Reviews

The detachable boy by Scot Gardner

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2008. ISBN 9781741753455
(Ages : 10-13) Over the Pacific, in his suitcase, John wants to go to the toilet. He manoeuvres his arm to get Ravi's grandfather's pen knife, cuts the tape, hops out and reassembles himself. He opens some of the boxes around him to satisfy his hunger, but when the flight attendant sees them decides they all need to be examined. Fainting women all around, John reassembles himself and gets out of there. He is off to rescue his friend, Crystal, kidnapped from Australia, and a message on his mobile has led him to the USA.

Here, he climbs his way down an underground bunker, finds Crystal, escapes, is recaptured, both rescued by Ravi and the trio goes through an extraordinary set of adventures before they return home in time to tell their parents they have been at a school camp for the week. A set of bizarre happenings, all bound up in this delightfully silly story, littered with slightly off jokes and puns will be sure to please middle to upper primary kids as they laugh out loud at the antics of the children whose appendages can be removed. Scot Gardner's books have always been a treat to read and this is no exception.
Fran Knight

Audrey goes to town by Christine Harris

cover image

Little Hare Books, 2008.
(Age 8-12) The adventures of Audrey take a twist when her family relocates to Beltana, a town in South Australia's Flinder's Ranges, for a month. Here they board with Mrs Patterson, known in the town as Patterson's curse, a noxious weed. But Audrey's inquisitive nature and endearing ability to put people on their back foot, undermines the prickly nature of the woman at every turn.

Mrs Patterson takes on Audrey as a project, wanting to teach her manners, how to knit and behave like a lady. Audrey in turn wants to find her good side, and beguilingly does so as she talks the older woman into wearing a yellow ribbon and coming along to the Beltana dance. Ann James' perfect illustrations keep us guessing until the very last chapter about what Mrs Patterson looks like, and her sly little glance at Audrey is enough to make any reader's heart melt.

Christine Harris' ability to make places and people come alive is nowhere more evident than in this, the second of the series, Audrey of the outback. Younger readers will readily see with Audrey's eyes, her new home, the dusty wide streets, the houses, the people who live there. She innocently compares her house with that of Mrs Patterson, revelling in the different rooms, the windows, the linoleum and the table, but soon longs for the dirt floors and glassless windows of her home. Beltana now is little more than a ruin, but Christine Harris fills the place with life, revealing it in its useful days before the railway bypassed it. And along the way, readers will learn many of the expressions and words no longer in use, and fittingly, there is a glossary of 'interesting words' to help people remember them.
Fran Knight

Sprite Downberry by Nette Hilton

cover image

Angus and Robertson, 2008. ISBN 978073228548 7
(Age 11-14) Highly recommended. Sprite's refuge is her family; her dad, the artist; mum, the fun loving woman who starts things but never finishes them; and Mozz her little brother. Nits stray into her hair, and her school friends reject her, saying she is dirty. But she still has her family. When her family begins to unravel, and her father stays away one night, Sprite goes to school the next day, hopeful that he will return that evening. But her class mates talk of seeing her mother at the clinic, and call her a druggie, which sets the precarious Sprite off, and she hits one of her tormenters. Returning home she finds her mother has not left her bed and is too full of sorrow and remorse to think clearly.

This is a fearless book, showing a family in disarray, the young girl left to look after the mother and her brother. She holds onto the belief that her father will return, all the while piecing together the bits of information she has learnt about her mother; the sweet tobacco smell when she smokes, the fact that she has gone to a clinic, the overheard argument between her parents when her father told her to get rid of it before the police found out. She begins to realise that her mother has an addiction, and this addiction has permeated all their lives.

One of the many highlights of this book is the lack of recrimination. Hilton presents the story as any story of any child who may be in trouble. This is a family in crisis, with a child called on to make adult decisions about herself and her family. Children reading it may be shocked at the behaviour of the mother and possibly the father, but it will open a window into the lives of some of their classmates, and for those for whom this story has resonance, what a marvel for them to see that they are not alone and that there can be a resolution.

And most appreciatively, it is in the third person, making it not just another angsty sub-teenage novel told in the first person, but a rounded, informative story about a family from a benevolent and omniscient point of view.
Fran Knight

Black Rabbit Summer by Kevin Brooks

cover image

Penguin Books 2008.
(Age 15+) As a huge fan of Kevin Brooks I fell on this book - two of his previous novels Candy and Kissing the Rain are in my opinion near perfect. Black Rabbit Summer tells the story of Pete - sixteen, lonely and a little depressed and the events that catapult him and his friends into disaster. This is a summer of change. Everyone has left school, friendships have drifted and Pete is losing touch with the people he grew up with. A call from his former girlfriend results in a trip to the fair with his old friends. Undercurrents bubble away, fuelled partly by the drugs and alcohol that are now on the scene. The night ends in tragedy when two of the group go missing - streetwise Stella and damaged Raymond. Are their disappearances connected? Is someone with a troubled mind capable of murder?

Stella's body is discovered and Raymond, still missing, becomes the prime suspect. But Pete is convinced of his innocence and sets out to prove it, exposing the real perpetrators in the process and putting his own life on the line.

The plot is gritty and realistic but for me Brooks' story never really takes off. At over four hundred pages this is a weighty tome that in my opinion could have been pruned by at least a quarter. Brooks' fondness for stream of consciousness results in lengthy forays into minute detail which become irritating after a while and I was exasperated at how slowly the story developed.

This book is relentlessly grim. The characters are flawed and dark and I found it hard to empathise with any of them apart from Raymond, and he disappears early on. There is plenty of shock value which may impress young readers, but I found the whole story strangely flat. Brooks packs a lot into this novel: homosexuality, abuse, drugs, murder, knife crime, blackmail - but for me the tide of 'issues' was just too overwhelming. In comparison it made me recall one of the seminal teenage novels: Junk by Melvin Burgess, scenes from which remain with me to this day. Black Rabbit Summer had much less of an impact and I finished this book with a sense of relief.
Claire Larson

The gift of the Magi by O. Henry

cover image

Walker Books, 2008.
(All ages) This beautifully illustrated book, recreates the story of the Christmas presents given by a married couple to each other, in such a way that the story is given extra breadth and depth. Many will know the story. A young couple, living in impoverished circumstances in a flat in an American city, sell one of their possessions to buy the other a present. The girl sells her hair to buy her husband a watch chain, and he sells his watch in order to buy her combs for her hair. It is a wonderful story of the selflessness of giving, of love and marriage, of the custom of giving presents, begun by the magi on the first Christmas.

The illustrations expose the poverty of their lives, the dirt and grime of the city, the haven that is their flat. The preponderance of brown, grey and white underscores the paucity of their lives, as she counts out her small money, saved to buy him a present. Students of all ages will immediately see the irony of the story, and will readily pick up the echoes in the illustrations. A lovely picture book which will be read by many, particularly at Christmas, when present giving becomes the opposite of what is shown here.
Fran Knight

Death diamond by Dan Jerris

cover image

Lothian, 2008. ISBN9780734410719
(Age 9-12) The first in the series, Dragon Blood Pirates, Death diamond is a funny, tongue in cheek story of 2 boys transported back in rime to the age of piracy. Redolent of Pirates of the Caribbean, and with touches of many other pirate stories and themes, this series of novels will fill a niche for readers of early chapter books. 80 pages long, with large print and many funny drawings by Rory Walker, this book is easy to read and follow.

Al and his friend, Owen are searching a chest in the attic, when they find themselves on a rock in the ocean. Rescued by the crew of The Booty, they are offered maggoty biscuits for tea, and that is just the first of their problems. Following the treasure map is the crew of another ship, The Tormenter, with their hideous captain, Snotty Nell. Each side tries to outwit the other as they search for the treasure through a cave with mantraps, clues and lots of danger.

A funny tale with lots of hilarious episodes, all giving a passing nod to famous stories and films, this book will have appeal to kids looking for an escape to another world.
Fran Knight

Big and me by David Miller

cover image

Ford St, 2008.
(Age 7+) Highly recommended. Congratulations to the author on tackling such a difficult topic as mental illness in a sensitive and moving way. Big and Small are machines that work together as a team. 'But some days Big goes a bit wobbly', and Small gets 'a lot worried.' With the assistance of The Boss and Mechanic, Big gets some medicine to help him get better.

The book is a wonderful metaphor for a young child living with someone who is mentally unwell. It is not difficult to substitute an adult for Big and the story goes through many of the things that a young child would see when living with an unstable person. Sometimes the pair work as 'a good team, the best', but sometimes Big does strange and frightening things. Medicine helps Big, but when he is convinced that he doesn't need it any longer, the world becomes 'grey and dull'. As Boss explains, it is not Small's fault that Bgi's computer is not working properly and this explanation should help relieve children's fears about being the cause of a parent or care giver's strange actions. The author doesn't avoid the big issues in this book and it will be a tremendous help for both children and adults in understanding mental health problems.

Miller has illustrated this book with fantastic paper sculptures of big and small machines set against vivid backgrounds of ochre and dark blue. They are a treat in themselves and their close examination will give lots of enjoyment, as well as adding to the meaning of the text.

The book ends on a positive but realistic note - Big will always have problems but with medicine will be OK most of the time. This is a book that has a place in all libraries.
Pat Pledger

The Trap by Sarah Wray

cover image

Faber and Faber, 2008.
(Age 11+) Luke is amazed to find that he has been accepted to go to a camp in New York State for high achievers. The camp is designed to give nerdy kids some outdoor activities and work in social situations, things which some of them miss. But from the start, Luke has trepidation about the place. One of his room mates, Mark, is a bully, his friend, Matt, seems nervous, and he is surprised to find Natalie, a girl he knew at primary school, at the camp. On the first day, Luke finds a coded note in his cabin and when they work out what it means, they are excited as to what it will lead them to. Each day builds tension and fear amongst the campers, and this is increased when they hear the tale of three campers who disappeared from one of the camps in the past.

A horror story which will have broad appeal to middle school kids, this tale has some very creepy moments, made even more so by the strange counselor Luke has in his cabin.
Fran Knight

Blackthorn by Elizabeth Pulford

cover image

Walker Books, 2008 ISBN9781921150470
(Age 10+)When her father dies, Alyana can no longer play the role of the dutiful daughter and be relegated to a relative's house, learning to cook and sew. She renounces all attempts at helping her, preferring to hide out in the nearby forests and survive alone. She has hunting skills learnt form her father, and feels she is able to stay alive without help.

But she is naive and needs the help of the man who finds her in the forest, starving and scared, the one she calls Boar, the man with the twisted leg. He gives her a puppy and together they survive with the skills and instincts taught her by Boar. Calling herself Blackthorn, she denounces all that she knew before and learns to survive in the forest.

Here she learns more about herself and her limits, and sees for herself some of the other inhabitants in the forest. An unusual little read about acceptance and self determination.
Fran Knight

A good arriving by David McRobbie

cover image

Puffin Books, 2008. ISBN 978014300403 5
(Age 11+) When Helen's family is evicted from their small farm, Helen is forced to go and work in the big house nearby. She attracts the attention of the son of the lord, and in rebuffing his advances, loses her job. She becomes a friend of the doctor's wife in the village and when that family decides to emigrate to New South Wales, Helen is invited along as companion to the wife and nurse to the child. On Board the Recovery, the family discovers that the ship is also a convict ship.

An interesting look at the migration of a varied lot of English people to early Australia, A good arriving is broad in it scope. On the Recovery, Helen finds that the doctor is interested in her, so she must repel him. The son of the house where she worked is also on board, offering his protection. One of the sailors also looks kindly upon Helen, so she must be wary. Below the cabins dwell the convicts and they are seen but rarely. When they do come on deck, Helen recognizes one of them, a small boy called Ben who she helped when he was in the big house as a chimney sweep. She helps him again and this leads to his release on board ship from the confines of the convict quarters.

This book will prove an easy way of learning about Australia's early history. The main character Helen, is too modern to be believable, but kids will enjoy the way she makes her way in the world. Once the amazing coincidences are forgotten, the story reads very easily, smoothly taking in historical romance, crime and adventure all rolled into one. When Helen arrives in NSW, the stage seems set for a sequel.
Fran Knight

War's end by Victoria Bowen

cover image

Random House, 2008. ISBN 978174166662

(Age 12+) Gradually waking in a bed not her own, and surrounded by shadows which flit back and forth, it takes a long time for Nell to realise that she is in a hospital. Relegated to a back room, she waits for her father to come and get her, in the mean time helping the overworked nurses as they scurry between the overload of patients.  

Nell has been hospitalized with Spanish Flu. It is 1919. The Great War has ended, with disease making its way around the world, killing more people than all the years of the war. When her father finally comes to pick her up, the two are estranged and the trip home on the train with her grandfather and father is unsettling. Throughout the trip conversations between the threesome reveal the suffering of the father away at war and the despair of those left back home. Stories which many have had as children suffuse the story, making it all the more accessible to the intended audience. And these stories are some which are behind Nell's silence with her father.

Bowen includes a great deal of historical information, and while most is relevant and quietly part of the story, some is more obvious, as when Nell's father talks about his time in France. But the novel tells a strong story with a likeable main character who carries the plot along. Students interested in this unexpected ending of World War One, will be intrigued and involved along with Nell as she makes her peace with her father.
Fran Knight

Cinderella by Max Eilenberg

cover image

Walker Books, 2008
(Ages: all) A beautiful retelling of the story of Cinderella, by Max Eilenberg, this book will delight younger readers, older readers and adults. Those who know the story will take pleasure in hearing it again and pointing out the minor changes made by this author. Those for whom the story is new, will be enchanted as Cinderella wins the prince despite the behaviour of her step mother and sisters.

The illustrations by Niamh Sharkey will intrigue and amaze the readers. The stepmother is sharp and angled, while her two daughters are opposites, one large and cumbersome, the other tall and very thin. Cinderella by contrast, is all she should be, demure, blonde, long suffering and surprised. The small animals which dot the pages add a comic element to the story. Each of the invitations to the balls (there are three) is on a playing card and watch out for the size of the girls' feet when trying on the glass slipper. All in all an agreeably presented variation to the traditional story of Cinderella, which will be a treat for those who read it.
Fran Knight

Cosmic by Frank Cottrell Boyce

cover image

Macmillan 2008
(Age 9+) Highly recommended. Liam is desperate to win a trip to a theme park in China which offers a ride in The Rocket - the biggest thrill ride in history. The only problem is that the winners have to be dads accompanied by their children and Liam is only twelve years old. On the plus side he is taller than average and has an embryo beard. He is also in the gifted and talented group at school. These, he feels, are the qualities needed to pass himself off as a dad. Against all odds Liam is a competition winner and sets off to China with his friend Florida, who reluctantly agrees to play the part of his daughter.

This is a wonderful story, whimsical, unusual, thought provoking and funny. Cottrell Boyce confronts some topical issues - the nature of fame and celebrity, the problem with parents who are either completely absent or who push their children too far, and the underhand behaviour of adults who manipulate children to fulfil their own obsessions.

Four winning dads and children arrive in China to discover that The Rocket is much more than just a theme park ride. It is ironic that Liam as the 'dad' realises he will be missing out on the adventure of a lifetime as it is only the children who will venture into space; the dads have to remain on earth and fill in all the boring forms! Eventually Dinah Drax, the brains behind The Rocket, decides to offer an ultimate prize for one of the dads - the opportunity to accompany the children on their space flight.

Liam wins the prize, but his skills as a dad are sorely tested as drama and danger threaten the space flight, and he faces up to the possibility that they may not make it home. Liam's attempts to behave in a 'dadly' way are superbly portrayed. At what point do you admit you are scared? How do you make four frightened and argumentative children do as you say when you are just a kid yourself? You may be gifted and talented, but there are times when you still need your dad.  Cottrell Boyce has such a direct approach that young readers will empathise with Liam's dilemmas.

Liam has always felt too big. He has been picked on by teachers because 'a big lad like you should know better,' and the other kids call him names. It takes a trip to the far side of the moon to put his size into perspective and make him feel small again.

This is a superb book. It would be an excellent story to read aloud in upper primary and lower secondary, and should generate all kinds of discussion and comment. The ending left me with a smile on my face and a lump in my throat. I'm hoping that Cosmic will make a well deserved appearance on next year's Carnegie shortlist.

Claire Larson.

Hamlet by John Marsden

cover image

Text Publishing, 2008. ISBN 978192135147 1
(Ages: 12+) A modern version of the well known tale of Hamlet is sure to raise eyebrows when the author tells us that he has made it more accessible to an adolescent audience. Some will say it is dumbing it down, but I found it to be better than that. Yes there is an element of change for change's sake, and I was annoyed at the sex scenes designed to titillate rather than further the plot, but Marsden sticks to the storyline, while trying to expose the incredible decisions Hamlet must make. Sometimes his attempts to translate Shakespeare's language into a more palatable form, is clunky and readers will notice the variation of style. Marsden includes some links between the familiar scenes which draw out some of the possible reasons behind peoples' actions which will make some events clearer for the novice.

Hamlet and co are adolescent, Hamlet at boarding school in nearby Gravatar when he hears of his father's death and mother's remarriage. He lopes along, understandably trying to make sense of it all, but when the ghost appears, he is torn. From playing football with Horatio, and having lewd thoughts about Ophelia, he now must turn to graver actions. He gives the players newly arrived at the castle, some extra lines to say in their play and this serves to warn us all that dire deeds will soon transpire.

When he next sees Ophelia, he is maddening in his response, when he sees Gertrude he hears something behind the curtain, and stabs, killing Polonius. Laertes then comes on the scene wanting revenge and Claudius plots for Laertes and Hamlet to meet in a competition. The end is near when Gertrude drinks the poisoned wine meant for Hamlet, Hamlet stabs Laertes with the poisoned sword and is also wounded. Struggling towards Claudius, Hamlet then stabs the king and dies.

And when is it set? The use of carriages and 'Your Royal Highness', and the word lavatory mark it as nineteenth century, but when the butler refuses to change around the furniture because it is not on the list of things he does, I became confused. Sandwiches appear at Gertrude's wedding, Hamlet and Horatio play a strange form of golf with racquets, and talk of playing football on Saturday afternoons.

But perhaps I'm nit picking. Kids will enjoy the thrill of it all; teachers will give it to kids as an introduction to the play; some adults will read it to remind them of their schooldays, and some will read it to find out how the author has remodeled the play to suit a 21st century audience. But many like me, will go back to the play, eagerly wanting to reread the familiar and entrancing words.
Fran Knight

The pop up dinosaurs galore by Giles Andrease and David Wojtowycz.

cover image

Orchard Books, 2008.
(Age 3+) In this fun dinosaur book, the reader gets to see what different dinosaurs look like. A tyrannosaurus rex chases after a small dinosaur, a pteranodon swoops through the air, a triceratops nods to its young, the neck of the diplodocus sways above the trees and the earth shudders when the giganotosaurus stomps on the ground.
The appealing story about each dinosaur is told in rhyme and would be good to read aloud. The vivid illustrations are a delight. Each dinosaur has a quirky face and devilish grin, which should delight a young audience.
There are lots of tantalising tabs and flaps for the reader to find, each with fun objects behind. The pop-ups are wonderful and will give a young user lots of opportunity to learn about the shapes of different dinosaurs while having a lot of fun.
As with all pop-up books, care is needed to keep the pop-ups intact, so this is a book to keep safe and treasure.
Pat Pledger