Reviews

The Reformed Vampire Support Group by Catherine Jinks

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2009.
ISBN 978174175672 2
Highly recommended. Picking up a Catherine Jinks novel is akin to eating Haighs chocolate. The richness is overwhelming and while it is in your hands, you are very aware that this is the best. There is nothing like it, it will stay with you and keep on nourishing you a long while after it is finished. And reading this pushes all other vampire novels which have littered the scene lately, simply out of your head.
The group meets every Tuesday evening with Father Ramon for support and companionship. Their lives are not those of the mythology, they are despondent, some almost wishing death, fed up with their diet of guinea pigs, and the continual cramping and illness which pervades their nights. The young girl, Nina, is one of the last to have been infected by Casimir, who arrived from Europe in the nineteenth century. Several of their number tracked down all those infected by Casimir and gathered them together to support each other so they would no longer go out and fang people.
But one day they find Casimir has been killed. The usual things have happened: a silver bullet, a stake through his heart, head removed form his body, leaving behind just a pile of ash. Stunned they set out to investigate the murder. This takes Father Ramon, Nina and Dave to Cobar in the west, and they uncover an appalling pair of men who have live bait fighting on their farm. But not dogs or cocks, they have found a werewolf and it is this young man who is forced to fight, each full moon. for vast amounts of money to enrich his captors.
Laugh out loud, clever, witty and with a vocabulary that warms the soul, The Reformed Vampire Support Group is magnificent. Each of the characters is sharply defined and the reader cares about what happens to them all. Full of heart stopping escapades, I read this book everywhere but the shower, as I followed Nina and Dave in their quest to hunt down the killer.
Fran Knight

Curly saves Grandma's house by Sally Morgan, and Ambelin, Blaze and Ezekiel Kwaymullina

cover image

Ill. by Adam Hill
Random House, 2009. ISBN 978741662931
This middle primary novel is an easy read with large print and cartoonish pictures of magical creatures called Fents and Grents. The Fent called Pook, who looks like a long- haired furry seal, lives with Curly and was introduced in the first book, Curly and the Fent. It would help to have read this book first, but you will still discover that Pook has magic powers, eg inducing dreams in others, and is a rival of the nasty tricksters, the Grents. Both fantasy types are only seen by those with the Sight. The antics of these creatures are a subplot to the main themes of corruption at local government level and uniting divided families. Curly, about 10, learns that his grandmother is about to have her home bulldozed by the mayor who is going to sell the land for a marina and become rich. Curly sets out to thwart the scheme.
The family characters and Pook are vividly and realistically drawn, whilst the mayor and police seem stereotypes. The plot seems to be designed to create a political awareness amongst this age group, rather than realistically capture an event. This may be Sally's contribution, with the fun of the Fents and Gents perhaps coming from the children authors. Well written, its 'message' approach may limit its appeal, worthy though it is.
The book ends with a new crisis, so that you want to buy the next one to see what happens.
Kevyna Gardner

Mrs Lincoln's dressmaker by Lynda Jones

cover image

National Geographic, 2009. ISBN 9781426303777
(Ages 10+) A picture book format but with a large amount of text, this book is aimed at upper primary and lower secondary students interested in the history of the USA. It is the story of the relationship between the president's wife, Mary Lincoln and her black dressmaker, Elizabeth Keckley. Told chronologically, the tale covers the days of slavery, up to Lincoln's inauguration, the Civil War and his assassination and the years following his death.
The two women met when Elizabeth was developing a sound business in New York making dresses for women of fashion. A seamstress as a child, she had developed a strong business in the south before buying her freedom and moving north. She sought out Mrs Lincoln's business, eventually becoming firm friends with the woman. But when Mr Lincoln was killed, Elizabeth gave up her business to try and help the almost destitute Mary Lincoln, eventually losing all credibility herself and dying in poverty.
A fascinating look at the history of the USA in the middle of the nineteenth century, the book has many photos which readers will pore over. The book reveals the life of a slave in the southern states, alongside that of a woman brought up with slaves to command. Most interesting is the life of Mrs Lincoln after the assassination, and the downfall of Elizabeth Keckley, in trying to help her friend. Surprisingly, considering the publishers of the book, there are no maps.
Fran Knight

Riding the black cockatoo by John Danalis

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2009. ISBN 9781741753776
This true story starts with John, a mature age white Australian, taking a token 'indigenous writing' course as part of his university studies in 2005. In one of his tutorials, he inadvertently blurts out; 'That's nothing: I grew up with an Aboriginal skull on my mantelpiece'. The shocked reactions from his fellow classmates cause ramifications that take John, and his family, on a long journey of introspection.
Growing up in the 60's and 70's John had never thought to ask why an Aboriginal skull, named 'Mary' was displayed on the family mantelpiece. With amazing honesty John recalls the prejudices, not only the general ones of the times, but of those of his parents. He states that'do gooders were tolerated. Abo-lovers were despised,' and that interaction with aboriginals was a one way mirror. One looked but didn't interact. Such was the insidious nature of racism in Australia at the time.
John's decision to return 'Mary' from Melbourne to her Wamba Wamba home near Swan Hill took him on a long self-discovery tour of Aboriginal history and culture. His recollections are riveting and educate the reader equally well. He examines how institutions like museums often regarded aboriginal remains as trophies and were reluctant to hand them back. We learn that aboriginal people are often reported falsely in the media. Even on the two dollar coin a generic aboriginal caricature is used, not a specific individual, as happens when white people are depicted. The patience, generosity and forgiving attitude of most aborigines is illustrated again and again.
The ceremonial handover of the skull reconciles past and present for John and his parents. His father said afterwards, 'I've had to rethink 60 years of attitude'. John becomes somewhat obsessed with chasing more information on the aboriginal culture and this leads to some personal problems. His journey is well summarised in the statement, 'you're just a whitefella who's learnt to listen.'
This unique book should be required reading in all upper secondary classes, and especially Australian history. Teacher's notes are available via the publisher's website. Australians who grew up in the 1960-70's will also find great interest in this book.
Kay Haarsma

Tuck by Stephen Lawhead

cover image

Atom, 2009. ISBN 9781905654130
(Age: 13+) Although Tuck is the third in the series in this retelling of the Robin Hood legend it can be read as a stand alone novel. Tuck, the rather corpulent friar we are all familiar with, takes his place in the Lawhead version in a different way than that we are used to. He is as fond of his ale and food as we would expect. His part in this particular telling, however, is a major one.
The setting of Lawhead's tale has moved to the Welsh marshes where William Rufus' hold is not quite as firm as in England. The wild primordial forest gives Rhi Bran and his followers protection and sustenance, with their greatest advantage being the long bow, its range and devastating fire power used with small raiding parties or in battle. Tuck provides Bran with a different sort of intelligence than usually seen in Robin Hood stories. Tuck is able to go where Rhi and the rest of his band are unable to go. As a mendicant friar he is welcome in most places high or low, and his basic understanding of Latin, French, Welsh and English makes him an invaluable tool against the Normans or Ffreinc as the Welsh know them.
Lawhead's story is an exciting one, but because he is essentially retelling a very well known tale it plays out conventionally. The characters are those we're used to, the names vary with the change of setting. The author also gives a pronunciation guide at the beginning of the book and how seriously this is used depends entirely on the reader.
The ending gives reasons as to why the story has come to be now set in Sherwood Forest and in Nottingham in a very clever and satisfying way. A good rollicking read that will give pleasure to any of the vast number of Robin Hood followers. The first two books in this series are Hood and Scarlett. Suitable for secondary readers.
Mark Knight

The 10 pm question by Kate De Goldi

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2008
ISBN 9781741757354
Highly recommended. I greatly enjoyed this well written book which tackles the themes of early teenage angst and relationships, depression and adult agoraphobia. Its appeal lies largely in the believability and likeability of the characters, many of whom can be described as mildly eccentric in the English way. It was not immediately obvious that the book was set in New Zealand, but the cultural tone is refreshingly different to Australia.
Although thirteen year old Frankie is squeamish and neurotic, his concerns undoubtedly reflect many normal teenage worries and the author's skill in sharing what is going on in his head creates empathy and care for him. Frankie has a lot to worry about with his mum being agoraphobic for the last nine years, and he feeling unnecessarily responsible for her in the way that sensitive children do. Plus a new girl suddenly appears in his life and threatens not only his relationship with his good mate Gigs, but also his carefully created stability and order. The book is set over some four months with each chapter set about two weeks later than the last one. Despite its serious theme there is humour and vivid detail aplenty.
Frankie's caring family are individual but normal characters and his three maiden aunts are unforgettable in their unsatiable zest for life. You wish you had aunts like this. The teacher, Mr A, is a character we no longer see in schools, more's the pity. In Sydney, the new girl, Kate De Goldi creates a remarkably confident, non-conformist and likeable young lady who succeeds in spite of a very unstable background. She and Frankie have life lessons for each other but this isn't a 'message' book. I liked the way De Goldi creates characters who are original, creative, different, likeable and accepted. We need more like them in these increasingly conformist times. So what if the family calls dad 'Uncle George', his mum never steps outside the door and Frankie doesn't get to Camp? They all still have a lot going for them!
I felt the title and cover design of a bird did not do justice to the book, given how teenagers are so visually driven, and how real the people in it are. More discerning readers in all secondary years will enjoy this book. Its 'old-fashioned' tone is like a breath of fresh air.
Kevyna Gardner

George's cosmic treasure hunt by Lucy and Stephen Hawking

cover image

Random House, 2009.
(Age 9+) In an exciting new adventure, we see the return of George and Annie following the success of Lucy and Stephen's first novel George's Secret Key to the Universe.
George is devastated when his best friend and fellow space adventurer Annie moves to the United States with her family. It isn't long before George receives an invitation to join Annie and he soon realises all is not as it seems. Annie needs George's help to solve clues that she believes are being left by aliens and soon another mission to outer space is underway. We're introduced to a new friend, a computer genius named Emmett who drives the inseparable pair crazy to begin with, before they realise Emmett's invaluable skills to get the super computer Cosmos working again so they can solve the clues and save planet Earth.
As with the original story, the authors have cleverly weaved fact and fiction together. Annie's scientist father Eric provides George with a unique book The User's Guide to the Galaxy, which contains interesting space facts in simple dialogue. The middle of the book contains some incredible photographs of space. These visual stimulations are further enhanced by fantastic illustrations by Garry Parsons.
With a return of favourite characters including the evil Dr Reeper, this sequel is sure to delight space adventurers all over again. The factual boxes appear intermittently throughout the story and The User's Guide to the Galaxy has been used cleverly to blend these in with the main story. Stunning pictures, factual information presented in a simple manner, a great adventure story and a lesson in forgiveness combine to make this a fantastic novel for young readers. This is a highly recommended book for boys and girls, especially those reluctant readers and children beginning to explore novels.
Alison Woodward

Guantanamo Boy by Anna Perera

cover image

HarperCollins, 2008,
ISBN: 9780732288952
(Age 15+) Guantanamo Boy is a shocking story, particularly if, as the author asserts, it is inspired by real events. Khalid is an average fifteen year-old kid from Lancashire in England. He loves hanging out with his mates, playing football and online computer games. He also fancies Niamh, a new girl at school. Khalid's Mum is from Turkey and his Dad is from Pakistan and so when his grandmother dies back in Pakistan, Khalid's family travels to Karachi to visit his aunts. Khalid has a cousin called Tariq who lives in Lahore and whom he has never met, but they communicate over the Internet. One night, Khalid and Tariq are playing Bomber One, a computer game that Tariq invented, when armed men storm into the house where Khalid is staying, seize Khalid, cover his head with a hood and throw him into the back of a van, where he's kicked and beaten. This is just the start of a long and harrowing journey during which Khalid is deprived and tortured into admitting he's a member of Al Quaida and part of a terrorist plot to blow up cities around the world. Having supposedly confessed to his crime, Khalid is then taken to Guantanamo Bay and held in Camp Delta in appalling conditions and subjected to the most inhumane treatment. It takes two years before his innocence comes to light, during which Khalid's mind slips in and out of sanity. Thoughts of his family, his home in England and Niamh are all that hold him together.
This book is told in a simplistic manner to appeal to younger readers and with an obvious bias. Nonetheless, it is an important and topical story, though quite disturbing. It would be suitable for senior fiction.
Marilyn Coleman

Guantanamo Boy by Anna Perera

cover image

HarperCollins, 2008,
ISBN: 9780732288952
(Age 15+) Guantanamo Boy is a shocking story, particularly if, as the author asserts, it is inspired by real events. Khalid is an average fifteen year-old kid from Lancashire in England. He loves hanging out with his mates, playing football and online computer games. He also fancies Niamh, a new girl at school. Khalid's Mum is from Turkey and his Dad is from Pakistan and so when his grandmother dies back in Pakistan, Khalid's family travels to Karachi to visit his aunts. Khalid has a cousin called Tariq who lives in Lahore and whom he has never met, but they communicate over the Internet. One night, Khalid and Tariq are playing Bomber One, a computer game that Tariq invented, when armed men storm into the house where Khalid is staying, seize Khalid, cover his head with a hood and throw him into the back of a van, where he's kicked and beaten. This is just the start of a long and harrowing journey during which Khalid is deprived and tortured into admitting he's a member of Al Quaida and part of a terrorist plot to blow up cities around the world. Having supposedly confessed to his crime, Khalid is then taken to Guantanamo Bay and held in Camp Delta in appalling conditions and subjected to the most inhumane treatment. It takes two years before his innocence comes to light, during which Khalid's mind slips in and out of sanity. Thoughts of his family, his home in England and Niamh are all that hold him together.
This book is told in a simplistic manner to appeal to younger readers and with an obvious bias. Nonetheless, it is an important and topical story, though quite disturbing. It would be suitable for senior fiction.
Marilyn Coleman

Mac Slater, Cool Hunter 2: I love NY by Tristan Bancks

cover image

Random House Australia, 2009.
(Ages: 10-14) After successfully winning the title Coolhunters Mac Slater, his Dad (as chaperon) and Paul his fellow inventor head to New York to attend the Imaginator Festival of Inventions and Creativity - the prize for winning the Coolhunters competition. Unfortunately all does not go according to plan on their arrival in New York. Speed and Tony the Coolhunter bosses are nowhere to be found, traffic conditions challenge Mac's dad and their accommodation is less than ideal. When they arrive at Madison Square Gardens to attend the festival they are stunned at their inability to enter. Fortunately a simple plane delay has held up Speed and Tony and before long Mac and Paul make contact - things seem to be back on track. Once again their task is to discover 'cool' happenings around New York - they know this isn't going to be easy. As is the case with Mac and Paul things have a way of backfiring! But then they meet Melody and discover a hidden world of wonderful inventions. However they also come across a secret too mind blowing to keep. The consequences of revealing what they discover, though, have almost fatal results.
Having really enjoyed the first novel involving these characters I found this sequel a little lacking.
Tracy Glover

Jackdaw Summer by David Almond

cover image

Hodder Children's Books, 2009. ISBN 978034088198 9
The summer Liam plunges his knife into Nattrass, is the summer he begins to grow up. Before that summer he is unaware of life going around him, content with his friends and school, family and village. He is aware that his best friend is growing away from him, finding a girlfriend, no longer interested in camping out and war games, looking ot the future. He is aware that Nattrass, the school bully and a former friend is goading him, turning up at places where he thought he was alone, exerting power over him. But after he finds a baby in the old ruins near his home, things change.
Liam and his family visit the child in its foster home and meet two other foster children, the enigmatic Oliver a refugee from Liberia, looking far beyond his 13 years,  and Crystal, a refugee from appalling foster homes after her family died in a fire. When Crystal and Oliver turn up at Liam's place they expect Liam to help them escape and hide from the police. But Nattrass is watching.
A most unusual story, Jackdaw Summer is the story of Liam's awakening to life around him. He learns that life is not always fair, that he has a role to play in life and must work out his part in it. The stories of Oliver and Crystal shake Liam's safe existence, the abandoned baby becomes a catalyst for his family and the wildness of Liam, camping out and playing at war is most successfully contrasted with the reality of Oliver's background and that of the other boy Nattrass, while this is all underscored by the reality of the war games being played in the hills by the Army Reserve. A thought provoking read, students will find that they continue thinking about the nature of humanity, war, refugees, families and the beast within us for a long time after the last page is read.
Fran Knight

A certain music by Celeste Walters

cover image

Random House, 2009
ISBN 978174166333 4
(Age 7-10) Recommended. A gentle story set in the Vienna Woods of a loner and lonely child (who is always called 'child' or 'Liebling'), who is enchanted with Beethoven's music and finds unexpected joy and happiness in listening to the man seated at the piano playing the most beautiful music she has ever heard.  The plot is simple, but the richness of the descriptions of the surrounding woods, cottages and market place make the story come alive. It's an unusual way to introduce young readers to the joy of classical music and in particular Ode to Joy, but the reader is drawn to the sympathetic portrayal of the child, her Mutti, Beethoven and later her Father. Anne Spudvilas' black and white illustrations add another dimension to the simple charm of the book. It's a tragic story of a father who likes to drink and eventually finds work in the army and a Mother who coughs up blood.  But the overwhelming feeling belongs to the child who is sweet and caring and understands the worries of a brilliant composer. The end is quite special.
The font is close. Sensitive readers will enjoy this short story (121pp).
Recommended for Middle Primary, especially girls.
Sue Nosworthy

Posse by Kate Welshman

cover image

Random House, Sydney, 2009; 278 p.ISBN 978 1 74166 335 8

Posse is targeted at teenage girls with the story revolving around girls from a Sydney private girl's school on a year 11 camp.Amy, the main character, comes from a split family and lives with her mother and grandparents.The grandma has a narcissistic personality disorder and is a control freak over everyone.The vagaries of teenage friendships are examined closely through the school setting. Sixteen year old Army is having a lesbian relationship with a younger student but also has a group of five peers, her posse, through which much of her daily interactions take place.

At the school camp both Amy and her friend Clare are attracted to Bevan, a good looking instructor (and trainee minister) and this causes some jealousy. Both strive for his attention and end up alone in his room at different times.Allegations of sexual impropriety are made and the story follows how Amy's friends, parents and the teachers react to this.

This first novel of Kate Welshman, appears a bit contrived and seems to take quite a while to reach a conclusion. However, the themes of sexual experimentation and teenage life should prove popular with secondary school aged girls. Could possibly be used for a middle school text or for health / personal development lessons examining the adult - junior relationship issue, responsibilities and ethics.

Kay Haarsma (Salisbury East HS)

Waterslain Angels by Kevin Crossley-Holland,

cover image

Orion children's books, 2008. ISBN 9781842556917. Ages 10+
When an angel's wing is found in the attic of the local church, Annie is agog with stories of the times of Cromwell and the destruction of the idolatrous. The town of Waterslain believes the angles were all destroyed, but Annie and her friend, Sandy, think otherwise and set out to find them. Fourteen angels in all decorated the medieval church, flying high above the worshippers. Sandy, recently returned with his mother from USA, is a geeky young lad, worried about his future in the town of his mother. His father, now dead, was an American airman, stationed in the area during WW2, meeting Gracie and taking her back to the states when the war finished.
It is the 1950's, and children are not adhered to indoor games and television and computers as they are now, but free to roam the wilds of the countryside and follow their noses in spying out a clue of two. Crossly-Holland readily evokes the most beautiful of settings for his story, and develops a clutch of rounded characters to intrigue the reader. Some heart stopping sequences will thrill, as the children firstly climb into the church tower, forbidden because of the bees, then clamber through a cellar under the church when the tide is coming in, and finally descend a well in the church yard, convinced that the statues lie at the bottom.
A beautiful story of finding what is lost and of renewing the past, Waterslain Angels is one of those books you will want to keep. Its underlying themes about the shaping of history and of forgiveness, make this book a superb read aloud in middle to upper primary schools.
Fran Knight

Shrapnel by Robert Swindells

cover image

Corgi, 2009. ISBN 978 0 552 559300
(Ages 10-13) When young Gordon finds a gun hidden in the chimney of his brother's room in their London home, he is agog. His brother is rarely home, and in his late teens, has not enlisted in the services, and he is never home to receive his call up papers when they arrive. Gordon, however knows where he hangs out and waits for him. When confronted with the story of the gun, Raymond tells Gordon that he is a government spy, doing underground work in secret, and enlists Gordon's help. Gordon is sent to buy a model plane which he is then to let fly over the fence of a nearby factory. Gordon does this three times, believing himself to be helping fight the Germans, but the third time, police are involved and Gordon runs.
A thriller about one boy's involvement in bigger issues than school, and the collection of shrapnel, Swindell's story gives readers a different perspective of war at home. With airplane battles overhead, buildings being bombed, people rushing to their shelters and students collecting shrapnel to sell to their classmates, the story has an authority which will intrigue its readers.
Fran Knight