Review Blog

May 29 2011

Being here by Barry Jonsberg

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2011. ISBN 978 1742373850.
Leah Cartwright lives in a nursing home and suffers from Alzheimer's disease but is aware that she is in her declining years. When Carly, a sixteen year old student interviews her for a history project, Leah recounts her childhood living on a remote farm with only her mother for company.
Leah's loneliness of childhood is reflected by her existence in the impersonal care facility. Despite her assurances to Carly that her life was not unhappy, the reader is left with a real sense of sadness for a childhood spoiled and lost.
Being a puritanical Christian with an unhealthy, dogmatic, Old Testament view of life, Leah's mother is arrogant, ignorant and completely indifferent to the views, needs and rights of others. What Leah forgives and understands as circumstantial behaviour is nothing short of child abuse in emotional and physical form, perpetrated by a domineering bully.
The suffering of Leah's childhood is moderated by the character of Adam, a boy of her own age who manifests as an imaginary friend yet develops substance, influence and presence to a degree which must be determined and rationalised by the reader.
Through Leah, Jonsberg conveys the message that we are in control of our stories. As a child, Leah was completely and utterly powerless to alter any tangible aspect of her life and she had no recourse to social authorities, friends, family or witnesses of any kind. In the midst of this powerlessness however, the child responds by re-writing her story in her own imagination, creating an escapist, alternative experience which merged and also diverged with her reality. It could be considered that this response is a symptom of mental illness which would be an understandable outcome produced by the mother's psychiatric problems.
Interviewed by Carly, Leah has the opportunity to tell her story to a person who at first appears completely disconnected in a cultural and generational sense, yet who becomes captivated by the tale. Talking together, the pair offer insights which touch each other and a meaningful relationship beyond the school project is formed.
The theme of story telling continues with Leah's desire to commit her life to tape, almost as a statement but with an attempt to positively influence Carly, thus altering and participating in her life story.
This narrative will be interpreted differently by readers as Jonsberg invites them to take some responsibility for bringing the character of Adam to life and making conclusions about his nature and purpose.
Rob Welsh

Archived Blog Entries
Latest News
2017 Children's Peace Literature Award Short List
Inkys Awards 2017
2017 Miles Franklin Literary Award
2017 NSW Premier's History Awards
The Queensland Literary Awards 2017
CBCA Awards 2017 winners
Environment Award for Children's Literature 2017
Speech Pathology shortlist 2017
2017 CILIP Carnegie and Kate Greenaway Medals
2017 Branford Boase Award
2017 UKLA Book Awards

ReadPlus Features
Print similar authors bookmark
Read similar authors
How to find lesson plans
Sample theme animation

Promote Reading
Staff holiday reading list 2016
South Australian Christian Schools Conference 2016 - Library Displays
Display calendars
Value of School Libraries
Library, Reading development and the Internet
Free Rights of the Reader Poster
Reviews: Author index
Bookmark and poster templates