Reviews

Roman diary: journal of a young slave by Richard Platt

cover image

Ill. by David Parkins, Bloomsbury Books, 2011. ISBN 9781 4063 25478.
(Ages 10+) Recommended. Picture book. On their way to Egypt to see their holdings there, the Greek ship is attacked by pirates, and Iliona and her brother, Oliver are sold as slaves to the Roman market. The time is AD 107, with the Roman Empire at its height and the diary of Iliona's life in Rome reveals a huge bustling city, easily comparable with modern cities today. Sold to a family where she must look after a baby, Iliona soon learns that her owners are kinder than others she could have been sold to. Through her eyes we see the Roman city, its streets and houses, baths and market places, clothing, hairstyles, water system, and arenas. We see a triumph where the prisoners of a battle are brought in to be slaughtered, a fight to the death with lions, gladiators fighting, and a banquet. All flavours of the life of a Roman citizen are shown through the slave's eyes. When her master dies and she is unexpectedly freed, she opts to stay on with her former mistress.
As with Pirate diary, pages at the end of the book reveal other information, maps and a sound usable index.
Fran Knight

Against the odds by Marjolijn Hof

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2011. ISBN 978 1742375083.
(Ages 9+) Recommended. When her dedicated father goes missing in Africa, en route to a hospital that is in desperate need of a doctor, Kiki plays out something she has heard. The odds are that he will survive but in her child's eye she decides that other things dying will increase the odds of him staying alive. So she asks the local pet shop for a dying mouse to look after, and when it does die, she buries it with much ceremony in her garden. She cannot ask her mother about her father as she is too distraught to give her the time. When her grandmother rings every day, often more than not wanting news, her mother becomes even more fraught whenever the phone rings.
Asking the pet shop for an old dog to look after, the attendant becomes suspicious and sends her away. So she takes their pet dog, the old dog she does not like, to the freeway intending to throw it over the edge. She is interrupted in her mission by a man who talks to her about what she is doing and persuades her that this is not the way to go. Her father's rescue and return home brings her to another quandary to sort out, the loss of a limb.
A seemingly simple story, Against the odds underscores the loneliness of the child, caught up in an adult event over which she has no control, and by merit of being young, is left out of the discussions and decisions. It is a cry for a child to be involved to be told the truth about what is happening, as her understanding becomes skewed with the little knowledge that she has.
Fran Knight

The Folk keeper by Franny Billingsley

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2011, (c1999). ISBN 9781408813195.
(Age 11+) Recommended for those who love a retelling of a fairy tale, The Folk keeper has happily been reissued after the success of Chime earlier this year. Corinna Stonewall is a Folk Keeper. She sits in a cold, dark cellar feeding the Folk, drawing off their anger and keeping ordinary people safe from having their crops damaged and animals harmed. They are vicious, vengeful lot but Corinna is a determined, powerful girl who keeps them under control. One day she is summoned by Lord Merton to come to his vast holdings by the sea as Folk Keeper and unanswered questions rise to the surface. Who were her parents? Why does the sea call to her? How can she live in her own skin?
Billingsley writes fabulous, original prose with unforgettable characters and an understated romance.
Written as a diary, the reader is transported into the world of Corinna, as she struggles with who she is and her amazing powers. The idea of keeping evil, in the form of the Folk, at bay is intriguing but Corinna is undaunted. She is strong willed and determined, brave in the face of unknown danger but fair in her dealings with others. Finian, determined to build boats and not interested in estate management, is an excellent foil for Corinna, and gradually helps her to ease into a world of light.
I loved the challenging ideas, beautiful descriptions and memorable story in The Folk Keeper and know readers will experience delicious shudders at the scary moments while delighting in the plight of Corinna.
Pat Pledger

I love my baby sister by Anna Walker

cover image

Scholastic Press, 2011. ISBN 9781741698947
Ollie, like Miss Nearly 5, has a new baby sister. After all the waiting and anticipation, she is finally here. But is having a baby sister worth all the fuss? It's hard to be patient, especially when everyone keeps telling you you are going to be a big sister and then, when the big day comes, it's all about her and not a lot about you. And where's this playmate you were promised? 'She always sleeps and her ears are small. I say 'hello' but she says nothing at all.' But, quickly Baby Sister, like Miss 10 weeks, grows, and when Ollie, like Miss Nearly 5, pulls a face she starts to giggle, and sing, and play in the bath and play peek-a-boo. And, at last, having a little sister is fun.
This is a simple rhyming book just right for the preschooler who is awaiting this momentous event and the perfect conversation starter to prepare Big Sister to expect a tiny, helpless bundle rather than a ready-made, just-like-you girlfriend.
Barbara Braxton

Cloud tea monkeys by Mal Peet and Elspeth Graham

cover image

Illus. by Juan Wijngard, Walker Books, 2011. ISBN 978 1406300925.
(Ages 9+) Folk tale. Highly recommended. Tashi and her mother live in the village by the plantation. Each morning Tashi wakes to familiar noises, and goes with her mother to the tea plantation where she and many of the village women work. The overseer, a bossy man, tells them the same instruction each morning, to gather only the most tender of shoots. One morning the familiar noises are replaced by mother's harsh cough, and too poor to afford a doctor, Tashi resolves to take her mother's basket and gather the leaves herself. Being small her efforts are derided by the overseer, and she cries in the nearby woods. Here her friends the monkeys try to placate her, and the males and older monkeys take her basket and rush away up the mountain side. An official tea taster comes to the plantation, and of all the teas gathered, Tashi's tea is the best. It is called Cloud Tea and for her basket of tea, she is given a purse of gold coins, enough to fetch a doctor and for her mother to retire. Each year the tea taster returns with another gold purse in return for Tashi's basket of Cloud Tea.
A beautiful retelling of an old Indian folk tale, sumptuously illustrated with paintings of the women and the tea plantations, along with Tashi and the monkeys, students will revel in this story of a child wanting to help her mother and then the animals helping her. What, for most of us is an ordinary cup of tea, is given extra background with this story showing how it is collected and the importance of this work to the village women. Near to the end of the book is an illustration which stood out for me. It is of Tashi and her mother, with an umbrella, walking along the road to the plantation. There is so much to talk about with just this one illustration, and the whole of the book will entertain and inform students, encouraging them to think about their cup of tea and where the tea came from and who picked it.
Fran Knight

Noosa River holiday inspires Hazard River series

cover image

by J.E. Fison
I admire authors who grow up with a burning desire to write - penning novellas in primary school and signing their first book contracts in their twenties. I'm not one of them. I took the long way round, but I had a lot of fun on the way and don't regret a moment of it.
As a girl, I was more likely to be found at the local creek, catching guppies, than writing or even reading a book. On holidays, I led my brother and cousins on boating expeditions around Moreton Bay, in Queensland - exploring mangroves and investigating the wildlife. When I did read, it was wildlife magazines and the Atlas of the World that kept me interested. I was into facts. I wanted to be an explorer when I grew up. I wasn't quite sure what that meant and was disappointed to discover that most of the world had already been explored. I had missed my calling by a few hundred years. So, I settled on journalism.
I spent my twenties working as a television reporter in Australia, Asia and Europe - covering the student uprising in China and the fall of communism in Eastern Europe. I also had the chance to travel extensively - camping with elephants in Kenya, encountering lions in South Africa and making friends with an orang-utan at the Sepilok Sanctuary in Borneo. Eventually I returned to my hometown of Brisbane and settled down to family life with a job in marketing and an interest in travel writing.
The children's fiction idea crept up on me while I was on holiday in Noosa with my husband and two sons. Most people know Noosa's Main Beach, Hastings Street and the Noosa National Park, but just across the Noosa River is an unspoiled paradise that is accessible only by car ferry - the Noosa North Shore. We spent a month there. My two sons hooked up with friends and spent the holiday exploring sands banks, building bush camps, making rafts, riding along dirt tracks to the beach, dodging snakes, avoiding sting rays and generally having a Boy Versus Wild adventure. I had to write about it.
Hazard River chronicles the holiday adventures of four children, Jack Wilde, the narrator, his brother, Ben, the Stink Collector, their neighbor, Lachlan Master, the Master of Disaster and Professor Bigbrains, Mimi Fairweather, who lives on a yacht in Hazard River. The stories are fast-paced and fun, but each one was inspired by a serious fact.
In the first story, Shark Frenzy, the children find a dead shark washed up on the sand. It has no fins. They decide to investigate. Their mission takes them to a marine park, where they find fishermen killing sharks for their fins. It's up to the children to stop them. Although the story is fiction, the issues are very real. Some experts estimate that 100 million sharks are killed each year, mostly for their fins. The practice of shark finning, where the sharks' fins are cut off and the body is dumped into the sea is widely condemned as barbaric and is decimating shark populations. It continues, however, to fill the demand for shark fin soup, which is considered a delicacy in Asia.
In the other books in the series, Bat Attack, Tiger Terror and Snake Surprise, the Hazard River gang comes up against rogue miners, smugglers and developers as they fight to protect ghost bats, koalas and even a couple circus tigers. In between tracking down the baddies, the kids fall into quicksand, get stranded on boats, find messages, discover super-cool secret bases and abandoned boats. They play pranks on each other, get lost, get found and get into a whole lot of trouble.
Editor's note: All three reviewers who read books in this series recommended them.
Pat Pledger

A sick day for Amos McGee by Philip C. Stead

cover image

Ill. by Erin E Stead. Allen and Unwin, 2011.
(Ages 5+) Recommended. Picture book. Each day Amos McGee gets up early, doffs his pajamas and dons his suit ready for work. He takes the bus and gets to his workplace, the City Zoo. Here he communes with many animals, but notably the elephant, tortoise,
rhinocerus, penguin and owl. With each animal he spends time doing something that they cannot do, and the line for each gives a hint as to another story about each animal.
But one day Amos McGee is sick in bed and cannot come to work. The animals are bereft without their friend and together they make up their minds that they will visit him, leaving the zoo, boarding a bus and cramming into his small home.
An endearing story of friendship, the illustrations are a treat, offering another layer of story within the text. Images are given to reinforce what Amos McGee does for the animals, and little jokes can be found by the diligent reader. A warm inviting story, this book is a Caldecott Medal Winner, amongst its many other awards and prizes.
Fran Knight

Rescue by Anita Shreve

cover image

Little, Brown; 2010. ISBN: 9781408700747.
(Age 13+) Peter Webster grows up in a small town in Vermont, USA. He becomes an EMT (paramedic) and dreams of building a house on a nearby ridge with panoramic views. However at 21 years of age he finds himself married to Shelia Arsenault and living in a one bedroom apartment above an ice cream shop after an unplanned pregnancy and the resultant birth of his daughter Rowan.
Initially married life is rosy for Webster but then Sheila starts drinking heavily, saying that 'I feel like a trapped lunatic.' Then a drunken Sheila is involved in a road accident in which infant Rowan is thrown through the car window in the baby seat and another car driver is badly injured. Sheila faces a jail term but flees interstate leaving Webster to bring up Rowan alone.
The book fast forwards eighteen years. Webster is worried by Rowan's change of behavior as she suddenly experiments with drinking and lets her grades slip. He searches for Sheila on the internet and tracks her down in Massachusetts and visits to ask her to come and meet her daughter, hoping that may help the situation. Shelia, who has been sober for years, refuses saying: 'I severed the mother-daughter tie the minute I got in the car drunk with Rowan in the back.'
At home the alienation between father and daughter gets worse when Rowan sees Webster reading her diary that he has accidentally found.  The night of the graduation prom Rowan and a friend jump off a quarry ledge and hit their heads on rocks underneath the water. Rowan survives but in a coma.
This book asks the question 'is love worth saving - no matter the cost?'It examines the forces that stretch human relationships and of forgiveness. It also supports the notion that friends look after each other. I found it a good read after a slow start. Would be suitable for readers 13 years plus.
Kay Haarsma

Long Reach by Peter Cocks

cover image

Walker Books, 2011. ISBN 978141632474.
Longreach's publishers recommend this ultra violent, fast paced thriller for readers 14+. As a parent and library staffer, I would add two more years because the violence is graphic.
Opening implausibly, the story recovers well and the experience of Eddie Savage, working undercover for an obscure justice authority is related in style and language which will meet with the approval of young adults.
A familiar plot is employed with Eddie seeking to avenge his murdered brother and he is cast well as a physically tough, resilient and street smart young man. Curiously he is written as a seventeen year old, a factor which caused me some discomfort since the plot involves him and his under aged girlfriend drinking remarkably frequently. Disturbingly, Eddie as an individual and the couple are depicted as being independent and sophisticated partially due to their attendance at restaurants, private functions and relaxing in their own homes, all activities where drinking appears to underline their maturity.
Eddie infiltrates an established and feared London criminal family and working undercover becomes embroiled in their drug trafficking, art fraud and stand over crimes. Susceptible to discovery at any time Eddie must collect evidence and report back to his controllers and the author cleverly conveys the sense of constant fear, pressure and mixed loyalty which the central character faces.
The story is fast paced and captivating, yet the author is so clearly focused on preparing sequel titles that he does not create an adequate conclusion for this one. Coming to a desultory halt, Peter Cocks pretty much shouts that we will have to await the next title to find out what happens, a marketing tactic which is disappointing to the reader.
Whilst the author could not be accused of glamorising crime, he does fail to demonstrate legal consequences or emphasise moral outcomes for the teenaged readers his publisher states he writes for. Certain characters appear to have been preserved for subsequent plots and do not receive justice.
It could be argued that teenaged readers are capable of developing their own moral conclusions and that the harsh realities that crime sometimes does pay and that villains do go free are concepts worthy of literary depiction.
Whilst the author pitched sexuality (implying experiences rather than describing them) and language (limited swearing only when necessary for authenticity) in an age appropriate fashion, it bothered me that gross violence was treated as acceptable, if not a selling point for the book.
Rob Welsh

Violet Mackerel's remarkable recovery by Anna Branford

cover image

Ill. by Sarah Davis. Walker, 2011. ISBN 9781921529184
(Age 6-9) Highly recommended. Violet Mackerel's Brilliant Plot is on the shortlist for the CBCA Younger Readers Award, and this companion volume is equally as good as the first. Violet has had many sore throats and Dr Singh decides it is time for her to have her tonsils out. Violet is not too happy about this but decides that she will make a remarkable recovery and that her voice will improve so much that she will be able to sing opera on the radio.
Violet is such a wonderful character. Her warm and positive nature is quite inspiring without being didactic. Violet mentions the small things that she has observed having an impact, like the little flower that Mum's boyfriend brings her and the hug that she is sure is in the scarf that Mum has knitted and she thinks about 'The Theory of Giving Small Things'. This moving idea is one that could engender lots of discussion if the story is read aloud and shared. Children (and adults) could come up with ideas of small things that they could give to make people happy. Thinking outside the square helps Violet find the elderly lady she met at the hospital, and this too is a fabulous concept to introduce to young children.
I love the special feeling of family love that shines through the whole book. Mum, her boyfriend Vincent and siblings Nathan and Nicola are warm and loving. Sarah Davis' illustrations bring these characters to life for the reader. Violet's exuberance and thoughtfulness are highlighted, and Mum is drawn as a wonderful loving person that everyone would like to know.
This is an outstanding book that deserves to be in every library. Although the cover may be more appealing to young girls, I believe that this book would be welcomed by boys especially if read aloud. The humour and thoughtful ideas will be enjoyed by all. A website with activities and downloads, as well as a competition, supports the series.
Pat Pledger

Surface Tension by Meg McKinlay

cover image

Walker Books, 2011. ISBN 9781921720284.
(Age 9+) Recommended. 'The day that I was born, they drowned my town' and so begins Cassie's story of life in her town and the mystery that she uncovers in the lake. Cassie has to swim six laps every day because she was born prematurely and has to build up her lung function. One day after finding another disgusting band-aid in the town's pool she goes to the lake to swim instead. There she meets up with Liam, a boy who has a tragic past, and as the water recedes in the lake because of the drought, they discover that it hides a sinister secret.
I was fascinated by this story and in particular, its setting of a drowned lake during a drought. I once taught near a reservoir whose waters had covered a valley similar to the one in Cassie's story and found the idea of preserving old headstones and the history of the place excited students. It is intriguing to imagine just what tragedies and mysteries have been submerged in the murky depths. What is the secret that Cass and Liam uncover? Has someone been murdered? How will they prove what has happened if the lake is flooded once more?
McKinlay has written a wonderful mystery that kept me guessing to the end. She has scattered clues throughout the book for the more astute reader, but I was still unsure of what exactly had happened right to the stunning conclusion - a wonderful thing for a mystery writer to achieve.
In addition to the suspense, McKinlay has grouped together a range of characters and family situations that also give depth to the story. Readers will identify with Cass, who has to work so hard physically to have a normal life, and with Liam, where a family tragedy has left his father mentally ill and difficult to deal with. The author's writing is a winning combination of vivid descriptions of life in a country town during a drought, the thrill of swimming in dangerous water and the excitement of uncovering a puzzle.
This is an engrossing story that will be enjoyed by both boys and girls in upper primary school and also has enough substance for young teens. After reading this excellent introduction to the mystery genre, I can imagine readers going on to seek out other books by this author and to devour other mysteries.
Pat Pledger

Ondine: The Autumn Palace by Ebony McKenna

cover image

Egmont, 2011. ISBN: 9781405256384.
Recommended age: 12+. Ondine has found the perfect man in Hamish. But Hamish has a secret - he can turn into a ferret! And now, in his ferret form, he has a mission - to spy for the duke, who fears someone wants to kill him. Suddenly Hamish has no time for Ondine. Can she get back her dream of romance?
Follow Ondine and Hamish along with their witch of an aunt through carefully taste testing the duke's food, doing the dirty laundry, pondering about raining fish and drunken duchesses. All to find out who is out to kill the duke for his fortune.
Love it!!! I have read the first book in the series and found it a bit disappointing in the way that it was a bit hard to read, but she has surprised me with this book. It has held my interest so much more with gripping turns in the storyline and surprises on every page. I would recommend this book to people who love a good mystery, but you will need to read the first book first otherwise only parts will make sense. But then again Ebony is very clever in how she has marked certain words and sentences with little hints and explanations to help you along. Definitely a good read.
Taylor Oxenham (student)

Moonstone Promise by Karen Wood

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2011. ISBN 9781742373164.
Recommended age: 14+. After a harsh childhood spent in foster care, Luke finally feels at home on Harry's farm, working with horses. When Harry dies and Luke has a bitter falling-out with the people around him, he does a runner, leaving everything behind. He takes off to the Gulf Country in search of brumbies and finds himself camped by a river with three aboriginal elders.
Can a mob of wild brumbies and three wise men help Luke discover who he is and where he belongs?
Very interesting book, it captures a young man struggling to make ends meet. I really enjoyed this book and probably cried through half of it but also laughed through the other half. With death, love and hate a good read for anyone who loves horses and/or a good long read with a heartfelt storyline. I would definitely love to read more of this series and I hope that you all will feel the same. I should also say that this book is not aimed at any gender and would be a great read for either boys and girls or woman and men.
Taylor Oxenham (student)

Vinnie's war by David McRobbie

cover image

Allen and Unwin 2011. ISBN 978 1742375762.
I highly recommend Vinnie's war as it is an excellent historical fiction novel for readers from about 11 onwards. Dealing with the evacuation of children to English country towns before the Second World War Blitz, the story has a similar feel to Magorian's Goodnight Mr. Tom, without the harsher theme.
Vinnie, an orphan who has struggled to live a happy existence in London, finds himself sent to the village of Netterfold and on the train finds new friends of a similar age in Dob and Kathleen and the latter's younger brother Joey.
Resilience is a theme which continues throughout the tale and I warmed to the characters who display courage and stoicism dealing with bereavement, homesickness, bullying and starting afresh in a strange environment. The various escapades and plots are realistic and wholesome, with the result being a well crafted narrative which rings true. Indeed I imagine that elderly folk who lived in these times would approve of and enjoy McRobbie's work.
The characters discover that hardships may be overcome and conflict can be resolved, with friends being found in former opponents. I particularly appreciated that Vinnie discovers that despite having a miserable childhood as an orphan, he could move on, to experience a fulfilling life. Assisted by kind people who take interest in his welfare, the child finds happiness and I feel that this is theme which is applicable to (and may resonate with) young people in modern times.
McRobbie includes an insightful afterward in which he explains many of the historical events and factors such as rationing, billeting and bomb shelters. This is based upon the author's own experiences as a 'Vaccie' or evacuated child. I could not help thinking that this useful inclusion would have been better placed as a prologue, to assist modern children who may have little or no knowledge of the historical context.
Rob Welsh

Fast Grandma by Margaret Clark

cover image

Ill. by Craig Smith. Aussie Nibbles. Puffin, 2011. ISBN 9780143305705.
(Age 6-9) Recommended. Another of the great Aussie Nibbles series, Fast Grandma presents a wonderful non-stereotypical grandmother for young children to think about.
When mum and dad go away to look after Aunt Faye, who is ill, Grandma comes to stay to mind Evie and Matthew. She is the fast grandma, who comes by a fast plane bringing gifts, and when she finds the fridge bare, she speeds around the supermarket buying her version of fast food. She goes so fast that Evie and Matthew have a difficult time keeping up with her. She rock climbs, goes skateboarding and even rides the Tunnel of Terror while all the other grandmothers sit and sip tea. The children are a bit embarrassed because she tells everyone that she gets her energy from eating red and green vegetables, but when she rescues a little boy they are really proud of her.
I raced through this story, delighting in the way that Clark depicted Fast Grandma as someone who loves to do all sorts of physical things. Children will enjoy the humour of being told how red and green vegetables will make you fast and I was fascinated by the energy of the grandmother.
Illustrated with detailed and amusing black line drawings by the talented Mr Smith, children will love to pour over the pictures showing the antics that grandma gets up to. They will get a laugh a minute from Smith's exquisitely funny expressions on the faces of the children and bystanders and enjoy looking at this unique family.
This is a delightful and entertaining book that is ideal for young children making the transition from picture books to independent reading. Best of all, it is a lot of fun to read.
Pat Pledger