Reviews

iBoy by Kevin Brooks

cover image

Penguin, 2011. ISBN 978 0141326108.
(Ages 14+) Speculative Fiction. Recommended. Tom and Lucy's lives are shattered one day by two incidents that are linked, although neither realise it at the time. The Crow Estate is a rough place to grow up. The tower blocks are the homes of two rival gangs which operate as a law unto themselves.
When an iphone is thrown from the 30th floor of a tower block and hits Tom on the head it almost kills him. When Ben, Lucy's brother is beaten up and Lucy gang raped in their flat, Lucy withdraws from life numbed and taumatised by the experience. As Tom recovers weird things begin to happen in his brain. He is able to link with electronic networks around him; he can access the net, text, sent emails, hack into data bases and listen in to mobile phone conversations at will.
Through this network he learns of Lucy's rape and discovers the perpetrators through the video footage he can access. His anger and desire for revenge lead him to take on a different persona: a kind of super hero he labels iBoy. As his understanding and control of his new power increases he understands how powerful he can be.
But there is also a moral dilemma. How should he use this power? If he uses this power for revenge and payback isn't he acting in the same way as a gang member? If he has this power exactly who and how should he help and who should he exclude?
Kevin Brooks knows how to manipulate his readers. The story, even given the outlandish premise, invites you to put yourself in Tom's place. The moral outrage at what has been done and the inability of anyone to do anything about it urges Tom to use his powers to crush the gangs, but the consequences of such actions tend to be put at the back of your mind.
A great read with plenty of violent action, information and food for thought.
Mark Knight

Bartimaeus - The Ring of Solomon by Jonathon Stroud

cover image

Doubleday, 2010. ISBN 9780385619165.
Recommended for readers of 10 years or older. Bartimaeus - the djinni with attitude is back in a fourth book of the series, a prequel, only to be enslaved to King Solomon and kept in line by the awesome powers Solomon's ring brings across the realm. That doesn't stop him trying everything to be free of Solomon, and does nothing to curb his endless insolence and wise cracking. When a girl assassin is sent to kill King Solomon and take the ring for her queen, Bartimaeus manages to interfere and things get interesting.
This is a great story well told, with twists and turns. Crackling one liners keep the book at an energetic pace, and there's an unexpected twist in the tale.
Highly entertaining and very un put-downable, the book stands by itself and you don't need to have read the other books in the series to thoroughly enjoy this one.
Dean K.

I kissed the baby by Mary Murphy

cover image

Walker, 2011 (c2003). ISBN 97814063299964.
(0-4) Recommended. A re-issue of an old favourite, I kissed the baby tells of the joy that the farm animals have when a new baby arrives. There is much excitement and talk about the new baby. 'Did you see the baby?' asks one animal. 'Did you tickle the baby?' asks another, and so on until finally the little mouse asks the duck if she has kissed the baby, and the reader finally sees just what the baby looks like.
Perfect to read aloud to very young children or to siblings, who have a new arrival in the house, this story captures beautifully the thrill surrounding a new baby. Murphy gives the listener lots of opportunity to have fun, singing, feeding, and tickling the baby until it finally appears after getting a huge kiss. The rhythm in the story and the repetitive nature of the text are sure to appeal to young children.
The simple illustrations are done primarily in black and white, which is ideal for young eyes. However the book never appears to be dull, as Murphy has used strips of vibrant colour on the edges of her pages as well as on the print.
Large pictures combined with strong emotion make this a joy to read.
Pat Pledger

Room: A novel by Emma Donoghue

cover image

Picador, 2010. ISBN 9780330519014.
(Age 15-Adult) Recommended. Jack seems to be a typical 5 year-old. He watches TV and plays games with his mother. He is bright and energetic, curious and intelligent. But his life is far from ordinary. He is enclosed in a room that measures 12 feet by 12 feet, seeing only his Ma and a frightening night time visitor, Old Nick.
Initially the disturbing aspects of this book put me off. I didn't really want to read about sexual abuse and the difficult life of a young child. However when it was chosen by my book group and also featured as one of the 10 books written for adults that have special appeal to young adults in the ALA 2011 Alex Awards, as well as being on the Man Booker Prize list, I decided to try it . Right from the first page the voice of Jack, the narrator, drew me in and I found that I couldn't put it down. His descriptions of life in the Room, where he has given names to all the objects like Bed and Wardrobe and Floor, because these are his world, are fascinating and give a whole new perspective to everyday things. He thinks that the things he sees on TV are imaginary and his naive descriptions of the lengths that his mother goes to, to protect him from Old Nick, are heart rending.
What I found particularly moving was Jack's description of Ma. She is a survivor, determined that Jack grows up as creative and intelligent as she can under horrific circumstances. She is such a young and defenceless woman but somehow she manages to give her son a life that is interesting and challenging even though they are both captives.
I can imagine that many teens would find this book fascinating. Those who liked the child's voice in The boy in the striped pyjamas by John Boyne or the young girl's narration in The lovely bones by Alice Sebold will find this original story equally as compelling.
Pat Pledger

Matched by Ally Condie

cover image

Penguin, 2010. ISBN 9780141333052
(Age: 14+) Highly recommended. Cassia has just turned 17 and in her society that means she is now ready to be matched, on her birthday. The officials in her society decide everything that happens, who you love, when you will get married, how many children you have and when, where you will work for your whole life and when you die. When Cassia is matched she believes that he truly is her perfect match, but then she starts to fall in love with someone else.
I love this book! For anyone who loves a good romance novel this is a must read, it takes priority over Twilight for me, and I'm Twilight obsessed.
A beautiful love story that truly captivates you, I guarantee that you will get lost in this book. I was torn between the two male characters; I wanted both of them to live happily with Cassia. I was hanging on every word that Ally Condie wrote, mesmerized by the sentences that were formed.
I really truly hope that you will love this book as much as I have.
Taylor Oxenham(Student,14)

A waltz for Matilda by Jackie French

cover image

HarperCollins, 2010. ISBN 9780732290214.
(Age 11+) Recommended. At the turn of the last century Australian women lobbied for the right to vote, depression and drought caused widespread unemployment and young men enlisted to fight in the Boer War. Trade unions engaged in strikes, notably in the wool industry. Racism against Chinese, Pacific Islander and indigenous people cast a shadow over the colonies as they moved towards Federation.
Jackie French has woven these events into the story of Matilda O'Halloran, who leaves the city after her mother's death to be reunited briefly with her father before taking responsibility for his sheep property. She develops from a determined 12 year-old factory worker into a self-assured young woman.
The troubles and achievements of the era are an integral part of Matilda's story. Her life is intertwined with those of a squatter, striking shearers, indigenous and Chinese people and women campaigning for female suffrage. She is directly linked to the creation of the song 'Waltzing Matilda'. At a deeper level, Matilda wonders about the secrets in her family history and we discover, with her, that some of these secrets are also part of our nation's history.
Behind the apparently effortless integration of narrative and character development, there is evidence of considerable research and an intuitive understanding of daily life in the past. The personal journeys of all the characters, men and women, contribute to the storyline, ensuring that the novel will have wide appeal.
The narrative is told in the third person but we hear Matilda's voice in her letters. Some of her attitudes are unconventional for the time but she is good-hearted and her independent thinking is convincing. The author has prefaced the book with an apology for the use of racist terms no longer in common use and provided endnotes which explain the controversies of the era.
A waltz for Matilda is an engaging, well-crafted work of historical fiction. It is also an insight into a formative period in Australian history and into the way in which history is revealed to us.
Elizabeth Bor

Dog boy by Eva Hornung

cover image

Read by Bruce Kerr. Louis Braille Audio, 2010. 9 CD's, 10 hours. Text Publishing Company, 2009.
Highly recommended. Abandoned by his mother and uncle, Romochka eats everything he finds in the apartment, until spurred on by hunger and loneliness he ventures outside, a place his mother warned him never to go alone. Avoiding strangers, another of his mother's rules, he is taken by a dog to her lair, and in so doing becomes one of the cubs, suckled, protected and trained by her. This extraordinary story of the dog's life lived by this small boy is absorbing, as Horning details how the boy becomes one of the pack, living in the basement of an old church, hunting in a pack at night, fending off strangers and developing the skills to stay alive. He cannot emulate their sight, smell and hearing skills, but he can use his hands, fashion tools and weapons and so be of assistance in a different way. And they protect him in their stead, seeing him as a member of the pack, fighting together, sharing their food and protecting each other in time of need. At times he is caught, once by authorities and another by a group of boys intent on torture and death. His pack comes to his rescue. The puppy, another boy brought to the lair by the female dog, is caught by the authorities and in trying to find out if he is alright, Romochka is taken to a children's home, and eventually comes into direct contact with its director. Here is a different sort of nurture, one which is clinical, watchful, with a mind to publish the results for the further funding of the impoverished home.
Hornung has vastly added to the literature about children raised with animals, the story is one that has always captured people's interest and this tale is riveting. Engrossing, intelligent and informative, the story makes the reader think about ideas; ideas about our basic needs, about survival and what it is to be human. Along the way she delights the reader with insights into the behaviour of animals and what makes them take in a boy to nurture and defend. And humour abounds in the clinical observations of the psychiatrists trying to twist new meanings into what they are seeing, finding a new area of research or twisting known ideas around the boy's behaviour.
Set in Moscow after Perestroika, the background feels like war, but is set in an area of Moscow built up and then abandoned; redolent of hunger and lack of civilisation, while the all encompassing cold during winter is keenly felt. The vivid setting impels the reader to sympathise with the boy and his pack as they roam the streets, scavenging food from all sorts of places, sometimes grabbing shopping from strangers, sometimes given food by a sympathetic cook, often crawling over the mountain of rubbish.
The reader, Bruce Kerr tells this story with a deliberately paced strong voice, reminiscent of early ABC TV news readers. His steady thrum is just right, betraying no idea of where the book is set, focusing our attention on the events surrounding the child's survival. He varies his voice for the boy's words, and of those he meets along his journey, but in the main this calm steady voice underscores the brutality of what is going on.
(The book has deservedly won accolades: Winner, Fiction category, Prime Minister's Literary Awards, 2010: Shortlisted, Vance Palmer Prize for Fiction, Victorian Premier's Literary Awards 2009: Shortlisted, ASL Gold Medal, 2010: Shortlisted, Literary Fiction Book of the Year, ABIA, 2010.)
Fran Knight

Samantha Seagull's sandals by Gordon Winch

cover image

Ill. by Tony Oliver. New Frontier Publishing, 2010. ISBN 978 19210425091.
(Ages 4+) Recommended. First published in 1985, and republished most years since then, this new edition will be a treat for teachers and librarians now able to replace the tattered old copies in their schools. A marvelous book to use when talking to children about competition, difference, fashion, growing up and friendship, this story of Samantha has resonance with all children.
Samantha desperately wants to be different, and so buys shoes to wear on the beach. But each pair of shoes she buys causes problems for her going about her everyday activities, and so she must exchange them. The high heels sink in the sand, the rubber boots fill with water, the slipper's pompoms get soaked and lose their oomph. Each time, her legs and face become redder with shame and embarrassment, but all the while, her best friend, Simon comes to her rescue.
The repetitive nature of the lines will encourage younger readers as they predict what the other seagulls will say and the humour of the situation will cause much laughter amongst all who read the book. The resolution is a neat resolve to the situation, informing the readers of the difference between younger and older silver gulls. A delightful book, with luminous shimmering illustrations, redolent of a day at the beach, this story will have wide appeal.
Fran Knight

Drawn from the heart, a memoir by Ron Brooks

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2010. ISBN 978 1 742371559.
All ages. Autobiography. Highly recommended. Some books are impossible to put down. This is one. The frank and lucid telling of events in his life as an illustrator is mesmerizing, as Brooks makes the slog of finding a niche for himself in the publishing industry a fascinating insight into the unseen backdrop to the books we read. Having always loved John Brown Rose and the midnight cat, I was fascinated to see the first drawings and read of the places which gave Brooks his inspiration for the setting. Living with his grandparents when he went to a local school to study art, the sense of that house comes through many of the stories, John Brown being just one.
The struggles Brooks made to study art are fascinating in themselves, as art was seen as a Cinderella subject and so he had to fight to be able to study on his chosen field. Going on to college meant, as for many people in the 60's and 70's, doing a teaching course to be able to study art, and so parallel teaching with freelance art work. Picking up work where he could, Brooks was in the right place meeting several people who would mentor him through the early years while establishing himself. Haworth Bartram of Childerset, Jenny Wagner, Pat Thomas of Macmillan, Albert Ullin of The Little Bookroom, Peter Pavey amongst many others were members of his network.
Not only are we lucky enough to get snippets of each story, thus rekindling time spent with old friends, but Brooks goes into details about his choices for his illustrative techniques and reprises the absolutely engrossing reasons behind each decision made. It impels the reader to grab hold of one of the finished books and relish it all over again, but this time with greater insight from Brooks' writing. Some first draft illustrations too are reproduced showing not only the range of this man's abilities but the thought processes her went through in illustrating a new book. Some of the criticisms of his work are also included, showing that not all was rosy in the work that he did, and I laughed out loud at the reviews reproduced from English, American and German reviewers about John Brown, Rose and the Midnight Cat.
A treat for all, this will not only inform those in the field, and endear those already in love with his work, but will create a new audience eager to search out his illustrations for themselves. The only thing I missed was an index.
Fran Knight

Rabbit's year by Melissa Keil

cover image

Ill. by Jedda Robaard. Black dog books, 2011. ISBN 978 1742031750.
Feeling sad and alone, Rabbit plays a tune on his cello. He would love a friend but is too shy to join the other animals as they play their instruments. But he loves music; he is creative and loves doing creative things, but in playing his cello, he finds that other animals join him, finding that they are drawn to the beautiful sounds. First Dog finds the player, then Sheep follows the sound, then Pig wants to join the trio, and on and on until all the animals of the Chinese Zodiac join together to make beautiful music together.
A simple tale of friendship and working together, of music and its power, form the subtext of this book outlining the 12 animals that make up the Zodiac.
At the end is a double page spread containing an outline of the 12 animals, with a brief description and a list of the years in which those animals take centre stage.
The main character will please younger readers and introduce them to the 2011 Year of the Rabbit, as well as informing them of the Chinese Zodiac and what it means. The line and water colour drawings are most appealing to younger readers.
Fran Knight

Smuggler's Cave by Sonya Spreen Bates

cover image

(Orca Echoes). Orca, 2010. ISBN: 9781554693085.
When cousins Jake and Lexie race and Jake loses, it is impossible for Jake not to take up the challenge of a second event. This time, however, the race is to be by boat to Smuggler's Cave and back. Because Jake can't leave his younger brother, Tommy alone, the two participate together. Things go wrong and the boat ends up in the cave with the water level rising. Stories about the cave make the children uneasy and add to the adventure.
As a simple adventure tale, Smuggler's Cave will probably appeal most to the emergent reader or the middle primary reluctant reader. With only minimal pages in the book and fourteen of those being illustrations, this is an easy and quick read, accessible to both male and female readers as the protagonists are also of both sexes. These illustrations are useful to the reader as they support the text without being so busy that they would detract from the child's concentration levels. The theme of competition between boys and girls in the story would be familiar to the young readers, possibly adding to the interest level.
Jo Schenkel

The Messenger by Yannick Haenel

cover image

Translated by Ian Monk. Text Publishing, 2011. ISBN 9781921758003.
(Age17+ years) The Polish ghettos and the death camps established by the Nazis during World War 2 for the elimination of the Jews were hidden from the eyes of the world. This book tells the story of one man, Jan Karski, who, although not a Jew, did visit both the Warsaw ghetto and one of the death camps so that he could take first hand knowledge to the allies about the fate of those incarcerated. As a young Polish officer at the start of the war Jan Karski escaped both the invading Germans and Soviets to become a runner for the Polish underground. In 1942 he was smuggled into the Warsaw ghetto by two Jewish leaders and asked to inform the 'civilized' world about what he saw, to carry a message to open the eyes of the allies to what was happening to the Jewish people. It is an understatement to write that he was shocked by the suffering, there in the ghetto and in the camp he succeeded in visiting. Through contacts in the Polish government in exile he took his terrible message to England and the United States. His appeals to the allies were met with disbelief and even, he suspected, boredom. His message rejected, he had to live with both the horror of what was happening and the belief that the allies were compliant. The book is tripartite; the first section describes Karski's appearance in the Claude Lanzmann movie Shoah, the second is a summary of Karski's own book Story of a secret state (1944), and the third is a fictionalized version of Karski's attitudes/philosophy many years later. In the first section we see on camera how Karski resisted his memories, and then the horror of the images that he gradually offers. The second section describes his life as an agent, his difficulties, being captured and tortured, and finally reaching the 'land of the free'. The final section is an imaginative reconstruction of Karski's life in New York, his sleeplessness, his attempts to escape the past by suppressing memories, and his final embracing of the need to bear witness. This is the story of a man who still believes that his message has not been heard, and that he therefore still carries the message. So disgusted by the camp, he believes that he died afterwards, but came back to life to carry a pinpoint of light that he continues to try to shine on those terrible events. The story is compelling, horrifying and challenging, and could make an illuminating comparison with the movies The Pianist or Schindler's List, or with the Jacobson novel The Finkler question. It is recommended for capable senior students.
Jenny Hamilton

The genius wars by Catherine Jinks

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2009. ISBN 978 1741758542.
Recommended for 14+. Genius wars follows two previous titles in the series - Evil genius and Genius squad. I imagine that readers familiar with these novels will enjoy reacquainting themselves with familiar characters and discovering how events from earlier plots lead to this finale. Newcomers should not consider that reading the earlier tales is necessary however as Jinks cleverly sets the scene and provides character narratives which enlighten the uninitiated, allowing this story to stand solidly by itself.
As a child, the central character Cadel had been exploited and manipulated by adult criminals who engaged in high technology escapades detailed in the first title. In the second book, Cadel and his friends pool their knowledge and experience to assist authorities to locate and prosecute criminals.
At the start of Genius wars, Cadel finds himself in a happier place, living with foster parents who love him and look out for his welfare and best interests, in contrast with previous 'parental' figures whose motivations were selfish and actions abusive. Fifteen year old Cadel attends University with the intention of formalizing his considerable I.T. skills and his few close friends are similarly gifted. Sonja, a girl with multiple disabilities is rightly presented as a maths genius and a vital team member, rather than a sundry character who happens to be confined to a wheelchair. Similarly Cadel's hacker friend Hamish, an annoying but likeable character drawn with realistic flaws and traits is someone whom we might all know.
Cadel's foster father is a detective and his foster mother a social worker. With their protection and support from his loyal friends, Cadel engages in a virtual 'war' with Prosper English, a sinister father figure from earlier times who seeks to harm him.
Cadel must pit himself against Prosper, testing his intelligence and endurance and it is gratifying to read a story which celebrates cerebral powers over physical violence.
It was pleasing to relate to characters which are boldly different from those routinely employed by some authors to plod through their sometimes hackneyed dramas depicting contemporary teenage life. Jinks' idea is fresh and her topic challenging as wildly complex technology features prominently amongst the action. The communications, surveillance and security technology described is so advanced that one is never sure if elements stray beyond current reality, however within the framework of the tale, this is entirely acceptable.
Jinks has successfully created a story containing action and suspense in a familiar Australian setting and whilst hyper technology is involved, absolute understanding of every detail is not vital as the reader is soon caught up and carried along with the pace.
Rob Welsh

The Iron Witch by Karen Mahoney

cover image

Random House, 2010. ISBN 978-186471864718270.
Donna Underwood is just your normal girl, that was until a horrific attack in the Ironbridge Woods ten years ago, when she was only seven. In this attack her father tells her to get behind him and grabbing the axe, he goes off to get the Wood Monster. When the Wood Monster comes, Donna's father tries to hold it off, but fails. In the fey attack she almost lost both her arms, after they got bitten by the Wood Monster. Maker saved them by binding her lower arms and skeleton in pure star iron and silver and marking her with magic. Donna is not sure whether it's because of her father's death or the fey attack, but her mother has gone mad and only very rarely remembers who anyone is.
Ever since then she has been involved with the hidden world of magic, as her parents both belonged to the Order of the Dragon, an ancient alchemist society. Only when Donna's best friend Navin Sharma is take by wood elves, the worst kind of fey there is, does Donna accept who she really is. With the help of her new-found friend, Alexander Grayson (Xan), she rushes head-long into the deepest and darkest place there is.
Karen Mahoney has captured the prefect teenage novel, action, drama and romance, in The Iron Witch. Being the first in a series it will make for a wonderful read. I highly recommend it to all teen readers. You will enjoy!
Zoe Pfeiffer (aged 14)

Alice-Miranda Takes the Lead by Jacqueline Harvey

cover image

Random House, 2011. ISBN: 9781864718492.
Highly recommended for children ages 8 and up. Alice-Miranda is the most kind, considerate, genuine seven and a half year old anybody could wish to meet. On her return to boarding school, she is delighted to be reunited with her friends, teachers and the staff of the school, each of whom she appears to have changed in a positive way during the previous terms. Even the arrival of the dreadfully rude new student, Sloane Sykes, and her mother, September, has her trying to find the best in people. Talk of a witch living in the woods causes the children some concern, until Alice-Miranda gets left alone whilst out riding. She then becomes involved in a mystery which she endeavours to solve and bring things to rights.
With this having been my introduction to Alice-Miranda, I now wish to go and read the two preceding titles. As much as this little girl is too good to be true, she is an utterly loveable character, able to endear herself to all with whom she comes in contact. She proves to be totally unselfish, thoughtful and equally as engaging a character as was Pollyanna in my childhood reading. This series could be used as a class read aloud to even younger children, with a focus on giving others the benefit of the doubt, generosity of spirit, sharing with and over-looking the flaws in other people, thereby allowing them to be themselves. This is a most engaging and entertaining tale of mystery, friendship, loyalty and honesty.
Jo Schenkel