Reviews

A clue for Clara by Lian Tanner

cover image

Allen & Unwin, 2020 ISBN: 9781760877699.
(Age: 9+) Highly recommended. Bullied and despised chook Clara, retreats to the farmhouse where she sits all say watching television. Her favourite shows are detective series, Death in the city and Amelia X Girl detective. She develops skills similar to the sleuths she admires, determining to become a detective herself, and solves the egg stealing episode at the chook house, although Rufus the rooster takes all the glory for himself. She wants to share her abilities so when a police car comes to the farm, investigating the latest round of sheep thefts, she tries in vain to communicate with them, but when she inadvertently finds herself in the police car, she works out a way to communicate with the young girl in the back seat, Olive, the policeman's daughter.
Humour abounds in this merry tale, as the reader sees a slightly worse for wear chook, the lowest in the pecking order in the farmyard, using her television inspired skills to solve a crime. The contrast between what the reader knows and what Clara thinks she knows will have readers laughing out loud. Her attempts at using morse code to talk to the girl for example, is seen by the girl as just an annoying peck from the strange chook on the floor of the car. Eventually Clara works out that she can peck out messages on Olive's mobile phone, and they communicate. Olive is being bullied by a new girl in the school, Jubilee, and her father Mr Simpson is the talk of the town, Little Dismal, as he has saved the pub from being closed and has offered to install CCTV cameras to catch the thief.
But Clara suspects his girl of being a master criminal so her surveillance of the family leads to the solving of the crime, but not in the way Clara thinks. The witty text is wonderfully supportive with equally funny illustrations by Cheryl Orsini.
This smart, clever and very funny story of standing up to bullies, of friendship in the most unlikely of places, of coping with grief, all wrapped up in a story about a girl and her pet chook is one of the most endearing tales I have read for a long time.
Tanner quietly introduces the fact that Olive's mother has died, and the grief that surrounds Olive and her father is pervasive. The efforts of those around them makes the bullying by the 'Merrycan' girl even more despicable, and it is with a loud cheer that she becomes undone. Life in rural Australia with the problems of stock theft, of towns closing down, of people moving away, of a lone police officer trying to cope with angry farmers, saddled with drought, dwindling prices and fewer staff to help work the properties forms a most credible background to the story.
It is a book that begs to be read and enjoyed. Teacher's notes are available.
Fran Knight

Ten sleepy sheep by Renee Treml

cover image

Penguin Random House Australia, 2020. ISBN: 9781760896768.
(Age: 0-3) Highly recommended. In a gentle rhythmic narrative that reads aloud beautifully, the young child is invited to count backwards from ten, looking at the animals that could be found on a farm.
Ten sleepy sheep walk back to the shed.
9 sleepy pups settle in bed.
Right from the beginning when 5 sheep and 5 little lambs can be seen walking back to the shed on an Australian farm, the young child will enjoy counting sleepy puppies, foals,  chicks, calves, ducklings, parrots, lizards, foals, koalas and a joey.
The pastel backgrounds fit beautifully into each of the pictures - a soft brown to show the background of the Australian farm with white sheep walking across it, pale green grass for foals to lie on, a gorgeous blue for baby ducklings and pretty lilac for parrots. Each of the animals or birds is outlined in black and filled in with soft whites and browns, with detailing bringing the fur of the kangaroo and koalas alive.
This is a lovely, gentle board book that will be appreciated at bedtime as the young child is soothed to sleep.
Pat Pledger

We're going on a treasure hunt by Martha Mumford

cover image

Illus. by Laura Hughes. Bloomsbury, 2020. ISBN: 9781408893395.
(Age: 1+) Recommended. Lots of fun can be had as four bunnies go off on an exciting quest to find ten gold coins and a treasure chest. Children will enjoy following the cute rabbits, all dressed as pirates, as they prance along avoiding obstacles and uncovering gold coins one by one.
The repetition of the refrain on every second double page spread ensures that children will be able to join in as they hear it again and again:
We're going on a treasure hunt.
Yo! Ho! Ho!
Help us find the golden coins . .
ARRRRR!
Off we go!
Even very small children will enjoy the rhythm and repetition and will love to see the cute little animals and birds on the way. Older children will find the repetition of every second double page will be a great help when they are just beginning to read and the story is sure to be one that children who want to start to read aloud will pick up. Sounds made as the cute little rabbits chase the coins add to enjoyment of the narrative: Watch out for the Crabs . . . Snip, snap, snip! and the parrots, squawk, squawk, screech.
The lift the flaps are quite sturdy and reveal a gold coin with the number written on it. This will enable older children to enjoy counting from one to ten. Other lift the flaps reveal animals and even a very hungry shark to delight all and bring smiles to faces.
Laura Hughes illustrations are very engaging. The rabbits are so cute, dressed in pirate hats, bandanas and eye patches and the bright colours of the beach, sea and vegetation are gorgeous.
This is perfect to read aloud for younger children and one that older children can use to practise their reading as was the previous book, We're going on an elf chase, which followed a similar format. It is sure to be a keeper.
Pat Pledger

Jacinda Adern: A new kind of leader by Madeline Chapman

cover image

Nero, 2020. ISBN: 9781760641818.
(Age: Senior secondary/adult) Highly recommended. There are few women in powerful positions around the world, and this story of Adern's rise makes for an amazing read, one which may excite other young women to strive to follow their passion.
Adern came from an unusual background, a small farm in Muruparo the daughter of Mormon parents. The book details her early foray into human rights issues at school, then attending Waikato University and volunteering at the New Plymouth by-election. From there she worked for a grass roots MP in Wellington when she became attracted to the Young Labour Movement, eventually becoming world president of the International Union of Socialist Youth in 2008. A spectacular rise for one so young, but as the book points out, she did not become president through being naive. She was clearly cunning, astute and clever, using her opportunities to perfection.
On leaving home her views of the world changed and she espoused Maori rights and climate change action as well as championing gay rights, bringing her into conflict with her family and her religion. The Labour Party at this time was trying to bring more women into leadership roles. She was in the right place at the right time. And she is a worker. Through a series of quick leadership changes in 2017, she became leader of the party just a couple of months before election day with Labour polling 23%. Tirelessly promoting a positive position, using social media to perfection, her boundless enthusiasm saw her party neck and neck with the National Party which had ruled for the past nine years. The NZ First party backed Labour and which led to Ardern becoming Prime Minister in a minority government. Here she promoted climate change policy, gender equity and Maori rights. She attended the UN world summit in 2018, the first world leader to bring a baby into the proceedings. Her speech promoted the need for gender equality around the world, trade and climate change and was universally applauded. But, it was her response to the terrorist attack on two mosques in Christchurch in 2018 that has defined her. She received the news at 1:50 pm about a situation in Christchurch on her way to speak at New Plymouth. She went to the police station, by 4.20 pm held a press conference, and by 7 pm gave an address to the nation. This speech, quoted in the book named the killer as a terrorist, and called not for revenge, but love and kindness. She flagged the changes to gun laws and within the week this was being formulated. She attended the Muslim Centre wearing a headscarf as a sign of respect, calling for peace. Radio stations broadcast the Muslim call for prayer, and Adern's names was broadcast around the world, showing a compassionate leader putting herself on the line. Her speech is well worth reading.
The book gives hints to what makes her such a fine leader, that fearless determination to do what she sees as right for New Zealand and all of its population. Sometimes she appears naive and sometimes it is hard to separate that from a born politician, but people do not call her the 'smiling assassin' for nothing. Details about election wins, take up many pages, but then it is a biography of a politician.
This is an eminently readable, sometimes frustrating, book which gives a broad look at a woman who has made a difference.
Speeches are quoted at the end of the text, with pages of sources and a useful index. Themes: Jacinda Adern, Biography, Christchurch NZ, New Zealand, Politics, Terrorism.
Fran Knight

Hound the detective by Kimberley Andrews

cover image

Puffin, 2020. ISBN: 9780143774655.
(Age: 5+) Highly recommended. Hound is known for always solving his cases, hunting out clues to find the answer to the question, but this time he is stumped and asks the readers to walk alongside him as he follows the clues on each page. Readers are at once saddled with a quest, to seek out  the clues on each page, noting things which may lead Hound to a conclusion, and along the way search for the 17 hidden  caterpillars.
Readers will love searching through the detective paraphernalia illustrated, from magnifying glasses to the deerstalker hat, while notes, scraps of paper, letters, postcards and signposts all muddy the waters ready to sweep the avid sleuths onto the wrong trail.
Each page has a different clue, given in the rhyming stanza, pointing the reader to look in a certain way and travel along the path given, through several houses, and gardens, a village fair, shop and cabin in the woods, a train station, and finally to a dark part of the town with overhanging Elizabethan timbers to meet his fate.
A fun time will be had as readers follow the sleuth, finding with him the answers to the questions posed in the stanzas, marvelling at the sumptuous illustrations, taking in the huge amount of detail before their eyes, watching out for the array of animals on each page, hunting for the caterpillar, and above all having fun.
Author of Puffin the architect and Song of the river, Kimberley Andrews lives and works in Wellington, after training as a biologist in Canada and living and working in London, New Zealand and Borneo before settling in New Zealand where she is able to pursue her passion for the plants and animals of that country.
Theme: Detecting, Clues, Animals.
Fran Knight

The Constant Rabbit by Jasper Fforde

cover image

Hodder & Stoughton, 2020. ISBN: 9781444763638.
(Age: Adult). Recommended. Jasper Fforde is back with a satirical, absurd but surprisingly relevant novel, The Constant Rabbit. Known for his Thursday Next series helmed by The Eyre Affair, Fforde is no stranger to outlandish and humorous stories. What he has managed to do with this book however is to intertwine the ridiculous with the less savoury aspects of recent times.
Set in an alternate England where rabbits have anthropomorphised into six feet tall talking humanoids, The Constant Rabbit centres on Peter Knox, a mild-mannered father living in a small village who is forced to make a moral choice. Peter works for the Rabbit Compliance Taskforce and his job is to ensure the largely segregated rabbits are following human laws and living peaceably in society. When Prime Minister Nigel Smethwick of the UKARP (United Kingdom Against Rabbit Population) party announces a plan to forcibly move all rabbits into a facility in Wales, Peter is torn between his job and the concerns of his fellow villagers and his increasingly complex relationships with rabbit neighbours and friends.
The novel paints the picture of a society where xenophobia, paranoia and "fake news" are the norm. The story is an irreverent but clear dig at contemporary British society where racism, anti-muslim and anti-immigration sentiments and Brexit concerns have dominated the social and media landscape in recent years. It is a challenging though excellent read and the reader will be constantly pulled between the witty, dry jokes and the realisation that the plot is hitting too close to home. This book is recommended for fans of Fforde's previous work as well as those who enjoy cutting but humorous observations of human life. Themes: Rabbits, Xenophobia, Humour, Satire, United Kingdom.
Rose Tabeni

What Zola did on Tuesday by Melina Marchetta

cover image

Illus. by Deb Hudson. Puffin, 2020. ISBN: 9781760895167.
(Age: 6+) Highly recommended. The second in a series of books about the irrepressible Zola, has the year two girl becoming interested in knitting, partly because her Nonna is trying to knit a scarf, but also because the new family next door is doing some knitting. When her teacher encourages the class to do something for those less fortunate than themselves, Zola suggests knitting a scarf. But once she has suggested this she remembers that perhaps her Nonna is not such a good knitter.
Full of humour and brimming with the close ties of family, alongside new arrivals in the community, children will love reading of Zola and her life. She helps Nonna in the community garden, tries hard to make her dog obedient, plays with her friend Allesandro who lives in the house behind her, and now makes new friends with Bianca and Omar next door.
With gentle subtle humour, Marchetta parallels the arrival of Italian migrants to these shores several generations ago with the newer arrival from the Middle East.
Each family is strongly family oriented, with a grandma living with the families. They come together over their animals and knitting, while the two families share some of their culture with each other. This is a charming story of Zola and her eagerness for make people feel welcome. The book is one of a set of seven and has two pages of knitting instructions at the end of the book for those so intrigued that they want to try it themselves.
Theme: Family, Immigration, Knitting.
Fran Knight

The Verindon Alliance by Lynne Stringer

cover image

Rhiza Edge, 2020. ISBN: 9781925563993.
(Young Adult) Recommended. While The Verindon Alliance is a prequel to Australian author Lynne Stringer's Verindon trilogy, no prior knowledge of the original stories is needed to read this standalone novel. Set in the same universe as the trilogy but with a more immediate and explicit focus on the science fiction genre, The Verindon Alliance is a fast-paced and enjoyable story for young adults who enjoy their action with a dash of romance.
The novel centres on Princess Vashta of the Vendel and Brandonin, the prince of Verindal (the confusing proliferation of V-words eventually begins to make sense). The Vendel and Verindal races have been warring for centuries and this conflict influences every aspect of the royals' lives. Vashta has just graduated from combat training and is ready to actively join the fight when, unexpectedly, Brandonin approaches the Vendel monarch seeking peace. The two find themselves working together, despite the hostility of their families, to face an external danger that threatens the future of both their peoples.
Both main characters are well-developed, three-dimensional and easy-to-like, particularly Vashta, a strong-willed and determined young woman who refuses to conform to any stereotypes associated with princesses. Stringer is also adept at blending the romantic aspects of the plot with the action sequences and does not go overboard with either.
The Verindon Alliance is an easy and entertaining read from this emerging Australian author. Readers of the Verindon trilogy will especially enjoy the fleshing out of the story of Vashta and Brandonin's love and alliance. Themes: War, Love, Family, Aliens.
Rose Tabeni

Small town by Phillip Gwynne

cover image

Illus. by Tony Flowers. Puffin, 2020. ISBN: 9781760893484.
(Age: 4+) Highly recommended. Irresistibly charming, this tale applauds the work done by small communities which have welcomed refugees into their midst, offering accommodation, work and support in their new country. Small cities such as Toowoomba, Bendigo and Newcastle and even smaller communities such as Nhill, have given these new arrivals a place of safety.
Gwynne tells of a small community losing its population to the city, putting their economy and school in peril of shutting down. This is not a new occurrence, but how some communities respond is wonderfully new. Milly is aware that some of her friends have left and her class is smaller, but when the loss of girls imperils the future of her basketball team, she decides to act. Her teacher has told them of war, famine and privation overseas and the class has discussed refugees, so Milly writes and asks that some come to her town where there are jobs and housing to accommodate them.
The mayor questions what she is doing, but she has an answer for every negative point he brings up. The children make a video of their community and send it to the refugees.
They wait and wait and another family leaves, but then a convoy of cars comes with refugees. The whole town pitches in and welcomes them, repairing the empty houses, helping them unpack their belongings, finding them work, happy to have a doctor in the town at last.
The contrast between the town as it was and the town as it is now is subtly shown with the naming of Millie's basketball team. Initially it was made up with four girls called Chloe, and Millie. Now it is two Chloes, Farhia, Hanan, Amina, Sharifa and Millie.
Wonderful in its seeming simplicity, Gwynne uses powerfully spare prose to get his message across.
Flowers' watercolour illustrations reveal small town life in Australia with dots of houses spread over vast areas, windmills, a runway and tin roofs with a soft pallet of colours, reminiscent of long sunny days in the country.
The town's unusual name is used as a refrain, 'my town is so nice, they named it twice' repeated through the story encouraging children to join in as it is read to them and forming a link between the old and new generations.
Themes: Small towns, Refugees, Inclusivity.
Fran Knight

When she was good by Michael Robotham

cover image

Cyrus Haven Bk 2. Hachette, 2020. ISBN: 9780733644849
(Age: Adult - Senior secondary) Recommended. Following Good girl, bad girl, comes a thrilling instalment in the lives of Cyrus Haven and Evie Cormac. At the end of Good girl, bad girl readers were left pondering the mystery of just who Evie was and why she had been hiding for so long. She has been safe in a secure home when Cyrus is called in to investigate the murder of Detective Superintendent Hamish Whitmore. As he follows the trail left by the detective, he gradually grows closer to finding out the secrets of Evie's past. However, Evie knows that it is very dangerous for Cyrus to be uncovering what has happened in the past and both she and Cyrus are in peril from some very powerful people in high places and the evil hitmen hired by the leader.
Told in alternating chapters by Cyrus and Evie the story of Evie's past gradually unfolds. The tension was so great that I devoured this book in a few sittings as I followed Cyrus' investigation of what has happened, heart in my mouth as I saw how dangerous it was for Evie and appalled at the child abuse, manipulation and murder that she had witnessed. It was horrifying but totally engrossing to find out Evie's background, while also seeing Cyrus develop as a person and to find out more about his broken childhood.
Evie's ability to tell when a person is lying is a strong thread in the story, as is the question about whether the past should stay buried and monsters left alone. The ability of powerful people to manipulate the police and the justice system was also highlighted.
Robotham's clever plotting, character development and twists and turns keep the suspense alive the whole way through to the unexpected and exciting conclusion. Although the main mystery of Evie's past is uncovered for the reader in When she was good, fans will be happy that some options have been left open for Cyrus and Evie to continue working together, using their unique skills and backgrounds.
Pat Pledger

LEGO Batman : Batman vs. The Joker by Julia March

cover image

Dorling Kindersley, 2020. ISBN: 9780241409404.
If you are a fan of LEGO and Superheroes, then this book is for you! In this brightly coloured comic-ish style book fans will see the ultimate list of superheroes vs villains and be able to choose for themselves who is the final winner!
In the never-ending saga, Batman wants to show The Joker that he is the boss of Gotham City and brings his friends Robin, Nightwing, The Flash, and Wonder Woman (to name just a few) to help him out. The Joker also has a team behind him comprising of bad guys such as Lex Luthor, Poison Ivy and Scarecrow (plus many more). They also bring their trusty vehicles along which many kids will love.
As children move through the book, they will see a huge range of LEGO Batman sets and minifigures which are used to create the illustrations for this book. All of which are said to be the latest toys - making it the perfect book for LEGO Batman fans!
This book is full of facts and information about the characters and their nemeses, pitting them up against each other in 4 different sections: vehicles, Gotham City, wider world, and loyal friends.
As a LEGO fan from my childhood, and now with LEGO loving children this was a great read. Although it was limited on words, it meant that both my 10 and 6 year old could enjoy it together and were able to both get enjoyment out it. They loved the 'Did you know?' section and often had to get up to tell Daddy (another LEGO fan) what they had read about. When I asked what their favourite part was they both loved the real LEGO sets and figures (especially their facials), with the only criticism from Master 10 who would have loved a list of the actual sets with item numbers so he could look them up to purchase! The two added LEGO figures (Batman and The Joker) were fought over for days, but a lovely tactile addition none the less.
Overall, this would be a great book/gift for a LEGO or Superhero loving child.
Lauren Fountain

The Great Godden by Meg Rosoff

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2020. ISBN: 9781526620538.
(Age: Senior secondary - Adult) Highly recommended. I am a great fan of Meg Rosoff's books (particularly There is no dog and Picture me gone) which are complex, challenging and unforgettable. The great Godden is no exception, a book that highlights manipulation and loss of innocence. One large messy family stay in a holiday house by the sea every summer, but this year there is a difference, the Goddens, charming Kit and morose Hugo, are staying with older cousins nearby. It is a summer when unexpected consequences will unfold, told in the unforgettable voice of the unnamed narrator.
Everyone talks about falling in love like it's the most miraculous, life-changing thing in the world. Something happens, they say, and you know . . . That's what happened when I met Kit Godden. I looked into his eyes and I knew. Only everyone else knew too. Everyone else felt exactly the same way. pg. 1.
There are four teenagers in the family, beautiful Mattie who immediately attaches herself to Kit, Tamsin who is obsessed with horses, younger brother Alex, who loves bats and wildlife, and our unknown narrator, who loves to draw and observes everything that is going on. Initially life continues as normal with swimming and games and then there is a wedding to plan for Mal and Hope (known affectionately as Malanhope), but Kit is an unexpected storm on the family's horizon. Mattie is not the only one who comes under Kit's influence, even though the morose but ultimately surprising Hugo tries to warn the narrator about his nature.
Rosoff's description of the way that Kit manipulates Mattie, playing on her emotions, attentive one moment and cold the next, will be a lesson for all about the manoeuvres of a master controller and the devastating consequences of sex without feeling. There are some shocking revelations about Kit's actions and how he sways the whole family.
The great Godden has been compared to Rumer Godden's The Greengage Summer, a tale of loss of innocence. It is a coming of age story that will linger in the memory, ideas to be brought out again and again to examine and think about. The manipulation here could also be compared to that in The lost witch by Melvyn Burgess.
Rosoff is a skilful writer and it is easy to see this story becoming a modern classic and it would also make an ideal TV series.
Pat Pledger

Time for adventure, Daddy by Dave Hackett

cover image

UQP, 2020. ISBN: 9780702262852.
(Age: 4+) Highly recommended. Following Time for bed, Daddy (2015) and Time for school, Daddy (2018) Dave Hackett's funny look at family life with Dad as the main character being sorted out by his single minded daughter, will elicit gales of laughter from the audience as they sympathise with the two characters and recognise themselves and situations they have been in. Circumstances are reversed as the daughter gets ready for an adventure, packing a picnic basket, making sure Dad has been to the toilet before they leave home, returning all the things he wants to take with them.
And they have a great time, skipping over stones in the creek bed, stepping over a big log, finding a worm to take home, walking in the sunshine, collecting leaves and twigs, and when Dad's feet become too tired to walk any more,  deciding where to place the picnic rug for their picnic.
All the fun of outdoors is shown as the pair walk, skip, run and jump, making use of the environment around them. An array of things are shown which children will recognise and enjoy, recalling the last time they did something similar or living in some expectation of doing it in the future.
In these times of isolation, the book is most apt, revealing something everyone can do, a picnic with the family, wandering through the great outdoors, be it close by or some way away. All the efforts at getting the outing ready are shown, as well as the things to be expected when away from home on such an occasion. And all told with a great sense of humour as the roles are reversed, and the adventures are filled with fun.
The jaunty illustrations add to the sense of fun as the wide smiles invite readers to see what fun can be had from a simple outing with their Dad. Teacher's notes are available.
Themes: Humour, Fun, Adventure, Role reversal, Picnics.
Fran Knight

Kitty is not a Cat: Teddy's Bear by Jess Black

cover image

Hachette, 2020. ISBN: 9780734419774.
(Age: 6+ years) Recommended. Kitty is not a Cat: Teddy's Bear by Jess Black is one of four books being released this year by Hachette. The book series is based on the Australian animation television series which has been sold around the world. Orange is the theme colour of this book and the other remaining books are blue, purple and pink. The story begins with a brief introduction to the characters and an explanation of the context of the story. Kitty is a girl who is dressed in a bright orange costume with ears, a tail and paws. She joins the clutter of cats that live in the mansion on the hill. Each cat has its own name and special qualities it brings to the group. In this particular story the cats decide to find a teddy bear for Kitty. Each cat brings what they think a teddy bear is to the others but one interpretation causes absolute mayhem. Eventually a teddy bear is found for Kitty and peace reigns once more.
This book is a very readable story that will entertain young developing readers who are ready for short novels. The fact that it is series will also appeal to those students who will benefit from word repetition. The book contains very detailed illustrations and highlighted text where emphasis on a specific word is important to the flow of the story. Themes: Cats, Friendship, Bears.
Kathryn Beilby

Mr Brown by Thomasina Williams

cover image

Illus. by Naya and Kostya Lazareva. Little Steps, 2020. ISBN: 9781925839463.
Recommended. Mr Brown is a story about a bear trying to organise himself for hibernation. Mr Brown has a long list of things he needs to do before he can settle in for his big sleep, but it seems that something always gets in the way! It may be his memory, a fire that won't light, or fish that get scared away. Fortunately for Mr Brown he has wonderful friends who are there to help him through each stage and get him sorted.
This is a lovely rhyming book that tells listeners a story of friendship. It shows how when we help our friends (or just others around us) we are doing a good thing, but also making them smile. I also loved how at the end Mr Brown cannot resist but share his prepared meals with all his friends as a thank you gesture - it was very sweet!
Each of Mr Brown's friends only want the best for him in his time of hibernation and through the illustrations we see their genuine faces.
We enjoyed both the story and the illustrations as together they really contributed to a good reading experience. There were lots of things to discuss in the pictures and Miss 6 and I had a great talk about hibernation and friends. Her favourite animal was the cat, however mine was the rabbit who can be seen stealing the last sandwich off cat's plate as they toast their friend to a happy hibernation!
Overall a nice story with interesting illustrations and a good message, 4 out of 5.
Lauren Fountain