Reviews

Hello Lighthouse by Sophie Blackall

cover image

Orchard Books, 2019. ISBN: 9780316362382.
On the highest rock of a tiny island at the edge of the world stands a lighthouse. From dusk to dawn, the lighthouse beams, sending its light out to sea, guiding the ships on their way. As the seasons pass and the waves rise and fall, outside, the wind blows; inside, the lighthouse keeper writes, and the rhythms of his life unfold. But change is on the horizon . . .
Whatever the season, whatever the weather, the lighthouse keeper must keep the light going to warn ships of the dangers nearby. and this stunning book by Australian illustrator Sophie Blackall takes the reader back to a time in history when men lived on these far-flung beacons, isolated from civilisation and charged with keeping the ships and their sailors safe, regardless of whatever might befall them. Set on a lighthouse on the tip of Newfoundland, the story unfolds of the loneliness and the joy of a typical lighthouse keeper who has a duty above all else.
In 2016, Blackall was awarded the Caldecott Medal, the first Australian to receive if for her work on Finding Winnie and now, in 2019, she has won it again for Hello Lighthouse. 'Masterful ink and watercolor illustrations illuminate the story of a lighthouse and the family inside. Stunning images of the lighthouse in all kinds of weather alternate with views of intimate interior detail and circular motifs. Blackall's skill with composition, line and close attention to detail have created an exquisite book.'
But apart from the quality of the illustrations, this is a book that will resonate with so many who are familiar with lighthouses as there are over 350 of them dotted around our coastline. While there are no longer any manned, nevertheless they still hold an appeal and this journey back into another time because regardless of its position, life was pretty much the same for all those who tended the beacons.
Something very different that deserves a place in any collection.
Barbara Braxton

Colouroos by Anna McGregor

cover image

Lothian Children's, 2019. ISBN: 9780734418821.
In the Red Centre of Australia live the red kangaroos; in the Blue Mountains live the blue kangaroos; and on the Gold Coast live the yellow kangaroos. When the drought drives each group from their traditional homes and they go in search of water and end up gathered around the same waterhole, they look at each other and think they are strange. But they all enjoy the cool water, are afraid of dingoes, leap on their long legs and eat the juicy grass and when, at night. 'the colour left to dance in the sky above', they all looked the same. And strange things began to happen . . .
On the surface this is a delightful Australian story for our youngest readers about the mixing of colours to create new ones, and it does this very effectively, although the adult sharing it might have to explain how joeys arrive. Full of colour, rhythm and repetitive text it engages and perhaps inspires the young child to do some experimenting with their own paints and ask What happens when . . .? It could give rise to a host of science and art activities about colour and light.
But a deeper look could also lead the older reader into considering how humans also mix and match, mingle and marry and give birth to the continuing story of multiculturalism and diversity that makes each community so special. Not just colours interacting but also cultures, foods, sports . . .
If there is one book to put on your to-buy list in preparation for the next Harmony Day, this is it. The best picture books span the age groups seamlessly and this debut by this author/illustrator has nailed it.
Barbara Braxton

Kids who did - Real kids who ruled, rebelled, survived and thrived by Kirsty Murray

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2019. ISBN: 9781760524470.
(Age: 10+) Highly recommended. A collection of biographical accounts of the lives of young people who have made a difference is presented in a larger than average paperback book with a few margin illustrations, a contents page which offers the biographies in groups and an index which I found more useful.
Beginning with stories of ordinary kids and their acts of bravery in a chapter called Rescuers, the stories of kids as young as nine are given in a fictional way making it more readable than a large amount of text. This is followed by a chapter called Whizz Kids, showcasing kids and their extreme intelligence, like George who at 11 stumped the professors at Cambridge University with his mathematical skill, not unlike a modern calculator. This is followed by a chapter called Feral Kids with the tale of Victor a child who walked from the forest one day in France and was presumably raised by wild animals. Rulers follows which has stories of historical rulers who struggled to maintain power, like Lady Jane Grey and the Dalai Lama. Each chapter is full of interest and offers a range of lives to ponder, going on to include, rebels, battlers, superstars, change agents, climate warriors and survivors who were/are doing things quite unexpected from people so young. This is an interesting and often inspiring collection of forty stories about young people, some well known, others not so well known, drawn from across the globe and presented in an easy to read way which will attract young readers. They will certainly be intrigued with stories of people of their own age, taking hold of things happening around them, striving to make a difference.
Themes: Children; Biography; Survival; Overcoming difficulties; Fear; Prejudice; War; Sports; Heroes and heroism. Teacher's notes are available.
Fran Knight

Tess of the road by Rachel Hartman

cover image

Tess of the road book 1, Southlands book 3. Random House Books for Young Readers, 2018. ISBN: 9781101931288.
(Age: 14+) Highly recommended. Hugo Award Nominee for Best Young Adult Book (Lodestar Award) (2019). In this highly readable coming of age story, Tess is a troublemaker. After trying to be good for the sake of her twin sister Jeanne who is getting married, she once again finds herself in disgrace, after punching a relative's nose. Being told that she must go to a nunnery, she decides to run away and takes to the road where she meets once again an old friend, a quigutl. Together they travel across the land, both carrying the past with them.
Set in the same world as Seraphina, 2012, and Shadow scale, 2015, fans of this series will welcome another stand-alone story that features dragons and a girl who won't bow to pressure to be good and behave as a docile young woman. The reader is gradually exposed to Tess's backstory and the reason why she is shunned by her mother. It is a heart breaking one that will remain in thoughts for quite a time after finishing the book as the reader thinks about the way girls are treated and how they are blamed for mistakes made, while young men are able to act irresponsibly and thoughtlessly. However Tess is resilient and compassionate, intelligent and strong, and she makes the most of the lessons that she learns on the road in her quest to find the origins of the quigutl.
Tess of the road has an original and unique fantasy setting, with relatable characters and themes of resilience and empowerment and well deserves its Hugo nomination. I look forward to the next book about Tess's life.
Pat Pledger

Love, luck and the demon by John F. Roe

cover image

Wakefield Press, 2019. ISBN: 9781743056431.
(Age: Adult) Non-fiction. Memoir. This is very much a love story. John F. Roe tells how he fell in love with Ella the first time he saw her, but through various misadventures it wasn't until years later that they actually came to spend much time together and then to get married. Roe describes his life then as incredibly lucky, to be with the woman he loved, to gradually find a rewarding career in teaching, and to have adventures in England, Rhodesia, and eventually Australia. His descriptions of that time are rich with wit and humour and many references to the literature he loves - reminding us how powerful literature is in sharing experience and understanding.
We know that his luck changes, because the first chapter warns us of the demon that comes to haunt his dreams and invade his life. And as we read on there are mentions of what is to come - but always that is for later. Really more than two thirds of the book is full of happy memories and funny stories - which must have brought so much pleasure to write. Because what does eventually come is incredibly sad. The writing changes as Roe goes on to tell us of the demon of dementia that took over his beautiful and intelligent wife, causing a horrible period of distrust and unhappiness. Through all that time, the doctor consultations and the eventual move to nursing care, he held onto to the love that still united them, and there are lovely accounts of their outings, him pushing her in a wheelchair, to all their favourite cafes and shops near the care home in North Adelaide.
Dementia is a cruel disease, and it is something that more and more of us are going to have to confront, as it is predicted to become the second most lethal killer, after heart disease. What is uplifting about this story is how Roe managed to keep love central to their life, and the care and companionship he provides for Ella is rewarded by happy moments of shared memories even at the end.
Helen Eddy

The talent show by Delphine Davis and Adele K Thomas

cover image

Mermaid holidays book 1. Penguin, 2019. ISBN: 9780143796510.
(Age: 6-8) Delphine Davis and Adele K Thomas introduce us to the underwater world of Turtleville where four special mermaid friends live with their families. Best friends since they were little merbies, Sophia, Willow, Chloe and Olivia love meeting up again after returning from their separate boarding schools. This is a special holiday, and something exciting is about to happen, Turtleville's first Talent Show.
Sophia Seashell is especially excited; she loves to sing and wants her friends to be backup singers for the performance. Her sidekick Smedley Seahorse cautions Sophia to consider what her other friends are planning. When they meet to practice at the lagoon, Sophia arrives last, excited to share her ideas. Wearing her super sparkly popstar sunnies and holding her glittery microphone, Sophie launches into one of The Flyfish Girls pop songs. Her friends are taken aback. They don't want to sing; they can't sing. Smedley tries to smooth things over to no avail.
Team work requires cooperation, listening to everyone's ideas and working together, and that's just what the best friends do in the lead up to their performance. Will they win the prize, tickets to The Guppy Cove Adventure Park?
The talent show presents a gorgeous underwater world, filled with sea creatures and sparkly mermaids. Pink borders and accents enhance the story and add fun to the delightful cartoon illustrations. Written in a fun and charming style with plenty of alliteration and special pops of pink-coloured exclamations and highlighted words, this story is just right for mermaid-loving young readers.
Themes: Mermaids, Friendship, Performing arts.
Rhyllis Bignell

All right already! by Jory John and Benji Davies

cover image

HarperCollins, 2019. ISBN: 9780008330033.
Bear and Duck are neighbours - but two more different would be hard to find. Bear is huge, slow and somewhat grouchy; Duck small, energetic and always looking for fun. Told in dialogue with each character having their own font that cleverly echoes their nature, each story focuses on a conflict between the two as Bear wants one thing - usually a quiet life - while Duck wants the opposite. And it is the same in this latest addition to this series for very young readers...
It has snowed overnight and Duck wants to make the most of the fun it offers while Bear wants to stay in his cosy warm house. Even after Duck coaxes him out he is a reluctant participant in the games and when he starts to sneeze, Duck bundles him back inside (where he wanted to be all the time) and assumes the role of nurse. But Bear is not particularly grateful and when Duck begins to sneeze too and heads for her home, it remains to be seen whether Bear will step up and nurse her.
Apart from being a charming story that young readers will enjoy, there is much it offers for the development of early reading behaviours for them as well. Firstly, being a series, it is an opportunity for the adult to ask the child what they remember and know about the characters already so their thoughts are already set to the contrasting characteristics of each. When Duck goes to Bear's house, full of excitement and anticipation, what sort of reception is she likely to get? There is also the opportunity to explore the concept of dialogue as the whole story is told in conversation with Duck's voice in a different, lighter font to that of Bear's. It offers lots of things to chat about such as why it snows and why most Australian children won't wake to a snowy morning; how we need to protect ourselves from catching a cold and how we can keep from spreading the one we have, and also the things we can do to make a friendship solid and sustainable.
While bedtime stories should always be about the bond and the connections between reader and listener, there are subtle ways that these concepts about print can be shared so that the young one engages even further with the story and becomes even more determined to become an independent reader.
Barbara Braxton

The oceans between us by Gill Thompson

cover image

Headline Publishing, 2019. ISBN: 9781472257956.
(Age: 16+) Highly recommended. It was 1941. Jack has happy memories of his mother holding him, as a 5 year old, in her arms, singing and dancing with him, then hiding with him under the table at the sound of sirens and German bombers flying over London. But one day whilst he is at school, there is an explosion, and his whole world is changed forever. His mother disappears, and Jack ends up in the dormitories of Melchet House run by the Catholic nuns, a life of chores and punishments.
Unbeknown to Jack, his mother survived the explosion but was left with amnesia. She passes her time in a hospital ward desperately looking for something she is missing, but she doesn't know what it is.
Life becomes worse for Jack as he becomes one of the thousands of children shipped to Australia to a promised land of sunshine and oranges. However, far from being a paradise, Bindoon, the Boys Town, is a place of hard labour, beatings and abuse. Jack eventually has an escape, taken to be adopted by Kathleen and John, an Australian couple unable to have children. But he can't forget the suffering of the other boys and when his friend Sam dies there, Jack is determined to one day seek justice.
Thompson's novel brings together many themes: the suffering and abuse of child migrants brought to Australia and placed in harsh institutions; Aboriginal children taken from their parents to live a life of servitude; the racism in Britain towards the Jamaican immigrants who came on the Windshuttle; the threat of the childhood disease of polio; and the crude treatment of mental health patients. The novel paints an authentic picture of the times, and would be of interest to students studying the history of the period. It concludes with the apologies of both the British and Australian prime ministers to the children shipped to Australia as child migrants, told they were orphans and brought to Australia without their parents' knowledge or consent.
This book would make an interesting comparison with Jae-Dee Collier's Jae-Dee survives the home of many mothers (2019), a fictionalised account drawn from the author's memories of her life as one of the forgotten children in Australian orphanages, more of a memoir than a novel. Thompson's story builds a wider context to the experience of the institutionalised child, yet both share the loneliness and fear the children suffered, and their longing for kindness and love. Both stories reveal the long-standing aftereffects of abuse.
That is not to say that The oceans between us is difficult to read. On the contrary, we are drawn into the lives of the characters; there is romance, and there are happy as well as sad moments. I thoroughly recommend it - it keeps the reader engaged until the very last page.
Helen Eddy

The wall in the middle of the book by Jon Agee

cover image

Scholastic, 2019. ISBN 9781760663490.
(Age: 4+) Highly recommended. Themes: Walls, Barriers, Prejudice, Isolationism. A solid brick wall appears in the centre of each double page. A child in armour appears with a ladder, and tells the reader that his side of the book is safe because the wall is there to protect him from whatever is on the other side. The other side has a range of large animals: a rhinoceros, tiger and baboon, all interested to see over the wall. But a small mouse happens along and scares them away. On the safe side, water appears to be rising rather rapidly, causing the boy to climb the ladder even higher, while on the other side the animals are replaced by an ogre. The boy tells us that the ogre is the scariest thing on the other side, but when the water keeps rising and he is about to drown, or perhaps be eaten by the lurking crocodile, the ogre leans over the wall and plucks him to safety.
The boy is frightened when he realises that he is on the other side of the wall. He tells the ogre that he is frightened that he will be eaten, but the ogre assures him that this will not happen and shows him around. All his fears vanish as he is befriended by the animals and plays with them.
Readers will laugh out loud at the contrast of what is happening on each side of the wall, especially when the 'safe' side becomes anything but safe as the little fish are swallowed by a bigger fish then a much larger fish as the water rises.
Readers will understand the theme of the book, that walls do not make us safe, and discuss the way walls are used to give an impression of safety in various situations. And unfortunately there are a lot of examples around the world of wall building to draw upon.
This is a laugh out loud look at the aim of keeping safe through building walls, where building bridges would be more appropriate.
The watercolour and pencil illustrations are just wonderful, the drawing of the wall down the centre of each page underlining the difference between each side and causing much hilarity when the situation is reversed.
Fran Knight

And then there were four by Nancy Werlin

cover image

Speak, 2018. ISBN: 9780147510266.
(Age: 14+) Recommended. A book for mystery lovers, Werlin has written an easy to read and engrossing story about five teenagers who escape death when a building collapses on them. It is not an accident, someone is trying to murder them. Gradually the group piece together a theory, unlikely as it may seem.
The plot contains enough twists and turns, unexpected events and red herrings that the reader will be kept guessing until the end about the teens' theory and whether it is true.
Written in two alternating voices, that of Saralinda del la Flor and Caleb Colchester, Werlin skilfully draws out the characters and events that befall the group. Saralinda's voice is quite unique with exclamation points and strange sayings and once the reader becomes accustomed to it, is very enjoyable to read. Caleb's on the other hand is darker and told in the second person. All the characters are unique and interesting, particularly Saralinda who has a club foot and diabetes, but who with humour, manages to often be the voice of reason in this diverse group. Caleb has suffered all his life, labelled a bad boy, Kenyon is an outspoken young woman who has used social media to call out a rape, while Evangeline and Antoine are popular school leaders. As a group they don't appear to mesh well, but when one of them dies, they have to work out a way to stay alive and use each other's skills and expertise. And there are some budding romances as well.
Mystery readers who enjoy books by Lauren Oliver and Karen McManus are likely to enjoy the fast pace and suspense of And then there were four.
Pat Pledger

Fart Monster and me: The class excursion by Tim Miller and Matt Stanton

cover image

ABC Books. 2019. ISBN: 9780733340215. 57p
(Age: 8+) Recommended. Themes: Humour, Speculative/Sci fi. Ben Dugan takes his Fart Monster to school. His teacher, Mr Bendentoot has organized an excursion to the Space exhibit at the local museum. On the bus, various children deny causing the foul emissions of the Fart Monster. At the museum, Professor Wilson demonstrates the interactive displays to the class, which cleverly foreshadow the novel's twist! After Fart Monster failed to find his home in the simulated Solar System, an anti-gravity experience keeps Lucy, Carter, Dave, Laura and the rest of the class occupied while Ben and the Fart Monster investigate the Space Shuttle display.
Fart Monster convinces Ben to read the instructions so that they can use the shuttle to take him home to his beloved 'Let her Rip' planet. Despite his reservations, Ben and Fart Monster take off. Their spacecraft stalls with their destination in sight but they solve the problem and land the space shuttle. What will Fart Monster's planet be like? How is Ben going to get home?
Another bodily function narrative with pleasing caricatures, guaranteed to make you laugh out loud.
Deborah Robins

Find Spot at the library by Eric Hill

cover image

Penguin Random House Children's, 2019. ISBN: 9780241365694.
(Ages: 1-4) Themes: Libraries, Board book, Lift the flaps book. Lift-the-flap books are usually instant winners with little ones, especially when there is a cheeky animal or two hiding behind and this third title in a new Spot series (previous titles are Find Spot at the zoo and Find Spot at the museum) is no exception. The series is a real nod to the original Where's Spot first published in 1980, and while Eric Hill may have passed away in 2014 these have been done with the same humour and fun that has seen generations of children fall in love with his books. Young children will especially love finding Spot at the end, all dressed up in his tiger costume for dress-up day at the library (it would have been better if they had to lift a flap to find him though). All his friends are there for the party too. The book also includes all the elements that children love about visiting the library: borrowing and returning books, story time, sing-along time, playing and creating and quiet reading. This series will be a real hit with toddlers, and this title a definite must for little library lovers.
Nicole Nelson

When the war is over by Jackie French

cover image

Illus. by Anne Spudvilas. Angus and Robertson, 2019. ISBN: 9781460753026.
(Age: 10+) Highly recommended. A powerful book written in poetry by the word master, Jackie French, depicts the return of those who have fought in the wars from WW1 to the present day. The book does not try to give details of the wars, just the endings showing when and how those who fought came home.
Jackie French has crafted a wonderfully moving poem that is easy to read aloud while the illustrations by Anne Spudvilas are so poignant that they will certainly bring tears to the eyes of most of the readers that pick up this book. The joy, the desperation, the heartbreak and the loss that war brings is shown in each illustration with a great diversity of subject by the illustrator.
It will be a favourite in schools for Anzac Day and Remembrance Day resources as it is short and direct and will bring about much discussion about all the different wars to which Australia has sent people to fight, many that children will not know about.
It could act as a spring-board for further research for the Year 10 History curriculum into war and conflicts around the world.
For younger children just analyzing each picture and what the illustrator was trying to show for that war will provide some marvelous discussions in Middle and Upper Primary classes.
Teacher's notes are available. Themes: Peace, Love, World wars, Family reunion.
A great addition to this subject area for all schools and libraries.
Gabrielle Anderson

Catch a falling star by Meg McKinlay

cover image

Walker Books, 2019. ISBN: 9781925381207.
(Age: 10-14) Highly recommended. Themes: Family, Skylab, Death, Grief, Coming of age, Friendship, Astronomy. McKinlay is an Award winning author (Prime Minister's Literary Award-winning A Single Stone, and CBCA-shortlisted No Bears and Duck for a Day) and has written an engrossing and heart-wrenching story dealing with a death in the family and its aftermath. Frankie Avery is left looking after her young brother Newt (short for Newton) while her mother works very long hours as a way to forget the death of her husband, which is never mentioned in the house. The news stories of the imminent fall of Skylab bring back many memories of the times she and her father watched the skies through their telescope and seem to have affected Newt, who begins to act strangely.
The historically accurate setting in 1979, when Skylab is going to fall out of the sky, provides an excellent background for McKinlay to explore the dysfunctional family dynamics in Frankie's household. She is the one who must ensure that Newt is safe, but she is little more than a child herself. As the threat of Skylab looms, it looks as if Frankie won't be able to manage anymore and she desperately needs a way to cope.
McKinlay is an expert wordsmith, who brings both the characters and the setting to life with vivid imagery and description. Readers will find themselves shedding a few tears along the way as they hope that things will improve for Frankie, while despairing about the grief that has led to the neglect from her mother.
This would make an ideal class set or literature circle book, as well as one that would read aloud very well. Teacher notes are available.
Pat Pledger

52 Mondays by Anna Ciddor

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2019. ISBN: 9781760523480.
(Age: 8-12) Recommended. It's 1960's Australia and Anna is a young girl with a strong wish. She desires a doll similar to Hitty, the doll in her favourite story.
Anna's family try to help her find the doll of her dreams and they decide that the best place to find the perfect doll is at the weekly Monday auctions, hence the title 52 Mondays, the number of weeks of patient searching it takes to fulfil Anna's wish.
During the years search, we get to see everyday life in Anna's home, a loving caring household where simple everyday events such as birthday parties, fixing broken china and playing in the backyard are gently told.
There are insights into Anna's Jewish background and her visits to her grandparents give an understanding into the family's recent history.
This novel is based upon the author's own childhood and I enjoyed the picture she painted of a simpler post war Australia. There are many 1960's insights into everyday life, playing with paper dolls, delivery of milk by a milkman and having photos developed to be picked up later.
Throughout the novel there is a strong sense of family love and understanding.
I recommend this book to 8 to 12 year olds.
Jane Moore