Reviews

The night fairy by Laura Amy Schlitz

cover image

Candlewick Press, 2010. ISBN 9780763636746.
(Age: Primary) Well recommended. This is a charming story in every way: from the story line to the delicate paintings, the dust jacket, the end papers and the smooth pages.  This is a quality fairy story.  The author says 'As a child I adored fairies and fairy tales'. She was motivated by the girls who came looking for books about fairies. ' They adore the prettiness of fairies, the miniature-ness, but they are also nature lovers and lovers of adventure' p119. 
These comments by the author sum up the book well!   Flory a night fairy, no bigger than an acorn, loses her wings and finds living very precarious.  She meets many creatures who become part of her journey to survive and to understand life.  Skuggle, a squirrel becomes her first friend along with the gentle human, 'giantess'.  Flory's greatest challenge comes when the humming bird, which Florey wants to serve her all the time, is caught in the spider's nest. Then she learns about nature, love and being a good friend. The illustrations are soft, dainty and beautiful.
Sue Nosworthy

Library of Doom series by Michael Dahl

cover image

Raintree, 2010.
The book that dripped blood. ISBN: 978 1406212822.
When a young man sells an exotic, fur covered book bearing exotic golden hinges and titled 'Claws' to an old shopkeeper, a chain of events is set in motion. The book is quickly passed from one person to the next with pain and suffering ensuing. The Librarian magically emerges from the pages of a paperback novel just as The Collector arrives. Will he manage to find a solution to the problem before the book is able to wreak any further havoc?
Containing only five chapters, few sentences on each page, a liberal sprinkling of illustrations and with only 32 pages of text in the body of the story, this would appear to be aimed at the older reluctant reader. It is gruesome enough to hold a certain amount of appeal for even secondary students to whom reading does not come easily. With the simple vocabulary and various words highlighted by underlining or almost having become part of a rebus or pictogram, the story is relatively accessible. With a glossary, discussion questions and writing prompts, this could be well utilised by classroom teachers working with special needs students, as part of their literacy program. In certain primary schools, the place of this series in the collection may well be deemed as contentious by some parents! Although sharing some similarities with the Harry Potter books, this would probably fit best in a section designated for older readers in primary schools.
Jo Schenkel

Other titles include:
The beast beneath the stairs. ISBN 9781406212815.
After much travelling the Librarian returns to his library to find that his collection of deadly books is missing.
Poison pages. ISBN 9781406212846.
After reading a few pages of a strange book, a young woman finds herself trapped in a book.
The eye in the graveyard. ISBN 9781406212839.
The Librarian risks being buried in a weird tower, if he cannot work out a legendary secret.
Cave of the bookworms. ISBN 9781406212877.
A young boy rescues the Librarian from a terrible bookworm that has captured him.
The creeping bookends. ISBN 97814062128.
A young boy is accidentally locked inside the library. Ravenous lizard-like bookends start to devour the books.
Escape from the pop-up prison. ISBN 978140212617.
Can the Librarian stop the evil criminals being freed from a pop-up book?
The smashing scroll. ISBN 978140621853.
The Spellbinder has a scroll contained in a silo. Will it smash the earth?
Pat Pledger

The Crowfield curse by Pat Walsh

cover image

Scholastic, 2010. ISBN 9781906427153.
10+ Fantasy. Highly recommended. Gathering wood in the forest is part of William's work living at Crowfield Abbey as a servant after his family's death in a fire. But he hears a voice full of pain and looking around finds a small animal, a hob, about the size of a cat, but it can talk. His leg is caught in an illegal trap, and William frees him, taking him back to the Abbey to Brother Snail, the healer. Both keep knowledge of the hob to themselves, but things in the Abbey are on edge as the Abbot is dying and two guests, an unusual event, are about to come and stay. Seeing to the guests William realises that one, Master Bone, is a leper, and his carer Shadlok, a cold man with piercing eyes, asks him detailed questions, bordering on things William knows but does not wish to tell. Sent to the woods to let the pigs forage, William is startled by the appearance of Shadlok who claims to have saved him from the fay in the forest, and asks him more questions.
Many years before an angel had been killed protecting a hob, and now Master Bone and Shadlok want to find the grave to dig up and use the bones to cure the leprosy. William is torn. There are forces in the forest which seem to know all about him and what he is about to do but Shadlok has placed a spell on Brother Snail, placing him in a coma forcing William to do his bidding. Retrieving the angel from its grave does not have the results William expects.
A masterful story, The Crowfield Curse had me putting the book aside, partly because of its tension, but also because I did not want the story to end. The cold, isolated abbey, with its handful of thin, wasted men, keeping close the reasons for the curse, is an apt place for a dead angel to lie buried. The curse winds its way into the reader's consciousness, giving reason for the angel being there, showing why the monks are so bitter, and why they keep a feather in the sacristy cupboard. But William is warned that he is in danger, so leaving the way for a sequel. I can't wait.
Fran Knight

I'm the best by Lucy Cousins

cover image

Walker Books, 2010. ISBN 9781406323689.
(Age 3-6) Recommended. Lucy Cousins, an award-winning author, has produced another of her brightly coloured books this time with a thought provoking theme. Dog is certain that he is best at everything. He boasts that he can run faster than Mole, and dig holes better than Goose. He is bigger than Ladybird and can swim better than Donkey. All his friends feel sad and inadequate but then they realise that they can do some things better than Dog, who is suitably chastened. However being the good friends that they are the reassure Dog that he is the best at being a best friend and having beautiful fluffy ears.
The illustrations are lively, vivid and almost like those a child would draw. Dog is gorgeously attired in checkered pants, and his animal friends each have a beautiful piece of clothing on. The expressions on the faces of the animals are exquisite and really fit the personalities of the animals. Dog is just so proud of himself! Background details are wonderful splashes of bright watercolours, each quite fascinating to examine. With bold black print, the text is very short and easy to read for new readers.
At the back of the book Lucy Cousins outlines how she had the idea for the book after winning a tennis competition and telling her family and friends about it. She perfectly describes the impact that boasting has on friends, but doesn't pull any punches with the last proud word that Dog has.
An ideal book for young reader that will give them an insight into the power of friendship and how careless boasting can affect the emotional well-being of friends.
Pat Pledger

The Robot King by H. Badger

cover image

Space Scout series. Hardie Grant Egmont. ISBN 978 1921564840.
Well recommended. For reluctant readers, boys and early middle primary students. Obviously not the first in this series, this science fiction based story opens with twelve year old Kip Kirby participating in the Particle Ball Grand Final. This game, reminiscent of soccer but with an ever changing sized ball sets the scene for an action packed and fast moving plot!  Kip and his second  in command, part arctic wolf and part human companion Finbar, set off on their mission to try to discover the next earth.  The detailed illustrations give a very visual picture of the futuristic story which no doubt contains known scientific facts mixed with the author's vivid imagination.  Kip and Finbar find their fast moving star ship MoNa ready to fly them on their mission to Arboria where they meet Pappy who has developed the art of Digitisation. What with acid rain, pollution and armoured robots, the story has many unusual twists.  Clear, well spaced text and short chapters make this an ideal novel for struggling readers, particularly boys.
Sue Nosworthy

The boy and the toy by Sonya Hartnett

cover image

Ill. by Lucia Masciullo. Penguin Viking, 2010. ISBN 978 0670073627.
Picture book. Highly recommended. While his father goes away on business, the boy is left with one of father's inventions, a small robotic toy to keep him company. But father tells the boy that if he is needed then to send a message with the seagull. The boy and his toy do all sorts of things together, swimming, diving, running, playing hide and seek and playing puzzles. Impressed with the toy's cleverness he spends the day making an even better puzzle for the toy. But the toy, cross at losing the boy's attention, pushes the pieces out of the window. Over the next few days the toy tries to maintain the boy's interest, but fails as he brings out other toys to play with. Perplexed with the toy, the boy builds a replica of himself for the toy to play with while he summons his father.
A delightful story about friendship and companionship, Hartnett uses a wide range of words to tell the tale. Children will delight in the toy and what it can do, and respond eagerly to the implied questions of what makes a good friend or companion and how a friend should behave. Stories about the best toy in the world will be forthcoming from the absorbed audience.
The quirky illustrations by Lucia Masciullo are just wonderful. Colourful and mischievous, they draw in the reader to look at the array of inventions, toys and gizmos in the background of each page. The speech bubbles above the toy would be well used by an astute teacher or parent in asking what words could be in the bubble, so developing further the idea of what makes a good friend. There are a number of pages that particularly drew my attention. The endpapers are just wonderful with the boy on the sand with the seagull at the start, then playing with the dog at the end; the double page of dad and the boy in father's inventing room is fabulous with its array of things to look at, as is the double page spread with the boy making up his replica, while pages near the end with the boy and his father running down the spiral staircase is full of movement and warmth and resolution.
Fran Knight

The Limping Man by Maurice Gee

cover image

(Age 13+) Recommended. Fantasy/Horror. In this stunning conclusion to the Salt trilogy, Hana watches in horror as her mother swallows deadly frogweed poison rather than be captured by the Limping Man. She tells Hana to run for her life, but Hana, gripped by a sick fear, watches as the women of the Burrows are burnt as witches and her mother's body is flung into the flames on the orders of the Limping Man. With the aid of Hawk, Hana goes on a dangerous journey away from the city and meets Ben, son of Lo. Together they travel back to the burrows intent on ridding their country of the evil Limping Man who has the power to take over people's minds.
Maurice Gee is an award winning New Zealand author who has come up with an original dystopian tale with a fabulous setting. I was on the edge of my seat as I followed Hana's dangerous trip away from the city and finished the story in a couple of sessions waiting to see what would happen. Would she and Ben be able to find the source of the Limping Man's hypnotic power? I was also fascinated with the relationship Hana had with Hawk, and Gee brought the world seen through the eyes of a bird alive for me.
Hana is a determined, courageous girl who uses her intellect to work out problems. She is loyal to Ben and Lo and will not desert them even though she is in desperate danger. The story of Lo, who limps like the Limping Man but doesn't 'want to be king and conquer worlds' (pg. 167), is also fleshed out in this book by Gee.
The series is brought to a satisfying conclusion with a small opening left for other books that could explain the forest people and their powers. Teaching resources are available.
Pat Pledger

Striker boy by Jonny Zucker

cover image

Frances Lincoln Children's Books, 2010. ISBN 9781847800237.
(Ages: Upper Primary and early Secondary).Well recommended. With the World Cup about to start in South Africa, this thriller strikes a winner for soccer enthusiasts who like an exciting plot!  Set in England, the hero Nat Dixon is thirteen and has set his sights on becoming a member of the Hatton Rangers team.  They are about to be relegated so Nat's opportunity is before him.  He and his Dad have travelled the world since his Mother died in a car crash seven years before.  Dad (Dave), thinks it's time to come home and they start afresh in a very run down cottage.  Nat is big and strong for his age and he has had a year playing soccer in Brazil, so although the likelihood of such an opportunity happening in real life is unlikely, it's one many young players dream about.  Many elements of adult novels appear here, not the least cheating, bullying and tough talk. But Nat's relationship with his father grows from strength to strength and the book exudes the good qualities of human relationships.
Sue Nosworthy

With a sword in my hand by Jean-Claude van Rijckeghem and Pat van Beirs

cover image

Translated by John Nieuwenhuizen. Allen and Unwin, 2010. ISBN 9781741758658.
Middle school. Historical. Highly recommended. Marguerite pours out her hatred for her father, the man who sent away her mother, who was brought to near madness and despair after a series of shocking births, stillborn children and the early death of her only son, leading her to drink poison. The presence of his only living child, Marguerite, daily mocks his absolute despair for a son, a boy to inherit his castle, a boy to carry his name, the next Count of Flanders. But when he hisses at her, throwing a chair at her while leaving the room, she goes to the one place where all women go who hate the men in their lives, the little chapel on the marshlands, containing the disheveled statue of Mary, known locally as 'Our Lady of Hate'. It is fourteenth century Flanders, and the count is in constant battle with his daughter, Marguerite.
What an amazing tale. Marguerite is a marvellous character, full of fire and life, denying her father's dismissal of her, undermining his authority by riding her horse like a man, learning to fence and finding a kissing partner. He often taunts that he will marry her off, and when he announces that he has chosen as his son in law, the son of the English king, Edmond, Marguerite is shocked to her very core. Here is the son of the king who murdered her grandfather, who is part of the English monarchy fighting France through the Hundred Years' War, but supplying Flanders with the fine English wool which keeps the people of Bruges spinning their fine cloth. The political tension is well realised, as the Count must weigh up the influence of the French court which includes his mother, and the English court which supports his country's economic base.
This exceptionally well written book, redolent of medieval times, moves along effortlessly, with no hint of it being a translation. Each sentence is a joy to read, each page memorable in its detail and flow, each chapter urging to be reread. Several pages at the end give an account of the real Marguerite, adding to the story read in the novel.
The religious basis, the everyday life in court as well as the kitchens, bath houses, training places and the castle, all add a finely detailed background to this novel which tells of one person's life, a life restricted by circumstance, birth and religion. Although the freedoms Marguerite enjoys are more consistent with a girl from the twentieth century, the story, background and the characters carry the novel along, completely immersing any reader.
Fran Knight

Me and You by Anthony Browne

cover image

Doubleday 2010. ISBN 9780385614894.
(All Ages from 7+) Highly recommended. Anthony Browne is an expert at creating multilayered picture books which offer an apparently superficial storyline, but with a much deeper message once readers dive below the surface. He's done it again with this retelling of Goldilocks and The Three Bears.
The real power lies in the contrast between the blandly colourful illustrations of the smug bears and their large, modern detached house, and the brooding, monochrome pictures of Goldilocks's tough inner city existence.
Mummy and Daddy Bear are preoccupied with careers and possessions and sadly Baby Bear is well on his way to following in their footsteps. Goldilocks on the other hand, trudges past derelict buildings, graffiti, barred windows and barbed wire before stumbling across the pretty yellow house belonging to the bears. The story that follows plays out in the traditional way, but the ending is subtly different as, with hair flying, a terrified Goldilocks returns to the all encompassing loving arms of her Mum.
Pat Hutchins did it with Rosie's Walk in about fifty words and Anthony Browne has penned another classic in under 250 words, although of course the power and impact comes from the delicate balance between illustrations and text. This is a well timed story that comments on our obsession with money and the growing disparity between rich and the poor.
Lower juniors at my school follow a unit of work on fairy tales and they love the 'alternative' stories in this genre. There are plenty out there, humorous ones that focus on cunning little pigs duping an innocent wolf or Cinderella as a feisty princess who shuns the boring prince. Me and You is a more serious interpretation of the traditional fairy tale and I can't wait to share it with the children.
Claire Larson

Grug and the Circus by Ted Prior

cover image

Simon and Schuster, 2010. ISBN: 978 0731814343
Grug learns to read by Ted Prior
Simon and Schuster, 2010. ISBN: 978 0731814473
Ted Prior's new offerings in the Grug series are simple stories reflecting the day to day existence of the young reader. In the first title, Grug spies a circus tent which inspires him to immerse himself in a game of make believe and he develops acts for his own circus. Very few children have not, at some stage, 'put on a show' for their parents and this story simply serves to illustrate the idea. The second title outlines the way in which Grug first visits his local library to borrow books and then teaches himself to read by copying the children from the nearby school. Again, Prior uses as his focus experiences shared by all.
I had to check the Internet to see when the other titles in this series were first published and was surprised to see they were released between 1979 and 1992. They seem to have been part of library collections for as long as I can remember. I now suspect, however, that I first saw them whilst studying Children's Literature at Teacher's College and they must have been quite new. The simplistic shape of the character Grug seems so familiar and distinctly reminiscent of the Australian bush and May Gibbs' Gum nut babies. Despite the simplicity of the stories, these books continue to be a favourite of many children and I cannot help but love having had the opportunity to re-visit the series.
Jo Schenkel

Slice : juicy moments from my impossible life by Steven Herrick

cover image

Woolshed Press, 2010. ISBN: 978186471964 2.
(Year 14-16) The central character in this amusing and light-hearted book is Darcy Walker, a cheeky but good-natured boy who I am sure students and teachers will all recognise as a realistic character in class. Darcy suffers from 'premature enunciation' - he speaks before he thinks, incurring counselling from his successful, professional parents, admonishments from teachers and the occasional beating from bullies.
Darcy is growing up and meanders through his difficult teenage years with humour, kindness and maturity when it counts. This is not the dark and bleak exploration of teen angst, suffering or abuse so prevalent in many stories aimed at young adults. Instead Herrick portrays the realistic but balanced experience of contemporary school aged children as the central character observes and deals with influences such as bullying, drugs and alcohol, sexuality and the importance of meaningful relationships with individuals of different ages.
Youths will not cringe or snort with derision at the language of conversation, characters' thoughts or situations portrayed as Herrick leads them through what could conceivably be a description of their own school and family life. Similarly, parents and teachers will acknowledge the authenticity of the characters and their behaviours whilst nodding with approval at how Herrick deals with difficult issues in a responsible and plausible manner.
This is a happy and wholesome story. I liked that Darcy loves his parents and they love him. I enjoyed that he interacts with teachers in a comical way without stepping too far into disrespect or confrontation. Darcy empathizes with people, including teachers and he treats girls with respect whilst wrestling with his own sexual urges.
Most of all, I want to cheer for Darcy, who is an average student but who has literary interests. He knows what he does not like (Shakespeare), yet quotes him often. It is refreshing to read about a generally happy kid who does not subscribe to the 'dumb is cool' and not being interested in anything.
Rob Welsh

Thai-Riffic! by Oliver Phommavanh

cover image

Penguin, 2010. ISBN: 9780143304852.
(Recommended for ages 10+) Having spent his primary school years being taunted about his heritage and the fact that his parents own the Thai-Riffic! Restaurant, Albert Lengviriyakul begins high school. After being late on his first day, and meeting his new teacher, Mr. Winfree, who has a menagerie of stuffed toys, Albert has to re-asses his opinions after he is given the nickname, Lengy. For the first time ever, he thinks that maybe he could achieve his dreams of blending in and becoming more Aussie. It seems, however, that this will never happen. The whole class suddenly seems to develop a liking for his parents' cooking and their restaurant, while all Lengy wants is to escape this and go out for a pizza. Things seem to go from bad to worse as his best friend decides that they should study Thai culture for their major assignment of the term.
Phommavanh displays his understanding of children, and uses a great deal of humour in telling Lengy's story. I continued to wonder just how much of the novel was based on the author's own experiences at school both as a student and a teacher. I was amused to find a picture on his blog which showed him in his teaching days, drowning in a sea of toys. This is an entertaining read which should appeal to students from middle primary and up and could also be utilised as a shared class novel to discuss such issues as friendship, family, Australian identity, belonging and also the importance of accepting one's own history. (A quick search proved that there is such a beast as Thai-Riffic in Newtown and that it served as the venue for one of the book's launches. I'd love the chance to eat there and compare!)
Jo Schenkel

Wolven by Di Toft

cover image

Chicken House, 2009.
(Ages 9 +) Wolven has just been shortlisted for the Stockport Schools Book Award 2009, and is proving popular among upper juniors at my school.
Our hero, Nat Carver longs for a dog, but ends up with a scrawny looking mutt his Grandfather buys for a song. There is something distinctly odd about Woody, but Nat finds himself strangely drawn to his pet's soulful amber eyes and soon discovers the reason - Woody is actually a Wolven, a special breed of werewolf once owned by Richard the Lionheart.
Unfortunately Woody is being pursued by the evil werewolf Lucas Scale, whose boss Professor Gruber has almost wiped out Woody's clan in a series of dastardly experiments. It is up to Nat and Woody to try and defeat Gruber and discover whether any other Wolven still exist.
This is a fun read with touches of humour and a pacy plot with plenty of bloodcurdling werewolf action. Di Toft is an accomplished writer and her action scenes, set in the secret government lair, are a cinematic mix of raw excitement and great humour - I can just picture Nat's prim and proper elderly neighbour storming the top secret government location and firing rounds of silver bullets at snarling werewolves. Perhaps Wolven will get a DreamWorks makeover just like Cressida Cowell's How to Train Your Dragon! In the meantime this is a timely book for younger readers which will surely satisfy their current obsession with werewolves, vampires and all things ghoulish.
Claire Larson

Will Grayson, Will Grayson by John Green and David Levithan

cover image

Text Publishing, 2010. ISBN 9781921656231.
(Age 15+) Recommended. A YALSA Best Fiction Nominee for Young Adults (2010), Will Grayson, Will Grayson is the story of two teens with the same name, who meet in a porn shop where neither of them want to be. Their meeting sets off a series of events surrounding the very large and very gay Tiny Cooper, who is writing a musical about his friend the first Will Grayson.
The collaboration by John Green and David Levithan works very well, both authors giving their characters an authentic and often humorous teen voice. John Green's Will Grayson is not into taking risks. He regrets that he has taken a stand defending Tiny Cooper's sexuality and hasn't kept to his rules: 1, don't care. 2, shut up. He dreads how Tiny will portray him in the musical that he has obtained funding for. The other Will Grayson is depressed and for much of the book, I found myself disliking him as a character. On reflection I decided that it was Levithan's excellent portrayal of the downs of depression that made me feel that way. It was interesting, too, to get two viewpoints of Tiny Cooper who is the central character. John Green portrays him as a rather unfeeling friend to his Will Grayson, while David Levithan's Will Grayson see him as a shining star, too bright for him. Other characters in the mix are well fleshed out: Jane the patient friend and Maura the Goth girl feel like real people and depressed Will's mother is a loving parent. However it is the three boys, with their relationships, friendship and loves, who are the ones who stand out.
The themes of finding yourself and your sexuality, of true friendship and of depression are powerful and both authors bring many moments of revelation about teenage life. I particularly liked Tiny Cooper's insight that his musical was about love, not Will Grayson or Tiny Cooper.
Fans of John Green's books (Looking for Alaska, An abundance of Katherines, Paper towns) and David Levithan's books (Nick and Norah's infinite playlist, Naomi and Ely's no kiss list, Boy meets boy) won't be disappointed. Green's writing as always, is brilliant, brimful of humour and memorable observations and Levithan's description of a gay teen fighting depression is poignant. Recommended for older teens, as it contains some strong language and sexual themes. You can read an interview with John Green and David Levithan from Out .
Pat Pledger