Reviews

Willy and the cloud by Anthony Browne

cover image

Walker, 2016. ISBN 9781406366969
(Age 4+) Highly recommended. One of my favourite authors, Anthony Browne, has done it again with another wonderful book starring Willy. This time Willy has a dark cloud that seems to be following him, no matter what he does to try and get rid of it. When he goes to the park, everyone else is sitting in the sun and enjoying themselves but he shivers under the cloud feeling miserable. The cloud follows him home and he is very unhappy. He tries to work out how to make it leave, but nothing works until he comes up with a solution to banish it and he can then be happy.
Browne's signature illustrations are as captivating as ever. The misery on Willy's face will ensure that readers will empathise with Willy as he does his best to overcome his unhappiness. The drama of the moment when Willy shouts at the cloud and makes it go away with resonate with readers, who will be thrilled to find that Willy can be happy in the rain and the sun.
This is sure to be a perfect book to discuss feelings with children at home and in the classroom. It could lead to an understanding that everyone can feel depressed, anxious and lonely and Willy has one solution to make his cloud go away. Children may be able to come up with other ways of combating depression and loneliness.
Willy and the cloud is a keeper.
Pat Pledger

When we go camping by Sally Sutton

cover image

Ill. by Cat Chapman. Walker Books, 2016. ISBN 9781921977787
(Age: 5-7) Recommended. Camping. Holidays. Everyone who has ever been camping will relate to this amusing and informative picture book that shows a family on holiday. The whole family, including grandparents and pets, set out on a camping holiday. All the trials and tribulations of setting up a campsite are shown in humorous detail. The family members have to put up the tents, and try to avoid tripping on the guy ropes; they place their sleeping bags inside the tent on the floor and lay down to rest. When all is organised off the children go to have lots of fun at the campsite, swimming, playing with other kids and boiling a billy. They even have to face the long-drop toilet that stinks!
Each double page spread has three lines of verse, with rhyming words and lots of repetition and then a version of the phrase 'smacketty tappetty bopp-io' to suit the picture. Children will have lots of fun trying to guess the words in each of the phrases. The rhymes and onomatopoeia make it ideal to read aloud and independent readers will have a ball finding things to look at on the pages.
The narrative is accompanied by charming pictures by Cat Chapman that not only complement the text but add to it. The grandparents are seen sitting under an umbrella, a little dog appears on most pages and has lots of fun with the children and the bush and beach background is beautifully illustrated in soft pastel colours.
Sally Sutton has written other excellent books, including Roadworks and Farmer John's tractor and this lives up to the high expectations that I had of this author.
Pat Pledger

Granny's place by Allison Paterson

cover image

Ill. by Shane McGrath. Big Sky Publishing, 2016. ISBN 9781925275629
Themes: Grandparents, Family, Change, Australian Social History. For anyone who has had a Grandparent who lives in the country or on a farm or whose grandparents have a house that retains historical accoutrements, rather than a collection of 21st Century mass-produced decor, this book will create links to their personal past. The illustrator has depicted delightful images that speak of social history and life before mass production. The Granny in this book lives initially in a charming house with simple possessions and it has strong appeal for the child remembering holidays there. When Granny moves to the city because of a loss in her life (a fact very gently mentioned for the sake of younger readers), her new home is still a historical snapshot of the 1960s/70s. The child who visits remembers with fondness her visits to Granny's Place.
This book is essentially a virtual time capsule of life from previous generations, and it is perhaps a child's parents (or even grandparents!) who will recognise the features illustrated. The essence of the story is that it isn't the architecture, furnishings or surroundings that make Granny's place special - but rather Granny herself.
With the occasional clumsy sentence structure that would complicate a read-aloud experience, the true hero in this book is the illustrations that open the window to the past. (I had moments of reverie myself!) Teachers may be able to use these illustrations to discuss how life has changed over the generations. For example the pantry on Granny's farm includes a Fowler's Vacola Preserving Unit, and no cans or packets!
(Note: valuable as an Australian Curriculum History resource for Year 1: Present and Past Family Life)
Carolyn Hull

Colours of Australia by Bronwyn Bancroft

cover image

Little Hare, 2016. ISBN 9781742976914
(Age: 6+) Highly recommended. Award winning Indigenous artist, author and illustrator Bronwyn Bancroft celebrates the vibrant hues of the landscape, the earth, sea and sky in her new picture book Colours of Australia. How richly rewarding to read and discover each new setting, beautifully captured in both word and paint. Her words are crisp, clear, and evocative, so carefully chosen to compliment her unique artistic style.
Indigo - Streaks of cloud across the evening sky
Find rest on a bed of mountains

Against a vivid, bold striped background, these purple and azure mountains filled with a myriad of dots reach up to touch the sky. There is a harmony, a fluidity of line, tone upon tone of colour that holds your gaze. After reading the descriptive phrase, take the time to discover 'the raindrops falling, the black shadows on the water and the full moon poised against the night sky.' Tactile exploration, the need to touch the pages, to follow the lines and explore the ways Bronwyn has interpreted the settings, creates meaning and memories for the younger reader.
Colours of Australia makes a wonderful gift for an overseas visitor, with dot-paintings that truly bring our country to life. This is a must-have resource for schools for Visual Arts, English and HASS lessons, for students to gain respect, explore the visual artworks of Aboriginal Peoples, and develop their own artwork and texts.
Rhyllis Bignell

Goodnight everyone by Chris Haughton

cover image

Walker, 2016. ISBN 9781406352320
(Age: 6 months - 6) Highly recommended.
'No dreamer is ever too small, no dream is ever too big'.
Chris Haughton's Goodnight Everyone is a simply told bedtime story, starting with a small yawn, that grows bigger and bigger until all the forest creatures fall asleep. Each turn of the page reveals the mice, hares, deer even Great Big Bear, and they are covered up and almost tucked into bed by the movement of the page. Of course Little Bear will not give, however all the animals are too tired and he too falls fast asleep.
Haughton's mastery of colour saturation, shape manipulation, composition and layout are key elements. Multi-layered digital images in vibrant, rainbow tones encapsulate and enliven this bedtime story. Engagement with the actions from small yawns, to gentle snores and a goodnight kiss opens up the simple, soothing narrative to a young baby.
The front and endpapers show the Southern and Northern night skies with the planets in order from the sun. The Little Bear and Big Bear constellations are highlighted and their shapes transform into the main characters. As the story is shared, look for the dandelion seed blown by one of the mice; it floats through the pages like the circle of life.
The easy to recite responsive text and bold illustrations make Goodnight Everyone by Chris Haughton a fantastic picture book for families to share. He writes about the inspiration for the book here.
Rhyllis Bignell

Ottoline and the Purple Fox by Chris Riddell

cover image

Ottoline, book 4. Macmillan Children's Books, 2016. ISBN 9781447277927
(Age: 7+) Highly recommended. Ottoline and the Purple Fox is a dazzling new story from UK's Children's Laureate, Chris Riddell. It was the first that I had read about Ottoline, but I had no problems with the characters or the plot as it read beautifully as a stand-alone story. Fans of Ottoline will no doubt be thrilled to read another story about this independent little girl and the strange hairy Mr Munroe. In this story the pair meet a purple fox who takes them on an urban safari where they discover all the animals who live in the city. While Ottoline takes notes about the animals, Mr Munroe is intrigued by the poems left on the lamp post and they both want to help the lonely poet find true love. The pair organise a dinner party for all their friends and hope to help out the anonymous poet.
This is a whimsical, humorous story that delights the senses with its wacky ideas and fabulous illustrations. Ottoline is a wonderful girl and the introduction of a new friend, Myrrh, who looks just like Ottoline adds a twist that has the reader thinking about where she fits into Ottoline's life. The purple fox grabs the reader's attention and the journey through the city that he takes Ottoline and Mr Munroe on is fascinating as various animals are shown in amazing habitats.
Each page has something for the reader to linger over and smile about and young readers will be pleased to be sent to other pages for more information. There is a nod to the stories about Goth Girl by Riddell - a subtle hint to the reader that there are other books by this author! At the back is a fancy dress fortune teller that children will love to make and use.
This is a series that is a feast for the imagination for all ages and will richly reward those who are prepared to spend time perusing the illustrations.
Pat Pledger

Mega Weird! by Anh Do

cover image

WeirDo Bk. 7. Scholastic, 2016. ISBN 9781760159092
(Age: 6-8, 8+ will also enjoy the simple humour!) Highly recommended. Themes: Humour, Family, Asian-Australian perspectives, Friendship, School, Identity. Anh Do does it again! He is a talented author, comedian, artist and television personality and his writing for young readers is spot on!
Another book involving the lovable wise-cracking Weir Do, who is up to the usual joke sharing and simple fun stuff that kids love. Anh Do tells the story of the Street Garage Sale and what that looks like for this Asian-Australian family. Their junk-gathering garage should be a gold mine for the family. Or is it just junk? Weir Do helps his family as they aim to raise some dollars for a very special reason. Along the way he also enters a writing competition and tells very funny jokes.
This is a simple chapter book with cartoon illustrations (and few words) that children love for its simplicity and amusing view of the unpretentious things in life. In addition, this series works for children that dislike or struggle with reading as it gives them a means of engagement with books and the entire series takes very little time to consume as there is probably only as much to read as a typical picture book. An Asian-Australian perspective is also refreshing.
Carolyn Hull

Party at Cuddleton Castle by Danny Parker

cover image

Ill. by Guy Shield. Lola's Toy Box series. Hardie Grant, 2016. ISBN 9781760126858
(Age: 5-6) Young Lola's best friend is Buddy a learn-to-dress clown toy with zippers, poppers, buttons and buckles, and together they go on amazing adventures to The Kingdom where toys are living things and magical events happen. When her older brother Nick stops playing hide and seek Lola decides to create her own fun. She chooses to take her friend Buddy and vanish inside her magical Toy Box. Where will this new adventure take them - to The Button Mines or The Story Sea? Of course, Buddy comes to life in the magical kingdom and he is there to help Lola in all sorts of situations. He loves to use alliterative and exclamatory statements - polish my poppers or bless my buttons!
The two friends land in Cuddleton Castle, the land of the Great High Bear and the home of the cuddly toys. In the midst of the festivities for the bear's birthday, a large cake arrives with a hidden dilemma inside. Lola and Buddy use their ingenuity to foil the wicked Plastic Prince's plans so order can return to the castle.
Lola's Toy Box is a series just right for the very young reader as an introduction to chapter books. With large easy to read text and Guy Shield's full page simple line drawings, these books are perfect for 5-6 year olds.
Rhyllis Bignell

Hester and Harriet by Hilary Spiers

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2015. ISBN 9781925266412
(Age: Secondary-adult) Highly recommended. Crime fiction. Humour. Asylum seekers. England. Two widowed sisters, Harriet and Hester, live together in a small cottage in an equally small village in the south of England. When one night they see their local homeless man, Finbar in some distress they find that there is a young woman and a baby in his living quarters, the local bus shelter. They take the girl in, keeping her warm, and feeding her, finding that she has a limited grasp of English and is very scared. At the same time, their nephew Ben, lands on their door step, having run away from home. They must give shelter to all three guests and find that the wayward and taciturn Ben, who in the past has caused some upset within the family, has skills never before known. He is able to talk to Daria, and look after her son, Milo, and even more surprising, finds a talent for cooking.
Problems compound when the women realise that someone has been in their house and Finbar attacked, while a strange man has knocked at their door, asking awkward questions.
The characters are a treat: each pedantic about the use of their language, correcting Ben without a second thought, while homeless Finbar is a classically educated man using Latin phrases. All three have a wonderful grasp of language adding to the pleasure gained in reading. When the women find that their houseguest has no passport and has run away from where she was working in London, only to be taken in by another couple with suspect motives, their impetus to get in touch with the police is stalled by Ben's revelations.
They begin to be aware of Daria's untenable status in this country and resolve to protect her, while at the same time keeping themselves safe.
This is a beguiling read but beneath the word play, humour and mocking tone lies a plea for refugees, asylum seekers, displaced people and those for whom home is no longer a safe place. Through finding out more of Daria's situation in England her legal rights are brought to the fore, giving the readers a firm basis of fact, enlisting their sympathy for people in this position.
Fran Knight

Timmy Failure: The book you're not supposed to have by Stephan Pastis

cover image

Walker Books, 2016. ISBN 9781406369762
(Age: 8+) Humour. Detectives. This is the kind of book written for kids who like silly humour, impossible logic and exceptionally odd and quirky characters who like to solve problems (even if the problems don't really exist). Timmy Failure is a legend in his own mind, and he considers himself to be the world's best young private detective, however his definition of genius and his tendency to see the world from a very warped perspective seem to get him into trouble. With the looming wedding of his mother to Doorman Dave (a man Timmy loathes), and with the punishment of NO detective work until school is over, Timmy takes unusual routes to hide his devious detective agency from her attention, and to avoid participation in the wedding. Failure is intensely awful at detective work, but he does not realise this. He also ropes in classmates with equally dreadful deductive reasoning and manages to just create mayhem wherever he goes.
Pastis has created a series that kids will like, but this is certainly not great literature. With a crazy plot, scattered comedic caricatures throughout the book and silly chapter headings, there are plenty of places to tickle the funny bone of readers aged 8+. But don't expect that they will grow in their maturity and empathy by reading this book... it is more likely that they will giggle at inappropriate moments!
Carolyn Hull

Spark by Adam Wallace and Andrew Plant

cover image

Ford St Publishing, 2016. ISBN 9781925272406
(Age: 4+) Highly recommended. Bushfire. Australian bush. Disasters. A cigarette casually thrown onto the dry grass is the spark which at first flickers but then the wind becomes its friend and helps the spark grow. It races across the dry grass, increasing in size, until it tops the trees and frightens the animals from the bush. It now flies above the tree tops, burning everything in its path. It asks the wind to quieten but it is too late, the wind keeps pushing it along until eventually weakening, it changes direction and the fire is reduced back to where it started, a small spark.
This involving story of taut, measured words shows readers the strength of a fire as it races over the scrub. With both the author and illustrator having first hand experience of fire in Victoria and South Australia (Ash Wednesday, 1983 and Black Saturday, 2009), the words and images are stunningly presented.
Plant's illustrations encapsulate the dreadful intensity of a fire, from the tiny spark to the ferocious firestorm engulfing all in its wake. His use of mixed media including water colour, pencil and crayon present the small flame beginning quietly in yellows with a pale blue sky then building to a intensity of reds and dark yellows, and on to blacks, grays and reds savagely taking up the whole page. Different illustrative techniques convey the changing nature of the fire, and readers will be in no doubt about its destructive force.
This will make a powerful addition to any class study of disasters and fire, of how fires start, of their destruction and place in the Australian environment.
Fran Knight

The Legends series by Michael Panckridge

cover image

Ford St, 2016.
Chasing the break. ISBN 9781925272482
Against the spin. ISBN 9781925272499
(Age: 10+) Highly recommended. Sports. School. With the upper primary reading group such a hard batch to satisfy with good books, it is great to see the republishing of Michael Panckridge's exciting series, The Legends. This is most welcome, with the series repackaged with an up to date cover and blurb, designed to appeal to this difficult group of the reading public. Each of the eight novels in The Legends series are very school based using day to day encounters to develop the plots, involving sports which are part of the school's competitions.
Chasing the break involves a surfing competition at Sandhurst Primary School. One boy, Travis Fisk, won the competition at last year's annual beach camp and intends to win again, but he is challenged by the new boy at school, Mitchell Grady. Told in short, easy to read chapters, the characters are well developed and identifiable, and the integrity underlining the story is easily in reach of every reader. They will cheer the hero as he strives to win despite the odds, overcoming the antagonism of the antihero of the story.
Against the spin has a similar plot line, with Travis nursing his wounds and Mitchell shining on the cricket field as well. But this involves more of Travis' undesirable bullying coming to the fore, and Mitchell and his friends having to deal with his antics both on and off the sporting field.
Exciting, fast paced and easy to read, each of these stories is about one hundred pages long with scores and quizzes at the end for further excitement. The whole set will rarely be left on the shelf.
Fran Knight

Animalia by Graeme Base

cover image

Penguin, 2016. ISBN 9780670079131
Thirty years ago in 1986 an armoured armadillo avoiding an angry alligator appeared from the pen of one of Australia's most iconic illustrators. It was followed by beautiful blue butterflies basking by a babbling brook and a host of other creatures including eight enormous elephants expertly eating Easter eggs; horrible hairy hogs hurrying homeward on heavily harnessed horses; meticulous mice monitoring mysterious mathematical messages; and even zany sabras zigzagging in zinc zeppelins.
For this was the magical, mystical, marvellous Animalia - an alliterative alphabet book and which, after selling more than three million copies worldwide and spawning a television series, is now celebrating its 30th birthday and a whole new audience is set to wonder at its creativity, its detail, its colour and try to spot the tiny Graeme on each page. It is indeed a feast of vivid visual literacy. And underneath the familiar dust cover which so cleverly hints at what is inside is a glamorous golden cover AND a fabulous poster of the lazy lions lounging in the local library. (Great role models for reading!!!)
Since Animalia's original publication we have come to associate Graeme Base with intriguing stories woven around the most scintillating illustrations and if this is your first introduction to his work, you will be on the lookout for his other works.
Congratulations Graeme - thank you for bringing us these superb creatures and creating such riches for our young readers.
Barbara Braxton

His Bloody Project. Documents relating to the case of Roderick Macrae by Graeme Macrae Burnet

cover image

Text, 2016. ISBN 9781925498257
(Age: Capable senior students) Recommended. Shortlisted for the Man Booker prize 2016. His Bloody Project is clearly subtitled as a novel, which is a useful guide as the book has the authenticity of a historical investigation. It has also been described as a 'crime story', that is, a story about a crime and not a 'crime novel'. The text is comprised of a number of sets of documents, including reports from the crime scene, the accused's thoughts written in prison, an account from a psychiatrist engaged to assess the accused and press reports written during and after the trial. The accused is Roderick Macrae, the son of a poor crofter living in a remote village in the Scottish Highlands in 1869. The reader learns that Roderick, aged 16, has admitted to brutally murdering the constable of the village. The crime scene documents detail events seen by a number of villagers who are all shocked and some of whom are sympathetic to Roderick. They agree that he was seen walking to the constable's house with several agricultural implements and returning covered in blood. However, attitudes to the boy differ. The school teacher attests that Roderick was a clever student, a neighbour that he was treated too severely by his father, but the minister that he was wicked and retarded. Roderick's statement is written in gaol at the behest of his lawyer. The reader is given a clear picture of the hardship and deprivation that was part of Roderick's life, though Roderick does not acknowledge that his own circumstances are any more difficult than anyone else's. Roderick's father is a dour, punitive man who seems to accept and administer hardship with a religious zeal. He is a poor farmer and father, and sends Roderick to work for the laird despite the teacher recommending further education. Roderick is dismissed as unsuitable and so is unable to help with the family's finances. Motivation for the murder is provided when the constable harasses the family and finally deprives them of their land. Roderick's lawyer is moved by the statement and hoping for a verdict of insanity engages a psychiatrist. The psychiatrist's report illustrates the nature of psychiatry at that time more than the character of Roderick. Doctor Thompson is supposedly an expert in the criminal mind. He has no interest in Roderick himself and little in justice but rather is concerned with proving his own theories about the criminal physiognomy and the criminal class. He is unimpressed by Roddy's writing though to the reader it seems thoughtful and humble. Doctor Thompson travels to Roddy's village and reinforces his theories by categorizing the villagers as stereotypes of the lowest class. Finally, the newspaper accounts relay the trial and its unsurprising conclusion.
The book is convincing and is a disturbing look at poverty and victimisation. It also, with its use of multiple voices and viewpoints, powerfully illustrates the impossibility of truly understanding the minds of others. It is recommended for capable senior readers.
Jenny Hamilton

Three sisters, three queens by Philippa Gregory

cover image

Allen & Unwin, 2016. ISBN 9781471133022
(Age: secondary) Recommended. English history, Tudors, Henry VIII, Status of women, Scottish history. When Katherine of Aragon comes to the Tudor court to marry Arthur, his younger sister, Margaret looks on with petulant disdain. This woman will be her sister in law, but Margaret is in no mood to be charitable. She will have to take second place to this foreigner who cannot speak English, and Margaret above all else, wants to be first.
However, she must be on her best behaviour at their wedding, as an ambassador is there to confirm her as the wife to be of James IV of Scotland. She is thrilled to be betrothed at twelve hardly able to wait until she marries at fourteen to be a queen.
Her younger sister, Mary is initially betrothed to the Spanish emperor, so the three sisters are to become queens and are all related through Henry. Katherine of Aragon becomes Queen of England when she marries Arthur's brother, the future Henry the Eighth, Margaret is Queen of Scotland and Mary, Queen of France, and their fictionalised lives make fascinating reading. Gregory's research is obvious in the huge amount of detail providing a solid background to these women's imagined lives. Details like James' metal belt worn next to his skin to remind him of his killing his father or Katherine's pregnancies and hair shirt, the progress made by the kings surveying their lands, the clothing and jewelry and extravagance of Henry's court are intoxicating. And the details of court behaviour, the differences between the three courts, the intrigues behind the decisions to declare war and the hapless lives of these women dependent upon the men in their lives, are absorbing to read. Margaret's petulance does not subside, she is ever comparing herself with the other queens, sometimes their solicitous friend, other times disgruntled and critical.
Her life going between Linlithgow, Holyrood, Edinburgh and Stirling Castles, carrying six children and losing all but one, is magnificently retold, ensuring the reader knows all there is to know about Margaret of Scotland and her part in the Stuart succession to the throne of England two generations hence.
She is self absorbed, but her life, always bound but her brother's ambition and political game playing, or that of her husbands and any people currying her favour, made her a more sympathetic creature, tossed around in a world where a woman's voice was seldom given credence.
A wonderful historical novel for those who love reading of Tudor times, and are particularly interested in the role of women in this society.
Fran Knight