Reviews

I broke my trunk! by Mo Willems

cover image

An Elephant and Piggie book. Walker Books, 2011. ISBN 9781406373592
(Age: 3-6) Recommended. Humour. Injury. Picture book. Animal characters. Friendship. Mo Willems manages to entertain with few words and simplified illustrations (and all text in speech bubbles); and young children will love this! With few colours and few words, Elephant tells the convoluted reason for his injured trunk. This begins as a recount of the events leading to his injury (akin in style to the fable, The giant turnip), but leads to a twist connected to his friendship with Piggie. The simple explanation is the basis of the humour, but this is then compounded and magnified when Piggie also gets his own 'broken body part'!
It is a crazy story with silly illustrations, but very appealing for a young audience aged 3-6.
Carolyn Hull

Home of the cuckoo clock by Robert Favretto

cover image

Ill. by David Eustace. Ford Street, 2016. ISBN 9781925272253 (hbk). ISBN 9781925272260 (pbk)
Deep in the Black Forest nestles the village of Schoenwald, frozen in time - but a somewhat chaotic time for there were no clocks and people did things when they felt like it (or remembered) rather than according to hands making a particular pattern on a numbered face. One day a weary cuckoo lands in a pine tree and is dismayed to see the disorder and disarray in the village and so the next morning, and every morning after that, this natural time-keeper for Nature sang out. What a difference this regular greeting made. Until one night a huge storm brought the cuckoo's pine tree crashing down and the cuckoo was blown off the mountain and way down into the valley.
Superbly illustrated in a calm palette and with intricate detail (including a hidden egg on each page) that draws the reader into this isolated village in a beautiful part of the world, this is a perfect story for introducing children to the concept of time and the need to have some order and continuity in our lives. Little ones will have lots of fun imagining what would happen at home or school if everyone could do what they liked when they liked and I can imagine two contrasting murals being created with each child contributing a vignette. Having explored the world of no-time, they could then be introduced to the vocabulary of time - before, after, during, now, then, soon, morning, afternoon, evening, night, dusk, dawn, first, next, last - and the skills of sequencing. Those wanting greater challenges could explore how and why the day is divided into the chunks it is; time zones; time pieces; what they can achieve in a given period of time. Time is the most abstract concept to teach but it is the one that is most prevalent in our lives. To have such a unique story and such stunning illustrations to kickstart its investigation is such a gift.
Students could also have lots of fun enacting a storm (complete with sound effects) so fierce that the cuckoo was blown away as well as predicting what will happen to the village. How could the problem be solved? what role might Franz, the village craftsmen have in that?
The call of the cuckoo might be unfamiliar to some so they could listen to it and discuss why it might be preferable to that of a rooster as a wake-up sound. This could lead into an investigation of familiar bird calls or the reasons behind the 'dawn chorus' as well as setting up a bird-watching station and identifying the common and seasonal birds which visit the school playground. And of course, there is always the old favourite round, Within the shady thicket. Maths, science, history, music and English outcomes could all be explored in this one title.
Further teaching notes are available.
Barbara Braxton

Black Sunday by Evan McHugh

cover image

Omnibus, 2016. ISBN 9781743627990
(Age: 11-15) Recommended. In February 1938, the largest mass rescue on an Australian beach took place when up to 300 people were swept out to sea from Bondi. I knew very little about lifesaving before reading this novel and found it informative and moving, to the point that I now have some understanding of the immense pride and affection that beachgoers have for their local lifesaving clubs and brave members.
Suitable for eleven to fifteen year olds, the story is told in diary form by Nipper, a boy of twelve who idolises his Grandfather and his lifesaving colleagues who patrol the beach at Bondi. Normally I find diary entry chapters tiresome, however the author has worked hard to make the story more interesting than simply leading to the main event, by setting time and place in the context of the post-Depression years in the prelude to World War 2.
Sometimes writers of historical fiction feel compelled to include every tiny detail of remote relevance from their research and there is faint evidence of this. However on the whole it works well and I completely understand why the author chose to do this, given that modern readers may have little appreciation of the simplicity of a time when children routinely left school at thirteen, possessions were few and the sight of an aeroplane was a magical wonder.
Some might consider the inclusion of Indigenous, environmental, gender, refugee and geopolitical issues to be a little busy and contrived. This is because they are all tied in to the story and certain characters voice modern, socially acceptable points of view as a counter to the prevailing attitudes of the time. This will however help younger readers understand historical perspective.
Importantly, this is an exciting story with plenty of structure and drama which recounts an amazing historical event without being a boring lesson. On this momentous day, a series of colossal, freak waves dragged hundreds of people far out to sea in dangerous rips which prevented their return. By chance, a large number of lifesavers beyond those on duty were present for training and they soon plunged into action. What happened was truly stunning and the reader is brought to understand the enormity of the feat by Nipper's description of rips and long training periods where he tries to improve his swimming to a standard which will serve him in later years as a lifesaver.
Informative historical notes are included at the conclusion of the story.
This delightful book would make an excellent text for study at senior primary level and libraries should consider it for general reading.
Rob Welsh

Mechanica by Lance Balchin

cover image

Five Mile Press, 2016. ISBN 9781760401085
(Age: All) Highly recommended. Picture book for older readers, Technology, Machines, Environmental destruction, Extinction, Science fiction, Dystopia. Machines have taken over the role of animals in this dark view of our future, where the continued use of fossil fuels has caused the environment to collapse, species have become extinct and large areas of the world uninhabitable. Built to replace the work done by animals (for example, a mechanical bee was developed to propagate the crops) these interbred with drones built for surveillance purposes when the world descended into war. Their offspring are presented in this highly imaginative and compulsive picture book, set out like a scientific catalogue of a new species. What began as drones escaped into areas beyond human reach and meeting the mechanica, designed by man to replace the animals lost, their offspring become the most intricate and beautiful of creatures, darkly mechanical, steam punk in their design and absorbing in their detail.
Each verso page has the most imaginative of illustrations, depicting one of these mechanica. One I particularly like is on page 23: Interfectorem Apis (scientific name) or Killer Bee, and beneath is given information about where it is found, how it was developed and why it is called a killer bee. An example of its power is given and then facts about the mechanica: its weight, length, speed, power source, sensors and origin. Each fact adds to the knowledge of this bee, giving hints about why it was created in the first place and how dangerous it now can be. It is a formidable bee, and the illustration is staggeringly beautiful. Readers will be enthralled at the detail given, the mechanical elements of the creature and its possibilities. And this is only one of a dozen or so creatures, which aided by a useful index will be enjoyed by readers of all ages. An afterword tells how the person who complied this catalogue has found a real butterfly, so adding a note of optimism to this bleakly dystopian story.
Readers from a young age to adult will pour over these pages, looking at every detail of these creatures.
This powerful image of our future will resonate with many readers, stunned by the destruction of our global environment and concerned at the advance of war technology.
Fran Knight

Mac the Dog Man by Elizabeth Vercoe

cover image

Elizabeth Vercoe, 2016. ISBN 9780994587008
(Ages: 3-6) The author, Liz Vercoe, met Mac in Melbourne during her early morning walks by the river. Her story is about him: a dog walker who is a 'kind-hearted king and the boss of the dogs'. The text is comprised of stories that Mac tells about his dogs ('When I came back, this one was so excited that she jumped right up to my shoulder'), alongside details about Mac's practices ('Mac speaks gently but firmly to all the dogs'), and with refrains of 'The dogs love Mac' and dog noises ('Snoodle! Woff! Yap!'). The text is quite lengthy and the way it jumps around may make it difficult for younger children to follow. Some children may also find it difficult to grasp some of the stories Mac tells about the dogs; but what they will understand is that the dogs love Mac and Mac loves the dogs. The soft watercolour illustrations highlight Mac's gentle nature and the unique character of each of the dogs. This will appeal greatly to dog lovers and the rhythmic language flows beautifully when read aloud.
Nicole Nelson

Snail and Turtle: Rainy Days by Stephen Michael King

cover image

Scholastic, 2016. ISBN 9781760159061 (Ages: 3-6) Friendship. Stephen Michael King brings his distinctive style to this seemingly simple tale of friendship. Snail and Turtle are friends but it has been raining for days and days and Snail will not come out of his shell. Turtle tries performing Snail's favourite tricks, but to no avail. Therefore, Turtle works very hard to build Snail a lovely, warm shelter. Turtle's tenderness and patience with his friend is inspiring and the book carries a lovely message about being in tune with the feelings of others and thinking about how we can bring lightness to their lives. Turtle's smile is obvious the whole way through the story, as he remains optimistic that Snail will one day come out of his shell. As always, King's illustrations are playful, lovable and filled with symbolism. While this is a story with a deep undercurrent of depression and inescapable sadness, I feel like its symbolism may be lost on younger children who may think that Snail is refusing to come out of his shell because it is raining (thereby being confused because snails generally like the rain). While its theme may be appropriate for older children its simplicity makes it more suited to early childhood use. Nevertheless, this book will please fans of its predecessor, Snail and Turtle are friends, as well as those unfamiliar with the pair. Nicole Nelson

Little Koala lost by Blaze Kwaymullina

cover image

Ill. by Jess Racklyeft. Omnibus Books, 2016. ISBN 9781742991283
(Ages: 2 - 5) Belonging, differences, Australian animals, counting. This is an amalgamation of two common picture book structures, comprising a counting element and a plot of a lost animal looking for a place to belong. As implied by the title, one little koala is lost in the bush, so off he goes looking for a place to live. 'Can I live with you?' he asks two marvellous magpies, three tricky turtles, four pesky pelicans, and so on. Each time the animals say no, citing koalas lack of a physical attribute or ability that they have that he does not. The emus tell him his legs are too short for running fast and the magpies ask him how he would greet the dawn when he cannot sing. Just when little koala has lost all hope and begun to cry, ten kooky koalas appear in the trees. 'Would you like to live with us?' they cry. The Aussie landscape depicted on each page and the responses given by the animals that koala approaches give some information about Australian animal behaviours and their habitats. While there is little to set this picture book apart from many others in the same genre, it provides a pleasant reading experience.
Nicole Nelson

Such stuff: A story-maker's inspiration by Michael Morpurgo

cover image

Ill. by Michael Foreman. Walker Books, 2016. ISBN 9781406364576
What a master storyteller Michael Morpurgo is! His body of work and his reputation are both completely awe-inspiring. This unparalleled weaver of dreams who was the UK Children's Laureate from 2003-2005, with over 100 books to his credit (many translated into other languages) and numerous awards, has provided those of us who are such admirers of this work with an unprecedented insight into his writing. This is truly a joint production. When Michael's brother suggested that so many people always ask about how the stories come to life it would be a good idea to write about it, Michael took up the idea with enthusiasm. It was natural to involve his long-time illustrator and collaborator, Michael Foreman, who has often provided him with the germ of an idea for a story. And along with his wife, Clare, he began the task of collating anecdotes, excerpts and background information for the brilliant format of this book.
The story of each book begin with Michael's recount of the first idea, sometimes a real life incident, a media story, an historical fact or a yarn from someone met in a pub. He discusses how the pieces of each story then come together, to be woven into one narrative. At times, many such singular ideas all combined into the one book. Then follows an excerpt from the book in question, these selected by Clare and lastly, a few pages of information that provide back story to the particular theme of each all fascinating and interesting aspects of the relevant title.
As an indulgence I must share this from the chapter on 'I believe in unicorns':
We know the best parents and the best teachers do this, change lives. So often forgotten are the best librarians, dedicated people who go quietly about their business of trying to encourage reading. For many children who are not read to at home, or who have been frightened of books, or bored by them, at school, a good library and good librarian can change the life of a child, by judicious and sensitive recommendations, by arranging book groups, by readings, by inviting authors in to talk to children.
Thank you Michael both for that positive affirmation of our profession but also for the joy you bring to our lives with your superb writing.
I highly recommend this to you for students who are interested in the process of creative writing, for lovers of Michael's work and for your own professional reading. This one stays firmly on my own shelf!
Sue Warren

Mila and the missing lions by Celeste Hulme

cover image

Five Mile Press, 2016 ISBN 9781760066826
(Age: 5+) Lions. Animals. Circuses. Lion taming. A curiously old fashioned conceit of a child wanting to grow up to be lion tamer like her parents will reveal a work environment no longer seen by children. She takes the necessary equipment from her parents' storage chest and makes a mane for her dog, Ralph. But Ralph simply wants to sleep. He is not interested in being Mila's lion so that she can practise. So Mila goes to the cage where her parents keep their lions and inadvertently lets them escape. So begins a game of cat and mouse as Mila asks the other circus people if they have seen anything unusual. She does not want anyone to know what she has done. She walks around the circus until she finally gets to the tent of the bearded lady, an act that the lions seem to like. And sure enough there they are sitting down to afternoon tea with her. Mila works out how to get the lions back in their cage and all is well.
A delightful tale of righting a mistake the child has made, and working something out for herself, while showing a younger generation what an old fashioned circus is like. The illustrations move the story along, adding another level of humour to the story.
I love the double page of framed portraits of Mila's family, and the things being juggled by the juggler, while readers will love following the tail they see escaping onto the next page. And the last page of the text adds another level of humour and anticipation as Mila works out what she wants to do next.
Fran Knight

Valdur the Viking and the ghostly Goths by Craig Cormick

cover image

Ford Street Publishing, 2016. ISBN 9781925272420
(Age: 7+) Highly recommended. Ghost pirates, ghost Vikings and ghost ships. Did you ever wonder what happens to all who are lost at sea? This short, funny story has all of the answers. Valdur is a Viking child who has been sailing the seas, with his father, for hundreds of years. Valdur, his father and their crew are all ghosts. The pirates who attack them are ghosts. The ships the Vikings attack are ghosts. When Valdur's father and most of the crew are kidnapped by the pirate captain, Germanicus Bottom, Valdur is determined to sail after them and rescue everyone. What role will Ragna, Valdur's dog, play? What is salted porridge? Is it the Viking Captain Germanicus is really after?
Valdur the Viking is a quirky, easy to read novel and is highly recommended for boys aged 7+. It is a great step into first novels. The descriptive text is funny and boys will love the pirate and Viking adventure. Who knew ghosts were sailing around out there?
Kylie Kempster

Wiggle and the whale: A book of funny friends by Roger Priddy

cover image

Ill. by Lindsey Sagar. Priddy Books, 2016. ISBN 9781783413522
(Ages: 2-5) Rhyming. Animals. Friendship. Collage. This simple book in the Alphaprints series is explicit in its purpose, initially asking 'What makes a perfect animal pair?', and then explaining that even though friends can be different colours and sizes, all friendships are special. Then follows shorts rhymes about each of the pairs of animal friends: what makes them special and how they are different. The animal pairs are fantastical (including a pink baby bear and a hedgehog), but the drastic differences between them make the message even clearer. While the lower end of the target age may not fully appreciate the message of the story, they will enjoy the simple rhyming text and the fantastic illustrations, which use different objects (as well as many fingerprints) to create the animals and the brightly coloured worlds around them. Photographs of iced donuts create the bear and his lair, the hedgehog's body is a pinecone, and the flamingo's neck is a pink feather boa. Children will love identifying these objects and will enjoy the visual textures they create on each page. The rhymes about each animal, while not always masterful, are mostly pleasing when read aloud and relate accurate information about animal behaviours and habitats. Preschool and early childhood teachers will find this book useful to get children thinking about how they are different to their friends and to discuss diversity. It could also springboard art activities involving collage and fingerprint printing.
Nicole Nelson

The tale of Kitty-in-Boots by Beatrix Potter

cover image

Ill. by Quentin Blake. Frederick Warne, 2016. ISBN 9780241247594
By day, Miss Catherine St Quintin appeared to be a very serious, well-behaved black cat who answered to 'Kitty' whenever the kind old lady who owned her called her. The old lady saw a 'Kitty' with all the pleasant connotations that that name brings to mind but Miss Catherine St Quintin led a double life.
Because by night, when she was supposedly locked in the wash-house, Kitty was not curled up in her basket dreaming sweet dreams until morning. She was not the purring, nuzzling, gentle cat her owner believed her to be. Known to her more common cat friends as 'Q' and 'Squintums', she would leap out the laundry window to be replaced by Winkiepeeps, another black cat who would wait inside until Kitty came home just in case the old lady checked her, while she went hunting dressed in her coat and boots and carrying an air rifle. A female lookalike of Puss-in-Boots.
This particular night she collects her gun from her friend Cheesebox, determined to join Slimmy Jimmy and John Stoat-Ferret as they hunt for rabbits. However, she decides to hunt for mice instead, but being a rather unreliable and careless shooter, that is not very fruitful, only managing to shoot Mrs Tiggy-Winkle's bundle of washing and some sticks and stones that weren't mice at all. Sheep and crows seem a better target until they send her scurrying behind a wall in fright and she gets a big surprise when she fires at something coming out of a hole. Unexpectedly, she has met up with Slimmy Jimmy and John Stoat-Ferret who take her gun off her. But she refuses to hand over the pellets and so a rather adventurous night involving the ferrets, Peter Rabbit, Mr Tod the Fox and Mrs Tiggy-Winkles begins. Suffice to say, it's enough to put Miss Catherine St Quintin off hunting for ever.
The story of this story is as interesting as the tale itself. Potter completed the text in 1914 and created just one illustration but the outbreak of World War I and other events meant she never completed the rest. Thus the story went unpublished in her lifetime. Undiscovered until Penguin Random House editor Jo Hanks found it in the Potter archive at the Victoria and Albert Museum in 2013 and with Quentin Blake accepting the invitation to illustrate it, it has just been published to coincide with what would have been Potter's 150th birthday.
Fans of her works will be thrilled to share just one more adventure from this prolific creator and delight in the appearance of an older, more portly Peter Rabbit who has lost none of his smarts and wily ways as well as other favourite characters from her other books.
Barbara Braxton

Not the same sky by Evelyn Conlon

cover image

On cover: a story of Irish famine girls brought to Australia. Wakefield Press, 2016. ISBN 9781743052426
(Age: 12+) Recommended. Migration, Irish Famine, Indentured labour, Ship life. This book follows a group of four girls amongst a group of Irish orphans, made destitute by the Irish Famine, who came to Australia on The Thomas Arbuthnot, in 1849. They were under the care of Surgeon Superintendent Charles Strutt whose diaries about his voyage are now kept at La Trobe University in Melbourne. In part, these diaries form the basis of the story around these girls' lives. On board ship, Strutt made sure the girls were kept busy with quite a rigorous regime. Rosters were organised for wash days, singing and dancing, sewing and lessons organised so that the girls would have a knowledge of English, more useful than the Gaelic they spoke. They were organised into messes of eight girls each responsible for their own utensils with each having a planned menu, ensuring the girls had a reasonable diet aboard ship. Matrons appointed to look after the girls made sure the deck where the girls lived were scrubbed and kept clean, minimising disease.
Strutt thought about all the problems he was likely to encounter, and set out plans to circumvent these. He made sure the girls, all from different backgrounds, got on well, and were kept away from the crew, and that he and the captain were on cordial relations.
On their arrival in Sydney they were housed in the Barracks, and then allotted families where they would work as servants, some in rural towns, as well as Sydney. Strutt stayed and supervised the girls and their appointments, actually traveling to Yass with one of the groups. He did keep in touch with some and through his visits we hear of what happened to some of these girls, as they found husbands and had children. One of the girls whose lives we follow in this recreation takes on a life on the stage.
Historical fiction makes fascinating reading, as we see into the lives of the girls, based on diaries and historical research. The prologue introduces Joy Kennedy a monumental mason in Ireland who is contacted to build a memorial to these women and her story gives a modern day moral perspective on what happened to them. Life on board the ship was for me the most interesting part of the tale, and Strutt's care and attention to the daily routine of the girls admirable.
For readers interested in a small part of Australia's immigration history then this is a most interesting read.
Fran Knight

Tommy Bell Bushranger Boy: Shoot-out at the Rock by Jane Smith

cover image

Big Sky Publishing, 2016. ISBN 9781925275940
(Age: 8+) Highly recommended. Tommy Bell has been in trouble at school and has been sent to his grandad's farm for the summer. Tommy sees it as a punishment but grandma and grandad don't even talk about the troubles. They just make sure Tommy is busy and give him a horse to work with. Tommy is ecstatic. Horses are his favourite thing. It is the discovery of an old hat that makes life even more interesting as Tommy's grandad believes it is an old bushranger's hat. Tommy now has a connection with the bushranger topic he didn't find very interesting at school. Tommy finds himself back in 1836 and face to face with the bushranger Captain Thunderbolt. How is this happening? Is it the hat? Is Tommy imagining everything?
Tommy Bell Bushranger Boy: Shoot-out at the Rock is a short novel at 63 pages and would make a great read aloud class novel as it links well with the Year 5 History Curriculum. At the end of the book, readers will find historical information on the bushranger, Captain Thunderbolt, and there is also a question and answer section. It is an imaginary interview with the bushranger. Children could create their own version after listening to the story and doing their own research. This novel is great for readers who are venturing into the world of novels and who also enjoy a little adventure. The text is easy to read but still describes events in an exciting manner. It is highly recommended for readers aged 8+.
Kylie Kempster

My feelings ill. by Sarah Jennings

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2016. ISBN 9781408869048
(Ages: 4-6) Board book, emotions. This is about how to cope with and talk about emotions. It requires children to have a grasp on labelling and recognising their emotions already as it does little to identify what they are or what they look like. Rather than telling the reader what it looks like to be worried or scared, shy or happy, it gives practical suggestions for dealing with the feeling ('When you feel scared . . . Run away fast. Say 'I'm scared!''; 'When you feel happy . . . Whistle and sing!, Say hello').
Young children often have difficulty dealing with emotions, even positive ones, so this is a fantastic way to give them practical outlets. The pictures clearly illustrate the suggestions, giving children visual as well as verbal cues. This is a great book for parents to read through in its entirety, but also to pull out during emotional times to help young children find a way to deal with a specific emotion. It is appropriately short, and the bright illustrations and tab cutouts will keep young children engaged.
Nicole Nelson