Reviews

Mission Telemark by Amanda Mitchison

cover image

Walker Books, 2010. ISBN 978 1406311044.
Four teenagers from diverse backgrounds and trained as special operations agents are given the task of entering Nazi occupied Norway and destroying heavy water stores to prevent the Nazis making atomic bombs. Ase, Frederick, Jakob and Lars all have unique skills to contribute to the mission. Ase has explosives training, is a gymnast and speaks four languages. Frederick has a photographic memory, is bilingual in two languages and can read a number of others. Jakob is an all round athlete and born leader and Lars is a good outdoorsman and skilled navigator however has recently been interrogated by the Gestapo and is particularly withdrawn.
The four meet at a facility in the wilds of Scotland where they spend time preparing for their mission and getting to know one another and the skills they bring. Colonel Armstrong subjects them to various situations simulating what they might encounter during their journey and develops strength within the group to withstand extreme conditions and circumstances. When the mission begins this training proves invaluable to the situations they face and the execution of the mission is both dangerous and extreme with the group becoming separated in the final stages. This story has elements of espionage, intrigue, sabotage and personal sacrifice. The book is written in log form with entries by Ase and Jakob (whose entries are accompanied by sketches) which makes for an exciting and compelling read.
Tracy Glover

Chess nuts by Julia Lawrinson

cover image

Puffin, 2010. ISBN 978 0145304708.
Jackson a sports nut is aiming to win the swimming championships and so get the prized trophy naming him Athlete of the Year, before he leaves primary school. But he is interested in chess and plays at home, so the chess club appeals to him. But these people are seen as geeks and losers by his friends and certainly the other sporty members of the school, and particularly the school bully, Freak Buckley, who easily makes Jackson's life hell. Into this mix comes Anna, a girl in the chess club with whom Jackson has an odd relationship. Together they decide to help each other so that their team can win the school chess championships, and surprisingly, another member of the school offers to help.
Not just a story for chess buffs, this is a smoothly flowing story about kids at school, finding their own talents and abilities, helping each other achieves their goals and striving to do their best. Sport encompasses chess, so Lawrinson is not only engaging students with her story but flying a banner for this neglected team sport. Her chess nut family gave her the background for the story and I was intrigued with the chess boards laid out in spots through the story allowing readers to try out games for themselves. An absorbing read for middle school.
Fran Knight

The star by Felicity Marshall

cover image

Ford St Publishing, 2010. ISBN 978 1876462 92 5.
Picture book. Recommended. When the dancing and singing wooden doll, Marion, is seduced by stardom, her loyal friends go along, supporting her in her endeavours and striving to keep her feet on the ground as the man with the hat  keeps asking more and more changes from her. Eventually she has a reshaped nose, a chauffeur, bodyguards, someone to reply to the room full of fan mail and no real friends.
But when one day the Man asks her to change again, she falters, turning again to her friends for their help and support, but cannot find them. She has left them along the way and so must search the darker reaches of the city, a far cry from the life she is now living, to gain their help. She finds them in poor circumstances, but instead of questioning what she has done, readily come to her aid, but the whole sequence of events is repeated, and Marion is tossed aside. She joins her friends, a sadder but much wiser person.
A homily for our times when stardom and celebrity status is what many strive for, bolstered by our society's adulation of stars, this book will initiate much discussion among middle school readers, who will be able to readily identify many people that this has happened to. Fame without substance could be applied to many often seen in our newspapers or on television, and an astute teacher will be able to encourage student discussion along that path.
The story is well told and supported by superb illustrations, which highlight incredibly well the disparity between the life of those who have achieved fleeting fame and those without. I loved particularly the illustrations of Marion's face on the advertising hoardings, bright and glossy at the start, contrasting with the picture on the back cover of the tattered and torn poster of her face. The whole page illustration of Marion searching for her friends too, appealed (amongst many) with its contrast between the bright lights of the city and the destitute situation of her friends.
Fran Knight

Koala: The real story by Dr Mark Norman

cover image

black dog books, 2010. ISBN 978 1742031309.
(Age: Junior primary: Non fiction text). Recommended. From the enticing picture on the front cover, to the bandaged animal on the last page, the information Dr Mark Norman expounds in this book is stimulating and refreshing. Each double page is full of life, with photos of mainly sleeping koalas taken from all angles, alongside concise pieces of information. The facts, told in a chatty style, are most accessible to a younger audience: new words are given in bold print, their pronunciation following in parentheses: at the bottom of some of the pages is a smaller fact box comparing a child's life to that of the koala, adding a bit of fun to the non fiction text. Most of the photos are of koalas sleeping, because, after all, that is what they do most of the day, and it is fascinating to actually read about why they sleep so much.
Double page spreads are about particular topics, and these range from Awkward acrobats, Amazing birth, Bringing up baby to Koalas and climate change. The whole is served well with a succinct glossary, giving the reader meanings for some of the new words found in the text, and an index, teaching younger readers where to go when requiring information in the text. I was disappointed with the map showing where koalas live, as the text mentions Kangaroo Island and South Australia, but does not show it on the map, but an astute teacher will have a large map of Australia in the classroom to rectify this omission.
A delightful and charming expose of the inactive lives of the koala, the icon of Australian animals, told in a chatty and inviting style, brimming with accurate and up to the minute information, this book will be a hit with primary aged children. Dr Mark Norman is senior curator at Museum Victoria and well known for his books on life in the sea (The octopuses' garden: The Secret World under the Sea, The Penguin Book: Birds in suits, The Antarctica Book: Living in the freezer, The Shark Book: Fish with attitude and The Great Barrier Reef Book: Solar Powered) which have won accolades from the Children's Book Council of Australia and the Wilderness Society.
Fran Knight

The Number One Aussie Alphabet Book by Heath McKenzie

cover image

Black dog books, 2010. ISBN 9781742031477.
(Ages 3-5) Recommended. This alphabet book is both an early introduction to the letters of the alphabet and a fun way of learning about Australian animals. Ant (Aa is for ant) invites the reader to come along and meet more letters and animals. On turning the page the reader finds a letter, a verse and a zany illustration for the Australian animal.
A large capital letter and a lower case letter in vibrant colour will make it easy for little fingers to trace over and make the sounds. The accompanying picture is a comic representation of an Australian animal or bird. Not only are there the favourite Aussie animals like kangaroo and koala but less well known birds and animals feature like the long legged ibis, a 'black, and white and blue' jabiru and a shy numbat. The humorous illustrations should help the young reader to remember the letters while the rhyming text is both fun and good to read aloud.
At the back of the book the author, (H is for Heath McKenzie), has a page talking about the alphabet and the animals that are his favourites to draw.
Young children will have fun with this book, looking at the letters and laughing at the whimsical drawings of the animals while older children will love the verse. Recommended for libraries and as a gift for young children.
Pat Pledger

Closets are for Clothes, a History of Queer Australia by Rachel Cook

cover image

Black dog books, 2010. ISBN 978 1742031040.
Published in black dog book's The Drum series, this title adds significantly to the literature available at secondary level outlining the history of homosexuality in Australia. Beginning with the First Fleet, an overview of each historical period is given, showing the activity within that time frame. Each chapter relates its history and then adds to the bare facts with letters, epistles and stories of individual people. Many of these are real people, but some are fictionalised first person accounts, giving a sound authenticity using the facts from the times. So in the first chapter, A New World, White Settlement of Australia, the facts are presented in a text format giving the reasons for the First Fleet and what it represented for Australia. Interspersed are stories of individuals, such as Rebecca Cooper, Arthur Palls, Robert Pringle Stuart (a magistrate) and Lt Charles Bowen. Each story relates a differing point of view.
Little is known about the nineteenth century, so much of the text is devoted to the late twentieth century when attitudes were polarized. World War 2 made quite a difference to gay men and women, but it seems that once over, things went back to the way they had been. During the 50's and 60's, the medical profession came to view homosexuality as an illness, and the book outlines the 'cures' used over the world. In Australia, aversion therapy was used widely, and it is salutary to read of the attempts made using this barbaric treatment.
The 60's saw an upswing in movements for freedoms across the board, and the gay community stood up to be counted, resulting in demonstrations, arrests and threats. The onset of AIDS, Mardi Gras, the call for equality before the law, and so on are covered briefly in this book
A comprehensive index, glossary and time line, reference guide and acknowledgments accompany the book, making it an indispensible aid to studies at senior level. It makes salutary reading to realise that although things have changed, many of the attitudes remain the same and that there are still battles to be fought and won. 
Fran Knight

Boom! by Mark Haddon

cover image

David Fickling Books, 2009.
(Ages 9 +) Recommended.When Jimbo's friend Charlie is kidnapped by aliens, Jimbo enlists the help of his older sister Becky to plan a daring rescue. The two of them steal a motor bike belonging to Becky's Neanderthal boyfriend and head for the aliens' headquarters on the Isle of Skye in an effort to rescue Charlie and foil a dastardly alien plot to invade planet earth.
Haddon has a wonderfully laconic style full of understated humorous action and plenty of breezy one liners. Narrated by reluctant hero Jimbo, Boom! is filled with flamboyant characters. Dad has been made redundant and is recreating himself as Jamie Oliver. Charlie's mum is someone you definitely wouldn't want to meet on a dark night. Sixteen year old Becky, a moody, depressive Goth, can't stand her younger brother until she realises he is about to be murdered by aliens, while Charlie is full of grand schemes and wild plans. However, it is down to Jimbo's devious cunning and Becky's accuracy with a large cudgel that save both Charlie and planet earth. Although Boom! may not have the depth of The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night Time it is a light-hearted, rollicking read that shows just how versatile and original Haddon is.
In the foreword Haddon explains how Boom! was originally published in the early 90s as Gridzbi Sbudvetch! although he has almost entirely rewritten it for the modern technological age, and thankfully given it a new title too. I am always a bit suspicious of authors who rewrite earlier works once they become famous, but this has a freshness and originality that really works. Haddon is definitely making his mark. If any of your readers enjoy Morris Gleitzman try them with Boom! it should prove to be a big hit.
Claire Larson

The Enemy by Davide Cali and Serge Bloch

cover image

Wilkins Farago, 2009.
Highly recommended for all readers of 8 years and above. From the opening page, written in a huge white font on a dark background, we know 'There's a war on'. On the vast expanses of white paper, we then see what 'could be a desert' and two holes, each containing a soldier. All of this appears before the publication details and the red title page. As the soldier waits in his hole, firing a shot each day, otherwise staying hidden for fear of the enemy, lighting a fire only when hunger pains truly strike, he ponders their shared states of being alone and hungry. He reflects, also, on the information provided in his manual at the start of the war. From this he knows the enemy is 'cruel and ruthless - not a human being'. Fear and desperation lead him to finally leave the security of his hole, disguised by a branch, in order to kill the enemy. The result is that each is forced to see the other as a human being with a home, family and a different perception of what makes an enemy.
This picture book was published in association with Amnesty International Australia and deserves a place in every school library to promote the futility of war, the importance of human rights and the effects of propaganda. Likewise, it highlights such ideas as misconceptions or differences in perspective. Not only would it be a perfect resource to use in a unit on war but would fit exceptionally well as part of a study on bullying. It could be a great text when used in Restorative Justice Sessions, encouraging students to consider the viewpoints of others. The simplicity of the one-sided tale and the predominantly black and white sketches brilliantly support the story and make it accessible to all readers.
Jo Schenkel, Pilgrim School

Ripley's wild animals, believe it or not by Camilla de la Bedoyere

cover image

Scholastic, 2010.
Recommended (non fiction). A book of facts and photos of wild animals sounds a bit lame, but when it is produced under the auspices of the Ripley believe it or not team, then kids will know they have a winner to read. Full of strange facts about the largest frog in the world, or the family that has a pet buffalo in their house, or the macaques sitting in their spa with snow on their heads, or the chimps using a tool to extract ants from a nest, all the facts and photos are irresistible.
Divided into chapters with headings such as, Armed and dangerous, Mighty munchers, Meet the ugliest, Reaching the max and beast buddies, readers will need little incentive to pick up this book to read from cover to cover or dip into.
Fran Knight

Night School by Isobelle Carmody and Anne Spudvilas (illustrator)

cover image

Penguin Viking, 2010. ISBN 978 0670072071.
Picture book. A picture book which could scare the pants of its readers, Night School is definitely one for the older readers, with its atmospheric illustrations done in a variety of media, oil paint, water colour, graphite and coloured ink, and a story which gathers momentum as a group of children stay overnight in the seemingly deserted school. The instruction that each child, alone, goes into the hall then must go into each of three rooms and write their name on the list provided, is followed by the group, but they decide that as this is a war, then they must form a company and go together. They follow the light from the row of candles leading them into each room and do what they have been asked, until with a lantern they summon the boys and then find themselves face to face with the prince of midwinter night.
Hints of past wars, captured children, a lost sister, an odd caretaker abound to make the story redolent with all sorts of possibilities and yet none. The eeriness is a puff of smoke, a fog of words and illustrations, drawing the reader into its core, only to find nothing there. But it will cause an intense amount of discussion as readers use the clues to create their own stories, reasons, backgrounds and myths.
Fran Knight

Conspiracy 365: February by Gabrielle Lord

cover image

Scholastic 2009. ISBN 978 1741690347.
Callum has remained hidden for one month, knowing that he must remain alive for 12 months, surviving by his wits, as well as striving to uncover the reason his father was killed, and just who is trying to kill him and why. A book a month is being published by Scholastic, aimed squarely at the middle school reader, with added extras such as a website to log onto, with your own pin number and prizes for competitions throughout the year.
February sees Callum attempting to find out about the Ormond Riddle, and seeking more information concerning a family secret that has killed his father and puts his life in peril. Winter Frey may help him, but he must be wary lest she lead him even further into danger.  Scanning the car yard he spies a red haired woman who he thinks was the one who interrogated him. He finds out that she is the famous criminal lawyer, Oriana de la Force, and he hides out in a local drain to avoid recapture. When that drain floods he seeks refuge in the zoo, only to be clawed by a lion. Things are not looking happy for Callum and while fleeing yet another would be assassin, his foot is wedged in the train line with a train approaching.
Again, the action is fast paced with diary entries like bullets, full of speed and the probability of life threatening damage. Again, the countdown is underlined with the pagination of the book starting at 188.
Fran Knight

Nathaniel Wolfe and the Bodysnatchers by Brian Keaney

cover image

Orchard Books, 2009.
(Ages 9 +) This is an atmospheric ghost story perfect for readers who demand action rather than description. Keaney crafts a complex plot, but tells his story both simply and swiftly. There is barely time to pause for breath and plenty of cliff hanging tension to keep young readers on the edge of their seats as the plot twists and turns to its dramatic climax.
Nathaniel Wolfe is a ghost hunter in Victorian England, and this time it's the ghost of an old man that haunts him; an old man in great distress, who tries to give Nathaniel a mysterious gold ring. Nathaniel and his friends Sophie and Lily discover that the ghost longs to make peace with the daughter he rejected at birth. As a massive fortune is involved, the three children are in a race against time to locate the daughter and save her and the money from the devious and aptly named Mr Hemlock and his band of murderous bodysnathers.
Keaney immerses his readers in the Victorian era and his account of the harrowing opium dens is full of atmosphere, as is his description of Old Phossy, a shady character who suffers from Phosphorus jaw from his work in the match factories. Peoples' terror of cholera and the newfangled idea that cholera is actually a waterborne rather than airborne disease also gets a mention, although it was John Snow, not Henry Snow as Keaney suggests, who discovered this. (That kind of error, although minor, does irritate me as it smacks of slapdash research that should have been picked up at the editing stage if not before.)
Minor criticisms aside, three of the Year 5 children at my school (ages 9 and 10) devoured it and gave it top marks. This is the second Nathaniel Wolfe story, but it's not essential to read them in the correct order. I'm sure Keaney will write more and this has the potential to become a very popular series. If your readers enjoy this, they might also like Tim Pigott-Smith's Baker Street Mysteries.
Claire Larson

Hooray! There's a hippopotamus on our roof having a birthday party by Hazel Edwards

cover image

Penguin, 2010. ISBN 978 0670072637.
To celebrate the 30th anniversary of the now classic tale, There's a hippopotamus on our roof eating cake, Puffin has republished the original along with another tale by Hazel Edwards and illustrated by Deborah Niland, concerning  that same old hippo. This time the story revolves around the young boy getting ready for the birthday party. Each double page spread has the boy's preparations on the left hand side, contrasting with those preparations by the hippo on the roof for his birthday party on the right hand side page.
As mum and the boy mix the ingredients for the cake, the hippo on the roof is licking the bowl, as each of the children tries on different costumes for the party, so too, the hippo tries out different costumes, as the children play hide and seek, the hippo hides, and so on, all making delightful contrasts, one page to the other. Readers will love the hippo and the child all over again, seeking out things on each page to smile and laugh about, while reading the straightforward prose, which brings a smile to the face through its economy and what is left unsaid.
Fran Knight

When I was Joe by Keren David

cover image

Frances Lincoln Books, 2010. ISBN 978 1847801005.
Ty's life, as well as those around him; his mother and gran, changes dramatically when he witnesses a murder. He becomes Joe, begins a new life, becomes a different person but not in name only. Keren David begins a narrative that is exciting and very readable. It involves extraordinary circumstances, but in the end it is a coming of age tale with the same feelings of guilt and anxiousness of any young teenage boy but with the consequences of his actions having enormous repercussions for his friends and family.
As Joe, Ty is empowered. He has friends, girls find him attractive and mysterious, he is good at athletics and he finds a confidence in himself he never had as Ty.Always lurking in the background is the incident with the knife. It haunts him especially at night until he is unsure what is real and what is imagined. Popularity also brings its problems. Ashley the most influential girl in his school makes it known that she fancies him and won't brook no for an answer. He also becomes noticed by other boys in the school with their positions as top dogs to defend. Joe finds in the end that he's not exactly keeping a low profile.
His Mum, Nicki, doesn't cope with their changed lifestyle at first. She can't continue with her job or her study to be a lawyer. She has to leave her sisters and mother in London. She and Joe are alone in a new place with new identities. The police are their most constant source of information and for Nicki the only human contact other than Joe. She becomes depressed and introverted.
David's narrative continues and ramps up the pace when gran is attacked by the gang wanting to know the whereabouts of Ty, Joe is in increasing amounts of trouble at his new school, and his social life is going down the toilet. Just when the reader believes the package will be neatly tied up with a bow and ribbon we learn that we have to wait for the next book! This is the most disappointing aspect of the book. I would have liked it to reach its climax and any remaining mystery solved.
A good read. Hopefully David will be able to keep up the pace for another entire book.
Mark Knight

The City by Armin Greder

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2010. ISBN: 978 1742371429.
(Ages 10 and up) Highly recommended. 'The most beautiful son a mother could wish for' is born to a woman, living in a city in which grey winters seem to last for years. Having lost her husband in the war and wanting to protect her beloved child at all costs, she leaves the city and goes to an isolated place where she builds a house in which they can live. When some travelers arrive, having lost their way from the city, the boy expresses a desire to visit the city. His mother's only response is to love him even more until 'one moonless night she died'. The boy must then learn to take control of his own destiny.
Looking very much like his award winning book, The Island, this new title uses Greder's familiar style of illustration. Most of the pictures are done in charcoal and somber tones until the arrival of the strangers brings the addition of colour and vibrancy. The concept that isolation or living apart from society can give a sense of security is evident in both books. Here, however, the boy overcomes the fear and insecurities created by his overly controlling, albeit loving, mother to venture out into the world. Perhaps this is more of a cautionary tale for parents, warning them to prepare and socialise their children rather than closeting them away.
Greder's work is always thought provoking, powerful and challenging and this is no exception. Although it is not a title which children would necessarily seek out, it will be another which teachers will use with classes to illustrate such concepts as independence, confidence and coming of age.
Jo Schenkel, Pilgrim School