Reviews

Miki Falls: Summer by Mark Crilley

cover image

HarperCollins, 2007.
(Age 11-14) Miki tells the story about her forbidden love and the sort of relationships that happen in this world since she's known her boyfriend.
Miki's boyfriend is a kind of supernatural being called Delivers. He observes couples to see if they have true love and he gives tests to see if the couples could survive. If they can't, he will take their love and give it to another couple who have a chance. When Miki got to his house planning to surprise him, she sees him with another girl, who is a Deliver just like him.
Afterwards in her boyfriend's notebook, she sees some notes about her friend and her friend's boyfriend. She finds out that her friend's boyfriend is cheating on her with another friend.
Her friend accuses Miki of cheating on her with her boyfriend. Later Miki's boyfriend takes her out on proper dates. Then at this time the girl appears again to warn her off so Miki breaks up with her boyfriend, but Miki and her friend forgive each other because her friend's boyfriend confessed what happened. Miki's boyfriend still doesn't want to break up.
Lisa Cao (student)

Daisy Dawson and the big freeze by Steve Voake

cover image

Walker, 2009.
(Ages 7-9) What is Daisy to do? Woolverton, the curious young lamb, has disappeared into the ice and snow and Ricky the sheep dog is off working. It looks like it is up to Daisy and her loyal pet dog Boom to venture into the dangerous woods and rescue Woolverton. Who will they encounter on their way and what will they find? And most importantly, will they bring Woolverton home safely?
The third in the Daisy Dawson series by English author, Steve Voake, this book continues telling Daisy's adventures. Daisy is an energetic and kind girl who possesses the ability to talk to animals. Her home and school life is warm and cosy, providing the backdrop for her safe but satisfying adventures. The early chapters chronicle Daisy's day at school in the snow, which while engaging, left this reader impatient for the main storyline to develop.
The good-sized print, short chapters and regular illustrations make this a good choice for newly independent readers. Its appeal will be mainly for girls, particularly those who enjoy animal stories in cosy and comfortable settings.
Rachel Flenley

Evernight by Claudia Gray

cover image

HarperTeen, 2008.
(Age 14+) Teen romance, vampire angst, and ancient hatred all feature prominently in this plot driven story. Bianca has been enrolled in the exclusive Evernight Academy by her parents who also teach at the school and who are convinced that she needs to broaden her horizons and join the real world. Bianca doesn't fit in with the perfect students, all sleek and beautiful in their tailored uniforms. She wants to escape but then she meets another newcomer, Lucas, and feels an instant rapport with him, although he warns her to be careful. Can their love survive their differences and what are the secrets that the school is hiding?
The story is told in the first person from Bianca's point of view. Right from the start I was drawn into the plot and found it hard to put down as I followed Bianca's attempts to fit in and find friends and her growing obsession with Lucas. Bianca, although initially shy and rather withdrawn, grows into a strong heroine who is prepared to fight for what she wants. There are a couple of big surprises in the book and a third love interest with Balthazar, a very popular senior, as well as the inevitable battle between the vampires and their hunters.
Gray has written a suspenseful story with a great romance and her exploration of how vampires would need to survive in a modern world is leavened with humour. Readers who loved the Twilight series will love this book as well, and sequels are on the way!
Pat Pledger

Alive in the death zone by Lincoln Hall

cover image

Random House Australia, 2008. ISBN 9781741663372
(Ages 11+) Highly recommended. Alive in the Death Zone by Australian mountaineer Lincoln Hall successfully aims at the children's market, and is an adaptation of his adult book Dead Lucky.
The title refers to the author's miraculous survival from being left for dead overnight at 8,500 metres, just after summiting Mt Everest. Only the last 3 of 12 chapters are on this subject. Earlier chapters describe how Lincoln was introduced to climbing through his school's PE teacher and follows his career from initial excursions into the Brindabella's (ACT) and Blue Mountains, through to training in New Zealand and then completing his first Himalayan climb of 7,000 metre Dunagiri. It also describes how he worked as a trek leader and expedition photographer before his 2006 Mt Everest climb.
This book is brilliantly put together with the autobiographical story being regularly broken up with informative text boxes and captions on such topics as acclimatisation, snow blindness, dangers of couloirs (mountain gullies), yaks, lists of equipment etc. The 103 pages include 90 stunning photos enticing even the laziest person to have a browse. Reality is enhanced with a photo of Lincoln's black and decaying frostbitten fingers, parts of which are later amputated. This book can be read in less than 2 hours, or savoured a chapter at a time.
The climbing history of Everest is summarised: from the 1924 Mallory expedition; the problem that access from either Tibet or Nepal was forbidden for many years; and the successful attempt by Edmund Hillary and Sherpa Tenzing Norgay in 1953. A list of the world's highest mountains, a glossary and even a snakes and ladder type game of 'the Everest summit' also contribute to make this book educational.
Alive in the Death Zone is highly recommended for all upper primary and secondary libraries. Its picturesque cover and colourful and varied presentation from page to page will hold the interest of all. Additionally it will be a useful reference for those doing climbing in outdoor education. Adults seeking an inspiring story also will love this book and find themselves subconsciously extending their knowledge.
Kay Haarsma (Salisbury East High School)

Auslander by Paul Dowswell

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2009
(Ages 12+) Living in Poland with his German parents, Peter has only an inkling of what it means to be an outsider, a foreigner, when the German army comes racing through the countryside, killing and looting. After his parents are killed by a German tank, he is sent to an orphanage, but his German background and Aryan looks serve him well and he is adopted by a high ranking German professor of Eugenics at Berlin University.
Here he learns first hand that he must support the Nazi regime. At 14 he must join the Hitler-Jugend (Hitler youth) and be involved in patriotic things they do, as they become more and more allied to supporting the war effort. Peter meets Anna, and when she feels she can trust him, invites him to join her family supporting Jewish people hiding in the city. Peter's ideas of being an outsider, allied with his questioning of what Hitler is doing, alongside the news he hears which contradicts what the Hitler Youth is saying, sees him query the regime more and more. He and Anna visit a cafe where American music is played and must run for their lives when it is raided. His guardian bans him from playing Mendelssohn, then one day the older sister, Elsbeth, tells him what she has been doing as a nurse.
A page turning thriller, Auslander tells younger readers just how the Nazi regime put its ideas about a pure race into practice. Told against the background of the encroaching British and American armies, the story is exciting and involving, showing how some people rebelled against the Nazi order.
Fran Knight

Crime time: Australians behaving badly by Sue Bursztynski

cover image

Ford Street Publishing, 2009
ISBN 978 1 876462 76 5
(Age 11+) We all know the fascination held by many readers for true crime stories and investigations. Here is a well-researched and broad-ranging collection of tales which focus on criminals appearing throughout Australian history. Beginning in the 1600s, a comprehensive list moves through the decades to the early 2000s, featuring such names as John Giles Price, Ned Kelly, Squizzy Taylor, Ronald Ryan, Julian Knight, Ivan Milat, Chopper Read, and Carl Williams. Each story devotes about four pages to its subject, accompanied by a clever little portrait drawn by Louise Prout, with Did You Know facts presented as a footnote to each chapter. This compilation is readable and interesting, and perfect for the young investigator. Kerry Greenwood's introduction invites the reader, with great enthusiasm, to wallow in the 'deep, dark history of crime, true crime' of Australia's past. However, it is disconcerting to find some stories included, such as Martin Bryant's of the Port Arthur Massacre, with his portrait illustrating the title page, when the cover, title and introduction imply a certain light hearted or sensational element to the collection. Overall the collection is informative and extensive, with each entry conveying a good sense of place, time and character. A useful bibliography and index are included.
Julie Wells

The composer is dead by Lemony Snicket

cover image

Harper Collins, 2009.
(Ages:all) Recommended. This story is a crime tale, and the detective called to the scene of the crime, goes through the whole orchestra in search of the murderer. One by one he eliminates each section of the orchestra, finding out where they were at the time in question. On each double page spread the section of the orchestra under suspicion is drawn in silhouette, and bars of music are scattered from one page to another. The whole is a musical treat, as it introduces younger readers to the instruments which make up an orchestra and what each section does. The composer's death is still a mystery at the end, but all the orchestra including the conductor admit to having some hand at killing a composer at some time in their lives. Linked with humour, dancers, bars of music and the best of illustrations, every reader will be entranced,
The beautifully illustrated and presented hard cover book, The composer is dead, is augmented with a CD containing the story narrated by Lemony Snicket, and the instrumental version, tucked into the front inside cover. The illustrations by Carson Ellis reflect the humour inherent in the tale, using a small range of colour luminously. This book is a treat for all.
Fran Knight

Cicada Summer by Kate Constable

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2009. ISBN 97817417828 3
(Ages 10+)Highly recommended. Gently reflecting the twin values of family and friendship, Cicada Summer will captivate readers as they examine the enigmatic Eloise and her struggle to communicate. She is a lonely yet resilient 12 year old, wary of people, but desperate to have a friend. She takes risks, and although unable to speak, watches with an artist's observant eye.
Moving to the country supposes a fresh start for Eloise and her dad. With his grandiose ideas of developing his mother's long empty house, he hopes Eloise will find her voice, lost after her mother died. Not happy to see them, Eloise's Gran, Mo, is wrapped in her own reclusive world, and is even less happy when her son leaves for the city. An unhappy combination, Mo retreats to her study, while Eloise grabs an old bike from the garage to ride to Mo's abandoned house, briefly seen on the way. There she walks into a time when the house is full of people, the garden cared for and a child of her own age there to be her friend.
The world Eloise inhabits is both familiar and unsettling as she returns each day to be with Anna. The two girls paint the summerhouse, Eloise further developing her drawing and painting skills, and through her friendship with Anna, learning to accept her mother's death. Christmas sees Elois's father return with a friend and Mo's next door neighbours, the Durranis, decide to cook the Christmas meal for the family joining in with their celebrations. The stage is set for some revealing behavior from all sides.
Fran Knight

The Donkey who carried the wounded by Jackie French

cover image

Angus and Robertson, 2009 ISBN 978073228839 6
(Ages 10+) The inestimable Jackie French has done it again, writing a wonderful novel of a time in our history that we have all heard of, but may know little about. Effortlessly she makes us believe that the donkey which carried the wounded at Gallipoli was aware of what he was doing, that he had a relationship with Simpson, the ambulance man who retrieved the wounded from the terrible gulleys above the beach. Her writing, using alternate chapters about Jack (Simpson) and the donkey will impress the reader with their poignancy and authenticity. She has used wide research to make sure that her setting is real, the information is accurate and the ambience, truthful. Readers will soak up the atmosphere, cling to the stories of the wounded and immerse themselves in the world of Gallipoli in 1915, when so many were killed and wounded.
She tells us in her notes at the end that she made up the beginning and end of the story, and has used all sorts of research, myths and stories to write her novel. She has succeeded brilliantly in creating a story which will enlighten, inform and involve its readers. No-one will be immune from shedding tears while reading this, as French gives us chapters about some of the wounded, alongside Jack and the donkey, as well as chapters about the sniper in the hills, who eventually killed Simpson.
The whole, as in all of this series, The Animal Stars, has a large afterward, explaining the research that she undertook, and giving extra notes about some of the features of the novel, along with an informative glossary. This beautifully written book is a significant addition to the books about Gallipoli, especially Simpson and his Donkey. And, as in all of her books about war, she promotes the lives of those less well known, the footnotes of history, and this makes history truly real for her readership.
Fran Knight

Ever by Gail Carson Levine

cover image

HarperCollins, 2008.
(Ages 9-14) Imagine that you are a young girl on the brink of womanhood, and because of an oath that your father has made to the god, Admat, you are going to be sacrificed. Kezi, knowing that she has only a month to live, is trying to keep up her spirits, when she notices a majestic, muscular young slave at a wedding. Unknown to her, it is Olus, the god of the wind, and he has has fallen in love with her and is determined to help her. He offers her the chance to become immortal, but to do that they both have to undertake a difficult task to prove their worth.
The author has written the story in the first person, with alternating chapters told by Kezi and Olus. The reader gets to know the two characters quite well as they recount their fears, feelings and what is happening around them. All the sentences are short, as are the chapters, and this makes for ease of reading. The exotic setting, perhaps the Middle East, is fascinating, particularly the descriptions of rug making and dancing, both of which Kezi excels at.
On the surface Ever appears to be a straight forward love story between a young god and a mortal girl, and younger readers will enjoy the plight of the young couple and the action surrounding the difficult quest that each must undertake. More discerning readers will spend time pondering the meaning of love and what some people are prepared to sacrifice for it. Religion is also a major theme and Levine examines the way that two different belief systems can operate: in Kezi's world there is only one god, but in Olus's domain there are many.
A very attractive cover will be sure to draw in readers, who will then have to read on to find out if Kezi survives and if the young lovers find happiness.
Pat Pledger

Bite of the Mango by Mariatu Kamara with Susan McClelland

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2009.
(Ages 15+ ) Biography. Civil war in Sierra Leone means that Mariatu and her family have no idea of where to run when the rebels arrive. Burning villages, raping, murdering and mutilating those they come across, the drug addled, and leaderless anarchistic rebels cut off the girl's hands in an effort to stop her voting for the president. What is a president? She asks, underlining her innocence and naivety at what is going on around her.
This amazing true story will fill readers with dread as they read of what is happening in countries where guerilla bandits attempt to take control, or at the very least, destabilise their country. It is a story filled with horror as harrowing story after harrowing story is related by this young girl. Eventually getting to a hospital, she finds that she is pregnant, not to one of the rebels, but raped by her husband to be.
Living in a refugee camp where she and her friends must beg to survive, Mariatu is heartened by news that people from rich countries have read of her plight and sent her money to survive. She revels in the fact that she is being noticed, and is eventually taken to Canada where her benefactors find a place for her to live and be educated. She decides that her education will be the savior for herself and her country and now divides her time between Canada and Sierra Leone helping others in her situation.
A distressing story from start to finish, the core at its heart is Mariatu's spirit. She rarely allows herself to be self pitying, instead looking for ways to ensure her survival. She takes every opportunity available to her, noting that those who have come from a life like hers are eagerly taking up the education offered to them. It is a salutatory read, one which will enhance our students' view of themselves in this world, making them much more aware of the courage that some display to survive. Fran Knight

The best cow in show by Andy Cutbill and Russell Ayto

cover image

HarperCollins, 2009.
Ages 5+ Following on from the success of The cow that laid an egg, comes this charming picture book, relishing in the cow with her chicken offspring. When the farmer's wife declares a competition to see who has the most beautiful baby, all the cows are prepared to present their offspring. There are calves everywhere, except for one place of course. Marjorie and her chicken, Daisy, are ready to be inspected by the farmer's wife, when Daisy spies a worm in her hat. Without further ado, she picks off the worm, and the farmer's wife faints. All the cows laugh, but Marjorie whisks Daisy into her arms telling them that she may not be the same as all the others, but she is loved. With that the bull, Derek, gives her the rosette as best in show because she is the prefect mum.
A delightful story with a serious message, The best cow in show will absorb and amuse younger readers as they follow Marjorie's antics through the book. The moral of the story is obvious to all, and many discussions in class will follow as the children talk of how love is unconditional. The fine illustrations by Russell Ayto are perfect, paralleling the nonsense of the story, with the theme of a mother's love reflected in the eyes of all the cows.
Fran Knight

Torn pages by Sally Grindley

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2009.
(Ages 12+) The impact of AIDS in Africa is told to readers using a small family left alone by the distress of the deaths of their parents. Lydia, a young girl in her early teens must look after her ill sister, Kesi and brother Joe. One would expect other family members to come to the fore and help the youngsters, but their only relative, their father's mother, proves to be a disturbing and undermining grandmother. She cannot accept her son's death and so blames the mother, leaving the children bereft of any support.
In describing the family's plight, Grindley reveals the force of this disease on the community. Lydia and her siblings can no longer attend school, so their future is made even grimmer. Their isolation by some members of the community, reinforced by the suspicion that Kesi has AIDS, and the fear of catching the disease, is underlined by Kesi's separation from other students at school. It is the daily existence that Grindley explains so well: the family's attempts to grow vegetables, Lydia's attempts to repair their clothes, the kindness of others in the village, the daily struggle to attend school and Lydia's nervousness at the offers of help from a local man. Lydia's continual support comes from the diary left by her mother, encouraging the young girl in her efforts to be optimistic and aware of her parents' love. Quotes from this diary form a neat parallel to their day to day existence.
Reading this novel will engender plenty of discussions about AIDS and its progress through a community, and students will be able to compare this book with others written on the same theme, Chanda's secret (Allan Stratton) The Heaven Shop (Deborah Ellis) and Two Weeks with the Queen (Morris Gleitzman) .
Fran Knight

When the Hipchicks went to War by Pamela Rushby

cover image

Lothian, 2009. ISBN 978 0734410917
(Ages 14+) Using the medium of three young girls off to Vietnam to entertain the troops, Rushby presents an easily digested story of the Vietnam War and its impact on all concerned. Told through the youngest of the girls, Kathy, a sixteen year old apprentice hairdresser, we see her caught up in the times, the swinging sixties, wanting more out of life than setting perms for housewives. She goes along to an audition for dancers, and is dismayed to see the hundreds of girls just like her lining up. Another girl suggests that she, Kathy and a third girl present themselves as a trio, and they are immediately hired.
Once in Vietnam, they are quickly employed by the Americans to tour the hospitals and they see the war at first hand. Covered in protective gear, they ride in jeeps and helicopters of all shapes and sizes to the hospital tents where they entertain the sick, injured and dying. The impact on the girls is overwhelming, and Rushby's writing ensures that the reader will be just as moved. The journey the girls take from innocence to horror is riveting, and confronting. Kathy's brother is called up, her boyfriend and closest girlfriend back in Australia are involved in the anti Vietnam War rallies, they are followed by a journalist Jan, who writes about their experiences for the Women's Weekly and so on, all these experiences are real and add to the authenticity of the story.
Rushby shows the changing times incredibly well, the attitude to women, the protest movement, a shotgun marriage, the increasing disillusionment with the war; increasing use of drugs and so on, reminding me with immediacy of my uni days in the 1960's; the marches, the burning of call up papers, the TV footage of the wounded and dying, the self immolation of Buddhist priests, the imprisonment of conscientious objectors. The book is redolent with the changes that the Vietnam War and the sixties brought to the youth of Australia and will be an eye opener for astute mature readers from about year 9 and up.
Fran Knight

Chalice by Robin McKinley.

cover image

G.P. Putnam's Sons, 2008.
(Age 11+) Recommended. I have never been disappointed with a book written by Robin McKinley and this is no exception. Mirasol is a humble beekeeper, who tends her bees and sometimes hears the earthlines speak to her. She is astounded when she is chosen to become the Chalice, a very important member of the Master's Circle. It is her role to bind the Circle together with its new Master and keep the Willowlands and its people healthy. But Mirasol has not been trained for this important duty and the new Master is a priest of fire whose very touch burns. How can she give the Master his chance to lead his lands to prosperity?
McKinley never repeats her plots. Each book is a new and unique experience and Chalice brims with originality. Her heroine is a strong young woman who must contend not only with bees that are making huge amounts of honey and goats who are producing bounteous milk but the enigmatic Master who burns beneath his cloak and who also has doubts about his ability to lead.
This is not an action packed fantasy with sword wielding characters and wicked sorcerers; rather it is a rich and rewarding story about duty and love of the land. The tension revolves around whether her heroine and hero will be able to overcome their doubts and fears and reach their full potential.
The beautiful language ensures that the reader will remember the images of Willowlands, the earthlines and most of all the healing power of honey.
Intelligent readers who want their fantasy laced with intricate language, wonderful images and a quiet romance will need to go no further. This book is a keeper.
Pat Pledger