Reviews

The Mercies by Kiran Millwood Hargrave

cover image

Picador, 2020. ISBN: 9781529005127. 256pp.
Maren lives in the tiny settlement of Vardo on a Norwegian island in the Barents Sea close to the north-east border with Russia. It is 1617, a time when Christianity is concerning itself with devilry and witchcraft. On Christmas Eve a sudden storm drowns most of the Vardo menfolk who had put to sea to capture a school of fish. The storm drowns Maren's fiancee, Dag, her brother Eric and her father as well as the pastor. Altogether 40 men die and the women of the settlement grasp at reasons, including the suggestion that the devil sent the storm. Eric's pregnant wife, Dina, is from the Sami, the indigenous people of the area and the devout women direct suspicion at her, saying the Sami can call the devil. After nine days the bodies of the men begin to wash ashore and the women retrieve the bodies and store them until the earth thaws enough to bury them and Dina brings a Sami shaman to watch over the bodies and conduct rites for the dead creating further conflict. However the need to survive without the men leads the women to work together and put out to sea, netting fish as their menfolk had done. Eventually Pastor Nils Kurtsson is sent to lead the community but some of the women have tasted independence and found strength in it. When a Lensmann, Hans Koning, a kind of lord or sherrif, is appointed, he in turn appoints a Commissioner, Absalom Cornet, to travel to the village, stamp out any heathen tendencies and promote the church. He brings with him his bride, Ursa, from Bergen to the south. As Absalom starts to pursue his agenda, Ursa forms an unlikely friendship with Maren. The narrative swings from Maren's perspective to Ursa's and they both watch with horror as the witch hunting in the settlement starts to unfold.
Based on historical events, the narrative reflects on some of the uglier aspects of human nature and the redeeming qualities of true loyalty and friendship. A hitherto unexamined period and setting that will appeal to readers of historical fiction.
Sue Speck

Peter and the tree children by Peter Wohlleben

cover image

Illus. by Cale Atkinson. Schwartz Books, 2020. ISBN: 9781771644570. 40pp.
(Age: 4-10) Peter Wohlleben, a German forester, writes on ecological themes. His 2015 bestseller book for adults, The hidden life of trees, explains in simple language what trees feel and how they communicate. His writings are based on his own experience within forests as well as on scientific findings. Peter and the tree children is his first children's book (apart from a young readers' edition of The hidden life of trees titled Can you hear the trees talking) and it introduces children to the idea of tree families, the importance of old growth forests and the impact people have on the way forests grow. Peter explains to the reader in a letter at the start of the book that Piet is a real squirrel who lives in the forest around his home in Germany and that in the forest is a spot where no one is allowed to cut down any beech trees so that the tree family can exist and grow unimpeded.
The fictionalised story follows Peter as he leads Piet through the forest to find the tree children. Along the way Peter helps Piet to understand that trees often need the protection of older, taller trees to grow up properly, that heavy equipment compacts the earth so that it is difficult for little trees to thrive, that squirrels help start beech seedlings and that some trees release an orange-smelling distress signal. There is also some extra information about trees and their families given at the end of the story, which expands on the detail given within the story.
The cartoonish illustrations are pleasing enough but lack the grandeur that could have been useful for portraying the immensity and intricacies of the forest. This was a missed opportunity, as was the decision to focus on Piet and his lack of a family (as well as lots of seemingly empty text) rather than giving more time to the what, how and why of tree communication. This is inarguably an important book because of the pressing and unique nature of its message, but disappointingly it doesn't completely hit the mark.
Nicole Nelson

Gregory Goose is on the loose: Up the mountain by Hilary Robinson and Mandy Stanley

cover image

New Frontier, 2020. ISBN: 9781925594942. 18pp. board book.
(Age: 0-3) Gregory Goose is on the loose up the mountain, is a sweet board book by Hilary Robinson and Mandy Stanley. It is one of 4 Gregory Goose is on the loose books, all featuring Gregory in a variety of locations (on the moon, in the jungle and at the fair).
In this story he is situated on a snowy mountain and is having lots of fun. Each page has a short sentence about where he might be, encouraging the young reader to search through the pages and find this cute little goose! There are also other animal friends to find on each page including a bear, rabbits and a beaver.
The story is an easy little rhyme, that is short and could be used to introduce the concept of a question (as each page is a question).
I really loved the vibrant illustrations and facial expressions of all the characters both human, animal and snowman! This book would be excellent for young children from a year old, up until approximately 3 years old - or even for a beginner reader sibling to read and share.
A lovely sturdy book that will hold up to many years of rough reading and enjoyment!
Lauren Fountain

Azaria : A true history by Maree Coote

cover image

Melbournestyle Books, 2020. ISBN: 9780648568407. 45pp.
(Age: 8+) Highly recommended. This is a matter of fact and honest illustrated summary of the case of the disappearance of Azaria Chamberlain in 1980. Coote has been responsible for a number of award winning children's books, including Animology: The big book of letter art alphabeasts but this is the first to really tackle a serious issue, the hugely shameful miscarriage of justice in Australia. She simply tells the tragedy, from the hysterical public and media reaction, to the poor initial investigation and subsequent jailing of an innocent mother, Lindy Chamberlain. From the outset the Anangu Aboriginal people should have been consulted. Thankfully the truth was discovered but it took over 3 years for Lindy to be released from jail and 32 years for her name to be cleared. There were positive outcomes and changes to the law as a result. We also learnt from other incidents across Australia that dingoes are wild animals and more than capable of attacking humans.
The large digital illustrations are fantastic at capturing the mood and the place and they support and add to the text so well. From the fabulous colours of the red desert and Uluru, the night time pictures of people looking for Azaria while the sand is covered in dingo footprints and the sad eyes of Lindy. There is much symbolism to discuss in these illustrations and I believe rich conversations could be had around this by parents and teachers with children. (There are teaching notes available on-line). There is not a lot of text but it has clearly been carefully researched and it is very succinct and meaningful. You could certainly discuss how the book alludes to this being a modern fairy tale. It is interesting to reflect on how rumour and gossip can fan out to judge people unfairly. One can only imagine with some trepidation what would have happened in this age of social media.
Jo Marshall

Snap by Belinda Bauer

cover image

Transworld Publishers, 2018. ISBN: 9781784160852.
(Age: Adult - Senior secondary) Highly recommended for lovers of crime novels. Booker Prize Nominee for Longlist (2018), and Theakston Old Peculier Crime Novel of the Year Nominee for Shortlist (2019), Snap is a novel for one or two sittings. It is dark and engrossing with moments of humorous dialogue to lighten the story. It also has non stereotypic police officers and a 14 year old boy, Jack Bright, who is really the hero of the story. Years earlier Jack had been left in the car with his two sisters when it breaks down. His mother goes off to get help leaving him to look after his sisters. Then she doesn't come back, her body found in a ditch days later. Jack's father cannot cope and leaves the children alone, Jack once again in charge and having to support them all to keep away social welfare. He turns to theft to feed and clothe the family, trying to navigate a house full of newspapers that his sister Joy uses to make tunnels throughout the house, and a little 6 year old sister Merry who is precocious. Then there is pregnant Catherine who wakes up to an intruder in her house and a note that says: 'I could have killed you', and a knife that she hides in her underwear drawer. DCI John Marvel who has been banished to Taunton after failing a job in London, is not particularly interested in solving the burglaries committed by the Goldilocks burglar, but when he gets a whiff that a murder might be involved, becomes involved in trying to solve the cold case of Jack's mother's murder.
Bauer draws a poignant picture of Jack, a boy who breaks into the homes of happy families and lies in the beds of the children, trying to remember a happy time in his own life before his mother was murdered. Goldilocks is the nickname that he is given by the police and when he finds some evidence that might lead to his mother's killer, he is determined to get help even if it means that he will be arrested. The suspense around whether Catherine will be the next victim of the killer and whether Jack's attempts to keep his family safe will fail, keep the reader breathless until the stunning end to the story.
I will certainly be picking up more books by Belinda Bauer. This is a must for readers who enjoy mysteries and suspense.
Pat Pledger

Almost a mirror by Kirsten Krauth

cover image

Transit Lounge, 2020. ISBN: 9781925760507.
(Age: Adult) Highly recommended. Krauth once wrote of Bill Henson's images that they walked "that blurry line between the acceptable and forbidden, innocence and knowing". Her latest book Almost a mirror explores this territory: the opening chapter has a young girl, Mona, being posed and photographed by photographic artist Dodge while her mother Kaz sits in a back corner. Dodge creates images of beautiful young bodies, innocent, but always on the edge of being sexually enticing.
It is 1980's Melbourne, the music scene, with rock bands and ardent young fans, under-dressed and over made up, hanging outside stage doors with autograph books in hand; the time of the Kids in the Kitchen, and Nick Cave and the Boys Next Door. Each chapter of the book is inspired by an 80s song; you can listen to a mixtape on YouTube as you read.
Chapters interweave the past and the present, images and scenes, pieces of the story that gradually come together. They reveal episodes in the lives of teenagers Mona and Jimmy, and of Benat, a musician, immersed but also a spectator on the edge of the music and drugs scene. They are all young, vulnerable, exploring, taking risks, living life on the edge.
At the heart though, is the relationship between adults and children. The 1980's, whilst a time of teenagers and rock bands, was also the time when Australia suddenly became aware of child sexual abuse. Adults became unsure what was acceptable and what was not. Child abuse, sexual abuse, neglect, all were issues that we had to confront, and try to understand what was going on. In Krauth's story, the photographer Dodge is an artist; when asked about it, all that Mona's mother Kaz can say is that Dodge had won them all over, the critics, the parents, the teachers and headmistress.
For Jimmy though, the hurt was forever.
Almost a mirror collects images and thoughts, snippets of life, like a collage that can constantly be rearranged to explore the relationships, and try to understand what was happening. At the same time it presents beautiful interactions between parents and children, just as the galahs hover over the young bird at the side of the road. There is love and grief. And you can rewind, go back and read it over again (as I did.) Or listen to the music.
Themes: Music, Rock bands, Suicide, Sexual abuse, Parent child relationships.
Helen Eddy

Haywire by Claire Saxby

cover image

Australia's Second World War series. Omnibus Books, 2020. ISBN: 9781742769196. 240pp.
(Age: 12-16). Highly recommended. The second book in a new series of stories about the second World War, this story follows the journeys of two adolescent boys who are affected by the War, one living in an outback town in Australia and one living in Germany at the time Hitler invaded Poland. Claire Saxby has written the story in alternating chapters to tell their stories alongside one another which gives the reader a complete picture of how the war impacted children around the world.
Tom Hanlon has been forced to give up his dreams of becoming a doctor to help in his family's bakery when his two brothers go to fight in Europe. He resents the fact that he can't follow his dreams but commits to staying and assisting at home.
Max is a young boy whose family is in trouble in Germany because of their political beliefs and they decide to send him to live with his uncle in England. This is a temporary solution as England decides to put all Germans and Italians into internment camps, first in England and then in Australia or Canada. Max endures so much on his journey to Australia and when he arrives at the Internment camp in Hay all he wants is a quiet life. But he still must suffer the attentions of some bullies in the camp and quickly learns to be helpful in the kitchen where these bullies never go. There he meets Tom, who is delivering bread from his bakery to the Internment camp. They quickly form a friendship and tell each other their hopes and dreams. Both wish they could escape their lives, Max to go back home to Germany and Tom to go and study in Sydney.
The first book in this series is War and resistance by Sophie Masson and both books contain a great mix of historical fact and entertaining drama and will keep any reader absorbed to the end. They would be a great addition to the Year 10 History work as they present lots of opportunities to research some of what happened to the children during wartime. Themes: World war II, Boys, Friendship, Family, Prejudice.
Gabrielle Anderson

To the bridge: the journey of Lennie and Ginger Mick by Corinne Fenton

cover image

Illus. by Andrew McLean. Walker Books, 2020. ISBN: 9781925126822. 40pp.
(Age: 4+) Highly recommended. This is the amazing story of nine year old Lennie Gwyther who rode his horse, Ginger Mick from Leongatha to Sydney to see the opening of the Sydney Harbour Bridge, a journey of six hundred miles.
Lennie had always been thrilled to read of the building of the bridge, the first to read of its progress when the newspapers were dropped off at the siding near his family's farm in Victoria.
When Lennie's dad broke his leg, Lennie took over his role on the farm, feeding the chickens, chopping firewood, milking the cows and ploughing the fields. When dad came home he was so impressed with his son that he promised him a reward. All Lennie wanted to do was to see the opening of the bridge.
Father could see how much he wanted to do this, that he gave his consent. He set out, charging through bushfires, crossing the Snowy Mountains, meeting swaggies along the road, meeting school children who had heard of his quest, passing though Canberra where he was met by the Prime Minister, Jo Lyons, finally arriving in Sydney, thirty three days after leaving home. People along the way gave him food and shelter. He became well known and on March 19, 1932 he rode across the Sydney Harbour Bridge and made history.
Andrew McLean's wonderful pencil and watercolour illustrations take in the sweep of the countryside in Victoria and New South Wales, showing the contrasts that make up Australia's environments, stunningly reprised in the end papers. His city scapes too are dazzling, recreating the feel and look of Sydney during the Great Depression, when the building of the Sydney Harbour Bridge was a government sponsored program designed to keep men in work.
The images of Lennie will entrance the readers as they can see how young and small he is to undertake such a feat, marvelling at the miles he rode, comparing them perhaps with themselves and the small steps they take.
More information of the story of young Lennie can be found in any Google search and images of the lad and his horse crossing the bridge can be seen. Another book about his exploit was published in 2015 by NLA,
Lennie the Legend: Solo to Sydney by Pony (Stephanie Owen Reader) so children may like to read them both. Teacher's notes are available. Themes: Sydney Harbour Bridge, Australia - history, Sydney NSW, Journeys.
Fran Knight

The good turn by Dervla McTiernan

cover image

HarperCollins, 2020. ISBN: 9781460756799.
(Age: Senior secondary - Adult) Highly recommended. If charmed by enigmatic Detective Cormac Reilly in McTiernan's previous two novels, The Ruin and The Scholar then you will be enthralled by his investigation style once again in The Good Turn. Here he is still out of favour at his station at Galway, fighting to remain sane after being stripped of his team, called away to help in a drug bust. But when an invalided boy sees a girl kidnapped outside his bedroom window, Reilly must summon who he can to help. His boss is deaf to his pleas, and when Garda Peter Fisher follows a strong lead alone, it ends with the suspect being killed. Fisher is sent out of the way to a small staton run by his estranged father, while Reilly is relieved of his post. Reilly flies to Brussels to see Emma, and she suggests that he resign and they stay in Europe, but Reilly has contacted his old friend who works for Interpol and together they see that there are stronger forces at work behind Reilly's shafting.
So he returns to Galway bent on uncovering the web of deceit and corruption which appears to lie at the heart of the station.
Meanwhile Fisher is contending with his hated father, an self opinionated old style cop who cuts corners. While investigating a pair of murders near the town, Fisher realises that things were not investigated with any purpose, things were overlooked, assumptions made. Fisher's grandmother is elderly and frail, looked after by an itinerant young woman and her daughter, blow ins from Dublin.
And so we have a set of gripping, overlapping stories, each one engrossing and at times heart stopping as Fisher and Reilly investigate things they are not supposed to, disobeying orders from above, putting their own careers and lives on the line. Ireland, Crime fiction, Corruption, Murder.
Fran Knight

Bab Sharkey and the animal mummies: The prickly battle by Andrew Hansen and Jessica Roberts

cover image

Illus. by Jessica Roberts. Walker Books, 2020. ISBN: 9781760651190. 240pp.
This is a book for a very particular readership. The title is indicative of its style and content. Many children would have difficulty navigating the complex action which jumps about from past to present against a too exotic Egyptian setting. The vocabulary and word games may appeal to a niche market - perhaps children who are very much besotted and /or obsessed with Egyptian culture. To most children, the allusions would "go through to the keeper." This, combined with the difficulty of working out the interrelationships amongst the too many characters may make it hard for the young reader to relate to them. The characters themselves are very strange. One example is the "Unpharaoh" (a strange phenomenon to come to grips with). Another is the somehow personified Pharaoh's beard. This may be too large a leap for most children.
The action is frantically paced and the plot is convoluted. The clever references are nuanced and obscure. Young readers may have difficulty connecting with the storyline.
This book may be representative of a new genre which appeals to a new breed of readers. It may be like the "cult movie". The author obviously enjoys the word play but only a child who has been thoroughly initiated into this mode of thinking could really keep up with it.
Wendy Jeffrey

Wink by Rob Harrell

cover image

Angus and Robertson, 2020. ISBN: 9781460758878. pbk., 315 pp.
(Age: 12+) Recommended. Being a normal seventh-grader is already tough as it is, and when Ross Maloy gets diagnosed with a rare eye cancer all that goes out the window. Losing his hair, wearing weird hats, or dealing with bullies are all things he does not want to deal with.
This story is based on Rob Harrell's real-life experiences, and included are also illustrations and cartoons he has drawn himself. The story is very much true to life in its details about high school and how teenagers act towards each other and shows the reader an uplifting side to getting through it.
Rob has crafted a funny and memorable story following Ross Maloy that deals with a lot of tough topics that teenagers might come to face at some point in their lives. High school and bullies. Friends and change. And of course, the process of being diagnosed with cancer. But Rob also brings to light that we can still find laughter and happiness when times might seem overwhelming and stressful. These topics and more Ross did well to interpret into his story, and in the end made this a noteworthy read that I think teenagers just coming into high school would enjoy.
Kayla Raphael

The unstoppable Letty Pegg by Iszi Lawrence

cover image

Bloomsbury Children's Books, 2020. ISBN: 9781472962478.
(Ages: 10+). Highly recommended. The unstoppable Letty Pegg by Iszi Lawrence is a factual historical account of the Suffragette Movement in England in 1910. Women were fighting for the right to vote and being treated shamefully by the law, the public and the Government. Eleven year old Letty Pegg is the daughter of a middle class mother who belongs to the Suffragette movement and a working class police constable father - their marriage being something of a rarity due to the class system at that time. Letty accidentally witnesses the brutality of the police during a Suffragette march and through a turn of events becomes a student of Jiu Jitsu. The Academy where Letty learns and masters Jiu Jitsu is run by Sensei Edith Garrud. This is a well researched historical fact that the author has tied successfully into Letty's story. Edith Garrud was an important figure in the Suffragette struggle and became a Jiu Jitsu instructor to the Women's Social and Political Union (WSPU). With her husband she held classes to teach women of all ages how to defend themselves during the increasingly violent protests. Letty is mentored and supported by Garrud and puts her training to good use and forms important friendships along the way. Included in the story is the disturbing school system of the 1900s. The teachers were cruel and administered corporal punishment freely. Girls were treated poorly and educated basically for marriage or to go into service. Letty and her soon to be close friend Mabel continually baulk at this and Letty is continually on the receiving end of a caning from her unpleasant teacher, Mr Metcalfe. While there are times in the story where Letty's escapades and situations seem implausible, readers will gain a valuable insight into the class divide at the time, the oppression of females and the distressing schooling situation.
The Australian Curriculum Year Six History component looks at Suffragettes and this novel would be a welcome introduction to this very important topic. There are many events in the story for 21st century students to explore and research. This book would be an important addition to any class or school library. Themes: History, Friendship, Suffragettes, Jiu Jitsu, Women's rights.
Kathryn Beilby

The glass hotel by Emily St. John Mandel

cover image

Macmillan, 2020. ISBN: 9781509882816. 256pp.
(Age: Adult - Senior secondary) Recommended. This is a deeply complex story, its narrative structure demanding our attention and echoing that complexity. Emily Mantel's narrative is interwoven in time and place, as she delves into the dark world of the pursuit of wealth at any cost, moving always between the past, the present, and indeed briefly into the future. While this is a challenge for the reader, the story is absolutely riveting, as we are given frequent little clues as to the darker deeds that are at the heart of this narrative, and are made progressively aware of the immorality of what is happening.
In a sense, this clever narrative controls what we know and only reveals small details of the lives of the characters, their activities, and their lives' trajectories. So we have to work to build our own sense of what we know about their world and their interactions, motivations, daily lives and their fate. It sparkles and it is gloomy, it puzzles and it reveals, and we are led through an extraordinary tale of venomous acts, of cheating those who place their trust in people, and of a deep and complex mystery. Ultimately, we are driven to ask what might be the meaning of the title, that glass hotel that can be seen from the outside but what is seen is only part of the story and really the actions that take place are not seen. So that glass is both transparent and opaque, allowing some information to be seen and understood and the deeper mystery and evil is unseen, yet is in plain sight if the characters were able to perceive that what they see is evil.
Taking place in various areas, such as a ship, the city of Manhattan, or the wilds of British Columbia, Mandel's narrative leads us deeply into the setting in which the narratives take place, and we also become aware of some of the odd aspects of the characters' lives. In exposing the notions of illegality and immorality in the pursuit of wealth, Mandel presents these choices as being acceptable to those for whom others' lives are immaterial, where one's corrupt actions may lead to knowingly ruining people's lives. This is a gripping aspect of the novel, as Mantel pushes the reader to seek answers as to the rationale for the choices made by the characters, and their capacity to live with ruining the lives of others through the ongoing massive levels of deceit.
Mandel presents this very intriguing narrative as a reflection on the breakdown of the usual expectations of a good life, or indeed of a life seen to be well-lived, rather showing us how, and sometimes why, the expectations that we have can be drastically skewed. In demonstrating how one character's life can be dramatically changed by a single action, choice or event, Mandel forces us to consider, and thus to grasp, how this could impact dramatically on a person's life. Perhaps the structure, cleverly giving us wonderful depth and a developing understanding of the events, shows us the way in which the puzzling nature of life elicits responses that we may never have expected.
This riveting novel would be suitable for older adolescents and adults.
Elizabeth Bondar

Elizabella and the haunting of Lizard Lake by Zoe Norton Lodge

cover image

Illus. by Georgia Norton Lodge. Elizabella book 3. Walker Books, 2020. ISBN: 9781760651855.
(Age: 8-11years) Recommended. The third book in this entertaining series begins with Elizabella and her best friend Minnie in the Bilby Creek swimming pool talking about the Year 4 school camp. They are trying to decide which mischievous deeds they could get up to that would have the most impact. This sets the tone of the story and the reader will wait in anticipation for what comes next. The two girls are in separate bunk rooms at camp but this does not stop them meeting up at night and trying to solve the mystery of the suspected ghost that haunts the camp site. Both girls spend time in 'the think about what you've done' room at camp after causing great anxiety for the camp counsellors and school principal.
Within the main plot involving Elizabella there are a number of sub plots. Mr Gooblefrump, the Acting Principal, has been told to have a vacation to lower his stress levels so he decides to go on camp as he loves rules and believes the camp rules will release the happy chemicals he needs to function. Larry, the frill-neck lizard belonging to Elizabella, has stowed away in her bag in the hope of meeting like-minded lizards to converse with. He understands English perfectly but cannot speak it so hopes to encounter other lizards who can speak the language of Lizish. The missing camp counsellor who disappeared under mysterious circumstances is helped by Elizabella and Minnie on the final evening. There is also a new student Anaya whom the other children think is a liar but who surprises them in the end.
The characters in this story are all very likeable and believable. Mrs Goose, the camp cook, takes Elizabella under her wing, the three Camp Counsellors are forever happy even when they are not, Elizabella's classmates and friends are always wondering what will happen next and Elizabella and Minnie are somewhat oblivious to the mayhem they cause.
Throughout the book are small sketches that cleverly add interest to the story. At the end of the book is a Revenge Plan as well as a fairy tale written by Elizabella.
Elizabella and the haunting of Lizard Lake is an enjoyable read that will keep fans of Elizabella entertained and looking for the next book in the series. Themes: Friendship, School camp, Mystery, Humour.
Kathryn Beilby

Gregory Goose is on the loose: At the fair by Hilary Robinson

cover image

Illus. by Mandy Stanley. Gregory Goose is on the Loose! series. New Frontier, 2020. ISBN: 9781925594959. 18pp. Board book.
(Age: 1-3) Another in this series, this time Gregory Goose is at the fair. This brightly coloured board book with its easy to read out loud narrative is sure to appeal to young children who will appreciate the opportunity to try and find Gregory Goose as he hides in the pages.
The illustrations of the fair are done in vivid colours with bright yellow and green foregrounds, lilac and pink skies, coloured balloons floating and lots of interesting details in each double spread. The young reader will get to see a carousel, giant slides, a big wheel, a space ride, a teacup ride, candy stalls and a hoopla tent, all giving the young child a taste of what they could find at a fair or show. Astute readers will notice little details like the tiny white dog that often appears on the pages and will appreciate the subtle humour and happy smiles on the faces of all the children who are enjoying the rides at the fair.
This joins others in the series, In the jungle and On the moon.
Pat Pledger