover the hidden bone key in the Great Room and the secret passage that leads to the sleeping warriors' chamber.
The final battle scenes are heightened drama, fighting a skeleton army riding skeleton horses, fierce giant rats, swash-buckling sword fights and overcoming the witches evil acts that nearly foil the prophecy's fulfillment.
Kate Forsyth's rich imagery, feisty characters, lyrical language, fast-paced action and engaging magic and fantasy elements, make the The Impossible Quest series appealing to both younger readers and adult fans of this genre.
Rhyllis Bignell

Me and Earl and the dying girl by Jesse Andrews

cover image

Allen & Unwin, 2015. ISBN 9781760290184
(Age: 14+) Recommended. For those thinking this contemporary debut is similar to John Green's The Fault in Our Stars, think again. This entertaining and highly realistic novel is not your average 'sick lit'. Greg Gaines is a bit of a social chameleon. His goal is to remain civil with everyone at school but not to belong to any particular clique. After all, Greg just wants everyone to like him. He only has one real friend, the pint-sized and foul-mouthed Earl, who shares his love of film making. At least Greg only has one friend until his mother makes him hang out with Rachel, an old childhood acquaintance who has been diagnosed with leukaemia. Despite Greg's protests, his mother believes that he can use his infamous humour to cheer Rachel up in her time of need. Greg ends up sharing more with Rachel than just his jokes, and he is well and truly pushed out of his comfort zone. The one thing that he tried to avoid, being disliked by anyone, becomes all too hard after all.
Jesse Andrews explores many themes in his debut including grief, peer pressure, poor family backgrounds, and of course, cancer. He tells the story of a leukaemia stricken girl in a very honest way and uses humour to soften the harshness of this topic. Some mature middle school students could handle this book, but it would better suit senior school students due to the language used, and the reoccurring use of drugs and smoking in the novel. Although, both are well within the context of the story and are necessary in exploring the theme of poor family backgrounds. Boys will especially enjoy this truly hilarious and very real novel.
Emma Gay

Blue whale blues by Peter Carnavas

cover image

New Frontier Publishing, 2015. ISBN 9781925059410
(Age: 4+) Warmly recommended. Whales, Depression, Friendship, Environment. When Penguin hears Whale singing the blues, he decides to investigate. He asks what the problem is and Whale points out that his bike is not right. Penguin laughs saying it is just upside down and puts it up the right way and Whale is happy. Later Penguin hears him singing the blues again and asks him what the problem is. Whale is concerned that his bike is getting wet so Penguin gives him a towel to dry it. This story line continues as the Whale sings the blues and Penguin comes along like a good friend to help. Each four page sees something which troubles Whale, and a friend coming to his aid. When Turtle turns up on a trike, Whale laughs when Penguin explains that he cannot use a trike as he has no legs and arms. This evokes a great belly laugh from Whale and the friends are happy that Whale is happy.
A gentle repetition of one line about the Whale feeling happy will be a line readers will call out when each situation occurs. The song to accompany the story is available as a download, and the illustrations will cause a ripple of laughs from the readers as they spy the absurdity of Whale's concerns under the sea. Along the way readers will get a sense of some of the rubbish which eventually finds its way into the oceans, and wonder how it affects the animals that live there.
Fran Knight