Reviews

Fire song by Libby Hathorn

cover image

ABC Books, 2009. ISBN 9780733324208.
(Age 11-14) From the first paragraph Libby Hathorn focuses the reader's attention upon the dangers facing the young Ingrid Crowe who carries a burden of responsibility that no young person should have to contend with. Her mother has revealed that she intends to set fire to their home at the end of the day.We discover that Ingrid's father is away for the long term, her two older brothers are being looked after on a farm far from home, and she and her sister Pippa live with a mother who has had little success with a boarding house in a fairly isolated country town. It becomes clear the Ingrid's mother is unable to cope with her situation and makes this terrible decision about the immediate future. She tells Ingrid that she must commit to the plan.
The story covers only a few days but within that time we see the emotional trap that envelopes Ingrid, and we watch in fear as she tries to save all those who are precious around her. She has a strong sense of family, history and the courage required to face daunting circumstances. There are numerous people in the town who would help her but, at what cost? Her family will be further torn apart by this devastating plan.It is all too difficult to contemplate. We become so involved in the young girl's predicament that our journey through the book is full of tension too; we try to anticipate Ingrid's next move.This is a powerful story, well told, with realistic characterisation, but be cautioned, the subject matter may be frightening for the immature reader.
Julie Wells

The golden flower by Eleanor Coombe

cover image

Lothian Children's Books, 2009.The Faraway Series; book 10. ISBN 9780734410511.
(Primary) The glacier is melting and so are the hobyahs. Set on Faraway Island, Ziel the Asrai River Fairy Princess, works her magic and together with the hobyahs turns the hated goblin tunnels into 'giant ice blocks' (p46). Along with the Mistral trees, Astara the Fairy Queen, Blaize, the Singing Fairy, Cedar, Puck and Wattleman, outwit Garton the New King of the Grim Goblins who have mined the Diamond River of its precious jewels and in doing so have polluted the river and restored Asrai's health.
The black and white illustrations emphasise the good and bad characters and some of the names such as Puck, Eden and Wattleman are quite obvious. Text is well spaced and clear appealing to early primary girls who enjoy reading books belonging to a series.
Sue Nosworthy

Here lies Arthur by Philip Reeve

cover image

Scholastic, 2007.ISBN 978 140710 358 7
(Ages: 10+) Highly recommended. One of those books I had heard lots about so bought it to read. For those wrapped up in the Arthur legends then here is a definitive book that makes you want to reread the Arthur books and legends of old. Reeve has made Arthur just like a media personality or politician, and taken apart the hype that surrounds him, showing how it is all generated by his publicity man, in this case, Myrddin (Merlin) He creates stories about Arthur to tell at camp fires and towns in the area where Arthur is the local war lord. Myrddin is convinced that Britain needs an Arthur to drive out the Saxons and make Britain great under one ruler. And doesn't that sound familiar!
In this story, Myrddin is at one of Arthur's pillages of a community, when he spies a young slave girl trying to escape. She jumps into the lake and holds her breath long enough to swim a long way down the river, holding her breathe it until she can surface out of harm's way. Here Myrddin conceives a plot to engrandise Arthur using her ability for swimming under water. So the Lady of the Lake is born, and Gwyna, now called Gwyn becomes Myrddin's servant.
When Gwyn becomes older, his femalenees becomes more apparent so Myrddin thinks to installs him as Arthur's wife's servant, and so is privy to what is happening in Gwenhwyfar's quarters. But Gwyna becomes enamoured of Peri, a lad she found dressed as a woman by his mother, to avoid being taken as a warrior.
The story weaves back and forward, like a tale told at a campfire, with plots and sub plots brimming over, wrapping up the Arthurian legends in a way not told before. It is engrossing, entrancing and credible. The perspective given by Reeve is unlike any other, but like others is based on a great deal of research, many of the stories he tells being found in old manuscripts. His character of Gwyna/Gwyn is fictional, but then what is the story of Arthur, but a wonderful old tale.
Fran Knight,

The last thing that I remember by Andrew Klavan

cover image

Headline Publishing, 2009. ISBN 9780755352999. Homelander series.
Recommended. A gripping and fascinating beginning to what becomes a very exciting and nightmarish journey for Charlie West. Well written, fast moving and strongly of the genre of good versus bad, the plot is quite mysterious to begin with, but the reader is blown along with the intricacies of the plot. In his amazingly physically terrifying state, Charlie recalls what his life was before he is captured. The people he meets and the encounters he faces auger well for a very exciting sequel. How exciting to read a modern adventure book, with all the usual personalities, both helpful and unfriendly who are very involved in the adventure. Boys will love this series. As with some books there is a page of pull out stickers.
Sue Nosworthy

Beyond the Knock Knock door by Scott Monk

cover image

Random House, 2009. ISBN 9781741664072.
(Primary) This is a modern fantasy, fast moving with an amazing list of characters and fearsome animals. The Bowman triplets are plagued by the terrifying Thornleigh sisters. Michael gives a homeless man his fare and the intrigue begins. The triplets answer a riddle in a door and find themselves embroiled in a world of exotic people who challenge them in their beliefs and judgement. It's action packed and races from one hair raising situation to the next with hardly a breath in between. The text is well spaced and clear, an encouragement to boys to read. Modern dialogue will appeal to readers.
Sue Nosworthy

Lucky by Rachel Vail

cover image

Harper Collins (Harper Teen. 2009. ISBN 9780060890452.
(Age 13+) An American teen novel sadly popular with pre teens as well. It's very hard to be enthusiastic about such hum drum writing, especially when shrouded with rich girl syndrome, beautiful people controlling the year group and constant references to money! Phoebe and her four friends are excitedly preparing for their middle school graduation with the 'hottest party' ever. Spoilt, over indulged girls who think of little other than who will be invited and what they will wear is painful to read, (but I'm not 14!).
Phoebe's crisis comes when her mother loses her job. Dad is a teacher and the family can't afford the beautiful green dress on the cover (and only from Neiman Marcus!) or the cost of the dance. In her speech as year captain, Phoebe tries to redress her friendship with her friends and this is a highlight of the book.
No doubt teenagers will read it as Rachel Vail has written many in this genre.
Sue Nosworthy

Without looking back by Tabitha Suzuma

cover image

Corgi Books, 2009.
(
Ages 10 +) Highly recommended. We've all heard harrowing stories of children abducted by one parent, leaving the other in fear and anguish. Tabitha Suzuma weaves a powerful story around three children trapped in just such a traumatic situation. For Max, Louis and Millie, life in Paris with their high flying French mother is difficult enough without their parents fighting for custody in a vindictive divorce battle. The children know that their Irish Father is at risk of losing them due to his fragile mental state, so a final weekend with him before the start of the new school year is especially important to all three.
However, what begins as a weekend in Paris turns into an unexpected flight to England. A promised week of extra holiday as a special treat stretches into two, and finally the children are confronted with the truth; their father has kidnapped them.
The story is told through the eyes of twelve year old Louis, the middle child and a talented street dancer. Gradually all three children adjust to their new lives in the Lake District and Louis's friendship with fellow dancer Tess, seals their fragile sense of security. However, Louis and Tess's winning entry in a dance competition is reported in the newspaper, and terrified of discovery, their father forces them to flee again.
Suzuma maintains a cracking narrative with a strong vein of realism and plenty of excitement and tension. She confronts difficult questions in a way that young readers can relate to, but which never avoids the reality: however the situation resolves, someone will lose out. The unexpected ending shows just how messy such situations can be and left me longing to find out more. Perhaps there is room for a sequel? Tabitha Suzuma is already an established and impressive writer for teenagers and here she turns her talents to a younger readership. The strong plot, coupled with Louis's passion for dancing keep the story fresh and up to date and able and mature readers of 10+ are in for a treat.
Claire Larson

Little bird by Penni Russon.

cover image

Girlfriend fiction). Allen and Unwin, 2009.ISBN 978 1 74175 864 164p
(Age 11-14) Recommended. A twitty adolescent novel, appealing to the teenager who is unsure of herself, but through a series of family incidents gains confidence finds friends and accepts who she is. It's a family novel, centring around Shandra who is organising her perfect wedding and everyone around, including her younger sister Ruby-Lee who tells the story. To complicate matters, Shandra's best friend Collette is also to be a bridesmaid and will make the dresses. She has a baby Maisy born to Spence a teacher at Ruby-Lee's school. Ruby Lee is fascinated with Spence and the situation becomes awkward when Ruby Lee baby sits Maisy. She falls out with her best school friend and life becomes very difficult. But, Ruby-Lee learns about pain, love and respect. She has grown up a lot.
Sue Nosworthy

Labour day by Joyce Maynard

cover image

Harper Collins, 2009. ISBN 9780061920783.
(Age 15+) Recommended. An intriguing novel, written from a thirteen year old's point of view. Henry and his Mother Adele live an unusual and increasingly lonely and dysfunctional life. Into their lives comes Frank, a man with a black past. On a rare visit to a department store Frank attaches himself to the pair. For the next five days over the Labour Day weekend the reader learns of Adele's past, Henry's inner anguish about adolescence; girls, sex and making love and Frank. Henry desperately wants a change over the hot August holidays and that he gets. It's a change within himself as we see him share his innermost thoughts and those he observes from his Mother and Frank with the reader.
It's a psychologically interesting novel highlighting the vulnerability and frailty of the human condition.
Sue Nosworthy

First the egg by Laura Vaccaro Seeger

cover image

Frances Lincoln Children's Books, 2009. ISBN 9781845079697.
(0+) Highly recommended. A 2008 Caldecott Honor Book and rightly so, this is a beautiful and fascinating picture book that looks at how things evolve. First comes a white cut-out of an egg and on page turn, the reader sees the egg change into a chicken. Then there is a tiny green cut-out of a tadpole which turns into a frog.Other wonders of nature follow, including a seed growing into a flower and a caterpillar turning into a butterfly. Then in an interesting twist, a word turns into the story that has been read so far.
The illustrations are lush and colourful. Bold, bright brushstrokes show the beauty of the transformations. The simple text will lend itself to being read aloud to the very young and beginning readers would have a delightful book to practise simple words.
Certain to become a classic, this is one book that is sure to be cherished by its readers.
Pat Pledger

Servants depots in colonial South Australia by Marie Steiner

cover image

Wakefield Press,2009. ISBN 9781862548053.
(Ages: Senior secondary). A sliver of history in the broad sweep of South Australia's 180 or so years, is taken up in this slim book, to show us how women were treated in early SA, and what part the government played in their protection. In 1855, shiploads of single women were in assisted passage to SA, to find employment and husbands. Surprisingly to me, many were Irish. When these women arrived, a depressed harvest in SA meant that there were few jobs available and so the government stepped in and provided depots in Adelaide initially and then Victor Harbor, Clare, Gawler, Robe, Kapunda, Mt Barker and Willunga. These places boarded the women with a matron, and helped them find employment. Steiner goes through the running, maintenance and success of depots, devoting a chapter to each.
One particular ship, the Nashwauk, which foundered at Moana Rocks in 1855, and held 163 Irish girls is given close attention. We are told about the women, and what happened to each in turn as they found employment and/or husbands, or travelled on to Melbourne, hoping for better prospects.
It seems that the government at the time felt that some care should be taken with these girls, lest they fall into bad company and prostitution, so set up these depots where people wanting employees could come and talk to the girls. The strict 'boarding house' regime reflected the life in the ships they came in, and so I imagine many were very happy to get work. But some came back within a few weeks, either the pay was poor, or not as much as promised, or the work far too hard, or they found they were in a place with no other woman. Many reasons for returning are explained, and it is interesting to see the lengths the board (Female Immigration Board) went in checking their stories, and in the case of several of the matrons, retrieving moneys owed to the girls by employers who dismissed them. A fascinating look at a small part of our history, this book would be particularly useful to students of women's studies or the history of South Australia.
Fran Knight

The dragon tattoo by Tim Pigott-Smith

cover image

Hodder Children's Books,2008.
(Ages 8-12) The renowned actor Tim Pigott-Smith has turned his hand to writing and created an enjoyable Holmes-esque yarn surrounding the kidnap of a young girl whose father is mixed up with a sinister Chinese gang called the Dragons. The Irregulars are a band of youngsters who assist Sherlock Holmes in solving crimes and mysteries. The Dragon Tattoo tells the story of how they first come together in their efforts to find Holmes (who has disappeared in mysterious circumstances) and rescue Ann-Li from her dastardly kidnappers. Among the motley crew of Irregulars are Holmes' page boy Billy Chizzell, Sam almost as intuitive and devious as Holmes himself and Titch who has to disguise herself as a boy to survive on the streets of Victorian London.
A fun story, competently written and with sufficient excitement, plot twists and the occasional touch of pathos to satisfy most young readers. The references to Sherlock Holmes and Watson elevate the story from a routine adventure and with luck will entice youngsters to try Conan-Doyle himself. Chris Mould's atmospheric illustrations and Pigott-Smith's cinematic action sequences add to the suspense. It's all rounded off nicely with a sample of the Irregulars next adventure at the end of the book. Look out for The Rose of Africa published this autumn which is sure to please young readers eager for a series.
Claire Larson

The whisperer by Fiona McIntosh

cover image

HarperCollins, 2009. ISBN 9780732286675
(Age 9-12) Griff is a boy with an amazing ability - he can hear people's thoughts. He works in a circus as a grunt, putting up the circus tent and doing odd jobs. One day he carelessly lets the greedy circus owner find out about his magical skill and finds himself as an act reading people's minds. Unhappy, he joins forces with Tess, who has a group of mythical animals, and together they flee from the circus, and go on a quest to find the Whisperer, the young prince, Lute, who speaks in Griff's mind and whose wicked uncle Janko is trying to take over the kingdom.
The story is told in alternate chapters which flow along easily, giving the reader a good understanding of what is happening to Griff and to Lute. There are many elements here that make for a good fantasy - the good prince versus his evil uncle who is after the throne, courageous children with the ability to talk to animals and to read thoughts, and fabulous mythical beasts.
The plot is action driven and with enough adventure to please the young reader. Griff, Lute and Tess are courageous and loyal, and the adults in the novel are well developed characters, from the weak, kindly king to the brave Pilo who guards the young prince. The antics and dialogue of the dwarf Bitter Olaf and the pirate queen, Calico Grace, provide many laughs.
McIntosh has written an engrossing novel that primary children should enjoy.
Pat Pledger

What does your daddy do? by Gordon Reece and Vilma Cencic

cover image

Lothian Children's Books, 2009. ISBN 9780734411129.
(Age 5-7) Tina goes crying to her room because her teacher asks everyone what their fathers do, and her father doesn't have an important job. Ranjit's father is an actor on TV, Peter's father is a rock star and Julie's is a famous judge, but Tina's sweeps the streets. Mum explains that the most important job in the world for a father is to love his child and Tina's Dad is expert at that. He reads her stories at bedtime, listens to her tall tales and looks after her.
Vilma Cencic's illustrations are a delight. She has chosen animals for the characters in the story and each fits the type of occupation that the fathers have. Tina and her parents are cute koalas, the rock star father is an echnida with spines reminiscent of spiky hair, and the general in the army is a wicked looking crocodile with sharp teeth. Lots of humorous detail will keep young children giggling as they listen to or read the story.
This has a reassuring message for young children. After reading this book, they can go away knowing that no matter what their father's occupation is, love is the most important thing of all. It's better to have a loving, caring parent than a father with the most important job in the world.
Pat Pledger

The bone tiki by David Hair

cover image

HarperCollins, 2009.
ISBN 9781869507343.
(Age 11+) Recommended. Very reminiscent of The Dark is Rising by Susan Cooper, this powerful novel stretches the reader's imagination in a fascinating way. For readers not familiar with the Maori stories there is an added layer, a little like the Australian dreamtime stories. To share the parallel words in New Zealand, then and now, makes for a fast moving, many times bloody and gruesome journey for Mat. He made his parents a pendant, the Maori half for his father and the Celtic knot for his mother. Mat lives with his lawyer father, his mother now lives in Taupo. Through a convoluted series of incidents, Mat has the man shaped tiki which Puarata wants for his evil dominance. Mat Wiri, Kelly and a dog (who has other forms) called Fitzy embark on a quest to free Wiri from the hated Puarata. The creatures, people and towns from an earlier time give the reader a realistic feeling for another time, through Mat's eyes.  It's an exciting time travel, with well rounded characters, both good and evil.
Sue Nosworthy.