Reviews

Merrow by Ananda Braxton-Smith

cover image

Black Dog Books, 2010. ISBN 9781742031361.
Sitting on the bottom of the sea, surrounded by the kelp forests, past the shelf of the beach near where she lives, Neen sees another face amongst the swaying tendrils of seaweed. She is not alarmed, for this is the place she feels most at peace, her refuge from the unanswered questions of the world above, a world where she is an orphan. Her father died at sea when she was a babe and her mother disappeared 12 months later, some say, returning to the sea from whence she came.
The opening sequences draw the reader in, the switch and sway of the seaweed almost mesmerizing as the reader ponders the girl's situation in life. Her unsympathetic aunt draws our censure as Neen tries hard to be of use to this bitter woman, but is sent off to do the most difficult of tasks to keep them alive. Her one friend is the blind musician, Scully, who appears to know more than he lets on, seemingly giving Neen information through stories about the past. But it is her aunt's story that shakes her to her foundations, told when a stranger is rescued from the sea, half drowned and talking of a mermaid saving him.
The stories ebb and flow like the tide, giving explanations for what has happened in the past, giving authority to people's lives, but it is when Neen finds her mother's bones deep in a cave beneath the tide line that she wonders about the stories she has been told, and where her story may lie. This gentle story of Neen's coming of age will have readers following the story with delight as they ponder the truth. For Neen the truth is the story she eventually tells of her mother's life, one that she can retell easily: a story separate from those she has been told. The stories that make up people's lives are slippery and changeable, just as is Neen's mother's story and Braxton-Smith has eloquently shown how stories can alter according to circumstances. Lower secondary girls in particular will adore this imaginative tale and think long about the stories of their own lives.
Fran Knight

The Ruby Talisman by Belinda Murrell

cover image

Random House, 2010. ISBN: 978 1 86471 987 1
(Age 10+) Highly recommended. Angry about her parents' separation, frustrated by the additional responsibilities at home and having become non-communicative toward her friends, Tilly goes to stay with her aunt Kara to provide her mother with a chance to rest and relax. Whilst there, Kara shares some information about their French ancestors and allows Tilly to try on a precious family heirloom. Forgetting to take the necklace off, Tillie goes to bed full of wishes and dreams of being transported to another life. One hundred and thirty years earlier, in Versailles, Amelie-Mathilde also goes to sleep wishing to be saved from a loveless arranged marriage and wakes to find Tilly alongside her. Almost immediately, the Revolution begins and the girls embark on an adventure to escape to safety, not knowing who to trust. As a result of her visit, Tilly influences her friends to ensure the safety of both her predecessors and herself.
This was an easy and engaging story, filled with themes that affect the lives of many young readers: family, separation and friendship, and is simultaneously a coming of age novel and a history lesson rolled into one title. Although more for female readers, it could perhaps be used as a class text or paired with a title involving a male protagonist such as Jackie French's Macbeth and Son. Both novels use the knowledge of the modern day protagonist to explain and reflect on the plights of those in the earlier times. With a French glossary at the front of the novel and three pages of facts regarding the French Revolution at the end, this is a most accessible text. A highly recommended read for readers aged ten and above.
Jo Schenkel, Pilgrim School

Little Else (series) by Julie Hunt and Beth Norling

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2010.
Middle primary. This series of short novels is aimed at middle primary readers. The include the books Ghost hunter, Trick rider and On the run. All are about 60-80 pages long with simple, clear, line illustrations and short chapters. The prose is clear and unencumbered, with short sentences, lots of dialogue and clear, evocative descriptions of the characters and the settings. With their harder than average covers, pleasant size, and an easy to read, clear font, these will be eagerly picked up by newly independent readers.
Trick rider (ISBN 978 1 74175 878 8)
The first in the series Little Else, tells of Else's time in Ma Calico's Bush Circus, where she performed under the name of Petite Elsie, tumbling and leaping with the Flying Giuseppe. But not receiving a penny for their efforts sees Else searching for the bushranger, Harry Blast to help them.
On the run (ISBN 978 1 74175 878 8)
Else leaves the circus and astride her huge horse, Outlaw, once belonging to a bushranger, she inadvertently frees a team of ill treated bullocks, and so is being chased not only as a cattle duffer, but a horse thief.
Ghost hunter(ISBN 978 1 74175 878 8)
Little Else is the leader of a small but ruthless gang of bushrangers. Needing to have her horse reshod, the gang stops at the blacksmith shop where they meet Billy Sparrow, the jockey. For the loan of several horses, Little Else agrees to race the unraceable horse, Long Shot in next day's race. Winning, she secures her prize of a group of horses and she and her followers, Lightning Jack, Toothpick, Firebolt Jim and Dangerous Dan are off to search for the Lost Herd, last seen near Mt Lost. Adventures come thick and fast as the group must leap over a chasm, avoid being lost in the back of beyond, and use Little Else's skill of horse whispering and tumbling to bring the cattle home.
Fran Knight

Need by Carrie Jones

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2010. ISBN 978408807408.
(Age 14+) If you thought that pixies were cute little things with pointed ears, then you are in for a surprise with Need. Zara has been sent to stay with her grandmother in Maine after the death of her stepfather. She is angry with her mother, who doesn't seem to care any more and depressed that she was unable to help her stepfather when he collapsed. What makes it worse is that she has seen a tall stranger who seems to be following her. Zara, with the help of some new friends, Nick, Issie and Devyn, works out that the man is a pixie and that there are other strange creatures who change shapes and prowl in the night.
Jones immediately gained my interest with her chapter headings, each one a different phobia that Zara spends some time explaining. They ranged from phobophobia, fear of phobias, to merinthopobia, fear of being bound or tied up. I enjoyed Zara's voice and the fact that she was into saving the world, writing letters for Amnesty International and starting a group at her school. This gave her a depth of character not always found in this type of story. Although there seemed to be the inevitable love triangle with Nick and Ian in the first few chapters, it soon becomes apparent that Nick is the love interest. He is strong and protective and I look forward to seeing how their romance progresses in the next book in the series, Captivate.
This book will appeal to girls who enjoy reading paranormal stories. The combination of a heroine who has pixie blood and fights evil, a gorgeous werewolf love interest and a luscious looking cover will entice teenage readers who want a quick light read.
Pat Pledger

Duck for a day by Meg McKinlay

cover image

Ill. by Leila Rudge. Walker Books, 2010. ISBN 9781921529283.
96p, Middle primary. Highly recommended. When the new teacher arrives with a class pet the kids are agog, because it is not the expected cat or rat or mouse, but a duck. They fall over themselves to see whether this pet is allowed home to stay overnight as all the other class pets have been, but are thrown by the number of conditions the teacher imposes on allowing her duck, Max, stay over. Neighbours Abby and Noah compete for the privilege with some very funny results. At first they try to build a pool each, and then conform to the other conditions of a mud bath and strong fencing. But Abby is the first to have Max stay and when she finds him missing in the morning, both children work together to find him.
A delightful story of sharing and working together, this book is a charming response to a scenario often seen in primary classrooms. The joy of the class pet is reflected in the wonderful illustrations and the whole book is joyous to read. The last line, 'It was just a few small hops, after all' will engender much discussion, as it reflects the idea of breaking down barriers, of finding friends through working together, both on a small scale, and then of taking a small step for mankind, looking at the world view. This is a wonderful book, rich and multilayered, one which would be a fabulous read aloud in a primary school, if it is on the shelf long enough for a teacher to find.
Fran Knight

The Lonely Hearts Club by Elizabeth Eulberg

cover image

Penguin, 2010.
This is a story about the synergy created by bringing people together for a common purpose. Eventually the activities and energy of the girls in the 'lonely hearts club' at a North American high school is even found threatening by the principal as well as the boys at the school.
Penny Lane, named by her Beatle mad parents, is the narrator of this story. The front cover of the book is even a spoof of the famous Abbey Road album. Penny is betrayed by her long term boyfriend Nate. 'I found out the hard way that fairy tales and true love don't exist'. She decided to form a lonely hearts club, with just herself until her friend Diane, recently dumped by the school heart throb Ryan insists on joining her club too. Ryan was the 'biggest cliche at our school: a star athlete with good grades who just happened to also be gorgeous' (pg29)
The club grows in numbers and enthusiasm. They meet every Saturday night at Penny's home with the support and encouragement of Penny's parents. They go as a group to the school dance and the school prom, rather than with dates. They attend basketball games together, upstaging the official cheerleaders. They also develop rules which include 'no dating'.
Meanwhile school heart throb Ryan, is patiently waiting at his locker, located close to Penny's, to talk to Penny. Penny's confusion about her feelings towards Ryan continues to grow through the novel. Finally all is resolved and the club rules are changed to allow dating, along as it does not undermine the girls' friendship and support of each other and Ryan and Penny are able to organise a date together.
Teenage girls giving priority to their boyfriends is a topic that will be relevant in many teenagers' lives. This is a story about how one North American teenager found unexpected support from her female friends through organising a club of 'lonely hearts' and motivated them to support each other and how threatening this was to the male powerbrokers in the school.
This is a story about the power of the group, standing up for yourself and the eternal themes of friendship, trust and loyalty.
This is very light and easy read.
Jenny Brisbane

Betrayals by Lili St Crow

cover image

A Strange Angels novel. Razorbill, 2009. ISBN 978921518331.
(Age 14+) Betrayals is the second in the Strange Angels series and continues on from where Book 1, Strange angels, left off. Christophe leaves Dru and Graves abruptly to find their way with the djamphjir and wulfen teens in a strange school. She is the only girl there and isn't allowed to go to any advanced classes or try to find out about her vampire killing skills. While Graves comes into his own with the wulfen boys, she is left alone, desperately trying to work out what is going on. It becomes increasingly clear that someone in the Schola is out to kill her and she knows she can trust no one except Graves. She must find the courage and knowledge to save herself from betrayal within the school and the threat of the dangerous Sergei.
Lili St Crow has produced another fast paced story with action galore as Dru struggles to understand what is going on and to control her burgeoning talent as svetocha. Betrayals sees Graves come into his own. He discovers that he can be a leader of the pack and enjoys running with the wolf pack and making friends. But when Dru is threatened he uses all his powers to protect her. Dru is just as protective of Graves and refuses to allow anything to happen to him. I enjoyed the growing romance between the two, although the mysterious Christophe is still lurking in the background and adds some tension as another romantic interest. Dru is a strong character and her witty asides allowed me to take a break from all the mystery and suspense.
This is an entertaining and compelling novel that has enough action, danger and romance to please fans of the vampire and supernatural genre. A third in the series is due out in 2010.
Pat Pledger

Things We Didn't See Coming by Steven Amsterdam

cover image

Highly recommended. This series of linked short stories depicting one man's survival in a dystopian future covers an astonishing array of communities and people, trying to make sense of what is happening. Some stories follow chronologically from the one before, others seem to veer off into an unconnected space, but all give a sense of impending doom as the unnamed narrator struggles to keep going whichever way he can. A thief, a government worker, doing menial chores of clearing the dead or turning people out of their homes, or simply an opportunist, the man keeps going until, at the end of the novel he comes full circle, meeting his father once again.
The opening story is set at the turn of the new millennium, when he and his parents drive to their grandparent's farm in the country to celebrate the event. His father is unconvinced about the safety of being in a city, and his wife teases him with talk of the millennium bug, and things stopping or exploding. Next the boy is older, living with his grandparents who require a carer, because he is about to go to court, branded a thief. We see that times have changed; there is talk of needing a pass to live in the country or the city, of meds to keep people alive in this strangely autocratic regime.
Again, the story moves into a bleaker future where the man is surviving in a rainsodden world, one where he has the task of moving people off their land before the flood envelopes them. Later he and his companion are surviving against all odds, taking their meds to ward off the killing cough that people are spreading across the land. In another story he is a tour guide to the terminally ill, all requiring meds to stay alive and with the bus pumping out immunity air. In another he teams up with a girl who promises the earth, but uses him to gain credits.
An apocalypse, rising water levels, global warming or epidemic, the cause of the societal change is unexplained, but the results see the narrator surviving through successive stories with hints of varying forms of autocratic governments. He finds people living in small communities in the hinterland, developing their own creed to stay alive, governments sweeping all before them, disease savaging those left, with life threatening illnesses requiring government supplied meds.
Each is an individual story telling of a different aspect of this dystopian society, and while they can be seen as one, the story of the boy's progression from being a teen to an older and wiser man, they can stand alone and so make wonderful short stories to read or work on with a class. Each story resonates with wider implications, of varieties of backgrounds and themes, which could be teased out with students.
Fran Knight

Maisy goes to preschool by Lucy Cousins

cover image

Walker Books, 2009.
(Ages 3-5) Recommended. Maisy has such a good time at preschool. She learns how to read her name when she hangs up her coat on a hook labelled 'Maisy'. She has a wonderful time with her friends making brilliant paintings; enjoys fruit and muffins at little lunch and listens to a story. After a refreshing nap, they all make loud music with the musical instruments, dig in the sandpit and play on the outdoor equipment. All in all, they have a very good day.
The vivid colours that are a Cousins' trademark reinforce the happy nature of the preschool experience. Children will have lots of fun looking at the expressions on the animals' faces and have a giggle when the animals go to the toilet.
Another book in the Maisy First Experiences series, reading this title to young children will be a welcome introduction to preschool for parents and caregivers. Maisy is obviously very happy with her friends and the teacher Mr Peacock so this makes it a very useful book to reinforce the fun that can be had at preschool.
Pat Pledger

My worst best friend by Dyan Sheldon

cover image

Walker Books, 2010. ISBN 9781406304206.
(Age 13+) 'There were basically two kinds of girls: Those Girls and everyone else.' Savanna Zindle was one of Those Girls. 'I'd never had a friend like Savanna before'.
Gracie, considers herself one of the 'everyone else'. She is interested in lizards and climate change. Savanna is interested in boys and shopping. Gracie, as narrator, tells this story with understated wit and humour.
While the two girls have different interests, their friendship develops within the context of a (north American) school. They meet up before school and at lunchtime, sitting with Archie, Savanna's boyfriend and Cooper, a quieter character, who shares Gracie's view of the world. Nightly phone calls, trips to the mall on weekends and sleepovers all help to cement the sharing of secrets and the development of the friendship between Gracie and Savanna.
The characters are developed well and given quirky and lovable characteristics that kept me turning the pages. Gracie often corrects Savanna's grammar and syntax in a dryly humorous way.
Gracie and Cooper share a love of old films and best each other at naming characters and films. The friendship between Gracie and Cooper progresses when Gracie goes with Cooper to assist at the Quaker run 'Neighbours' literacy project. Gracie doesn't see their outings as 'dates' as Cooper is just a friend and Savanna insists that Cooper has never talked about liking girls.
Gracie's Dad, the Professor, is a lovable character who quietly offers support to Gracie throughout the story. Marianne is introduced as the long suffering friend in the background who at the end of the story plays a crucial role.
When Savanna meets and goes out with Mark, an older man, without telling her parents and continuing to be Archie's girlfriend, Savanna's manipulation of Gracie grows. How long will Archie believe Savanna's lies and betrayals? Who will Gracie put first, Cooper or Savanna, as the end of year dance looms? Will Gracie finally be able to stand up to Savanna?
This is a story about friendship, trust, betrayal, growing up and moving on. The cover makes clear this novel is aimed at teenage girls.
Jenny Brisbane

Don't Want to Go by Shirley Hughes

cover image

Random House 2010.
(Ages 3-93) Highly recommended. I would defy anyone not to be captivated by the tousle haired, pyjama clad heroine we meet on the first page of Don't Want to Go. Toddler Lily's dad faces every parent's nightmare when Mum is struck down with a dose of flu and he has to go to work.
Dad rings a friend and is confident that Lily will have a lovely day at Melanie's house. Lily is not so sure. However, with the distraction of a friendly pet dog, Melanie's baby boy and some old fashioned cutting and sticking, Lily discovers that new experiences aren't as scary as she thought. When Dad arrives to collect her she's having such a lovely time she doesn't want to go home.
Shirley Hughes skilfully captures Lily's mutinous body language and anxious expression when Dad drops her at Melanie's and says goodbye. The little girl's gradual build up of confidence as she begins to enjoy the simple activities is beautifully portrayed. In our hectic lives of organised hobbies and electronic wizardry it's lovely to see children enjoying the pleasures of imaginative play.
Shirley Hughes' books have a timeless, whimsical appeal that span the generations and it's hard to believe that Lucy and Tom, the protagonists of her first book published nearly fifty years ago, are now old enough to be Lily's grandparents! This is a must for children and their carers to savour. Brilliant!
Claire Larson

The unfinished Angel by Sharon Creech

cover image

Puffin Books, 2010.
Highly recommended. Lolling about in her tower at Casa Rosa, the angel is surprised when the daughter of the new owner, Zola, sees her and begins a conversation. Zola's father is about to set up an international school in this village in the Swiss Alps, and causes some noisy changes to the small elderly community. Zola tells the angel about the children she has seen sheltering in the barn in the village and wonders why no one is doing anything about them, telling the angel that she should do something. The angel is perplexed; not only is this person able to see her, she is extremely bossy and expecting the angel to do things she has not thought about doing, if indeed that is part of her role as an angel. The angel sees herself as unfinished, with work still needing for her to be complete. She is unsure of what she is able or should do, and in her own unfinished way of speaking, uses the most amazing language, full of compound words and words that sound like something we have heard but is not quite right. It is an endearing trait.
The angel does as Zola demands, bringing the children into the tower for shelter and little by little the villagers, come to accept the children, giving them far more than shelter. But there is a problem as the mayor wants the children removed, after all no one knows where they are from or who they belong to, but the story is resolved beautifully with the international school having its cohort readymade.
This is a beautifully tender story, showing the links between old and young, the need for places to have children to carry on traditions and keep people feeling young, the cycle of life and death. In amongst the acts of kindness, the angel too learns more about herself and the reasons she is on earth, while the reader absorbs many of the stories behind the villagers, which will bring tears to the eye. Students will love reading of this angel, and delight in her very funny language, using it as a springboard for their own imaginations.
Fran Knight

Future justice edited by Helen Sykes

cover image

Future Leaders 2010 ISBN 9780980332049.
(Age 15+) Recommended. Every year, Dr Helen Sykes, founder of the 'Future leader' program, chooses a theme to be considered by expert commentators and younger writers. This year's theme is future justice - the possibility of creating a more just world for future generations.
Janna Thompson defines intergenerational justice, Ian McDonald questions society's preoccupation with economic growth and Michael Kirby promotes equity regardless of sexual orientation. The Australian Constitution is examined by Cheryl Saunders and George Williams explains the Victorian Charter of Human Rights and Responsibilities. Spencer Zifcak offers solutions for the problems of the United Nations while Jennifer Robinson compares the fates of West Papua and East Timor to highlight the value of self-determination. Paula Gerber argues the case for human rights education.
The moral dilemmas created by climate change are a recurring theme. Peter Doherty considers the science, Julian Burnside discusses Australia's obligations to environmental refugees and Larissa Behrendt reminds us of that we hold the land 'on trust'.
Ten award-winning contributions by younger writers have a broader theme - the human condition. Their subjects range from fictional treatments of emotional issues, such as Alzheimers, to a wry recount of a year spent running a school Environment Club.
The adult contributors have credentials in science, law, economics and medicine, a passion for their subjects and experience as effective communicators. Even when swayed by personal experience, their articles are considered, balanced, concise, well organised and easy to read. Technical terms are explained in the body of the text. The younger writers demonstrate a desire for a fairer society and a growing awareness of the power of the written word. br> Future justice is a thought-provoking and rewarding book. A free copy can be obtained from the Future leaders website.
Elizabeth Bor

Now by Morris Gleitzman

cover image

Puffin Books, 2010. ISBN 9780670074372.
Ages 10+. Warmly recommended. Zelda, named for her grandfather's best friend who died at the hands of the Nazis, is looked after by her grandfather when her parents leave for Dubai. She has some trouble coping with the bullies at school, and when she tells them of her famous grandfather, a doctor of some repute, she is vilified by her classmates. She tries to make amends, but in so doing destroys her grandfather's precious letters from his patients, collected over many years. All the while, Gleitzman, with consummate ease, builds up a picture of Zelda's grandfather and what happened during the war. Zelda drops in little bits of information about him, trying to please him, but ultimately making him remember things he would prefer to forget. Gelitzman's accomplished writing leads the reader to laugh and cry with the two main protagonists as slowly all of the grandfather's secrets are revealed, and Zelda realises why he always calls her Babushka, rather than her given name.
In the background, bushfires tumble across the hills of Victoria, closer and closer to their home on the outskirts of Melbourne. Fleeing is eventually impossible, and try as they might, they cannot sustain their attempts at putting out the fires in the house. Eventually they find shelter, digging open the hole Zelda's dog has dug, sheltering within the earth, covered by all of their blankets and doonas. When the fire has passed, another disaster unfolds, as their neighbor, Josh, finds it impossible to breathe and so grandfather and Zelda must operate to clear his windpipe.
Gleitzman's skill at distilling major events down to a few pages is staggering. Within the grandfather's time surviving during World War 2, we hear stories of heroism and regret, survival and tragedy. The story of the Victorian bushfires too is distilled into two families, surviving the fires by with courage and a large amount of luck. Both stories are presented thoughtfully and reverently, with room for the reader to ponder such tragedies, one a natural disaster, and the other of human hands.
Grandfather Felix's story has been told in two other books, Once and Then, showing his life surviving the Nazi holocaust, but these do not have to be read to understand or appreciate Now, although having read Now, I'm sure readers will search out the other books.
Fran Knight

Toppling by Sally Murphy

cover image

Walker Books, 2010. ISBN 9781921529 429.
John's world revolves round his school friends, particularly Dom, and his hobby, dominoes and toppling. The boys are in year six and their teacher has given them an assignment to do which involves research, collating information and finally presenting it in class at the end of the term. Teams are set up, projects defined and they are off, but Dom and John are wary of the school bully, Ky. In class one day, Dom is very ill and taken home by his parents. The next few days John does not see his best friend, and when someone does talk about him, it appears that something is wrong. Eventually John is told that Dom is very ill and in hospital with cancer.
John is extremely worried for his friend, and forbidden to visit him, takes himself off to his room where he builds domino runs for toppling. Eventually he is allowed to visit and initially reticent, their conversation flows as the two friends exchange news about what they are doing and what is happening to them.
A warm hearted story which gives information about children in hospital and how to comfort the ill and their friends, this tale will have appeal to middle primary students. Told in blank verse, the short sentences resonate with layers of meaning as the two boys find their way around each other, the hospital, the disease and their classmates, including the bully.
Fran Knight