Reviews

The last alchemist by Colin Thompson

cover image

Random House, 1999 (Reprinted 2010). ISBN: 9781741664171.
(Ages 5 to 95) Highly recommended. With the new Millennium fast approaching, the King has ordered Spinifex, his nineteenth alchemist, to find the secret to producing gold. Although Arthur, the alchemist's assistant, endeavours to watch and assist with the project he perceives values in life differently to the King and the alchemist. When sent into the countryside to collect gold, he returns with sunshine, canaries, marigolds and egg yolks, causing the alchemist to become angry. Spinifex takes his turn at going to collect gold but achieves very little. By the time the Millennium arrives, the alchemist has gone mad through his efforts and disaster strikes.
Colin Thompson's zany, intensely colourful, meticulously detailed illustrations provide a perfect backdrop to this cleverly written tale. The reader can either consider just the somewhat ordinary text without glancing at the pictures or alternatively ponder for hours over the intricate details included therein. A bilby like creature is hidden on many pages, along with multiple references to 'Max' the dog. Escher like staircases cause one to lose one's sense of perspective and clever references to gold are used as book titles, for example Gold Comfort Farm and How Gold was my Valley. Thompson's books are suited not only to junior primary students but to multiple age groups. A wonderful title for any class discussing values and endeavouring to discover what is most important in life!
Jo Schenkel, Pilgrim School

When you reach me by Rebecca Stead

cover image

Text, 2009. ISBN 9781921656064.
(Age 10+) Highly recommended. Winner of the prestigious Newbery Medal, When you reach me is a complex, challenging and ultimately very rewarding book. Set in the 1970's, it tells the story of Miranda, as she weaves her way through complications at school, having to walk past a crazy man on her way home and losing her best friend Sal, who after being hit by another boy, withdraws from her. Miranda writes to some unknown person, who has asked her to write down the events that have occurred. She tells of how her apartment key disappears and how anonymous notes appear telling her to do strange things.
Set in New York City, the book gives an intimate look into urban life. The reader gets to know Miranda's apartment, her school and the deli where she has a lunch time job with some friends. Characters in the book are finely drawn. Her mother is determined to win the $20,000 Pyramid game show and I became engrossed in the preparation and practice that Miranda and her mother's boyfriend, Richard, give her mother. She makes new friends and is appalled when she discovers that one of them, Marcus, fascinated by the idea of time travel, is the boy who hit Sal.
Miranda is obsessed with the book, A wrinkle in time by Madeline L'Engle and themes like time travel, friendship and  mystery thread through the book. It is a complicated puzzle: why is she receiving these notes, who has written them, and what is going to happen? Astute readers will ponder the clues on the way, others like me will rush ahead to see what happens. All in all a very satisfying book.
Pat Pledger

Iggy and me by Jenny Valentine

cover image

HarperCollins, 2009. ISBN 9780007283620.
(Ages: 6-10) Award winning author of The Ant Colony and Finding Violet Park, Jenny Valentine has created a couple of very funny characters in Iggy and her older, long suffering sister, Flo. The scrapes they get into will have instant appeal to middle primary students, who will instantly recognize all the sorts of things they get up to at home. Iggy's world is totally self centred, as she marches through the day, expecting everyone to fall in line with what she wants to do. From cutting her own hair with disastrous results, finding out what a mirage is, to demanding that everyone call her Iggy instead of her real name, both girls in this book will endear themselves to the reader. 
Fran Knight

How to heal a broken wing by Bob Graham

cover image

Walker Books, 2008. ISBN 9781406325492
(Ages Junior Primary) Highly Recommended. This award winning picture book is one that warms the heart and soul of all readers, and the story it portrays will cause many to simply go 'ahhh' at its completion. As with many of Bob Graham's picture books, the premise is seemingly simple. A small boy finds a wounded bird on the street near the underground. No one else has seen it or if they have, they have hurried past, or moved around it and not bothered. The boy retrieves the bird, takes it home and cares for it. With time and care, the bird recovers from its injury until the family takes the bird back to where they found it and release it. The background story of a loving, caring family permeates the story, as the pictures show the family creating a place for it in their home, bringing home a bird cage for it, watching it take its first steps and then flying around their sitting room. The whole is redolent of looking after what is in your own backyard, of taking time to see what it in front of you, of being prepared to put yourself out for someone or something else, of reaching out to help. The implicit storyline portrays a selfless individual caring about his environment. But more than this, the whole is based firmly, as are all of Bob Graham's books, in the family. The heart of his tales show a loving, caring family. The children are never alone, they have parents there to help and guide them, to back them up. A beautiful picture book, I love the way Graham shows the family, the parents concerned not only for the bird but their child, the looks on their faces showing their apprehension about their baby. The yellow glow on several pages spotlights the family in the midst of the moving, uncaring crowd, intent on their own purpose of rescuing the bird. Children reading the book will love looking at the crowd of people, the plethora of animal images in the family's home, the sights of London and finally a bird's eye view of the city.
Fran Knight

One smart fish by Chris Wormell

cover image

Jonathan Cape, 2010. (Ages 3-6) In spite of an entertaining story and vibrant illustrations I felt short changed by this book. Wormell's smart fish can sing, dance, paint and perform, wowing all his friends. However when this fish visits the 'landside' for his holiday he gazes up the beach and longs to explore. Everyone knows fish can't walk, so Smart Fish makes himself some feet and walks up the beach. He is the first fish, indeed creature to walk on the land and although he returns to his friends in the ocean, change has begun. Wormell concludes his story by describing how millions of years later other fish began crawling on their fins and in another few hundred million years they grew feet instead, until eventually people emerged. This brief text is accompanied by a fabulous double page illustration of reptiles, dinosaurs, mammals and humans. On one level this is an entertaining fantasy, but on the other Wormell is introducing the concept of evolution. Modification of species, dominant genes, natural selection and the work of Darwin and Mendel are obviously inappropriate in a story for young children. However, somewhere, perhaps as an epilogue, I would have appreciated a mention of Darwin, and even the word 'evolution' to show children that this is not just a fantasy but the story of our very existence. I think Wormell (or perhaps his publisher) misses a trick here, offering a beautifully illustrated story that could have gone one step further to begin to explain to young children the concept of evolution. Claire Larson

Wintergirls by Laurie Halse Anderson

cover image

Text, 2009. ISBN 9781921656149.
(Ages 14+)Recommended. Chosen by the American Library Association as one of their 2010 Best books for young adults, Wintergirls is an unflinching and very frightening look at eating disorders. Lia is haunted by the death from bulimia of her best friend Cassie who had sent her 33 messages before she died. She is consumed with guilt because she didn't answer the phone and relives some of the moments that she has shared with Cassie as well as the struggle that she has with anorexia nervosa.
Anderson has written about a difficult subject in a confronting and honest way. She describes Lia's descent into the depths of her disorder, her lies and her feelings about her parents, stepmother and stepsister . Everyone who has ever dieted will be familiar with the counting of calories : a muffin (410), an orange (75); and the hard grind of a treadmill to wear off even more calories. Lia takes dieting to a new high, always striving to lose more weight and even cutting herself to forget the shadows that surround her. It is a frightening portrayal of an intelligent young woman who has been unable to cope since the death of her grandmother and her parents' divorce.
Lia is offered all sorts of help: she is hospitalised; she visits a psychiatrist; her mother is prepared to sell her stocks and her father to get a second mortgage to pay for her medical expenses. However, Cassie's ghost seems to sit on her shoulder, encouraging her to lose weight. It is not until she reaches the depths that she confronts the idea of staying alive.
This is a compulsive, honest and disturbing book.
Pat Pledger

Zac Power: Extreme mission 1: Sand storm by H.I. Larry

cover image

Hardie Grant Egmont, 2009. ISBN 9781921564055.
(Ages 6-10) For children who enjoyed the Zac Power books there is a new series which has four titles, Sand storm, Dark Tower, Ice patrol and Water blaster. The first in the series, Sand storm, is an adventure filled story, with Zac Power being dragged off by his grandfather in the middle of the night on the hunt for a fabulous gadget called IRIS. Zac is thrilled to go on the mission, but he knows that his grandfather hasn't been entirely honest with him about the origins of IRIS, which has been broken up into four parts. Why has that happened? Will he be able to survive the desert and the tricks of Blackwood and Caz, who are also after IRIS?
Newly independent readers, especially boys, will be thrilled with this series. It has plenty of action to keep a young reader going, the gadgets are fascinating and Zac is an engaging hero.
Pat Pledger

The Eagle of the Ninth by Rosemary Sutcliff

cover image

Puffin, 2004 (50th anniversary edition. ISBN 9780140308907.
Highly recommended. With the release of the film of this book in September 2010, there will be enough hype for kids to want to reread this classic tale. New editions have been released; in the last ten years, along with the 50th anniversary edition in 2004, and I expect another will be released as the film opens. Already some citizens of the USA are seeing the film as criticism of their exploits in Iraq and Afghanistan, and the publicity is being stepped up. So I retrieved my husband's year 8 copy from the back of the bookcase and began to read. And I was overwhelmed with glee as I reread one of my favourite authors from my teens, Rosemary Sutcliff. Her work is undergoing a revival and no wonder, her novels are exciting, involving, with characters that are believable, and issues that remain with us to this day.
The Eagle of the Ninth is the story of a young centurion, Marcus Aquila, proudly leading his cohort. It is his first tour of Britain, and his first command, and he is very aware of the might of the Roman army and all it does in bringing civilized society to the savages. He suffers a major injury in an heroic battle against the Painted People, having then to find another occupation. While recuperating at his uncle's house, he attends a gladiatorial fight and seeing something defiant and brave in the young Briton pitched against the gladiator with a net and trident, asks to buy him as his personal slave.
But Marcus cannot forget that his father was the First Cohort of the Ninth, the famed legion that was lost and never heard of again, losing their eagle, the pride of the corps. So he takes on the role of an oculist, and he and Esca, head north, the place of the painted savages, to search for the lost 4,000 and their eagle. Adventures come thick and fast as they roams the villages and settlements of the north, curing them of eye disease and gathering information. They finally meet a soldier of the Ninth, who escaped the carnage and settled with a northern village, he is able to tell Marcus what happened to the legion and more importantly, his father. Along the way, Marcus learns more about the people he has been sent to conquer and about himself and where his future lies.
Fran Knight

Half-minute horrors ed. by Susan Rich

cover image

HarperCollins, 2009.
(Ages 10+) Recommended. Subtitled Very small stories, very big scares, this is a collection of terrifying short stories that can be read silently or out loud in half a minute. It is a quality collection of dozens of chilling stories written by outstanding international authors like Neil Gaiman, Lemony Snicket, Jerry Spinelli, Kenneth Opel, James Patterson, Jenny Nimmo, Margaret Atwood, Melissa Marr and Libba Bray.
Ideal for teachers to use on school camps or as a fun end of the day activity, this collection could also be used as a starter for encouraging creative writing of a horror story. The stories will also have immediate appeal to reluctant readers as most take up only a page or two. There are also illustrated stories that are equally haunting and quite challenging.
Pat Pledger

Charlie Bone and the Red Knight by Jenny Nimmo

cover image

Random House, 2009. ISBN 9781741664386.
(Ages 8 and up) Recommended. In this eighth and final book of the Charlie Bone series, we find Charlie still missing his parents, the Pets' Cafe closed, and Billy trapped in Badlock. To make matters worse, it seems that the Bloors are becoming more of a threat, as they recruit stronger and more dangerous allies in their race to find the box which holds the secret to the Bloors' power. Charlie's parents are in danger, and he no longer knows who he can trust. Then a mysterious Red Knight appears, and Charlie must discover if he is really there to help him. With a huge cast of characters, readers may find themselves needing to refer back to the family tree at the start of the book, but all the characters are intriguing and have their own role to play. A very satisfying end to the series.
Donella Reed

Scream Street: Skull of the Skeleton by Tommy Donbavand

cover image

Walker Books, 2009. ISBN 9781406314281.
(Ages 8 and up) Recommended. The fifth book in the Scream Street series finds werewolf Luke Watson searching for another of the relics which will help his family escape back to their old lives. It's Halloween, and the arrival of a new celebrity resident is causing a stir. Eddie aka the Headless Horseman, makes a grand entrance, causing mummies and skeletons alike to swoon. That is, until his head disappears. Meanwhile Luke, Cleo and Resus must fight a demon created by Sir Otto before his parents, and indeed the whole of Scream Street are destroyed.
This book, while part of a series, is also successful as a stand-alone read, as the characters are reintroduced and motives explained clearly. With witty writing, an abundance of bad taste, and a fast-moving plot, this is sure to entertain.
Donella Reed

The Watchmaker who saved Christmas by Bruce Whatley

cover image

Random House, 2006 (reprinted 2009)ISBN: 9781864719567.
Ages 5 and up. Highly recommended. Three days before Christmas, the Watchmaker, an old style craftsman, is visited by a bearded gentleman with silvery-white hair and beard. On the back of the watch he leaves to be repaired are the initials S.C. Instead of the usual internal workings, the Watchmaker finds a myriad of unusual and delicate parts which he sets about straightening and cleaning. When he is unable to find a suitable piece to replace a broken wheel, his young friend Peter supplies him with a part from his hearing aid. This enables the Watchmaker to complete his repair in readiness for the elderly gentleman's return. The Old Man's arrival and the retrieval of his special time piece lead to the journey of a lifetime for the craftsman.
Whatley has the happy knack of combining his simply written texts with detailed, realistic and appealing illustrations. His depiction of the shop and the old clocks brings back memories of a bygone era. This story of friendship, persistence, kindness and generosity is told without appearing to be sickly sweet. Peter, despite his hearing impairment, is happy and positive, willing to help the cause by giving and sharing and expecting nothing in return. A delightful story, this could be enjoyed by children and adults alike.
Jo Schenkel, Pilgrim School

Poles apart: Life at the ends of the Earth by Dr Mark Norman

cover image

black dog books, 2010. ISBN 9781742031354.
(Ages: Primary) Highly recommended. What a wonderful, idea! And beautifully executed. One of my pet ggrrrs is that people mix up the animals, habitat and bird life of each of our polar regions, and here is a book which sets out plainly and seemingly simply, exactly what lives where.With succinct and precise words, Dr Mark Norman elucidates what each polar region is like. The North Pole is ice on sea, with the sea floor four kilometres below, whereas the Antarctica is land with three kilometres of solid ice above it. On the next page we are told what sort of flora exists in each region, then to the animals, the pages that will interest most kids.
Each double page spread has the North Pole information and pictures at the top, with the South Pole information and pictures at the bottom. Between each is small globe reiterating where the Polar Regions lie in relation to each other. No one reading this book will have any excuse to mix up the two! A clever device which works well is the simple turning of the book around to fit all this information together.
I was amazed at the differences between the two regions, the tundra of the north and the moss of the south, the flowers and insects in the north and the 'walks' in the south! Each double page spread held me captivated, learning new information and recalling things learnt years ago but long forgotten. The last double page tells the reader of the affects of global warming, and exhorts them to play their part in helping reduce the impact by planting trees, recycling and so on. A number of web sites is given for more information, and the book is wells served with a succinct glossary and useful index.
This like Dr Mark Norman's other books (The octopuses' garden: The Secret World under the Sea; The Penguin Book: Birds in suits; The Antarctica Book: Living in the freezer; The Shark Book: Fish with attitude and The Great Barrier Reef Book: Solar Powered) will attract attention from those who give out awards, and more importantly from its target audience, the kids. Dr Norman is senior curator at Museum Victoria.
Fran Knight

I'm Taggarty Toad by Peter Pavey

cover image

Walker Books, 2010. ISBN 9781921529481.
Picture book, ages 3-6. One of my children's favourite stories, when first published in 1980, this one will be revisited with mirth and gusto by another generation of families and classes. The drawings have lost none of their freshness, the intricate cross hatching testament to the time it took Peter Pavey to do the illustrations, and probably why he didn't stay in that profession! The clever and bold Taggarty has an array of adventures, taking on fearful pirates, loathsome dragons and even the sun in his quest to show that he is braver than most. Children will delight in the intricate drawings, running their fingers over each page in search of the variety of animals and objects almost hidden from view. The last few pages invite the reader to add their own swashbuckling adventure, and come home at last with the little worse for wear toad. Themes of taking risks and being adventurous are at the base of this picture book and so could be used with some success with smaller children.
The last two pages of the book give an interesting essay from editor, Myra Lee, outlining the reason this book was chosen to republish and then an enlightening piece by Peter Pavey about writing and illustrating this book. Both add an extra layer to the reading and enjoyment of this book.
Fran Knight

The Phoenix Files: Contact by Chris Morphew

cover image

Book 2, Hardie, Grant Egmont, 2010. ISBN 9781921502408
(Age 11+) Those who have read the first in this series, Arrival, know the trio of teenager Luke Hunter and his friends Jordan and Peter are the only that can stop the destruction of the human race. There are only 100 days until all civilization beyond the remote Australian town of Phoenix is destroyed by something called Tabitha.
Contact takes up the story where Arrival left off, with 88 days to go at the beginning and 70 at the end. The trio's fearless investigation and a few lucky coincidences enable them to learn what Tabitha is and where the secret operational centre of the sinister Shackleton Corporation is.
Tension arises between the two boys over who will win the brave Jordan's affections. Parents behave strangely and the school principal is revealed as a malevolent character. The sleuthing leads to a nail biting climax where the heros narrowly escape death in order to appear, one presumes, in the next four books in the series. They succeed and survive, of course, despite incredible odds against them.
As in Arrival, Contact is written in an easy to read, mostly dialogue style with the teenagers being smart and funny. The evil Shackleton emerges as a traditional ruthless comic book, sci fi baddie bent on world power for an as yet undefined reason. Whilst there are tense moments and grisly events in this page turner some may find the pace too slow as the teenagers figure what to do next.
However, once hooked, both genders of middle school age will no doubt eagerly await book 3.
Kevyna Gardner